Saturday, March 29, 2025

As AP Sues For Oval Office Access Judge Asks How Many Events in 2024 as Butler Photo Cited

 

by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

DDC COURTHOUSE, March 27 – In Associated Press' lawsuit about being removed from the press pool covering events in the Oval Office in the White House, an evidentiary hearing began on March 27 before Judge Trevor N. McFadden. Inner City Press was there. From the thread:

All rise! Judge Trevor N. McFadden: I have received the Government's late-filed declaration and the AP's motion to strike it. I will deny that motion.  The Local Rules speak to briefings.  AP lawyer Charles D. Tobin: We will put on two live witnesses

 Judge McFadden: I view it on a spectrum, four scenarios. I think the Government agrees under the case law that AP has a right to access East Room events, where other press can. On the other hand it has not right to an interview with President Trump...

 AP's Tobin: I can confirm we are not seeking an exclusive interview. US Attorney's Office Civil DIvision chief Brian P. Hudak: If the press stormed the stage in the Brady briefing room, we might have to rethink the hard pass system, make it more like the Oval Vucci: We did get an exclusive interview with President Biden... 

AP's Tobin: Does the exclusion of AP hurt the public? DOJ's Hudak: Not sure if you're taking objections, but we object. Judge: I am entertaining objections, but I overrule this one

Vucci: Yes, it deprives the public of our fact-based non partisan news.  AP's Tobin: Are you hurt by not being on Air Force 1? Vucci: Yes. Trump loves to talk, he'll come back in the cabin. We miss that. I was on AF1 when Reince Priebus was fired, down back stairs

 Cross examination. DOJ's Hudak: You said there is a pecking order, the order in which journalists walk into the Oval Office? Vucci: It's based on how many people your media reaches. I think AP reaches 4 billion people.

 DOJ's Hudak: Let me show you some photos for sale on the AP website. You see this one, of Karoline Leavitt - it was talking by SIPA USA, but AP is selling it. Vucci: I think we have a distribution deal. I am not on the business side.

DOJ's Hudak: AP still has access to Pebble Beach, where dignitaries come in? Vucci: Yes. These days I go out there and take photographs of the people being interviewed by others. DOJ's Hudak: AP can still photograph Elon Musk and his kid getting on Marine One? Yes

DOJ's Hudak: You talked about preserving history, but it is also about making money - this SIPA photo, AP is selling it for $35 to $495, right? Vucci: People don't only buy from our website. DOJ's Hudak: The meeting with Zelenskyy, NPR ended up running AP? Yes

 DOJ's Hudak: And AP, ever since March 1, has had access to all tarmac events, right? Vucci: I don't know, I don't work weekends. Judge McFadden: Seniority has its benefits, I see. Let me ask: you can take a flattering picture or not? Vucci: Yes. But we're fair

 Judge: Since the ban, have you changed your coveage? Vucci: No, I am a professional. Judge McFadden: How does the number of Oval Office events compare to last year? Vucci: We were allowed into all. Judge: But how many were there? Vucci: I don't know

Thread continues with Zeke Miller

Extra on X for Subscribers here and Substack here

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

Alleging Rape by Jeffrey Epstein Doe 200 Sued Indyke and Kahn Who Seek to Quash & Seal


by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

SDNY COURTHOUSE, March 26 – Jane Doe 200 sued Jeffrey Epstein's executors Indyke and Kahn, alleging their connection to an incident in which "Epstein came up behind Doe, grabbed her and pulled her pantyhose down before he physically forced her face down on the massage table and violently," etc.   On March 26, 2025 a proceeding was held before U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Edgardo Ramos. Inner City Press, which wrote the book on Ghislaine Maxwell, Maximum Maxwell, covered it. From the thread:

Defense lawyer: Jane Doe 200, who claims Mr. Epstein raped her, also says she met Mr. Indyke - but he'd know nothing about it. Her lawyer suggests this was a RICO enterprise. That is false. Indyke did not deal with him daily. My client Mr. Kahn was the bookkeeper 

Defense: If Mr. Kahn helps some of these women with tax returns, it was not to help keep them in the country as sex slaves. And it had nothing to do with Jane Doe 200. We have settled 199 claims but not this one, which is unlike the others. 

