Saturday, May 12, 2012

Syria Alleges Terrorism But Rice Calls It a Diversion, As Ban Cites Gaddafi


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 8 -- The split between the Syria statements of envoy Kofi Annan and his successor as UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon is growing more pronounced, with Annan on Tuesday pointing out some improvements in the country.

  Meanwhile Ban, according to the Atlantic Council where he spoke on Monday night, said that Bashar al Assad might face the same fate of Liberia's Charles Taylor or even Libya's Gaddafi.

  One wondered: is Ban now celebrating the role of the gun in Gaddafi's on-camera end?
  Inner City Press asked Syrian Permanent Representative Bashar Ja'afari about Ban's statement, and Ban's difference from Annan. (Some say that Ban's material is increasingly written in Washington, where he delivered the Monday night remarks).

Ja'afari stayed diplomatic, saying that ten days ago he urged Ban to support Annan's mission and stay positive and that he now reiterated this "humble request."

Ja'afari said that his country is fighting terrorists, specifically Al Qaeda. He said, when Al Qaeda attacks the US, the Security Council jumps into action. But the Council treats Syria differently.

(Not all of the Council. Indian Permanent Representative Hardeen Singh Puri told Inner City Press that while there are "still some problems," Annan mission has "had some calming effect.")

Inner City Press asked US Ambassador Rice about the claim of terrorism and Al Qaeda in Syria. Rice called this "substantially a diversion," while noting that "we've seen-frankly seen foreign fighters in Syria-transit Syria-for years on their way into Iraq, and there may be a flow in the opposite direction."

  As her stakeout's final question, Inner City Press asked Rice about the US position on Guinea Bissau, where ECOWAS and its appears the Security Council are ready to grant 12 months to military coup leaders. 
 
  Rice said "Guinea Bissau and Syria are far apart, so let's take them one at a time." Okay, different continent, but the concept of democracy connects or should connect them. On Guinea Bissau, she said the US wants to increase pressure on the coup leaders, and mentioned sanctions. 

  Rice said, "we're going to continue in partnership with others to increase the pressure on the regime and work toward the swiftest possible restoration of a democratic government." Twelve months is the swiftest possible?

  Yesterday the ECOWAS minister told Inner City Press that a full year is needed, for such things as review of the voters' rolls. Is the Security Council's -- and the US' -- approach to democracy different in Syria and Guinea Bissau? It sure looks like it...

On Syria, a European source directed Inner City Press to the opposition's changing tactics in Aleppo, and to the number of pending visa requests for observers. UN Peacekeeping chief Herve Ladsous refused again to speak to the press. 
 
French Ambassador Gerard Araud explained his own refusal to speak: "We are in an electoral period in France, so I am awaiting my new authorities to arrive." Some are hoping that means a new Permanent Representative, including in the spirit of the Arab Spring. 
 
Other wonder if Francois Holland and his new foreign minister might move to replace Ladsous, who after all was an aide to Sarkozy minister Michele Aliot-Marie, when she flew on aircraft of cronies of Tunisian dictator Ben Ali. Watch this site.

From US Mission to the UN transcript:

Inner City Press: The Syrian government keeps saying that they're facing terrorism or foreign fighters. The ambassador just waived around a CD saying that these are confessions of foreign fighters, and he said that, if Al Qaeda attacks the United States, immediately people come to the Council but that the same thing should happen in this case. Is that totally specious? Are there any foreign fighters involved and what do you say about it? And I'm going to ask you one more thing about Guinea Bissau, I'm sorry to say, since it's on the Council's agenda-

Ambassador Rice: Hold on. Because Guinea Bissau and Syria are far apart, so let's take them one at a time. With respect to the challenge of terrorism and foreign fighters, I don't think anybody can say with complete certainty that there are not any foreign fighters in Syria. I mean we've seen-frankly seen foreign fighters in Syria-transit Syria-for years on their way into Iraq, and there may be a flow in the opposite direction. But this is substantially a diversion from the main point.
The main point is that the government continues to kill its own people, and having done so over the course of more than a year, it has created a situation in which people have taken up arms to defend themselves. Peaceful protesters and those who set out to address their concerns through peaceful means continue to do so. But there are some who have taken up arms in self-defense. And there are some who may be taking advantage of what is increasingly a violent and chaotic situation, who have extremist motivations and who may be doing this for reasons that have nothing to do with the aspirations of the peaceful protesters. And on Guinea Bissau?

Inner City Press: Very briefly. Some are saying that what the Council would consider doing or what ECOWAS is doing is essentially rewarding coups leaders-that there was a coup and that now the plan is to give them 12 months to make a transition and then have elections that were supposed to have already been held right about now. Does the U.S. support the ECOWAS plan and how does that comport with its commitment to democracy elsewhere?

Ambassador Rice: Well the United States has been very clear in condemning the coup. We have imposed sanctions on those who have committed the coup, and now Guinea Bissau's assistance is suspended pursuant to U.S. law. Our position on this and other situations where a government is overthrow by force is that that is completely unacceptable. We've said as a Council that there could potentially be consequences, including potentially sanctions on the coup regime. So, we're going to continue in partnership with others to increase the pressure on the regime and work toward the swiftest possible restoration of a democratic government.

