Showing posts with label review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label review. Show all posts

Sunday, August 25, 2013

Film as (Gonzo) Journalism, Central African Republic Worse Off After Mads Brugger's "The Ambassador," UN's French Connection


By Matthew Russell Lee
UNITED NATIONS, August 25 -- A film about the Central African Republic, "The Ambassador" by Mads Brugger, opened in New York a year ago. Using hidden cameras it cover efforts to purchase diplomatic credentials from Liberia and to deal in conflict diamonds in the CAR under the Bozize government.
  A year later, Bozize has been thrown out -- although he hasresurfaced in Paris. He was not ousted due to his corruption, but by the Seleka rebels, now themselves accused of child soldier recruitment and other abuses.
  While there is much hand-wringing, for example fromEuropean Union official Kristalina Georgieva and the UN's Valerie Amos, about the crisis in the CAR, the UN Security Council has not this month as expected passed any resolution about the country.
  As first covered by Inner City Press, the reason for inaction is that French Permanent Representative Gerard Araud and others in the French Mission are on vacation for the month, and France "holds the pen" to draft all resolutions in the Council on the CAR, as it does on other former French colonies like Cote d'Ivoire and Mali.
  In "The Ambassador" -- trailer here1.6 GB download for $8.50 here -- the CAR's head of state security Guy-Jean Le Foll Yamande says on hidden camera that it is France which "taught corruption" in the CAR. He is later tortured and killed.
  In full disclosure, Inner City Press appears in the film, in connection with exposing the reasons and results of the UN pulling out of Birao. Due to lack of planning by the UN Department of Peacekeeping Operations, troops from the MINURCAT mission thrown out of Chad also left Birao in CAR -- and rebels took over the town immediately after that.
  The UN's DPKO has been run, for times in a row now, by Frenchmen. The current head of DPKO Herve Ladsous refuses to answer Press questions about his past, including during the Rwanda genocide in 1994, when he was France's Deputy Permanent Representative to the UN, arguing for the escape of the genocidaires into Eastern Congo.
Now Ladsous commanders an all-African Intervention Brigade to "neutralize" armed groups like M23 which Congolese leader Joseph Kabila doesn't like. Plus ca change.

While Liberia fought back against the film -- see for example Toga McIntosh's speech, here -- and while Brugger may have played a bit fast and loose, troubling questions remain about the head of Ellen Johnson Sirleaf's Unity Party Varney Sherman.

A promise was made to Brugger, playing Mr. Cortzen, that he could get his credential when Johnson Sirleaf returned to Monrovia from the UN General Assembly in September 2010, and that the money he paid would go toward her re-election.
What is amazing almost two years after that General Assembly, and a year after the film opened in New York, is how little has been done. While again noting some unresolved question about whether some of the purported hidden camera video was in fact agreed to, we and the Free UN Coalition for Access recommend the film, including as journalism. Watch it.

 
  

Saturday, June 29, 2013

As ICC Is Used In NBC's "Crossing Lines," Of Immunity, Ruud Lubbers and UN's Failure in Sri Lanka


By Matthew Russell Lee, TV Review
UNITED NATIONS, June 29 -- The UN system has become so low-profile if not to say irrelevant during the tenure of Secretary General Ban Ki-moon that any mainstream coverage might seen good. And so some welcomed NBC's new series “Crossing Lines,” which uses the International Criminal Court, albeit inaccurately and absurdly.
  In the pilot double episode, a “dream team” of six detectives wants to investigate four killings in four European countries, but doesn't have jurisdiction. How to solve this plot problem? Travel to The Hague and meet Luis Moreno Ocampo facsimile Donald Sutherland.
  At first Sutherland / Ocampo demurs. But then after a reference to Kosovo, a card is played: the crime of aggression. That's it -- Sutherland gives the detectives a warrant. And they're off to Paris.
  But there the local authorities are not impressed by the ICC, not unlike the current government of Kenya. The detectives are locked up until they show their ICC paper. They are released. Simple as that.
  The bad guy uses diplomatic immunity, American, to drive through check points without getting his car searched. This week at the UN, Inner City Press asked Ban's deputy spokesperson Eduardo Del Buey about a Peruvian diplomatic to the UN now charged with human trafficking. Not our problem, Del Buey in essence said. Transcript here. And below.
  The idea of the ICC being used against immunity, though, brings to mind for example the UN's own immune Ruud Lubbers, here. Or why not the UN bringing cholera to Haiti?
  The whole thing makes one wonder why the ICC could do nothing -- nothing! -- about the killing of 40,000 civilians in Sri Lanka in 2009. There wasn't even much call for ICC involvement, unlike today in Syria. It's only TV. And that was a war without witnesses.
  One imagines a realistic show about the UN. One imagines. Watch this site.
  