Judge: Their letter does say that Jane Doe 200 had personal contact with Mr. Indyke.  Defense: It was never raised until responding to these motions. I am skeptical. Jane Doe 200's lawyer: Propensity evidence is admissible 

Jane Doe 200's lawyer: These two men have personal knowledge of Mr. Epstein's sexual assault and assisted in concealing them- Judge: You are making factual allegations that I don't know if they have basis in the record. I've read he assaulted women 

Indkye's lawyer: Plaintiff's lawyer is not new to this Jeffrey Epstein saga. Our clients were sued in another case, yes, that they should have known - it was not based on personal knowledge of assaults. He does not need this for Rule 415 

Defense: Jeffrey Epstein is dead. The only evidence will come from Jane Doe 200, saying that he raped her. We will oppose her, saying that she continued to visit him.  There is no need for this discovery about a 1-time incident. It would take us months to respond. 

Plaintiff's lawyer: They are sitting on evidence of 191 other sexual assaults- Judge: If a Mets shortstop shot a Yankees shortstop in front of 50,000 fans, you would not be expected to call 50,000 witnesses. Why not a sample? Plaintiff's lawyer: Subtract the 56 

Plaintiff's lawyer: We believe that when Jeffrey Epstein was under investigation he modified documents to reward people who helped conceal his crimes - we believe including Mr. Indyke and Mr. Kahn. We need to understand their financial interest in this case  Judge: What's the basis of your theory?

Plaintiff's lawyer: Depositions we took in Epstein cases against JP Morgan Chase and against Deutsche Bank. Kahn's lawyer: There is a sealed deposition, under a protective order - if it has leaked, it violates an SDNY order

Judge: I'll let defendants move to quash, or for a protective order Afterward, the defendants asked to seal some of the transcript. Watch this site.

 The case is Jane Doe 200 v. Indyke, et al., 1:24-cv-4775 (Ramos)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

Assange Visitors Sued CIA Under 4th AM Now All Dismissed Including UC Global

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Maxwell Book

SDNY COURTHOUSE, March 25 – When jury selection was completed for the retrial of accused CIA Vault 7 leaker Joshua Schulte, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Jesse M. Furman told the jurors, Do not read or say anything about the case. Inner City Press was there, and live tweeted here.

[July 20 denial of access here; Brutal Kangaroo]

On August 15, 2022 after conviction Schulte, a group of lawyers and journalist who visited Julian Assange in the Ecuador Embassy in London sued Mike Pompeo for surveillance in violation of the US Fourth Amendment. They held a press conference, and Inner City Press asked if they will seek emergency relief. Not for now (video here; Complaint here).

Jump cut to February 18, 2025, when the plaintiffs' last claim was dismissed with the state secrets doctrine cited.

On March 21, 2025 the plaintiffs wrote in asking that default judgement be entered against UC Global and Morales.

On March 25, 2025 Judge Koeltl dismissed them as well, noting they are private parties and he had already dismissed a Bivens claim, saying he therefore didn't get to get to the Government's long standing state secrets privilege argument.

On October 12, plaintiffs' counsel asked to adjourn and postpone the October 17 conference in the case: "Plaintiffs had difficulty locating the accurate addresses for the two Spanish defendants, David Morales (“Morales”), a Spanish citizen, and Undercover Global S.L. (“UC Global”), a Spanish corporation."

On January 13, 2023, the US Attorney's Office wrote to Judge Koetlt requesting a pre-motion hearing for them to dismiss the complaint against Pompeo and the CIA.  DOJ argues that there is no "Bivens" remedy available, and states that "matters intimately related to foreign policy and national security are rarely proper subjects for judicial intervention."

On January 18, the plaintiffs responded that the CIA and Pompeo have defaulted, and waited until the last day to filed a letter for a pre-motion conference. They note they are not suing the CIA for money, only an injunction against sharing information. They say the Court will conclude that the Defaulted Defendants motion to dismiss should be denied.

On Saturday, January 14, Judge Koeltl ordered that "the parties are directed to appear on January 20, 2023 at 2:00 p.m. (Signed by Judge John G. Koeltl on 1/13/2023) (jca)

On January 20, Inner City Press covered and live tweeted it, thread here.

On February 16, US DOJ requested and obtained another 30 day extension, saying the Fourth Amendment claim requires it. The plaintiffs did not consent, but the extension was granted. Letter on Patreon here.

On March 16, Judge Koeltl granted a joint request under which the CIA and Pompeo expanded their word limit to 14,000 - and the plaintiff's delayed their opposition to May 8, reply May 30.

But on May 4, plaintiffs' counsel wrote in asking for an additional money due to being on trial and traveling. On May 5 Judge Koeltl granted the extra month.

