Saturday, May 5, 2012

Tweeking Sudans Resolution, No Comment on Child Soldiers, Hilde's Anti-Aircraft

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 1 -- On April 30, the United States put its amended draft resolution on the two Sudans "into blue," setting it up for a vote. Still that evening, US Ambassador Susan Rice spoke with her Chinese counterpart Li Baodong and Russia's Deputy Permanent Representative Pankin.

  On May 1 outside an afternoon meeting of Council members' political coordinators, Inner City Press was told that the US was adamant that the resolution would be put to a vote on May 2, that the US has "the votes." One wondered, does that mean an abstention is possible?

  Later one of the objectors told Inner City Press that talks and even changes on the draft resolution would continue Tuesday night, right up to any Wednesday vote. 
 
  Another well placed Council member pointed out that while the African Union's request "carries a lot of weight," the African Union did NOT ask for Article 41 (sanctions) and also did not specify WHICH paragraph it wanted supported under Chapter 7. "That's where the negotiation is," the source told Inner City Press. We'll see.

  Meanwhile at the May 1 UN noon briefing Inner City Press asked:

Inner City Press: an Ambassador of South Sudan has said that Khartoum is conscripting young South Sudanese in the territory of the north and making them fight; for example in Heglig and on the border, and I wanted to know, is anyone in the UN system aware of that? And do they have, can they confirm that, and what is going to be done about it?

Deputy Spokesperson Eduardo Del Buey: Well, I’ll have to check on that. I don’t have the information with me. I saw the media reports this morning; we will have to check and see and come back on it. As you know, our Missions in Sudan are limited to Darfur and Abyei, so we don’t have missions in the rest of the country. Consequently, we can’t monitor what is going on in the entire country.

Inner City Press: But Ms. Coomaraswamy does do reports on countries where you don’t have a peacekeeping mission. She says this is a problem, the recruitment of children, this would be the forced recruitment of child [inaudible]…

Deputy Spokesperson: Well, you might want to contact her Office and find out.

Inner City Press: Right. But, isn’t she the Special Envoy of Ban Ki-moon?

Deputy Spokesperson: Yes, but you might want to contact her Office and see.

Inner City Press. OK. Hilde Johnson gave an interview to The Citizen in Juba, and she said that we have a mandate, we, UNMISS have a mandate to protect civilians but we can’t do it. We don’t have the resources, because we don’t have anti-aircraft missiles. She said it a couple of times. At least the article reports it twice. And so, it is unclear to some, is she asking, she seems to say that they’d like to have them. And is that something that UNMISS, does UNMISS want to have anti-aircraft missiles? Is that what the interview means?

Deputy Spokesperson: I don’t interpret it that way. What she was asked was, you know, what can you do, you are there in South Sudan, what can you do to stop people from being killed by aerial bombardment? And, she said, well we don’t have the tools to be able to repulse the aerial bombardment, and she mentioned specifically the fact that they had no ground-to-air missiles to deal with planes coming over the border to bomb the place. I don’t think she was asking for anything; she was basically making a statement of fact.

Inner City Press: does South Sudan have such equipment? Does she think that they should?
Deputy Spokesperson: I don’t know if South Sudan has that equipment or not. But, I don’t think she was saying that they should have it. All she was saying was that, in terms of her mandate to protect the civilian population of South Sudan, she does not have the tools in her arsenal to be able to fight against aerial bombardment. Okay, thank you very much, ladies and gentlemen.

No, thank YOU. Watch this site.

At UN, China's DESA 2, Senegal for DGACM, US Moves on DPI, Split DM?

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, May 1 -- The musical chairs game triggered UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's five year mobility rule has very few seats left to fill. 

  China, it has reliably been confirmed to Inner City Press, has submitted two names to replace Sha Zukang as head of the Department of Economic and Society Affairs mid-year, after the Rio + 20 conference. 

   Inner City Press can report that the Senegalese registrar at the International Criminal Tribunal on Rwanda, Adama Dieng, is being eyed for the top position in the Department of General Assembly and Conference Management, a belated post for sub Saharan Africa.
  Dieng was previously passed over for Special Adviser on Africa, as exclusively reported by Inner City Press, given to Maged Abdelaziz who is still even after the award by Ban representing Egypt at the UN.

  The top position in the Department of Public Information, a major donor tells Inner City Press, might to an American, "so Ban can do better on Capitol Hill and with the US press." 
 
  Other say what with the US in line for the Department of Political Affairs, probably with Jeffrey Feltman as first reported by Inner City Press, the best the US could get in DPA would be an Assistant Secretary General post which for now does not exist.

   In this scenario, Inner City Press is told that "some Austrian" would get the DPI top spot. This is how Ban's UN works, or doesn't.

  Japan has been taken care of, with former Permanent Representative Yukio Takasu being put atop the Department of Management. 

  Several sources had told Inner City Press that the US was opposed to this, and now predict that the Office of Human Rights Management and even the Controller will be moved out of DM and report directly to Ban Ki-moon. If so, it would be a loss of face for number two funder Japan.

  Ban's senior adviser and now "Change Management" czar Kim Won-soo was seen this week briefing the Group of 77, which passed a resolution to hold Ban's plan to account in the General Assembly. Kim in his previous incarnation as Deputy Chief of Staff often traveled with Ban, but this time did not go with him to Myanmar. 
 
  Nor, apparently, did new Chief of Staff Susana Malcorra, seen Monday night at the US End of Security Council Presidency reception. Ban's Myanmar trip gave rise to very few updates to the press, as we've noted. What will happen with Ban comes back? Watch this site.

Playing Chicken with China on Sudans, Germany Fights for 1540 Seat, ECO-Watching

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 1 -- After the US put "in blue" a draft UN Security Council resolution about the Sudans on Monday, it emerged there is not agreement on the sanctions reference in the draft and another more nitty gritty fight is in the Council.

