Sunday, September 4, 2022

US Opposes Tartaglione Bid To Strike Death Penalty But Is OK With Trifurcated SDNY Trial

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

SDNY COURTHOUSE, August 29 –  To withhold documents about the death of Jeffrey Epstein in the Metropolitan Correctional Center in lower Manhattan, the U.S. Department of Justice cited the then-pending trials of Corrections Officer Tova Noel and the still-pending death penalty trial Michael Thomas and former Briarcliff Manor Officer Nicholas Tartaglione.

But how much of it was a cover-up?   Inner City Press, which pushed for full access to the trial of Ghislaine Maxwell, live tweeted it, here and below.

 On August 26, 2022 DOJ filed a lengthy, partially redacted opposition to Tartaglione's motions to strke the death penalty. While it was in 2019 under the previous Administration in Washington that the death penalty was sought, the current Attorney General apparently still seek it here - and in another SDNY case, the upcoming Saipov terrorism trial?

  In this cas, DOJ writes, the Death Penalty Notices alleges that Urbano Santiago, Miguel Luna and Hector Gutierrez were "kidnapped and killed to prevent them from providing information to law enforcement regarding the kidnapping and murder of Martin Luna."

 DOJ's August 26 brief argues that "The Death Penalty is Constitutional" and, relevant to Saipov, that "Death Qualifying Prospective Jurors Does Not Render a Resulting Death Sentence Unreliable." Then 10 pages of redacted responses on "as-applied Constitutional challenges." DOJ says, "This section of the Government's brief has been redacted from the publicly filed copy solely because Tartaglione has redacted the corresponding part of his Motion. The Government defers to the defense to explain the need for sealing and takes no position on the issue." Inner City Press believes that it should all be unsealed, and may file to that effect because on the Court's response to the unilateral redactions. Watch this site.

 Back on September 29, 2021 SDNY Judge Kenneth M. Karas has granted Tartaglione and a small team permission to have photographs taken in the MCC, which will be reviewed "for any security issues." Apparently, never public. We'll see.

From the docket: "ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT ACCESS TO METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER ("MCC") as to Nicholas Tartaglione. Nicholas Tartaglione ("the defendant"), having requested access to certain areas of the Metropolitan Correctional Center ("MCC") in New York, New York, and the Government having consented to such access, the Court hereby finds and orders as follows: 1. On September 30, 2021, the defendant's counsel shall be provided access to the following areas of the MCC: (a) all cells in which the defendant has been held since his arrival at the MCC on December 16, 2016, including any Special Housing Unit ("SHU") facilities, and; (b) all common areas to which the defendant has had access including, but not limited to, any medical treatment, legal visit, library, recreation, and/or exercise facilities."

Back on April 9: Assistant US Attorney: Because we don't know how the criminal trial against Nicholas Tartaglione will go, so we shouldn't have to release these records and impact a death penalty trial. 

Judge Engelmayer: Can you assure me that any document that has been withheld based on Tartaglione mentions Epstein? AUSA: No. [Sounds like it's time to go "in camera" and have the judge take a look at the withheld documents, with an eye toward releasing them]  

Judge: Are there documents being withheld based on Noel? [Corrections officer charged in connection with Epstein's death]

AUSA: Yes.  AUSA: There is a belief that disclosing these documents could make it difficult to seat jurors.

 Judge: Is that credible? The issue in the Noel case is, did they make false statements about locations. I would be started if it turns into an autopsy of Epstein. 

Now in the (Epstein) FOIA proceeding, "Don King case in the 2d Circuit" is quoted, along with argument that in the Noel (and Thomas) case, gag orders won't be needed. Inner City Press, which will cover that trial, would oppose any gag order or other restriction.

 Judge is leaning toward in camera review of the documents, asks what he should be looking for. Assignment rosters, in Vaughn index; and the "2000 emails taken off the table." 

Here's from "Index of Withholdings in Full," including "Incident Report of Jeffrey Epstein's July 23, 2019 Apparent Suicide Attempt" and "Psychological Reconstruction of Inmate Death." 

The case is US v. Tartaglione, 16-cr-832 (Karas)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

US Wants Delay of EDNY Murder Trial of Man in MDC Brooklyn but Judge Says Not So Fast

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Maxwell Book
BBC - Honduras - CIA Trial Book - NY Mag

EDNY COURTHOUSE, August 29 – Charles Powell is in the Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklyn awaiting trial before U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York Judge Eric R. Komitee. 

 But with a switch in Assistant US Attorneys, from Jack Dennehy on "indefinite leave" to Andres Palacio (who thus described the leave),the prosecution on August 29 asked for an adjournment of trial.

 In a proceeding covered by Inner City Press, Judge Komitee said, in essence, not so fast. 

 Defense counsel pointed out that the new AUSA is asking for delay in favor of a November trial on a defendant who is not in custody, before Judge Diane Gujarati.

Judge Komitee asked for a filing by August 31, at midnight - and then inquired into the defendant's appearance at the time of arrest and now, and the US' Brady obligation. 

 Then his dog barked.

