Saturday, September 28, 2024

After Inner City Press Reports Sierra Leone UN Mission Decay Default now State Dept Disputed


By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Sept 20 – Sierra Leone's Mission to the United Nations has been sued for "posing an immediate danger [with] mold and vermin infestation." Inner City Press first reported the case on May 21, 2021 and it has since been picked up.

The Sierra Leonean Mission is at 245 East 49th Street, right near the United Nations which also poses dangers, in its impunity.  Inner City Press live stream here.

Now Inner City Press reports, in May 2024, that Sierra Leone stopped paying or communicating with its lawyers at Foley Hoag, who on May 8 withdrew, see below.

  Then from Freetown, this: "The Commissioner explained that the investigations revealed that an initial Two Million Five Hundred and Sixty US Dollars (USD 2,560,000.00) was approved for the refurbishment of the building around 2012. He said a Procurement Unit was formed in New York during the stewardship of the then Ambassador Vandi Minah to ensure that procedures were complied with. This followed quotations received from newspapers in the US to invite bidders and bids were received with the highest being Eighteen Thousand US Dollars (USD 18,000) from the New York Times and the lowest was One thousand one hundred and fifty-five US Dollars( USD 1,155.00) from Sunday Metro.  ..Yet the Government of Sierra Leone signed the contract represented by the then Ambassador/Permanent Representative to the United Nations, Adikalie Foday Sumah,” he said.  Commissioner Kaifala said immediately after the signing of the contract, the sum of One Million US Dollars ($1,000,000.00) was remitted into the mission’s building account in Citi Bank in New York... The Commissioner said the the ACC had concluded therefore that the transactions surrounding the contract are fraudulent and did not follow due process, thus all involving parties will be held accountable. It is in this regard he stated that the Commission, during the course of the investigations, interrogated a number of persons of interest, including former Permanent Representative to the UN Dr. Alie Kabba, former Minister of Development Dr. Francis Kaikai, the Accountant General Richard Solomon Ralph Williams, former Ministers of Foreign Affairs Nabeela Tunis and Dr Samura Kamara, former Director General of the Ministry and current and former Heads of Chancery, among others. He said, based on the investigations, not less than six people, including the contractor, will be indicted by the Commission for their various roles in the misappropriation of funds, which has caused an embarrassment to the country, as the State has been sued by neighbors of the country’s UN House in New York as result of this project."

And now, a request to add two more parties to the lawsuit. Sierra Leone's Mission to the corrupt UN is due October 4. Watch this site.

  On June 4, not the Mission but contractor Empire Group NYC, LCC made a number of proposals, including cleaning up the Mission's debris. The cover letter says, "as soon as the Permanent Mission of the Republic of Sierra Leone to the United [Nations] appears in the case, the Court should schedule a prompt return date for its response to the OTSC issued by the Court."

On July 26 an emergency hearing was sought as Sierra Leone's UN mission and its contractors refuse to comply with an order, for example: "Remove all debris from inside the Mission that pose an ongoing fire hazard... The Mission's lawyers have refused to take additional photographs or any any inspection of the Mission on purported grounds of Sierra Leone's national security."

And the response on July 27 confirmed: "The Mission has imposed certain restrictions on access to and documentation from within the Mission, as referenced in the Plaintiffs' Letter, citing national security grounds." Sounds like the corrupt UN-world of Guterres, still banning Press.

So does this invocation of impunity: on August 20, Sierra Leone's lobbying firm put in a letter that argues that its decrepit, nuisance "diplomatic premises are inviolable as a matter of federal and international law." Tony's law - beat up the press, kill with cholera, leave garbage everywhere, and cite immunity. Will it work?

  After Inner City Press exclusively reported on this case, and was contacted by media in Sierra Leone, now the Foreign Ministry has issued a two page press release saying it has been directed to our media report, and calling it misleading and inaccurate.

 While unlike the even more corrupt UN of Antonio Guterres, who rather than respond to questions using UN Security to rough up and ban the Press that asks them, the Ministry has spoken, it does not stand up. Just consider the photos of how they left the site of their "Chancery."

And they do not specify what they say the US State Department did not do. (Inner City Press got answers from the State Department on May 27, here, but has not yet asked about this, since it didn't know of the Ministries response until May 28).