In Murky UNIFIL, 20 Minutes in Israel Called "Quick," Nepal Mislabeled Truck

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 8 -- As the UN murkily meanders into its Syria observer deployment, it provides what appears to be spin about its UNIFIL mission next door in Lebanon.


Inner City Press: The Government of Lebanon, has complained to UNIFIL about a Spanish officer of the UNIFIL contingent rep, crossing barbed wire and meeting they say with Israeli forces for 20 minutes, they say it violates their sovereignty. Did it actually take place? Is it a violation of the SOFA or, or whatever the understanding is between and, and what’s the explanation?

Spokesperson Nesirky: Let me find out about that particular topic, because I haven't heard about that. Let me check on that for you. 
 
  Later in the day, Nesirky's office emailed and inserted into its transcript:

Subject: Your question on UNIFIL
From: UN Spokesperson - Do Not Reply [at] un.org
Date: Mon, May 7, 2012 at 1:16 PM
To: Matthew.Lee [at] innercitypress.com

Regarding your question at today's noon briefing, we have the following information from the UN Interim Force in Lebanon (UNIFIL):

Yesterday a UNIFIL technical team was carrying out measurements on the ground to ascertain the exact location of the work carried out by the IDF in the general area of Kafr Kila.

In carrying out its work, the technical team was accompanied and assisted by UNIFIL Spanish troops. In the process, one of the peacekeepers inadvertently crossed the Technical Fence and quickly came back, as soon as he realized it.

This issue has been addressed at the tactical and operational level between the Lebanese Armed Forces and UNIFIL.

  But is 20 minutes "quickly"? It's reported that 
 
"the Spanish officer crossed the Fatima Gate in southern Lebanon, facing the Israeli town of Metulla, held talks with Israeli troops for 20 minutes and then returned back to the Lebanese territories. A Lebanese army source [said] that the incident is an 'unjustified violation of Lebanon’s sovereignty. We demanded the UNIFIL’s Command to take strict punitive measures against the (Spanish) officer as he violated the agreement signed with the peacekeeping mission, which prevents any of its members from crossing into Israel.'"

  So which is it? Actually, the Spanish exodus from Lebanon will, relatedly or not, be more extensive:

"Spanish Defense Minister Pedro Morenes stressed on Tuesday his country’s commitment to reduce by 20 percent the number of Spanish troops in the United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon. He told Spanish state television that the rest of the Spanish troops will completely withdraw from the international force in 2013."

Meanwhile, Inner City Press also on May 7 asked, about Nepal:

Inner City Press: In Nepal, there is a report in Republica, a paper there, that a police officer was killed by a UN vehicle; this was, it was published on Friday and I just wonder, is that the case, and more than that, what did the UN, given that it has immunity or legal immunity, what does it do in circumstances such as this?

Spokesperson Nesirky: In Nepal, right. I don’t have anything on that, Matthew. I’ll check.

  The next day the UN replied:

Subject: Your question on a vehicular accident in Nepal
From: UN Spokesperson - Do Not Reply [at] un.org
Date: Tue, May 8, 2012 at 10:56 AM
To: Matthew.Lee [at] innercitypress.com

Regarding your question about a fatality and reports of the involvement of a UN vehicle in Nepal, we have the following information:

A lorry, carrying two Nepal Army Mine Protected Vehicles, intended for use by the United Nations, lost one cargo vehicle, which accidentally killed a Nepalese policeman. The local police investigated the accident and cited a brake failure as the cause of the accident.

These vehicles are white in color and marked with black UN letters on the side, hence the initial confusion.

  Okay. Next question: how can the UN keep dodging on having introduced cholera into Haiti? Watch this site.

On Syria, Post-Coup Fiji Sends Observers, UN Stonewalls, Araud Won't Speak

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 8 -- As envoy Kofi Annan briefed the UN Security Council about Syria on Tuesday, it remained unclear from the Department of Peacekeeping Operations how many observers, and from where, are in the country.

  Finland, which is running for a seat on the Security Council next year, sent two observers in the first deployment, and has spoken of eight more. 

 At what seemed another campaign event across the street from the UN on Tuesday morning, the Institutional moderator said, "You are sending observers to Syria, I am not sure what my question is, but that is an interesting situation." Interesting, indeed.

  Even more interesting, in terms of Kofi Annan's time as UN Secretary General, is the inclusion of eight observers from Fiji. While he was S-G, Annan announced that no new deployments of Fijian peacekeepers would be accepted, given the coup d'etat in that country.

