Saturday, June 4, 2011

Sri Lanka Report Held by UN's Ban & Nambiar Partially Describes White Flag Killings Nambiar Involved In: Conflicts

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 24 -- With the UN still withholding its Panel of Experts' report on war crimes in Sri Lanka, The Island in its ninth day of publishing portions of the reported that were leaked, presumptively by the government of Mahinda Rajapaksa, has run the “'White Flag' incident” section (see below).

This section raises questions about UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon not having required the recusal of his chief of staff Vijay Nambiar, who was involved in the incident -- about the the Panel of Experts itself.

The Panel's report as leaked to The Island describes part of the White Flag killings and lists by name the involvement of Mahinda Rajapaksa, his brothers Gotabaya and Basil and Permanent Representative to the UN Palitha Kohona, against whom a filing has been made to the International Criminal Court for his involvement in the presumptive war crime.

As partially described by the UN Panel of Experts, “Nadesan and Pulidevan, and possibly Colonel Ramesh” conveyed a request to surrender to an “official[] of the UN” and received assurances they would not be killed through “intermediaries.” They were then killed.

While the Panel's reports, troublingly, does not disclose the involvement of Vijay Nambiar, instead referring only to a UN intermediary as having conveyed assurances that those surrendering would not be killed, Nambiar has acknowledged being involved.

Inner City Press, which visiting Sri Lanka covering Ban's trip in May 2009, has followed this issue closely, repeatedly asking for a statement by Mr. Nambiar describing his role. Inner City Press was directed to a single filmed interview Nambiar gave, in which he acknowledged a role

The Panel of Experts, named and essentially paid by the UN of Ban Ki-moon, was remiss in not naming Nambiar. Given how and by whom the Panel's members were named and paid, and their final work product, there was a conflict of interest.

Ban Ki-moon, many now conclude, has been remiss in allowing Nambiar to remain involved in handling the report, even inreviewing it for what the UN should do next. It is a blatant conflict of interest.

Following numerous previous inquiries by Inner City Press into this, including Palitha Kohona heatedly disputing the account that Nambiar gave, on April 12 and 19 Inner City Press again asked Ban's deputy spokesman Farhan Haq if Nambiar would be involved or recused.

Haq, who previously denied the existence of the filing with the ICC which details Nambiar's role in the White Flag killings, said that Nambiar is a senior advisor and was involved in reviewing the report.

Other leaked portions describe Nambiar interfacing about the review with Kohona and his Deputy, General Shavendra Silva, also reportedly involved in war crimes at the end of the conflict.

Still other leaked portions allude to a February 22 meeting, which Ban's lead spokesman Martin Nesirky in essence denied to Inner City Press took place, between the Panel of Experts and Sri Lankan Attorney General Mohan Peiris, in the office of another of Ban's advisers, Lynn Pascoe.

Late arriving on the scene, in Sri Lankan press accounts, is Ban's deputy chief of staff Kim Won-soo, perhaps in belated acknowledgment that Nambiar should never have been allowed to be involved in the report, which partially describes the White Flag killings in which he was involved.

Now it is said that Ban will take a call from Minister G.L. Peiris. Even if the report is released on April 25, along with a UN response in which Vijay Nambiar has clearly been involved, it is too late, and poisoned by the conflicted involved of Nambiar. This is all a new low for this UN. Watch this site.

From the leaked Panel of Experts report:

The "White Flag" incident

170. Various reports have alleged that the political leadership of the LTTE and their dependents were executed when they surrendered to the SLA. In the very final days of the war, the head of the LTTE political wing, Nadesan, and the head of the Tiger Peace Secretariat Pulidevan, were in regular communication with various interlocutors to negotiate surrender. They were reportedly with a group of around 300 civilians. The LTTE political leadership was initially reluctant to agree to an unconditional surrender, but as the SLA closed in on the group in their final hideout, Nadesan and Pulidevan, and possibly Colonel Ramesh, were prepared to surrender unconditionally. This intention was communicated to officials of the United Nations and of the Governments of Norway, the United Kingdom and the United States, as well as to representatives of the ICRC and others. It was also conveyed through intermediaries to Mahinda, Gotabaya and Basil Rajapaksa, former Foreign Secretary Palitha Kohona and senior officers in the SLA.

171. Both President Rajapaksa and Defence Secretary Basil Rajapaksa provided assurances that their surrender would be accepted. These were conveyed by intermediaries to the LTTE leaders, who were advised to raise a white flag and walk slowly towards the army, following a particular route indicated by Basil Rajapaksa. Requests by the LTTE for a third party to be present at the point of surrender were not granted. Around 6.30 a.m. on 18 May 2009. Nadesan and Pulidevan left their hide-out to walk towards the area held by the 58th Division, accompanied by a large group, including their families. Colonel Ramesh followed behind them, with another group. Shortly afterwards, the BBC and other television stations reported that Nadesan and Pulidevan had been shot dead. Subsequently, the Government gave several different accounts of the incident. While there is little information on the circumstances of their death, the Panel believes that the LTTE leadership intended to surrender.

