Saturday, December 16, 2023

Michael Cohen Filing Used Fake Cases It Seems Seeking Supervision End Now Sanctions Loom


by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Dec 12 – A month after Michael Cohen testified in the NY Attorney General's lawsuit against the Trump Organization, Cohen on November 29 asked to have his federal supervised released terminated early - calling his state testimony "well received." 

  This is in a filing with U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Jesse M. Furman, now on Patreon here.

On December 4, the US Attorney's Office opposed Cohen's request, quoting his state court testimony that he lied to SDNY Judge Pauley. Response letter on Patreon here.

 Inner City Press was in NYS Judge Engoran's courtroom when Michael Cohen admitted to having lied to SDNY Judge William Pauley. (The transcript Cohen annexes misspells it "Pauly.')

LATE of December 8 Cohen new counsel replied, that he was a predicate for the NY AG case against Trump. Full letter on Patreon here

Judge Furman noted a footnote therein, that cases in the first submission could not be verified. Inner City Press tweeted out the Order here. More on Patreon here.

The case is US v. Cohen, 18-cr-602 (Furman)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

As CITGO Sues Insurers Over Oil Taken by Guaido Forces Sealed Witness Not Named


by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Dec 12 – Venezuelan government owned oil company sued insurers to be paid for a million barrels of crude they say were taken off the M/T Gerd Knutsen on February 9, 2020 by Guaido forces.

But in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, the name of a witness - one of four captains - is being kept under seal, and the courtroom will apparently be sealed when his videotaped deposition is shown to the jurors. 

  Inner City Press was in the courtroom on December 12 when Judge Gregory H. Woods said that if the sealed witness was further identified in opening arguments, he would revisit his sealing order.  

 This takes place as elsewhere in SDNY, the criminal trial of Carlos Orense, which included testimony alleging the defendant used CITGO to launder money from the US back to Venezuela, is coming to a close.  

This civil case is Citgo Petroleum Corporation v. Ascot Underwriting Limited, for and on behalf of Lloyd's Syndicate 1414 et al, 21-cv-389, (Woods) 

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

UN Blocks Anyone From Taiwan from UNHQ But US State Department Dodges about ICAO


by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

UN GATE, Dec 12 – While today's US State Department says it is working to try to get Taiwan admitted as a member into some peripheral United Nations bodies, it ignores and does nothing about the fact that residents of Taiwan are unable to even enter the UN, as tourists - or journalists.

Under Secretary General Antonio Guterres, who replies only with the phrase "One China Policy" and bans the Press which asks about this, the UN will not allow anyone in with a Taiwan passport.

 Since the UN has no respect for freedom of the press - it has banned Inner City Press which asked about this, and CCP bribes - it bans any journalist from Taiwan.

And yet, today this: "On December 13, 2023, the American Institute in Taiwan (AIT) and the Taipei Economic and Cultural Representative Office in the United States (TECRO) convened representatives of the U.S. Department of State and the Taiwan Ministry of Foreign Affairs for consultations in Washington on expanding Taiwan’s participation in the United Nations system."

Today's State Department has done nothing about the UN's ban on Inner City Press, either.

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

In Extortion of Fire Victims Trial of Jatiek Smith Pro Se He Wins Motion on Evidence Tampering


By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Maxwell book

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Dec 12 –  The lead defendant in a criminal case alleging gang extortion in the field of clean-up services to properties damaged by fire asserted his Speedy Trial Act rights. 

 On September 9, 2022, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Jed S. Rakoff held an in-person arraignment and detention or bond proceeding, with the defendant's family and supporters filling half of the courtroom gallery. Inner City Press was there.

  On the request to move up the scheduled May 2023 trial to October, Judge Rakoff said he will speak with Judge Analisa Torres about changing the schedule of her US v. Tim Shea (We Build the Wall) trial. We'll see.

  On detention or release, the Assistant US Attorney recited from audio recordings of threatens, saying "N-word, I'm gonna kill you."  

