Saturday, April 14, 2012

Who Picked Ban's Google+ Hangout Guests, Soft on UN, No Cholera or War Crimes Qs?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 10, updated -- Partnering and not for the first time with Google, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon on Tuesday afternoon took scripted questions over YouTube and Google+ from six young people, up to 29 years of age, from the US, Kenya, UK, Brazil and Sri Lanka.

It was unclear how the questioners were selected. (Inner City Press submitted this as a question, but it was not answered by the end or this publication.) The youth jobs question came from the self-proclaimed owner of a technology company receiving investment from a Hong Kong billionaire.

A questioner from Nairobi, Kenya -- from where there appeared to be two -- asked how to avoid discrimination by ethnicity while combating terrorism. While this might seem to refer to crackdowns on ethnic Somalis when Kenyan including soldiers suffer losses to Al Shabaab, Ban's answer was to tout the UN's bureaucratic CTITF, then thank Kenyan "women and men" as troops in Somalia.

The UN is under fire for having brought cholera into Haiti and then refused to acknowledge or try to make amends for it. Inner City Press wondered, including online, whether the "hang out" would include this Haiti cholera question, about which Inner City Press also asked at the day's noon briefing.

Ban, as it happened, brought up Haiti but largely to praise the band Linkin Park. When they came to the UN, Inner City Press asked some band members about the complaints of Haitians against the UN, but the band did not answer.

It appears that Linkin Park, like Google or at least the executive who moderated the hangout, vaguely believe the UN to be only good, that promoting the UN without any questioning or accountability is a good thing in itself.

Perhaps most strikingly, this small Google+ plus hangout included a youth (of 27 years old) in Colombo, Sri Lanka. Despite the controversy about the UN there, with many Tamils feeling sold out by the UN and Ban, and Sinhalese nationalists denouncing the UN Human Rights Council for its recent vote, the question was about Rio + 20, from a UN Volunteer. Who selected this guests? The question remains.

Through the UN site and otherwise, Inner City Press asked again how Ban can say nothing about having as an adviser on peacekeeping Shavendra Silva, whose 58th Division is depicted in Ban's own Panel of Experts report as engaged in war crimes, and why Ban's "minders" now seek to hinder press coverage of this. The question itself has led to pushback, and was asked again at Tuesday's noon briefing. Watch this site.

On Syria, Annan's Technical Mission Stalls on Preconditions, Rice Says, Qatar & Saudi Funding Not Discussed

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 10 -- After Kofi Annan's letter was distributed to Security Council members by the US, this month's Council president, Annan's deputy Jean-Marie Guehenno was asked questions and so-called "elements to the press" were agreed to, and enunciated later by US Ambassador Susan Rice.

Inner City Press asked Rice about two points in Annan's letter, which Inner City Press obtained and put online at 12:28 pm while the meeting was still underway. Annan recounts that Assad on April 8 set pre-conditions including that regional countries not fund the opposition. Was there any discussion?

Rice replied that "there was general discussion of the additional conditions, and the letter of the envoy as well as the discussion in the Council made clear that nobody is prepared to contemplate or give validity to any additional conditions. There was no specific discussion of the details of those conditions."

Inner City Press what "substantial differences emerged" between General Mood of Annan's team and the Assad government. Rice replied that "there was a bit of discussion about it in the Q and A, and Jean-Marie Guehenno indicated that, at a certain stage, the Government and its engagements with the Mood team were essentially reflecting some of the conditions that they had said publicly, which were not consistent with the envoy's plan and the Six Point Plan endorsed by the Security Council; therefore, it became difficult to continue to productively proceed along those lines. I think we'll get a fuller understanding of those challenges and what next steps, if any, are contemplated with the technical team on the 12th when Kofi Annan will have had an opportunity to debrief with his team leadership."

Annan's letter asked the Security Council to register it deep concern. It is debatable if an "elements to the press," the weakest form of Council action if in fact it can even be considered an action given that it is not even put on the Council's web site, really registers or expresses such deep concern. It was a fast response, however.

