Friday, November 20, 2026

After Habeas of Man Shot by ICE in Marble Hill Unsealed by Inner City Press Now Judge Denies It and No More Unsealing

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Nov 20 – On October 9 Inner City Press covered the habeas corpus hearing on Oscar Belgal, shot in Marble Hill by ICE the day before, DOJ wrote in they intended to detain him in MDC Brooklyn, and live tweeted here and below.

On October 14 it was refiled in EDNY in Brooklyn, and assigned to Judge Hector Gonzalez. The filings were not available on PACER. So Inner City Press wrote in, and Judge Gonzalez to his credit docketed it. Then on October 21: "ORDER: Interested party Matthew Russell Lee's request is granted to the extent he seeks public access to filings that are not filed under seal.  The Clerk of Court is respectfully directed to make all previous and future filings on the docket, except for those filed under seal, publicly available via remote access."

On November 4, the day after Inner City Press made similar requests to seven EDNY judges, DOJ spokesman John Marzulli targeted Inner City Press and got the District Executive's Office to confiscate its press passes to the Huawei and Clase trials and have it escorted out of the courthouse.

Six days later, still out, Inner City Press wrote to Judge Gonzalez on another habeas case he has:


While grateful for the transparency, it appears that the Clerk of Court misperceived your Order: today November 10 Belgal's initial petition, and all filings up to October 22, on PACER (outside the courthouse) are still listed as "You do not have permission to view this document."

  Since your October 22 order, your EDNY District Judge colleague Judge Rachel P. Kovner has docketed an Inner City Press request in Cepeda Guaman v. Maldonado, 1:26-cv-05827 - RPK, adding that "As a one-time courtesy, the Court has docketed the request at Dkt. #16. In the future, requests for court action should be filed through ECF or the Clerk's Office."

  I regret that on November 4, 2026 the District Executive's Office confiscated my EDNY press pass in such a way that I am no longer able to access the Clerk's office as I did before. I am again emailing this request to Chambers. There is more to explain but I am keeping this to one page.

Thank you for your consideration. A PDF of this letter is attached for ease of docketing.

Full letter on Inner City Press' DocumentCloud here.

Ten days after that, with Judge Gonzalez and others now following the District Executive confiscation Press passes have refused to even docket these requests to make public (Judge Kovner did docket, she said for the last time), on November 20 Judge Gonzalez denied Belgal's petition: "On October 8, 2026, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (“ICE”) arrested Petitioner Oscar Belgal in Manhattan’s Marble Hill neighborhood. Petitioner was ultimately transferred to the Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklyn (“MDC”), where he remains detained. He now seeks a writ of habeas corpus pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 2241. ECF No. 1 (“Petition”).  1 For the reasons that follow, his Petition is DENIED." Order on Patreon here.

Watch this site.

More on X for Subscribers here and Substack here