 The defense lawyer, retained from Staten Island, pointed to those in the gallery and called the threats hyperbole. Judge Rakoff said the defendant clearly had supporters, but was a danger to the community. He was ordered detained.  

Afterward by the elevators, supporters said of the prosecutors after they left in a separate elevator, "They lie."

Jump cut to March 27, 2023, when Judge Rakoff convened a Curcio hearing on the lead defendant. In short order he ruled, there is no conflict, and adjourned the proceeding. Ten days prior, Judge Rakoff had denied this request to suppress the forensic copy of his phone, taken after he was denied entry into Jamaica and was found with $10,000 upon his return.

Back on September 13, Judge Rakoff held a proceeding with co-defendants. The lead defendant Jatiek Smith applied to move his trial from October 17 to November 28 was granted, and three co-defendants were allowed to join him for trial beginning that date, one with a new lawyer. The others remain for trial on "5-1-22," which we take to mean May 1, 2023.

On April 27, Jatiek Smith appeared before Judge Rakoff, seeking to go pro se. His CJA lawyer, it was said on the record, collapsed in the subway; Inner City Press is voluntarily not report further medical details.

  Jatiek Smith said he is tired of waiting for lawyers; he said, "You view me as an animal, so I'll just do it myself."

Judge Rakoff pointed out that the first CJA counsel's sickness was not his fault.

  Then Jatiek Smith asked for the courtroom to be cleared to speak about his experience with his lawyers. Inner City Press did not contest the sealing; it stood by the elevators with six AUSAs and, separately, supporters of Smith. When summoned back in, it was put on the record that Smith will communicate by 5 pm on May 1 if he wants to go pro se - in which case trial would start May 8 or 15 -- or continue with another CJA lawyer, or two, on August 14, moved up in the sealed session from September 19.

It emerged that 3500 material and other discovery cannot be shared with Smith on the same timeline as other defendants, which would impact his ability - and Constitutional right - to represent himself. It was unclear how or if this was addressed in the sealed session.

Thing became clearer on May 1, when the trial date (and representation) were set: "ORDER as to (22-Cr-352-1) Jatiek Smith. On 4/27/23, the Court held an in-person conference with Jatiek Smith, his then-primary counsel Thomas Nooter and co-counsel Jill Shellow, and prospective counsel Andrew Patel, as well as counsel for the Government. See 4/27/23 Hr'g Tr. As discussed further on the record during that proceeding, severe and unexpected medical setbacks that had very recently arisen affecting Mr. Nooter's health meant that Mr. Nooter was no longer able to try this case... following an on-the-record (but sealed) colloquy regarding the risks of going prose, Mr. Smith asked for some time to further consider the issue. He has since written the Court (in a letter that has been docketed separately, see dkt. 211) stating his preference to remain represented by Ms. Shellow (as primary counsel) and Mr. Patel (as co-counsel) and proceed with an August 14 trial date."

On July 11, the US Attorney's Office asked for at least 60 months for Hasim Smith.

On July 19, Inner City Press went to the proceeding for Jatiek Smith to fire his lawyers and go pro se. Judge Rakoff ordered everyone out of the courtroom except outgoing counsel and two associates in the courtroom gallery.

After more than half an hour, the press and public were allowed back in. Judge Rakoff said he had had a cordial talk with Smith and that he would be appointing now counsel, to meet with Smith by July 24. A week after that, Smith is to write in whether he wanted to keep these new counsel and see his trial pushed back, or go forward pro se with the trial starting August 16.

Docketed on July 27 was Jatiek Smith's letter from the MDC, that he will take CJA counsel and see his trial delayed.

On July 28 his brother Hasim Smith was up for sentencing, and got 30 months. Inner City Press was there, thread:

 Inner City Press  noticed the late - today - defense sentencing submission

Defense lawyer says he was late because his client is being "sentenced for things he didn't do."

Judge Rakoff thunders, You brought this on yourself.

Hasim Smith says Parole recommended he go to work in his brother's company, "chasing fires at night... I did not assault anyone."