On March 20, the US filed its 42 page motion to dismiss, arguing among other things that Plaintiffs Had No Reasonable Expectation in their alleged conversations with Assange, and that the "incident" capture of US Citizen info during extraterritorial surveillance of foreign targets does not violation the 4th Amendment." More on Substack here.

On June 6, the plaintiffs filed a memo of law against the motion to dismiss, among other things quoting from Pompeo's memoir "Never Gave an Inch" that "I was sitting with Susan and Nick... reading an unclassified summary of the US government's rules and guidelines on extrajudicial killings," - Assange was being contemplated? Full memo on Patreon here.

On November 16, 2023 Inner City Press live tweeted the oral argument - the motion to dismiss seemed to stall, with letter due in a week. Thread:

Assistant US Attorney Barnea, "for the Federal defendants," goes to the podium: At the outset -

Judge Koeltl: The claims against Pompeo is sole for damages, under Givens, and against the government if for injunction relief?

AUSA Barnea: Yes, your Honor.

AUSA Barnea: On standing, the plaintiffs allege no ongoing harm. Nothing has happened in seven or eight years. They do not allege any imminent plans. The information could be a file cabinet.

Judge Koeltl: They do allege an ongoing concern, that the information seized could be disseminated. They want the return of the information now.  AUSA Barnea: They are just hypothesizing.

Judge Koeltl: They are saying, your continuing detention of my information is harmful. Do you have any case law? AUSA: The Phillips case from the 9th Circuit, albeit different... The Court said for seek expungement, plaintiff had to assert some imminent harm

 AUSA: This was a one-time event. The cases they cite are about ongoing harm, like siphoning up metadata and querying it. That was ongoing, in ACLU v. Clapper. Here, they can't ask for injunctive relief.

AUSA: Plaintiffs allege with the Spanish defendants were approached by the CIA. But even if true, it doesn't prove that the CIA controlled the Spanish defendants. Seeking information from a foreign police force does not show control

 Judge: But contemporaneous monitoring was from in the US, no? AUSA: I imagine they are alleging that. But the test is not involvement, but control by the US government. Were those doing the searches controlled by the US government? Money and training is not enough

Judge: What about direction, if not control? AUSA: The Second Circuit uses the combined phrase, direction and control. So we can only hypothesize. Maybe a contractor... Even if the 4th Amendment applied, they did not have a reasonable expectation of privacy

AUSA: Government buildings commonly have security cameras. There is no expectation of privacy, like in a police station, except if privacy is promised, like in attorney meeting rooms. No one told plaintiffs that. The question is not if the CIA was listening

 AUSA: Turning over their passports and electronics waived any expectation of privacy. Even if they did, surveillance would have been reasonable. The 4th Amendment does not apply to a search of a foreign citizen outside of the US. No warrant is needed

 AUSA: Assange was being investigated for various criminal acts. So surveillance was reasonable. Judge Koeltl: What about the content of their electronic devices? AUSA: No warrants are required outside of the US. Judge Koeltl: What case?

AUSA: Bombings in E Africa Judge: Your papers imply a warrant is required for the contents of the phones-- AUSA: Let me clarify. They just allege conclusorily it was illegal. We put in a footnote about that. Judge: I frankly don't understand what you just said. [Laughter in the courtroom]

Judge: Don't you say the plaintiffs haven't even alleged that no warrant was obtained? I can re-read them, they were read with care initially... AUSA Barnea: No doubt, your Honor. Judge: The government should know if a warrant was obtained. Now you're saying, No

 AUSA: No warrant requested under the Constitution outside the US. There are statutory -- Judge Koeltl: You reply on East Asia bombings - AUSA: East Africa bombings, In Re... Maybe it's in the reply brief... Page 8, we cited it. 2d Circuit 2008.

 Judge: So all the plaintiffs have to do to make this claim survive is to replead that the warrant was required & it wasn't reasonable? AUSA: If they had standing.  We'd have to study how they repleaded. If they made that type of allegation it could solve the issue

AUSA: All they allege is that someone took their phone and it was illegal. Now in a footnote they say they have more.  Judge: It would seem to me unnecessarily wasteful to tell the plaintiff, motion to dismiss ruled on..

