Friday, October 4, 2024

On Honduras Narco Urbina Soto US Asked for 240 Months now He Is Sentenced to 226 Months


by Matthew Russell Lee, Substack

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Oct 3 – In the closing arguments on March 6, 2024 AUSA Tarlow said that narco trafficking had grown under Honduras President Juan Orlando Hernandez. On March 7, out of the hearing of the jury and for then the Press, JOH's lawyer Stabile said he'd heard different overnight.

  From who?

  The defendant's wife he said.

  Was this just a play for a mistrial?

Judge Castel concluded it was, and denied Stabile's motion, Order on Patreon here.

Later on March 8, the verdict, here- then the book Narco Drama in English then Spanish.

On August 28, successor President Xiomara Castro asked Honduran Foreign Minister Enrique Reina to "denounce" the country's extradition treaty with the United States.

Amid that on August 30 Arnaldo Urbina Soto, extradited from Honduras on January 31, 2023 after jail time there, asked for a time served sentence on September 13 at 11 am.

The US Attorney's Office wrote in asking for a 20 year sentence - and on September 12, the eve of sentencing, defense counsel wrote in asking for an eight week adjournment in sentencing, arguing "the government provided cooperating witness testimony that alleges Arnaldo Urbina Soto received bribes from a drug trafficker “in exchange for information from the government” and “in exchange for violence,” among other things. See Gov. Ex. A at 830. This is the first time these issues have been provided to the Court" - letter on Patreon here.

On September 25, sentencing was pushed back to October 3: "ORDER as to Arnaldo Urbina Soto: IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the sentencing scheduled for September 25 is adjourned to October 3, 2024, at 3:00 PM (Signed by Judge Denise L. Cote on 9/25/2024)

On October 3, Inner City Press went and live tweeted - he got 226 months - thread:

All rise! Judge: The guidelines are 324 to 405 months. The US recommends 240 months while the defendant wants time served...He became mayor of Yoro in 2009. He was convicted of money laundering.

 Judge: I understand that co-conspirator(s) did not want him to run again as mayor of Yoro. AUSA: We ask for 20 years. He used political power so that drug trafficking could florish in his district. JOH told him not to run again & hurt JOH's campaign for president

AUSA Robles: Ton quantities of cocaine were sent to the US. Defense lawyer Carla Sanderson: He had a religious conversion. He worked in the kitchen in the MDC. His crimes, he committed with his brothers.Defense: When he was in jail in Honduras, he could have family visits. Not here. No further punishment is needed.

 Judge Denise L. Cote: Mr. Urbina Soto? Urbina Soto: I have accepted responsibility. I am 44 years old, with 4 children. I apologize.

 Urbina Soto: I wish my wife could be here, but she does not have the right papers to travel. I apologize for my misbehavior. God bless you, Your Honor.

Judge Cote: You used your position as mayor to promote drug trafficking.Judge Cote: I have found the trial testimony [which Inner City Press live tweeted] quite useful. I sentence Mr. Urbina Soto to 226 months in prison and then submit to deportation

Defense: Please recommend prison in Pennsylvania. Judge Cote: I will. Adjourned.

This case is US v. Soto, et al., 18-cr-497 (Cote)

More on X for Subscribers here  and Substack here

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

At Daniel Penny Suppression Hearing NYPD Officer Says Neely Had a Pulse and a Muffin


by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

NYS COURTHOUSE, Oct 3 – In the run up to the trial of Daniel Penny for the death of Jordan Neely on an uptown F train in NYC on May 1, 2023, there was a suppression hearing on October 3, 2024 complete with body cam video and post-arrest statement. Inner City Press was in the courtroom and live tweeted, some of thread here, extra / analysis on X for Subscribers here and Substack here

[Penny is sitting at defense table, his video interview is being played. So these interchanges are from the interview]

Police: The doors close and he's still yelling - when does he throw the jacket? Penny: He said, I'll kill you, this and that.

 Penny: Afterward, the cop came. I asked the people on the train to stick around, the cops are going to come. I'm not out here trying to attack. That's not me, that's not how I was trained. This guy was saying he's going to kill people, he's prepared to go to jail

 Police: Did he go up to particular people? Penny: He's saying, I'm going to kill you. Detective Medina: The DA's Office said they wanted to get involved and attend..

