Saturday, September 11, 2021

In Jan 6 Oath Keepers Case Race Baiting of Defendants Alleged, Corruptly Called Unconstitutionally Vague

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Podcast Song Filing  II Video Podcast
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

FEDERAL COURT, Sept 8 -- Months after the DC Circuit's decisions in US v. Munchel and more recently Tanios, on September 8 DDC Judge Amit P. Mehta held a lengthy proceeding in the Oath Keepers cases before him, on the Constitutionality of charges and the bias of the DC jury pool. Inner City Press live tweeted it, here:

Defense lawyer says Shouting in Congress, that's what we do. It's not obstruction of Congress for purposes of the statute, or Poindexter, or 1502.

Judge Mehta: You cannot compare standing up in a Committee Room and what these defendants are being accused of, at least in terms of state of mind.

Defense: What about interrupting confirmation hearings? Judge Mehta: They weren't charged with obstruction.

Judge Mehta: Ms Hernandez, it's better not to interrupt me when I'm trying to move on. Tell me why the plain text of the statute, 1512, doesn't reach this conduct: corruptly obstructs or impedes any proceeding?

Hernandez: During confirmation of Justice Kavenaugh- Now Hernandez quotes Justice Ginzberg that it is not the court's job to fill in or expand what Congress did (in that instance, a spoliation statute).

Judge Mehta: What about 1512(c)(2) - isn't that a catch all provision? Hernandez: That's what the government says.

Judge Mehta, to AUSA: So is a person stands up in a Supreme Court confirmation hearing and says, Stop the proceeding - is that a 20 year felony? AUSA: Likely not.

Judge Mehta: Let's not pretend this was simple parading. Hernandez: Some acted illegally. My client did not assault anyone. Judge Mehta: Isn't this a jury question? Hernandez: The statute is unconstitutionally vague.

Hernandez: Maybe some were jerks. Judge Mehta: Let's move to Count 4, remaining in a restricted or protected area. Why is Judge McFadden wrong? Defense: It creates chaos, anyone could do the protecting. It should be limited to a Secret Service protectee

 Defense: Mr. Caldwell never entered the Capitol building. Judge Mehta: He was on the balcony. Isn't that like the rotunda? Defense: No. Judge Mehta: There's a map associated with the statute. D: Mr. Caldwell and the VP were never contemporaneously on the grounds

Lawyer for Joshua James: We have a right to know which session of the grand jury, under the Arthur Anderson case. Judge Mehta: What does it matter, which particular grand jury that's been empaneled over these many months, was alleged impeded by Mr. James?

 Defense: We want to change venue. There is so much prejudice against these defendants -- Judge Mehta: How do you know that? Defense: This city is anti Donald Trump.

Judge Mehta: Do you have any polling data? Defense: My client doesn't have the thirty or forty thousand dollars lying around to do polling. Judge Mehta: You are arguing that DC residents are repulsed by traditional American values. Don't we here have American values? This brief reads like a blog.

Judge Mehta: Casting aspersion against people who live in this District is not the way to go. This brief looks like it's been ripped out of blog posts. It's not going to fly. Case law requires more. 

Defense: I'm not trying to denigrate the citizens of DC. Defense: My client and these defendants have been subject to race baiting day after day. He's not a racist. But everyday the Washington Post and the Attorney General and the President call him a white supremacist.

 Judge Mehta: I'm not condoning that either. We ought not to be characterizing people in large groups. I expect any jury selected would do the same. Hernandez: I'd like to file more.

Judge Mehta: Meet the deadline. Sometimes you don't. I would like more from DOJ

 AUSA: We'd like three weeks. Judge Mehta: I'll give you two, to the 22nd. Any defense reply by October 6. I'm already 15 minutes late to a meeting. Let's convene next Thursday at 11. Can we bring the detainees to court? They are reducing from five rooms to two.

 Judge Mehta: Mr. McMann is out of the country but co-counsel Mr. Spina can make it. See you all on the 16th at 11 am. Adjourned.

On Kenneth Harrelson on August 5, Inner City Press filed a letter and motion with Judge Mehta, on its DocumentCloud here.

On August 16, this: "Judge Mehta is in receipt of your email requesting access to the videos filed in United States v. Harrelson, No. 21-cr-28-10.  Under Standing Order No. 21-28, in order for the court to grant Inner City Press access to the videos filed in Mr. Harrelson’s case, you will need to file an application for access pursuant to D.D.C. Local Criminal Rule 57.6."

That rule provides: "Any news organization or other interested person, other than a party or a subpoenaed witness, who seeks relief relating to any aspect of proceedings in a criminal case... shall file an application for such relief with the Court. The application shall include a statement of the applicant's interest in the matter as to which relief is sought, a statement of facts, and a specific prayer for relief."

