Saturday, September 11, 2021

Another Case of UN Racism On Which Guterres Won't Answer Press So Petition

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Appeal SG Response
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

UN GATE, Sept 4 – How corrupt and unaccountable is today's United Nations?

 Well, in November 2020 Inner City Press went to attend and report on a UN Dispute Tribunal proceeding about a case of sexual harassment in the UN, a proceeding which was announced as open to the public, as US court cases are. 

 But when Inner City Press signed in and gave its name, it was excluded. Later, when it obtained and published evidence presented in the case, a UN Dispute Tribunal judge ordered it to destroy the evidence or be banned from all future proceedings. 

 This while UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres falsely claims to have zero tolerance for sexual harassment and abuse, while himself banning Inner City Press from UN briefings now for 1251 days.

  On August 24, Inner City Press - without any recording of which it was baselessly accused after UN sex abuse evidence was leaked to it by UN staff disgusted with Guterres' cover ups - live tweeted another UNDT proceeding from Nairobi, about collusion with the Ethiopian government, here and below.

Then on Augst 29 we noted this typical case of racism in the UN of Guterres: "The Applicant has served as a Conflict Resolution Officer at the P-4 level with UNOMS since September 2004. 3. The Applicant also acts as the President of the United Nations People of African Descent (“UNPAD”), an ad hoc special interest group created in 2016 to raise awareness about issues of racism in the United Nations.

4. In October 2019, in her capacity as President of UNPAD, the Applicant wrote to senior officials of the United Nations advocating on behalf of a staff member. 5. By email dated 24 October 2019, the Ombudsman informed the Applicant that she should step down immediately from any leadership role and active participation with UNPAD. The Ombudsman stated that “[her] role as president of UNPAD undermines the neutrality and independence of the office” whose role is not to advocate on behalf of any one individual employee. The Ombudsman wrote that there was a conflict of interest when the Applicant advocated for a staff member who was referred to UNOMS and there was a potential conflict of interest in future cases.

6. On 4 November 2019, the Ombudsman received an email from the Director of the Division of Healthcare-Management Occupational Safety and Health (“DHMOSH”) informing her that the Applicant, as a Conflict Resolution Officer in  Case No. UNDT/NY/2021/035 Order No. 78 (NY/2021) Page 3 of 13 UNOMS, was requesting a meeting concerning a staff member she had previously advocated for as President of UNPAD. The next day, the Ombudsman responded to the Director of DHMOSH that the Applicant was not acting on UNOMS’s behalf and had no authority or standing to discuss such private sensitive issues.

7. On 1 April 2020, the Applicant began a temporary assignment with the United Nations Economic Commission for Africa. 8. In early March 2021, the Ombudsman was notified that the Applicant would be returning to UNOMS, effective 1 April 2021. 9. On 8 March 2021, the Ombudsman reached out to the Ethics Office to request an opinion as to whether the Applicant’s service as President of UNPAD represents a conflict of interest with her duties as a Conflict Resolution Officer in UNOMS. 10. On 12 March 2021, the Director of the Ethics Office responded that it constituted a conflict of interest, stating that “the official duty of a UNOMS staff member to remain independent and neutral would conflict with leading and representing UNPAD and its staff special interest”. The Director of the Ethics Office continued that “it is for the Head of Entity to assess whether a particular act or omission raises a potential conflict of interest” and that staff members are obliged “to follow instructions on how to resolve the situation, including to avoid and remove the conflict or the circumstances that make it a possible conflict”.

11. On 15 April 2021, the Deputy to the Ombudsman wrote an email to the Applicant to discuss her work plan for the 2021-22 cycle. In the email, the Deputy to the Ombudsman wrote that the Applicant would directly report to him and that she would take over several focal point functions. 12. On 23 April 2021, the Ombudsman informed the Applicant that the Deputy had been placed on sick leave for the remainder of his tenure with UNOMS. Noting that the Deputy had started discussions with the Applicant on her work plan, the Ombudsman asked the Applicant to clarify whether she was still serving as President  of UNPAD in order to make an informed decision on her workplan.