Judge Rakoff: This defendant is articulate, even eloquent. I sentence him to 30 months.

 On August 16, 2023 a pre-trial conference for Jatiek Smith was on the schedule for 11:30 am. Inner City Press went but found the courtroom door locked. A woman by the elevators with a young child also asked why it was locked.

  Hours later into the docket went a letter from the prosecutors: "this morning, due to reports of the defendant's noncompliance with the U.S. Marshals at the courthouse, the Court adjourned the conference until September 6, 2023."

On September 25 Judge Rakoff docketed this laptop access order - to be contrasted with that, for example, Sam Bankman-Fried's lawyer continue to demand: "ORDER as to Jatiek Smith. The trial of Jatiek Smith was previously scheduled to start on August 14, 2023. By Order dated May 1, 2023, the Court found that numerous security-necessitated lockdowns in the MDC were preventing Mr. Smith from having access to a computer to meaningfully review his discovery and adequately prepare for trial, and the Court accordingly directed that Mr. Smith be provided access to a computer notwithstanding the lockdowns. See Dkt.214. The trial of Mr. Smith has since been rescheduled and will now commence on November 27, 2023. Accordingly, the Court's May 1, 2023, electronic access order (Dkt. 214) is hereby vacated and the following Order substituted. It is hereby ordered, on consent of the parties, that, regardless of lockdowns in the facility, MDC shall permit Mr. Smith to have access to a computer to prepare for trial for no fewer than seven hours per day every day starting on November 6, 2023 and continuing until November 27, 2023, and after the trial begins to have access to a computer for no fewer three hours per day on days when Mr. Smith's presence is required at the courthouse and no fewer than seven hours per day on days when Mr. Smith's presence at the courthouse is not required. (Signed by Judge Jed S. Rakoff on 9/25/2023)." Watch this site.

Then one of Jatiek Smith's co-defendants was sentenced, with a medical facility recommended: "as to Kaheen Small (4), Count(s) 1, Dismissed; Pleaded guilty to Count(s) 2, Imprisonment for a total term of Twenty Four (24) Months. Supervised release for a term of Two Years. The court makes the following recommendations to the Bureau of Prisons: Incarceration in a Chronic Care 3 Facility such as FCI Butner Low, Butner, North Carolina or FMC Devens Low, Ayer, Massachusetts. The defendant shall surrender for service of sentence at the institution designated by the Bureau of Prisons before 2pm on 11/28/2023. Special Assessment of $100 which is due immediately. (Signed by Judge Jed S. Rakoff on 9/26/2023)."

On October 10, Judge Rakoff docketed: "ORDER as to Jatiek Smith: The Court has received two prose filings from defendant Jatiek Smith, dated September 28, 2023, and October 6, 2023. Mr. Smith, although offered the opportunity to proceed prose, has chosen to be represented by appointed counsel, Jonathan P. Buza. Accordingly, the Court has warned Mr. Smith that such prose filings are not permitted and all applications must be made through his counsel. As a courtesy to Mr. Smith, the Court will forward copies of his submissions to his counsel so that Mr. Buza is apprised of these improper filings. (Signed by Judge Jed S. Rakoff on 10/10/2023)." And he set a pre trial conference for October 23 at 11 am.

Inner City Press went, and found the Assistant US Attorney's waiting out in the hall. Later, it went in as Judge Rakoff authorized a paralegal to act as Jatiek Smith messenger, but not to provide any legal advice. Then "Defendant's motion to proceed for trial pro se and have standby CJA counsel appointed granted after a Faretta hearing proceeds. The trail date remains 11/27/2023."

On November 3, Judge Rakoff docketed that Smith may be shackled for trial, for anger management issues - so a bench trial is being briefed.

