Friday, November 20, 2026

In MLB Bribery Trial of Clase EDNY $400000 Expert Does Not Want To Day How Much DOJ Pays Him

EDNY COURTHOUSE, Nov 18 – The baseball bribery trial of suspended Cleveland Guardians pitchers Emmanuel Clase and Luis Ortiz, along with bettor Robinson Vasquez Germosen completed jury selection after two full days on November 3.  Then during the opening statements on November 4, EDNY prosecutors' spokesman John Marzulli, with a single call to the District Executive, had Inner City Press escorted out of the courthouse, amid its reporting including that the non-appearance of cooperator Enoc Pena is a major black eye for this prosecution team, and the whole Office.  It has remained out for 12 days, until with an SDNY court order it returned on November 14, with witness Olivo on the stand. A nearly-live tweeted thread:

OK - back in US v Clase trial after "escorted out" for 6 days, now US witness Olivo on stand, Enoc Peña nowhere to be seen; at least 2 in here using phones. Clase in pink suit. Inner City Press not using one, instead "live" tweeting just after, thread below 1/x

AUSA Rebecca Urquiola: How much did you bet on Mr. Clase's pitches on this day?
Olivo: $1468, on the 9th inning, 1st batter, 1st pitch.
AUSA: GX S-3 [will these be made available?]
AUSA: Who gave you the information?
Olivo: Enoc Peña. He gave info, below 94.5 mph

AUSA: OK, let's turn to June 13, 2023. Who were the Guardians playing?
Olivo: San Diego. This was text sent by Enoc Peña to the WhatApp group.
AUSA: Did Mr. Clase end up pitching that day?
Olivo: No.
AUSA: June 16, 2023 - who did Guardians play?
Olivo: "Diamonds"

Pena
AUSA: And how just came in?
Agent: Emmanuel Clase [in a light blue park, it was April and a surprise party - and now, surprise surprise, EDNY spox Marzulli comes in. #Casablanca

AUSA: What does this message say?
Olivo: There is work, the boss says.
AUSA: Who was "the boss"?
Olivo: Enoc Peña.
[The woman with (very) short hair Inner City Press previously observed with Luis Ortiz leaves the courtroom]
On November 18, after suing in SDNY, restored in EDNY, and after hours, this:

OK - back in US v Clase trial after "escorted out" for 6 days, today press pass restored, Wharton prof, Juan Gonzalez on the stand, Enoc Peña nowhere to be seen. Now after the fact, "live" tweeting, thread below 1/x

Cross of prof
Clase's lawyer: Professor Taylor, is there a substantial difference between Kalshi and DraftKings in sports betting?
Taylor: At one time Kalshi was saying they didn't accept prop bets.
Clase's lawyer: On Kalshi you can't bet on strikeouts per game?

Taylor: I don't know.
Clase's lawyer: Do have any reason to think you can't?
Taylor: At one time Kalshi said they didn't accept it.
Clase's lawyer: So you don't know what bets the company you consult for offers?
Taylor: No, I don't

Clase's lawyer: You're paid for your time testifying here?
Taylor: Yes.
Clase's lawyer: With taxpayers' money?
Taylor: Yes.
Clase's lawyer: In total, Market Economics billed $733,860 for all experts from your company?
Taylor: That's sound about right.

Clase's lawyer: And for your personal time they billed $322,760?
Taylor: I assume you're taking that from the invoices.
Clase's lawyer: I absolutely am.
Taylor: That was the total for me and my staff.
Clase's lawyer: So your staff's billing is under your name?

Taylor: One of my assistants is classified that way.
Clase's lawyer: So when the report says, By Prof Dan Taylor, it might not be?
Taylor: Well it's classified by experts and one of them is me and my staff member and then there's another one

Clase's lawyer: The other expert billed $411,100 for a little over 800 hours?
Taylor: I don't think anyone has billed for that high an amount
Clase's lawyer: Well, that's in the breakdown that's what it says
Taylor: There are two others on my team, maybe combined

Clase's lawyer: Do you do other consulting work for the EDNY US Attorney's Office?
Taylor: I do.
Clase's lawyer: And with DOJ in DC?
Taylor: Yes.
Clase's lawyer: How much have you billed DOJ this year, in total?
Taylor: My company?

Clase's lawyer: Other than this case.
Taylor: Do I need to provide that?
Clase's lawyer: Your Honor, it goes directly to the witness' credibility and possible bias.
Taylor: Well I'd rather not disclose that information.
Judge Matsumoto: I do think it's proprietary

Clase's lawyer: Judge, can we have sidebar on this?
Judge: Sure.
[Extended sidebar on whether DOJ / EDNY's expert, paid with taxpayer funds, will be allowed to NOT disclosure how much the government has paid him]

There's more - 2d book coming


Back on November 3 Judge Kiyo A. Matsumoto ruled that the defense CAN say, in opening statements on November 4, that "Pena is a cooperator." The prosecution opposed it and said they will continue to object.

Inner City Press, covering the case toward a book, live tweeted jury selection and pushed, twice more, to get the promised overflow courtroom open, mentioning to the judge herself as she ate a yogurt in the hall during a break. We're looking into that, she said. Later, the overflow court room not only didn't have a video feed: it was locked again. Inner City Press was told only "in-house" media as defined by the EDNY District Executive's Office could be in the courtroom at one point. Then the overflow room must be and remain open throughout the trial. 


November 3 (jury selection) extra on X for Subscribers here and on Substack here

   Earlier extra on X for Subscribers here and on Substack here

This as the 2d Circuit ruled late on Nov 3: "USCA ORDER: It is hereby ORDERED that the motion for a stay of the district court proceedings and the petition for the writ of mandamus be submitted for merits determination by November 17, 2026, or the first available panel thereafter. The October 30, 2026 denial of Petitioners motion for an administrative stay of the district court proceedings remains in effect. Certified Copy Issued: 11/3/2026. USCA# 26-2965. (VJ)"

It's on....

More on X for Subscribers here and Substack here