Saturday, November 4, 2023

In Attorney Steering Case Guilty Plea Planned by Del Valle Who Seeks Sentencing Estimate


by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Nov 3 – On a daily basis, defendants are brought into court and either get appointed counsel or choose to pay a private attorney, if they can.

But this system can be gamed. 

   March 30, 2023 saw "charges against DIONISIO FIGUEROA, a/k/a “Dionicio,” an employee of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York (“the SDNY District Court”), and TELESFORO DEL VALLE, JR., a/k/a “Ted,” a criminal defense attorney practicing in the SDNY District Court and elsewhere, for their participation in a scheme in which FIGUEROA referred criminal defendants to DEL VALLE and encouraged those defendants to retain DEL VALLE as counsel in exchange for cash payments from DEL VALLE to FIGUEROA."

  Inner City Press, which closely covers the Magistrate Court, had in 2022 reported the investigation against Del Valle.

Now on November 3 Inner City Press first reports the De Valle's Albany-based counsel has informed Judge D'Agostino that Del Valle "has decided to plead guilty to counts 1, 3, 5 and 7" and requests a Pimentel estimate of sentencing guidelines.

The case is US v. Figueroa et al.. 23-cr-161 (D'Agostino)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

Bob De Niro Assistant Chase Robinson Crossed on Grandiose Signature Block and B Word Use


By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Nov 3 – Robert De Niro and Canal Productions were sued in 2019 for gender discrimination by Graham Chase Robinson, who had begun working as De Niro's executive assistant in 2008, at 25 years old.

 She said she was discriminated against - then De Niro sued her, and she sued him. 

On March 10, 2020 U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Magistrate Judge Katharine H. Parker held a  proceeding. Inner City Press covered it.  Inner City Press had previously checked in on the case, on January 30, 2020, here.

"in SDNY, Robert De Niro is being sued by former employee Graham Chase Robinson for gender discrimination, not paying overtime - and retaliating. De Niro's lawyers complaint to SDNY Magistrate Judge Parker that the plaintiff won't say to whose salary she's comparing what she was paid."

 The case was reassigned to District Judge Lewis J. Liman; a protective order was filed.

On October 30, 2023, the trial is set to begin with jury selection, and to sit daily from 9 to 5. It begin a civil case, each side gets 20 hours...

  Inner City Press called to cover the June 28, 2021 conference, and found the defendants hammering away at plaintiff Robinson's alleged misrepresentations.

On December 15, 2021, there was another conference, that Inner City live tweeted here

On January 31, 2022 Judge Parker held another proceeding and Inner City Press again covered it. Judge Parker extended discovery, reluctantly she said, "for the sole purpose of deposing the five individuals identified by Plaintiff: Mr. Robert De Niro, Mr. Michael Kaplan, Tom Harvey, Michael Tasch and Tiffany Chen.

On December 30, 2022, Judge Parker denied a request to seal a filing concerning among other things De Niro's claim that Robinson was "binge-watching Netflix" and misusing SkyMiles.

Jump cut to the first day of trail on October 30, 2023. De Niro was on the stand being questioned about his texts with Tiffany Chen, who accused the plaintiff of "imaginary intimacy." Thread:

Plaintiff Robinson's counsel: It was to get out the middle of your relationship with Ms Tiffany Chen?

De Niro: Uh, yes.

Jury is shown Tiffany Chen's text to De Niro about Robinson's "imaginary intimacy" with De Niro.

Q: Ms Chen gave you an ultimatum to get rid of Ms Robinson?

With jury gone for the day, lawyers are fighting about exhibits. De Niro in a dark green polo shirt and jacket, leaves the courtroom

There followed a discussion of exhibits PX97 and PX 18.

On November 2, Tiffany Chen was on the stand. Among other things, she called out the plaintiff as "crazy" and bullsh*t, whereupon counsel told her, Let's try to filter ourselves a bit more in court.

Yeah, let's. With the jury out of the room, plaintiff's counsel asked for a limiting instruction as to the crazy talk. Denied.

On November 3, Inner City Press managed to really live tweet some of the trial, on SDNYLIVE, thread:

De Niro's lawyer: Did you dispose of your recordings of Mr. De Niro and his company? Chase Robinson: No.