On the morning of April 21, Inner City Press asked Ban's top two spokesmen to "please state the role of Mr. Nambiar in reviewing the report." No response has yet been received, more than 60 hours later. We will have more on this. Watch this site.

On Sri Lanka, After Russia Bashes UN Report, Ban Withholds It, Asks Medvedev to Support Him for Second Term as S-G

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 22 -- Shortly after reneging on his Spokesperson's Office repeated commitments that the UN Panel of Experts' report on Sri Lanka war crimes would be released “this week,” UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon told Russian leader Dmitry Medvedev, "I'd like to really count on your strong support, leadership and guidance in continuing my work as secretary-general.”

In Colombo, Russia's Ambassador Valdimir P.Mikhaylov had the previous day appeared at a press conference with Defense chief and presidential brother Gotabaya Rajapaksa and said "unfortunately it seems that the panel of experts went beyond its task, at least as it had been made known to our representatives of New York... we speak not about a 'UN report', since it was prepared neither by a UN body or nor even by its request. It was just a personal initiative of the UN Secretary General.”

In this context, for Ban to ask Russia in this way and at this time not to veto the second term he wants seems to many to telegraph that while the report may inevitably be released, Ban will not take serious action on it.

As leaked to The Island newspaper, presumptively by the government, the report urges Ban to himself investigate the UN's own compliance with international humanitarian law.

Ban's own chief of staff Vijay Nambiar was involved in the so called white flag killings of surrenderees, as described in a filing with the International Criminal Court.

As such, Nambiar is at a minimum a witness, perhaps a person of interest, in a violation of international humanitarian law.

But Ban has allowed Nambiar to be involved since then in the work on the Panel of Experts, including handing the report to General Shavendra Silva, reviewing the reports and, it seems, deciding not to release it when promised.

On the morning of April 21, Inner City Press asked Ban's top two spokesmen to "
please state the role of Mr. Nambiar in reviewing the report." No response has yet been received, more than 24 hours later. We will have more on this. Watch this site.

On Western Sahara, US Position on Human Rights & Trip Unclear, South Africa Questions AU-Less Group of Friends

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 19 -- How can the Western Sahara “Group of Friends” set up by the UN Security Council not include any African country? Inner City Press put this question to South African Permanent Representative Baso Sangqu on Tuesday after Council consultations on the draft resolution Inner City Press obtained and published before the meeting (click here).

Ambassador Sangqu said, that's a good question. Inner City Press asked if it is his understanding that members of the Group of Friends, once the Group issues its draft resolution, are not supposed to negotiate to make it any stronger. That question, Sangqu did not answer.

Inner City Press has learned that in the Group of Friends meeting on April 18, France wanted to limit human rights to Morocco allowing in UN Special Rapporteurs. South Africa and others want to see an ongoing human rights monitoring mechanism in the UN peacekeeping mission MINURSO.

The interim compromise, pushed by the UK, is to invite High Commissioner on Human Rights Navi Pillay to visit Western Sahara and make a recommendation. That alternative is in the draft. The draft is new in that way: the Group of Friends did not reach a total agreement.

While the US has not commented publicly despite requests, Inner City Press is told that the US is not a meaningful supporter of a human rights monitoring mechanism in MINURSO. The US “holds the pen” on the issue, however, and Ambassador Susan Rice attended and presided over the April 18 meeting.

Afterward Rice declined comment on the place of human rights in the draft and MINURSO mission.

But as South African Ambassador Sangqu, described by the New York Times as having been “frog marched” (as a South African newspaper put it) to the Council to vote in favor of Libya no fly zone resolution 1973, put it, how can a country call for human rights in Libya and not Western Sahara? How indeed.

There are, sources tell Inner City Press, discussions of sending a mini-visit of UN Security Council Ambassadors on a trip to Western Sahara. The last such trip was in 1995. The US has blocked the proposed Council trip to the Middle East. What is the US position on this proposal? Watch this site.

At UN, AFL-CIO & SMCC Protest Ban Ki-Moon's Anti-Labor Moves & Memo, Air Tests of Capital Master Plan Blocked

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 20 -- News of the labor problems of the UN under Secretary General Ban Ki-moon has now spread beyond the UN.

Inner City Press has learned that the major union confederation AFL-CIO has written in protest to Ban, about Ban's proposed elimination of 17 union Broadcast Engineer jobs. Click here for the letter, which the NY AFL-CIO copied to Senators Chuck Schumer and Kirsten Gillibrand and Rep. Anthony Weiner.

