Tuesday, July 7, 2020

Carpenter Serving 40 of 70 Months Wants Out Obese With Flooring But SDNY Judge Denies


By Matthew Russell Lee, PatreonBBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - The Source
SDNY COURTHOUSE, July 7 – Trevor Carpenter was sentenced to 70 months in Federal imprisonment but was caught in the MCC during the COVID-19 pandemic.
On July 7, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge P. Kevin Castel held a proceeding to consider a sentence reduction. Inner City Press live tweeted it. Waiting for court reporter, Judge Castel called this week a "soft opening" of the courthouse, with no jury trials in sight.
Federal Defender Marcus Amelkin says that in the MDC, inmates are stacked on top of each other, quotes SDNY Judge Engelmayer about incarceration meant "as punishment, not trauma," at a sentencing on [Thursday.]
 Judge Castel: If Carpenter was sentenced in 2017, why was he in the MDC?
FD: He was in transit and got stuck in MDC. His property is already at the next facility.
Judge Castel:  A couple of weeks ago, I heard BOP had designated 3 transit facilities
FD: The same memo was sent to Federal Defenders. But we haven't seen any movement. New arrests are being put in MCC & MDC, quarantined for 14 days. Some who've come in off the street have tested positive. We filed our motion on June 23. Things are worse since then... Things are first weren't so bad in Butner, Yazoo City and Oakdale. Then things got bad quickly.  So Mr. Carpenter is at risk. He is overweight. He has gained more, they get cold salami and baloney sandwiches as their meals
Judge Castel: He's 5'9'' & he's 170 pounds?
FD: We think he's over 190.
Judge Castel: CDC says BMI of 30. FD: That's obese. He's overweight. He has family history of diabetes. He should be released. He was originally charged in The Bronx. It was a trigger lock.
FD: He took a class on flooring. Judge Castel: F-L-O-O-R-I-N-G?
FD: Yes. Refurbishment. He took a class on real estate too. He was not a drug kingpin. Hand to hand weight, in his underwear. He is not a danger to the community.
AUSA Krouse: He has not shown that he falls into the narrow band with increased risk if they contract #COVID19.  The MDC has had certain issues. [This morning a defense lawyer spoke of a "gun loose" in MDC, leading to lockdown, here.
  AUSA Krouse: This Court sentenced him to 70 months. Nothing has changed. He's only served 40. His 7th conviction, 5th felony, all firearms related. One attempted murder, firing into a crowd outside a McDonalds. 14 rounds in the magazine, one in the chamber.
FD: He was not convicted of attempted murder. He was charged with it, and pled guilty to felony destruction of property. We did the math. If he weighs over 190, he'd be obese. He's close to the threshold. Nothing has changed? Everything has changed.
 FD: The sentence was 70 months, with rehabilitation. But he's in lock-down, terrified of getting the virus. All programs have been suspended. We ask that you grant compassionate release.
AUSA Krause: If I could be heard -
Judge Castel: You mean Paragraph 40?
Judge Castel: My copy has the counts he was sentenced on. As a trial judge I took at the columns. Count 2 was monument, intentional damage. Court 4 for firearm possession. Count 5 was attempted murder, he got 8 years. It seems he pled guilty to that.
FD: You are correct, if I misstated, I apologize. I don't want to get into a fight on it. 
Judge Castel: Page 3 of the sentencing transcript, there was no objection to the PSR. Just to make that little point... I realize the defendant has had a difficult upbringing. Age 19, criminal trespass. Age 24, convictions I went through including attempted murder. At this stage of the game, he's served 40 of 70 months. He's taken flooring, which I learned about today
Judge Castel: Defendant has not met his burden.
The case is US v. Carpenter, 17-cr-455 (Castel) 
***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

HuffPo Use Of Jon Hamm Crotch Photo Triggers Suit From Copyright Troll in SDNY


By Matthew Russell Lee, PatreonBBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - The Source
SDNY COURTHOUSE, July 7 – In 2013 the Huffington Post used a photo of Jon Hamm with his crotch obscured by a box saying, Image Loading.
 Now notorious copyright attorney Richard Liebowitz, recently slammed by U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Jesse M. Furman, sued. 
 On July 7 SDNY Judge Ronnie Abrams held a proceeding in the matter. Inner City Press covered it.  
Liebowitz, perhaps wisely, let James H. Freeman do the argument for him. And it was a highbrow argument, about what constitutes satire and thus fair use, and what doesn't.
The defendant's lawyer argued that the box made it a commentary; Freeman said that real Jon Hamm fans would want to license even the doctored picture, and so he needed discovery.
 Judge Abrams reserved judgment.
The case is Schwartzwald v. Oath Inc., 19-cv-9938 (Abrams)
***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Securities Fraud Defendant Neil Cole Asks Where He Is In Queue For Trial But Unclear


By Matthew Russell Lee, PatreonBBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - The Source
SDNY COURTHOUSE, July 7 – Neil Cole was indicted in 2019 for securities fraud and "improperly influencing audits" of Iconix Brand Group.
On July 7, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Edgardo Ramos held a pre-trial conference. Inner City Press covered it.  
The case had been scheduled for trial on May 11, but that was pushed back due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
On July 7, defense counsel asked, Where are we in the queue? Judge Ramos was not able to say with certitude. A new conference was scheduled, for August 11 at 11 am.
The case is US v. Cole, 19-cr-869 (Ramos)
***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Mintz Sued Loeb Partners Then Died But Breach of Contract Claims Lives On At SDNY