 The pickers-upper also note that Sierra Leone's government transferred some $3.2 million to their UN Mission in New York, including "5-Sep-19 FT1924808290 Outward Swift Payment 9,329,999,975.14," the spending of which remains unclear given the conditions of the "Chancery." There's also the IMF's March 15, 2021 OK-ing of $50.37 million to Sierra Leone under its Rapid Credit Facility. We aim to have more on this. Watch this site.

 Next door neighbors have sued the Mission in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, which Inner City Press while banned from the UN by Antonio Guterres now covers daily.

  The complaint identifies Sierra Leonean diplomats' "failure to follow basic fire-prevention protocols... creating an opportunity for flying debris, fire and other dangers."  

The SDNY docket reflects that, of the complaint, "service was accept by Fatima (F/B 40-49 years old, 5'4" tall, 140 pounds with black hair and brown eyes) who advised at the time of service that she is authorized to accept on behalf of the Permanent Mission of the Republic of Sierra Leone to the UN." 

  On May 27, the SDNY's Deputy Clerk certified serving the country's foreign minister, pursuant to the Provisions of the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act, 28 USC 1608(a)(3).

  On November 29, 2021, Sierra Leone's law firm wrote to Judge Ramos that they would like to move to dismiss based on the total immunity of Sierre Leone, no matter what it does.This is the international system / racket under Antonio Guterres.

On June 27, 2022 with the case still going, the Harvey's wrote to Judge Ramos that "a significant rat infestation has invaded the Harvey's home from the headquarters." UNHQ?

On July 1, 2022, Judge Ramos denied Sierra Leone's motion to dismiss: "MOTION to Dismiss filed by Permanent Mission of The Republic of Sierra Leone to the United Nations. The Mission's motion to dismiss is DENIED. The Harvey's motion for contempt and sanctions is DENIED in large part, and the motion for a preliminary injunction is DENIED. The parties are directed to appear for a status conference on July 15, 2022."

In October 2022, Sierra Leone wrote it to "clarify" that it would not even be attending the October 26 status conference, since it got a stay pending appeal to the Second Circuit on the issue of diplomatic immunity. How dangerous could the building get? Judge Ramos conferred with those who did attend, and directed that a proposed case management plan be submitted by October 28.

Jump cut to May 8, 2024 - Judge Ramos granted the request for Foley Hoag to drop Sierra Leone as a client - the firm said Sierra Leone was not paying, and had not even communicated in ten months.

On June 4, despite an order to find new counsel, the Mission's "Minister Counselor" A. Salieu Kamara wrote it asking for an unspecified day to find new counsel. The plaintiffs have proposed a June 14 deadline.

On June 14, Inner City Press covered Sierra Leone's non-appearance, thread:

OK - now case against UN Mission of Sierra Leone, which as Inner City Press exclusively reported left its mission building full of rats and is now absent despite being ordered to appear in court 

Judge: Has Sierra Leone done anything to fix its building?

A: Nothing. Nothing at all. Judge: The Mission is not being used at all? A: Not at all. We are moving for default. The Court has repeatedly told the Mission it must have counsel in this case.

 Plaintiff's lawyer: The Court told the Mission it had to appear in this case. All they did was send a vague letter saying they couldn't comply. They are in contempt of this Court. We move for default. Judge: I'll ask that you do this on papers.

 Judge: This involves intl relations, our government and Sierra Leone. So we need to dot our i's and cross out t's. 

Judge: When will you move by? A: In 7 days. And we'll move for attorneys fees. [But would Sierra Leone pay?]

Dysfunction? Impunity? Or both? This is today's UN World of SG Antonio Guterres.

Letter to withdraw for non payment on Patreon here

On July 3, 2024 Sierra Leone's UN Mission's default was noted, officially, and the process for damages started, with reference to among other things nuisance, diminution in the value of Plaintiffs' home, and remediation.