The Ombudsman reminded the Applicant that it had been determined that there is a conflict of interest between the work of a Conflict Resolution Officer in UNOMS and her position as President of UNPAD. 13. On 28 April 2021, the Ombudsman wrote an email to the Applicant. She stated that she understood that the Applicant was still the President of UNPAD and would not step down and asked the Applicant to clarify in writing. The Ombudsman warned that in the absence of any clarification in writing, she would proceed to take the administrative actions that she deemed appropriate. 14. On 30 April 2021, the Ombudsman wrote to the Applicant that until her status with UNPAD was clarified, the Ombudsman could not complete any discussions around work assignments and stated that she had not been given any assigned work.

15. On 12 May 2021, the Ombudsman issued a written reprimand to the Applicant for the continuation of the conflict of interest. 16. On 16 June 2021, the Applicant was notified that her fixed-term appointment would not be renewed beyond its expiration on 31 August 2021. The Applicant requested the reasons for the non-renewal decision and received the following response: [The Ombudsman] advised that her decision not to renew your appointment is based on the ongoing conflict of interest with your role as President of UNPAD, which is in conflict with your position as a conflict resolution officer requiring neutrality as per the mandate of the Office of the Ombudsman.

[The Ombudsman] further advised that she has repeatedly communicated the conflict of interest with you but that you have taken no action in this regard. Due to this conflict of interest, [the Ombudsman] indicated that she has not been able to assign you any work related to conflict resolution, the role for which you were recruited.

[The Ombudsman] stated that this has been the situation since your return from a temporary assignment 1 April 2020. Case No. UNDT/NY/2021/035 Order No. 78 (NY/2021) Page 5 of 13 17. On 16 August 2021, the Applicant received the memorandum titled “Separation upon expiration of appointment”

  NOTE: Ms. Kamara-Joyner is a “Conflict Resolution Officer” in the Ombudsman's office, which is patently incapable of mediating or resolving a conflict in the Ombudsman's office. Close observers note that counsel for the Secretary-General is arguing that if you are black, and you take an active role in a UN organization to raise awareness of racism – you cannot get involved in drawing attention to a blatant case of racism because that would compromise your independence given your role in the Ombudsman's office.  In Big Tony's UN it's perfectly OK to have a group that raises awareness about issues of racism in the UN – provided that they don't actually raise any specific examples of racism in the UN…. which rather begs the question of what purpose it actually serves.

  Since then, UN Spokespeople Stephane Dujarric and Melissa Fleming have request Inner City Press' written requests to for comment on this. Meanwhile, there's an online petition, here.
We'll have more on all this.

From August 24: now a case in UN kangaroo court in Nairobi. UNDP Country Director Samuel Bwalya is charged with conspiring with minister of Ethiopia goverment.

Bwalya's "lawyer" Edwin had his cross examination cut off by UNDP representative Esther Shamash. Then he was cut off altogether.

 Bwalya's "lawyer" is back. UN "judge" Rachel Sikwese immediately rules to exclude evidence, and questioning, in this case about UN colluding with Ethiopia government / Minister.  Now on next question, UNDP's Shamash objects. And the document is out.

The witness, who is being protected by UNDP's rep and it seems the judge, seems to be named Helina Tadisse. But that camera is not on. Unclear how any finder of fact would make a judgment about credibility.

 Balwya's lawyer: So the Minister was very happy with the UN's work? Witness: He was satisfied, yes.  Balwya's lawyer: In processing the procurement contract- Witness: I don't recall. I don't remember. Balwya's lawyer: You don't remember. UNDP: Asked and answered!

 Balwya's lawyer: If we can go into the report, I will conclude. Judge: We are waiting. UNDP "counsel" - These matters are not before the tribunal. [Inner City Press: Like UN claims its giving of Uighur names to China is not in case of  Emma Reilly

 Bwalya's lawyer: Did you provide that to the ATA? Witness: I may have, I don't remember. Bwalya's lawyer: That doesn't help me much. UNDP's "counsel" - I'm being blindsided. [Reference to a bundle that is apparently not public.]