 Penny's 2d lawyer: What did you find in Mr. Neely's jacket pocket?

Officer Tejada: A muffin. A full muffin. Penny's 2d lawyer: You saw the muffin top... Was Mr. Neely still breathing? Officer Tejada: Seemed like it. He had a pulse too.

Penny's 2d lawyer: You didn't do CPR for several minutes, right? Officer Tejada: We didn't. Penny's 2d lawyer: But you did use NARCAN, right?

ADA: Objection! Relevance! Judge: I'll allow it for now.

Officer Tejada: Yes...Penny's 2d lawyer: Two witnesses were taken to the precinct, right? A white woman and an African American woman? Officer Kang: Yes. Penny's 2d lawyer: Let me show you the video [Two women shown. One says, He was saying, Kill.. and It wasn't a choke hold

 Penny's 2d lawyer: It sounded to you like the witnesses were taking the side of Mr. Penny, talking about how threatening Mr. Neely had been? Officer Kang: Yes.

Judge: We'll break here.


extra / analysis on X for Subscribers here and Substack here

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

Inner City Press Asks IMF of China Murky Loans Kenya Graft Review and Egypt Timing


by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

NYC, Oct 3– When the IMF held its press briefing on October 3, Inner City Press was able to ask the spokesperson three questions:  on Kenya and governance / corruption review, on China's murky emergency loans to lower income countries, and the 4th IMF review of Egypt's program.

On Kenya, what is the IMF's response to reported pressure on Kenya to request an IMF assessment of corruption and governance issues as part of a push to unlock lending that has been stalled by the shelving of tax hikes?

On Egypt, can you confirm that the IMF has postponed the fourth review of Egypt's economic reform for the loan program to November?

What is the IMF's response to US Treasury official Brent Neiman saying, as to China, "we must make sure the result is the expansion of transparent, credible and on-budget financing flows or debt relief to countries undertaking reforms, not potentially damaging forms of lending"?

The spokesperson Julie Kozack's replies included that the timing on Egypt hasn't changed, that a list of countries in governance review will be provided - and it was, here, including Cameroon


and that the US's - and others' - in put is welcome, including in connection with the Bretton Woods organizations' 80th birthday. More video coming on IMF's website.

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

Of Group Extradited from Cyprus for Boiler Rooms One With Cancer Triggers MDC Letter


By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon

SDNY MAG COURT EXCLUSIVE, Oct 2 -  In the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York on November 28, 2022, a detention or bond proceeding  was held by Magistrate Judge Stewart D. Aaron on a white collar defendant charged in a case involving "boiler rooms" in Cyprus, Romania, Spain and Cambodia.

  Inner City Press was there, the only media in the Mag Court.

 The defendant Scott Steven Neilson, it was said, might be seeking upon release on bond to travel to the United Kingdom. But travel was restricted to the SDNY and EDNY. Scott Steven Neilson was wearing black pants and shirt, and had a retained attorney. He was released on $500,000 bond, secured by $30,000.

  In the same case, Daniel Nielson pleaded guilty on September 30, 2022, before District Judge J. Paul Oetken.

   Jump cut to August 20, 2024 when a trio extradited in from Cyprus were presented, arraigned and detained - one of them extremely thin, taking from cancer treatment in Cyprus. Thread:

The back row on the Magistrates courtroom gallery is full of 7 law enforcement: prosecutor has not arrived yet. One of the three defendants is a woman; a younger man in a track suit and an older man, with a Cypriot-sounding name and longer gray hair. Awaiting AUSA

 Assistant US Attorney has arrived, takes 1 IRS agent up to the prosecutors' table. All rise! AUSA: They came into our custody in Cyprus yesterday.

 Judge: You are charged with conspiracy to commit wire fraud & money laundering, & aggravated ID theft. How do you plead? 3 not guilties, British-sounding accents. Judge: All 3 of you will be detained.