Inner City Press has been covering the downward trend in Ban's relations with labor for some months, most recently publishing a leaked “mobility” memo from Ban's chief of staff Vijay Nambiar to his chief of management Angela Kane and head of the UN Office of Human Resource Management Catherine Pollard, it is suggested that “40 percent of total recruitment in every Department every year be set aside for applicants external to the Department.”

Before that publication, Inner City Press asked Under Secretary General Angela Kane about the memo. She said, We think about a lot of things -- but when you write about them it makes trouble.

The trouble, though, come from affected UN staff themselves. The fourteen UN system unions in the SMCC have written to Ban, Nambiar and Kim Won-soo among others, citing the memo “now in the public domain,” asking Ban to “accept that your memo can and will no longer be a point of discussion of action.” Click here for that letter.

So with the Ban administration is under fire, how does it react?

Affected staff accused of posting a flyer about their plight were threatened with being fired. Ban's spokesman do not answer questions about the disputes: not Inner City Press' question months about the broadcast engineers, not more recent questions to lead spokesman Martin Nesirky about the elevator operator positions being pushed out of Union 32BJ, not yet this, on safety, from April 19:

Inner City Press: I wanted to ask two questions about the building. One concerns air tests. Previously, the Staff Union was allowed to conduct air tests for asbestos and other toxins, and I am told that now either the Department of Management or the CMP [Capital Master Plan] has blocked any type of air tests. Can you either confirm or deny that, and explain why those tests are not allowed to be performed by those who work here?

Acting Deputy Spokesperson Farhan Haq: No. I will check with the Capital Master Plan.

But 23 hours later, no information has been provided.

The CMP, however, was responsible for loud drilling and hammering while the Security Council met about Sudan on the morning of April 20.

Weeks ago, Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesperson's office about a new ASG working in the Department of Safety & Security, questioning why that appointment had never been publicly announced. An answer was promised but never given.

Now this week the appointment has finally been announced, with the statement that General Assembly sign off on creating the ASG position had belatedly been obtained. But what does the GA and member states think about Ban's mounting problems with labor? Watch this site.

UN Hangs Laurent Gbagbo Gift to Ban, Not Stating Where They “Protect” Him

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 19, updated -- A week after the UN Mission in Cote d'Ivoire fired from helicopter gunships on forces of Laurent Gbagbo, a painting Gbagbo gave to Secretary General Ban Ki-moon in 2008 was still proudly on display in front of the office of his Under Secretary General for Management Angela Kane, one floor above the offices of the media including Inner City Press at the UN.

It's a dreamy painting, accompanied by two plaques. The first, in French, says “Offert par S.E.M. Laurent Gbagbo, President de la Republique de Cote d'Ivoire.”

The second, to the side of the painting, says “Gift from Cote d'Ivoire to Secretary General Ban Ki-moon, 23 April 2008.”

What is the UN supposed to do with artwork gifted to it by a leader against whom the UN subsequently deployed gunship helicopters?

Update: at 10:15 am on April 19, Inner City Press told Ban's envoy to Cote d'Ivoire Choi Young-jin about, among other things, the paintings. We'll see.

Inner City Press on April 18 asked Ban's acting Deputy Spokesman a series of questions about Cote d'Ivoire, one of which despite saying he'd look into he had not answered even by the next day, another he declined to answer claiming it had been addressed by top UN Peacekeeper Alain Le Roy the previous week, when Inner City Press was in Washington, asking the US State Department about the same now dead minister, Desire Tagro:

Inner City Press: there is this list of 107 Gbagbo supporters that were taken to the Golf Hotel, where apparently there is some UNOCI [United Nations Operation in Côte d’Ivoire] presence. There is a report that Christophe [inaudible], the doctor of [Laurent] Gbagbo, has in fact been killed. He is one of the people taken to the Golf Hotel. And I wonder, what is UNOCI doing? One, can you either confirm or not confirm that? And two, what is UNOCI doing? What’s the status of those people in the Golf Hotel, and does UNOCI have any protection? Are they saying anything about it? And what if people are actually killed there?

Acting Deputy Spokesperson Haq: First of all, yes, UNOCI is providing protection to a range of political stakeholders, including people in the Golf Hotel. About this particular person, I’ll see whether there is any further detail we have about his situation. I don’t have any confirmation on that.

Inner City Press: How about the killing of the former minister [Desire] Tagro, does UN… does UNOCI have any knowledge? It’s been confirmed that he was killed and that he was killed in the course of being apprehended. Does the UN have any knowledge of either responsibility or…?

Acting Deputy Spokesperson: Yes, Alain Le Roy spoke about this at length last week, Desire Tagro.

Inner City Press: Did he confirm that Gbagbo is in Korhogo?

Acting Deputy Spokesperson Haq: We haven’t specified where he is in particular. He is in the north of the country.

Inner City Press said the name: Christophe Ble. No one in the UN asked for it to be spelled out to them, but in the UN transcript they say the name of a person they are supposed to be protecting, who now is reportedly dead, is “inaudible.” Watch this site.