De Niro's lawyer: Would you agree it's over 40 hours of recordings? Chase Robinson: It's about that

De Niro's lawyer: You know Mr. De Niro values privacy? Chase Robinson: I believe he does. De Niro's lawyer: It's your belief that if he knew, he might have fired you? Chase Robinson: I don't know what Bob would have done.

 De Niro's lawyer: In your recordings, did you say you were the victim of gender discrimination? Chase Robinson: There are records about Tiffany -- De Niro's lawyer: You used the term gender discrimination? Chase Robinson: No.

De Niro's lawyer: You're suing for millions and you didn't listen to them? Chase Robinson: I lived these calls. De Niro's lawyer: You were a personal assistant to Bob? Chase Robinson: I was an executive assistant to Bob.

De Niro's lawyer: Then you were called director of production at Canal? You created the title? Chase Robinson: I discussed it with Bob

De Niro's lawyer: At the end your signature block said "Office of Chase Robinson." Was there an Office? Chase Robinson: Lulu became my assistant... American Express and Delta Sky Miles can be confusing. 

De Niro's lawyer: We're going to talk about the B word..

 De Niro's lawyer: Did you use the B word in the Offices of Canal? Chase Robinson: No. De Niro's lawyer: In written correspondence on behalf of Canal?

Chase Robinson: There's a possibility. It's a common curse word. Depends how it's used

 De Niro's lawyer: You used the word to describe Ms. [TIffany] Chen? I'm going to play the audio of some calls. [Audio of Chase Robinson: Bob and I have had our moments, I have pulled back for obvious reasons, I don't want to be a triangle of this, she's f*ckin

 De Niro's lawyer: What did you mean? Chase Robinson: I wanted to get out of the middle of them and their home live, their personal life. De Niro's lawyer: Next clip, DX 84

Audio of Chase Robinson: I need to wrap up, two years or two f*cking days, I need my space

Audio of Chase Robinson: I can't, I just can't. I have plans, I plan on things, I literally canceled my f*cking weekend, you're a socio pathic b*tch, she should grow a pair of ba*ls De Niro's lawyer: Were you referring to Ms. Chen? Chase Robinson: Uh, no.

 Audio of Chase Robinson: F*cking TIffany wants to run the house, she's so...  I did six bags of shredding yesterday De Niro's lawyer: You were angry about your interactions with Ms. Chen and recording another employee? Chase Robinson: I was scanning and shredding

 De Niro's lawyer: You were free to quit in 2008? Chase Robinson: Technically.  De Niro's lawyer: You got a raise to $300,000 a year?

Chase Robinson: Yes. De Niro's lawyer: Your Honor, I'm at a breaking point. Judge Liman: We'll go to five.

 De Niro's lawyer: Matters related to Bob's family were sensitive, yes? Chase Robinson: All families are. De Niro's lawyer: You were privy to his personal life? Chase Robinson: I was.  Judge Liman: We'll break for the day. Counsel, remain... [Jurors leave]

Judge Liman: I'd like your comments on the draft jury charge by Saturday at 5 pm.  [Counsel makes religious objection, gets Sunday]

Defense: We may have two more witnesses: Michael Tasch on AmEx, and Dan Harvey Judge Liman: On AmEx, you could have asked questions

 De Niro's lawyer: What about the verdict form? We submitted a draft -- Judge Liman: Send me more if either of you have more thoughts. Adjourned.

The trial continues.

The case is Robinson v. De Niro et al., 19-cv-9156 (Liman / Parker)

sdny

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Crypto Defendant Avi Eisenberg Seeks Delay in Trial to 2024 After Move from Essex to MDC


By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Maxwell Book

SDNY COURTROOM, Nov 3 -  In the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York on December 27, 2022 a complaint was ordered unsealed charging Avraham Eisenberg with commodities fraud. He was arrested in Puerto Rico.

Inner City Press is covering the case(s), often as the only media in the Mag Court. Related Mag Court live-tweeted thread (more on Patreon here) vlog here

On January 9, Inner City Press came across the CFTC case against Eisenberg, just filed (still with no title in PACER) and put it out on Patreon here. The 21-page civil complaint is, as is often the case, more detailed...

 On April 12, the US Attorney's Office filed a motion to intervene and stay the Mango Labs v. Eisenberg case, saying that neither side opposed the stay. The US seeks a "full stay until the conclusion of the parallel criminal case."

