Friday, November 20, 2026

After Huawei Trial Courtroom Closing Opposed by Press EDNYnews Spox Ousted It Now Closing



After Huawei Trial Courtroom Closing Opposed by Press EDNYnews Spox Ousted It Now Closing

by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

EDNY COURTHOUSE, Nov 16 – With the USA v. Huawei trial now underway in Federal court in Brooklyn, presiding Judge Ann Donnelly on September 8 instructed prospective jurors: "China and the Communist Party … are not on trial."

  The same was said, or claimed, in the Southern District of New York in the UN corruption trials of CCP-member Ng Lap Seng, and CCP-NGO boss Patrick Ho of the China Energy Fund Committee. Both were convicted. But is Huawei different?

On September 9 Inner City Press put out a 20 tweet thread of the opening arguments, on X and Bluesky.

September 9 extra on X for subscribers here and Substack here

  On September 16-17 Inner City Press published a book, Huawei on Trial in Brooklyn, Surveillance from Iran to the UN, here. It contains information on how Huawei enables surveillance by many UN states / the UN. In the White House on September 18 there was talk now minimizing spying.

On the afternoon of September 18, this: "on the government's motion to close the courtroom for three witnesses's testimony."

  Inner City Press that night emailed opposition to the closure, along with a request that DOJ's motions for the closure be unsealed, now docketed here.

Jump cut to October 19, when Inner City Press went and spoke at the podium against courtroom closure, noting that not a single page of transcript of October 2's closing had been provided.

After receiving the parties' responses (themselves sealed), on October 20 this:  "After the public hearing held on October 19, 2026, the government, at the Court's direction, filed supplemental briefing in support of its motion to close the courtroom for an additional witness's testimony. The government's motion and all supporting and opposing briefing have been filed under seal. (See ECF Nos. 898, 904, 906, 911, 913.) The Court grants the government's motion. The closure of the courtroom will be tailored by providing access to redacted transcripts as soon as possible after the witness's testimony. Specifically, the government will provide proposed redactions to the defendants within 72 hours after the witness testifies, at which point the defendants may offer objections that the Court will promptly resolve. Opinion setting forth the Court's reasoning in detail to follow. Ordered by Judge Ann M. Donnelly on 10/20/2026."

 So, 72 hours then another 72 hours for the defense? Meanwhile, nothing from October 2. Nothing.

That remained the same on November 4, when EDNY prosecutors' spokesman John Marzulli had Inner City Press "escorted out" of the the courthouse, and on November 16 when, after an SDNY Judge's order said / confirmed it has a right to enter and cover, it went back in. Even with comparative restriction which should be removed, it almost-live tweeted the jury charge conference, and from the US closing:


OK - back in Huawei trial after "escorted out" for 6 days, now jury charge conference. At first there was no overflow courtroom, there there is one, with at least 2 with laptops. Inner City Press not using one, instead "live" tweeting just after, thread below 1/x

On the jury charge
Q: For the obstruction charge, does misleading in a Congressional hearing count?
Judge Donnelly: I'm permitting it, because it's in the indictment.
AUSA: Mr. Stout has an issue.
Judge: Go ahead.
AUSA Taylor Stout: Page 99 of the jury charge...

AUSA Taylor Stout: Our letter of very early Saturday morning...
Judge Donnelly: Gas-lighting [light laughter in the courtroom, as least so it seems from the overflow courtroom where the large screen is lit so you can't see, and the clock by it has no hands]

Judge: I don't think we can say the banks aided and abetted Huawei in allegedly violation IEEPA

Asst US Attorney: The banks are innocent parties.

[HSBC which got a Deferred Prosecution Agreement here in EDNY under Loretta Lynch for money laundering for El Chapo?

 

As promised, with restriction now more from Huawei (in which other use laptops freely in the overflow but Inner City Press remains restricted).

AUSA Meredith Arfa: ... Count 7 is wire fraud by false statements to HSBC and BNP Paribas. A scheme to defraud.

AUSA: You've seen the admission of Ms. Meng... They told banks they didn't produce government equipment, that they didn't work with the IRCG. That was false. They said they did not use the victim banks for money from Iran, that was false

AUSA: They sent a lot of the Iranian money through dollar clearing in North America. They lied about North Korea. The government doesn't need to prove all of those, only one. We must prove Huawei defrauded banks to obtain money

AUSA: You heard about Ms. Meng lying to Alan Thomas of HSBC... Huawei obtained billions and billions of dollars in loans.

Extra Nov 16 on X for Subscribers here and Substack here


On November 4, Inner City Press was targeted by the DOJ prosecutors' spokesman John Marzulli and then the office of the EDNY District Executive and marched out of the courthouse by three federal Court Security Officers. It has hindered Press coverage of this Huawei trial.

  The allegation? Using a cell phone in the courtroom - as happens from many, every day, in the Huawei trial. This supposed crime, with which a full day later I have not been charged in writing, was only alleged by the US Attorney's Office's Marzulli, ignoring those friendly to him using cell phones right next to him. 

  It reflects poorly on the US Attorney's Office and DOJ, to have personnel falsely and selectively accusing people and having them punished without due process. And so on November 6 I filed a FOIA request. On November 9, DOJ as it is way denied expedited processing. That morning, all three firms defending Huawei were informed that the Press has been removed from the courtroom, including Jenner & Block whose Katya T. Jestin objected repeatedly on November to questions to Huawei witness Wong about Iran, and Syria, and Sudan. Thread here, and watch this site.

More on X for Subscribers here and on Substack here


More/update on X for Subscribers here and Substack here

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

Mail: Box 130222, Chinatown Station, NY NY 10013



Other, earlier Inner City Press are listed here, and some are available in the ProQuest service, and now on Lexis-Nexis.

 Copyright 2006-2026 Inner City Press, Inc. To request reprint or other permission, e-contact Editorial [at] innercitypress.com