At UN, Yemen Taken Up by Security Council, Syria Discussed But No Bahrain, Under Ban Envoy Litmus Test

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 18 -- While Yemen wasn't listed as a topic for the Security Council's “horizon” briefing on Monday, once UN Department of Political Affairs chief Lynn Pascoe mentioned it, several members asked to have more information.

And so on April 19 at 3:30 pm there will be a separate Security Council briefing devoted to Yemen. German Ambassador Wittig told Inner City Press that the situation in Yemen raises regional issues, including piracy.

Inner City Press asked Wittig if Germany would like Syria, which also discussed in the horizon briefing, to ascend to the Security Council agenda. Wittig said that Germany is concerned, that an eye should be kept on Syria.

Another Council member's Deputy Permanent Representative said that the Yemen briefing was okay because “he” -- Pascoe or Ban Ki-moon -- sent an envoy there, “so let's hear what he has to say.”

So if Syria accepted an envoy, it too would be discussed in the Security Council? This puts Ban not pushing for an envoy -- Oscar Fernandez Tarranco -- to Bahrain in a different light.

We will have more on Yemen, where the capital city is said to be split in two with a renegade general in control of half. Watch this site.

On Libya, US Says Arming Rebels Is Legal, Deferred Answer on Visas of d'Escoto

By Matthew Russell Lee

WASHINGTON DC, April 14 -- While at its April 14 briefing the US State Department on Libya was primarily asked why it is not arming or funding the rebels, giving more planes or even “whacking” Gaddafi, described as “fist pumping” in a convertible in Tripoli, Inner City Press ask State Department spokesman Mark Toner if allowing funds to the rebels might not result in violations of the arms embargo in UN Security Council resolution 1970.

While the idea is that arming the rebels would require another resolution, beyond 1973, Toner replied that arming the rebels is legal. See transcript:

MR. TONER: We believe that – our understanding of the sanctions and what was prohibited, that this was – this action was legal, that it was lawful.

Inner City Press: How about the arms embargo? How does – I mean, if this – both revenue streams, do you feel that the arms embargo under Resolution 1970, which is a total arms embargo on the country, is this something that you would be discussing with (inaudible)? Do you think – you keep saying that the revenue stream is only for the operation of the government.

MR. TONER: We’ve talked about this before, and what we’ve said is that 1970 – taken in totality, 1970 and 1973 – that it is permissible to get arms to the opposition, and that’s something that remains on the table, certainly. We’ve never taken that option away.

Inner City Press: And could I ask you about visas, too? So also on Libya, there – I’ve tried to ask this to the mission in New York --

MR. TONER: Yeah.

Inner City Press: -- but there was – there were stories saying that Ali Treki, who is the former foreign minister of Libya, was denied a U.S. visa, more recent stories saying that D’Escoto Brockmann, who was named to represent Libya, couldn’t get a visa. Is that true? And what’s the visa status of the two diplomats who left?

MR. TONER: D’Escoto Brockmann is the Nicaraguan?

Inner City Press: Nicaraguan. Absolutely.

MR. TONER: Okay. Yeah. I’m trying to remember, but this is a couple weeks ago, I believe, when this was in the news. But we had very real concerns about his status, and I believe we were looking into it, but at the same time, obviously, complying with our obligations as a host nation for the UN. But we felt that he had – we had concerns – there were concerns about his status here that needed to be addressed. I don’t know what the exact status is today of that, though. I’d have to check.

Inner City Press: (Inaudible) the Nicaraguan? His --

MR. TONER: Yes, the Nicaraguan. As far as the Libyan --

Inner City Press: The representatives – yeah, Shalgam and Dabbashi.

MR. TONER: -- representative – I’m not sure what the status of that is. I’ll have to check for you.

Inner City Press: : Okay. Yeah, thanks.

Seven hours later there still was no answered. And while an official of the US Mission to the UN, which has rebuffed Press questions about visas for some time, told Inner City Press that on Libya the legality of UN envoy al Khatib also being paid by Jordan would be publicly addressed this week, it hasn't been. We'll see -- watch this site.

At IMF, DSK Dismisses “French Questions,” None Taken on Cote d'Ivoire

By Matthew Russell Lee

WASHINGTON DC, April 14 -- Dominique Strauss Kahn was filled with bon mots and seeming bonhommie at his press conference at the IMF on Thursday. Perhaps it was because the questions and questioners were carefully selected, and those DSK didn't like, he didn't answer.

An RTL radio reporter asked him in French if by the Fall the IMF might have a new Managing Director -- that is, if by then DSK will already by campaigning to replace Nicolas Sarkozy.

“The French part of the question,” Strauss Kahn told the rest of the hall in English, “is irrelevant.” He added, in French, that he would answer questions later in that language, but only on the topic of the IMF's and World Bank's Spring Meetings.