Inner City Press: could I ask you about a charge of human trafficking against a UN diplomat that works at the UN in the Peruvian Mission. And given --
Deputy Spokesperson Del Buey: Well, excuse me…
Inner City Press: Alright.
Deputy Spokesperson: He does not work at the UN.
Inner City Press: In the UN.
Deputy Spokesperson: He works for the Peruvian Mission.
Inner City Press: Okay, absolutely. He is a UN diplomat. My question is just, given the important of this topic to the Secretary-General and the Secretariat in general, does he take any interest in this case? Do they see this as a proper use of immunity? If the allegations are true is this a proper use of the term human trafficking and is there some concern that people work in the building, not for the UN, have you know, immunity that this may be a loophole for human trafficking?
Deputy Spokesperson: Well, we are not going to prejudge what happens until we have the information, Matthew.
Inner City Press: Right, but you will seek the information…?
Deputy Spokesperson: Well, we are…
Inner City Press: I mean, at some point?
Deputy Spokesperson: …we are obviously monitoring…
Inner City Press: Okay.
Deputy Spokesperson: …the situation, but as I said at the beginning, this… the reports we’ve seen are of a Peruvian diplomat assigned to the Peruvian Mission at the United Nations…
Inner City Press: Sure.
Deputy Spokesperson: …not a United Nations staff member…
Inner City Press: No, I understand.
Deputy Spokesperson: …not a member of the general Secretariat.
Inner City Press: Sure.

Wednesday, February 6, 2013

Exclusive: UN's Post-Sandy Review Admits Snafus, Urges Plan to Relocate to Another UNHQ



By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, February 6 – The effects on the UN of Hurricane Sandy, even after more than three months, continue to be felt. And now a copy of the UN's “After Action Review - Storm Sandy” has surfaced,or leaked, and Inner City Press is exclusively publishing it here.

  There are many understatements, for example that “communications to Member States, staff and to the wider public during the immediate period following the storm were unsatisfactory.”

  Member states led by Algeria, then the head of the Group of 77, lambasted Secretary General Ban Ki-moon and his team for failing to send them a single e-mail during the storm.

  The Review recounts that the UN didn't even have current contact information for its own member states: “On Monday 29 October at 11:35am, a broadcast message was sent out, advising Member States and all staff of the need to relocate all vehicles to the 2B Garage level as a preventative measure. It was later discerned that the mailing list used to contact Member States did not contain the latest accurate contacts for all Member State Missions to the UN.”

  In one of most interesting recommendations, the Review suggests that the UN beginning planning to work out of a headquarters other than in New York City:

events could affect the UN Secretariat campus in NY, requiring closing for a much longer period because of severe damage to UN facilities, infrastructure (including disruptions to New York City’s core infrastructure (i.e. public transportation; electricity; wireless communications, etc.)... Recommendation: SEPT should take up the issue of contingency planning for major events, ones that could realistically require relocation of UN functions to another UN headquarters.”

  The Review does not say where this might be, or how it might impact UN staff. Some of the staff most impacted are in Publishing, “affecting approximately 300 staff and included three leased digital printers which produce 95-99% of all the official documentation requirements.”

  Now machines are running even after-hours on the North Lawn Building's second floor. Many functions in the third sub-basement 3B are still suspended, as in the less known 4B and 5B.

  As Inner City Press reported earlier today, after a fellow member of the Free UN Coalition for Access was injured and put into a UN wheelchair, the UN Medical Service still has no X-Ray capability. So who will be accountable? Watch this site.