  The so-called 1540 committee on terrorism has eight experts, but nine candidates this time. The fight boils down to two seats for three experts from three countries: the UK, Germany and Pakistan.

  Pakistan says that the 1540 experts group already "Europe-heavy." Germany counters that geography is not the criterion, and there is no reason to limit this stage to a three-for-two in which it is expected to drop out. All eight are up for grabs.

  Meanwhile on Tuesday, even Security Council members going in for bilateral meetings with the new Azeri president of the Council for May asked Inner City Press about the status of the Sudans resolution. 

  There is not only the question of sanctions, but how to deal with South Sudan's entry into, and some say intentional destruction of, Heglig oil facilities.

   Several Council members' Ambassadors in Khartoum -- NOT the US -- were taken to visit Heglig; one country called the damage "sizable." Another Council member has photographs and estimated the damage at $1 billion. Who will pay?

   Another item floating as Azerbaijan takes over from the US is whether and when ECOWAS will come for Security Council endorsement of its plans in Mali and Guinea Bissau. 

  A well placed Council member told Inner City Press on Tuesday that ECOWAS "may" come brief the Council about Guinea Bissau, and ask for endorsement at that time. 

   Or they might "pull a Kenya" -- a reference to Kenya merely informing the Council president that it had sent troops into Somalia, or "pull an Ethiopia." For the record, Eritrea's President Isaias Afwerki resurfaced over the weekend on state television, putting an end it seems to reports at the UN of his death. Watch this site.

Footnote: the US Mission last act in April as a Jazz Day concert in the General Assembly, featuring among others Herbie Hancock, Wayne Shorter, Hugh Masekela, Stevie Wonder, Esmeralda Spalding and near the end a Latin jazz groups led by Bobby Sanabria, accompanied by a 91 year old drummer. 

US Ambassador Susan Rice opined that the General Assembly Hall had never been so cool, and might never be again. We'll see.

On Syria, Ladsous "Studying" Drones, Claims Free Movement, Borrel Scandal Qs

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 1 -- When Herve Ladsous, the fourth Frenchman in a row to head UN Peacekeeping, appeared Tuesday for a rare press conference, the UN's deputy spokesman said that only questions about Syria would be accepted.

  This kept off limits not only questions about South Sudan, where Ladsous' Department is bemoaning its lack of anti-aircraft missiles while refusing to issues its report on the dead of Pibor in Jonglei State, and Haiti where peacekeepers presumptively brought in cholera, but Ladsous' own scandals, including arranging flights with cronies of Tunisian dictator Ben Ali, and improperly intervening in a death investigation in Djibouti, see below.

  On Syria, Inner City Press asked Ladsous about his previously-exposed proposal that the UN use drones -- did he intend to try to use these in Syria?

  Ladsous replied that on drones, "we are conducting a study: technical, financial and other, one very strong parameter would be to secure the consent of the government concerned." Then he would use them?

  Inner City Press asked about the call for freedom of movement of UNSMIS, how does it compare to the restrictions that Ladsous' DPKO accepts in Western Sahara, as revealed even by the recent report that was watered down under Ladsous, at the request of his country, France?

  Ladsous said, "I won't think the situation compares. We did have some initial, some few restrictions of movement for our people, presented to us as motivated by security considerations, I would say, over last week freedom has been ensured, they can go places they want."

  So Ladsous is both bragging about freedom of movement in Syria, and belated acknowledging but not explaining a less degree of freedom of movement accepted by his DPKO in Western Sahara, restrictions on MINURSO by French ally Morocco.


"The senior judges of the Tribunal de Grande Instance in Paris ruled admissible Thursday, March 2 complaint by Elisabeth Borrel, widow of a magistrate died in Djibouti in 1995, for 'pressure on the judiciary,' complaint against a former spokesman for the Foreign Ministry, Hervé Ladsous, said on Friday, March 3 judicial source. In a statement dated 29 January 2005, the Quai d'Orsay had regretted the expulsion of six French aid workers of Djibouti before announce that a copy of the court record on the death of Bernard Borrel would 'soon' sent to the Djiboutian justice.
"[The] magistrate's family filed a complaint in February, whereas this announcement ten days before the French investigating judge was formally received the request for judicial assistance issued by Djibouti, could be interpreted as 'pressure on the judiciary.'"

How is this man the head of UN Peacekeeping, and how does he get away with answer no questions, and then appearing in such a way that questions about only one country - on which his duties are eclipsed by former (second of four Frenchmen) DPKO chief Jean Marie Guehenno? We aim to have more on this.

As Ban Belatedly Speaks From Myanmar, It's Promise of UN Money, on Jazz Day

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 30 -- After the Myanmar silence of UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon was blamed by his deputy spokesman on limited Burmese "infrastructure," belatedly a read-out of Ban's meetings with the Thein Sein government was issued.

  In it, Ban expresses his commitment to work with the Government including "UN technical assistance and help to mobilize financial support for Myanmar's first population and housing census in 2014."

  So who would pay? It's reported that 
 
"in the two years leading up to the data-collection period, the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) will be assisting in surveyor training and drafting survey documents. UNFPA's country representative Mohamed Abdel-Ahad called it an especially steep challenge due to the amount of time elapsed since the last census...Abdel-Ahad said workers expect to carry out the census in April, 2014. The United Nations is expected to at least partially cover the estimated $53-million cost."

The Thein Sein government, even as it denies voting rights to and shoots at the Kachin, is being lavished with debt forgiveness and other funds. Still Ban's buying friendship, and nice quotes, with UN money. What's new?

[One thing's new on April 30 at the UN: Jazz Day, video here.]