Friday, November 20, 2026

In MLB Bribery Trial of Clase Special Agent Reads Messages Mostly Involving Absent Enoc Peña

EDNY COURTHOUSE, Nov 17 – The baseball bribery trial of suspended Cleveland Guardians pitchers Emmanuel Clase and Luis Ortiz, along with bettor Robinson Vasquez Germosen completed jury selection after two full days on November 3.  Then during the opening statements on November 4, EDNY prosecutors' spokesman John Marzulli, with a single call to the District Executive, had Inner City Press escorted out of the courthouse, amid its reporting including that the non-appearance of cooperator Enoc Pena is a major black eye for this prosecution team, and the whole Office.  It has remained out for 12 days, until with an SDNY court order it returned on November 14, with witness Olivo on the stand. A nearly-live tweeted thread:


OK - back in US v Clase trial after "escorted out" for 6 days, now US witness Olivo on stand, Enoc Peña nowhere to be seen; at least 2 in here using phones. Clase in pink suit. Inner City Press not using one, instead "live" tweeting just after, thread below 1/x

AUSA Rebecca Urquiola: How much did you bet on Mr. Clase's pitches on this day?
Olivo: $1468, on the 9th inning, 1st batter, 1st pitch.
AUSA: GX S-3 [will these be made available?]
AUSA: Who gave you the information?
Olivo: Enoc Peña. He gave info, below 94.5 mph

AUSA: OK, let's turn to June 13, 2023. Who were the Guardians playing?
Olivo: San Diego. This was text sent by Enoc Peña to the WhatApp group.
AUSA: Did Mr. Clase end up pitching that day?
Olivo: No.
AUSA: June 16, 2023 - who did Guardians play?
Olivo: "Diamonds"

AUSA: What does this message say?
Olivo: There is work, the boss says.
AUSA: Who was "the boss"?
Olivo: Enoc Peña.
[The woman with (very) short hair Inner City Press previously observed with Luis Ortiz leaves the courtroom]
Olivo: June 16, he didn't that day

AUSA: Here what does it say?
Olivo: He needs to throw two roosters.
AUSA: What does that mean?
Olivo: That any money he made, he would bet on two cockfights [in DR]
AUSA: And where it says, say the [efe], what does that mean?
Olivo: Efe means efectivo means cash

Olivo: Here is says, Did you bring it to him liquid? That's when his eyes fill up.
AUSA: Who does that refer to? Who is "the man"?
Oliva: Mr. Paca.
AUSA: OK, now the Oakland As. Did he pitch?
Olivo: Yes. But I lost on a parlay betting also on the Diamonds

AUSA: Did there come a time in 2023 when betting because difficult? What does this say?
Olivo: It is from Draft Kings, saying the Enoc Peña had multiple accounts.
AUSA: Did they demand information from you?
Olivo: Yes, I had to send in my driver's license.

AUSA: Did you later continue betting?
Olivo: Yes.
AUSA: Here, what does it say?
Olivo: Este maricon [EDNY prosecutors mistranslate it as "jerk"] he throws too many strikes. Stupid Paca was not paying attention
[Clase confers with Pablo Davis now at defense table]

 

As promised, with restriction now more from US v Clase (in which other use phones but Inner City Press remains restricted).
Vasquez Germosen's lawyer Spodek: You started the "san" in 2019?
Olivo: Or 2020.
Spodek: Before any bets on Clase?
Yes

Spodek: Mr. Vasquez could have used his money from the san to bet, right?
Olivo: Yes.
Spodek: You opened an account in the name of your partner?
Olivo: Yes she likes to bet on football [soccer]
Spodek: Did you use her account to gamble?
Olivo: When she had money

Spodek: Did you meet with the FBI?
Olivo: Yes.
Spodek: And in your first interview you provided no information that Mr. Vasquez betting?
Olivo: I did not
Spokek: He wasn't in your betting conversation?
Olivo: I didn't know he was betting

Spodek: You met with the FBI on Oct 28, 2025 by Teams?
Olivo: I don't remember the date. My lawyer was present. At the beginning I did lie.
Spodek: About?
Olivo: About having inside info from Enoc Pena.

Spodek: But you didn't tell then about any role for Mr. Vasquez
Olivo: I did not.
Spodek: Did you go to the prosecutors' office down the block from here [on Cadman Plaza] on November 21, 2025?
Olivo: I don't remember the date. This time I was honest

Spodek: Never anything about Mr. Vasquez?
Olivo: Never.
Spodek: Did you sent Mr. Vazquez Zelle payments for the san?
Olivo: Yes. Every week for 7 to 8 years. My brothers too
Spodek: You never sent for bets on Emmanuel Clase pitches?
Olivo: No

Spokek: Enoc Pena was your information source?
Olivo: Yes. By phone and text, sometimes in person.
Spodek: Your Honor I believe a juror may have to ask for a pause
Judge: Already, break

More to follow, hopefully with less restrictions

On November 17, as "live" tweeted from Cadman Plaza park during the lunch break:

OK - this morning in US v Emmanuel Clase trial after "escorted out" for 6 days accusing of phone - when in EDNY courtrooms today, as before, dozen use laptops & phones. EDNY Spox willfully blind, "Casablanca," now pending 11/18 reply "live" tweets below

AUSA: Special Agent, who is in this video?
Agent: Robinson Vasquez and Enoc Pena
AUSA: And how just came in?
Agent: Emmanuel Clase [in a light blue park, it was April and a surprise party - and now, surprise surprise, EDNY spox Marzulli comes in. #Casablanca

AUSA: What does this text say?
Agent: For Enoc Pena to stay in town. He answers, I'll ask the guys, they are poor today and they will be poor tomorrow so there is not much difference.
AUSA: What's this video from Robinson Vasquez' phone?
Agent: it's of Enoc Pena

AUSA: And what's this a screenshot of?
Agent: "Your payment was sent," from Enoc Pena to Robinson Vasquez.
AUSA: For how much?
Agent: $2575
AUSA: In this one, what does Clase say it's for?
Agent: Repairs at the country house, steel bar so we can let the dogs out

AUSA: Who's drivers license is this?
Agent: Enlly Manuel Alvarez Mayi.
AUSA: Your Honor, can I put him on the board?
[Chart of mugshots not visible to those of us in the courtroom. @EDNYLIVE Spox Marzulli leaves - to "call Gene" again?


Back on November 3 Judge Kiyo A. Matsumoto ruled that the defense CAN say, in opening statements on November 4, that "Pena is a cooperator." The prosecution opposed it and said they will continue to object.

Inner City Press, covering the case toward a book, live tweeted jury selection and pushed, twice more, to get the promised overflow courtroom open, mentioning to the judge herself as she ate a yogurt in the hall during a break. We're looking into that, she said. Later, the overflow court room not only didn't have a video feed: it was locked again. Inner City Press was told only "in-house" media as defined by the EDNY District Executive's Office could be in the courtroom at one point. Then the overflow room must be and remain open throughout the trial. 


November 3 (jury selection) extra on X for Subscribers here and on Substack here

   Earlier extra on X for Subscribers here and on Substack here

This as the 2d Circuit ruled late on Nov 3: "USCA ORDER: It is hereby ORDERED that the motion for a stay of the district court proceedings and the petition for the writ of mandamus be submitted for merits determination by November 17, 2026, or the first available panel thereafter. The October 30, 2026 denial of Petitioners motion for an administrative stay of the district court proceedings remains in effect. Certified Copy Issued: 11/3/2026. USCA# 26-2965. (VJ)"

It's on....

More on X for Subscribers here and Substack here