Showing posts with label del ponte. Show all posts
Showing posts with label del ponte. Show all posts

Monday, July 29, 2013

On Syria in General Assembly, Talk of Chemical Weapons Witnesses Killed While UN Plays Hide the Ball


By Matthew Russell Lee
UNITED NATIONS, July 29 -- When the Syria Commission of Inquiry's chairperson Paulo Sergio Pinheiro briefed the UN General Assembly on Monday morning, it had the feeling of a ritual, one that the UN made it difficult to cover.
  It was supposed to be in the Trusteeship Council Chamber at 10 am. Inner City Press arrived there at the same time as UK Permanent Representative Mark Lyall Grant -- but the room was shut. Even he had not been told of the move.
  Running to the North Lawn building, where the new General Assembly hall has banned the press from the floor up to a Media Booth with no table and no interpretation, Pinheiro had already begun. His fellow Commissioner Carla Del Ponte, who previously spoke of strong suspicions the rebels used chemical weapons, was again not with him.
  But Pinheiro did cite the recent execution of soldiers in Khan al Asal, and named the opposition armed group responsible.
  Syrian Permanent Representative Bashar Ja'afari when he spoke said these executions were to eliminate witnesses to the rebels' use of chemical weapons there, just as the UN's Angela Kane and Ake Sellstrom reached a still undisclosed agreement about probing such use.
  Ja'afari derided petrodollar policies and sexual jihad; he chided Pinheiro for not describing the Al Nusra Front as a terrorist group. As Inner City Press has reported, Al Nusra is not on the UN's list of child soldier recruiters, either.
  While Ja'afari spoke, the UK's Lyall Grant took notes and tweeted (including a responsive tweet to Inner City Pressabout Somalia, here) then got up to speak. He cited sexual violence; he echoed the EU's Thomas Mayr-Harting that the rebels' abuses do not match in scale or intensity those of the government.
   Instead Araud's stand-in for France cited the ICC, whileHerve Ladsous the fourth Frenchman in a row atop UN Peacekeeping met this month with ICC indictee Omar al Bashir.
Turkey spoke of keeping its borders open (Ja'afari said they let terrorists flow into Syria). Qatar's speech was translated, on the webcast heard in the hallway, as citing "crimes wars" -- while the rebels it funds commit them. 
  Saudi Arabia's Permanent Representative said they embrace in full the Pinheiro report -- perhaps because it does not cover which countries are funding the armed extremist rebels.
  Ban Ki-moon met Monday morning with Angela Kane, but by the time of the noon briefing there was no read-out. Some wondered why.
  Inner City Press ran from the North Lawn to the briefing to ask why the UN Media Alert did not even list the meeting, no Media Accreditation and Liaison Unit staff were there, and there was no interpretation in the Media Booth, which theFree UN Coalition for Access raised to the Department of Public Information back on June 10, still without any action.
  During this Syria meeting, the UN Correspondents Association used the room the UN gives them, S-310, to host the Club des Chefs des Chefs -- those who cook for heads of state. 
  UNCA 2013 president Pamela Falk of CBS was with the chefs -- she had already fronted for Saudi-based Syria oppositionist al Jarba on Friday, it was time for other spoon feeding.
  The one UNCA Executive Committee member at the noon briefing did not raise the lack of access, or answer why an UNCA intern has a press pass while actual journalists are being threatened. and in another case were banned from using a "focus booth" then taken by the intern of the UN Censorship (and Spying) Alliance. So it goes at this UN.

 
  

Friday, May 10, 2013

On Somalia, UN Walks Back from Eliasson's Estimate of 3000 AMISOM Deaths, Gentler Than on Del Ponte on Syria



By Matthew Russell Lee
UNITED NATIONS, May 10 -- Returning from the Somalia conference in London, UN Deputy Secretary General Jan Eliasson on May 9 told the press, "You would be shocked to learn that maybe it is up to 3,000 AMISOM soldiers that have been killed during these years that AMISOM has been there. Uganda, Burundi, have paid a tremendous price... the Kenyan troops are, of course, also a large part of AMISOM."
  The number seemed high. And lo and behold, on Friday afternoon the UN walked back, ever so gently, from Eliasson's estimate:
"we would like to clarify the following: The casualty figures used by the Deputy Secretary General were an estimate based on information from informal sources; dissemination of exact casualty statistics is solely the responsibility of the African Union and the individual troop contributing countries."
Compare that to what happened to Carla Del Ponte after she spoke of evidence leading to strong suspicions that sarin gas was used in Syria -- by the rebels, not the government.
   Inner City Press asked Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesperson Martin Nesirky if Ban's prober Ake Sellstrom had got or sought Del Ponte's information. Video here.
  The UN pointed out that Del Ponte's co-paneled Paulo Pinheiro had immediately undercut Del Ponte, as did White House spokesman Jay Carney (who spun insider journalists off the record about Benghazi on Friday) and then the spokesperson from the UK's David Cameron.
  Will others jump in on Eliasson's statement? We doubt it. Watch this site.

