OUTSIDE EDNY COURTHOUSE, Nov 18 â A
criminal case in the Eastern District of New York is
supposed to be public. Wednesday afternoon, a status
conference in United States v. Jeffries, et al. is to be
held by Zoom, and as of Wednesday morning the public
docket did not list a public call-in or listen-only line.
Only some press were told, and they were told to telephone
the EDNY District Executive's office to learn the "public"
call-in line. This is how today's EDNY works, or doesn't.
Inner City Press wrote to Judge
Nusrat J. Choudhury, emailing chambers and submitting a
PDF for the docket, asking that one be posted. It argues
that a hearing held by videoconference is as presumptively
public as one in a courtroom, and that a hearing with no
means for the public or press to listen is not public in
practice, however it is docketed.
A closed or restricted hearing, it notes,
would need a specific on-the-record sealing determination,
which when sought by the government requires review by the
Department of Justice in Washington. The letterâs
sharper point concerns how people are told about the line.
The public, it says, cannot legitimately be required to
telephone the EDNY District Executiveâs Office as the only
way to get the number. Nor should members of the public
have to be on a selective distribution list of the U.S.
Attorneyâs Office to learn that they may listen. That
arrangement, it says, leaves the impression that the
public may listen only with the approval of the District
Executiveâs Office and, apparently, of the U.S. Attorneyâs
Office.
This has happened before in the case. When
it last wrote to Judge Choudhury, the response was an
email from Mr. Loguercio of the District Executiveâs
Office. That, the letter says, does not solve the
public-exclusion problem. It adds that this is
particularly so given the Officeâs recent actions in Lee
v. Corcoran, the Southern District case Inner City Press
has brought over the revocation of its press passes in two
EDNY trials. In that case, it says, a request on Monday,
Nov. 16 that the District Executiveâs side clarify by 10
a.m. Tuesday whether an EDNY-admitted attorney may bring
devices into the courthouse went unanswered by that time.
The docket is at CourtListener.
It also says it submitted to the
District Executiveâs Office in August an informational
request about EDNY access criteria, which remains
unanswered. The request is that the public call-in
line be docketed forthwith, and for all future virtual
conferences in this and other EDNY criminal cases.
The courts have long held that the right of the public and
press to attend criminal proceedings is rooted in the
First Amendment (Richmond Newspapers v. Virginia, 448 U.S.
555 (1980)). Whether that right has been honored where the
means of listening is controlled by an administrative
office rather than posted on the docket is the question
now before Judge Choudhury.
Inner City Press will report what the Court
does. Neither Judge Choudhuryâs chambers nor the District
Executiveâs Office had responded to the letter at the time
of publication