Counsel to female defendant: She was taken out of the hospital [The female defendant does look extremely thin. She was being treated for cancer in Cyprus]

Defense counsel: This is unconscionable. The case has been going on for two years Judge: I will sign the medical needs order to the MDC.

On September 9 Inner City Press went to the next conference. The extraditee taken out of the cancer ward in Cyprus was not present; the other defendants were in the jury box. Thread:

AUSA: There are at least two more to be extradited- one from Northern Ireland, the other fled Cyprus. [The names were given] These four have not requested discovery, but rather, talks.

Judge: Next is Dec 11 at noon

Defense counsel: There is a member of the press here.

AUSA: We have no objection to sealing the transcript.

Judge: Shall we do it at sidebar? [In fact, they went into "robing room," entirely out of view. When they returned it was only said that the transcript would be sealed]

On October 2, the female inmates of 3 North of the MDC-Brooklyn wrote to Judge Oetken with "deep concern about our fellow inmate Mrs. Brenda Laverty... Her condition has deteriorated... an open wound on her abdomen." Now what?

More on X for Subscribers here & Substack here

The case is US v. Neilson, et al., 21-cr-189 (Oetken / Aaron).

sdny

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Honduras Mario Jose Calix Hernandez Arraigned As Future Extraditions Said Stalled


by Matthew Russell Lee, Substack

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Oct 2 – In the closing arguments on March 6, 2024 AUSA Tarlow said that narco trafficking had grown under Honduras President Juan Orlando Hernandez. On March 7, out of the hearing of the jury and for then the Press, JOH's lawyer Stabile said he'd heard different overnight.

  From who?

  The defendant's wife he said.

  Was this just a play for a mistrial?

Judge Castel concluded it was, and denied Stabile's motion, Order on Patreon here.

Later on March 8, the verdict, here- then the book Narco Drama in English then Spanish.

On August 28, successor President Xiomara Castro asked Honduran Foreign Minister Enrique Reina to "denounce" the country's extradition treaty with the United States.

In September in the Mag court which Inner City Press covers, "Minute Entry for proceedings held before Magistrate Judge Valerie Figueredo: Initial Appearance as to Mario Jose Calix Hernandez held on 9/5/2024. Detention Hearing as to Mario Jose Calix Hernandez held on 9/5/2024.  BAIL DISPOSITION: Detention on consent w/o prejudice.

On October 2 he was arraigned before Judge Castel, pled not guilty and had a January 9 hearing set. The prosecutors said he had filed a sealed letter - but two hours after the proceeding, there was nothing in the docket.

The case is USA v. Diaz Morales, 1:15-cr-379 (Castel)

The case is US v. Archaga Hernandez, 24-cr-337 (Clarke)

More on X for Subscribers here  and Substack here

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

Handler For Day Care Fraud Pled Then Fought Now Gets 58 Months Will Brief Bail as Appeal


By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Oct 2 – Isidore Handler, Martin Handler, Menachem Lieberman, Harold Schwartz and Ben Werczberger were indicted and then presented on January 11 before U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Magistrate Judge Robert W. Lehrburger.

Inner City Press was there, the only media in the Mag Court. There was an argument about the defendants phones being searched, see below.

  The charges include wire fraud, theft of government funds, aggravated identity theft and money laundering.

On August 31, a change of plea (to guilty) hearing was docketed: "ORDER as to Isidore Handler: The Court has been informed that Defendant Isidore Handler may wish to enter a change of plea."

He did, and on February 16, 2024 Isidore Handler asked for a non-custodial sentence.

On March 7, it emerged that the lead defendant is to plead guilty: "ORDER as to (23-Cr-00004-1) Martin Handler. The Court has been informed that Defendant Martin Handler may wish to enter a change of plea. Accordingly, on Tuesday, March 12, 2024 at 10:15 a.m., a plea proceeding will take place... (Signed by Judge Jennifer H. Rearden on 3/7/2023)."

This was pushed back to March 15 at 10:30 am. Inner City Press went, see

Ok - now at guilty plea of Martin Handler. 

AUSA: He needs to be arraigned on the S-2 indictment first.

The plea deal is to tax evasion. 