But even on major IMF topics, DSK did not take questions. There was nothing on Ireland or Iceland, and as spokesperson Caroline Atkinson called the session to a close, a reporter cried out, “Please, one question about Portugal!” But no.

Inner City Press, which does its best to get questions answered at the IMF's biweekly online briefings, held hand aloft for the entire press conference. Perhaps DSK would have dismissively characterized as “a French question” any inquiry about Cote d'Ivoire, where the IMF in January told Inner City Press it had suspended its programs due to instability.

Before Strauss Kahn spoke, the President of the World Bank Robert Zoellick held his own press conference. It had many fewer jokes, but more information -- and not only his answer to Inner City Press on Libya and Yemen.

On Cote d'Ivoire, Zoellick said he would be meeting in the next days in DC with former IMF official Alassane Ouattara's finance minister Charles Koffi Dibi.

Will Strauss Kahn be participating in this meeting? If not, why not? Or is that too a “French question”? Watch this site.

World Bank Can't Deal With Libya Rebels, Says Danger Drives It Out of Yemen

By Matthew Russell Lee

WASHINGTON DC, April 14 -- Minutes after Robert Zoellick touted the World Bank's engagement with civil society in the Arab world, Inner City Press asked him if the Bank has had any contacts with the Libyan Transitional National Council based in Benghazi.

No, Zoellick answered, since its founding in 1944 the World Bank can deal “only with established governments.” He went on to describe World Bank assistance to those fleeing Libya, referring to a program with Bangladesh to get its nationals out and provide then assistance once back in Bangladesh.

But Bangladesh's Permanent Representative to the UN has told Inner City Press that most of his nationals remained trapped in Libya, unlike for example Belgium which immediately flew its 78 citizens out.

Zoellick implied that some part of the $500 million program just announced with Tunisia will help those fleeing Libya to that country. We'll see.

Inner City Press also asked Zoellick about Yemen, whether World Bank programs continue there and what it would take to change that -- that is, if there is a limit to the repression that the World Bank would accept.

Zoellick replied that nearly all of the World Bank's international staff have been removed from the country for safety reasons, although a “resident” remains to work on “the bank [or Bank?] brief” there. He mused that the World Bank likes to watch things, to be ready. But ready for what? Watch this site.

Leaked French Memos Discuss Destablizing Gbagbo, Coup Plots & Leaders

By Matthew Russell Lee, 2d in Exclusive series

UNITED NATIONS, April 13 -- French government documents obtained by Inner City Press reflect, as far back as 2005, France and the UN wanted to “put in place a plan of action to destablize Laurent Gbagbo.” See document here, under the rubric “From New York: Departure of Gbagbo.”

The French were monitoring, to say the least, plans for a coup d'etat against Gbagbo, that would result in Gbagbo's “displacement” outside of Cote d'Ivoire. See document here.

France's internal reporting on military forces and leaders in Cote d'Ivoire is here.

Also obtained by Inner City Press is the French analysis of the “failure” of African leaders Tandja, Mbeki of South Africa and Obasanjo of Nigeria -- later given UN mandates and pay elsewhere. Click here and here for French analyses of the three heres, and here again for a French memo on the intentions of Guillaume Soro, referring to another childhood friend of Gbagbo and his “ethnie Bete” -- Bete ethnicity.

After Inner City Press' publication on April 8 of the first installment in this series, which endeavors to use primary documents as background to recent action in Cote d'Ivoire -- as well as to question why a French diplomat, Romain Serman, arrested in New York for attempt purchase of cocaine and resisting arrest, has resurfaced as France's general consul in San Francisco -- Yousoufou Bamba, who has represented the forces of Alassane Ouattara at the UN for months, called Inner City Press.

Bamba, who has always been amiable and on the record, complained he thought Inner City Press is “being used,” adding that in Ivory Coast, these French documents are seen as helping Gbagbo. But question then the contents of the documents.

And on l'affaire Serman, France has not come forward with any explanation of re-sending Serman or of the other documents -- such explantions or comment would of course be published here -- and the US Mission to the UN has yet to answer questions it confirms it received from Inner City Press over the weekend, to know

as quickly as possible, whether the US was informed / aware of French diplomat Romain Serman's arrest in New York in 2006 for attempted purchase of cocaine and resisting arrest before Serman re-appeared in the US as France's current general consul in San Francisco.

See, e.g., http://www.innercitypress.com/nypd1serman.pdf

Separately, please comment on the applicability of US law and precedent to this case, l'affaire Serman.

This is something the US State Department should be able to answer. Watch this site.

Asked If Ban Ki-moon's Panel Met Sri Lanka AG, UN Said “That Is Simply Not the Case" -- Misleading Report?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 12 -- To prepare the UN report on accountability for presumptive war crimes in Sri Lanka, Secretary General Ban Ki-moon claimed in December and January that his panel could travel to Sri Lanka due to the “flexibility” of President Rahinda Rajapaksa, who along with his brothers is accused of the war crimes at issue.