So, citing the Rule, Inner City Press filed another letter, one page, docketed here

Podcast here.  And Podcast II of August 19 here.

Now on August 19, it's been granted (shouldn't have been necessary): "MINUTE ORDER as to KENNETH HARRELSON (10) granting Inner City Press's 343 Application for Access to Video Exhibits. The United States shall make available to Inner City Press the video exhibits entered into evidence during the detention hearing of KENNETH HARRELSON (10), consistent with the procedures set forth in Standing Order 21-28. Inner City Press is granted permission to record, copy, download, retransmit, and otherwise further publish these video exhibits. Signed by Judge Amit P. Mehta on 8/19/2021."

So now, immediately, put on Inner City Press' YouTube, video here

Similarly, Inner City Press asked DOJ and then Judge Timothy Kelly for access to the videos that DOJ had shown to the court in the case: judicial documents that, under case law, must be made available to the public. But it was denied access, on the theory that Judge Kelly's order earlier in the month limited access to these judicial documents to a particular sub-set of the public.

 Inner City Press on July 27 wrote to Judge Kelly, including in the form of a motion, now on DocumentCloud, here. By noon the next day, July 28, nothing - no responses, no response. We'll have more on this. For now, podcast here; music video here.

Inner City Press live tweeted Riley June Williams on January 25, here. 


  From January 22, song here: Thread here.

 Inner City Press' John Earle Sullivan song on SoundCloud here. 


***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Carpenters Union Bribee Tagliaferro Get 60 Months Starting Jan 10, To Forfeit $290,000

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - The Source

SDNY COURTHOUSE, September 8–  Charged with demanding bribes to join the United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners of America, Salvatore Tagliaferro has begun trial before U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Paul A. Crotty.

  On April 21 Inner City Press up in the courtroom published: "day ended as witness described planning with Tagliaferro, in Brooklyn, to charge $600 fees "into our pockets... Our motive? To make some money." 2 big guys laugh."

   On April 28: "TAGLIAFERRO, the president of Local 926 chapter of the United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners of America (the “Union”), was found guilty today in Manhattan federal court of honest services wire fraud, conversion of union assets, and conspiracy, in connection with his involvement in a scheme to solicit cash bribes from hundreds of prospective members in exchange for union membership.  The jury convicted TAGLIAFERRO today following a one-week trial before U.S. District Judge Paul A. Crotty.  TAGLIAFERRO is scheduled to appear for sentencing before Judge Crotty."

 It was pushed to September 8 and Inner City Press went and live tweeted it here:

Now at sentencing of Tagliaferro for his Carpenters Union corruption  @SDNYLIVE . Inner City Press covered the trial. Now his lawyer says charging him for Union's legal fees would be unfair.

Defense: He unionized more people than anyone. He had plans to run for Union President. Probation would be enough. AUSA: Let's talk about the victims -as Mr. Rosenberg didn't. The Union was a victim. We seek $290,000 [approx], from Mr DeFalco too.

Tagliaferro (sobbing) I wish I'd never trusted John DeFalco. I did not know that animal was taking money. Only the District Council has a problem with me. I stood up to corruption. I am innocent. (Slamming defense table).

Judge Crotty: I think the jury was correct. I was a member of the Teamsters. I sentence you to 60 months, two years of supervised release. Forfeit $296,400. Restitution of $145,065.33.

Back on April 26, after the government's closing, Tagliaferro's lawyer Susan Kellman noted that the jury consists of "11 women and a black man," and that women's weren't allowed on juries until 1957. Then she tore into cooperating witness John DeFalco, quoting him about his home as big as a school - with a dock, no less.

   She portrayed Tagliaferro as increasingly powerless, 200 of his members taken, and DeFalco as the one selling union books. He was in Puerto Rico, she said, "not dropping paper towels from helicopters" but volunteering. Tagliaferro nodded to five family members / supporters in the front row.

  There was talk of a leak in SDNY - we'll have more on this.

Back on March 30, Judge Crotty ruled on various motions in limine: "OPINION & ORDER as to Salvatore Tagliaferro. The Court DENIES the Government's motion in limine to introduce the Defendant's 1997 conviction as impeachment evidence against the Defendant or any character witnesses, should they elect to testify at trial. The 1997 conviction is inadmissible for all purposes. The Court GRANTS the Government's motion in limine to introduce the two kickback schemes as subjects of cross-examination against character witnesses. The Court DENIES Tagliaferro's cross-motion to exclude evidence about the Contracting Kickback in the Government's case-in-chief. The Court DEFERS judgment on the Government's motion in limine to preclude or otherwise limit testimony regarding the Defendant's prior activities as a confidential informant."

