Saturday, September 4, 2021

In Jan 6 Case Q-Anon Shaman Chansley Now Pleads Guilty With Much Under Seal

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Podcast
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

FEDERAL COURT, Sept 3 – Back on March 5, so-called QAnon Shaman Jacob Chansley had a detention hearing before DDC Judge Royce Lamberth, who questioned Chansley's Clayton, Missouri-based retained counsel Albert Watkins about allegedly disobeying orders and allowing 60 Minutes to film and interview Chansley during an attorney client video call from the jail to Watkins' office.

 Judge Lamberth put into the docket the Feb 10 email to Chansley's lawyer's firm, that interviews had to go through US Marshals Service & be approved by judge, email on Patreon, here

 But now there are sealed exhibits, and off the record talks. On September 3, citing these, Chansley pled guilty, with a sentencing on November 17 at 10 am. Inner City Press live tweeted it here (podcast here)

now Jan 6 case of so-called QAnon Shaman, Jacob Chansley - he is prepared to plead guilty before DDC Judge Lamberth, by phone. On the line, somehow yells, "Freedom!" Now everyone is muted

 Defense lawyer Albert Watkin says Chansley has reviewed the psych evaluation. Judge Lamberth: Mr. Chansley, I have to determine if you are competent. Chansley: I am very appreciative for the court's willingness to have me and my mental vulnerabilities evaluated

 Chansley: I hope you weren't offended by anything I told the psychologist. Judge Lambert: I was not. Chansley: Thank you for what you are doing for out country. Judge Lamberth: The plea agreement has a mistake. You are pleading to Count Two, obstruction.

Judge Lamberth: You are charged with corruptly seeking to obstruction and impede Congress with threats and remaining in a restricted building, and disorderly conduct - do you understand? Chansley: Yes Your Honor. Judge Lamberth: Maximum penalty twenty years.

 Judge Lamberth: Please describe the agreement. Watkins: I reviewed it with my client. The government acknowledges we can argue for pre-sentence release. Judge Lamberth: I'll take that under advisement. I've had a discussion off the record...

 Judge Lamberth: You've signed a statement of offense. Is what what really happened, & you are guilty of? Chansley: Yes. Judge Lamberth: I enter a finding of guilty. I'll consider release, since you have not pled to a crime of violence. I'll listen to your motion.

 AUSA: Under our agreement, any new filing would be  breech. Judge Lamberth: OK, I'll go on what I have. The motion is under seal. Can you argue an unsealed part of that? Watkins: There's a sealed exhibit to the motion. [The whole exhibit is sensitive mental info?]

Watkins: We had an honest discussion off the record. [Also - is that appropriate? The basis for release or detention? Was it as least transcribed, so if the DC Circuit were to say to release it, they could?]

 Watkins: I have identified a family he can stay with, a family with their own adult child with special needs.He will be monitored during the pre-sentence period. A psycho-therapist will deal with the psych issues in a non dilatory way

Watkins: To help Mr. Watkins, we have a former FBI agent,  in geographical proximity to me, to put Mr. Chansley in a position of knowledge. We ask for pre-sentence release. AUSA: We wanted the motion dealt with before the plea. No more need for counsel access

AUSA: He's been incarcerated 8 months, a guideline sentence would be much more. We are concerned about safety of the community and return to court, for the imminent sentencing. We filed this under seal. [How can all this be sealed, in a criminal case?]

 Watkins: We did have our private in virtual chambers discussion with the court [Inner City Press: Bad practice - should be transcribed]

Watkins: He was not a planner or organizer. We need to discuss the pre-sentence report, and for humanitarian reasons

Watkins: The US military has known that Mr. Chansley has a personality disorder. I want to get him healed. 

Judge Lamberth: I'll take it under advisement and rule later. Adjourned

 Inner City Press has uploaded the plea agreement, to 41 to 51 months, here

Inner City Press live tweeted March 5 it, here:

Chansley's lawyer Watkins: Trump convinced people like my client that something was occurring that, if true, would have justified their actions. You have high tens of thousands of people who went to the Capitol because they believed our President.

