Showing posts with label yvo de boer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label yvo de boer. Show all posts

Saturday, April 17, 2010

For UN Climate Job, 11 Candidates Including from Barbados and UN, Pasztor's Only Partial Recusal

UNITED NATIONS, April 15 -- With the UN's approach to climate change under fire, both politically and scientifically, the race is on to replaced Yvo de Boer as head of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change. So far two candidates have come to UN headquarters and held press conferences: Costa Rica's Christiana Figueres and, on April 15, Barbados' Elizabeth Thompson.

Inner City Press asked Ms. Thompson for her position on the widespread criticism of how the Copenhagen summit was run. She replied that there were both positives and negatives.

She declined to comment on IPCC chairman Rajendra Pachauri's refusal to disclose how much is paid by Deutsche Bank and Credit Suisse, among others, for his climate advisory services. She said she would comply with UN rules. Video here.

Later on April 15, Inner City Press asked UN spokesman Martin Nesirky how many candidates there are, and whether Janos Pasztor, Ban Ki-moon's main climate advisor, is one of them:

Inner City Press: how many candidates have been put forward? And can you say either by country or region? What can you say on that topic? And can you confirm that Mr. [Janos] Pasztor is actually one of the candidates, the current advisor to the Secretary-General on climate change?

Spokesperson Nesirky: Well, two things. One is that, as we have mentioned before -- and it is standard practice, not just for this job but for any job -- we do not reveal the names of candidates. But I can tell you that there are 11 candidates from 11 different countries. And although we do not normally comment, as I said, on individuals, we obviously understand the interest in a candidate that works for the Secretariat and therefore we can confirm that Mr. Pasztor has been nominated by the President of Hungary. The appointment will be made following a normal competitive process run by a selection committee and in consultation with the bureau of the UNFCCC. All candidates will go through the same process. I should tell you -- and this is important -- upon the announcement of his candidacy, Mr. Pasztor was asked to dissociate himself from activities relating to the UNFCCC with immediate effect.

Inner City Press: But how is that possible, to perform the job that he is conducting without in some way dealing with the UNFCCC? Can you explain that?


Elizabeth Thompson on April 15, UN rules and Pasztor not shown

Spokesperson: What I can tell you is that it will be dealt with in a transparent manner and Mr. Pasztor’s office is clearly not involved in the process of selecting a successor to Yvo de Boer. And, as I say, he has been asked to dissociate from activities that relate to the UNFCCC, and that is with immediate effect. And that is what is happening.

This seems like a fake and flimsy safeguard. How can one function as the UN Secretariat's main climate advisor while "dissociat[ing one]self from activities relating to the UNFCCC"? For that, with all due respect for the affable Mr. Pasztor, one should quit or take a leave of absence. It's what Shashi Tharoor did, for example, while he ran unsuccessfully for Secretary General.

It is not enough to says like Ms. Thompson one would abide by UN rules -- because, in essence, there are no UN rules. Watch this space.

Footnote: even to the use of the UN's press briefing room, the stated rule is, questions only by journalists. But at Thursday's session, various Caricom Ambassadors spoke up with prepared statements endorsing Ms. Thompson and nothing was said about it. It's not the ambassadors' fault -- it's the fault of Media Accrditation, which in turn fingers the UN Spokesperson's Office. So when the UN cites its suppposed rules against journalists...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/fccc1pasztor041510.html

Sunday, February 28, 2010

UN Ban Defends IPCC Report, No Comment on Pachauri, Derides Comparisons

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/ban3ipcc022410.html

UNITED NATIONS, February 24 -- Three weeks after the UN told the Press that "it's not really for the Secretary-General to weigh in on this specific report" of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Ban Ki-moon pointedly urged member states to "reject the last-ditch attempts by climate skeptics to derail negotiations by exaggerating shortcomings in the [IPCC] fourth assessment report."

Some wondered, if the UN saw no need to respond three weeks ago but now belatedly steps into the ring, does this indicate the type of desperation exhibited by the UN's hastily put together press conference after Yvo de Boer announced his resignation?

