Saturday, September 11, 2021

After Honduras JOH Brother Tony Gets Life + 30 Yrs, Geovanny Fuentes Gets New Lawyer

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Song Filing
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Sept 8 – Honduras President Juan Orlando Hernandez took a briefcase of cash and said he would stuff drugs up the noses of the gringos, a jury was told on March 16, 2020.  Inner City Press live tweeted it, morning here and then the afternoon, about the video(s), here and below. Geovanny Fuentes was found guilty, and his lawyer told Inner City Press he thinks JOH will be or has already been indicted.

Now on September 8, 2021, Geovanny Fuentes has fired that lawyer, and gotten a new (also publicly funded) one, photo here. Judge Castel ruled: "ORDER as to Geovanny Fuentes Ramirez. The trial of this action has resulted in a verdict. Defendant's post-verdict motions have been decided. The only proceeding remaining in this Court is sentencing. This Court does not appoint counsel for appeal. For good cause shown, the application of Mr. Moskowitz to withdraw is GRANTED. John M. Burke, a member of the CJA Panel, is appointed as counsel for Mr. Fuentes Ramirez. (Signed by Judge P. Kevin Castel on 9/8/21)." Watch this site.

On July 19 on the Salgueros, this: "Minute Entry for proceedings held before Judge P. Kevin Castel: (Telephone) Status Conference as to Otto Rene Salguero Morales, Ronald Enrique Salguero Portillo held on 7/19/2021. Defendant Otto Salguero-Morales present with attorney, Robert Feitel. Defendant Ronald Salguero-Portillo present with attorney, Linda George. Defendants waive physical appearance. Government and defense counsel are required to submit letters by August 15, 2021 regarding blackout dates for the first quarter of 2020. Defendants' motion for a bill of particulars shall be filed by August 2, 2021. The next conference is scheduled for October 12, 2021 at 12:00 p.m. in Courtroom 11D. Time is excluded until 10/12/2021. Defendants continue to be detained." Inner City Press will stay on the cases.

 On May 10, in the parallel case of US v. Lobo,  Honduras police officer Ludwig Criss Zelaya Romero was being sentenced by Judge Schofield. Inner City Press live tweeted it here:

Inner City Press video stand up afterward here.

This case is US v. Lobo, et al., 15-cr-174 (Schofield)

  On April 26, the lawyer for co-defendant Otto Salguero Morales wrote to Judge Castel complaining he hasn't been given the recorded calls and emails "obtained in the Giovanni [sic] Fuentes case." So he says no trial date can be set. This while the UK sanctions Oscar Ramon Najera. What is the US State Department doing? We have asked them, and the US Mission to the UN, without answer.

Now on April 29, Otto Salguero-Morales' lawyer has followed up with a motion for "random reassignment" of his case, away from Judge Castel. He asks why his case was linked to that of Tony Hernandez, while Leonel Devis Rivera-Maradiaga and Alexander Ardon-Soriano have different judges. He questions the process of superseding indictments. Now there's also a Motion For Reassignment of Indictment . Document, filed by Ronald Enrique Salguero Portillo. Watch this site.

  On April 23, Fuentes' lawyers filed a motion to set aside the verdict or for a new trial, arguing among other things that Judge Castel erred in permitting Leonel Rivera to testify to statement made by Metro and to Fuentes' alleged statements in the MCC. Inner City Press tweeted photo here. The US Attorney's Office immediately asked for an extension until May 21 to response - and got it. Watch this site.

  On March 16, JOH's brother Tony Hernandez was belatedly up for sentencing before U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge P. Kevin Castel, who oversaw his trial leading to guilty verdicts in October 2019. Judge Castel sentenced him to life plus thirty years and said in prison he should reflect on how to help his family "and [his] country" - perhaps a reference to telling the US government and then juries what else he knows. Inner City Press live tweeted it, here  and below. The ensuing celebrations, across Worth Street from the SDNY courthouse and in Honduras, Inner City Press dubbed the "Castel-ebracion."

Now on April 12, two more defendants in the case had a status conference before Judge Castel. Inner City Press live tweeted it, here:

Judge Castel has a proceeding on Otto Rene Salguero Morales and Ronald Enrique Salguero Portillo.


Lawyer for Ronald Enrique Salguero Portillo says she wants more discovery information, all she's been given is testimony of a cooperator, Ardon. Says she needs time to meet with the defendant at the MCC jail.

