Showing posts with label nuclear free middle east. Show all posts
Showing posts with label nuclear free middle east. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 23, 2013

US & UK on Diego Garcia In UN Disarmament's Long Day's Journey into Night: Saudi, Sushi


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, October 23 -- Wednesday was Disarmament Night in and across from the UN, with the Latin American nuclear free zone of the Treaty of Tlatelolco collecting its award, complete with classical music, sushi and four kinds of beer. 


  Wednesday night diplomats approached Inner City Press on both sides of First Avenue with their own tales of abuse by the UK and US, on the African nuclear free zone or Treaty of Pelindaba.

  It is diplomatically stated that "the status of the Indian Ocean island of Diego Garcia, controlled by the United Kingdom and used as a military base by the United States, with regard to the Treaty is unclear."
  UNclear? If the US and UK are so high and mighty on nuclear proliferation, why not just commit to not landing there? Fueled by finger food and liquor, an African diplomat told Inner City Press neither country wants to say which of its ships are nuclear. "It's absurd," he said. In the UN's First Committee, this is heard at much, much length.
  Inner City Press has been following the end of session rights of reply in the First Committee, usually involving North Korea taking on South Korea or Japan. North Korea wins many of these skirmishes: their speaker is articulate and sassy, for example asking South Korea to "talk to its master" -- the United States -- if it has the courage, or ask another to do it.
  In the time allotted after 6 pm, Inner City Press has been live-tweeting these exchanges, and getting responses. Some agree the North Koreans are well trained, and others don't. There's talk of the South Korean mission melting down last year at how they were losing the exchanges, and of a trash-talk school.
  Down at the disarmament award reception on the UN's first floor Wednesday night, talk turned to the Nuclear Free Middle East proposals, and Saudi Arabia's renunciation of a Security Council seat. Was it about Israel, on this, or Iran? The consensus was Iran. And we'll have more on that tomorrow. Watch this site.

 
  

At UN, Nuclear Free Latin America Gets Disarmament Policy Award, No Questions Allowed on UK and Malvinas, UN Censorship Alliance


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, October 23 -- On Wednesday the UN Office for Disarmament Affairs, the World Future Council and the Inter-Parliamentary Union invited the media to a 30 minute UN press conference "to announce the Future Policy Award 2013 for the world’s best disarmament policies."

  Seeing in the front row an official associated with the "Treaty for the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons in Latin America and the Caribbean," it seemed that at least some had been told in advance of the winner.

  But Inner City Press live-tweeted the naming of honorable mentions from Belgium, Costa Rica, Mozambique / South Africa and Mongolia, and Silver awards to Argentina and New Zealand. (The description of each policy provided in advance is below.)

  The UNODA moderator said there would be time for questions, and Inner City Press had one, even tweeted it to UK Ambassador Mark Lyall Grant in advance for comment: what about the nuclear protests of the UK and Malvinas / Falkland Islands?

  The prepared statement giving the award mentioned Cuba hosting nuclear weapons. But what about the UK?

  But the prepared statements were allowed to take up the full 30 minutes. Inner City Press raised its hand, and prepared toprotest on behalf of the Free UN Coalition for Access@FUNCA_info. A press briefing must allow questions; otherwise journalists are being used as "extras" in a made for video production.
  But grabbing the first question as has become an untenable routine, the president of the UN Correspondents Association, Pamela Falk of CBS, proceeded to THANK those who gave the questionless press conference. Then she used the privilege to ask her own question.
Her sidekick, too, wanted to ask a question, about the IAEA. But the main question had to be: how could this be organized this way? 
  And if about Latin America and nuclear weapons, how could the UK and Malvinas not be mentioned? Inner City Press asked, and the panelist agreed it should be raised, the UK cuts its budget but not nuclear.
We have yet to hear back from the normally responsive Ambassador Lyall Grant on this. Here were the seven short listed finalists:
1. Argentina – National Programme for the Voluntary Surrender of Firearms, 2006 [Silver]
2. Belgium – Law on Anti-personnel Mines, 1995 and the Law regulating Economic and Individual Activities with Weapons, 2006.
3. Costa Rica – Abolition of the Army, Article 12 of the Constitution, 1949.
4. Mongolia – Law of Mongolia on its nuclear-weapon-free status, 2000.
5. Mozambique and South Africa – Agreement between the Government of the Republic of Mozambique and the Government of the Republic of South Africa in Respect of Cooperation and Mutual Assistance in the field of Crime Combating, 1995.
6. New Zealand – New Zealand Nuclear Free Zone, Disarmament, and Arms Control Act, 1987 [Silver]
7. Latin America and the Caribbean– Treaty for the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons in Latin America and the Caribbean, Treaty of Tlatelolco, 1967 [Winner - Malvinas not shown]
This evening the awards will be given out, alongside a UN First (Disarmament) Committee reception. Watch this site.
Footnotes: At the noon briefing, Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesperson Martin Nesirky announced there would only only five minutes of questions. For FUNCA, Inner City Press asked why this was, how the questionless press conference before was permissible. 
  Nesirky replied not to waste what little time he granted on a "technical" question -- Inner City Press also asked about Sudan's statement of what the UN's Herve Ladsous, who dodges questions, heard about visas -- then said tomorrow's another day.
It is, but the shrinking of media / question access remains a pattern, one not being confronted (in fact, being allowed and encouraged) by the Gulf and Western media on the Executive Committee of the UN Correspondents Association, now known as Ban's UN Censorship Alliance. 
 The point here, at a minimum, is that the UN must allow another press group to exist, rather than trying to threaten the withdrawal or suspension of accreditation for hanging the sign of the Free UN Coalition for Access while its UNCA has five signs.
 Before the disarmament briefing, a UN staffer had put a rain coat over the "UNCA chair," so Falk could occupy it when arriving late. But occupy it for what? Watch this site.