Handler: ... On counts 5 and 7, from for profit day care NY Early Learning Co., I misapplied more than $5000...On the superseding information, I claimed charitable deductions for funds that weren't given until later. I am sorry.

 Then they went back to the S-2 indictment...

Jump cut after much litigation to October 2, 2024, when Martin Handler was sentenced in a full courtroom. Inner City Press was there, thread

now at sentencing of Martin Handler in NYC day care fraud case. His daughter is sobbing and asking for leniency for him. 

AUSA: This case is not about technical violations - this is about greed, not need. He chased financial gain. He put his loved ones in the crosshairs of the criminal justice system, as you saw in the Rangott trial [which Inner City Press also covered]


Martin Handler: It is years since my arrest. I want to apologize to the Head Start program at large. I don't want to waste your time Your Honor as I apologize to my family. My mother says it was not my fault but it was. I have lost so much.

 Judge: I will take a break before imposing sentence..

 Back in packed courtroom. Judge: I sentence Martin Handler to 58 months.

Then a schedule to brief bail pending appeal...

Back on July 22, with Arie Rangott on trial, Judge Rearden addressed his request to cross examination CW-1 about a divorce proceeding more than ten years ago, and a night the witness spent in the jail. Judge Rearden denied the request, or to put it another way, precluded that cross. She asked the sealed filings highlight in the copy to Chambers what is being withheld from the public. In this case, the US Attorney's Office's filings, too, have a many redactions.

On July 23, the prosecutors played for the jury voice notes between Rangott and Isidore Handler, about installing Chelsea in the financial position previously held by Sarah, and showing Head Start paperwork to back it up. And so it proceeds.

On July 24 it emerged that Chelsea will be the US' next witness, after Peralta. There is a pending motion for a defense witness.

On July 25 Chelsea was on the stand, in person - not as she was initially interviewed, by Zoom. In the docket, we can now report, Rangott has raised the Supreme Court's decision in Fischer v US about 18 USC 1512...  Inner City Press remains on the case.

On July 29, cooperator Schwartz was on the stand, describing how he was CEO in name only, and that he knew that it was wrong. Isidore Handler's photo was shown to the jurors...

On July 30, Sara Newman was on the stand, looking at herself being quoted from a meeting she said never, in fact, occurred...

At the end of the trial day on July 31, the jury charge was debated, from a question of multiple conspiracies (with Second Circuit case law cited) to Ragott opposing a "conscious avoidance" jury instruction - or in the alternative, wanting it emphasized the good faith would be an absolute defense.

On August 2, Arie Rangott was found guilty by the jury on all three counts. Sentencing set for 12/10/2024 at 11:30 AM before Judge Jennifer H. Rearden

On August 27 for Ben Werczberger, counsel wrote in asking for time served when he is sentenced on September 10 at 11:30 am.

Inner City Press went on September 10, into a full courtroom, from the thread:

Werczberger: I'm a family man. I have caused heartache. I am sorry.

Judge: The US requests time served, 6 months home detention. You made false statement to a bank. I sentence you to time served, 3 months home detention, 100 hours community service

The indictment, while ordered unsealed on January 11, was still not in PACER - in its place were two copies of the order to unseal. Inner City Press has obtained and published it on its DocumentCloud, here. 

Docketed on April 15, another co-defendant now intends to plead guilty: "ORDER as to Ben Werczberger. The Court has been informed that Defendant Ben Werczberger may wish to enter a change of plea. Accordingly, on April 18, 2024 at 2:15 p.m., a plea proceeding will take place (Signed by Judge Jennifer H. Rearden."

Summary: They are charged with participating in schemes to steal millions of dollars from government-funded childcare programs for low-income families, including by stealing proceeds from a fake after-school program that received millions in funding and by using funds to purchase private real estate, items at auction, and a luxury vehicle.

  The defendants were ordered released on bond on January 11.

There was an argument about phones seized from the defendants. Defense counsel wanted to litigate before any search warrant can be obtained. But Assistant US Attorney Daniel Wolf said the issue wasn't ripe, that they could move to suppress later. 