On July 9, Judge Ramos set a schedule - and invited the US State Department into the case, presumably to assert or argue immunity for the rogue mission, as it did for the UN when it brought cholera to Haiti and killed 10,000 people: "ORDER Janet and Joseph Harvey filed this action on May 14, 2021. Doc. 1. They bring various claims alleging that the renovation and expansion of the Permanent Mission of the Republic of Sierra Leone, which is located next door to their Manhattan home, presents a danger to their health. Shortly after the Second Circuit's mandate issued, counsel for the Mission sought leave to withdraw, citing the Mission's failure to cooperate in the representation and its failure to pay legal bills. The Court has scheduled an order to show cause hearing for August 7, 2024, at 10:00 a.m., to address (1) whether an order should be entered permitting the Harveys and the Mission's codefendants in this matter to access the Mission's renovation site, and (2) whether the Harveys should be permitted to move for damages in support of default judgment against the Mission following an inspection of the site. Given the nature of these issues, the Court finds it appropriate to invite the U.S. Department of State to provide its views, if any, on the Harveys' requests or on any issues of interest to the United States. The Department of State may file a statement of interest by July 31, 2024, or it may appear at the order to show cause hearing on August 7, 2024. If the Department of State does not do so, the Court will resolve the Harveys' requests on the existing submissions. By July 12, 2024, the Harveys are directed to serve a copy of this order on both (1) the Mission, and (2) the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York (for delivery to the State Department). It is SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Edgardo Ramos on 7/9/2024)."

On July 31, DOJ wrote in that "the State Department considers the Mission's premises to be inviolable [and] therefore respectfully requests that the Court refrain from issuing the order requested by Plaintiffs." Impunity...

On August 2, the plaintiffs wrote in to preliminarily contest inviolability of what they call the "renovation site."

On August 7, Inner City Press attended, thread:

State Dept  says even as construction site, dormant for 5 years, is inviolable.

Judge: Have you spoken with  US Ambassador to the UN  Linda Thomas GreenfieldPlaintiff: They've done nothing.

Judge: I am going to declare Sierra Leone  in default. But the State Dept  says no one can enter it, like the Russian Mission back in the day.

Plaintiff: We will be seeking money damages.

Judge: I'll refer that for an inquest by the Magistrate Judge

Construction company lawyer: We are also being injured. [NOTE:  Sierra Leone is this month's President of the UN Security Council...]

 Now  State Dept  lawyer: I am flying out for vacation on Thursday Adjourned.

On August 8, the assigned Magistrate Judge Stewart D. Aaron set a September 10 inquest: "ORDER SCHEDULING CONFERENCE: On August 7, 2024, Judge Ramos entered an Order finding that Defendant Permanent Mission of the Republic of Sierra Leone to the United Nations (the "Mission") is in default. (8/7/24 Order, ECF No. 240, at 2.) Judge Ramos further referred this matter to the undersigned for a damages inquest/damages hearing. (Id. at 2; see also Order of Reference, ECF No. 239.) The undersigned shall hold a conference to address the timing and format of the damages inquest on Tuesday, September 10, 2024."

Inner City Press covered the September 10 proceeding, from the thread

Plaintiffs' lawyer: We expect to resolve cases against all defendant except the Mission of Sierra Leone by September 24 [the day the UN's "high level" week begins] and then we'll put in proof of damages the mission [/country] owes.

Judge: They are in default  Judge: So, mail notice to Sierra Leone of the next steps.

ORDER: Following a telephone conference today with the parties to address the timing and format of the damages inquest arising from the default of Defendant Permanent Mission of the Republic of Sierra Leone to the United Nations (the "Defaulting Defendant"), at which counsel for Plaintiffs and Defendants Empire Group NYC, LLC and David I Montesi (the "Empire Defendants") were present, and having been apprised by Plaintiffs that they expect that a resolution will be reached by and between Plaintiffs and the Empire Defendants, Defendant Jules Davis, and Defendant Fairfield Construction Associates, LLC (collectively, the "Non-Defaulting Defendants"), by September 24, 2024, it is hereby ORDERED as follows: 1. No later than September 24, 2024, Plaintiffs shall file a letter to the ECF docket with respect to the resolution of the claims against the Non-Defaulting Defendants. 2. No later than October 22, 2024, Plaintiffs shall serve the Defaulting Defendant and file Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law concerning all damages and any other monetary relief permitted under the entry of default judgment. The submission shall contain a concluding paragraph that succinctly summarizes what damage amount (or other monetary relief) is being sought, including the exact dollar amount. The submissions shall be served upon the Defaulting Defendant and proof of such service shall be filed to the ECF docket no later than October 25, 2024. 3. Plaintiffs' Proposed Findings of Fact should specifically tie the proposed damages figure to their legal claim(s); should demonstrate how Plaintiffs arrived at the proposed damages figure; and should be supported by one or more affidavits, which may attach any documentary evidence establishing the proposed damages.