Now Judge lets UNDP "lawyer," who reps UNSG  @AntonioGuterres , run the table. Guterres has had Inner City Press banned from UN briefing for 1249 days - and  @UN_Spokesperson  doesn't answer it questions, or Quinn Emanuel letter, video here.

  On evidenc destruction-gate, banned Inner City Press' timely appeal has been "deferred" from Guterres' kangaroo Appeals Tribunal, until October 2022 at least, while his Melissa Fleming refuses to answer even a major US law firm - this is impunity, see below.

Now this UN report complains, "15. During the reporting period, the holding of public hearings remotely raised its own set of difficulties. The registries experienced difficulties in controlling the access to the virtual public gallery, which is not problematic in the physical courtroom. It is also more difficult to control whether the public abide by the Tribunal’s instructions, in particular the prohibition of recording the hearing." No, UN staff disgusted with Guterres' cover ups leak.

The deferral: "The June 2021 Synopsis file of UNAT judgments was published.  They heard only 32 appeals, and the last appeal number heard in the session was 1468. So Inner City Press'  appeal number 1502 won't be considered at a minimum until the late October 2021 session.    The current estimated time from submitting an appeal to being considered is almost one year.   Speedy justice?  The Guterres Administration knows and exploits this.  A typical UNDT case takes at least 18 months and then the appeals process takes at least a year.   Hence why the Administration appeal every successful UNDT judgement by a staff member, it costs them nothing, while it costs the staff member plenty, as well as delaying any justice they may end up getting, which is usually little. Guterres' UN is corrupt - and cannot be allowed to continue banning the Press which reported on it.

  In the case Inner City Press was ordered to destroy evidence of who-done-it, even the UNDT has found Padula guilty - but has insisted that he be anonymized, that is, covered up for. The shameful order is here, and recites for example that the person - Padula - covered up for

.“grabbed [AA’s] face, held her closely, leaned forward and attempted to kiss her”; b. “when [AA] resisted [the Applicant] kissing her, [he] forced [AA’s] head down and kissed her on the forehead”;  c. “grabbed [BB’s] face, held her closely, leaned forward and attempted to kiss her”; d. “tried to move physically close to [AA] and [BB] while dancing, despite their attempts to keep [him] at a distance”; e. “attempted to grab [CC’s] face; when she blocked her face with her hands, [the Applicant] grabbed her hands and tried to pull them apart; when she resisted, [he] fell on her forcefully”; and f. “took and pulled [CC’s] hands to try to get her to dance, despite her resistance”.

  But in Guterres' UN they do not want the public to know who did this - and the Press which exclusively published and name and evidence is banned and its written questions not answered. On the morning of February 4, 12 hours before publishing this when no answer was received from Guterres, Dujarric, Fleming, Amina J. Mohammed et al., Inner City Press in writing asked this: "what are SG Guterres comments and more importantly action on the UN Dispute Tribunal on Feb 3 confirming sexual charges against Padula - while having told Inner City Press to destroy all evidence or remain bannned, and maintaining Padula's name sealed, confirming the cover-up culture under Guterres?"

 The UN claims it has to protect the identity of Padula (and will NOT report him to NYPD for any criminal offense) because they have to protect the identity of the VICTIMS - it's like Guterres' rationale for covering up genocide and mass killing, for example in Cameroon.

  Inner City Press is even banned from submitting questions by WebEx, on which the International Monetary Fund for example answers its questions, as it did on February 4 about the Burma coupl. The only difference is Guterres and his corruption.

   On December 21 Inner City Press filed a formal appeal with the UN Appeals Tribunal, full filing here on DocumentCloud.

 And now in late January Guterres' long time Portuguese lawyer Miguel de Serpa Soares has responded, that Guterers is not waiving immunity, impunity response on Document Cloud here. Impunity.