AUSA: I apologize

Judge Koeltl: Never apologize

AUSA: I was just getting to the Bivens point. Judge Koeltl: I understand it has never been applied in the context of national security and abroad. I envision that Congress would not be amenable to providing this remedy overseas AUSA: There are alternate remedies

 Judge: What about qualified immunity? AUSA: I'm happy to summarize it for the court. Judge: I'm familiar with it. AUSA: All they have are conclusory statements by Mr. Pompeo, it's not sufficient to implicate him personally

 Plaintiffs' lawyer Levinson: There is no doubt that the plaintiffs have standing, under ACLU v. Clapper... They would not have engaged in conversations there if they thought the CIA was listening

Judge: Listening to the government today, if you made a few more allegation about the seizure of the electronic devices, their objection would fall out. There should be a simply way to add this to the complaint and we can move on. I can accept a letter amending

 Plaintiff's lawyer Levenson: That's what we proposed in Footnote 10 - a letter amendment with additional allegations. Judge: When? Levenson: In a week. Oh, Thanksgiving. Judge: Two weeks.Plaintiffs' lawyer Levenson: Mr. Pompeo wanted to crush Mr. Assange. The CIA gave software to UC Global to surveil Mr. Assange... They filmed, and video of Pamela Anderson with Mr. Assange was on David Morales' laptop. These are private actors on the payroll

 Plaintiffs' lawyer Levenson: It came out that the CIA learned how Mr. Assange could get diplomatic status - and acted in hours. On the need for a warrant, see Riley v. California Judge: What about the passports? Levenson: That was to show the CIA knew they were US

 Plaintiffs' lawyer Levenson: We are not alleging a 4th Amendment violation for photographing the outside of a passport. I had to show my passport to get into the building today. But Riley is about the content of the phone Judge: And surveillance of the meetings?

Plaintiffs' lawyer Levenson: The government knew these were American citizens, and they were being surveilled without a warrant. Judge: Any case on this, privacy in a foreign embassy? Levenson: There is no case like this. There are prison cases cited by the US

 Plaintiffs' lawyer Levenson: These were not prisoners. These were lawyers going to meet a client. Judge: But you can expect surveillance in an embassy, just like in this courthouse. Levenson: These were private areas, journalists were there to see a source

 Plaintiffs' lawyer Levenson: The government is relying on terrorism cases. That's not what this is... We allege that took photos, inside the phone, "of something called the IEMI card," that gives them access to information.

Judge: Bivens? Levenson: This is worse Plaintiffs' lawyer Levenson: A phone is more private than a home: it could have compromising photos. Riley v California in 2014 made it clear that phones are off limits.  Judge: The Supreme Court has only found Bivens violations 3 times Levenson: Phones are worse

 Plaintiffs' lawyer Levenson: There are no national security implications to these meeting. These are not people crashing the border. They are not on a watchlist or no-fly list. Judge: No one has suggested that they are [Again, laughter in the courtroom]

 Judge: The danger the US is asserting is Mr. Assange. Plaintiffs' lawyer Levenson: He is not the plaintiff here. These visitors were surveilled. Judge: Anything further? AUSA Barnea: We have no cases on this on Westlaw. What about police stations?

AUSA Barnea: A court concluded even police don't have an expectation of privacy in the precinct. Also the Port Authority, a nurses office - there was a secret camera but that was found to be OK. There are surely security cameras in this courthouse

AUSA Barnea:  Last point. These IMEI numbers, they are simply written on the phone, they are not the content

Judge: I'll take the motion under advisement. I look forward to the letter.

On December 19, Judge Koeltl issued an order granting the Government's request to dismiss Pompeo (on a Bivens claim) and on communications with Assange and photographing of passports and devices - but DENYING the motion to dismiss as to the contents of the phones: "the Government’s motion to dismiss the plaintiffs’ claim against the CIA with regard to the seizure of the contents of the plaintiffs’ electronic devices is denied." Full order on Patreon here.

On April 11, four days before its motion's due date, the US Attorney's Office wrote it asking to submit a classified "ex parte" submission, from Director William Burns and a memo of law. Meanwhile, Inner City Press recently won an order in the Joshua Schulte case unsealing CIPA transcripts.

On May 24, 2024, the plaintiff responded that the CIA's motion to dismiss is wrong on the applicable standard: it is not whether it involved classified information but rather if the information poses a threat to national security. Plaintiffs note that the facts in the case are not a "secret" as they have already been the subject of testimony in court proceeding including in Spain and the UK, where Assange recently won the right to a full appeal of extradition to the US.

Docketed on February 18, 2025, Judge Koeltl dismissed the plaintiffs' last claim in the case, citing the "state secrets privilege."

 Inner City Press will stay on the case(s).

Back on October 13, Judge Koeltl pushed the initial pre-trial conference back to February 21, 2023: "ORDER granting [13] Letter Motion to Adjourn Conference. Adjourned to Tuesday, February 21, 2023, at 2:30 PM. SO ORDERED." 