Once Rajapaksa blocked the announced trip, talk turned to sending Sri Lankan officials including Attorney General Mohan Peiris to New York to meet with Ban and his Panel.

On February 23, Inner City Press photographed the beginning of the meeting between Ban and Mohan Peiris and others including another accused of war crimes, General Shavendra Silva. Click here for Inner City Press report on that meeting, which had been denied.

Before and after, Inner City Press asked if Ban's panel would meet with the Sri Lankan officials, but no answer was given.

On March 7, Inner City Press directly asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky about “a report in Sri Lanka quoting UN sources, saying that after a meeting between the Attorney General of Sri Lanka and Mr. Ban and other officials, there was another meeting with, in fact, the Secretary-General’s Panel. That, I just want you to either confirm or deny that.” Click here.

Nesirky replied that “the reporting over the weekend suggested that there was a secret meeting with the Secretary-General, and you know as well as I do, because you were there, that that is simply not the case. You were there taking pictures, so the reporting may be a little bit shaky.”

So, Inner City Press asked if there was a meeting of the Sri Lankan officials “with, in fact, the Secretary-General’s Panel” -- and Nesirky's answer was “that is simply not the case.”

Inner City Press published an article on March 7 that the UN was denying the occurrence of a meeting with Ban's Panel -- which is what Inner City Press asked Nesirky about, even as transcribed by the UN.

On March 28, after even a high South African official spoke of the Sri Lankans' meeting with Ban's Panel, Inner City Press again asked Nesirky

“the Vice-President of South Africa, in a formal address to and Q and A with the Parliament, said that he understands that the panel, Ban Ki-moon’s panel, met with the Sri Lankans here in March... did the panel meet that day, that mysterious day, or some other day in March with Sri Lankan officials?”

Nesirky did not answer that question, and after Inner City Press' next question, Nesirky left the briefing room. Since then he has tried to block Inner City Press from asking follow up questions, and has even told Inner City Press in advance that he won't answer its questions. Why, one wonders, go to a briefing where questions are responded to in this way?

On April 12, for the noon briefing at which Ban's receipt -- but not release to the public -- of the Sri Lanka Panel report was to be announced, Nesirky did not appear. He sent his deputy Farhan Haq to deny that he has been misleading:

Inner City Press: from this podium, I don’t know if it was only Martin or if it was you as well, it was said that there was no meeting in March when the Attorney General of Sri Lanka came, no meeting… there was a meeting with the Secretary-General, but no meeting with the Panel.

Acting Deputy Spokesperson Haq: No, no, Matthew; you’re mischaracterizing. He said that the Secretary-General met with the Panel. He said that he did not comment on what the Panel did.

Inner City Press: I saw the briefing. So are you confirming now that there was a meeting between the Attorney General…

Acting Deputy Spokesperson Haq: Matthew, I saw the exact same briefing. Like I said, the work of the Panel will be detailed in the report and you can see for yourself what they’ve done.

Inner City Press: But this is important, though. Can you say for yourself that the meeting took place? I mean, we can go over the transcript, but it seemed pretty clear that this meeting was not disclosed.

Acting Deputy Spokesperson Haq: Go over the transcript. I remember this. You tried to put some words into his mouth, in which you said he denied there was a meeting, and which he explicitly did not [deny].

This last shows at Ban's spokesman's office feels free to add words to its transcriptions. But even as it has transcribed it, the answers on Sri Lanka are troubling. And now what of the report? We will have more on this.

UN Western Sahara Report Delayed After Leak, TCC Postponed, France Against Human Rights Monitoring

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 12 -- A week after Inner City Press published the drafts of the UN's report on Western Sahara on which Morocco and France have been lobbying to exclude any human rights monitoring mechanism, the final report has still not been issued.

A meeting of the Troop Contributing Countries of the UN Mission MINURSO, scheduled for the morning of April 12, was canceled pending release of the report.

On the morning of April 12, Inner City Press asked Morocco's affable Permanent Representative Loulichki when the report would be published. “You know better than anyone,” he replied as he entered the Security Council chambers, in one room of which the Council was in closed door consultations.

On April 8, Inner City Press asked Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Martin Nesirky to respond to statements in Moroccan state media that the Secretariat had been lobbied at the highest level to condemn as “unfortunate” the publication of the draft report, calling it an “internal working document.”

Nesirky angrily declined comment, telling Inner City Press “you've made your point.” But it was a question: how can the UN call a document it has shown to Moroccan, allowing it to lobby, an “internal document”?

When UN Department of Peacekeeping Operations chief Alain Le Roy took questions on Cote d'Ivoire on April 8, Inner City Press asked him to describe DPKO's role in the Western Sahara report. We all make proposals, Le Roy said, but the Secretary General makes the final decision.