Now on March 31, this: "SEALING ORDER as to Salvatore Tagliaferro. This order GRANTS the parties' request to file the following material under seal: the Government's supplemental motion in limine ("SML"), Tagliaferro's response (Def.'s Resp. dated Mar. 25, 2021), and the Government's reply (Gov't's Reply dated Mar. 28, 2021) (collectively, "the Briefing"), along with Tagliaferro's ex parte letter dated March 25, 2021 (the "Ex Parte Letter"). The Court has weighed the presumption of public access to these judicial documents against the risk that public disclosure would present a significant risk to (1) Tagliaferro's safety, (2) the safety of a potential defense witness, and (3) law enforcement efforts."

  Inner City Press will be pushing that this in-person trial also be open to the press and public by phone, given COVID. It is not either / or. Watch this site.

This case is USA v. Tagliaferro, et al., 19-cr-472 (Crotty)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

In Capitol Case Frank Scavo, Charged With F-Bombs Protesting Rain Tax, Pleads Guilty

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Podcast Song Filing  II Video Podcast
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

FEDERAL COURT, Sept 8 -- Months after the DC Circuit's decisions in US v. Munchel and more recently Tanios, on September 7 DDC Judge Royce C. Lamberth had before him Capitol breach defendant Frank Scavo - to change his plea to guilty after being charged with, among other things, "loud, threatening or abusive language."

 Inner City Press live tweeted it here - and its podcast here:

now Jan 6 case of US v. Frank Scavo. He is charged with, among other things, dropping the F-bomb in the Capitol. Repeatedly. Also, wearing a "Stop the Rain Tax" COVID-mask. He's here to plead guilty.

 Judge Royce Lamberth: You will be charged with perjury if you do not answer my questions truthfully. Have you had enough time with your attorney?

Scavo: Yes.

Judge Lamberth: If I accept your plea, you will waive your right not to incriminate yourself.

 From "statement of facts" - "SCAVO turned the cellphone camera on himself and stated, “This is top-secret shit. Stormed the fucking Capitol of the fucking United States at 58 years old. What the fuck is wrong with America?” Scavo is pleading to Court 4: picketing

More from DOJ's "Statement of Facts" - Scavo "is not in the camera’s view during the video, but can be heard saying, “Your own personal tour of the freaking Capitol. We fucking took it back. Took it back.” Statement charges "loud, threatening or abusive language."

 Judge Lamberth: I have been given a "Statement of Offense." Are you in fact guilty?

Scavo: Yes, Your Honor. Judge Lamberth: I appreciate that. I accept your guilty plea. Sentencing will be November 22 at 10 am.

Judge Lamberth: So for sentencing I'll see you all back here on November 22 and we'll celebrate the birthday of one of us. Adjourned.

On Kenneth Harrelson on August 5, Inner City Press filed a letter and motion with Judge Mehta, on its DocumentCloud here.

On August 16, this: "Judge Mehta is in receipt of your email requesting access to the videos filed in United States v. Harrelson, No. 21-cr-28-10.  Under Standing Order No. 21-28, in order for the court to grant Inner City Press access to the videos filed in Mr. Harrelson’s case, you will need to file an application for access pursuant to D.D.C. Local Criminal Rule 57.6."

That rule provides: "Any news organization or other interested person, other than a party or a subpoenaed witness, who seeks relief relating to any aspect of proceedings in a criminal case... shall file an application for such relief with the Court. The application shall include a statement of the applicant's interest in the matter as to which relief is sought, a statement of facts, and a specific prayer for relief."

So, citing the Rule, Inner City Press filed another letter, one page, docketed here

Podcast here.  And Podcast II of August 19 here.

Now on August 19, it's been granted (shouldn't have been necessary): "MINUTE ORDER as to KENNETH HARRELSON (10) granting Inner City Press's 343 Application for Access to Video Exhibits. The United States shall make available to Inner City Press the video exhibits entered into evidence during the detention hearing of KENNETH HARRELSON (10), consistent with the procedures set forth in Standing Order 21-28. Inner City Press is granted permission to record, copy, download, retransmit, and otherwise further publish these video exhibits. Signed by Judge Amit P. Mehta on 8/19/2021."

So now, immediately, put on Inner City Press' YouTube, video here

Similarly, Inner City Press asked DOJ and then Judge Timothy Kelly for access to the videos that DOJ had shown to the court in the case: judicial documents that, under case law, must be made available to the public. But it was denied access, on the theory that Judge Kelly's order earlier in the month limited access to these judicial documents to a particular sub-set of the public.

