Tuesday, May 19, 2009

At UN, Russia's Day Ranges from Georgia to Espresso, N. Korea Praise, No Sri Lanka

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unsc2ministerial051109.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 11 -- Russia' foreign minister Sergey Lavrov met Monday morning with Secretary General Ban Ki-moon, then in the afternoon with the foreign ministers of Turkey and Austria. In between he chaired the Security Council's meeting on the Middle East and held a short press conference at which he took only seven questions. One was on Sri Lanka: why has Russia fought to keep the carnage there off the Council's formal agenda? Lavrov answered that Russia is of course concerned as civilian casualties -- but only on in Sri Lanka, also Afghanistan and now Pakistan's Swat Valley. He said that civilian casualties should not be politicized.

Some remember back in August, when Russia called the casualties of Georgia in South Ossetia to be victims of war crimes. There was a Security Council meeting, requested by Russia, which began at 1 a.m.. Inner City Press was present and covered it. But in the face of over 400 civilians deaths over the weekend in Sri Lanka, not a single Council meeting. In another context on Monday, Lavrov decried the use of violence to solve political problems.

Lavrov was accompanied by the Russian Mission's previously spokeswoman, Maria Zarakhova. Before an open microphone, she said that they had recently visited North Korea. It is going better there, she said. The people have cell phones and she'd even seen a Hummer vehicle. That's why the last round of sanctions targeted luxury goods, she said. There improvements are less visible to those seeking to flee into China.

Monday after the Council's lunch, the Turkish delegation went into the Security Council. Lavrov followed, telling a security officer that “they have good coffee, please bring two cups of espresso, one for me and one for the Turkish minister.” A well known Arab League staffer, who will leave unnamed for now, is known to have fought to keep good coffee in the Council, when Lavrov was Russia's Ambassador. Using an espresso machine donated by Mexico, he ordered roasted beans, wholesale from Chicago. Others speak of the small bar by the Council chamber, always open during Lavrov's time, and how he saved the job of the bartender. Those were the days, many people say. Not Tamils, at least not recently.

Throughout Monday, the highest ranking Russian UN official in New York, Dmitri Titov, squired Lavrov around. First to the elevator up to meet with Ban Ki-moon. (Titov's boss Alain Le Roy made a point that it was him, and not Titov, who attended the meeting with Ban.) Then Titov went in and out of the Council, during Lavrov's bilateral meetings, at 2:52 and 3:14 p.m.. Finally, the UN Secretary provided a corrected read-out of the morning's meeting, which we run in corrected form:

Subject: Your question at noon (SG-Lavrov readout)

To: Inner City Press

From: UN Spokesperson - Do Not Reply/NY/UNO

Date: 05/11/2009

The Secretary-General (SG) met with the Foreign Minister of the Russian Federation this morning and had a constructive meeting. They spoke about the Middle East, the forthcoming SG's debate to the Security Council on [the Middle East], the SG's fourteenth report on the Mission in Georgia (UNOMIG), the Democratic People's Republic of Korea, and Kosovo.

One wag joked that Russia, for its month atop the Council, wanted an issue which does not directly impact its interests. It could have made Georgia the topic, but time is on its side. The trend is the opposite on Kosovo but nothing, it seems, can stop that. And so, the Middle East, and a Presidential Statement which an OIC Ambassador told Inner City Press is very weak, “it would have been better to pass nothing, it is intended to publicize a Moscow event that will never happen." We'll see.

At 3:37 p.m., with an air kiss from Maria Zarakhova and a cursory wave from Lavrov, they were gone, headed back to Moscow. From Russia with love...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsc2ministerial051109.html

At UN, Kouchner Speaks On Sri Lanka to Select Reporters, IMF and Tariff Views Not Known

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un2may4srilanka051109.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 11, updated -- In the face of the weekend's bloodbath on the beach in Sri Lanka, the UN Security Council had its more throw-away meeting yet on the topic, not even an informal Council session, without members such as China and Russia, the Council's president this month. In April, the Council met in the UN basement in informal interactive sessions, with all 15 members present and a common statement at the end. Monday, only some members went up to a meeting room booked at the last minute on the UN”s 33rd floor.

The basement “wasn't available,” a Permanent Five member's spokesperson told Inner City Press. No list of the NGOs participating was available. Inner City Press asked U.S. Ambassador Susan Rice about Sri Lanka. She said she would be attending the meeting. Inner City Press asked if she would speak publicly on the topic after the meeting. Maybe, was the answer. As of 3 p.m., it had not happened.

After the meeting, the foreign ministers of France, the UK and Austria came down to the microphone in front of the Council. Inner City Press directed a question at France's Bernard Kouchner, whether he would use the expiration of the European Union's favorable tariff treatment for Sri Lankan textiles, the so-called GSP Plus, as a way to try to protect civilians from government bombing as took place over the weekend.

The answer came from the UK's Miliband, that “Sri Lanka does not want to isolate itself from the international community... Sri Lanka depends to some extent on trade with the European Union [so] the human rights aspects of the discussion are taken seriously, by the European Commission at this stage.” Only then did Kouchner answer, that “Benita Ferrero-Waldner has been involved.”

After the stakeout was over, Kouchner was spirited to one side of the stakeout, and security officers let some reporters through and not others.

Inner City Press was blocked, physically, by French Ambassador Jean-Maurice Ripert. “You just had him,” Ripert said. “He can talk to the French press, can't he?” Inner City Press nodded. Behind Ripert were numerous non-French reporters and publications, from New York, London, Tokyo and elsewhere. Some Ripert had reached into the crowd and pulled in. “I don't want you to use that,” Ripert insisted, pointing at the recorder Inner City Press was holding. “We work well, right?”

Kouchner was heard to say, Devant nous, des milliers -- “right in front of us, thousands,” presumably meaning civilians, killed on or near the beaches of north east Sri Lanka. At this same location, Ripert had told the Press that while the American want to play with the IMF loan, France wants to stop the violence. That hasn't worked. Now the UK is on record tying the IMF loan to the conflict, and speaking about the EU tariffs. And France? Watch this space: when we are informed of France's views, they will be published on this site. The French mission suggests http://www.franceonu.org/spip.php?article3903

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un2may4srilanka051109.html

At UN, UK's Miliband Decries Sri Lankan Bloodbath, IMF Loan Linked, No Resolution

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un2may3srilanka051109.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 11, updated -- After a weekend of bombing and “bloodbath” in Sri Lanka, the first official to speak out at the UN in New York was UK minister David Miliband. He stopped to speak to the Press on his way into the UN Security Council's meeting on the Middle East. He said he has arranged to speak with Sri Lanka's Foreign Minister Rohitha Bogollagama later in the day. Inner City Press asked if the UK will be proposing a Security Council resolution on Sri Lanka, and for the UK's position on Sri Lanka's application to the International Monetary Fund for a $1.9 billion loan.