By Matthew Russell Lee, PatreonBBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - The Source
SDNY COURTHOUSE, July 7 –   Norman N. Mintz sued Loeb Partners for a million dollars on a 2013 deal. He sued in 2019 to recoup the money - and then in 2020 he died. 
 On July 7 U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Katherine Polk Failla held a proceeding. Inner City Press covered it. 
 Judge Failla expressed condolences, which counsel thanks her for.
 Then she read out a decision dismissing Mintz' unjust enrichment claim, but kept his breach of contract claim alive, how ever ironic.
The case is Mintz v. Loeb Partners Corp. et al., 19-cv-4829 (Failla)
***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

In Ozuna Case SDNY Judge Vyskocil Gives Oleaga Final Warning As Shroff Cites W2


By Matthew Russell Lee, PatreonBBC - Decrypt - LightRead - Honduras - Source
SDNY COURTHOUSE, July  7 -- On March 24 Erick Oleago's lawyer Sabrina Shroff announced in the SDNY Magistrates Court that a case of Coronavirus had been identified in the MCC jail and 11 North locked down.
 On May 4, Shroff wrote to SDNY District Judge Mary Kay Vyskocil in rare opposition to an SDNY prosecutor proposed protective order: "Re: United States v. Ozuna 20 cr 213 (MKV) Dear Judge Vyskocil: I write on behalf of Mr. Erick Oleaga, and in opposition to the government's request that the Court enter its proposed protective order. See Docket No. 62. The order as drafted is over broad, and, given the on-going pandemic, makes meaningful review and preparation of defendant’s case difficult, if not impossible."
 On July 7, Judge Vyskocil - and Shroff and Oleaga - held a proceeding. Inner City Press live tweeted it:
AUSA Bagliebter: We are concerned... We defer to Pre-Trial Services.
Judge Vyskocil: Anything from Pre-Trial? Speak louder.
Pre-Trial: I don't believe there are any conditions that could ensure his compliance. We urge revocation of bail and remand to Marshals.
Pre-Trial: I hoped having this hearing scheduled would help defendant regain compliance. But last weekend he was out for hours.
Defense lawyer Shroff: He is working. Judge Vyskocil: He was supposed to provide verification.
Shroff: I have the W-2. It's on the books... We can't re-do his childhood. Let's try one judicial warning, and another hearing in three weeks or 30 days. He's enrolled in therapy. I've heard from another lawyer that MDC is on lock-down due to a loose gun [! picked up]
Judge Vyskocil: Ms. Shroff, I signed an order on June 4 modifying bail conditions to provide for mental health. You're telling me that has not yet been done?
Shroff: It was scheduling. Judge Vyskocil: Mr Oleaga, you are in a very serious situation here.
 Judge Vyskocil: I will give you one more chance. I will ask Pre-Trial Conference to keep me informed. I will set another status conference, I'm not going to call it a bail hearing because I hope it is not that. Final warning.
 We hope to have more on this - or not.
 The case is US v. Ozuna, et al., 20-cr-213 (Vyskocil)
***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

SDNY Judge Engelmayer Advised He Might Remand Angevine Now Does For 5 Months


By Matthew Russell Lee, PatreonBBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - The Source
SDNY COURTHOUSE, July 7– Jaquan Angevine was charged in 2017 with identity theft and bank fraud.
Now he is on Supervised Release, and on June 16 appeared before U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Paul A. Engelmayer on alleged violations of supervised release. Inner City Press covered it, here.
  On July 7, Inner City Press covered the sentencing, live tweeting it:
 AUSA Herman cited social media posts show Angevine with a lot of cash, giving a Cartier watch to a woman, while not paying restitution.
Probation: We are seeking 11 months due to continuing non-compliance. "Angevine left his house June 24."
 Judge Engelmayer: "I previously indicated my intention to impose a term of imprisonment today. But where and when should he report?" Probation: He can self-surrender to Marshals in SDNY. Judge Engelmayer: I will give a date, this week. Where? Probation: 500 Pearl.
Angevine's lawyer Mr. Diaz: "All my representations are based on information and belief based on my conversations with Mr. Angevine... This is a non violent offender... There is #COVID19 in the jail. I recommend an additional year of supervision." 
Angevine speaks: I'm going through alot. My mother getting sick, losing my friends to violence. I'm asking if I could please get another chance. Judge Engelmayer: I'm just going to take a moment & collect my thoughts.
Judge Engelmayer: A term of imprisonment is required here. You have committed a series of violations of the terms of your supervised release. You pled to four separate violations... To a much lesser degree, there is general deterrence. I can't say I'm thinking much about that here... I sentence you to five months imprisonment, beginning Friday at 2 pm. After that, 3 years of Supervised Release.
Back in June, Judge Engelmayer provided notice in advance, "the Court may order Mr. Angevine's immediate remand."  Sentencing on the violations was set for first week in July.
 Judge Engelmayer says "it's my understanding that at some point in July the court will open for non-trial criminal conferences.... Mr Smallman will tell you if it's that, or CourtCall."
He declined to remand Angevine, citing COVID-19, and said how he acts between now and July will mean something.
The case is US v. Angevine, 18-cr-108 (Englemayer).
***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.