 Inner City Press on July 27 wrote to Judge Kelly, including in the form of a motion, now on DocumentCloud, here. By noon the next day, July 28, nothing - no responses, no response. We'll have more on this. For now, podcast here; music video here.

Inner City Press live tweeted Riley June Williams on January 25, here. 


  From January 22, song here: Thread here.

 Inner City Press' John Earle Sullivan song on SoundCloud here. 


***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Mike's Candyshop Drug Dealer Luis Meson Gets 108 Months After Death of Vine Founder Kroll

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Sept 7 – Luis Meson was  imprisoned in the Metropolitan Correctional Center in lower Manhattan beginning in October 2019, for his participation in the Mike's Candystore drug trafficking organization. He pleaded guilty, and on September 7, 2021 he was sentenced. Inner City Press live tweeted it, below.

On December 2, 2020  U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Katherine Polk Failla held a lengthy bond hearing on and with Meson. On December 7, "proceedings held before Judge Katherine Polk Failla:Motion For Temporary Pretrial Release on disposition sheet as to Luis Meson held on 12/7/2020. AUSA Nicholas Chiuchiolo present. Defendant's Counsel Lorraine Gauli-Rufo present. $150,000.00 PRB, 4 FRP, Travel restricted to SDNY/EDNY, Surrender travel documents (& No new applications), Pretrial supervision as directed by pretrial services, Drug testing/treatment as directed by PTS, Mental health evaluation/treatment as directed by PTS, Home incarceration, GPS, Deft not to possess firearm/destructive device/other weapon, Deft to be detained until all conditions are met. Defendant to live with one of the co-signers, [Name not published by Inner City Press, voluntarily] in Queens, NY, or with another co-signer, so long as that co-signer's living quarters are approved by Pretrial Services. Defendant is not to communicate with witnesses and/or co-defendants outside of the presence of counsel. Deft is to self-install GPS monitoring at the direction of Pretrial Services. (jw)."

  Now the September 7, 2021 sentencing, resulting in 108 months of incarceration, live tweeted here:

Now sentencing of "Mike's Candyshop" drug dealer Luis Meson; 2018 death of Colin Kroll, the co-founder of the now-dead video-hosting service Vine is cited. Meson is a/k/a Sito. US wants 135 to 168 months.

Judge Failla: How likely is deportation? Will Meson be contesting it? Defense: We've looked into it, it appears it is most likely he will be deported. He has been in this country for 26 years. His mother is here. His daughter is here.

Judge Failla: Paragraph 94 of the Pre-Sentencing Report, on his part ownership of an ale house in Brooklyn. He invested $50,000 in the ale house. How did he have that money? Defense: That's an error. The correct sum was $15,000 and he was paying from salary AUSA

Nicholas Chiuchiolo: Mike's Candyshop was selling 7 nights a week, heroin, fentanyl and cocaine. Mr. Meson would make the deliveries on the doorstep, three to four times a week. He is not being held for the overdose death - but it could have been anyone

 Defense: Mr. Meson had nothing to do with the gun. In 2019 Mr. Meson had moved away from the crime and tried to open a bar. He heard after the fact about the death. Judge Failla: He didn't think it was linked to the drugs? Defense: He heard rumors.

 Defense: He only sold drugs two days a week. He was released on bail by your Honor, we've very grateful for that. He has a job. He knows he did something wrong. He has been a productive member of society. It was a mistake.

 Meson: I've done damage to my family. I apologize for my actions. Judge Failla: I saw the AUSAs talking - anything you want to say?

AUSA: After he was arrested, he had contraband phone in his cell. What he was doing with it makes it no less of a crime.

Judge Failla: I'm going to step off the bench for five minutes or so. 

 Judge Failla is back and says: the Guideline is 135 to 168 months, with a 60 month minimum. I've been thinking about the request I think about all of Mr. Meson. And I will. He took classes while detained. But it was a well-run and deadly conspiracy.

Judge Failla: I will sentence Mr. Meson to 108 months. Then four years of supervised release.

 Back on December 2, 2020 after lawyers' arguments about the ability to review discovery while in lockdown, Judge Failla put questions to Meson himself, with his counsel's consent. 

  Meson explained how in 7 South they are let out of their cells only from 7 am to 7:30 am, three days a week. Sixteen inmates compete for a single computer.  

  His lawyer described a fire; the Assistant US Attorney blamed it on a prisoner using a lightbulb outlet to charge a cell phone -- contraband. Later the AUSA said that was just his understanding. 

  A decision earlier in the pandemic by EDNY Judge Garaufis was cited. And on December 7, the decision to free Meson on bond.

The case is US v. Tavarez, et al., 19-cr-690 (Failla)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.