SDNY COURTHOUSE, Nov 15 â Federal judge J.
Paul Oetken on November 12 heard a request to restore the
press credentials and electronic device privileges that
the Eastern District of New York District Executive
"confiscated" on November 4, near the end of the US v
Huawei trial and midway through US v. Clase, et al.
The First Amendment case is Lee v. Corcoran, 26-cv-9896
(Oetken) and will go forward. But on the afternoon of
November 15, the eve of the closings arguments in Huawei,
Judge Oetken denied
the TRO. Reconsideration was immediately sought, here,
and Chambers notified.
Judge Oetken's Order (ECF No. 24)
says the Press âhas not shownâ a likelihood of success on
its First Amendment retaliation, viewpoint and Fifth
Amendment due process claims, and that, because it can
still attend the trials and take notes by hand, it has not
shown irreparable harm.
But reporting on a delay, occasioned
by leaving the courthouse and filings from a public
library on the other side of Cadman Plaza, is a harm. And
EDNY had already shown an inability or unwillingness to
provide an overflow courtroom for those who cannot fit in
the "real" courtroom, even when Judges Kiyo A. Matsumoto
(Clase) and Ann M. Donnelly (Huawei) say there will be
one.
Inner City Press immeidately filed a
motion for reconsideration or, in the alternative,
clarification, with a letter-motion asking that Defendants
be directed to respond on an expedited basis. The motion
points to matters the Order does not address: â
The standard. The Order applies the âclear
or substantial likelihoodâ test for mandatory injunctions.
The Press had argued, citing North American Soccer League
v. U.S. Soccer, that restoring passes it held without
objection until Nov. 4 restores the status quo and is not
mandatory. The Order does not discuss that argument.
Karem and Sherrill:
The Press cited the D.C. Circuit holdings that press
credentials are a liberty interest, requiring published
standards and fair notice before the conduct. Those cases
are not mentioned. Last month, applying them, Judge Kelly
of the D.D.C. granted a preliminary injunction restoring
White House passes to CNN, MS NOW and POLITICO (No.
1:26-cv-03287), which the government has appealed. Are
there separate and unequal First Amendment protections for
smaller, non-corporate media? Or for coverage in federal
courthouses as opposed to the White House or elsewhere?
The facts. The Order places the 2022
conversation both with Loguercio and with Marzulli, while
the complaint alleges a call with Marzulli and a meeting
with District Executive Corcoran. In the latter meeting,
Corcoran said the judges in EDNY don't like live tweeting
- this after Inner City Press live tweeted a trial from an
overflow courtroom where others were using laptops to
email in quotes to their newsrooms. What is the
difference? The Order also does not weigh the allegation
that others who used phones that morning were not removed,
a fact that Inner City Press has gone out of its way to
not flesh out despite requests.
The motion for reconsideration
also states that "
"Defendant Marzulli said he believed Plaintiff must be audio recording court proceedings because Plaintiff's reporting was so detailed. Counsel for Defendants on November 13, the day after oral argument, told Plaintiff that Defendant Corcoran said the same exactly thing. If accurate, these statements show that both Marzulli and Corcoran were aware of the content and detail of Plaintiff's reporting, and that their attention to Plaintiff was prompted by that reporting. In fact, they acted specifically on the content of Plaintiff's reporting - a very definition of First Amendment violation(s). They bear on the knowledge and causation gaps identified at Order at 5-6, and they are consistent with the allegation that Plaintiff was removed because of his newsgathering rather than because of a rule about phones."
Harm. The Order says the Press may
take handwritten notes and report later. But another
reporter was live-tweeting Clase while, the Press says,
reporters with in-house status can file from a press room
and the Press would have to go across the street, hours
later - and then wait in line again at security as the
court proceedings continue. For a news reporter, timing is
the work - as certainly as it was found actionable when
corporate media was removed from the White House press
pool and had to rely on (less) delayed pool reports.
The Press also asks the Court to clarify
footnote 2, which says Administrative Order 2025-02 lets
admitted attorneys âbring electronic devices into the
courthouseâ but does not say they may use them in a
courtroom. It asks whether an EDNY-admitted attorney may
keep a device stowed in a bag in such a courtroom, and use
it elsewhere in the building, such as the cafeteria, to
write up notes. The Press also plans to file an amended
complaint and a motion for a preliminary injunction,
including all after arising facts.
The November 11-12 papers: the verified
complaint, filed November 11 with a motion for a temporary
restraining order, names four defendants in their official
capacities: EDNY District Executive Eugene Corcoran, his
employee Michael Loguercio, USAO spokesman John Marzulli,
and U.S. Attorney Joseph Nocella Jr.
It charges First Amendment
retaliation, denial of due process, selective enforcement,
and seeks declaratory relief. The day after seven
unsealing letters to seven EDNY judges about public access
to ICE cases, Spokesman Marzulli who represents DOJ and,
essentially, ICE, said he would call the District
Executive, whose staffer Loguercio then arrived on the
10th floor and had three Court Security Officers demand
press passes for the Clase and Huawei trials. The showing
of a NYS bar card, and EDNY admission as a lawyer, was to
no available - the CSOs were told to "escort" out of the
courthouse.
On November 12, the assigned
AUSA - from SDNY, not EDNY - called this due process, and
also claimed there are not First Amendment issues. He
seemed to say that there is no right to take notes, even
by hand, in a courtroom. But what if the Marzulli's and
Corcoran's of the legal world allow only their friends to
use electronics and to report live or nearly so, while
telling the Press they don't like it can't even take
notes?
In a declaration filed four hours before
the argument (ECF No. 20), Corcoran said his office âwas
informedâ the targeted reporter âwas observedâ using a
cell phone in Courtroom 6B South during the Clase trial,
where a sign bans phones. He says he âdirectedâ Loguercio
to revoke both press credentials, both Clase and Huawei,
âand the associated privileges allowing him to use
electronic devices within the Courthouse.â The declaration
says, lawyer or not, the journalist will be required
"to provide his electronic devices to Court Security.â
In a letter brief (ECF No. 19), Assistant U.S. Attorney Gregory Margolis called Loguercio's arrival with three CSOs to confiscate press pass and direct the escorting out of the courthouse ânotice and an opportunity to be heard." He emphasized that the unsealing requests went to judges, not defendants. But Marzulli fielded and rebuffed Press requests for the promised redacted transcripts of the October 2 "closed" session in Huawei - STILL not provided as of November 12, with closing arguments looming. At the end of the oral argument, he said he accepted service of the complaint and other papers on behalf of all defendants. Good - because more filings are forthcoming.
Nov 12 courtroom extra on X for
Subscribers here
and Substack here
more coming, watch this site.