On November 29 Morales' and UC Global's lawyer filed a denial full of misspellings, such as pointing to Wikipedia to state that "purpouse [sp] far from acting as journalistic information whose sole purpose is dissent and media manipulation in order to influence public opinion with the clear intention of destabilizing the interests of Western countries," etc.

On December 8, Judge Koeltl ruled starting "  ORDER: The plaintiffs in this action have served all four of the defendants. See ECF Nos. 15-19. For two of those defendants, the Central Intelligence Agency ("CIA") and Michael R. Pompeo, the deadlines to answer were November 9, 2022, and November 18, 2022, respectively. To date, neither of those defendants has answered or otherwise responded to the complaint. The time for these two defendants to answer is extended-" full Order on Patreon here.

And this: "NOTICE OF APPEARANCE by Jean-David Barnea on behalf of Central Intelligence Agency, Michael R. Pompeo..(Barnea, Jean-David)."

On February 21, Judge Koeltl ordered: "on December 8, 2022, the Court directed those defendants to obtain local counsel and to ensure that such local counsel filed a notice of appearance and, if necessary, an application for admission pro hac vice on or before January 30, 2023. See ECF No. 21. The Court also directed those defendants to submit a letter, with local counsel's assistance, indicating whether the November 29, 2022 submission was intended as an answer to the complaint or a motion to dismiss. Id. That letter was due no later than February 10, 2023. To date, there has not been any appearance by local counsel for Mr. Guillen or for Undercover Global S.L., and the requested letter was never filed. The Court notes, as it did in its prior Order, that Mr. Guillen may proceed prose, but that Undercover Global S.L., as a corporate defendant, must appear by counsel. The time for Mr. Guillen and Undercover Global S.L. to retain local counsel is extended to March 21, 2023. Local counsel should file a notice of appearance and, if needed, an application for admission pro hac vice by that date. By April 7, 2023, local counsel for Mr. Guillen and for Undercover Global S.L. (or for only Undercover Global S.L., in the event Mr. Guillen chooses to proceed prose) should file a letter indicating whether the November 29, 2022 submission (ECF No. 20) was intended as an answer or as a motion to dismiss. If local counsel wishes to file a new responsive pleading or motion, local counsel may request an opportunity to do so in that letter. If Mr. Guillen chooses to proceed prose, he should file his own letter meeting the same requirements by the same deadline. The plaintiffs are directed to serve a copy of this Order and of the Court's December 8, 2022 Order (ECF No. 21) on both Mr. Guillen and Undercover Global S.L. and to file proof of such service on the docket by March 3, 2023. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge John G. Koeltl on 2/21/2023)."

 Inner City Press will continue to cover the case.

Back in August, Inner City Press immediately asked the United Nations, from which it remains banned, "What are the comments and actions if any of SG Antonio Guterres on lawsuit filed Aug 15, 2022 in SDNY alleging that lawyers and journalists visting Assange in the Ecuadorian Embassy in London were spied on?" No answer. 

On August 16, the case was assigned to SDNY District Judge John G. Koeltl, of whom Inner City Press has so far reported on 223 cases. It will report on this one. There was an earlier notice: "info for these parties has been modified: Margaret Ratner Kunstler, Deborah Hrbek, John Goetz, Charles Glass, CIA, Michael R. Pompeo, David Morales Guillen, Undercover Global S.L.," tweeted here.

It is Kunstler, et al. v. Central Intelligence Agency, et al., 22-cv-6913 (Koeltl)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

BrutalKangarooBookByMRL

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

As Khalil Sues Columbia and Congress Speech or Debate Clause Nips and Tucks Promised


by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

SDNY COURTHOUSE, March 25 – In a case by Columbia University students seeking among other things to block their school from answering subpoenas from the Committee on Education and the Workforce in the House of Representatives on March 25 U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Arun Subramanian held an oral argument. Inner City Press was there. From the thread:

All rise!  Judge Arun Subramanian: Mr. Abbas, as I noted in my email today [not in the docket] I will be asking those questions. What do you want?

Plaintiffs' lawyer Gadeir Abbas: We want to enjoin provision of any records - Judge: Of your clients? A: All records 

Abbas: We also want Columbia to be enjoined from complying with the March 13 letter Judge: So you're requesting all of the relief you've requested? Abbas: We could agree to some Speech or Debate Clause nips and tucks-

Judge: So Paragraph 3 is out? Abbas: No, in 

Abbas: We'd just suggest a caveat, "consistent with the Speech and Debate Clause." 