Chansley's lawyer: There are people who sold online property they stole in the Capitol, and they are free, brushing their teeth in this home. My client never used a flag in a violent fashion. It is not a spear. You can characterize things anyway you want

Chansley's lawyer: You can't lump all of them under one moniker. There is no one else currently being held who was not violent, did not have weapons. The flag is not a spear.

Chansley's lawyer: My client owns it. He has apologized and showed his face without paint. This is as strong a case for pre-trial release as any out of January 6.

Judge Lamberth: The Marshal asked me if I gave permission for Chansley to be interviewed by 60 Minutes. How did that come about? It seems you did it as a subterfuge, in your office, by video.

 Chansley's lawyer Watkins: There was no subterfuge. There was no interview in the jail. 

Judge Lamberth: The facility was told it was an attorney client interview.

Chansley's lawyer: I didn't tell them it was an interview with 60 Minutes.

Judge Lamberth: I'm sure you didn't. I'm going to file this in the record today. They told you in advance.

Chansley's lawyer: I admit I took all the steps with 60 Minutes.

Judge Lamberth: I'll put this into the record for your response. And I'll rule as quickly as possible. Adjourned.

We'll have more on this.

Inner City Press live tweeted Riley June Williams on January 25, here. 


  From January 22, song here: Thread here.

 Inner City Press' John Earle Sullivan song on SoundCloud here. 


***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

UN Mission of Equatorial Guinea Faces Motion For Sanctions For Misusing Immunity in SDNY

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Sept 2 – Equatorial Guinea's Mission to the United Nations faces a motions for sanctions for misusing sovereign immunity (like the UN itself, some say) in a pending lawsuit. 

  On September 2 U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Kenneth M. Karas received a motion for sanctions against the Permanent Mission of Equatorial Guinea to the United Nations, uncovered by Inner City Press at the SDNY.  

Leonard and Carol Eisenberg since 2018 have been seeking resolution from the Equatorial Guinea UN Mission and Anatolio Ndong Mba, residing at 102 Hillair Circle, White Plains for encroachment.

 But immunity or impunity continue to be cited. Hence a motion for sanctions.

The case is Eisenberg v. Permanent Mission of Equatorial Guinea to the UN, 18-cv-2092 (Karas)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

In Afghanistan UNDP Abandons Local Staff, Censorship By Guterres and Irish Mission

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Video Q&A
BBC - Guardian UK - Song - SDNY/FOIA

UN GATE, September 2 – Each day, the current United Nations gets worse. And Inner City Press, banned now for the 1258th day by Secretary General Antonio Guterres continues to report on it, on August 16 publishing a UN internal memo about moving international staff to Kazakhstan. On August 16, 17 and 18 it in writing asking Guterres and his UN Spokesperson Stephane Dujarric and Melissa Fleming about it - no answer. And no one they let in asked, or seemingly had the memo.

Now this about the UNDP's abandonment of Afghan staff, from whistleblowing sources to Inner City Press: "UNDP in Afghanistan is refusing to help national staff to leave the country. While other international organisations have evacuated all staff including guards and drivers, the United Nations Development Programme is declining to evacuate any national staff. The response is that it is not United Nations policy to evacuate national staff.     National staff are at risk because they served the UN and now are left to fend for themselves. Many are in hiding, including one woman who is forced to hide in a basement in fear of life or forced marriage to Taliban militia.     The Resident Representative, Abdallah Dardari, got himself out to Kazakhstan quickly despite the chance to remain within a well-guarded compound. All the better to avoid any responsibility when national staff start to get their throats cut by the Taliban simply because they worked for an international organization.     There are still UN humanitarian flights out of Afghanistan. Staff and their families could be got out if UNDP management accepted their moral responsibilities."

 This is today's corrupt UN that can't even take questions.

On August 30, the UN Security Council after significant watering down a draft resolution on Afghanistan nevertheless witnessed abstention and speech from China name-checking, to denounced, "ETIM," the East Turkestan Islamic Movement. No one mentioned the mass imprisonment of Uighurs. And Guterres' teams did not answer any of Inner City Press' written questions. Video of Q&A for access.  Song.
and now, podcast here.