Judge Castel: Let's hear from the US. Why haven't you answered the defense's emails about discovery? Asst US Attorney: We spoke in December.

Lawyer: I wrote to them in January, nothing heard back. What is my client charged with? It can't just be what Mr. Ardon says.

Lawyer: This client is a Guatemalan national. My other client [in Lobo case before Judge Schofield] was a member of the Honduras National Police.

Judge Castel: Does the government think there is a potential conflict? AUSA: No view at this time.

Judge Castel (sounding frustrated) - We'll get to the bottom of this - did the government send you the discovery from the Juan Antonio Hernandez Alvarado case or not?

Lawyer: Partially. We didn't get discovery about the videos, nor copies of documents

Judge Castel: I'm wondering if I've been lied to, by one side or the other.  Now lawyer for Otto Rene Salguero Morales asks for discovery from the Geovanny Fuentes Ramirez trial.

Judge Castel: So when will this case be ready for trial? Lawyer for Otto Rene Salguero Morales: I can't be sure yet. I'll be in New York next week.

 Judge Castel: OK, we'll get together again in six weeks. May 26 at 10:30 am.

Interim update: this morning's proceeding was technical and proceeding, but the case involves not only Presidential brother Tony Hernandez, but also... El Chapo. A photo of a filing from the case is here.

On April 7, Tony Hernandez filed notice of appeal to the Second Circuit - still with a lawyer paid by the US taxpayers, and even the $505 appeal fee waived: "Appeal Remark as to Juan Antonio Hernandez Alvarado re: [311] Notice of Appeal - Final Judgment. $505.00 Appeal Fee Waived. Attorney CJA."

 Also on April 7, another proceeding, this time in Judge Castel's own, smaller courtroom. Inner City Press live tweeted it here:

Mauricio Hernandez Pineda is in yellow prison jump suit. Inner City Press is alone in the gallery.  It has begun.

Mauricio Hernandez Pineda's lawyer Mr Leader has represented Zavala Velasquez in US v Lobo. Will he waive the conflict?

But first: he is 49, gets treatment for cholesterol. Brother passed away last week.

 US says both were members of same conspiracy. But Mauricio Hernandez Pineda waives any conflict of interest.

Proceeding is over. Next date is June 8, 2:30 pm, time excluded with US citing possible "pre-trial disposition" talks, which is standard

  On April 5, Inner City Press began asking what has happened with the 2018 indictment of Midence Oqueli Martinez Turcios? Since July 2018, there is nothing in the docket, although Honduran media reported he had turned himself in to the DEA. Where is he? Who might he testify against? Indictment and more on Patreon here.

 On April 2, with the indictment of El Tigre Bonilla still listed as "under seal," Inner City Press published the indictment on its DocumentCloud, here. Why is this still listed as sealed? Watch this site.

From March 30: Judge Castel: Juan Antonio Hernandez Alvarado, you are remanded to be imprisoned for life on Count 1... & 30 years on Count 2, consecutive. Forfeiture of $138.5 million. No fine.

Judge Castel: You have the right to appeal, including as a poor person. I hope that while you are in person you will reflect on your life and what you've done and turn your life around. Perhaps you can do some good for your family and your country.

 Defense lawyer Brill: I will file a notice of appeal, and then be relieved. Judge Castel: We are adjourned.

A question still: Does the right to access to Federal court proceedings extend to listen-only telephone lines, in the time of COVID and beyond? Should it?

 The question has been further raised in the ongoing Honduras narco-trafficking case US v. Geovanny Fuentes, which Inner City Press has been covering in-person in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, where it is "in-house press."

   On the morning of March 13, Inner City Press filed a challenge to the cut-off of audio access to the US v. Fuentes trial, citing the First Amendment, COVID and real-world politics, see here and below.

  Late on the evening of March 14, the US Attorney's Office filed a three page letter into the docket, specifically arguing the the call-in line be eliminated for two entire Witnesses and everything they say. US Attorney's Office's letter, now uploaded on Inner City Press' DocumentCloud, here.

 Inner City Press has immediately responded in opposition, here, stating among other things that "the US Attorney's Office seeks to specifically ban public access to two of their Witnesses, while saying that a transcript would be available at some unspecified date afterwards. Given that the Office has yet to unseal improperly redacted portions of their filings, there is little reason to have confidence in the speed of transcription, or that such transcripts would not be too expensive for the public or media. 