At Wednesday's UN noon briefing, three weeks after Inner City Press asked for comment on the IPCC's misuse of NGO press releases as science, it inquired into Ban's belated comment on the controversy, and his characterization of all who critique errors in the report as "climate skeptics."

Inner City Press asked asked how Ban's upbeat read out on Copenhagen squared with his Timor L'este envoy Ameerah Haq's frank statement to the Press that Copenhagen was a disappointment, reiterated February 23 at the UN Security Council stakeout.

Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky was once again testy, chiding Inner City Press that

"if you want to try to chip away between different people saying different things at different times, you could do that pretty much every day, and maybe you will... if you look at what might have been, had there not been the level of movement that there was in Copenhagen, then things would look even worse. Nobody has said that this is precisely what everybody wanted. Many people -- Yvo de Boer, Janos Pasztor -- who sat here right after the Copenhagen Conference with Bob Orr and spelled out what the role of the United Nations had been in getting to a good point, but that it was not good enough; that more needed to be done. So, it’s very easy to try to push a wedge between two different people."

After this diatribe, several correspondents asked Inner City Press in essence, what is wrong with Nesirky? To compare two statements is basic journalism. And to report on now-acknowledged errors in an inter governmental body's scientific report is not necessarily "climate skepticism" -- it is journalism. The UN does not seem to understand this.

Inner City Press asked, on February 3 and 24 and even before, for Ban's comments on IPCC chair Pachauri's refusal to make financial disclosure about income he receives from Deutsche Bank and others for advice related to his IPCC job. Nesirky responded that "To come back to the part of the question about business dealings and disclosure, this is something that he himself, Mr. Pachauri has spoken about himself, and I have no need to elaborate further on what he himself has said."

That's leadership. The person more and more widely accused of lacking transparency has rejected the charges. What more could the head of the Organization need to say? Perhaps, as on Himalaya Gate, Mr. Ban will comment in three weeks. Watch this site.

Footnote: beyond her refreshingly candid comments on Copenhagen as disappointment, Ms. Haq also answered Inner City Press' questions about an incident in which UN Police in Timor L'este were filmed standing by at Timor L'este police beat up a protester. She said it is under investigation, and that UNPOL has a duty to report. But don't they also have a duty to protect civilians?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ban3ipcc022410.html

Saturday, November 21, 2009

At UN, Yvo de Boer and Africa's Secret Climate Number, of Indian Black Carbon and Shell Games in the Niger Delta

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/uncope5offmessage112009.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 20 -- With the UN simultaneous shrinking hopes for the Copenhagen climate change meeting and telling the Press not to cover the diminshed expectations, its top negotiator Yvo de Boer on November 19 effectively set $10 billion as the ceiling for transfers to the developing world.

There is only one problem: the African Union alone is said to be looking for $67 billion annually, with a threat to walk out of Copenhagen is less is offered. Inner City Press asked de Boer is he knew of the African Union number, and if even a feigned successful conference would be possible in the Africans walked out.

De Boer said that as a UN official, he believes in bringing people together, and that any walk out would be bad. He then argued that $10 billion was only a start, not a ceiling at all. But by stating the number as an indicia of success, he effectively did that.

Inner City Press asked de Boer to comment on India's environment minister Ramesh's comment that not only will India not make binding commitments in Copenhagen on greenhouse gas emissions, it will not discuss black coal emissions at all: "Copenhagen meeting is for negotiations for cuts in GHG emission and not for black carbon emission. We would resist any move for bringing in black carbon emission for discussions. Scientific link between black carbon emission and global warming and melting of glaciers is still being studied."

At first de Boer said he hadn't seen the comment and so couldn't response. Then Inner City Press e-mailed it to him.Hours later, to his credit, de Boer responded:

Subj: Here's the Minister Ramesh / black carbon emissions quote I've asked about
From: Yvo de Boer [at] unfccc.int
To: Inner City Press
Sent: 11/19/2009 8:24:29 P.M. Eastern Standard Time

The Minister correctly states that the climate negotiations do not address black carbon as it is not a greenhouse gas. However efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions can also significantly lower emissions of black carbon

We'll see. Meanwhile, given the environment, some were surprised on November 18 to find Shell's Elizabeth Cheney in a UN conference room blithely praising her company's record.