On September 20, the plaintiffs wrote in that the US State Department acknowledges that FSIA gives the court jurisdiction, only arguing that injunction would be "imprudent." But what was in the alternative, to impunity?

 Inner City Press will be following this case, and others of impunity.

The case is Harvey et al. v. Permanent Mission of the Republic of Sierra Leone to the UN, et al., 21-cv-4368 (Ramos)

sdny

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Eric Adams Turkish UN Blues by Matthew Russell Lee, Inner City Press @SD...

Saturday, September 21, 2024

With Sean Combs Jailed in MDC New Book Echoes Epstein in MCC and Asks Diddy Do It?


by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Sept 21 – Two days after Sean Combs was detained in the MDC jail in Brooklyn, Inner City Press which live tweeted his two failed bail fights published a first book about the case, Diddy Do It? Paperback, audio book and e-book on Amazon here.

It begins: "On November 16, 2023 a lawsuit against Sean Combs went live in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York. Within days it was settled.   But the 35-page complaint remained in the PACER system. Its first page said, in red, "Trigger Warning: This document contains highly graphic information of a sexual nature, including sexual assault." Inner City Press covered it, and other cases filed in 2024: Lil Rod Jones, Adria English, Jane Doe, Crystal McKinney.   

  On September 17, 2024 Sean Combs was brought by US Marshals before SDNY Magistrate Judge Robyn F. Tarnofsky. He had been arrested the night before in a hotel on 57th Street and now he, through his lawyer Marc Agnifilo, was asking to be released on $50 million bond.   

  Just prior to the bail fight, US Attorney Damian Williams held a press conference in 26 Federal Plaza. Inner City Press went, and asked Williams if his office would be seeking pre-trial detention on Combs (yes) and how the case compared to the prosecution of R. Kelly, which Inner City Press had also cover. This question, Williams did not answer. But we will try to.

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

After NYCHA Extortion Take Down Starks Now Moves to Dismiss under Snyder Decision


by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Sept 16 – For days Inner City Press had heard from its sources there would be a "takedown" on February 6, each SDNY Magistrate Judge would handle seven to 10 defendants.

Arrests happen at 6 am. So at 5:55 am Inner City Press tweeted it, first to X subscribers with the spoiler alert: the expectation was that each of the current or former NYCHA employees would be released on bond the same day.  

And then hours later at 9:39 am the prosecutors announced it. Media rushed around reporting it.  Inner City Press had it first, and after discretely waiting, published it first. Then this thread of presentments, here

 Now in Courtroom on 9 Charles Starks, 57,  of NYCHA70 with a Big Law CJA lawyer argues for no bond, release on own recognisance. He's accused of $7000 in bribes over 3 years. He's already fired.  "This is not Bernie Madoff."
Judge: $50,000 bond; wife can co-sign

On March 5, this defendant's case was indicted and assigned to District Judge Jennifer L. Rochon.

On July 18, Judge Rochon held a status conference with Starks; Inner City Press was there. Starks' lawyer said he might be moving to dismiss under the Supreme Court's decision on June 2024 in US v. Snyder. Judge Rochon gave him until September 16 to make that motion. We will be covering it - as it has implications for the other NYCHA cases, many of which are already pled out.

On September 16, Starks moved to dismiss, noting that the indictment provided "almost no detail on... the timing" - and citing Snyder v. US. In the alternative, Starks asks for a Bill of Particulars.

Watch this site.

A case is US v. Starks, 24-cr-126 (Rochon)

 Watch this site - and these feeds: X and  X for subscribers.

And Substack here

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

Immunity Claim for UN Assistance to Hamas Oct 7 Attacks Now Motion for Amicus Briefs


by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Sept 20 - For the UN's role in Hamas' October 7 attacks, non-US citizen plaintiffs and estates on June 24 filed a lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York against UNRWA, Philippe Lazzarini, Pierre Krahenbuhl, Filippo Grandi, Leni Stenseth, Sandra Mitchel, Margot Ellis and Greta Gunnarsdottir. 

  The individual plaintiffs are sued for, inter alia, their "constant travel to New York" to raise and get money and "their material support of Hamas' terror infrastructure." Also cited, for jurisdiction and venue, is "over one billion dollars from UNRWA's New York bank account in Manhattan that Defendants then caused to be delivered to Gaza in cash U.S. dollars to benefit Hamas." 