Abbas: Let's start with the anti-Semitism definition. Only one court has adjudicated  Judge: Which case? Abbas: It's students in Houston v. Abbott- Judge: Hand it up. [Inner City Press looked it up: it's Students for Justice in Palestine v. Abbott, 1:24-CV-523-RP] 

 Inner City Press will remain on alert for Judge Subramanian's ruling(s), and will stay on the case.

The case is Khalil, et al. v. The Trustees of Columbia University in the City of New York et al., 1:25-cv-2079 (Subramanian)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

Yunseo Chung Wins Temporary Restraining Order Against Detention and Removal in SDNY


by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

SDNY COURTHOUSE, March 25 – Yunseo Chung filed on March 24 seeking a temporary restraining order against detention and removal. At 3 pm on March 25 U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Senior Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald held an emergency hearing. Inner City Press was there. Thread:

All rise!  Judge Buchwald: On the requested TRO, what is the government's position? 

Longtime SDNY / DOJ lawyer Jeffrey Oestericher : Our client does not consent. 

Judge: Take bail as an example: she's not a danger or a risk of flight. 

SDNY's Oestericher: This is not permissible under the INA 

Judge: I understand the Secretary of State signed a piece of paper. But I'd need briefing... The District Court doesn't usually deal with immigration. 

SDNY's Oestericher: I take your point but I am constrained, I cannot consent  Judge: I understand. I used to have your job… I'm prepared to sign the TRO, not preliminary injunction 

Oestericher: Give me a moment... Why is point 3 needed? 

Judge: No trips to Louisiana, as in that other case in this court [Mahmoud Khalil] 

Oestericher: We'll file by April 11. I'm constrained to lightly object.  Judge: Then they get two weeks, April 29. I have a non-jury trial starting then - so oral argument May 20 at 11 am.

More on X for Subscribers here and Substack here

The case is Chung v. Trump, et al., 1:25-cv-2412 (Buchwald)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
SDNY Press Room

Man Convicted of al Shabaab Attack Plan in Pro Se Trial Asks for Lawyer at Sentencing so Delay


by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

SDNY COURTHOUSE, March 24 – Cholo Abdi Abdullah is charged with planning with al Shabaab to attack the US with a commercial jet. 

 On September 5, 2023 he appeared in court saying he has lost faith in lawyers, and intially saying he now wants to represent himself. Inner City Press was there, the only media in the courtroom.

  U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Analisa Torres advised him that without a lawyer he would be at a major disadvantage.

On November 21, 2023 Inner City Press went at 9 am to Abdullah's Faretta hearing. But it was asked to leave the courtroom, from 9:22 am to 9:50 am. It filed a letter to get the transcript of the closed proceeding, here.

On August 5, 2024 Judge Torres set a schedule for an October 28 start of trial.

On October 18, the US Attorney's Office wrote in with issues for the final pre-trial conference on October 21, and trial set to start October 28: he "wants to merely sit passively during the trial... because he does not believe that this is a legitimate system."

He has not requested assistance in filing a proposed clothing order. So will he sit on trial in MDC tan? 

On October 21, he appeared in MDC tan for the final pre-trial conference. Inner City Press was there. Thread:

All rise! [Inner City Press is the only media - the only civilian - in the courtroom] Judge: Mr Abdullah, the trial begins next week.  Abdullah: I wish to remain passive

 Judge: If your stand-by counsel becomes active, I will assume it is with your consent. Abdullah: I am deliberating if I might question some witnesses. It is up to me. They are not going to participate in this case.

 Judge: If you engage in misconduct you may lose your right to represent yourself. You are at an extreme disadvantage if you represent yourself. You are putting yourself in extreme danger. Abdullah: I have my reasons. I keep them to myself

 Abdullah: I would prefer to not even have stand-by counsel. But you do not allow that. Judge: Did you receive the US motions in limine? Abdullah: I have objections, but no stamps to mail them. Judge: You may make them now.

Abdullah: The US is going to use Al Shabaab propaganda videos. Fine. But they should not show video of suicide bombers to the jury. It is going to play with verdict. I want them to cut the part with the shooting,start with the reporter

 Abdullah: There is CCTV provided by the Kenyan government. I do not want the suicide bomber video in AUSA: We want it in. He searched for the video almost contemporaneously. It is probative. [White noise is turned on]

 Abdullah: I don't object to the jury being shown the anti American and anti Zionist statements... But using the other Al Shabaab statements of CC-1 and CC-2, it is hearsay.