Tuesday, May 7, 2013

On Syria Sarin, UN Ban Ki-moon Spox Criticizes Inner City Press, Won't Say If Sellstrom Has Got or Wants Del Ponte Info



By Matthew Russell Lee
UNITED NATIONS, May 7 -- Why is the UN so defensive about its probe(s) into chemical weapons in Syria? Video here from Minute 15:12.
  On Tuesday, Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesperson Martin Nesirky did not answer Inner City Press' questions on whether Ban's prober Ake Sellstrom had received the information cited by Geneva-based rights prober Carla Del Ponte.
  Instead, Nesirky pulled out of a file a print out, and criticized Inner City Press' blog of the night before, which ran in full a response from his office, minutes after it was received, and noted
"it sure doesn't say that Sellstrom will consider the evidence his fellow UN system prober Del Ponte has and cited to. Last week, Nesirky told Inner City Press that Sellstrom would be willing to look at video footage collected by Russian state TV reporter Anastasia Popova. Why consider that, and not information from another UN system body? SHOULD these two inquiries be UNrelated?"

  These might seem like fair questions: should two UN system inquiries be consider "unrelated"? Getting more concrete, should Sellstrom simply wait and see what information is submitted to him? Or, at least in the case of information publicly cited by another UN system official, should he reach out and request the information?

  Nesirky after reading from Inner City Press blog not only would not answer if Sellstrom has received the information to which Del Ponte cited -- he would not answer if Sellstrom or Ban Ki-moon will EVER say if this information was received and considered. Video here from Minute 15:12.
  That goes or will go directly to the credibility of Sellstrom's report to Ban, and Ban's report to member states. So why get so angry that the question is asked? Nesirky ended the briefing and left, not allow other questions Inner City Press (and others, we assume) had prepared to ask

  These included questions refused by UN Peacekeeping chief Herve Ladsous, whose spokesman Kieran Dwyer on "World Press Freedom Day" cited Inner City Press' "blog posts" as the reason Ladsous won't answer. Video here. What next? Watch this site.

Footnote: Regarding the information or video footage of Russian state media reporter Anastasia Popova, after Inner City Press reported on her offer of proofanonymous social media accounts associated by the UN Correspondents Association and Reuters immediately falsely accused Inner City Press of being in the pay of the Assad government of Syria, just as they've made false allegation about the defunct Tamil Tigers of Sri Lanka, which led to death threats.

   This is the context. We'll have more on this.

Monday, December 10, 2007

At the UN, Del Ponte "Stupified" by UNMIK's Support for Ramush Haradinaj, Dodges UN's Srebrenica Role

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee at the UN
www.innercitypress.com/ictykosovo121007.html

UNITED NATIONS, December 10 -- As focus increases on Kosovo, which the UN has administered since 1999, on Monday Carla Del Ponte, Prosecutor for the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, strongly criticized the UN's leadership in Kosovo for having openly praised "a person indicted for war crimes," Ramush Haradinaj, and thereby having chilled and intimidated witnesses. Most recently, the UN's second-in-command in Kosovo, Steven Schook, has proclaimed "having great respect for Ramush Haradinaj's performance as prime minister of Kosovo," and has claimed that is one of the reasons he is under investigation by the UN's Office of Internal Oversight Services.

Monday Inner City Press asked about this, and Ms. Del Ponte replied that she is "stupefied" by this, and that she has had "a lot of problems with UNMIK," the UN's Kosovo mission, stretching back to the leadership of Jessen Petersen and even, before Ramush Haradinaj was indicted, Bernard Kouchner. "I have nothing against personal friendship between friends," she said, "except when it has a chilling effect on my witnesses!" She asked rhetorically how a prosecution witness living in Kosovo would feel, when the UN's de facto governors of Kosovo praise a man indicted for war crimes.

Inner City Press asked a second question, about whether Ms. Del Ponte supported the UN's attempt to cite immunity when sued in Holland for its role in not providing protection in Srebrenica. She called the question "completely different" than the Kosovo question, and then pointedly did not answer it. Video here, from Minute 20:03.

Ms. Del Ponte's long-time deputy, David Tolbert, who is also leaving at the end of the year, expressed shock that UN officials would "show friendship and support to someone indicted for war crimes." Afterwards, when asked by Inner City Press where he would be heading at the end of the year, when Serge Brammertz takes over as lead prosecutor of the ICTY, Tolbert declined to say where, only that it would be announced soon. Asked why he was not chosen, he said, "Ask the Security Council." Or, perhaps, ask Brammertz.

As luck would have it, there was a Brammertz sighting on Friday night when the Ambassador of Liechtenstein threw a party in his 50th story penthouse on 40th Street and Second Avenue. A guard with a guest list stood in the lobby; upstairs Brammertz, who usually is surrounded by three or four body guards, mingled with the crowd. Perhaps it's the transition from the Hariri case in explosive Lebanon to the quieter ICTY explains the seeming drop-off in security. Then again, things are heating up in Kosovo...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ictykosovo121007.html