Inner City Press asked about Shell's activities for example in Nigeria, specifically in the Niger Delta where Shell was accused for playing a role in the death of activist Ken Saro Wiwa, and is currently being sued before the ECOWAS court for pollution and human rights violations.

Ms. Cheney said Shell is "suffering the activities of criminal and terrorists [who] blow things up." She said, "We are not the government of Nigeria... sometimes we shut production and move out of area."

But what about pressuring those who oppose the oil drilling or distribution of revenue? "That's more detailed than we need to get into today," Ms. Cheney said. Afterwards she promised to put Inner City Press in touch with both "communications and... the leadership part of the business, there's more transparency there." If you say so...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/uncope5offmessage112009.html

Saturday, November 7, 2009

As UN's Ban Admits Copenhagen Deal Unlikely, His Story Is Re-Written

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/uncope3offmessage110409.html

UNITED NATIONS, November 4 -- For months, the UN and its Secretary General Ban Ki-moon have been calling for a legally binding agreement on climate change to be reached at the Copenhagen meetings in December. When Ban's advisor Jeffrey Sachs on October 6 said this would be unlikely, and Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesperson to comment, the response was that Sachs spoke only his his personal capacity.

When UN climate negotiator Yvo de Boer later in October was quoted by the Financial Times that a legally binding agreement was unlikely, and Inner City Press asked Ban's climate point man Janos Pasztor about it, Pasztor said that de Boer had been spoken to, and was incompletely quoted by the FT.

But when Ban was quoted in London that a legally binding agreement is unlikely, and Inner City Press asked his spokesperson Michele Montas to comment on this change of position, she replied "that has already been said here." Video here, from Minute 20:25.

To some it seemed that comments portraying an agreement in Copenhagen as unlikely has been repudiated by Team Ban, and only now adopted. Why not admit to the change?

Later a senior Ban advisor explained to Inner City Press, a legally binding agreement is now "physically impossible," given the amount of time remaining. But why publicly downplay the change? Inner City Press asked the advisor, and will continue to ask: what does "Seal the Deal" mean now? And who has the SealTheDeal2010 website, now that the 2009 version become of only historical interest? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/uncope3offmessage110409.html

In Run-Up to Copenhagen, of UN Web Sites Lost and Posts Empty by U.S.

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/uncope2offmessage102809.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 28 -- On climate change, while even Yvo de Boer of the UN says it's unlikely the deal will be sealed in Copenhagen in December, the UN Secretariat still maintains that there is no Plan B. And apparently that is true: while they got "SealTheDeal2009.org" to advocate for an agreement, "SealTheDeal2010.org" was recently obtained by another, through GoDaddy.com.

With all the resources the UN is devoting to Copenhagen, one might have expected them to at least take the 2010 domain name off the table. But perhaps they thought it would show a lack of faith.

Meanwhile, as a response to Inner City Press' article documenting nepotism in the Office of the President of the UN General Assembly, including PGA Ali Treki bringing his daughter and a cousin into the Office, Inner City Press has been informed that Treki asked the United States to second a staff member to his office on the climate change issue. The Obama administration has yet to come through.

From the October 27 UN transcript:

Inner City Press: I’ve been told that the, the Office of President Treki asked the United States to appoint a staff member to cover the issue of climate change, I guess to second a staff member from the United States Mission or the United States State Department to serve in the Office. Is that something you’re aware of? Is that true?

Spokesperson Jean-Victor Nkolo: Well, I don’t think I would like to go into staffing matters in a specific office at the United Nations. I don’t think that would be proper. But what I can tell you is that the Office of the President of the General Assembly is definitively staffed by a wide array of personnel coming from all horizons -- Africa, Europe, the Middle East, Latin America. It’s a very international team and I think that it will be good that the international profile of this team continues to be reinforced. What I wouldn’t like to comment on are specifics regarding staffing matters.