On November 15, of the SDNY prosecutors' objection, a bench trial was ordered: "MEMORANDUM AND ORDER as to Jatiek Smith. The Court remains mystified why the Government has refused to consent to a bench trial in this case. It cannot be that the Government has a policy of never consenting to criminal bench trials; indeed, this judge has in recent years conducted such trials with the Government's consent,7 as have his colleagues. The Court is not yet forced to the conclusion that the Government simply wants to parade Mr. Smith, with all his troublesome tendencies, in front of a jury, knowing it will prejudice him and make conviction more likely. But even if this is not the case, the Court finds the Government's unexplained insistence upon a jury trial in this case both striking and troubling. See generally United States v. Allen, 644 F. Supp. 2d 422, 431 (S.D.N.Y. 2009) (noting the "special role" prosecutors have in our system of justice "not solely to advocate for the guilt of the defendant" but also to seek "truth and fairness"). In any case, it is the Court's duty to guarantee Mr. Smith a fair trial, and thus, for the forgoing reasons, the defendant's request for a bench trial is hereby granted, the Government's objection is overruled, the defendant's latest request for an adjournment is denied, and the trial will go forward, as scheduled, beginning on November 27, 2023 as a bench trial."

Inner City Press went on November 27. Smith pro se cross examined an agent about the taking of his phone, and what the agent called a "ruckus." Judge Rakoff noted that he had previously ruled on the phone, albeit on a motion by one of Smith's prior counsel.

On November 28, cooperating witness Jackson described his work for First Response, running to fire sites to sign up the homeowner, then violence against competitors, including going to AES' warehouse in Ozone Park and assaulting the company's workers. Exhibits, including video of punches thrown in through a car window, were offered. No objection, Smith said. At one point he objected to a line of questioning as irrelevant to the RICO charges, but Judge Rakoff overruled. The trial continues.

On November 29, Smith cross examined Jackson about his work for EFS, and threats by other chasers. The AUSA objected, calling it outside the time frame of the conspiracy. Jackson was deadpan, as he explained this own threats to Carl Walsh.

On November 30, the re-direct of Jackson involved an audio of Jatiek Smith predicted the level of charges for a beat down, adding "none of us will escape the conspiracy." Then the US put on a Staten Island police officer, but Smith effectively objected to hearsay about a lost ID. Then another cooperator, who said he got punched in the face.

On December 4, with notably fewer people in the courtroom, subpoenaed victims testified. Peter Rafferty testified about showing up to a fire scene with First Response and being gripped, hard, from behind while his employer was being yelled at by First Response.

 Then Benjamin Vargas, owner of a ServPro franchise on the Upper West Side, described being told to pay $1000, then $2000, a week in order to be let in to "the rotation" of fires by Smith. He described the raising of the price over a lunch at Peter Luger's steakhouse, and threats to woman and children.

On December 5 on re-direct, Vargas said clearly, he only joined the "rotation" because of the threats to his family, and that there was no way to make money in the rotation. Records of payments from Vargas to Smith, $1000 then $2000, were shown (though not on the video monitor facing the courtroom gallery).

The defense Rule 29 motion was denied.

On December 6 Jatiek Smith was on the stand, being questioned by his standby counsel. The AUSA repeatedly objected, mostly successfully, to hearsay. But Smith got his story out - he had been the first one threatened by a gun or grip at a fire scene, and had gripped up after that. Alongside the Peter Luger's meeting with Vargas, he had another meeting. And when asked to name a person who told him something, Smith declined, saying he had to live in jail. So what was said, was not admitted in to evidence.

On December 7, Jatiek Smith was being cross examined by the AUSA. For ten minutes the courtroom was ordered sealed; there was discussion in the hall. While the evidence will wrap up on December 11, then there will be briefing as closing arguments.

Back inside the courtroom, the AUSA again played the audio of Smith saying "the only thing none of us will escape is the conspiracy." Judge Rakoff stopped and asked Smith about it.

  The AUSA asked Smith about calling Eddie a coward, but saying he didn't look afraid. Smith said Eddie didn't want to look like a coward. When asked if he was scared when they went to the AES warehouse, Smith said he didn't know how to answer that.