  So during the August 30 meeting, the last in August, Inner City Press wrote to the incoming UNSC Presidency for September, Ireland's Geraldine Byrne Nason, and her spokesperson Meghan Boroughs, for access at least by WebEx to their September 1 "press" conference.

  The Mission's self-described spokesperson replied that she referred the request to MALU - which does not response or explain - and the Irish PR held a presser with another spokesperson, Irwin, and did not answer written questions on Haiti, Cameroon, South Sudan, and Afghanistan. A fish rots from the head. Watch this site.

On August 26, this from a State Department Spokesperson:   "we have received confirmation that roughly 500 of the 1,500 Americans that we were tracking as potentially being in Afghanistan have been evacuated.  Second, over the past 24 hours, we heard from an additional roughly 500 people purporting to be Americans in Afghanistan who want to leave. We immediately began attempting to reach these individuals by phone, text, and email. Based on our experience, many of these will not turn out to be U.S. citizens in need of our assistance. The new submissions speak to the realities of the situation we have been addressing over the past 12 days – the situation is dynamic and so is the data.  Third, we are now in contact with the roughly 1,000 Americans we believe remain in Afghanistan. And, the vast majority – over two thirds – informed us that they were taking steps to leave. We believe many, if not most, of these individuals are nearly or already out of the country. And, we know that dozens more do not wish to leave Afghanistan for a range of reasons.  The Department of State will continue to provide updates on our progress" Unlike the UN.

 On August 18 Dujarric announced, as news, the two day old memo. Here is UNAMA's email:

"  From: Marija Sendekovic <sendekovic@un.org> On Behalf Of OSRSG-UNAMA Sent: Sunday, August 15, 2021 5:07 PM To: UNAMA-All Staff <unama-allstaff@un.org> Subject: Message to all staff    Message to all staff  The security and political landscape has evolved quickly and we may expect further volatility in the immediate period ahead. We understand the anxiety this has caused to all of you in face of such uncertainty.  Our top priority remains the safety and well-being of all personnel.  We have put in place and implemented many approaches and security measures to help protect staff. We will continue to make all necessary adjustments to procedures and work issues in order to safeguard personnel. Many colleagues from field offices have been involved in extensive relocation actions. I thank all the many teams across the UN family who made the relocations possible. I recognize such moves can be a real upheaval and stressful to colleagues and their families. Your safety is of paramount importance to us and we will continue to support you in every way we can.   The relocations were overwhelmingly successful with the vast majority of field-based personnel safely moved out of immediate harms’ way. With a focus on keeping personnel and their families safe, we will be looking to see most national personnel mainly working from homes or the place of relocation.  The UN’s leadership is continuing to explore every viable option to support national personnel in the challenging circumstances.  In order to further reduce risks we are also looking at options to consolidate personnel reporting to the office in to fewer compounds within Afghanistan.  Another step we are taking is to continue to lower the footprint of international personnel in Kabul. No evacuation is currently being considered but it is prudent that only senior management and essential international staff stay in Afghanistan for the time-being.  In parallel to lightening of our international footprint in Kabul, we are setting up a satellite office for the UN in a nearby state in order for some international staff to support our work in Afghanistan. Almaty in Kazakhstan -that is less than two hours flight time from Kabul- has been identified as the location from where a small group of international personnel can work.  We need to display patience and fortitude in the period ahead. As representatives of the United Nations we need to remain level-headed and all work together to shape these events so that they produce the best possible outcome for Afghanistan under the circumstances. These are the moments where the United Nations is called on to perform; let us strive to do our best to meet the great expectations that the Afghan people have on us." 

 The UN has neither responded to or offered any explanation when a lawyer's letter - to UN official Fleming, and Tal Mekel, and to each UNCA Executive Committee member - urged them to have a dialogue about ending the UN's banning and censorship of Inner City Press.