Inner City Press: Is there currently somebody, I mean maybe you can comment on this one, is there, on the issue of climate change, is there currently a staff member of the Office covering that issue?

Spokesperson Nkolo: What I can tell you is that we are only a few a weeks after the General Assembly started its session, and as you know, the work of any session of the General Assembly starts in mid-September. It takes some time, usually, to actually have all the positions filled and this process is still ongoing and it does not, it’s not limited to the climate change issues. There are other areas that are being filled and the cabinet of the President of the General Assembly is working hard to make sure that all areas are filled quickly, but as efficiently and professionally as possible.

So they haven't filled the climate change post, this close to the Copenhagen meeting? Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/uncope2offmessage102809.html

On Copenhagen, Un's De Boer and Sachs Dubious, Off Message on Upbeat Seal the Deal

By Matthew Russell Lee
www.innercitypress.com/uncope1offmessage102609.html

UNITED NATIONS, October 26 -- UN climate negotiator Yvo de Boer was quoted in the Financial Times last week that "a fully fledged new international treaty under the [UN framework] convention [on climate change] - I do not think that will happen. If you look at the limited amount of time remaining to Copenhagen, it's clear."

Monday at the UN, Inner City Press asked Janos Pasztor, Director of the Secretary-General's Climate Change Support Team, how what de Boer said is consistent with the more upbeat "Seal the Deal" message emanating from the 38th floor. Video here, from Minute 50:05.

"We discussed it with Mr. de Boer extensively afterwards," Pasztor replied. "Not everything he said was quoted. His message is total consistent." Pasztor added that they will go for an ambitious agreement in Copenhagen. We we cannot get a legally binding treat, he said, they we'll do it later.

When Inner City Press asked Pasztor if the UN is claiming de Boer was misquoted by the FT, he did not say yes; So apparently de Boer was read the riot act, and told to get back on message.

Some say de Boer is lucky -- Ban's deputy envoy to Afghanistan got fired for going public with his claims of electoral fraud in Afghanistan being covered up.


UN's Ban and de Boer: on the same page on deal being sealed?

On October 6, another Ban advisor Jeffrey Sachs told an audience including the Press that he doubts the deal can be sealed in Copenhagen. When Inner City Press asked Pasztor about this, he replied that Sachs represents and advises Ban only on the Millennium Development Goals. But perhaps Sachs too has now been read the riot act. If even the UN's small "global goods" team cannot stay on its polyanna message, can they be surprised as other fall away?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/uncope1offmessage102609.html

Saturday, March 7, 2009

As UN Covers For Obama Climate Backslide, It Does Not Carbon Offset, "Act Not Together"

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at the UN
www.innercitypress.com/ban2climate030609.html

UNITED NATIONS, March 6 -- As the UN provides groundcover for the Obama administration's retreat from its climate change rhetoric during the electoral campaign, the UN "doesn't have its act together" on even offsetting the impacts of travel by its Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon and other high officials, the UN's Yvo de Boer told the Press on Friday.

Mr. de Boer held a press conference to announce positive movement on climate change in Congress, at least in the House of Representatives. Inner City Press asked if he and UN agree with the Denmark's Minister of Climate and Energy Conniee Hedegaard, who has said if the U.S. doesn't pass cap and trade legislation in 2009, it will be a step backwards. De Boer responded that Rep. Markey (Dem-MA) told him legislation should emerge from his House committee in May. The Senate, de Boer said, is more complicated. That's an understatement.

Inner City Press asked if he agreed that Obama's climate negotiator Todd Sterns statement that any 25% reduction in emissions by the U.S. by 2020 is unrealistic is a "diss" of the UN's IPCC. De Boer said he agreed with Stern -- de Boer subtly moved the goal post being dissed to 40% -- but said that perhaps the U.S. could invest money in deforestation projects as a way to show seriousness.