On December 11, another fire mitigation veteran testified by video, questioned by Jatiek Smith and Judge Rakoff. He acknowledged that he had not been threatened by Smith, and praised him for his ideas. Given the video's audio, it was not always possible to hear what his lawyer beside him was saying. He was the last witness - now a briefing period, and perhaps more.

On December 12, Judge Rakoff partially granted Smith's motion, on evidence tampering: "ORDER as to Jatiek Smith. Following conclusion yesterday of the taking of evidence in the bench trial of this criminal case, defendant Jatiek Smith timely moved for a judgment of acquittal pursuant to Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 29. Count I of the indictment charges Smith with racketeering conspiracy in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1962(d) and Count II charges Smith with extortion conspiracy in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1951. In support of Count I, the Government alleges the conspirators agreed to engage in a variety of predicate criminal acts, including, inter alia, evidence tampering in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1512(c)(1), which makes it a crime to "corruptly... alter[], destroy[], mutilate[], or conceal[] a record, document, or other object, or attempt[] to do so, with the intent to impair the object's integrity or availability for use in an official proceeding." At the close of trial, the only evidence the Government had presented to support the predicate act of conspiracy to violate 18 U.S.C. § 1512(c)(1) was the alleged attempt by Smith to break one of his two cellphones when confronted by an FBI Agent with a warrant for its production. (Smith later turned over the phone). For the reasons already largely stated on the record, see Dec. 11, 2023, Trial Tr., the Court concludes that no rational trier of fact could find beyond a reasonable doubt that the alleged attempt to break the phone (which Smith denies) was pursuant to an agreement between Mr. Smith and his alleged co-conspirators to engage in conduct of a kind that would constitute a violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1512(c)(1). See United States v. Jackson, 335 F.3d 170, 180 (2d Cir. 2003). Accordingly, with respect to the alleged predicate act of conspiring to violate 18 U.S.C. § 1512(c)(1), the defendant's motion pursuant to Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 29 is hereby granted. In all other respects, the defendant's motion is hereby denied. (Signed by Judge Jed S. Rakoff on 12/12/2023)."

Watch this site.

  The overall case is US v. Smith, et al., 22-cr-352 (Rakoff)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

Venezuela Ex Spy Chief Carvajal Wants 9 DEA Files & CIPA Motion Deadline But Jan 17 Next


by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Dec 12 – Venezuela's former spy chief Hugo Armando Carvajal Barrios a/k/a El Pollo is in US custody in a narco-trafficking conspiracy case begun in 2011, after a long extradition fight in Spain.

    Carvajal was arraigned by U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Magistrate Judge Stuart D. Aaron on July 20. Inner City Press was there and live tweeted, thread: more on Substack here

Carvajal's lawyers have gone out into the hall with two of the three prosecutors. Bail deal seems doubtful. But they are talking...

Carvajal's legal team's statement emphasizes that he "broke publicly with the government of Nicolas Maduro and looks forward...to an unbiased American jury. A bail application will be forthcoming." So apparently going to consent to detention today

 Both Carvajal's counsel and the two prosecutors have come back into the courtroom.

 Carvajal is brought in by 2 US Marshals, in a white T-shirt. Has a lawyer sutting on each side of him. 

Assistant US Attorney says Carvajal arrived in the US yesterday at 1:15 pm. Judge Aaron reads out the charges. Defense: He pleads not guilty.

 AUSA: The government seeks detention. Defense: We consent without prejudice. Next hearing before Judge Hellerstein July 25 at 12:30 pm. Medical order signed.

Afterward Inner City Press asked Carvajal's lawyer about his client's letter in Spain about information he has, video here from 1:50.

Vlog in Spanish and English here

  On July 25 Carvajal appeared again, before Judge Hellerstein. His lawyer did not object to excluding Speedy Trial Act time to November 1 - he said he is applying under CIPA. (In the ongoing case of Honduras' Juan Orlando Hernandez, another CJA counsel was brought in just for the Classified Information Procedures Act issues). Nor was there any mention of applying for bail.