 
  

Tuesday, October 8, 2013

With US Coy on Egypt Aid, At UN Egypt Meeting US Absence Blamed on Shutdown


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, October 8 -- Amid the murk of how much aid to Egypt the Obama administration might cut, and why, Inner City Press noted that at the UN on Tuesday the US did NOT attend an Egypt-sponsored event about a Nuclear Free Middle East. 

  And that this was blamed, from the floor, on the US government "shutdown." Click here for Inner City Press story of Tuesday afternoon.

  This of course even then seemed dubious. The US State Department is continuing to function; the decision not to attend or speak at the Nuclear Free Middle East event, held in a too-small room and not televised by the UN, had explanations entirely beyond the shutdown.

  But in the Nuclear Free Middle East meeting, Egypt played to the standing room only gallery, saying a meeting by itself means nothing without results, saying it has in the past been at the table but still been on the menu, chiding Israel for not attending or at least not speaking.
  Egypt at this meeting did NOT criticize the US. Rather, from the floor a Frankfurt-based NGO offered excuses for the US' invisibility, blaming it on the government shutdown.
  As to WHY the Egypt sponsored "open" meeting at the UN on Tuesday was not televised like other meeting at the UN, the Free UN Coalition for Access @FUNCA_info repeatedly asked the UN.
    Past 9 pm, UN official Stephane Dujarric replied to FUNCA that "regarding, the Egypt sponsored meeting on the nuclear free-zone. I am not aware of any request by the organizers to have the meeting webcast or televised."
  This immediately raises questions: if a request to televise an open meeting at the UN is required, who requested televising Ban Ki-moon in a "closed" September meeting denouncing Syria's Assad? Click here.
   On Tuesday, Iran took shots at Israel, just as earlier in the day Israel wrote to UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon protesting Iran being rapporteur of the Disarmament Committee of the UN General Assembly of UNGA
On that, this was what the White House sent out at 8:42 pm:
Dear journalist colleagues: Many of you have been asking about news reports on U.S. assistance to Egypt. Below is a comment you may use on the record, attributable to NSC Spokesperson Caitlin Hayden:
The reports that we are halting all military assistance to Egypt are false. We will announce the future of our assistance relationship with Egypt in the coming days, but as the President made clear at UNGA, that assistance relationship will continue.
What else did Obama "make clear at UNGA"? Watch this site.

 
  

Amid UN Television Cut Offs, Favoritism Alleged & Raised by FUNCA, No Answers in 24 Hours - Then Half an Answer


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, October 8, updated twice -- At all levels of the UN there's a need to increase transparency and responsiveness, to root out favoritism and, yes, to increase assess. 

 That is the mission of the Free UN Coalition for Access, which 24 hour hours ago put a series of questions to the UN Department of Public Information's Stephane Dujarric, in charge of the News and Media Division and thus, at least he thinks, in charge of the press corps which cover the UN and what they write or even tweet.

  A complaint was received, then follow-ups, concerning among other things a hiring that Dujarric was said to be lobbying for. The individual concerned, Inner City Press has previously had opportunity to name, as responsible for cutting off UN Television while Syria's Permanent Representative Bashar Ja'afari spoke back in June 2012. Click here for that.