On that, Inner City Press asked de Boer whether he, Ban Ki-moon and the UN are offsetting the carbon emission of their travel. De Boer admitted that they are not, saying that they are trying to come up with a methodology but "we don't have our act together yet." Video here, from Minute 49:22.

This seems the least one could expect from a Secretary-General who speaks so much about climate change. A senior Ban advisor, speaking on condition of anonymity, told Inner City Press that the Ban administration thinks that carbon offsetting is hype. Why not say that publicly, then?

Inner City Press asked asked de Boer about a leaked draft of European finance ministers, that industry and not government should foot the bill of helping the developing world reduce its emissions. Governments print money, de Boer quipped, but they don't make it. One way or another, the taxpayer is on the hook. It's what the banks are saying, too. Some view it as competing ransom notes.

De Boer was asked about the climate "mini-summit" with Obama that the Ban Administration had leaked and then undercut, when they thought Obama would not come. De Boer said that climate and summits will be on Ban's agenda in Washington next week. We will continue to follow these issues.

Footnote: in fairness to Ban Ki-moon, Inner City Press asked the spokesman for President of the General Assembly Miguel d'Escoto Brockmann, before his recent trip through Iran, Syria and Geneva, if he would be carbon offsetting. Ask the PGA, the spokesman said.

But the next day, when d'Escoto took questions in front of the Trusteeship Council, Inner City Press was asked to not repeat the question, an answer would be forthcoming. Then none was received, despite Inner City Press providing its previous coverage of UN offsetting -- in the case of one conference -- and not offsetting.

It's like Ban's demotion of Tanzanian Anna Tibaijuku from the UN's top post in Nairobi, during women and gender week: practice what you preach. We'll see.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ban2climate030609.html

Saturday, April 12, 2008

UN's Climate Chief Yvo de Boer Unaware of WMO's "World Is Cooler" Statement, BBC Controversy

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/wmo1deboer041008.html

UNITED NATIONS, April 10 -- The UN's point man on climate change, Yvo de Boer, on Thursday told the Press he was unaware of comments to the BBC by the secretary-general of the UN World Meteorological Organization Michel Jarraud that the world has not gotten hotter since 1998. "I have not read the articles," he said when Inner City Press asked him. "If I get then and I were to read them, I'd be happy to respond." Video here, from Minute 48:57.

After the press conference, Inner City Press e-mailed him the articles, but nothing. From another UN source, WMO's back-tracking response arrived, in which "in response to media inquiries," Jarraud is quoted that "For detecting climate change you should not look at any particular year, but instead examine the trends over a sufficiently long period of time." De Boer in the press conference affirmed that the IPCCC has "pointed to, no, has shown" that temperatures have risen "since the Industrial Revolution."

The more troubling part of the controversy, from an independent media perspective, is that BBC while initially standing behind its quoting of Jarraud ended up not only changing its story, but not leaving any mark that it had done so. The piece's author Roger Harrabin is quoted in this UK environmentalists' account, and it does not look good. Following threats, he says, "we have changed the headline and more."

While leaving the UN briefing room, de Boer opined that he has in the past asked for headlines to be fixed. But what about the "and more"? We'll await his or the UN's response.

On straight environmental, and independent media, issues Inner City Press asked de Boer about the calls in Bangkok for the UN's International Maritime Organization and ICAO do to more on climate change. De Boer said both of these agencies -- and the WMO, see above -- are expert, but that some countries don't feel they've gone far enough. He pointed out that ships can use fuel or water as ballast, and can fuel-up anywhere, making enforcement difficult. Video here, from Minute 39:10. That and the exclusive jurisdiction of the flagging nation... To be continued.

Friday, February 15, 2008

UN's de Boer Explains Bali Tears and Comma's Silent Impact, Branson Dodges, Steiner's Secrecy

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/ga1climate021108.html

UNITED NATIONS, February 11 -- "You can't hear a comma," UN climate change point-man Yvo de Boer told Inner City Press on Monday. He'd been asked about the negotiations in Bali in December, specifically about his widely-seen but little understood crying jag near the end of the conference. While the voice-over on a number of global television broadcasts of his tears had ascribed them to the tenseness of the talks or the state of the planet, de Boer on Monday confirmed that he'd been accused by China of holding two sets of negotiations over two sets of documents. He said there had been confusion about when the informal talks ended, and the formal ones began. The rest, he said, "will be for my book." Video here.