 On the morning of January 26 Inner City Press emailed Guterres and his spokespeople this question: " Given that the UNDT order destruction of evidence concerning sexual harassment inside the UN, why is SG Guterres not waiving immunity?" No answer.

  

 

We will have more, including listing more of those complicit in the UN's cover up of abuse. Watch this site.

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Saturday, September 4, 2021

Federal Reserve on OneCoin & Wirecard FOIA Takes 5 Month to Deny, Inner City Press Appeal

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon FOIA Denial
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

SDNY COURT / BRONX, Sept 4 –    The Federal Reserve took five months to act on Inner City Press' Freedom of Information Act request about OneCoin, Wirecard and marijuana banking - and that provided no documents at all.  Denial on DocumentCloud here.

In response to Inner City Press' March 2021 FOIA request, the Fed on August 31 wrote:

"This is in reference to your email message dated March 10, 2021 and received by  the Board’s Information Disclosure Section on March 11. In your email, you note that  “Inner City Press has been covering the US v. Weigand bank fraud trial in the SDNY[.]”  In light of this coverage, and pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act (“FOIA”), 5  U.S.C. § 552, you request: all records in the possession or control of the FRS, from the past three  years, regarding Wirecard, including but not reference to the bank’s  collapse’s implications for the FRS’ view of German bank regulation  under FBSEA [and] all records the FRS has, in the past three years,  regarding [Gilbert] Armenta, Ruja Ignatova, Mark Scott and/or  OneCoin, and also regarding marijuana banking, central to the case(s).

With respect to the part of your request seeking the past three years’ worth of  records regarding Wirecard, staff searched Board records but did not locate any  information related to implications of “the bank’s collapse” or the Weigand case you  reference in your request.1   With respect to the part of your request seeking all records “regarding [Gilbert]  Armenta, Ruja Ignatova, Mark Scott and/or OneCoin” for the past three years, staff  searched Board records and located one responsive document.

 I have determined,  however, that the responsive information constitutes confidential supervisory information  (e.g., a supervisory report). This information is subject to withholding and will be withheld pursuant to exemption 8 of the FOIA, 5 U.S.C. § 552(b)(8).    

  Inner City Press has appealed:

"This is a FOIA appeal of the Deputy Secretary's August 31, 2021 denial in full of my and Inner City Press' March 10, 2021 FOIA request for 

'all records in the possession or control of the FRS, from the past three years, regarding Wirecard, including but not reference to the bank’s collapse’s implications for the FRS’ view of German bank regulation under FBSEA [and] all records the FRS has, in the past three years, regarding [Gilbert] Armenta, Ruja Ignatova, Mark Scott and/or OneCoin, and also regarding marijuana banking, central to the case(s)"    After taking more than five months, the Federal Reserve says it has no records about Wirecard, and only one about OneCoin, which it withholds in full. This is an appeal - and a request for how the Fed can justify taking five months to provide no documents at all.    As to Wirecard, the request is not as circumscribed as the response makes it appear. Given the payments issues raised by the Wirecard collapse, Inner City Press finds it hard to believe that the Fed has no records concerning it. And since the Federal Reserve did not and does not regulate or supervised OneCoin, Inner City Press contests the invocation of the bank supervision exemption to withhold this record in full. Particular given statements on cryptocurrency from Federal Reserve officials, for example the present of the Minneapolis Federal Reserve, that the entire Federal Reserve System claims to have a single document about OneCoin is not credible.   As to marijuana banking, to refuse to provide any documents is unacceptable. Given the legal issues of this substance being illegal federally but legal in several states, it is impossible to believe that the Fed has not provided guidance to banks on the topic. Those records are responsive, particularly after five months."

Watch this site. 

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

OCC Protest of South State-Atlantic Capital Under CRA, How Will Hsu Differ from Before?