Judge Komitee said that he was not in the office - but still his questions dug deeper. Inner City Press will continue to follow this case, in its new EDNY project.

The case is US v. Powell, 21-cr-572 (ERK) 

***

@SDNYLIVE courthouse #CourtCastCast
                              200 Worth Street
Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Indicted UAE Lobbyist Barrack Faces Sept 18 Trial With Ankle Bracelet & Cousin Vinny Talk

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Podcast
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

EDNY, August 29 – Thomas Barrack and Matthew Grimes, indicted for illegal lobbying for the United Arab Emirates, were arraigned on July 26, 2021 before U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York Magistrate Judge Sanket Bulsara. Inner City Press live tweeted it here (and podcast here)

 On August 3, 2021 Grimes asked the Court for permission to travel to New York where his lawyers are based - and then to take the train to Boston (the conditions of release were limited and car and common air carrier, with private jet access cited). Letter on CourtListener here.

On November 2, Judge Cogan held another proceeding in the case - but no listen-only call-in line was provided, unlike the in-person EDNY guilty plea the same day in US v. Daniel Rendon Herrera, a Colombian drug kingpin charged with continuing criminal enterprise and providing material support to a foreign terrorist organization before Judge Dora L. Irizarry. Inner City Press live tweeted thread here.

Why less transparency on Barrack?

On March 15, 2022, with the UAE Mission to the UN under Ambassador Lana Nusseibeh refusing to answer written questions from Inner City Press and documents sealed in EDNY, this Barrack argument; "while the indictment alleges that Mr. Barrack spoke positively about the UAE in the media, see Indictment ¶ 24, those allegations do not show he was the UAE’s agent, see Mot. 7."

On May 24, 2022, Judge Cogan held a proceeding and Inner City Press live tweeted it, here and below.

On August 29, in a nearly final pre-trial conference before the September 19 trial, Judge Cogan held a conference. Inner City Press live tweeted here:

OK - now in near final pre-trial conference for US v. Barrack and Grimes for UAE spying, Barrack's lawyer says jurors seeing his ankle bracelet would be prejudicial.

Judge Cogan: Just don't wear shorts. 

Defense says that proposal to modify Grimes' grand jury testimony to switch "Tom Barrack" to "the other guy" is like "something out of my Cousin Vinny."

AUSA: No, it's not from My Cousin Vinny, it's from the Second Circuit Court of Appeals.

 Judge Cogan: We'll find a war room for the defense, as close to the courtroom as possible. The prosecution, it's easier for them, they're right across the street...  I could tell the jury, you may be here until January. Just tell me long you'd need.

Defense: If we put on a case, it would be two or three weeks. But we don't know yet.

Judge: I like to say, "The case will take this long," without telling them, the US versus the defense's case. Just project the end date. I think the US adds 25 to 50% to estimate

Voice: Can I cut in?

Judge Cogan: Who is that?
2d voice: The public line.

Judge Cogan: Silence that.

[Note: Inner City Press believes there should be a listen only call in line for this national security trial, given COVID etc.]

 Defense: We don't want a surprise co-conspirator to show in trial. Judge Cogan: The US has been over-inclusive in listing everyone they might call (as) a co-conspirator. Could the government be more specific?

AUSA: It's not as much a mystery as the defense says.

AUSA: There is no requirement that we name every co-conspirator in a conspiracy trial. Judge (to defense) That's the best I can do for you.

Defense: They have an obligation to ID for us every co-conspirators they are going to allege during the trial.

Abbe Lowell: There are motions in limine pending. Given that some of these, I take it, are statements between people we didn't know - that was my point.

Judge Cogan: Mr. Lowell, as a practical matter, I'm including to take evidence like that subject to connection. 

Judge Cogan: I will see you all on September 19. Adjourned.

Back on March 22, 2022, Judge Cogan held a proceeding and Inner City Press again covered it, thread here:

OK - now in case of indicted United Arab Emirates illegal lobbyist Tom Barrack, a proceeding in EDNY.

Judge  Cogan: When can you file your motion - in 2 weeks? The answer is yes. Defense counsel asks for right to reply.

Judge Cogan: What about the Curcio [possible conflict of interest of counsel] hearing?  Let's do it 5:30 on April 7.

 Judge Cogan: I'd be willing to do the trial by video... [Why not? At least a public listen-only call-in line]

Judge Cogan: Is US going to supersede?  AUSA: We are mindful of trial timing, either way we won't impact it. Judge: When will you know? AUSA: By mid June.

AUSA: Your Honor will see us on May 19 on the CIPA issues. We may know by then. Judge Cogan: What might a superseding indictment look like, do you know? AUSA: We know.

  Judge Cogan: Would it mess up the trial schedule? AUSA: We don't think so. No new CIPA.

Judge Cogan: We have another status conference, say, May 24, 11:30 am. It's been designated complex, so [Speedy Trial Act] time is excluded. 