 Inner City Press, which daily cover the SDNY court in-person and the UN from outside the gate, banned from entry by SG Antonio Guterres, asked Guterres' spokespeople Stephane Dujarric and Melissa Fleming about the lawsuit, without any response per usual.

Nor have they responded to Inner City Press' June 19 application to enter the UN to ask these questions.

  On July 30, the US State Department - at the request of the UN - filed a letter asserting complete impunity: "At the request of the United Nations and in accordance with the United States’ treaty obligations to respect the immunities of the United Nations and its officials, we explain the application of those immunities in this case.1 In light of the United Nations’ immunity, the Court lacks subject matter jurisdiction over the United Nations. See Georges v. United Nations, 834 F.3d 88, 98 (2d Cir. 2016). Similarly, the individual U.N. defendants enjoy immunity for their official actions, and two of the individual defendants, by virtue of their high-ranking positions, also enjoy diplomatic immunity." Letter on Inner City Press' DocumentCloud here.

Judge Torres has set a schedule.

On September 13, the plaintiffs filed their response memo, including that the Convention on the Privileges and Immunities of the UN does not apply to UNRWA, much less to Lazzarini and Grandi.

On September 20, a proposed amicus brief arguing that UNRWA is not entitled to immunity under the CPIUN, nor according to jus cogen. We'll have more on this.

The UNRWA case is ESTATE OF TAMAR KEDEM SIMAN TOV, BY HEIR-AT-LAW GAD KEDEM v. UNITED NATIONS RELIEF AND WORKS AGENCY (UNRWA) et al., 24-cv-04765 (Torres)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

Sean Combs Wants Conference to Dismiss Crystal McKinney Assault Case While Jailed


by Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Book Substack

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Sept 20 – In May 2024 Crystal McKinney sued Sean Combs for sexual assault under the NYC Gender Motivated Violence in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.

  The suit recounts Combs inviting McKinney to Cipriani Downtown - in 2003 - then to his studio on West 44th Street where he drugged and assaulted her, according to the complaint. 

  On September 20, days after Combs was indicted and twice denied bail in the SDNY, as live tweeted by Inner City Press, Combs' legal team wrote to SDNY Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald asking for a pre-motion conference in anticipation of moving to dismiss Crystal McKinney's complaint. September 20 letter on Patreon here.  

  Inner City Press will be covering the Combs cases. This one is McKinney v. Combs, et al., 1:24-cv-3931 (Buchwald)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

In Battleground Michigan Disparate ChoiceOne Eyes Detroit via State Bank Opaque HELOC


by Matthew R. Lee, Patreon Substack

FEDERAL COURT, Sept 20 – In the battleground state of Michigan, a bank is trying to move into suburban Detroit via merger, with a disparate lending record. Fair Finance Watch with Inner City Press on the FOIA has filed a timely first comment on, the Applications ChoiceOne Financial Services, Inc., Sparta, Michigan; to merge with Fentura Financial, Inc., and thereby indirectly acquire The State Bank 

  Kelly Potes, ChoiceOne’s CEO said that the proposed "transaction will allow ChoiceOne to strengthen its presence in the suburbs of Detroit while adding the markets of Flint and Saginaw." But consider ChoiceOne's disparate lending record:      

Consider that ChoiceOne Bank in Michigan in 2023 - data not yet included in any CRA exam - made 759 mortgage loans to whites, and only TWENTY to African Americans. Meanwhile it denied only 246 applications from whites, while denying 10 of the applications that, based on its marketing, it received from African Americans. ChoiceOne should be referred to DOJ.   

Meanwhile The State Bank in Michigan in 2023 - data not yet included in any CRA exam - made 414 mortgage loans to whites, and only THREE to African Americans. Meanwhile it denied only 36 applications from whites, while denying one of the few applications that, based on its marketing, it received from African Americans. The State Bank should also be referred to DOJ.

On September 17, ChoiceOne calling itself COB wrote in, inter alia, that loans "denied were Home Equity Line of Credit loans, for which no denial reason is given. Reporting denial reasons for HELOCs is optional, rather than mandatory for COB, and COB opts not to report." This is far from a best practice - we'll have more on this.

Why would regulators even consider approving this merger? Watch this site.