A well placed regional source told Inner City Press on April 9, "Kofi has mediator's disease -- he'll never want to admit that he's failed, that he's been played. But when will he lose all credibility?"

Another source on April 9 told Inner City Press the buzz is that the Kofi Annan Foundation has been raising money "for Syria work." Inner City Press submitted this as a question to Annan's spokesman Ahmad Fawzi, who replied that he will look into it and response on Friday -- that is, the day AFTER Annan's briefing of the Council.

While Assad has asked Annan to stop countries like Saudi Arabia and Qatar from funding the opposition, some wonder if there is other funding in play. Where, Inner City Press has asked Annan's spokesman, is his Arab League nominated deputy Nassar El-Kidwa? The spokesman, admittedly busy and traveling to Iran, replied that he doesn't know. Watch this site.

From the US Mission transcript:

Inner City Press: The letter seems to say that on April 8th the Asad government asked Kofi Annan to get commitments from regional countries to stop the funding of the opposition, but it doesn't really say what was done on that. What was the position? Was there any discussion in the Council of this idea of regional countries openly saying they would fund the Free Syrian Army? And also, there's this mention of the General Mood-substantial differences emerged during his time there. Was there any Q and A with Mr. Guehenno? What can we say about these differences, and what do they foretell for an observer mission?

Ambassador Rice: Well, with respect to the additional conditions that the government announced on the 8th, there was general discussion of the additional conditions, and the letter of the envoy as well as the discussion in the Council made clear that nobody is prepared to contemplate or give validity to any additional conditions. There was no specific discussion of the details of those conditions. With respect to the technical assessment mission, the technical assessment mission-or technical mission-of General Mood, there was a bit of discussion about it in the Q and A, and Jean-Marie Guehenno indicated that, at a certain stage, the Government and its engagements with the Mood team were essentially reflecting some of the conditions that they had said publicly, which were not consistent with the envoy's plan and the Six Point Plan endorsed by the Security Council; therefore, it became difficult to continue to productively proceed along those lines. I think we'll get a fuller understanding of those challenges and what next steps, if any, are contemplated with the technical team on the 12th when Kofi Annan will have had an opportunity to debrief with his team leadership.

On Syria, Annan Letter to Council Says "Substantial Differences Emerged," Notes Assad on Qatar & Saudi Funding

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, April 10 -- Kofi Annan's letter to the Security Council was only distributed to Council members by the US Presidency for April after the doors closed on consultations on Tuesday morning. Inner City Press has obtained a copy and puts it online here, for now as an exclusive-must-credit.

In the letter, as some see it, Annan essentially extended Assad's deadline to April 12. He uses the word "timeline," and not deadline. There is more to say, but for now, here is the letter, and see below.

Update of 12:47 pm -- A key portion is at the top of page 3: Assad on April 8 made pre-conditions, but Annan has been advised by Russia's Lavrov that Assad is no longer insisting on written guarantees.

Update pf 12:52 pm: Top of page 4, Annan IS asking for a united Council to register its deepconcern: press statement?

Update of 1:02 pm: Assad on April 8 asked to stop countries from funding opposition. Annan says he's spoken with "countries of influence: no mention of funding.

Update of 1:40 pm -- the UNSC meeting has broken up, there will be "elements to the press" in 10 minutes. Guehenno was asked when it's right to deploy monitors. More soon - new story put online at 2:30 pm here.

On Syria, Annan to Give Assad an Extension, Guehenno to Brief SC, -ICP Sources

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, April 9, updated -- Kofi Annan is moving to give Syria's Assad an extension to the supposed April 10 deadline, sources exclusively tell Inner City Press.

In the hours after reporting on Monday that the UN Security Council would Tuesday get a briefing on Syria and a letter from Kofi Annan, Inner City Press learned more. Sources specify to Inner City Press that the Tuesday video availability will be by Jean Marie Guehenno, Annan's non-Arab League deputy and former head of the UN Department of Peacekeeping Operations.