“As you know, the issue has not yet been allowed onto the formal UN Security Council agenda. That's why we'll be having a range of meetings on the side of the formal meeting on the Middle East... merits the attention of the UN at all levels. The Secretary General has already sent his rep to Sri Lanka, the lack of access for the UN and its agencies remains a major concern.”

Inner City Press twice followed up on the IMF loan question. Video here.

Pausing as he walked away from the microphone, Miliband returned and said, “sorry, in respect to the IMF, I think you'll find that the issue is not coming up at the IMF today...it's essential that any govt is able to show that it will use any imf money in a responsible and appropriate way, and as I explained in the House of Commons last week, I don't that that's here the case.”

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un2may3srilanka051109.html

At UN, Bland Draft and Blood on Beach, Ministers Squired by Staff to Speak

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unsc1ministerial051109.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 11, updated -- Amidst carnage in Sri Lanka, foreign ministers meet Monday at the UN in New York on a bland Presidential Statement on the Middle East. As the text was negotiated last week, references to settlements and terrorism were dropped from the draft, the “blue” version of which Inner City Press is putting online here. The 15 member states will speak, and then Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov will hold a press conference at 12:30.

Lavrov emerged at 9:40 from the Security Council accompanied by the highest Russian UN official in New York, Dmitri Titov. They entered an elevator to go meet with Secretary General Ban Ki-moon. Inner City Press' reporting in recent weeks finds that Lavrov has twice urged Ban to hire more Russian, particularly in top envoy posts like the Niger mission of Robert Fowler, which ended in kidnapping and prisoner swap.

To some, the open involvement of UN official like Titov in the visit to the UN of a dignitary of “his” country is questionable. It would be like Sir John Holmes, the UN's top humanitarian, openly squiring UK minister David Miliband around, or top peacekeeper Alain Le Roy accompanying Bernard Kouchner. A Security Council staffer told Inner City Press that with Le Roy and Susana Malcorra out of town, Titov was by coincidence the peacekeeping Officer in Charge. Did he go up to speak of Georgia?

The foreign ministers attending, in the order they will speak, include Austria's Michael Spindelegger, Burkina Faso's Bedouma Alain Yoda, Turkey's Ahmet Davutoglu, France's Bernard Kouchner, Mexico's Patricia Espinosa Cantellana, the UK's David Miliband, Costa Rica's Bruno Stagno and Russia's Sergey Lavrov.

Kouchner swept up the escalator with Jean-Maurice Ripert; Miliband with John Sawers. Both are slated to speak at 1 p.m. about the situation in Sri Lanka, where hundreds were killed over the weekend. Watch this space.

Update of 10:26 a.m. -- walking into the Security Council at 10:25 was Titov's boss, Alain Le Roy. Inner City Press asked him, staff said you were away, and Titov standing in for you. No, Le Roy said, Titov was not in the meeting with Ban. So he squired Lavrov to and into the elevator?

Update of 11:41 a.m. -- click here for Sri Lanka story, Inner City Press' questions to UK's Miliband. On the Middle East, a prominent OIC Ambassador told Inner City Press that Russia's PRST is very weak, it would have been better to pass nothing, it is intended to publicize a Moscow event "that will never happen."

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsc1ministerial051109.html

Amid Death in Sri Lanka, UN Wedding in New York, Ban's Visit Delay Questioned

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un2may2srilanka051109.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 11 -- As in Sri Lanka Saturday bombs rained down on the supposed Safe Zone, in New York UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon prepared to celebrate the wedding of his son, Ban Woo-hyun. The ceremony was kept secret. South Korean media quoted an unnamed Ban aide that “Ban may have thought that an ostentatious wedding party for his son would be inappropriate.”

Well, yes. Earlier in the week, in the run-up to what even the UN had predicted as a “bloodbath on the beach” in Northern Sri Lanka, Ban had been invited to visit the country. His spokesperson Michele Montas said that if Ban thought it would save civilian lives, he would go. Inner City Press, having been told by well-placed Security Council sources that Ban would not be going in the coming days for scheduling reasons, inquired into this at two separate UN noon briefings and otherwise.

“Scheduling is a separate matter,” Associate Spokesperson Farhan Haq insisted. A senior Ban political adviser told Inner City Press on the night of May 8 that, while he had been told to stop speaking to the Press, Ban would go if he thought it would save “even a single life.”

The Korea Herald also quoted the anonymous aide that Mr. Ban “could also have been burdened by a frequent mentioning of him as one of South Korea's next presidential candidates." A Security Council diplomat, speaking Monday morning as the UN confirmed at least 400 civilians killed over the weekend including over 100 children, told Inner City Press that perhaps it would be good for the UN for Ban to move on.

When Inner City Press pointed out that weddings like this are planned months in advance and are hard to reschedule, the diplomat countered that Ban never should have claimed he would go if it would save a life.

“Had he gone this weekend, the government wouldn't have bombed so freely,” the diplomat said, going on to wonder aloud if the Sri Lankan government may have known of the Bans quiet wedding plans.

Last month, as the pace of civilian death spiked up, Ban sent his titular chief of staff Vijay Nambiar to Colombo, ostensibly to request a “humanitarian pause.” Neither Ban nor Nambiar, who has yet to speak to the Press, have called for a cease-fire, nor have they explained why not.

While Ban claimed that Nambiar had won a commitment from the government to allow a UN humanitarian assessment team into the conflict zone, its members have yet to be named, much less be allowed anywhere near the zone of death.

At the time, many questioned the wisdom of sending Nambiar, the highest ranking Indian in the UN system, as the envoy to Sri Lanka. The Sri Lankan government has spoken of extraditing the founder of the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam to India, to stand charges for the assassination of Rajiv Gandhi in the 1990s.

Recently Vijay Nambiar's brother Satish, a former Indian general and consultant to the Sri Lankan government, was quoted on the Sri Lankan military's web page praising the Army's and its commander's conduct of the war in the north, despite all the civilians killed. It is, the diplomat said bitterly, all a family affair.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un2may2srilanka051109.html

Children in Myanmar Are Political Football, UNICEF Has No Answer, Rohingya Ignored

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/caac1myanmar051009.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 10, updated May 11 -- While Myanmar wants off the UN's children and armed conflict list and the UN strangely praises them, three non-governmental organizations last week said that big problems remain, and spoke of Thai and Myanmar pressure on UNICEF to stay off of their border. Inner City Press asked about this pressure, and passed on to UNICEF the quote. Video here, from Minute 25:35.

UNICEF's spokesman on May 6 said he would get an answer. The next day, he said that "both the Thai and Myanmar reps are en route from a meeting and so I have no answers yet but hope to by tomorrow. Just wanted you to know we have not forgotten your questions."