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

Man Who Called to Withdraw Plea before OKd Got 151 Months Noting MDC Has No Stamps


By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Sept 20 – Mark Gonzalez pled guilty on August 31, 2022 before a Magistrate Judge to a conspiracy to distribute 400 grams and more of fentanyl. 

 Then, he says, from jail in Essex County he called his retained counsel and said he wanted to take back his plea.

 He says that was before the assigned District Judge formally accepted his guilty plea. 

   On April 14, 2023 U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Victor Marrero held a proceeding. Inner City Press went and covered it.  

 Gonzalez wanted to fire his retained counsel.

The CJA lawyer present said he was honored to be on the CJA panel and would accept appointed. He asked the prosecutors to leave the courtroom, and that the transcript be redacted. Inner City Press was still in the courtroom, openly.

  The upshot is that the change of counsel was made, and the CJA counsel will seek records about the alleged call, which would have been recorded, from the Essex facility.  

The AUSA, back in the room, said they should get a copy too, and a copy of Gonzelez' CJA affidavit which the SDNY AUSA called a judicial record and a public document. (This is ironic because when Inner City Press has moved to unseal CJA affidavits, the SNDY US Attorney's Office has said it "takes no position.") 

  Judge Marrero said that Gonzalez had already been found eligible for CJA counsel, and that the CJA should filed a letter in two weeks about the fruits of the subpoena.

On April 28, the letter was filed - there was a call between Gonzalez and his then counsel, but the file has been mailed to the new CJA lawyer, on a CD.

On May 1, the new (soon to be former?) CJA lawyer wrote to Judge Marrero that he met with Gonzalez on April 29 and was told he is fired. He has requested a conference in which he he said he would request to be formally relieved as counsel.

  Inner City Press went to that conference, on May 5. Gonzalez, dressed in the beige prison garb of the Metropolitan Detention Center, was brought in by two US Marshals, and spoke with a woman in the gallery, where Inner City Press was the only other civilian.
 
  When Judge Marrero took the bench, the CJA lawyer asked for the prosecutor to leave. (He did). The CJA lawyer explained his "acrimonious" relationship with Gonzalez, and disagreement on legal strategy which Inner City Press is voluntarily not reporting here. But the public version is that Gonzalez contests the 400 grams of fentanyl weight, and whether he could have been in a conspiracy with his co-defendant or some other relationship.
 
  Judge Marrero set a further - final? - conference on the matter of representation for May 12 at 10:30 am. He said he will not appoint any new lawyer for Gonzalez.

On May 10, the CJA lawyer wrote in to say that Gonzalez wants to keep him on, and he requested 30 days to file the motion for withdrawal of guilty plea. The AUSA wrote in to cancel the May 12 proceeding.

On July 7, there was another conference on the lawyer's motion to withdraw. Inner City Press went, but the prosecutor was out in the hall, only Gonzalez and outgoing / standby counsel inside. Later, this: "Minute Entry for proceedings held before Judge Victor Marrero:Status Conference as to Mark Gonzalez held on 7/7/2023. Defense counsel Richard Palma present with Defendant. AUSA Ni Qian present on behalf of the Government. Court reporter present. The Court scheduled this conference in response to Mr. Palma's letter informing the Court that he wished to be relieved as counsel. Mr. Palma and Defendant addressed the Court ex parte regarding defense counsels request to withdraw as counsel. The Court granted Mr. Palma's request to withdraw and ordered that Defendant shall proceed pro se with Mr. Palma on stand-by. Defendant's motion to withdraw his guilty plea shall be due July 21, 2023."

On October 31, 2023, Judge Marrero denied Gonzalez's motion to withdraw his plea: " it is hereby ORDERED that the motion of defendant Mark Gonzalez (Dkt. No. 132) to withdraw his plea is DENIED."

On January 11, Gonzalez got his last (CJA) lawyer: "The Court underscored that Mr. Gonzalez has been appointed numerous previous counsel, and that if Mr. Gonzalez decides that he is not willing to proceed with Mr. El Ashmawy, the Court will not appoint any other counsel, and Mr. Gonzalez would then have to proceed pro se or retain counsel. The Court reiterated it intended to proceed with sentencing on March 15, 2024, and the Court denied all outstanding requests or motions, without prejudice."