More on Substack here.

On June 14, Judge Berman held a proceeding to pick a trial date. Inner City Press covered it, thread here.

  On July 27 Eisenberg moved to dismiss and to suppress; he submitted a 7-page affadavit including "In the evening of December 26, 2022, I arrived by airplane at The Luis Munoz Marin International Airport in Carolina, Puerto Rico, just outside of San Juan. 3. I disembarked the airplane with my luggage, a backpack and a suitcase. 4. I walked to the United States Customs counter. There, I was questioned by a United States Customs and Border Protection ("CBP") agent regarding the purpose of the trip I had just completed and general questions about the contents of my luggage. 5. The CBP agent directed me to a specific area several feet away from the Customs counter for additional questioning, and there another CBP officer opened the suitcase and backpack. I recall the agent pulling out the laptop and asking me to turn it on" - full affidavit on Patreon here.

Watch this site.

The  complaint is on Patreon here

On February 3, Eisenberg in a yellow jump suit and feet shackled was brought into Magistrates Court at SDNY. He had, at least for the proceeding, the same lawyer Ethereum developer Virgil Griffith had in the North Korea sanctions case he pled guilty in: Brian Klein.

  His parents were in the gallery and he looked at them, from two rows away. The prosecutor said that (unlike on Sam Bankman-Fried) they were seeking detention, and that he was consenting at least for now.  Here is Inner City Press' thread.

There's more detail on Patreon here.

On February 14, there was a very brief arraignment, thread here

On November 2, 2023 Eisenberg's counsel wrote it seeking to push the December 4 trial to March or April. They said Eisenberg was moved from Essex to the MDC, and not allowed to bring his discovery material with him. The SDNY prosecutors acknowledge that's a problem, but want only a one-week delay to December 11 - or to April, citing an unrelated murder trial.

In a parallel civil case, on February 24 there was an hour and a half argument in Mango Labs v. Eisenberg before Judge Lewis J. Liman. Inner City Press live tweeted...

  Ultimately Judge Liman extended the TRO for two weeks, after for two letters by Tuesday, and said he will rule on March 10.

On March 10, Inner City Press was there, thread here

More with analysis on Substack here

Watch this site.

Inner City Press will have more on these cases.

The criminal case is US v. Eisenberg, 23-cr-10 (Berman)

The stayed CFTC case is Communities Futures Trading Commission v. Eisenberg, 23-cv-173 (Schofield)

The Mango Labbs civil case is Mango Labs, LLC v. Eisenberg, 23-cv-665 (Liman)

sdny

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

After Bankman-Fried Guilty of 7 Counts in FTX Trial Inner City Press Book Crypto Criminals


by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Nov 2 – On the US v Sam Bankman-Fried trial, hours after the guilty verdict, a book was published: "Crypto Criminal: The Conviction of Sam Bankman-Fried: As live tweeted and investigated from inside the SDNY courthouse by Matthew Russell Lee," paperback coming (in the morning?) for now, 200 page ebook here.

"When at last the Sam Bankman-Fried trial started on October 3, 2023 with jury selection, after Sam had been remanded to the MDC jail, the courtroom on the 26th floor was full, and an overflow room established on the 23rd.  The author went back and forth between them, and down to the Press Room he'd been admitted to after six months of covering cases here, after he was thrown out of the UN and took on this new identity.  Between the three locations he began to paint of picture of the trial, of Sam and the world around him. The portrait was made up of tweets or Xs, of vlogs filmed out on Foley Square and at the prisoners' entrance on Park Row. 

"He did not know then how it or he would turn out. It could have been called, Crypto Houdini. But it wasn't." And a second trial?

 Inner City Press live tweeted the voir dire and now, more on Substack here
and all on Patreon here

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

Bankman-Fried Guilty on All 7 Counts in FTX Trial Inner City Press Live Tweeted Book Soon


by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Nov 2 – For US v Sam Bankman-Fried, after more than a day of jury selection, late morning on October 4 the twelve and six alternate were selected. Inner City Press live tweeted the voir dire here and more below

On Nov 2, the verdict, in thread here

OK - now counsel have reassembled in the courtroom. SBF still not brought back in. AUSA Thane Rehn flipping through a document redactions. Judge Kaplan: So, I just want to make a record of the various notes

 Judge Kaplan: An hour ago the jury asked for the testimony of Boroujerdi (of Third Point) and Matt Huang (of Paradigm). They also asked for Post-It notes, and the actual indictment. Now we'll wait for further communications

 Now with the prosecutors (and judge) out of the courtroom, SBF is standing twisting something in his hands while his lawyer Mark Cohen speaks into his ear. Now SBF is being led out of the courtroom again by US Marshals

For those asking about Huang, here's from Inner City Press thread: "AUSA: Were you told that FTX was transferring money from this round of financing to Alameda? Huang: No. And we would not have invested. We invested $278 million. We've marked it to zero."