Five days later, there is nothing. Children are the future, but in terms of explaining how it deals with pressure from repressive governments like Myanmar's, UNICEF is no better than its UN brethren.

This is a problem or conundrum of the UN. Charged with defending children, it has to work with governments. So even the biggest recruiter of child soldiers in the world, Myanmar, gets treated with respect. The UN's expert on the problem praised the government last week. UNICEF promises a response, but provided none.

The NGOs were better. Watchlist had the courage to criticize UNICEF. Human Rights Watch, asked for its position on elections, promises to revert to Inner City Press with an answer and did, that the 2010 elections have no promise of effecting real democratic change inside Burma. This process is a clearly orchestrated process to ensure continued military rule with a civilian facade, the 2008 constitution ensures that. There is no possibility under present conditions that these elections can promise a more open Burma, or be in any measure a free expression of what people inside Burma want.

Still, and this is telling, neither group had an answer on the problem of Rohingya, the multiply oppressed Muslims of Myanmar. The UN's envoy Ibrahim Gambari had said it is beyond his mandate. Watch List said, we can get that (info) to you, but has not followed up. Video here, from Minute 30:28. A group that is ignored not only by the UN, but even NGOs, is suffering indeed. We will continue on this issue -- watch this site.

Update of May 11 -- after the publication of the article above, five days after the critique was made and question asked, the following arrived from UNICEF, which we publish in full:

Subj: Answer
From: UNICEF
To: Inner City Press
Sent: 5/11/2009

I have received a response from my colleagues in Myanmar, and they advise that UNICEF Myanmar Field Offices covers all parts of the country including the border area. Children from the border area included in the 1612 reporting as well as ILO mechanism to monitor forced labour which includes underage recruitment. The present UNICEF coverage in Myanmar is considered adequate and there is no immediate plan to beef up presence.

That's not what Watchlist on Children and Armed Conflict and Human Rights Watch say...

Update of May 11, 6 p.m. -- while Watchlist answered the questions in real-time, it has provided the appreciated information below about the Rohingya, in response to the article above:

Subj: Follow up from Watchlist on Children and Armed Conflict
From: watchlist.org
To: Inner City Press
Sent: 5/11/2009 5:13:29 P.M. Eastern Standard Time

Thank you for covering the launch of our report and sorry for not getting back earlier to you on the question of the Rohingya... In general, as we clarify in our methodology (p. ii), our report mainly focuses on the impact of armed conflict on children in Myanmar following our core mandate. In contrast, the situation of the Rohingya is mainly one of discrimination and neglect as a result of exclusion and discrimination by the Myanmar authorities on the basis of their ethnicity and religion. The Rohingya live under appalling circumstances as the Myanmar authorities deny them citizenship in their own country.

To alert to the dire needs of the Rohingya, we also further elaborated on their situation in our chapter on Refugees (p. 21):

Refugees in Bangladesh

Ethnic discrimination and religious persecution has caused 250,000 Muslim Rohingya to flee to Bangladesh since the early 1990s. Since 1982, the ruling authorities in Myanmar have refused to accept the Rohingya as Burmese citizens, turning them into stateless people in their own country, according to RI, “Rohingya: Discrimination in Burma and Denial of Rights in Bangladesh,” July 21, 2006. [The 1982 Myanmar Citizenship Law has had the effect of rendering the Rohingya stateless. Their status as citizens had already been downgraded under the 1974 Constitution.] Many are denied basic rights to freely move, work or marry without an official permission. At the same time, SPDC officials have exploited refugees for forced labor during the day and forced sentry duty at night without any form of compensation, according to RI.

While most of the Rohingya refugees in Bangladesh have been forcibly repatriated to Myanmar, many returned to Bangladesh because the situation in Myanmar was not safe for them. Approximately 26,300 Rohingyas still live in two camps in the southern Cox’s Bazar area, according to the USCRI, World Refugee Survey 2008 – Bangladesh, June 19, 2008. An additional 100,000 to 200,000 live as unregistered refugees outside the camp areas, according to the same source. Since 2006, the Government of Bangladesh has allowed UNHCR to construct new shelters for refugees in both camps and allow other UN agencies and NGOs to run programs in the refugee camps. In addition, a very small number of Rohingya refugees have been able to resettle to a third country.

We will continue to follow these issues.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/caac1myanmar051009.html

Saturday, May 9, 2009

On Sri Lanka, UN Split on Visit by Ban, Russia Lends an Ear, Monday Not Council

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1may8srilanka050809.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 8 -- On whether UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon should go to visit Sri Lanka, "the House is quite divided," a senior Ban adviser told Inner City Press late on May 8. He said many think that a Ban visit would be "most useful after the dust has settled," apparently referring to a final assault by the Sri Lanka military. Ban's office has spoken with, among others, British Tamils and urged them to call for the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam to let out all civilians who want to leave. "They just can't do it," the Ban adviser said.

Inner City Press pointed out that if Ban waits to go until after the final assault, it might become a tour of a dead zone. The adviser agreed, saying, "people will be locked in concentration camps for five years." Some say that if the UN knows that the camps they are funding are concentration camps, perhaps a change is needed. They say Ban should go now, taking the Press, and demand entry into the conflict zone.

The UN adviser mused that the LTTE leader may already have escaped. It would be good if he died, the adviser said, "there's a list of leaders who could emerge." He said the British Tamils were pushing for an airdrop of food and supplies into the conflict zone; the UN, he said, cannot act like a cowboy.

Human rights groups, meanwhile, briefed the Russian mission on Friday. Russia's deputy permanent representative, they said, was surprisingly interested in hearing arguments about why the carnage in northern Sri Lanka is a threat to international peace and security, the technical standard for UN Security Council involvement. Just because it's an island, the human rights groups argued, and people die trying to leave on ships, doesn't mean it's not a threat. The groups have yet to meet with China. And so it goes at the UN.

Footnote: there was a Tamil protest Friday before Japan's mission to the UN. "Shame on Japan," people chanted. Envoy Yosushi Akashi assured the Sri Lankan government of continued support. Monday's session on Sri Lanka at the UN is "not even a Council meeting," Russia's Vitaly Churkin told the Press. It will probably be in the basement. New lows are hit every day.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1may8srilanka050809.html

At UN, Obama's Magic Rice on the Speakers List, Sri Lanka Below the Basement

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/unsc1obama050809.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 8 -- The foreign ministers of eight of the UN Security Council's fifteen members are heading to New York for a May 11 meeting about the Middle East. The host country is not sending Hilary Clinton. The Council's List of Speakers, leaked on May 8 to Inner City Press, lists as the eighth speaker “Susan E. Rice, Permanent Representative of the United States of America and Member of President Obama's Cabinet.” There is nowhere near this level of detail, including a President's name, for any other speaker. Some call it the magic of Obama.