Received March 4 and docketed on March 8, Gonzalez wrote to Judge Marrero with emails between his former lawyer and one the lawyer called his "lady friend," about withdrawing his plea. Gonzalez argues it shows ineffective assistance of counsel. But sentencing is still set for May 17 at 1 pm. And his new CJA lawyer has request a conference to determine if Gonzalez wishes to go Pro Se again.

On March 11 Judge Marrero denied Gonzalez' (second) motion to withdraw his guilty plea.

On April 24, this: "On April 14, 2024, CJA attorney Yusuf El Ashmawy filed a letter notifying the Court that defendant Mark Gonzalez had fired him over email earlier that day, and requesting to withdraw as counsel for Gonzalez. (Dkt. No. 170.) The Court has previously warned Gonzalez that if he is not willing to proceed with El Ashmawy as counsel, "the Court will not appoint any other counsel... at this stage." (Dkt. No. 160, Hr'g Tr. 5:17-25; see also Dkt. No. 165 ("Regardless" of Gonzalez's choice, "the Court will proceed to sentencing of Gonzalez as scheduled on May 17, 2024.").) Accordingly, the Court hereby schedules a Faretta hearing this Friday, April 26, 2024, at 12:00 p.m., in Courtroom 15B at 500 Pearl Street, New York, NY 10007. At this hearing, the Court will consider El Ashmawy's request and determine if Gonzalez wishes to proceed with El Ashmawy or if he instead wishes to proceed pro se at his sentencing proceeding on May 17, 2024, at 1:00 p.m."

On May 10, Gonzalez' (outgoing?) lawyer wrote in asking for a 121 month sentence.

On July 19, Gonzalez was sentenced to 151 months: "JUDGMENT IN A CRIMINAL CASE as to Mark Gonzalez (1). THE DEFENDANT: pleaded guilty to count One of Superseding Information 21-CR-288. All open counts are dismissed on the motion of the United States. IMPRISONMENT: 151 months. The court makes the following recommendations to the Bureau of Prisons: The Court respectfully recommends that the Defendant serve his time of incarceration at FCI Fort Dix, or alternatively at FCI Danbury. The Court also respectfully recommends that the Defendant be admitted to the Residential Drug Abuse Program (RDAP), or any other drug treatment program available, to the extent he is eligible."

On August 14, a letter about the $5715 found under the bed in a red tin perfume box, that it was not connected to crime but rather a job with the NYC Department of Education and should be returned.

On August 24 the US Attorney's Office replied that Gonzalez now has no standing, and that his girlfriend cannot intervene in the criminal case but only in a later "ancillary proceeding pursuant to 21 USC 853 and Rule 32.2(c)." Few would do this for $5000, which the US still seeks in an order of forfeiture.

On August 30, this: "Gonzalez's objection is DENIED, and a Preliminary Forfeiture Order shall be entered forthwith. FOR THE REASONS STATES ABOVE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that defendant Mark Gonzalezs objection to entry of a forfeiture order is DENIED; and it is further ORDERED that a Preliminary Forfeiture Order as to Gonzalez shall be entered forthwith; and it is further ORDERED that, should Yahaira Rodriguez still wish to seek return of the seized money, she shall petition the Court for an ancillary hearing to adjudicate her interest in the forfeited property and to amend the Preliminary Forfeiture Order, pursuant to 21 U.S.C. § 853(n). An example of such a petition can be found at United States v. Meira, No. 15 Cr. 627 (S.D.N.Y.), ECF No. 439 (Oct. 17, 2018). Rodriguez is advised to attach to her petition documentation supporting her assertions. (See Order, Dkt. No. 198 (directing Rodriguez to provide documentation confirming her employment and salary at NYC DOE and confirming who was on the lease for her apartment during the relevant time period). it is further ORDERED that the Government and/or standby counsel Camille Abate are directed to promptly mail a copy of this Order to Rodriguez"

On September 20, this was docketed: "PRO SE LETTER by (21-Cr-288-1) Mark Gonzalez addressed to Judge Victor Marrero dated 9-5-24 re: I'm writing your honor to inform you that with all the lockdowns and the fact that MDC Brooklyn does not have stamps on there commissary, ("Mailbox Rule"). My motion for leave for reconsideration, that was written in early August of 2024, will be late. Thank you."

 Inner City Press will continue to follow the case. It is US v. Gonzalez, 21-cr-288 (Marrero)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
SDNY Press Room 480, front cubicle