As to why that happened, when the meeting was nearly over Dujarric replied, "I don't know. You should ask the organizers." In the spirit of transparency, this response was tweeted via @FUNCA_info (Dujarric favorited it); Egypt's Deputy Permanent Representative was asked if his mission asked to not have the open meeting broadcast. No, he answered.
  Now, 24 hours after it was sent, and after Dujarric said he would be replying today October 8 (it is now past 7:45 pm), here are inquiries that were sent to Dujarric by the Free UN Coalition for Access:
The question, like the tweet early this morning said, is a follow-through (and provision of due process) on a complaint received about the "Operations Branch" and a proposed recruitment.
I don't want to take any chance of putting the complainant in danger of retaliation, so I can only summarize with some charges the complaint. But this should allow you to answer it. In this light,FUNCA has been asking since January for due process to be afforded to all journalists at the UN: they should be informed or and asked about complaints made against them and given an opportunity to respond. FUNCA is still waiting to see the promised changes beyond the dubious Media Access Guidelines issued with UNCA.
Summary of the complaint (which, because it asserts the lobbying of Peter for this, is being cc-ed to Peter)
1) DPI's News and Media Division Director Stephane Dujarric is rushing Peter Launsky Tieffenthal the new USG of the Department of Public Information to make an exception for the appointment of [  ] the former Chief of Radio as Chief of the News and Media Division's newly created Operations Branch.
QUESTION 1: Is she proposed for this position? Would any "exception" be requested or required? Has Peter been consulted about this?
2) Though she does not meet any of the basic qualifications and requirements for the job, it seems that [Peter] is being pressured to seriously consider Dujarric's request for the promotion at the D1 Level of one of Dujarric's close advisers who does not meet the basic requirements for this high level post.
QUESTION 2: What are the requirements for this post? Is "pressure" being applied? What have been the steps in the outreach and recruitment, consideration and interviewing?
3) It is asserted (in response to other follow-up questions) that the position requires many years of experience in human resources, personnel, administration and budget which she does not have. That's why Dujarric has requested [Peter] to make an exception and overrule a negative decision probably made within OHRM. AN exception can be only granted by USGs as they make decisions on behalf of the Secretary General.
QUESTIONS 3-5: Was there a negative decision? If so, was it from OHRM? Is Peter being asked to "make an exception" to it?
4) More generally, and you can respond to this as you will, the complainant characterized her as, well, not competent, but favored because she has helped "cover up" mismanagement ranging from "waste of DPI money to manipulating posts and limiting promotions to a preferred and restricted group of people who are very loyal to 'Dujarric's gang.'"
Like I said, respond to this last as you will -- it is provided (as DPI did NOT do, including on a document DPI / Dujarric should never have been given, explicitly marked internal to UNCA) in the spirit of due process.
Given the UN's stated move into social media, you or someone in DPI should be available via Twitter (I've raised this to MALU as well, Twitter would be a good way for MALU and the wider DPI to be informed of problems, needs or opportunities for improvement, and anything else) -- notably, you responded to another complaint about a broken link to INSTRAW, but nothing (yet) on being informed that UN TV / Webcast got the name wrong of one of two presenters at recent migration press briefing.
Since the UN sent out the invite -- it first went through UNCA, which we protest -- and the UN sent a staffer who served ONLY those three media which went on the plane, this is a protest, by FUNCA.
On the Security Council stakeout, there is more to be said, but FUNCA notes that during the General Debate you put in tables there for the White House press corps. This shows that tables CAN go there, and while it would probably NOT be as many as you put and photographed, it should be some, we maintain, to enable optimal coverage of the UNSC.
FUNCA is trying to help; FUNCA aims for a more accessible and transparent UN, including one where journalists have due process rights and there is no specter of censorship, lack of free speech or association, or (now on this complaint) of retaliation.
Expectantly, and in the spirit of an improving and more accessible UN,
The Free UN Coalition for Access.
  First, Dujarric said "I'm just now looking at my Twitter account and see a question from you. What exactly do you want to know? If you need urgent attention, always best to call or email. There days when I'm on Twitter a lot and other days almost not at all."
  This seems strange, for a person so associated with the UN and social media. And after Dujarric's accreditation unit since June has threatened to suspend or withdraw Inner City Press'accreditation for merely hanging a sign of the Free UN Coalition for Access on the door of its shared office -- while Dujarric's favored (and politicized) UNCA has five signs -- FUNCA even more than before favors public domain, open source communications with UN Media Accreditation and DPI.
  Then, after receiving the above, Dujarric at 10 am Tuesday morning said, "Questions received. I hope to have something back to you by the end of the day." Then at 2:30 pm, "I don't know. You should ask the organizers." Then nothing, as the work day ended. Nothing.
  We will be happy to run whatever responses are received, again in the spirit of due process, and improving the UN. Watch this site.

Update - after another e-mail request sent to Dujarric and those above him, still no response. Although the individual named as cutting off UNTV on Syria's ambassador was named at the time without complaint (or really, response), we are redacting and pronoun-izing above. It's not required, but it's nice to be nice. 