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Story
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

FEDERAL COURT / S Bronx, Sept 4 – Whether or not the U.S. Community Reinvestment Act will be again enforced until the new Administration and its regulators is an open question.

Now the proposed acquisition by South State of Atlantic Capital Bank in Georgia will be a litmus test. South State is so disparate that in South Carolina in 2020 for mortgage loans to African Americans it had more denials (147) than loans made (133) - while making six loans to whites for every denial to a white applicant.

On August 17, Fair Finance Watch and Inner City Press on the FOIA) filed a comment with the Federal Reserve Board, below.

Now on September 4, Fair Finance Watch has commented to the Office of the Comptroller Currency, which some say has changed for the better. We'll see.

As to the Fed, which denies FOIA requests after five months, here, on August 25, this strange response: "Dear Mr. Lee,     This is to acknowledge receipt of your email to the Office of the Secretary for the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (Board) dated August 17, 2021, regarding the proposal of South State Corporation to merge with Atlantic Capital Bancshares, Inc., and thereby indirectly acquire Atlantic Capital Bank, NA.  To date, South State Corporation has not filed an application with the Federal Reserve System.  Currently, the public comment period for the proposal will end on September 20, 2021. 

   If an application is filed within the next three months from the date your comment was sent, your correspondence will be made part of the record, and the Board will evaluate your comment.  We will also send a copy of the public portions of the application as soon as possible after the application is received.     Sincerely,     Jennifer Snow  Senior Examiner  Supervision, Regulation, and Credit  Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta     Integrity. Excellence. Respect."

How can there be a comment period with expiration date, if there is no application? Inner City Press asked, and on August 26 is told:

"Our procedures provide that advance notice in the Federal Register may be requested in advance of a filing. The comment period end date applies to the Federal Register notice, which was filed in advance of the application being filed."

   What - the comment period running to its conclusion, before any application to comment on is available? This seems far too bank-friendly. How does it relate to the administration's Antitrust Memo? Watch this site.

Dear Chair Powell, Secretary Misback and others in the FRS:   This is  a timely first comment opposing the Applications of South State Corporation to merge with Atlantic Capital Bancshares, Inc., and thereby indirectly acquire Atlantic Capital Bank, NA .

 Fair Finance Watch has been tracking South State Bank NA:  The applicant's South State Bank NA in 2020 in Florida based on its disparate marketing made 5721 mortgage loans to whites, with 1019 denials to whites -- while making only 143 loans to African Americans, with 48 denials. This is far out of keeping with the demographics, and other lenders, in Florida - this is outrageous. 

This is a pattern. South State Bank NA in 2020 in South Carolina based on its disparate marketing made 3048 mortgage loans to whites, with 537 denials to whites -- while making only 133 loans to African Americans, with fully 147 denials. This is far out of keeping with the demographics, and other lenders, in South Carolina. The denials to African Americans are... outrageous.   

Perhaps most relevant, South State is disparate in the state it is trying to make this acquisition to impose and expand its practices. South State Bank NA in 2020 in Georgia based on its disparate marketing made 4068 mortgage loans to whites, with 451 denials to whites -- while making only 494 loans to African Americans, with 120 denials. This is far out of keeping with the demographics, and other lenders, in Georgia - this is outrageous.

 The comment period should be extended; evidentiary hearings should be held; and on the current record, the application should not be approved.


 Inner City Press (and Fair Finance Watch, on the HMDA) will have more to say about this. Watch this site.

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

In XRP Case Ripple Wants Trading Records of SEC Staff and Family on Crypto, SEC Says No

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Podcast
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Sept 3 – In SEC v. Ripple Labs Inc. et al., a discovery hearing was held on April 30 before U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Magistrate Judge Netburn. Inner City Press live tweeted it, see below, then put underlying emails on Patreon here.

On May 21, after an SEC submission now on Patreon here, podcast here, Judge Netburn held another conference, this time on whether the SEC can get access to legal advise to Ripple. Inner City Press fought to cover it and did, live tweeting it here and below.