 ALERT:  Courtroom deputy Andy: We have received a note from the jury that they have reached a verdict. [Inner City Press will live tweet, below]

Judge Kaplan: Madam Foreperson, I understand the jury has reached a verdict. Please hand it to Andy. Thank you. The clerk will publish the verdict. Please rise. Count 1: Guilty. Count 2: Guilty. Count 3: Guilty.

Deputy: Count 4? Guilty. Count 5: Guilty Count 6: Guilty. Count 7: Guilty. Deputy: Thank you. Judge Kaplan: There's another question, Andy. Deputy: Either or both?  Both.

SBF's lawyer Mark Cohen: We would like the jury polled. [Verdict is confirmed]

Judge Kaplan: Jurors, I thank you. You did what we hope all citizens do when called for service. That was your call. In just a minute I am going to discharge you. You can speak about it

 Judge Kaplan: If you do speak, be sensitive to the feeling of other jurors. If anyone involved in the case contact you and you say no and they don't take no for an answer, I will take appropriate steps if I lawfully can do so. Leave your notes there

Judge Kaplan: We have scheduled a second trial for March 11 [2024]. Let me know by February 1 if that is going to proceed. I want an update on that. What is the government's position on setting a sentencing date on this? AUSA Roos: Let's get the PSR process going

 Judge Kaplan: I'll need Andy for that. Or I can fly blind, let's see if I can get my own calendar up. We'll set sentencing for March 28 at 9:30 in morning. Defense submission by Feb 16, US by March 8. Enough time, Mr. Cohen? Cohen: Could we have more time?

 Judge Kaplan: Feb 27, March 15. Anything else? Cohen: Post trial motion schedule - we ask for the 20th of November. AUSA Roos: Can we have 3 weeks? Judge Kaplan: Dec 11. Anything else? Cohen: No. Roos: No. Judge Kaplan: Good job all around. Thanks. All rise!

 Judge leaves. Joe Bankman and Barbara Fried are in the front room of the gallery. They hug; she appears to cry. Sam Bankman-Fried is led back into the holding cell.

  More on Substack here

 Inner City Press live tweeted the voir dire and now, more on Substack here
and all on Patreon here

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

For Enabling Epstein JPMC Deal Opposed By Ransome after Deutsche $75M Blood Money


By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Maxwell book

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Nov 2 – J.P. Morgan Chase and Deutsche Bank were sued for their enabling of Jeffrey Epstein, in lawsuits filed on Thanksgiving 2022 in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, where Inner City Press found them in the docket.

  Late on May 17, 2023, plaintiffs' lawyer David Boies selectively announced a $75 million settlement with Deutsche Bank.

Nothing was filed in the docket until May 18: "Minute Entry for proceedings held before Judge Jed S. Rakoff: Telephone Conference held on 5/17/2023,without transcription or recording. Plaintiffs motion for preliminary approval of proposed class settlement is due by 5/26/2023. A preliminary fairness hearing will be held at 4:00 PM on 6/1/2023 in Courtroom 14B, the Daniel Patrick Moynihan U.S. Courthouse, 500 Pearl St., New York, NY."

In fact the fairness hearing was held on October 20, 2023. Inner City Press went. It was approved.

But for JPM Chase, on November 2 this opposition: "ORDER: Sarah Ransome, a putative member of the class preliminarily certified in the above-captioned case, has submitted an application requesting permission to appear virtually at the final class action settlement fairness hearings scheduled in this matter for November 9, 2023 at 4:00 PM to orally express her objections to the settlement. See Dkt. 247, at 3 & n.2. That application is hereby granted. full order on Patreon here (Signed by Judge Jed S. Rakoff on 11/2/2023)."