The line of the proceeding was when Judge Hellerstein asked if any of the co-defendants will also appear on November 1. The Assistant US Attorney said that with Cliver having pled guilty, no one of the other defendant - which include Nicolas Madura - are anticipated to be in New York on November 1. And after? Watch this site.

  El Pollo's case has the potential to spill the beans even more than Honduras' JOH's ongoing case, in which JOH's ties to El Chapo Guzman are alleged. 

  El Pollo told a Spanish judge that he has information about Venezuela - and drug money from Colombia's FARC - going to, among others, Brazil's President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva; Néstor Kirchner in Argentina; Evo Morales in Bolivia; Fernando Lugo in Paraguay; Ollanta Humala in Peru; Zelaya in Honduras; Gustavo Petro in Colombia; the Five Star Movement in Italy; and the Podemos party in Spain.

  The wrinkle is that, given El Pollo's flip to Guaido, the Nicolas Maduro government is asking for his re-extradition. And as with the current US administration's prosecution of Miles Guo Wengui Kwok, who the Chinese government also wants prosecuted or worse, will DOJ be eager to cut the cooperation deal it should or might?

On October 19, Pollo's counsel wrote in asking for permission to depose Fernando Blengio, recently released by BOP and removed to Mexico. He cannot reenter the US to testify at trial, so a Rule 15 deposition in Mexico was sought.

On November 1, Judge Hellerstein denied the request and set the next conference for December 12: "Minute Entry for proceedings held before Judge Alvin K. Hellerstein: Oral Argument as to Hugo Armando Carvajal-Barrios held on 11/1/2023. Pretrial Conference as to Hugo Armando Carvajal-Barrios held on 11/1/2023. Motion to take deposition is denied; Next PTC is set for 12/12/23 at 10:00 a.m.; Deft. cont'd remanded."

On December 12, Inner City Press was there, thread:

All rise!

 Judge Hellerstein: Please give me an update. AUSA: This is our 3d pre-trial conference. Mr. Caravajal's counsel has a number of discovery disputes. On the classified discovery front, our review is ongoing. Cliver had a CIPA component too

 AUSA: We expect to request a CIPA order in this case. We suggestion a Section IV deadline. Judge: Is this consistent with a Speedy Trial? AUSA: As an initial matter -- Judge: How do we hasten it? AUSA: We have produced a substantial-- Judge: Let's hasten it

 AUSA: He can make the motion --

Judge: How can he make the motion without having the discovery? AUSA: Under Section V or VI of CIPA, we will deal with whether the information can be used at trial. Pollo's lawyer Margulis-Ohnuma: We lack 9 discrete DEA files

 Judge: I'm interested in hastening the trial. If you need 30 days, you need 30 days. Margulis: Yes, that should tell the US we need the information to make our motions. AUSA: I have spoken with him, I've asked detailed follow up questions but we'd like to narrow

Judge: How about I give you two weeks and then a motion? AUSA: Fine. Judge: Huddle up with Mr. Margulis now and get back to me. AUSA: Right now? Judge: Yes. Off the record.

[Margulis and AUSA stand near jury box, whispering. Pollo chats with his other lawyers - one of whom was introduced as Spanish-speaking. Pollo looks chipper] They're back. Margulis: I think there was a misunderstanding about the scope of the government's review.

 Margulis: Now he says he's not sure he had the files, or which we already have. Let's not set a briefing schedule.  Judge: I'll give you a status conf in 30 days but what do you need? Margulis: There was a plane that crash landed in Campache in 2006, other cases

 Margulis: I've identified nine specific cases that relate to that. And the S-1 indictment, they haven't given me complete discovery on those areas. Mr. Bradley can go back to his team - maybe they dispute it. We can address in 30 days AUSA: I agree, we'll narrow

 Judge: I'm a prisoner of what you fellows are doing. I urge you to hasten. January 17 at 10:30 am. Margulis: That's fine.  Judge: What are we going to do then? AUSA Bradley: We will bring to the court's attention any remaining disputes, and set a briefing schedule

 Judge: Can I get briefs before January 17, to make decisions then? AUSA: We'd rather just come in. We'll ID documents that are candidates for deletion in an ex parte proceeding. Judge: Doesn't the defendant play any role in this? AUSA: No, under Section IV.