 Judge: Having received no objections, I issued an order on October 16. I assume you got it- Abdullah: I did not. Judge: You should read it. We will take a break.

On October 24 stand-by counsel wrote in that Abdullah has only been given access to legal research six days before trial. He had wanted jurors to asked about "bias about Israel and Palestine" but withdrew his request.

On October 28, Inner City Press attended the first day of jury selection, from the thread:

defendant who is representing himself (with 3 stand-by counsel) did not ask to appear in a suit, so he is here in tan MDC jail uniform

Judge: Does anyone have religious or philosopical beliefs that would impact their fairness in this case? No one says yes. Break taken.

Now judge questioning prospective jurors. Judge: Number 21? Woman: New Rochelle, Master in finance. I could be fair 2d woman: Rockland, hospice social worker.  Man (playwright)  I am concerned about the defendant representing himself, that I'll perceive propaganda

Woman, Lower East Side, Islamic Studies, Meddle Eastern studies. Spouse is a lawyer in estates and a Animal law... Woman, lawyer in larges civil rights & civil liberties firm. Concerned colleagues would talk about case. Would not ask them not to.

Judge: We'll break here.

On October 29, Inner City Press covered the end of jury selection, the shut-down of defense opening, then the US opening - they say (not surprisingly) the pace is "brisk." From the thread:

final  jury selection AUSA: We challenge Number 37. Judge: Does the defense challenge 38 or 48? Cholo (pro se) No. [Jury picked]

Judge: Openings? AUSA: 50 minutes. Cholo: I will explain why I will not participate. Judge: That is not a proper subject for opening. Cholo: Then no opening. Defendant said he wanted to open by telling  jurors why he will NOT be defending himself, but was told that is not a proper subject for an opening. So, no opening by him (!)

AUSA: The defendant traveled to meet al Shabaab. He learned to use explosives. He learned what's called operational security. After many months, he was told he was chose for a special important mission: to hijack a plane and attack. He agreed

 AUSA: He enrolled in flight school. He stayed in it for more than a year. He tried to get a job with a US airline. [Defendant Cholo Abdullah is sitting slumped in his chair at defense table, in a tan MDC-Brooklyn prison jacket. 2 of his 3 stand-by lawyers there

AUSA: After an attack, the defendant Googled it. He searched online. He maintained contact with his Al Shabaab handlers. In June 2019 he reached the final stages of his pilot training. But he was arrested [and has been in jail since, next cell to Joshua Schulte

AUSA: At the end of this trial [Nov 15?!?] we'll have a change to talk to you again. Between now & then, pay attention, follow Judge Torres' instructions, and use your common sense. If so, you'll reach the only verdict, that defendant Cholo Abdullah, is guilty

 Judge: Witnesses, after lunch. We'll break.Update: as US puts on the stand an American University professor about global jihad, Cholo Abdullah is not cross examining anyone, and once told that explaining why was not a proper opening argument, didn't make one...

As US v. Cholo Abdi Abdullah trial ends for the day, without defendant doing any cross, AUSA says "We are moving briskly."

On October 30, even more brisk, Your Honor - from the thread:

 AUSA: Professor, what are we about to see? Prof Tricia Bacon: People fleeing Al Shabaab's mall attack [Defendant Cholo Abdi Abdullah in final pre trial conference raised issues about these videos - but so far only objected once, overruled]

AUSA: Doctor Bacon, has Al Shabaab participated in airplane attacks? Bacon: Twice. In 2016, an operative with a laptop blew himself out of a plane. Also in 2016, they tried it in print cartridges. They didn't make it on the plane but they did injure several people

 Bacon: The one in 2018, they said they had intended to get on Turkish Airlines. AUSA: No further questions. Judge: Cross examination? Cholo Abdi Abdullah: No. [He is "going passive"] Judge: The government may call its next witness

 [Next witness] AUSA: What is your name? Witness: Joseph Kalum, of the Kenya anti-terrorism police unit for 21 years. AUSA: What sort of cases do you focus on? Kalum: All terrorism cases, digital forensics.

 AUSA: Did you investigate this attack? Kalum: Yes, Your Honor. Judge: Please don't call the prosecutor "Your Honor." You may call me that. Kalum: Yes, your Honor. AUSA: Did you collect digital evidence? Kalum: Yes, your Honor.