The foreign ministers attending, in the order they will speak, include Austria's Michael Spindelegger, Burkina Faso's Bedouma Alain Yoda, Turkey's Ahmet Davutoglu, France's Bernard Kouchner, Mexico's Patricia Espinosa Cantellana, the UK's David Miliband, Costa Rica's Bruno Stagno and Russia's Sergey Lavrov.

Advisers to Security General Ban Ki-moon tell Inner City Press that Mr. Lavrov has told Ban that Russians should be given more top jobs in the UN, and has asked how, for example, foreign Canadian diplomat Robert Fowler was named special envoy to Niger, where his kidnapping resulted, according to those responsible, in the release of Al Qaeda in the Islamic Magreb.

Mexico's Patricia Espinosa, when last at the Council to chair Mexico's thematic debate, skipped out on a scheduled stakeout and press conference, wanting to avoid questions about what was then called the Swine Flu. Ministers Kouchner and Miliband are convening a meeting about Sri Lanka, but not a Security Council meeting, not even an “informal interactive dialogue” such as took place in April.

As Russia's Vitaly Churkin, the Council president for May, left the chamber Friday afternoon, Inner City Press asked about Monday's event on Sri Lanka. It's not a Council meeting, Amb. Churkin said. There might be NGOs there.

Given that over 7,000 civilians have been killed this year in Northern Sri Lanka, some wonder about how Obama's principles, including those of his anti-war crimes adviser Samantha Power, are being applied. Susan Rice will represent the US on the Council's trip next week to Africa including the Congo, where evidence emerged Friday that the UN is working with indicted war criminal Bosco Ntaganda, click here for that litmus test.

The document being negotiated for adoption on May 11 has, through time, omitted references both to Israeli settlements and to terrorism. Late Friday afternoon, after a Council meeting on Chad and Sudan, Inner City Press asked U.S. Deputy Permanent Representative Alejandro Wolff, exiting a meeting with Russia's Churkin, how it was coming on Monday's statement. “Moving... we're still not there,” Amb. Wolff answered. They better hurry up.

Footnote: while some UN proponents grumble that not only Barack Obama, but now Michele Obama when she came to New York have not set foot in the UN, Michele Obama (or “FLOTUS” in pool parlance) did visit the US Mission. From the pool report:

“Her mission, she says, is to put a spotlight on the nation's employees who may feel underappreciated. 40 long-time U.N. employees sat to the left of the stage. These included Ivan Ferber who has worked at the U.S. Mission to the U.N. for 47 years... Other honored employees included: Bruce Rashkow who has worked at the USUN for 38 years.”

Raskkow is the US' budget expert. Some wonder if his approach is consistent with the pronouncements of the Obama administration. We'll see.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/unsc1obama050809.html

At UN, Sudan Accuses France of Drafting Chadian Letter, Origin of Rebels Disputed

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/chad1sudan050809.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 8 -- As rebels seek to overthrown Chadian President Deby, who himself took power by force, Chad's Ambassador to the UN Ahmad Allam-mi wrote a letter to the Security Council requesting an emergency meeting. Friday morning as the meeting began, Sudan's Ambassador to the UN told the Press that Chad's letter was “written in the French mission.” Inner City Press asked France's Jean-Maurice Ripert for his response to the charge. “I don't even answer,” Ripert said. “I think this is an insult to the Chadian government.” Video here, from Minute 4:40.

Inside the Council, France was pushing to include in the draft Presidential Statement a line that the rebels originated from inside Sudan. On the other side, Sudan's supporters were saying this should not be included. Sudan's Ambassador asked the Press, “What about Omdurman?” He was referring to the Justice and Equality Movement's drive last year from Chad all the way to the suburbs of Khartoum.

Friday at noon, the meeting broke up, to be continued at 3 o'clock. Over a lunch with selected journalists, the French mission said that the afternoon meeting might only take place if “the experts” worked out a compromise.

But the bells rang and the meeting started Friday afternoon. Some predicted it extending to Saturday.

Monday in the Council, Russia's center piece event of the month is slated, a ministerial meeting on the Middle East. They have managed to push back discussions of the UN's report on Gaza until Tuesday, and to confine discussion of the carnage in Sri Lanka to outside the Council chamber, most likely in the basement.

The round and round fighting between Chad and The Sudan is on the Council's agenda, and can therefore give rise to day long meetings about a single phrase. We will continue to follow these issues -- watch this space.

Update of 3:51 p.m. -- a deputy Ambassador, exiting the Council, tells Inner City Press "they are going to say the rebels came from 'outside' of Chad." Another compromise...

Update of 4:14 p.m. -- a five minute break has been taken, and an old draft given to the press, with the phrase “Chadian armed groups [receiving support and coming from the other side of the border, in Sudan]. But that was “rev 3;” inside, they are already up to “Rev. 5.” The Libyans, it's said, can't go further than their instructions, and their instructors are in South Africa for the Jacob Zuma festivities. Now there's talk of Monday...

Update of 5:20 p.m. -- it's done, the Council agreed on a compromise statement “condemn[ing] the renewed military incursions in eastern Chad of Chadian armed groups, coming from outside.” Coming from where? So far, no one has come to the stakeout to explain. US Deputy Permanent Representative Alejandro Wolff has done in to speak with Russia's Vitaly Churkin, this month's Council president, presumably about the Monday meeting on the Middle East.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/chad1sudan050809.html

Sri Lanka and Responsibility to Protect Arise in UN, Would Ban Take to Council under Article 99?

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1may7srilanka050809.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 8 -- With bombs dropping on civilians in Northern Sri Lanka and UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon still mulling the government's invitation to visit, the talk at the UN has turned to the Responsibility to Protect. On May 6 at a reception attended by Ban Ki-moon and Ed Luck, his special adviser on R2P, as it known, Inner City Press asked Luck how the concept would apply to Sri Lanka. "To both sides," Luck answered.

He noted that R2P was formally cited during Kofi Annan's mediation in Kenya. Inner City Press asked what he thought of the appointment of former Indian Ambassador Nirupam Sen as the adviser to the President of the General Assembly on R2P. While diplomatically praising Sen, Luck remarked that India was the "last country to come aboard" on the R2P Outcome Document in 2005.

In May 7, Inner City Press asked Nirupam Sen for his views on R2P, specifically regarding Sri Lanka. While refusing to answer on Sri Lanka, Sen insisted first the India wasn't the last to join consensus in 2005, then that it had only held out to make the points of "U.S. civil society groups." Sen said that India's position had been that R2P should only be a UN doctrine if the use of the Security Council veto by five countries were repealed, to "eliminate the strategic imperatives of any great power." Video here, from Minute 41:42.

Ironically, it is China's and to some degree Russia's veto threats which have kept the carnage in Sri Lanka off of the Council's formal agenda, and keep the Council "dialogues" on the topic confined to the basement.