On September 3, the SEC opposed Ripple's motion to compel the production of details of the trading of SEC employees and their family members. The SEC argues that its policy states that even ethically cleared transactions do not imply that what is bought is legal. Watch this site.

On August 31, Judge Netburn held another proceeding, and agreed to review documents in camera as to which the SEC asserts deliberative process privilege. Inner City Press live tweeted it, here and below, and now publishes from the case an email involving Tenreiro and others saying

"Thanks for your email. We did not agree to produce any DAEO list but did agree to look into your question regarding the presence of BTC, ETH, or XRP on such a list and to provide any additional SEC internal trading policies from 2013-18. This email addresses your questions re the DAEO list and we will produce a small number of additional policies this week. Our Ethics Office has a “Prohibited Holdings” list pertaining to securities that fall within 5 C.F.R. 4401.102(c)(1). BTC, ETH, and XRP have never appeared on this list." On Patreon here.

August 31 thread: Defense lawyer: We have been put through the ringer on discovery. But now the SEC is asserting deliberative privilege in a grossly overbroad way. On that basis alone, your Honor is empowered to order disclosure of all of these documents.

SEC's Jorge Tenreiro: No outsider would have knowledge of SEC internal deliberations. From our perspective, the case from the DC Circuit means knowledge of the underlying facts. A judge in this district adopted it [He does not name the judge]

Now Tenreiro does name an SDNY judge, says Judge Hellerstein denied discovery, external and internal, into the SEC. Judge Netburn: Is it the SEC's position that to determine if Mr Garlinghouse was reckless, you'll look at what was out in the public?

Tenreiro: He can say, I thought it was not a security. Judge Netburn: But that's a subjective test. To see if it was objectively reasonable, they are saying you have to see what the SEC Commissioners were saying at lunch. 

 SEC's Tenreiro: The law is what the law is. It doesn't matter what SEC staff think or say inside the SEC if the public is never told it. The deliberative process privilege protects this.

SEC's Tenreiro: They're saying, We're a unique asset - but we have a right to see everything said inside the SEC about other assets, this expanding segment of our economy. Disclosure would harm the quality of our internal dialogue, contrary to the NLRB case.

 Judge Netburn: So we're saying the privilege applies to a whole host of deliberations. But does the Court need to know the moment in time that the deliberations have ceased? Can there be perpetual deliberation on these complex issues?

Judge Netburn: It's my inclination to conduct an in-camera review, as proposed by the defendants. SEC's Tenreiro: There's a body of case law saying the privilege logs can be corrected and you need to consider prejudice to the privilege holder.

SEC's Tenreiro: Someone unmuted their line... I'm troubled by the request in Appendix A - they want conversations with other parties, and notes. Disclosing these would undermine our ability to gather information. The professor is on the pay-roll. There's a Senator

 SEC's Tenreiro: Ann Walworth (sp) works in terrorism finance --

Judge Netburn: I'm proposing that I review the documents. I may find them too far afield to be subject to discovery. But your privilege is a qualified privilege, unlike the attorney / client privilege

 Judge Netburn: I'd like the documents and a letter brief from the SEC, filed on the public record with redactions as limited as possible, a response (no reply needed), then I'll rule

 Judge Netburn: Mr. Tenreiro, when would you like to file your letter brief? I'd like 10 pages single spaced, or 20 pages double. SEC's Tenreiro: 2 weeks. Defense: 2 week after that for the response. Judge Netburn: So September 28. Send me the documents in a binder

 Defense: The public has a right to know what's in the SEC notes. [Inner City Press agrees with that.]
 Adjourned

  On July 8, the SEC asked Magistrate Judge Netburn to quash Ripple's subpoena to depose William H. Hinman, former director of the SEC's Division of Corporate Finance. Inner City Press previously filmed pro-XRP picket on Lexington Avenue on this topic, and published the SEC's opposition on Patreon, here.