AUSA: What kind of evidence? Kalum: From laptops, Your Honor. Judge: You should just not use that term Your Honor to anyone.  AUSA: Is this a portion of the CCTV footage? Kalum: Correct. AUSA: We offer GX 802. Judge: Any objection? [Silence] Judge: Admitted.

On October 31, the US put in audio and more - and then rested its case. Thread:

Assistant US Attorney: Agent, did you review messages form the Elusive Router account on Facebook? Agent: I did. Here's the IP address it used. AUSA: What is shown in GX 296? Agent: More log ins to Facebook. AUSA: Move to admit. Judge: Any objection? Cholo: No

AUSA: Special Agent, what website was he going to? Agent: The complete audio of the Sheikh Anwar al-Awlaki lecture series - he is a deceased member of Al Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula. There's a photo of him with others. I worked all of these cases

AUSA: Play the audio. Jury hears Anwar al-Awlaki talking about getting on planes with no ID check. "But America thought it could occupy and plunder without consequence." Chola Abdi Abdulla is slumped in his chair at defense table, stroking his beard.

 Update: Now Judge Torres has asked the prosecutors how they would argue against a Rule 29 motion (for acquittal) by Cholo Abdi Abdullah, if he were to make one - since he is NOT making one, or doing anything else. AUSA: We have proved our case

 Judge: Does the defendant wish to present evidence? Cholo Abdi Abdullah: No, I do not trust these public defenders, they work with the US. I was asking for discovery since January. I got it last week. Judge: I believe BOP- Cholo: I am an honorable person.

 Judge: I've watched you  talk to your stand-by counsel, then talk to me. So you accept his advice- Cholo: Only when it conforms with my views. Judge: Have you had enough time to discuss testifying or not? Cholo: He mentioned it to me. We did not discuss

 Cholo: I told him, I will remain passive. Judge: Have he mentioned your right to you, did he remain there in a listening posture? Cholo: I have no problem with- Judge: I need you to answer my question. Did he remain? Cholo: Yes.

 Judge: You've made a decision not to testify? Cholo Abdi Abdullah: That is correct. Judge: Be seated. The charge and jury sheet have been delivered. We are adjourned.

On November 1, Cholo Abdi Abdullah's stand-by counsel "on behalf of Mr. Abdullah, and his instuction," moved to exclude co-conspirator statements, citing US v. Rangott (which Inner City Press also covered). Judge Torres issued an order she will allow them to come in.

On November 4, he was quickly found guilty. Thread:

Cholo Abdi Abdullah has just been found guilty. Judge: Jurors, thank you for your service. You are excused. [Jury exiting]

Judge: Mr. Abdullah, will you continue to represent yourself? Abdullah: Yes. I will not take any advice. Judge: He continues as your stand-by counsel, I am requiring it. Any motion by Dec 6

 Judge: Sentencing March 10 at 10 am. Probation will want to interview you... Abdullah: Is it my choice? Judge: It is your choice. Abdullah: Then I will not talk with anyone. I will never change my mind. You already know this about me. I will remain rigid

 Judge: I want to thank the lawyers for your civility. We are adjourned.

On February 21 his appointed lawyers wrote to Judge Torres for more time for the sentencing memo because "he has refused to speak with counsel since November 14, 2024, and has insisted on not participating in sentencing proceedings."

On March 3 the US Attorney's Office wrote in asking for life imprisonment. Sentencing was scheduled for March 10.

Until it wasn't: "ORDER as to Cholo Abdi Abdullah. Accordingly, by March 10, 2025, Standby Counsel shall file a sentencing submission. Such submission shall include Standby Counsel's analysis of (1) the appropriate Guidelines range to be used and (2) the sentences that have been imposed in comparable cases. The sentencing scheduled for March 10 is ADJOURNED to March 24, 2025. (Signed by Judge Analisa Torres on 3/4/25)

On March 10 standby counsel wrote in that he has no reason to believe that the Guideline is not life in prison but emphasized that "the pro se litigant is entitled to a favorable exercise of the Court's discretion."

On March 13 the US Attorney's Office wrote in that "there is currently no basis to believe that the defendant has adopted stand-by counsel's sentencing memo," and suggested questions to be asked.

On March 24, Inner City Press went to the sentencing. But the defendant told Judge Torres he now was considering asking for a lawyer, not the assigned CJA stand-by lawyers. Judge Torres asked everyone else to leave the courtroom, and reportedly after than pushed the matter back in to April.

Watch this site.

More on Substack here

  The case is USA v. Abdullah, 1:20-cr-677 (Torres)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com