The case is USA V. AL MALIK ALSHAHHI et al., 21-cr-371 (EDNY, Cogan, J.)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

In 9/11/01 Attacks Case Recommended Order Would Deny Victims Access to $3.5B

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon
BBC - Decrypt - LightRead - Honduras - Source

SDNY COURTHOUSE, August 28 – In the ongoing lawsuit "In Re Terrorist Attacks on September 11, 2001," originally filed in 2003, a conference was held on February 22, 2022 after the US' action on frozen Taliban funds. Inner City Press covered it, below.

  The conference concerned writs of execution levied against Afghan assets held in the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. Counsel cited applicable New York law in the CPLR, and expressed deference to US foreign policy. The UN, it's said, is complaining about the use of funds - it it doing its own fundraising off Afghanistan.


U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Magistrate Judge Sarah Netburn held the conference.

Inner City Press live tweeted Judge Netburn's November 10, 2021 conference, here.

On Thursday October 28, before a Monday hearing, John Fawcett's right to now invoke the Fifth Amendment to avoid questions about his leak of information from the case was taken up, and disposed of, by Judge Netburn. Inner City Press live tweeted here.  The rejection of Fawcett's Fifth Amendment claims by Magistrate Judge Netburn was upheld by District Judge George B. Daniels on October 29.

On Saturday October 30, two days before the hearing, Saudi Arabia proposed cutting off the audio line and closing the courtroom for some or all of Fawcett's testimony. Letter here. It is an outrage: "counsel for Saudi Arabia proposed that the  courtroom be closed for any testimony that reveals protected material, and counsel for Fawcett  proposed that, in order to avoid inadvertent disclosure of protected material, the courtroom be  closed and the audio feed be cut off for the entirety of Fawcett’s testimony, that counsel  promptly review the transcript and propose redactions, and that the transcript be made public as  soon as practicable after the hearing. Saudi Arabia takes no position on whether the courtroom  should be closed for the entirety of Fawcett’s testimony. If the courtroom is not closed for the  entirety of Fawcett’s testimony, we request that counsel and the witness be instructed not to  disclose Saudi Arabia’s or Al Jarrah’s protected information without giving us an opportunity to  object and to request that the courtroom be closed for that specific part of the testimony."

On November 10, the Hogan Lovells law firm dropped the Taliban as a client. Judge Netburn held a proceeding; Inner City Press live tweeted it here and below.

In late August 2022, Magistrate Judge Netburn recommended not granting victims access to the $3.5B the Administration had said would be for them: "These creditors hold judgments against the Taliban for its role in the September 11 Terrorist Attacks or other terrorist acts. They move under § 201(a) of the Terrorism Risk Insurance Act of 2002 (“TRIA”) for a turnover of the DAB Funds to satisfy these judgments. The Court recommends denying these motions for three reasons. First, DAB is immune to this Court’s jurisdiction. It is the central bank of a foreign state. This means it is entitled to immunity from jurisdiction and its property is entitled to immunity from execution. TRIA may overcome DAB’s execution immunity, but not its jurisdictional immunity. Second, even if there was jurisdiction, the Court is constitutionally restrained from making the finding that TRIA requires to authorize the turnover. Only the President may recognize the government of a foreign sovereign nation. Courts may not do so directly or by implication. Authorizing the parties to satisfy the Taliban’s judgments with Afghanistan’s central bank funds unavoidably acknowledges the Taliban as the Afghan government. Third, even if that were not the case, TRIA § 201(a) requires an agency relationship in order to execute on an entity’s assets. This relationship requires a manifestation of consent that is not present where the Taliban has seized DAB by force." Only the President may - so what will the Administration do? Watch this site.

From November 10: Now in 9/11/01 case a plaintiff says despite Taliban takeover the case should go on against the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan, for default.

Judge Netburn: It is a new country with a new name.

 Judge Netburn: I'll need briefing on the issue. When US administrations change, the country doesn't. But what's happened in Afghanistan seems different. The country's name has changed, the fundamentals of the country have changed.

 Judge Netburn: I'm thinking we should ask for the opinion of the U.S. State Department, about the new government of Afghanistan. I'll take all this under advisement. We are adjourned.

Watch this site.

SDNY

Inner City Press notes that in this case, Docket Item 6122, Motion for Conference dated April 14, 2020, says "You do not have permission to view this document."

Judge Netburn has ruled, in the interim: "ORDER: On November 1 and 2, 2021, this Court held an evidentiary hearing into the breach of the protective orders in this litigation. This order governs subsequent proceedings related to that hearing. By November 24, 2021, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, the law firm of Kreindler & Kreindler, and John Fawcett shall file proposed findings of fact, conclusions of law, and any remedies the parties believe are appropriate based on that hearing. Proposed findings of fact shall be supported with specific citations to the record. These filings shall be made under seal pursuant to this Order, with access restricted to the parties. By December 1, 2021, the remaining law firms of the Plaintiffs' Executive Committees shall file a letter with the Court stating if they believe any redactions to the parties' November 24 filings are necessary. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Magistrate Judge Sarah Netburn on 11/4/2021)."

The case is In Re Terrorist Attacks on September 11, 2001, 03-md-1570 (Daniels / Netburn).

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

sdny

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com