 Judge Lehrburger recommended that defense counsel write a letter to the assigned District Judge Jennifer H. Rearden.

On January 18, they did, arguing that "the government has not set forth the basis for the agents' belief that - at the time of the seizure - they had probable cause to believe that these specific phones contained evidence of criminality." And some phones, they say, were not in plain view. Motion on Patreon here

On January 19, Judge Rearden held the arraignment, and moved on to trial date. Inner City Press thread here, more on Patreon here

On March 14, 2023, the US Attorney's Office docketed redacted letters as to Martin Handler and Martin Lieberman, asserting their lawyers have conflicts of interest - that could be waived - with the blacked out material said to "address ongoing non-public matters before the grand jury."

On March 16, Judge Rearden ordered: "ORDER as to Martin Handler, Menachem Lieberman. Defendant Martin Handler, his counsel, and the Government shall appear for a Curcio Hearing on March 22, 2023 at 11:00 a.m. Defendant Menachem Lieberman, his counsel, and the Government shall appear for a Curcio Hearing on March 22, 2023 at 2:00 p.m." Inner City Press asked in its March 16 story, Can they hold a Curcio hearing which does not disclose the conflicts?

  Almost, is the answer. Inner City Press attended and covered both Curcio hearings on March 22. The 11 am, or Menachem Lieberman, when smoothly: he waived the conflict. But at 2 pm, Martin Handler's lawyer contested several of the questions - and then argued that the Court cannot order her client to speak to another lawyer. Judge Rearden asked for a letter by 5 pm on March 23 before she issues an order.

At the end, the AUSA asked to redact the transcript, as the name of one of the companies was said. Inner City Press heard it and wrote it down, but is voluntarily not reporting it here.

On the afternoon of March 23, Handler proposed his own Curcio counsel, citing Supreme Court precedent on a defendant's right "to choose who will represent him."

On March 23, the US Attorney's Office responded that the Court should question the counsel Handler has proposed. Then it separately reported on cellphones, some of which it has still been unable to decrypt or extract.

On March 30, Judge Rearden ordered: "ORDER as to Martin Handler: Martin Handler's application to retain Stacey Richman as independent Curcio counsel, ECF No. 74, is GRANTED. Mr. Handler, his counsel, his independent counsel, and the Government shall appear ... on April 11, 2023 at 10:30 am to continue the March 22, 2023 Curcio hearing."

  Inner City Press was there. Midway through the more than an hour hearing, Handler said he couldn't or wouldn't waive the right to cross examine employees of the two entities. His lawyer added that is not what in her understanding the law or ethics requires - only that information gained in the previous representation cannot be used. It emerged that both entities in the last 24 hours provided waivers. But the AUSA sought and got a question on that these waivers are not necessarily forever. After all this, a knowing acceptance of the (possible) conflict was found, and the case proceeds.

On April 18, all defendants and their counsel were before Judge Rearden. The defense requested a trial date in mid May 2024 but Judge Rearden said that was too far off. One has a conflict in EDNY in March; Judge Rearden asked for emailed about other dates in the first     quarter of 2024.

Watch this site.

Inner City Press will continue to cover this case.

The case is US v. Handler, et al., 23-cr-4 (Rearden)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

Eric Adams Says US Witness Is Lying so Wants Trial Done By March But Judge Says Complex


by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Oct 2 – The five-count indictment of NYC Mayor Eric Adams was unsealed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Magistrates Court. Inner City Press was the first one in and live tweeted it - as it will his presentment, now set for Friday, September 27 at noon.  

The unsealing thread

On September 17 at noon he was arraigned and pleaded not guilty. Thread.

On September 30, Adams' lawyers now including William Burck did file a motion to dismiss... Count V, on the Turkish Mission. 25 page memo of law of Patreon here.

At 5:58 am on October 1, Adams' lawyers filed a motion for sanctions alleging grand jury leaks - memo of law on Patreon here.

On October 2, Inner City Press live tweeted the proceeding here; the next day is November 1, with Adams requesting a February or March trial

More/extra on X for Subscribers here and Substack here

The case is USA v. Adams, 1:24-cr-556 (Ho).

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com