Inner City Press asked asked Sen about Sri Lanka's application to the International Monetary Fund for a $1.9 billion loan, and whether the bloodshed and internment camps in the North should be considered. Sen said that "anything the IMF does to reduce and tone down conditionality is a step in the right direction," toward "mitigating humanitarian impact." But what if the loan is used to involuntarily relocate and detain people? The IMF wouldn't do that, Sen implied. But wouldn't they?

On May 8, Inner City Press asked a senior Ban adviser about Sri Lanka's invitation. I don't think the Secretary General should go, the adviser replied. The government could just use it. He suggested that, instead, Ban should invoke Article 99 of the UN Charter and push to put Sri Lanka on the Council's agenda, in the name of R2P. The draft outcome document gives the Secretary General that role, Ban's adviser said. Inner City Press asked Ban's Deputy Spokesperson about this an hour later, but she said she had nothing to add to what Ban had said on May 5.

Ban's Deputy Spokesperson announced on Friday an upcoming trip by Ban, not to Sri Lanka but Manama, Bahrain. To many these seem to be strange priorities.

Inner City Press asked French Ambassador Jean-Maurice Ripert if his foreign minister Bernard Kouchner, another major player in R2P, is requesting a Security Council session on May 11, when he and his UK counter-part David Miliband will be in New York. Ripert said, "On the side of the meeting on the Middle East... we are organizing with UK a meeting... we are working on the exact form." Video here, from Minute 10:53.

Footnote 1: According to NGO sources, Ambassador Ripert in a recent meeting with them said, of Sri Lanka's Army, "their war is our war," which the NGOs took to mean the "war on terror." Some wondered if this didn't just give a green light to the Sri Lankan Army. We'll see: we will report on this site any response received, on France's view of Sri Lanka (or in advance of the Council's trip to Africa next week of MONUC in the Congo appearing in a memo in French to work with a war criminal.)

Footnote 2: In what could be called an R2P cat fight, Nirupan Sen's criticism of Ban's adviser Ed Luck went further, when Sen said the Fifth (Budget) Committee was right to refuse to confirm him in his post, and to keep him on "a dollar a year." Inner City Press asked Luck about the dollar, and if he has a UN phone number. Of the latter, Luck said he still doesn't, but that at the UN there are many people with phones but the Secretary General doesn't pick up at the other end. And if the call came from the Vanni conflict zone, would Mr. Ban pick up?

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1may7srilanka050809.html

UN Hides As War Criminal Bosco Surfaces in April 4 Congolese Army Minutes

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1bosco050809.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 7, updated -- When it comes to working with war criminals, the UN Mission in the Democratic Republic of the Congo is willing and even wants to be deceived. Bosco Ntaganda, indicted by the International Criminal Court, appears in minutes of an April 4 meeting of the Congolese Army, known by its French acronym FARDC.

Four days later, the head of the MONUC mission, Alan Doss, received a Daily Report of “unconfirmed rumours of Bosco Ntaganda's designation as Deputy Commander of Operation Kimia II,” to which MONUC provided assistance. Click here to view the April 8, 2009 Daily Report.

What the UN did next is to ask the FARDC to tell them that Bosco was not a deputy commander. The UN has spend billions of dollars in the Congo, largely to the benefit of current president Joseph Kabila. His FARDC told the UN want they wanted to hear. But no explanation of the April 4 FARDC minutes, reproduced below, has been provided.

A UN official involved in preparing MONUC's response, below, told Inner City Press that as long as Doss received assurances from FARDC, it doesn't matter what the leaked minutes show, or even if they are true: the UN”s hands are clean. These dubious assertions should be a topic of the UN Security Council's African trip later this month, along with proposals to send Bosco Ntanganda's previous boss, Laurent Nkunda, from Rwanda into exile in a country other than the DRC.

On April 9, the day after Doss had gotten the Daily Report about Bosco's involvement in the FARDC's Operation Kimia II, Inner City Press asked Doss to confirm that MONUC had earlier received a request to help arrest Bosco. Doss confirmed that, among other things (click here for that story, and here for the request to MONUC about Bosco, and Doss' predessessor William Lacy Swing's response.) Doss said the request "has not been renewed," adding that MONUC will not work with Bosco. But see below.

On April 29, Inner City Press asked UN Associate Spokesman Farhan Haq

Inner City Press: do you have a response to these reports that Bosco, the ICC indictee for war crimes, was described as a deputy coordinator in the Congolese Army action against the FDLR, and also, therefore, calling into question the UN statement that it doesn’t work with indicted war criminals.

Associate Spokesperson: Yes, we’re aware of those reports. At the same time, the UN Mission in the DRC, MONUC, has not seen the documents that were referred to in the media reports that allegedly showed that Jean Bosco Ntaganda was part of the joint operation. Actually, on the contrary, the DRC authorities have shown MONUC relevant documents defining the operation’s command structure, which does not make any mention of Mr. Ntaganda. MONUC has clearly stated that it will not conduct or support joint operations in which Jean Bosco Ntaganda plays a part. This has been communicated directly to the DRC Minister of Defence and the Chief of the Defence Staff, who in turn have assured MONUC that Mr. Ntanganda is not a part of any joint operation’s command structure. MONUC leadership continues to engage with our Congolese interlocutors on this matter.

Inner City Press: Even when you actually see this document, what will the UN do if it turns out he was the deputy commander of that operation?

Associate Spokesperson: Well, as I just said, we continue to engage with our Congolese interlocutors. But I’ve told you exactly the precise assurances that we’ve been given by the Government of the DRC on this. And as for the hypothetical question, we’ll cross that bridge if that is a reality.

Well, now it is a reality. The April 4 FARDC minutes, obtained by Inner City Press, show in paragraph (d) Bosco Ntaganda taking the floor, and described him as deputy commander:

REPUBLIQUE DEMOCRATIQUE DU CONGO

FORCES ARMEES

OPERATION KIMIA II

COORDINATION

RAPPORT DE LA REUNION TENUE PAR LE COORD DE L’ OPS KIMIA II

EN DATE DU 04/04/2009

1. Ordre du jour :

a) Remerciements

b) Message du Comd Suprême

c) Directives du Coord des Ops

d) Divers.

2. Développement

a. Le Coord a remercié le Pers de l’EM de l’accueil lui réservé lors de

son arrivée et de l’enthousiasme manifesté à son endroit lors de la remise

et reprise avec le ChefEM FT ce 03 Avril 2009.

b. Message du Comd Suprême

Le Coord a transmis à l’assistance les directives du Comd Suprême sur le profil que doivent afficher les Mil des FARDC notamment ceux Å“uvrant dans les provinces du NORD et du SUD KIVU.

- Eviter tout esprit rétrograde ; NE PAS revenir aux mêmes méfaits qui

provoquent souvent les rebellions.