Is DPKO proposing not a human rights mechanism but to welcome Morocco admitting special rapporteurs? “I don't have to answer that,” Le Roy said.

DPKO sources on April 12 indicate that the report is still “blocked” between Le Roy and Secretary General Ban Ki-moon, leading to the postponement of the TCC meeting. Meanwhile the so-called “Group of Friends” has started negotiation the MINURSO resolution, under the chairmanship of the United States.

France is fighting hard, sources say, to keep human rights monitoring out of the resolution -- while citing human rights as the basis of its actions in Libya and Cote d'Ivoire. Watch this site.

After Fleeing NY Cocaine Charge, French Diplomat Serman Resurfaces in San Francisco as Sarkozy Consul : Press Questions

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, April 10 -- When French diplomat Romain Serman was arrested in Manhattan in 2006 for “attempting to purchase cocaine” and resisting arrest, he never faced trial or punishment.

As reflected in the New York Police Department arrest document Inner City Press has exclusively published, here, Serman immediately -- or after resisting arrest -- insisted to police that he was a diplomat with the French Mission to the United Nations.

Yet, after fleeing the US to escape this charge in 2006, Serman has re-appeared in the US representing France as its general consul in San Francisco. Several sources interviewed by Inner City Press say this is legally problematic, and may reflect a failure to disclose by France, negligence by the United States -- or both.

When Serman signed the arrest document, he added “Dip. Fr” after his name. And, sure enough, under then French Permanent Representative to the UN Jean-Marc de la Sabliere, Serman left the United States before any trial on the charge of purchasing cocaine.

Back in Paris, Serman was not punished, but rather continued to work for President Nicolas Sarkozy, on Africa and other issues.

In July 2010, Serman was sent back to the United States, to become France's General Consul in San Francisco.

Most recently Serman hosted Sarkozy minister Frederic Mitterrand during a visit to San Francisco where he met, among others, executive of Google, Amazon and Apple, and linked his visit to what he called the Facebook revolution in Egypt.

Click here for Serman's statements on his Twitter account, here for a video of Serman speaking in Salt Lake City about the education of children.

Six hours after Inner City Press published Serman's arrest document as part of an investigative story on France's policy and actions regarding its now war torn former colony the Ivory Coast / Cote d'Ivoire, Inner City Press was admonished that the publication, particularly of the arrest record, was gratuitous.

But several diplomatic sources, including in the US Mission to the UN, whom Inner City Press interviewed prior to publication said that Serman to re-appear in the United States as a French diplomat after he fled the country to escape charges of purchasing cocaine and resisting arrest is problematic.

It is illegal, one diplomat said, citing a provision of 8 U.S. Code Section 1101 regarding “a failure to appear before a court pursuant to a court order to answer to or dispose of a charge.”

In this case, the well placed source said, while Serman may have tacitly been allowed to flee the United States as a diplomat, he was “not supposed to come back in, as a diplomat.”

The source said that when he has been sent to other countries, it has always been vetted by the country to which he was sent, seeking “agreement,” a French diplomatic word meaning consent.

He noted that this comes at a time when the US is using visa law to block diplomatic status for some at the UN in New York.

This diplomat wondered whether this is a case in which France falsely did not disclose the previous charge against Serman when he was sent to San Francisco last year, or whether US authorities were “negligent” -- or both.

Inquiries are being made. Watch this site.

Leaked French Documents Show Cote d'Ivoire Strategy at UN of France on Liberia, Mali & Even San Francisco

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, April 8, updated -- With Cote d'Ivoire's defiant Laurent Gbagbo surrounded after French and UN military action in Abidjan's Cocody neighborhood, internal French government documents obtained by Inner City Press and published exclusively today paint a picture of France's communications with the UN Mission UNOCI, its analysis of the politics of Guillaume Soro, Liberia and the Malian press, even its recycling of a French diplomat arrested in New York as France's new general consul in San Francisco.

In the first document, France's Force Licorne (Unicorn) wrote to the Special Representative of the Secretary General about Gbagbo's import of heavy weapons. Click here to view. More recently, France is accused of violating the arms embargo by providing and facilitating weapons to the forces of Alassane Ouattara.

The second document is an internal French cable detailing the Financial Organization of the Rebellion, down to a “racket” of shaking down money for taxi licenses.

In the third document, France bemoans the failure of a visit of three African heads of state to Cote d'Ivoire, including Nigeria's Obasanjo and South Africa's Thabo Mbeki now active in Sudan, complaining that this situation can be prolonged until the international community decided to “impose a solution.”

In the fourth document, France analyzed and critiques South African policy toward Cote d'Ivoire and Gbagbo.

In the fifth document, France analyzes Liberia's foreign policy as pro-American. More recently, a purported interview of a Ouattara commander describing coordinating with a French citizen working with the UN Mission in Liberia has surfaced.