Afterwards, off-camera, de Boer said he "felt bad" for the Americans, who were "put in an uncomfortable position" by a comma not enunciated by the Indian delegation at the talks. As de Boer recounts it, the talk was of a sentence providing that developing countries should take real, measurable and verifiable actions ... but should be provided with real, measurable and verifiable financial resources into order do that. The question left unanswered by the reading, according to de Boer, was whether "real, measurable and verifiable" referred only to money, or related to other provisions. The U.S. was left out on a limb, and Yvo de Boer regrets it.

Asked about coal by Inner City Press, de Boer said that moratorium on coal use is not realistic, but there are still legitimate questions about whether carbon buried via "capture and store" technology will in fact stay buried. At least de Boer answered this question. An hour earlier, in the same room but with many more journalists present, Sir Richard Branson of Virgin Airways dodged the identical coal question from Inner City Press, answering instead about biofuels. After saying that corn ethanol does not, on balance, reduce dirty energy emissions, Branson admitted that he is invested in corn biofuel. Daryl Hannah, shrugging off the UN press corps' jokes about mermaids -- based, it seems, on her appearance in the 1980s movie "Splash" -- answered that biofuels are best when made from waste, or even algae. Video here.

In the Trusteeship Council chamber as afternoon turned to dusk, Sha Zukang of the UN Department of Economic and Social Affairs concluded with what he called, to some laughter, "propaganda from DESA." Kemal Devis of the UN Development Program -- and formerly of the World Bank -- said that the World Bank has a role in middle income countries. While the director of the UN Environment Program Aichem Steiner speechified, UN correspondents with time on their hands noted that Steiner is not listed as participating in any way in the UN's financial disclosure program. We'll have more on this.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/ga1climate021108.html

Wednesday, December 19, 2007

Post-Bali, UN Blames China for Breakdown of de Boer, Mr. Ban's Game Face Described

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/bali121807.html

UNITED NATIONS, December 18 -- Anyone who says that the climate change meetings in Bali weren't a success, the UN's Bob Orr told the press on Tuesday, "wasn't at the same meetings I was at." But Al Gore was quoted that "the maximum now considered possible here in this conference is still far short of the minimum that will really solve this process." Inner City Press asked if Al Gore, then, was at the same meeting. Ban Ki-moon's spokesperson responded deadpan that Mr. Ban and Gore had been together. There is a photo to prove it.

But what of the UN's Yvo de Boer breaking down in tears? Television stations which used the clip said that it showed how tense the talks were. But Tuesday after his formal briefing, Orr told Inner City Press that the Chinese delegation had accused de Boer of a lack of transparency, for some of the side meetings going on. That had pushed de Boer to the breaking point. He wept and said he'd been unaware of the side meetings. Orr also said that China was very constructive. Of course.

Of the side-story of Ban's subsequently-cancelled plan to fly from the Far East to New York to attend half of a Carnegie Hall concert to raise funds for a cultural center in South Korea, Orr laughed and said he hadn't heard of it while in Bali. Another reporter doubted this, since Ban nevertheless appeared at the concert by video message, apologizing. But maybe things really were that busy in Bali.

The UN Development Program had issued a report calling on China and India to commit to emission caps, a position with which the UN's Dr. Pachauri publicly disagreed. Inner City Press asked Orr about this split, but did not get an answer. Video here. Monday night, UNDP's Ad Melkert brushed off a request for a read-out on his UNDP-funded time in Bali. Perhaps we'll hear more, from Mr. Ban himself. It is said that when he returned to the Bali meetings on Saturday, the hall broke into applause. "They wanted a deal," Orr interpreted. We'll see.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/bali121807.html