  Now with the coup leader Commodore Voreqe Bainimarama still in place, Fiji is sending eight observers to Kofi's (or, the Kofi-affiliated) mission in Syria. Inner City Press has asked his spokesman Ahmad Fawzi:

"beyond the [12 day old] budget questions, can you comment on the fact that when Mr. Annan was UN S-G he said DPKO should cease new deployments of Fijian peacekeepers in light of the coup, and now Fiji is sending observers on this mission to Syria, while still led by the coup leader?
"11 substantive international staff (1 USG, 2 ASG, 2 D-2, 2 P-5, 2 P-4, 2 P-3) -- are the two deputies the ASGs? Which of the other position have already been filled or designated, and by whom?

"Likewise, what (and how high) are the "extra-budgetary resources" for three Political Affairs Officers for six months, and a Senior Advisor for three months? Has the Senior Adviser been chosen? Who? And, the "refurbishment of office space ($30,000)" -- which office is this?"

We will report answers when received.

  On the way into the Security Council, the press asked Ambassadors Susan Rice of the US and Gerard Araud of France, as well as Herve Ladsous the fourth Frenchman in a row atop UN Peacekeeping, if they would speak after the briefing.

  Ladsous said, in French and then English, "We'll see." Then it was revealed that he will not speak.

  Ambassador Rice said, "Probably," although it the time overlaps with Annan's stakeout set for 5:30 pm Geneva time this may not happened.

  Araud, who was not seen at the Security Council's meeting on Guinea Bissau on May 7, the day after Nicolas Sarkozy and by implication foreign minister Alain Juppe were voted out of power, appeared on May 8 and said that he will not speak. 

 Araud said, "We are in an electoral period in France, so I am awaiting my new authorities to arrive." Some are hoping that means a new Permanent Representative, including in the spirit of the Arab Spring. Watch this site.

On Myanmar, IMF Won't Assess Reversion to Repression, Kachin Not Considered

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 7 -- When the International Monetary Fund's Meral Karasulu took questions about the IMF's work in and assessment of Myanmar on Monday night, one expected military rule and fighting in the ethnic zones to be a topic.

  But amid the IMF's rosy view, pitching for example natural gas reserves, the world's major wire services focused on exchange rates, natural gas and, in the case of AFP, the Paris Club creditors getting paid back their money.

  Inner City Press asked Meral Karasulu two questions: how likely does the IMF think that a reversion to military rules, and did the IMF even consider the continued conflict in Kachin state in its assessment?

Meral Karasulu politely dodged the first question, saying that the IMF has no "comparative advantage in political analysis," even that it would be "inappropriate" to consider the risk of reversion.


  Meral Karasulu emphasized the Myanmar's main economic activity is not in the ethnic areas.

  Asked where Myanmar's reserves actually are, Meral Karasulu said in three state owned banks controlled by the Ministry of Finance.

When she was asked what percentage of Myanmar's budget is devoted to the military she said she did not know. (Perhaps relatedly, on Sri Lanka where the IMF does have a lending program, it downplays the growth of military spending even after the scorched earth military compaign of 2009).

Of corruption in Myanmar, Meral Karasulu said she has "no anecdotes," and that during country visits the IMF can't see it. Meral Karasulu will return to Myanmar in the second half of May. Watch this site.

On Guinea Bissau, ECOWAS Calls Coup-Reward Holistic, Angola - Gbagbo Roots?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 7 -- Why would Economic Community Of West African States, under the leadership of Alassane Ouattara of Cote d'Ivoire, be trying to give the de facto leaders of Guinea Bissau a full year as a reward for their coup d'etat?

  This question was asked in and out of two long meetings Monday at the UN, the first of the Security Council, and the afternoon session involving the European Union among others as well.

Outside the second meeting, after 6 pm, Inner City Press asked Salamatu Hussaini Suleiman, ECOWAS' Commissioner for Political Affairs, about the 12 month proposal. She answered at length, that a "holistic" approach is needed, to solve Guinea Bissau's problems "once and for all."

"The twelve months for the transition period is for updating voting register, for example, and other reforms." But there was a first round, that the Security Council wisely or not called mostly free and fair.

Standing next to and escorting Salamatu Hussaini Suleiman was Ivorian Ambassador Bamba, who won his credential at the UN to represent Alassane Ouattara with some fanfare.

Superficially, the fact that Ouattara was helped to power by the UN Security Council and France in the name of democracy led to even more consternation at ECOWAS under his leadership going soft on democracy. 
 
But a well placed Council source pointed out to Inner City Press that during Ouattara's standoff with defiant hold-over President Laurent Gbagbo, "Angola took Gbagbo's side." Now Angola is main player in the Portuguese Speaking Community configuration CPLP, and IS the MISSANG mission in Guinea Bissau. So Ouattara "goes in the other direction. But on Mali too? 
 
Inner City Press asked ECOWAS' Salamatu Hussaini Suleiman about Mali as well. She said the situation there is "better" than in Guinea Bissau, in that there is a Malian "transitional government." 
 
She said, "Definitely we are looking at the problems in Mali as well... There is a transitional government in place, it is easier to work with that resolution and put the reforms in place."

But, she noted, there are the rebels in the north. Yes. And some wonder how troops from Nigeria and Cote d'Ivoire would fare in hot desert conditions in Timbuktu. Watch this site.