Now on August 26, Magistrate Judge Netburn has extended time for depositions, and expert discovery: "ORDER granting [312] Letter Motion for Extension of Time. The parties' request is GRANTED. The parties may conduct the depositions of Defendants Garlinghouse and Larsen after the close of the August 31, 2021 fact discovery deadline. The deadline to conduct expert discovery is extended to November 12, 2021. The deadline for the parties to exchange their respective Statements of Material Facts pursuant to Local Civil Rule 56.1 and their pre-motion letters regarding motions for summary judgment is adjourned sine die pending resolution of the motions to dismiss and strike. (HEREBY ORDERED by Magistrate Judge Sarah Netburn) (Text Only Order)."

On August 9 the SEC filed an "emergency letter motion" seeking a conference on getting all of Ripple's Slack messages. The SEC writes that Ripple refuses to give them "on the basis of Ripple's mistakes in gathering that data." But, the SEC says, "the relatively few Slack messages Ripple has produced have yielded critically important information." The filing, or some of it, is for Selected Parties Only. Watch this site.

 On July 15 Judge Netburn held an oral argument, below, and ruled that Hinman must sit for the deposition, given the public interest. But it may be delayed a week. Here is Inner City Press' thread: (and now pocast here)

Update: Now on July 16 the parties have written to Judge Netburn that Hinman's deposition is being pushed back to July 27, with possible briefing before them to resolve the scope. Watch this site.

From July 15: Judge Netburn: I have before me the subpoena seek to depose former SEC official Hinman, and the SEC application to quash. SEC? SEC's lawyer: If official have to testify, years after, it would have a chilling effect.

SEC lawyer: Let me cite again your Honor's decision in the 9/11 case. From Page 14 of your decision, you raised the issue of repetition and [wait for it] ripple effect. The burden on Ripple here is high, and they have not met it. Any questions? Judge Netburn: Yes

 Judge Netburn: Let's talk about his 2018 speech. The next prong of the analysis is how is the government defining the speech. He stated these were his own views... So how would answering questions interfere with the deliberative process of the SEC?

 SEC lawyer Ladan Stewart: A speech is a speech, it's on the SEC's website. There is no tension. Director Hinman consulted with others in the SEC about the speech. It was all pre-decisional...

Judge Netburn: So what was the decision made? SEC lawyer: There doesn't have to be a decision made. We found another case, not in our letter: it's Nacchio, 2009 Westlaw 211511, Dist of Colorado, Jan 29, 2009.  [If it's an SEC case, how could they not have "found" it?]

Judge Netburn: For what proposition are you citing the Nacchio case? SEC lawyer: That Mr. Hinman falls under deliberative process privilege. Judge Netburn: Would the privilege be invoked if Mr. Hinman were asked, Why do YOU think xyz? SEC: Yes.

 Ripple's lawyer: Mr. Hinman was trying to provide guidance -- Judge Netburn: Why do you say that? Ripple's lawyer: The SEC held it out to Congress as such. Then the agency points to the speech, it shows the speech was meant to provide guidance.

 Judge Netburn: But if the speech reflects agency guidance, isn't the process that led up to it covered by the deliberative process privilege? Ripple's lawyer: We want to establish, with the deposition, if this WAS the policy of the SEC.

 Ripple's lawyer: Mr. Hinman was never at the apex of the agency. The SEC is 4,200 employees. Mr. Hinman's department was much smaller. Between March 2018 and March 2019 he had a number of communications giving guidance. Ripple's lawyer: He was being asked, Is it an investment contract under Howey. Mr. Hinman met with the founder of the Ethereum Foundation... And of Consensus, a leading software developer for Ether.

Ripple's lawyer: We don't know who all the 3d parties he met with are. We want to ask him.  Judge Netburn: Mr. Rapawy, if you were asking me to depose him for a list of who he met with, I'd direct you to his chief of staff or deputy. You could get his calendar

 Ripple's lawyer: It's going to be hotly contested, we need everything we can get. And even if the speech were the decision, we could still do discovery about things after the speech. Let us do the deposition, then brief it afterward.