 Judge: How long will discovery last? AUSA Bradley: There are other government components, equity holders. In Cliver, it took 5 months for the CIPA filing. Before Judge Engelmayer, Bradley [Yemen case] it took five months too. There are more material here

Judge: When will we be finished with pre-trial discovery, everything? AUSA Bradley: It depends. From our POV, the filing of the Section IV completes our duty. We want five or six months. Judge: June or July and we're ready to trial? AUSA: Subject to Sec 5 & 6.

Judge: So in March we should be ready to set a trial date? AUSA: That depends. Can we set June 1 for our Section IV motion? Judge: I hope it's faster, March. But we'll see in January. This case was filed in 2011. It's 12 years old.

 AUSA: Let's exclude time under the Speedy Trial Act. Margulis: No objection. On the classified discovery, let's set March 1 for the CIPA protective order. I'd like to be heard ex parte, I believe your Honor did with Cliver Alcala. Judge: That's correctJudge: See you January 17.

Margulis: How about March 1 as deadline for their motion?  Judge: Bradley? AUSA Bradley: We'd like five or six months. Judge: I'll set a date in January. Adjourned

 Inner City Press is on the case, which is US v. Carvajal Barrios, et al., 11-cr-205 (Hellerstein / Aaron)

More detail, and Spanish translation, on Substack here

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

Trevor Milton Wants No Jail US Wants 11 Years at Sentencing Pushed to Dec 18


Review, Patreon  Book

w/ Exclusive Interviews by Matthew Russell Lee

SDNY Courthouse, Dec 11  – In September and October 2022 Trevor Milton, founder of Nikola Motor was put on trial for fraudulent claims about NKLA's hydrogen trucks.

On Friday, October 14, Milton was found guilty on three of four counts.

  Published hours after the verdict was a book by Matthew Russell Lee, who live tweeted and reported on the trial daily, and put questions to Milton and his lawyers in Foley Square outside.

On December 14, Milton filed requesting a new trial - citing InnerCityPress.com "Book Interviews" published on October 16 and 17, 2022, see Milton's filing on DocumentCloud here.

On November 14, 2023 Milton's counsel  asked for mere probation, contrasting Milton to Elizabeth Holmes and more recently OneCoin's Sebastian Greenwood (whose sealing of sentencing letters Inner City Press has appealed while still seeking pro bono counsel). List of Milton's supportive letters on Patreon here.

On November 16, there was a brief proceeding about Milton being able to use documents from his arbitration with Nikola, for his sentencing. The parties were to confer. On November 20, Milton's counsel said the conferring had not been successful, and asked for an order providing access to, among other things, deposition and/or hearing testimony of Girsky, Russell, Brady, Worthen, Kevin Lynk and Dane Davis; and interviews of Tony Heaton, Pablo Koziner, Nicole Rose, Christian Appel, Michael Erickson, Vince Caramella, Stephanie Fleck- full letter on Patreon here.

On November 21, Judge Ramos docketed an order pushing Milton's sentencing to December 18.

On December 11, the US put it its requested sentence for Milton: 132 months or 11 years. Full letter on Patreon here.

Also on December 11, the US asked to put out a press release for victims: "The Government writes regarding notice to victims regarding sentencing and a potential restitution award in the above-captioned matter. For the reasons set forth below, the Government respectfully requests that the Court permit the Government to provide notice by issuing a press release and/or making a public post on a Department of Justice website." Full letter on Patreon here.

After Milton's past December 14 filing, Inner City Press reached out to the juror about Milton's team's claims. She scoffed, "It’s an old Facebook post from 2017 like when Bernie ran And it was a repost from AOC not even my words Trevor wasn’t even on the radar then. And I liked Elon until he bought Twitter Taxing the rich isn’t the same as fraud Which I think makes sense anyways The funny thing is. I really don’t use social media. Like yeah my Facebook is active and Twitter and instagram but I don’t actively use them. I’ll never delete my Facebook because if my family needs me that’s how they reach me."