- Travailler plus pour l’intérêt de la population et ce défi doit à tout

prix être relevé ; Ainsi nous devons nous atteler à gagner la confiance de

la Pop à laquelle nous devons beaucoup de respect. A ce sujet, le Comd

Suprême est strict. Les viols, pillages, tortures et autres traitements

dégradants infligés à la Pop doivent cesser a renchéri le Coord.

- Enfin, indigné par les jugements portés contre les FARDC dans les médias face au phénomène FDLR, le Comd Suprême nous lance un défi. NE doutant nullement des capacités des FARDC à combattre efficacement les FDLR, il attend les résultats probants et fera régulièrement lui-même l’évaluation de la Sit.

- Les Comd d’unités doivent privilégier l’intérêt des Tp et éviter le détournement des moyens mis à leur disposition

c). Instructions du Coord des Ops

(1) Continuité dans le travail entamé par le Comd des Ops conjointes et

le Chef EM FT.

- Traquer et détruire les FDLR dans tous leurs retranchements dans le

NORD KIVU

- Attaquer et détruire toutes les Positions FDLR dans le SUD KIVU.

(2) La chaîne Log est à revoir en vue de s’assurer que les moyens

arrivent au soldat.

(3) Eviter la bureaucratie et se trouver plus sur terrain pour mieux

Suivre l’évolution des Ops.

(4) Respecter la voie hiérarchique, tous les rapports doivent passer à

priori par le Coord des Ops.

(5) NE PAS garder des tourments dans les cœurs mais se confier

toujours à l’autorité

(6) Les planifications des Ops devront se faire en Coord avec la MONUC

sans toutefois retarder leur exécution.

(7) Respecter la Pop Civil.

(8) Mener des actions qui nous permettront de gagner la confiance de la

Pop, celle-ci pourra ainsi se dissocier des FDLR.

d) Prenant la parole à son tour, le GenBde BOSCO NTAGANDA, Coord Adjt, a soulevé les problèmes Log qui ont été à la base du retard qu’ont connu les Ops après celles menées conjointement par les FARDC et RDF. Ce qui a permis aux FDLR de se réorganiser et mener quelques Acn contre nos Tp.

e) Pour terminer le Coord a exhorté les Offr à travailler avec assudité

afin que la Nation Congolaise en général, le Gov et le Comd Suprême

en particulier NE soit PAS déçus et que la paix soient totalement

rétablie.

These minutes, and MONUC's response to them, should be a topic of the UN Security Council's African trip later this month, along with proposals to send Bosco Ntanganda's previous boss, Laurent Nkunda, from Rwanda into exile in a country other than the DRC. Watch this site.

Update of 12:55 p.m. -- at Friday's UN noon briefing, after publication of the article above, Inner City Press asked Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's Deputy Spokesperson Marie Okabe to respond to the April 4 FARDC minutes listing Bosco Ntaganda as Deputy Coordinator, including whether the UN disputes the authenticity of the minutes. Ms. Okabe said she had nothing to say on the topic. Minutes later, her Office sent Inner City Press the following statement:

From: unspokesperson-donotreply@un.org
To: matthew.lee@innercitypress.com
Sent: 5/8/2009 12:39:54 P.M. Eastern Standard Time
Subj: Your question on Ntaganda

In reference to your question about Jean-Bosco Ntaganda, we have the following:

MONUC has not seen the documents referenced in the media report allegedly showing that Mr. Ntanganda is a part of the joint operation. On the contrary, the DRC authorities have shown MONUC relevant documents defining the operation's command structure, which does not make any mention of Mr. Ntanganda. MONUC has clearly stated that it will not conduct or support joint operations in which Jean Bosco Ntaganda plays a part. This has been communicated directly to the DRC Minister of Defence and the Chief of the Defence Staff, who in turn have assured MONUC that Mr. Ntanganda is not a part of any joint operation’s command structure. MONUC leadership continues to engage with our Congolese interlocutors on this matter.

Better talk fast, with these Congolese interlocutors... Inner City Press is e-mailing the FARDC minutes to MONUC, which claims not to have seen them. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1bosco050809.html

On UN Security Risk Assessments, Briefing Differs from Letter, the Wrath of Kane

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/cmp2risk050709.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 7 -- With the controversies about safety, asbestos, and transparency swirling around the UN's billion dollar Capital Master Plan, the chief of UN Security in New York Bruno Henn was asked if Security Risk Assessments had been prepared. "No comment," Mr. Henn said.

The town hall meeting on the CMP and security had abruptly been closed to the Press, even though the sign outside Conference Room 3 didn't say the meeting was closed. CMP chief Michael Adlerstein's spokesman Werner Schmidt asked two of Bruno Henn's officers to remove this report from the room.

Afterwards, while Schmidt defended the ejection, Mr. Adlerstein said he hadn't been aware of it, and invited the reporter to the next town hall meeting. In the interim, he tried to explain the seemingly back-dated letter in which he acknowledged that the Security Risk Assessments won't in fact be finished until the end of June.

Adlerstein said the letter was a draft on which he was working with the Department of Safety and Security, he decided he had the wrong information and should have torn it up. But DSS' Mohammad Bani-Faris issued a nearly identical letter five days later, saying that the SRAs would finally be done by the end of June.

Adlerstein's spokesman Werner Schmidt then interjected, that because this reporter "didn’t unfortunately attend this meeting, So he didn’t hear that Bruno Henn say that security risk assessments have been done already."

If Bruno Henn said that, it is contradicted by Bani-Faris' letter. Mr. Henn, as noted, issued only a "no comment" when asked about it on his way out. There is a need, at a minimum, for a press conference.


Instead, there is a notice for another town hall meeting, by the Office of Human Resources Management, which some staffers are surprised to see requires one to in advance confirm or reject attendance. Adlerstein now says his future town hall meeting(s) are wide open. He also said, according to attendees, that "stuff happens." They say he has a new nickname: Michael "Stuff Happens" Adlerstein. Watch this space.

Footnotes: Inner City Press is informed by multiple sources that Department of Management chief Angela Kane, who previously in response to simple questions responded in writing that she has no time to answer queries from the Press, just ask them at the noon briefing, is now "vivid" at reporting on complaints about her unit's actions on relocation under the Capital Master Plan, suspension of the National Competitive Exam and mis-management of the UN Medical Service. A representative of Ms. Kane's office made loud inquiries into the UN's media accreditation process, what are the criteria for being accredited as a reporter.

Counter-question is what are the criteria for being accredited as an Under Secretary General, if when surrounded by controversy one refuses to answer press questions, hasn't held a press conference in months, and tries to retaliate against what little press coverage is given to the Department of Management. Ban Ki-moon today praised the press for holding accountable those who exercise power. Apparently, as with the USGs who refuse to make even basic public financial disclosure, Ban's message has not been received.