Inner City Press after its first filing waited nine hours, including this song, here, to report about it. Full first letter on Inner City Press' DocumentCloud, here.

  Inner City Press itself obeys all existing rules and is grateful for the additional access as in-house media (particularly since it is banned from covering the UN, which now Constitutional rights such as the First Amendment exist).

  But others have rights too - including journalists and regular citizens of Honduras. If the SDNY prosecutors are going to exercises essentially universal jurisdiction for any wire transfer that passes through lower Manhattan, how ever briefly, they should not oppose access to their trials by those impacted, for better and worse.

Judge Castel is a good judge, in Inner City Press' experience. When petitioned he has ordered the unsealing of certain court documents, in a North Korea crypto-currency conference case and the tech / child sex sentencing of Peter Bright former of ArsTechnica, both of which Inner City Press covered and requested. And Judge Castel is certainly in the mainstream in his March 12 psoition. But should it be rethought? Is there a right? Should there be? Watch this site.

The case is US v. Diaz, 15-cr-379 (Castel).

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Passing of SDNY Convicted Albert Vilar Noted Amid UN Echo Of Real Estate Corruption

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Sept 8 – The saga of Alberto Vilar in the Southern District of New York has been well known, including his re-sentencing to ten years for refusing to pay his victims, and more recently claims he can't, living off a $2,200 a month Social Security check.

On September 8, the Court was informed that "Defendant Albert Vilar passed away in his sleep on September 4, 2021 at his home in Queens County, New York." Noted.

 The United Nations connections, we had not known until now.   And now we know more.

 First, the present, Judge Richard J. Sullivan's order of July 30: "Minute Entry for proceedings held before Judge Richard J. Sullivan: Oral Argument as to Alberto William Vilar, Gary Alan Tanaka held on 7/30/2021. The Court held oral argument via ZoomGov videoconference on the government's motion to dismiss several third-party petitions filed in connection with the Court's August 2, 2019 and December 9, 2019 Preliminary Orders of Forfeiture as to Substitute Assets...The Court reserved decision on the pending motion to dismiss. The Court directed the Pension Scheme and the government to submit a joint letter by August 13, 2021 proposing a schedule for discovery, summary judgment, and an ancillary hearing."  

Docketed on August 20 is a letter from Laurie Christov, amplifying what she said in the July 30 proceeding: "I feel my oral arguments at the hearing on July 30 feel woefully short... the condition the arbitrator put on my husband's award was the worst case of unjust enrichment, leaving the burden of removal to Vilar and Tanaka, which of course they did not do, why would they?" Why indeed.

 Digging back through the docket, Inner City Press came upon Judge Sullivan's order (Docket Number 537) denying bail to Vilar, and specifically declining to credit the declaration of of Walter Pfaeffle "asserting that Defendant Vilar is not a flight risk."  

The underlying declaration by Walter Pfaeffle, a United Nations correspondent when Inner City Press was there and apparently still there, in the unresponsive UN Correspondents Association, said that

 "I am a German-born freelance journalist... Early on I invested successfully in residential properties. I live in one and rent out the other... I met Alberto Vilar for the first time in June 2005 following his release from the MCC. At the time, Alberto's then lady-friend helped arrange his $4 million bail package, to which I contributed... We often had dinner together and sometimes attended the opera... I was, somewhat by default, left in charge of emptying his apartment at 860 United Nations Plaza."

 But now on August 10, still awaiting the August 13 filing (and staring at a BOP site saying "ALBERTO VILAR Register Number: 57828-054 Age:     80 Race:     White Sex:     Male Released On: 09/10/2018," here's more on Pfaeffle, from another case, Ackermann v. Levine, 610 F. Supp. 633 (S.D.N.Y. 1985) -

 "present at the meeting was a friend of Mr. Bauer's, Walter Pfaeffle, a West German journalist living in New York who spoke both German and English and who Mr. Bauer referred to as his "financial consultant," a status not supported by the proof. (Tr. 463) At the conclusion of the meeting, Mr. Bauer agreed to keep in touch with defendant after he returned to West Germany; the two were to communicate through Mr. Pfaeffle (he possessed a Telex machine). (Tr. 306; 308) It was defendant's understanding that Mr. Pfaeffle would share in the commission. (Tr. 334)."