And on February 2, 2023, Milton's team filed a reply, quoting the above and equating skepticism about corporate fraud with racism, demanding a hearing or a new trial. They write: "her post-trial interviews - including one given recently about Mr. Milton's motions - demonstrate she understands perfectly well that the 'news' is not just YouTube and that "social media" includes Facebook and Twitter." Filing(s) are pending before Judge Ramos.

On January 23, Judge Ramos pushed Milton's sentencing back to June 21: "ORDER granting [261] LETTER MOTION request a revised post-trial briefing schedule and adjournment of sentencing. The revised post-trial briefing schedule is approved. Sentencing is adjourned to June 21, 2023 at 10 a.m. The Clerk of the Court is respectfully directed to terminate the motions, docs. 262 and 263. (Signed by Judge Edgardo Ramos on 1/23/2023)."

So how much change does Milton's appeal on this have?

  The Monday after the Friday verdict, Inner City Press conducted a second interview, after a first, screen shots on Patreon here - and full version of 2d interview here and below.

Interviews: Juror #9, "V" - "Sure, Overall the entire trial was very dense in terms of information I myself I estimate took at least 50 pages of notes front and back. While Mr. Milton may not have liked the result he should know that he did in fact receive a completely fair trial in my opinion. Personally in my notes I did have to write "credibility?" and ultimately did not use two witnesses testimony in my deliberation reasoning due to the fact I just couldn't find them credible....

... Roughly for the first hour and a half absolutely no decision was made at all on any counts. Personally it began to feel like we may have been a hung jury.

"This is when we began to request a few pieces of evidence we did not take any notes on that we needed to break the ice. Once we received those aids deliberations became smoother albeit there were moments of silence here and there as we contemplated what a juror may have said or looked for a piece of evidence that contradicted or further supported what was said.

"That being said on Count 2 that I've seen many questions on after looking up to see what the public thought was he was close to being convicted he reached 2/3 requirements and we began discussing the third it was then that I re-read the charge and noticed that while similar to count 1 count 2 had to meet ALL requirements.

"When asking if anyone noticed any evidence to suggest the government had met this criteria we found they fell short.   In regards to count four I just wanted to mention we in fact did not even like Mr. Hicks and personally I believe he is greedy, but examining the law Trevor was still in fact guilty." Full interview on Patreon here.

The case is US v. Milton, 21-cr-478 (Ramos)

  Watch this site.

    Lee was each day in the courtroom of U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Edgardo Ramos, and venturing farther afield to investigate leads exclusively give to him and Inner City Press and by Nikola whistleblowers.

   As the trial wound down, Inner City Press published descriptions of documented destroyed within Nikola, and guilty knowledge by officials still at the company.

   Material from those whistleblowers, the trial and even some more speculative and literary excursions featuring recurring characters Kurt Wheelock and Michael Randall Long, featured in the Ghislaine Maxwell book "Maximum Maxwell" as noted by New York Magazine, here, made its way at the speed of the Internet into the new book

"Hydrogen Heist: The Trial of Nikola's Trevor Milton: On Fraud, Guilty of 3 of 4 Counts; From Musk and Tesla Wannabe to Convict in SDNY, by Matthew Russell Lee

  E-book here; paperbook here

    This review will leave it to others to find over-reaches and typos. For his reporting, Lee was banned from the United Nations in 2018 by SG Antonio Guterres, whose Media Accrediation chief Melissa Fleming has ignored appeals from a UN Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Expression and, pro bono, the law firm of Quinn Emanuel.

   One might surmise that history leads to some of the book's (over?) identification with the defendant.  

The case is US v. Milton, 21-cr-478 (Ramos)

    A full scope instantaneous view of and taking off from trials like US v. Trevor Milton seems to be Inner City Press' project here.

And here it is.


Hydrogen Heist by Matthew Russell
                                  Lee

 ***


Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.