Perhaps, just as Mr. Adlerstein on Thursday said he didn't know that his spokesman Werner Schmidt directed UN Security to remove the Press from the CMP town hall meeting, Ms. Kane will say she didn't know that her staff were implicitly threatening the Press that reports on the Department of Management. Then again, Ms. Kane is the one who proposed driving up costs for the press at the UN to make reporting on the organization more difficult. Management, indeed...

And see, www.innercitypress.com/cmp2risk050709.html

At UN, Meeting on Billion-Dollar Rehab Plan Closed to the Press, Safety Questions

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/cmp1uncovered050709.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 7 -- As the UN spends billions of dollars on renovations with a general contractor Skanska embroiled in litigation about mishandling asbestos, its Capital Master Plan director Michael Adlerstein through his spokesman on Monday ordered security officers to eject a reporter from a “Town Hall Meeting” about the CMP. Adlerstein is under fire for having claimed that the litigation against Skanska doesn't exist, and for the claim that required Security Risk Assessments were either not required or were already done. In a letter delivered May 5, but dated April 23, Adlerstein acknowledged that the Security Risk Assessment are belatedly being done, to be finished, he wrote, by the end of June.

At Thursday meeting, senior UN Security officials arrived late at 1:45 pm. They are waiting for you, another officer told them. It is said that Adlerstein is trying to explain his own mis-statement by laying the entire blame on the UN Safety and Security Service, specifically on Bruno Henn.

In the brief portion of the meeting observed by this reporter prior to the ejection directed by Adlerstein's spokesman Werner Schmidt, Adlerstein narrated a slide about the reduction in service in the UN cafeteria. Monday, workers in the cafeteria complained to Inner City Press that they that day received notice of layoffs starting on August 2, with no relocation or retraining. They contrasts this treatment at the UN to what governments around the world are going during the financial crisis.

These issues, and the CMP, are overseen by the UN Department of Management, headed by Angela Kane, who is being questioned by staff and even member states these days on issues ranging from irregularities in the UN Medical Service she oversees through now triple confirmed attempts to keep her unit inside the UN compound during the CMP and force other units to move twice, to the suspension of the National Competitive Exam, one of the few merit-based ways that applicants from under-represented countries can work for the UN.

A well-placed UN staff member on Thursday told Inner City Press that since Germany is over-represented, it and Angela Kane, who he called a German national, favor the suspension of the NCE. Another said that when Germans took the test, their over-representation led to throwing out of some results. Another has chimed in noting that there are over 400 people "on the roster." But the reality is, hirings and "regularization" are being done for those hired outside the NCE, from the field.

Ms. Kane has said she has no time to answer questions, that all these should be asked at the UN's noon briefing. There, however, a limitation on the number of questions that can be asked appears to be in place.

Even so, at the noon briefing of May 6, Inner City Press asked

Inner City Press: a letter has emerged from Mr. Adlerstein of the Capital Master Plan confirming something that had been earlier, I think, denied by the Secretariat that these security risk assessments that were supposed to be produced for the swing spaces and for this building, in fact have not been produced. But now they claim they will be done by the end of June. What’s the explanation of the earlier statement that these were either done or were not necessary? And there is a reference to the CEB meeting of 4 April in one of the letters. Can you confirm that this issue came up and how does this impact...[interrupted]?

Spokesperson: I cannot confirm it at this point. I can ask, of course, Mr. Adlerstein to answer your question.

More than 24 hours later, no answer had been provided. And then Adlerstein through his spokesman had UN Security eject the Press from covering his "Town Hall" meeting.

News analysis: While Adlerstein, Kane and the UN's Ban Ki-moon administration have claimed to be transparent, the ejection of Press trying to cover essentially public comments about the billions of dollars the UN is proposing to spend is a new low. Watch this site.

Update of 1:58 p.m. -- as another UN correspondent has said, since the Capital Master Plan impacts everyone who works here, including the press, it is particularly inappropriate to close the CMP "town hall" meeting to the press who work here....

Update of 2:16 p.m., still outside the meeting room -- given his CMP chief's exclusion of the Press from a meeting the sign for which didn't even say "Closed," it seems more than a little ironic that earlier on May 7 -- and May 6 on Park Avenue -- Ban Ki-moon praised the press, and even "bloggers," for "holding authorities to account."

Update of 2:29 p.m. -- it emerges that even though the UN has not done the Security Risk Assessments, it has already moved staff to 380 Madison Avenue, starting on April 27...

Update of 2:59 p.m. -- While SSS's Bruno Henn, leaving the meeting, said "no comment" to Inner City Press, after another wait Inner City Press spoke with both Werner Schmidt and Michael Adlerstein. The former maintained that the press had to be excluded, saying "you wouldn't want staff in the press briefing room, would you?" Inner City Press said it had no problem with that, and asked when Adlerstein would hold a press conference. While that wasn't answered, Adlerstein said, "you are invited to the next town hall meeting." We will continue to follow this story, short- and long-term.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/cmp1uncovered050709.html

To Visit Sri Lanka, Ban Ki-moon Called “Too Busy” by UN Sources, Despite Japanese Urging and Invitation

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1may6srilanka050709.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 7 -- In the face of a “bloodbath on the beach” in Sri Lanka, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon “feels that if it can save lives, he will definitely consider” making an invited visit to the country. Inner City Press has learned that during Mr. Ban's little noticed bilateral meeting with Japan's Ambassador Yukio Takasu on May 4, Ban was briefing on the visit to Sri Lank by Japanese envoy Yasushi Akashi, and was urged to make his own trip. Click here for Inner City Press' exclusive account of Ban's mysterious dash into the Council while it met in consultations on May 4.

But now Secretariat insiders tell Inner City Press such a trip, for now, is unlikely. Ban has to attend Russia's May 11 debate on the Middle East,they say. And he intends to be in New York for a May 15 meeting with China's deputy foreign minister, so “there is no time,” they've been told. Some question his commitment.

Ban spoke genially to the Press at a World Press Freedom Day event at the residence of French Ambassador Jean-Maurice Ripert on Wednesday night. While wishing to give full off the record treatment to Ban's comment, Inner City Press did ask him about going to Sri Lanka, taking the Press, pushing the country's leadership for real investigations of the deaths of journalists. Perhaps on the record answers will be given.

At Thursday's UN noon briefing, just before publication of this article, Inner City Press asked Ban's Associate Spokesperson Farhan Haq to confirm Ban's meeting with Japan's Takasu, and that May 11 and May 15 commitments (with “Chinese diplomats”) make it unlikely Ban will go to Sri Lanka. “Scheduling is a separate issue,” Haq said. “If he can make a difference... then he will go.” Video through here. We include this denial, and emphasize if necessary -- in light of sensitivity the UN Secretariat has shown in the recent past -- that the "too busy" characterization is from senion UN Secretariat staff, anonymous for fear of retaliation, and not from Ban himself.