More including class analysis on Substack here

   The JPM Chase complaint is on Patreon, here.

On March 20, 2023 Judge Jed S. Rakoff in a bottom line order dismissed some but not all claims, in the Epstein-related cases against JPMC and Deutsche Bank.

Inner City Press put the order on its DocumentCloud here.

On April 28, a motion seeking class certification of Epstein-related claims against JPMC was filed; filing on Patreon here.

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

SBF Super Bowl Selfie Is Defense Last Stand As Judge Offers Jury Pizza Party Crypto Creeps

 

by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

LITERARY SDNY, Nov 1 -- First day of November and SBF was on the grill. For hours.

 Assistant US Attorney Nicholas Roos stood at the platform running through the crimes now amnesia of the defendant, who sat slumped in his chair typing away at this laptop.

If convicted, these laptop privileged would disappear. Type it while you can, seemed to be the idea.

  At one point the jurors' video screens broke down and a break was taken.

  Even upon return, Judge Kaplan told them not to use the monitor in the back row, and moved Alternate Juror Number 1 into the spot previously occupied by Number Four, who came in sick one day then wanted to stay, to stay on the jury, but got bounced.

Unlike the others he was now free to reach out on social media. Or was he? 

  When it was Mark Cohen's turn, the mood changed, decidedly winter. He looked straight down and read out his statement.

Sam - yes, personalize it, Sam - was not a monster. He didn't even play poker, Cohen insisted, twice focusing on the photo of SBF with a deck of cards.

On Cohen's photo array was the shot of Sam slumping, even then, with Bill Clinton and Tony Blair.   Cohen said, in words or substance,

They try to make it a crime, to look uncomfortable with Bill Clinton. Many had. But that wasn't the crime: it was using FTX customers' deposited funds to pay access to Bill and Larry David and the people in the photo at the Super Bowl party.

Why had Cohen put that one up, too? Maybe to say the prosecutors were being unfair. Trial by selfie (or now pizza). If so, Sam was losing

More on this, including pizza and timing, on Substack here

More book sample on Substack here. Extended on Patreon here.

Book here

Cover of
                        Crypto Creeps (book)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Bankman-Fried Had Amnesia 140 Times on the Stand US Says in SDNY Trial Closing


by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Nov 1 – For US v Sam Bankman-Fried, after more than a day of jury selection, late morning on October 4 the twelve and six alternate were selected. Inner City Press live tweeted the voir dire here and more below

On Nov 1, AUSA Nick Roos delivered the prosecution's summation, including this thread:

AUSA Roos: The core dispute here is whether the defendant knew that taking the money was wrong. He knew. He did it anyway. He thought he was smarter, and could walk his way out of it. Today, with you, that ends.

AUSA Roos: Did you notice how he evaded, with the layout of Alameda in an Airbnb, or why he chose the Miami Heat Arena to name? But how was he on cross examination? He couldn't remember a single detail. It was uncomfortable. 140 times...

 AUSA Roos: He asked for terms to be defined, terms he had already used. He tried to tell a story to exclude himself from the fraud. That was a lie. Over three days he took the stand and he lied. You'd have to ignore all the evidence

 AUSA: Before FTX there was Alameda. [Chart fail] Judge Kaplan: Is it not on the screen? AUSA: They don't have it in the middle row. [It's a chart of Alameda, signed by SBF]

[Tech snafu continues. Closings, it seems, will definitely go into tomorrow....During the lull, Bankman-Fried is sitting slumped at the defense table, seemingly-glumly typing on his laptop]

 Judge Kaplan: Alright, let's get the jury back in the box.

AUSA Sassoon: And maybe ask them not to touch... Jury entering!

Judge Kaplan: It went down again? Get into the jury box, folks.

Judge Kaplan (to jurors) The panel that may be the cause of the problem is in the back corner of the jury box. Please stay away from there. We're having Alternate juror 1 moved where Alternate 4 was. We'll get a single big screen if needed. OK, roll with it

AUSA Roos: The defendant WAS Alameda. 90% owner. It took out loans to do crypto trading. Then the defendant started FTX and started getting customer money. He thought this was a new source of money for Alameda. Caroline Ellison told you so

  More on Substack here

 Inner City Press live tweeted the voir dire and now, more on Substack here
and all on Patreon here

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com