Ripple's lawyer: In unique cases, you do sometime get depositions of senior officials, like in the Judge Furman case, the Secretary of Commerce....  Martin Flemenbaum for Christian Larsen: We must be able to him about his other public remarks.

Judge Netburn: If I allow the deposition to go forward, it's Monday? Flumenbaum: The Defendants are prepared. SEC: We'd need time to evaluate. [Meaning, appeal?] SEC: They want to depose him twice - he declines to answer some, then they bring the transcript to you

 Judge Netburn: In Nacchio, the deposition in fact happened...  Defense: Mr. Hinman met with Ether a week before the speech. This is not covered by the privilege. SEC lawyer: If it goes forward, we'll be instructing not to answer the questions on privileged info

Rapawy: We don't agree to push this back. It should be possible to avoid 2 depositions, if invocations of privilege are reasonable. Matthew Solomon for Bradley Garlinghouse: My client will be sitting for a deposition during this discovery period. No more delay

Judge Netburn: The issues are complicated. I am going to rule in part. I am prepared to find Mr. Hinman was a high ranking official. He is entitled to the standard in the Lederman case, 731 F. 3d 199.  

Judge Netburn: I find that this case is unique, and that the amount in controversy is substantial. And the public's interest is significant. In this case, Mr. Hinman must sit for the deposition. I am going to authorize it.

Judge Netburn: It seems to me to put it off for a week and think about how the privilege will apply is a good idea. Let me know.  SEC: That makes sense to us. We will meet and confer and get back to the court. Ripple's lawyer: Will confer

Judge Netburn: Let me know by tomorrow afternoon, if deposition is Monday or a brief postponement, you could bring the issues of privilege to me. I will wait to hear back.

   On June 14, Judge Netburn agreed to sign and issue letters for request for the individual defendants, Bradley Garlinghouse and Christian A. Larsen, to iFinex, Bitforex, Bitrue Singapore, Coinbene Ltd Vanuatu, Coinone Co., Upbit and others. Full request letter on Patreon here.

Now on June 15, the letters have been picked up, and we learn that they will be going to the Central Authorities of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, the Cayman Islands, the British Virgin Islands, the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of China, the Republic of Singapore, the Republic of Seychelles, the Republic of Korea, and the Republic of Malta.

The filing: "LETTERS ROGATORY ISSUED on June 15, 2021, and picked up by Cleary Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton LLP and to be served in the Central Authorities of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, the Cayman Islands, the British Virgin Islands, the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of China, the Republic of Singapore, the Republic of Seychelles, the Republic of Korea, and the Republic of Malta.(km)"

On June 2, the SEC asked for a 60 day extension of time for discovery. Full 7-page letter on Patreon here.

On June 4, Ripple wrote to Judge Analisa Torres that they oppose any extension and will put in more paper next week. Watch this site.

On Memorial Day weekend, Judge Netburn  issued a 9-page order denying the SEC's request, without prejudice to it being renewed, full order on Patreon here: "OPINION & ORDER re: [165] LETTER MOTION for Local Rule 37.2 Conference addressed to Magistrate Judge Sarah Netburn from Jorge G. Tenreiro dated May 7, 2021, filed by Securities and Exchange Commission, [166] LETTER MOTION for Local Rule 37.2 Conference addressed to Magistrate Judge Sarah Netburn from Jorge G. Tenreiro dated May 7, 2021, filed by Securities and Exchange Commission. The SEC's motion is DENIED. If, at some later date, Ripple raises its good faith beliefs or relies upon its privileged communications in support of its fair notice defense, the Plaintiff may renew its application to the Court. Respectfully, the Clerk of Court is directed to deny the motions at ECF Nos. 165 and 166. (Signed by Magistrate Judge Sarah Netburn on 5/30/2021)."

 Inner City Press will stay on this.

The case is Securities and Exchange Commission v. Ripple Labs Inc. et al., 20-cv-10832 (Torres / Netburn)


***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.