Ah, the UN - where the correspondents are supported by real estate speculation, as landlords, and bail out fraudsters who refuse to pay their victims. We'll have more on this.  The case is US v. Vilar, et al., 05-cr-621 (Sullivan). 

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

In PPP Fraud Case of Apocalypse Bella Lawyer For Toussaint Summoned to SDNY From Texas

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Sept 8 –   In a Paycheck Protection Program fraud prosecution of Apocalypse Bella, Mackenzy Toussaint and others, a defense lawyer is being summoned to New York, seemingly to be fired by the judge.        

   On September 8 U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Paul A. Engelmayer held a proceeding. Inner City Press covered it.   

Toussaint's lawyer Bret Martin, who said his Texas office is 15 minutes from where Toussaint lives, had missed the prior proceeding.

 He cited a medical procedure for his daughter, but was asked why he had not contacted the court, or arranged to get the transcript of the proceeding that he missed.  

Eventually he was ordered to come to New York with his client on September 15, in person, and to be prepared to discusses his retainer agreement.

The case is US v. Bella, et al., 21-cr-247 (Engelmayer)


***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

In SDNY Shulaya Enterprise Boxer Khurtsidze Disputes Above-Guidelines Re-Sentencing

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, CEFC Video, Scope

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Sept 7 – On March 26, 2019 when  Eleonora Podilska appeared for a jail sentence prior to being deported to Ukraine, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New YOrk Judge Loretta Preska was told how Podilska made Christmas ornaments in the MCC jail and saw her dream of opening a dance school in the U.S. crushed by her guilty plea. The government's sentencing letter said, "Podilska pleaded guilty on December 20, 2018, to a one-count indictment (the “Indictment”) charging her with racketeering conspiracy. Podilska was charged with her limited role in a credit card theft conspiracy and her more principal role in a scheme to seduce and rob men identified as targets by members of the Shulaya Enterprise. The Government respectfully submits that a sentence within the stipulated Guidelines range of 15 to 21 months is appropriate in this case." In the end Judge Preska, who the day before heard of UN briber Patrick Ho playing the violin the MCC, went slightly below, at one year and one day. She wished Podilska well, with her special needs son and what her lawyer called the bad conditions in Ukraine.

  Jump cut to September 7, 2021, when co-defendant Avtandil Khurtsidze is coming up for re-sentencing. His lawyer complains that he is the only one for whom the US Attorney's Office is asking for an above-guidelines sentence. He's been a model inmate, it's said. He flew to America from the Republic of Georgia hoping to continue his "rising boxing career." Then he was arrested for his participation in aspects of the Shulaya Enterprise.

The case was United States v. Shulaya, 17 Cr. 350 (LAP).

***

In Jan 6 Oath Keepers Case Race Baiting of Defendants Alleged, Corruptly Called Unconstitutionally Vague

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Podcast Song Filing  II Video Podcast
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

FEDERAL COURT, Sept 8 -- Months after the DC Circuit's decisions in US v. Munchel and more recently Tanios, on September 8 DDC Judge Amit P. Mehta held a lengthy proceeding in the Oath Keepers cases before him, on the Constitutionality of charges and the bias of the DC jury pool. Inner City Press live tweeted it, here:

Defense lawyer says Shouting in Congress, that's what we do. It's not obstruction of Congress for purposes of the statute, or Poindexter, or 1502.

Judge Mehta: You cannot compare standing up in a Committee Room and what these defendants are being accused of, at least in terms of state of mind.

Defense: What about interrupting confirmation hearings? Judge Mehta: They weren't charged with obstruction.

Judge Mehta: Ms Hernandez, it's better not to interrupt me when I'm trying to move on. Tell me why the plain text of the statute, 1512, doesn't reach this conduct: corruptly obstructs or impedes any proceeding?

Hernandez: During confirmation of Justice Kavenaugh- Now Hernandez quotes Justice Ginzberg that it is not the court's job to fill in or expand what Congress did (in that instance, a spoliation statute).

Judge Mehta: What about 1512(c)(2) - isn't that a catch all provision? Hernandez: That's what the government says.

Judge Mehta, to AUSA: So is a person stands up in a Supreme Court confirmation hearing and says, Stop the proceeding - is that a 20 year felony? AUSA: Likely not.

Judge Mehta: Let's not pretend this was simple parading. Hernandez: Some acted illegally. My client did not assault anyone. Judge Mehta: Isn't this a jury question? Hernandez: The statute is unconstitutionally vague.