Update of 5:30 am April 10: Annan spokesman Fawzi has replied to Inner City Press that "Mr Annan is sending a leter to the Council today, with an update on developments in the Syria crisis, Mr Guehenno will be on stand-by by VCR from Geneva to answer any questions the Council members may have."

More explosively, the sources tell Inner City Press that Annan will be granting Syria's Bashar al Assad an extension to meet his previous commitment to Annan's Six Point plan, including the supposed April 10 deadline -- it will, the sources told Inner City Press, be extended, probably to April 12.

"Kofi has mediator's disease," one of the sources told Inner City Press. "He'll never want to admit that he's failed, that he's been played. And so he'll just give an extension. But when will he lose all credibility?"

Another source earlier on Monday told Inner City Press the buzz is that the Kofi Annan Foundation has been raising money "for Syria work." Inner City Press submitted this as a question to Annan's spokesman Ahmad Fawzi but has yet to receive a response. When one comes in it will be published. It's now understood that a response will arrived at latest Friday, April 13.

The context is that Fawzi declined to answer Inner City Press' weeks ago question of whether the Kofi Annan Foundation has solicited funds from regional countries with an interest in Syria.

So where, one might ask, is the Arab League nominated deputy Nassar El-Kidwa in all this? Watch this site.

After UN Vague on Dictators Tweets, ICP Said to Mock as Ban Takes War Crime Advice

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 9 -- Last week UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon read a speech that said, "Some dictators in our world are more afraid of tweets than they are of opposing armies." Inner City Press ignored the quote, assuming that Ban as on issues from Syria to UN reform had simply read from an over-heated script written elsewhere.

But this Ban quote was noticed, and quickly gave rise to derision, including from international law professors who for once asked, "What's Ban Ki-moon smoking?"

And so, along with questions on Syria, Yemen and the Congo, Inner City Press at Monday's UN noon briefing asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky to clarify the comment and respond to the mocking. But first, Nesikry tried to hit back by implying that only Inner City Press was mocking Ban:

Spokesperson Nesirky: Let me check on that, Matthew. I think you had one other question, and then I think that will be it, okay?

Inner City Press: I want you to just clarify, there was a quote by the Secretary-General where he said that in our world some dictators fear tweets more than armies, it is a very interesting quote, but some people hav some questions, what exactly does it mean, which dictators is he referring to, is it really the tweets that they are afraid of or the people tweeting? Do you want to clarify it at all, because some have kind of mocked it.

Spokesperson Nesirky: I wonder who that might be who is mocking it, Matthew? But…

Inner City Press: Foreign Policy website, take a look at it.

Spokesperson: Well, let me just say it is very easy to parse speeches, remarks, articles, blogs — it’s very easy to do that. I think it is quite straightforward to note that tweeting has become a phenomenon in the political sphere; in the course of the Arab Spring that has been particularly apparent, but not just there and not just then. I think he is simply referring to that phenomenon, and the fact that, in some parts of the world, in some countries, you have seen tweets, you have seen other forms of social media playing a role in galvanizing public opinion and in providing dynamic movement for change. I think that’s — that’s a lot more than 140 characters — but I think that’s roughly where we are going.

[The Spokesperson later added that the Secretary-General would take part in a Google+ hangout with young people from Africa, Asia, Europe, the Middle East and North and South America on Tuesday, 10 April, from United Nations Headquarters in New York.]

We'll see how that goes. But Monday evening Inner City Press observed Ban posing for photos almost entirely with South Koreans at a photo exhibit he was thanked for, and on the sidelines of which Ambassadors from the panoply of continents said he was exercising censorship and weakening the UN.

At the same time, Ban accepted without comment an alleged war criminal as his adviser, then his minders tried to hinder Press coverage of the issue.

No canned "Google Plus hang out" can make up for that. Watch this site.