In the sixth document, France analyzes the “discrete attitude” of the Malian press.

In the largest set of documents published today -- there are more -- France details its work in the UN Security Council on resolutions concerning the UN mission UNOCI.

One of the French diplomats involved was Romain Serman, who was later arrested by the New York Police Department. See arrest sheet and signed statement, here. Then French Ambassador de la Sabliere, to “avoid a scandal,” sent Serman back to Paris.

But in 2010 he was re-assigned to the US, as general consul in San Francisco. And so it goes.

Update at 1pm, April 8: at the UN noon briefing, Inner City Press asked Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Martin Nesirky to describe how UNOCI has allowed Licorne to lobby it and attend its meetings, and if other countries have been allowed.

Nesirky said he would not comment on leaked documents, and also directed Inner City Press to ask the (French) chief of the UN Department of Peacekeeping Operations, Alain Le Roy. Watch this site.

Saturday, May 28, 2011

On Western Sahara, Draft Reports Published as UN Refuses to Take Morocco QOn Western Sahara, Draft Reports Published as UN Refuses to Take Morocco Q

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 6 -- For days, senior UN officials have been telling Inner City Press about aggressive lobbying by Morocco about the specifics of the forthcoming UN report on Western Sahara, a leaked copy of which Morocco was given from within the UN Secretariat.

Inner City Press on April 4 wrote about the topic -- having also obtained a copy from diplomatic sources -- and on April 6 repeatedly told Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Martin Nesirky that it wanted to ask a Western Sahara question at that day's noon briefing.

“I have a question on Western Sahara,” Inner City Press said, ceding first to another journalist on Haiti. But Nesirky then declared without explanation he would take only one more question, on another topic. Inner City Press repeated, “I have a question on Western Sahara.” But Nesikry stood up, declaring his briefing over. Nor does he respond to or even acknowledge the majority of e-mailed Press questions.

Diplomatic sources tell Inner City Press that Ban's final, post-lobbying report is due out. And so, Inner City Press now published a scanned version of the draft to obtained, both with Paragraph 119 as urged by Morocco and a proposal by the Office for the High Commissioner on Human Rights, which proposes a human rights mechanism for the UN's MINURSO mission.

Click here and here.

Even those close to Ban say that the level of pressure -- which Ban has apparently given into -- was extreme. At the same time, Ban is closely linked with France in military action in Cote d'Ivoire.

A day after French foreign minister Alain Juppe said that UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon agrees that Laurent Gbagbo must sign a letter ceding power to Alassane Ouattara, Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky if that is, in fact, Ban's position.

“I don't speak for the French Foreign Minister,” Nesirky said.

“But you do speak for the Secretary General,” Inner City Press asked. Is it Ban's position or not?

Nesirky would not answer, saying he would not characterize the Secretary General's communications with Juppe. Then he refused repeated requests that he answer a question about Western Sahara.

Thus does the UN thumbs its nose at transparency and lose credibility, by being used by France and Morocco, not only in Cote d'Ivoire but Western Sahara too. Watch this site.

At NYU, Galbraith's Kurdish Oil & Abrams' Contra Conviction Unmentioned

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 5 -- With Elliot Abrams slated to debate Peter Galbraith Tuesday on whether America's global wings should be clipped, moderated by ABC's John Donvan for the Intelligence Squared series, certain basic facts were expected to come out.

Elliot Abrams was found guilty -- and later pardoned -- for misleading Congress about Iran - Contra. More recently, Peter Galbraith's financial interest in oil in northern Iraq's Kurdistan region was exposed by the Norwegian and then US press. (Full disclosure: Inner City Press wrote about it, on this site.)

But neither fact was mentioned even when Galbraith, hiding in plain sight, asked why the US hadn't just left Kurdistan alone, since “it was working.” For him, clearly.

This is what happens when you set up a debate between people with similar Achiles Heels. With Mutually Assured Destruction, each debater clips his wings. But where was the moderator? Where was this Intelligence, Squared?

The program for the event, held in NYU's Skirball Center, listed among “Bright” donors Mort Zuckmerman, and among advisors Fareed Zakaria. So where was the journalistic impulse?

Donvan asked the audience for faux applause for rebroadcast on Bloomberg television. Eliot Cohen said his non-clipping side should win because on the other wise would be Kim Jong-il and Hugo Chavez. Lawrence Korb played the churlish accountable to Galbraith's oil man feint. Ultimately the two Elliots won. Truth and full disclosure, however, were each ill served.

All four panelists said they supported US involvement in Libya, though the wing clippers said they agreed that no ground troops should be used. But what about arming the rebels, and Obama (and Cameron's) position that they can, despite the arms embargo in UN Security Council Resolution 1970, even as modified by Resolution 1973? America's wings clipped, indeed....