Hernandez: Maybe some were jerks. Judge Mehta: Let's move to Count 4, remaining in a restricted or protected area. Why is Judge McFadden wrong? Defense: It creates chaos, anyone could do the protecting. It should be limited to a Secret Service protectee

 Defense: Mr. Caldwell never entered the Capitol building. Judge Mehta: He was on the balcony. Isn't that like the rotunda? Defense: No. Judge Mehta: There's a map associated with the statute. D: Mr. Caldwell and the VP were never contemporaneously on the grounds

Lawyer for Joshua James: We have a right to know which session of the grand jury, under the Arthur Anderson case. Judge Mehta: What does it matter, which particular grand jury that's been empaneled over these many months, was alleged impeded by Mr. James?

 Defense: We want to change venue. There is so much prejudice against these defendants -- Judge Mehta: How do you know that? Defense: This city is anti Donald Trump.

Judge Mehta: Do you have any polling data? Defense: My client doesn't have the thirty or forty thousand dollars lying around to do polling. Judge Mehta: You are arguing that DC residents are repulsed by traditional American values. Don't we here have American values? This brief reads like a blog.

Judge Mehta: Casting aspersion against people who live in this District is not the way to go. This brief looks like it's been ripped out of blog posts. It's not going to fly. Case law requires more. 

Defense: I'm not trying to denigrate the citizens of DC. Defense: My client and these defendants have been subject to race baiting day after day. He's not a racist. But everyday the Washington Post and the Attorney General and the President call him a white supremacist.

 Judge Mehta: I'm not condoning that either. We ought not to be characterizing people in large groups. I expect any jury selected would do the same. Hernandez: I'd like to file more.

Judge Mehta: Meet the deadline. Sometimes you don't. I would like more from DOJ

 AUSA: We'd like three weeks. Judge Mehta: I'll give you two, to the 22nd. Any defense reply by October 6. I'm already 15 minutes late to a meeting. Let's convene next Thursday at 11. Can we bring the detainees to court? They are reducing from five rooms to two.

 Judge Mehta: Mr. McMann is out of the country but co-counsel Mr. Spina can make it. See you all on the 16th at 11 am. Adjourned.

On Kenneth Harrelson on August 5, Inner City Press filed a letter and motion with Judge Mehta, on its DocumentCloud here.

On August 16, this: "Judge Mehta is in receipt of your email requesting access to the videos filed in United States v. Harrelson, No. 21-cr-28-10.  Under Standing Order No. 21-28, in order for the court to grant Inner City Press access to the videos filed in Mr. Harrelson’s case, you will need to file an application for access pursuant to D.D.C. Local Criminal Rule 57.6."

That rule provides: "Any news organization or other interested person, other than a party or a subpoenaed witness, who seeks relief relating to any aspect of proceedings in a criminal case... shall file an application for such relief with the Court. The application shall include a statement of the applicant's interest in the matter as to which relief is sought, a statement of facts, and a specific prayer for relief."

So, citing the Rule, Inner City Press filed another letter, one page, docketed here

Podcast here.  And Podcast II of August 19 here.

Now on August 19, it's been granted (shouldn't have been necessary): "MINUTE ORDER as to KENNETH HARRELSON (10) granting Inner City Press's 343 Application for Access to Video Exhibits. The United States shall make available to Inner City Press the video exhibits entered into evidence during the detention hearing of KENNETH HARRELSON (10), consistent with the procedures set forth in Standing Order 21-28. Inner City Press is granted permission to record, copy, download, retransmit, and otherwise further publish these video exhibits. Signed by Judge Amit P. Mehta on 8/19/2021."

So now, immediately, put on Inner City Press' YouTube, video here

Similarly, Inner City Press asked DOJ and then Judge Timothy Kelly for access to the videos that DOJ had shown to the court in the case: judicial documents that, under case law, must be made available to the public. But it was denied access, on the theory that Judge Kelly's order earlier in the month limited access to these judicial documents to a particular sub-set of the public.

 Inner City Press on July 27 wrote to Judge Kelly, including in the form of a motion, now on DocumentCloud, here. By noon the next day, July 28, nothing - no responses, no response. We'll have more on this. For now, podcast here; music video here.

Inner City Press live tweeted Riley June Williams on January 25, here. 


  From January 22, song here: Thread here.

 Inner City Press' John Earle Sullivan song on SoundCloud here. 


***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.