Haq did confirm Ban's meeting with Takasu and said “we don't provide read outs of meetings with Ambassadors.” Why wasn't the Takasu meeting -- about Sri Lanka -- even put on Ban's public schedule? “It came up all of a sudden when he had a bit of timing.” Timing is everything. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1may6srilanka050709.html

On Sri Lanka, IMF Dodges Loan and Human Rights Questions, UK Reverses Course

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/imf3srilanka050709.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 7 -- With controversy about Sri Lanka's application to the International Monetary Fund for a $1.9 billion loan swirling from London to Australia, IMF spokesman David Hawley held the organization's fortnightly press conference on Thursday in Washington. In Colombo, the government has said it is close to getting not only the IMF loan, but also another one from Libya. From the UN in New York, Inner City Press before the briefing sent a question to Mr. Hawley, his deputy William Murray and IMF Asia contact Yoshiko Kamata:

Please be sure this is put to IMF spokesman during 930 briefing-- “On Sri Lanka's application for a $1.9 billion loan, French Ambassador to the UN Ripert told Inner City Press that "the Americans are trying to play with the loan." Please confirm, deny and explain the status of the loan and respond to the human rights and press freedom questions raised.”

The IMF states that accredited journalists like Inner City Press can have questions answered during the briefing by submitting them electronically. Having heard nothing back, Inner City Press called Asia specialist Yoshiko Kamata. When Inner City Press was able to attend the IMF briefing in March and asked about the Sri Lanka, Ms. Kamata afterwards approached to offer to help get information. On May 7, her voice mail said she would be away until May 11, and to call the general number. Inner City Press asked Deputy William Murray and reached him.

I don't think you're going to get an answer to that question, Murray said, saying he was unaware of the Ripert quote. That quote about the IMF was picked up in the Times of London, the Australian and elsewhere, so it seemed fair to assume that the IMF's media professionals would or could find it.

Inner City Press said, just have the question asked, it is a matter of some controversy. We're in the middle of a press conference, Murray said. The line went dead.

Despite its timely submission, it appears that the question was not asked at the IMF briefing. The press conference ended quickly, meaning that there were few other questions asked. So there was no lack of time. But after closing the briefing, Murray sent the following response:

Subj: RE: Press question for 9:30 on Sri Lanka
From: William Murray [at] imf.org
To: Inner City Press,
CC: ".dhawley" Media [at] imf.org
Sent: 5/7/2009 10:21:36 A.M. Eastern Standard Time

Matthew, Our discussions with the Sri Lankan authorities about an economic program that could be supported by IMF financing are still ongoing. That is the current status.

The answer does not respond to the question, and the refusal to have publicly asked a question timely submitted raises other questions. Watch this site, and, for example, this article from Colombo, "Sri Lanka Will Get IMF Loan This Month."

Footnote: Weeks after the United Kingdom's Permanent Representative to the UN John Sawers told the Press there was "no relation" between the conflict in North Sri Lanka and the application to the IMF for a $1.9 billion loan, Sawers' boss David Miliband reportedly told the House of Commons that the situation on the ground in Sri Lanka would have to be considered before any positive action is taking on the loan. Inner City Press will be seeking new comment from the UK Mission to the UN. Wednesday was not possible, we'll see.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/imf3srilanka050709.html

At UN, Peres and Press Spar, UNRWA Cash Question Remain

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/banrep2gaza050609.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 6 -- The day after the UN's summary report on Gaza was given to the Security Council and leaked, Israeli President Shimon Peres came to meet with Secretary General Ban Ki-moon and then the Press. He slammed the report for not mentioning the rockets fired by Hamas; he said Israel respects and works well with the United Nations.

Inner City Press asked about the UN Relief and Works Agency's repeated complaint that Israeli does not allow them to bring cash into the Gaza Strip, and also that taxes and fees are imposed on them contrary to international law. Video here, from Minute 9:43.

President Peres responded that "I don't begin to understand the question. If Hamas didn't fire, there would not be a single cartridge shot from Israel." Inner City Press followed up, emphasizing that the question was about access to cash by and taxing of UNRWA. "We support UNRWA all the time," Peres answered.

At the UN's noon media briefing minutes later, Inner City Press asked Ban Ki-moon's spokesperson if Ban had raised either issue in his meet with Peres. "Not in this meeting," the spokesperson replied. Video here, from Minute 29:03.

Could she provide an update from UNRWA on the issues of cash and taxes? She said she would, and we will report on it upon receipt.

Immediately following Peres' media availability at the stakeout, an Al Jazeera reporter who had posed a number of questions was asked to show his UN identification card. He took umbrage, asserting that he was only being asked because of his questioning of Peres.

Others pointed at the heavy presence of UN and Israeli security officers at the stakeout, including in the "pit" with the journalists. The one question asked in Hebrew was not about Gaza or the UN report, but rather about the nuclear non proliferation treaty. Inner City Press posed the same question to Rose Gottemoeller, the US representative to the NPT meeting on which we intend to report soon. Watch this site.

And see, www.innercitypress.com/banrep2gaza050609.html

On Sri Lanka, UN Says Responsibility to Protect is a "Concept" Only, Video Not Seen

Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at UN
www.innercitypress.com/un1may5srilanka050609.html

UNITED NATIONS, May 6 -- The responsibility to protect is just "a concept" that does not yet have "an effective mechanism," UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesperson told the Press on Wednesday when asked about Sri Lanka. Inner City Press queried whether Mr. Ban has yet named a team to conduct the humanitarian assessment mission to the conflict zone he said his chief of staff Vijay Nambiar had won two weeks ago. I can get that information for you, the spokesperson said. Video here, from Minute 32:16.

The UN Secretariat is showing little urgency, senior NGO officials told Inner City Press on Wednesday. They pointed at UN humanitarian chief John Holmes' failure to appoint an assessment team, as he set off on trips elsewhere in the world. Ban Ki-moon has been invited to the country, how ever begrudgingly, but Wednesday his spokesperson said he hasn't decided whether or not to go.

Interviews Inner City Press conducted in the conflict zone Wednesday morning by satellite phone found a situation in which food had not been delivered for a week, and bombs were raining down. Wednesday at noon, Ban's spokesperson said finally some food is being loaded into the ICRC ship. But a week without food, without the naming of a humanitarian team, strike many as a low point for the UN.

Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesperson about a widely seen piece on Britain's Channel 4, filmed in an IDP camp with allegations, on camera, of the disappearance and rape of young women. Video here, from Minute 17:42. "You know I do not comment on press reports," the spokesperson said. "I haven't seen it, and I don't think the S-G has seen it either." Well maybe he should:

Channel 4 in the UK with allegations of rape and disappearance

And see, www.innercitypress.com/un1may5srilanka050609.html