Update II -- and after 9 pm, the following was received -- which on the Nuclear Free Middle East event implies that only events for which the organizers REQUESTED coverage by UNTV get it. So -- more newsy -- who requested coverage of the Ban Ki-moon "closed" meeting with the women's group in September where he called the Syria report he hadn't seen "overwhelming"? 

Did Ban request it? These answers never say what the rule is, or what the process is. This is the opacity (and double standards) that FUNCA will continue to oppose, even under Dujarric's censorship-related threat of June 24. Here:

From: Stephane Dujarric [at] un.org
Date: Tue, Oct 8, 2013 at 9:04 PM
Subject: Re: Re: Questions (those of 24 hours ago and still on Egypt's event on "Middle East zone free of nuclear weapons," no on EZTV? [and, FUNCA is trying to help; FUNCA aims for a more accessible and transparent UN, etc thanks
To: funca [at] funca.info
Cc's

Dear Matthew, In reference to your questions earlier I can tell you that the selection process for the position you mentioned is proceeding in accordance with the recruitment instructions established by the Under-Secretary-General for Management and the case will be reviewed by the Central Review Bodies.

Regarding your query about traveling press with the Security Council I understand you have already been in touch with the Spokesperson's office on this issue and I have nothing to add.

As for my availability on Social Media, I make every effort to answer queries but if you need an immediate answer, it's always best to pick the phone or send an email.

Regarding, the Egypt sponsored meeting on the nuclear free-zone. I am not aware of any request by the organizers to have the meeting webcast or televised.

Lastly, as for your comment about the end of the work day, I would delighted if my work day ended at 8:25p. As you can see from the time of this email, my work day is not yet over!

Stephane Dujarric (Mr.) Director
News & Media Division | Department of Public Information


So who requested coverage of the Ban Ki-moon "closed" meeting with the women's group in September where he called the Syria report he hadn't seen "overwhelming"? Watch this site.

 
  

At UN, "Open" Meeting on Nuclear Free Middle East Not Shown on UN Television, US Absent "Due to Shutdown"


By Matthew Russell Lee
UNITED NATIONS, October 8 -- It was listed in the UN's Media Alert: "Special Event on the Middle East zone free of nuclear weapons and all other weapons of mass destruction (co-organized by the Permanent Mission of Egypt and the Egyptian Council for Foreign Affairs)."
It was listed in Conference Room 7 in the North Lawn Building, a room with video cameras where events are routinely put on UN Television and in-house EZTV. But when the time came, the screen for Room 7 was in test pattern.
If the meeting was open, why not broadcast it? The Free UN Coalition for Access put the question by e-mail to the official in charge of UNTV, Stephane Dujarric, then ran over to try to attend the meeting in-person.
It was standing room only. In fact, the crowd spilled out into the cement-floored hallway of the UN's North Lawn Building. Photo tweeted by @FUNCA_info here. Inside, Egypt's Permanent Representative joked that even when Egypt is at the table, it is often on the menu.
Next to him, the UN's High Representative on Disarmament Angela Kane listened and prepared to leave early for another presentation she had to make, about chemical weapons in Syria.
  An irony of the non-broadcast, noted by Inner City Press: in September a meeting between Secretary General Ban Ki-moon and a women's group, though listed as closed, was broadcast by UNTV and Ban Ki-moon appeared saying Bashar al Assad has committed many crimes against humanity and Ake Sellstrom's report, which Ban had not yet seen, was "overwhelming."
  Tuesday's meeting on a Nuclear Free Middle East was listed as "open" -- but was not televised by the UN.
  The Russian Federation's speaker said that "someone" must pressure Israel to cooperate with the process.
Iran spoke, saying if we cannot put "outsiders" -- that is, Israel -- in, it's meaningless, and saying to focus universality of the NPT, the Non Proliferation Treaty.
Israel earlier on Tuesday complained to Ban about Iran becoming rapporteur for the General Assembly Committee on Disarmement.
A Frankfurt-based NGO said that reason the US was not represented at the meeting was because of the government shutdown (or slim-down, as some call it).
But there is no slowdown in spending, at the highest levels, in the UN. So why wasn't this meeting broadcast, as Ban's "closed" meeting on Syria was?
Near the meeting's end, the UN's Stephane Dujarric replied, "I don't know. You should ask the organizers."
And so Inner City Press did, asking Egypt's Deputy Permanent Representative if his country has asked that the open meeting not be shown on UN Television. No, he said, they had not.
So why wasn't this meeting shown? The Free UN Coalition for Access @FUNCA_info has in another series of questions, which Stephane Dujarric has indicated he will be answering. Watch this site.