On August 9, an independent (minded) journalist asked Dujarric about the letter, video here, transcript:

Question:  My second question is the law firm ‑‑ what is it called? ‑‑ Quinn Emanuel wrote a letter to the UN asking about reinstatement of our colleague Matthew Lee into the UN press corps. Do you have any comment on that?      

Spokesman:  No. All I can tell you is that we've received the letter, and I'm not aware of any change to his status.     

Question:  You're not aware? I mean, aren't you part of the group that decides the fate of... or even the negotiations... The letter calls for renegotiation [Cross talk]      

Spokesman:  I decide the fate of no one. [Laughter]      Trust me, trust me, my authority is extremely limited, whether at home or at work.       What I can tell you and, joking aside, is that the letter has indeed been received, and I'm not aware of any... and there has been no change in Mr. Lee's status.     

Question:  Has the letter been answered? Do you plan to answer it?      

Spokesman:  It's been received. Whether or not it's been answered, I don't know yet.

The letter was received by the UN's Melissa Fleming, Maria Luiza Vioti and Tal Mekel and to each UNCA Executive Board member, to them citing UNCA's stated goals that it has a charter to supposedly uphold.

What's next? Since the letter, Inner City Press has published exclusive stories not only from the U.S. court systems but about the United Nations, including its agencies UNOPS, UNFPA, UNITAR and UNESCO. (Also credited in AP, Daily Mail, and Nigeria's Sahara Reporters, amid answers from the IMF.)

But none of its written questions have been answered by the UN Spokespeople, and it remains banned from entry to the UN's briefings. This must end.   

 Having asked for a colleagial discussion, and while still offering it, things must turn to the law. UNCA is a New York State non-profit which has not only not abided by its stated goals - it has tortiously interfered with a journalist's right to cover the United Nations.    The United Nations itself propounds Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and has other legal duties that must be addressed by national courts, particularly in the UN's host country... 

Those in receipt of the first, friendly letter: melissa.fleming@un.org, marialuiza.viotti@un.org, mekel@un.org, malu@un.org,  and UNCA
Valeria Robecco, ANSA News Agency, Nabil Abi Saab, Al-Araby, Jianguo Ma, Xinhua News Agency, Edith Lederer, Associated, Giampaolo Pioli, Quotidiano, Linda Fasulo, Ibtisam Azem, Al-Araby Al-Jadeed Newspaper, Ali Barada, France 24, Asharq Al-Awsat; Oscar Bolanos, OMB News, Sherwin Bryce-Pease, SABC South Africa - Alexander Hassanein, The Tokyo Shimbun, Maria Khrenova, TASS, Philippe Rater, Agence France-Presse, Kaori Yoshida, Nikkei, Betul Yuruk, Anadolu Agency at president@unca.com, valeria.robecco@gmail.com, nabisaab@gmail.com, mjg222888@gmail.com, elederer@ap.org, giampioli@aol.com, lindafasulo@gmail.com, ibtisam.azem@alaraby.co.uk, abarada@hotmail.com, ombyvozque@gmail.com, s.brycepease@gmail.com, alexander@tokyoshimbun.us, khrenova_m@tass.ru, philippe.rater@afp.com, kaori.yoshida@nex.nikkei.com, byuruk@aa.com.tr

  We'll have more on all this. Watch this site.

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Stuart Finkelstein Was Charged For Fake ADA Lawsuit In SDNY Must Find Lawyer By Sept 17

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - The Source

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Sept 2 – Stuart Finkelstein filed Americans With Disabilities Act lawsuits in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, allegedly without actually representing or even contacting his putative clients.

   On December 3, 2019 Finkelstein appeared in SDNY Magistrates Court before Magistrate Judge Barbara Moses on mail fraud and aggravated identity theft charges. He was allowed to remain free on $150,000 bond with travel restricted to SDNY, EDNY the Southern District of Florida and three districts in or the entire state of Tennessee.

    Assistant United States Attorney Rushmi Bhaskaran proposed to also include the District of New Jersey, but Judge Moses said if this was only to fly through the airport in Newark, Finkelstein should not "hang out" in New Jersey. He agreed.

    Judge Moses asked, Why Tennessee. AUSA Bhasharan replied that Finkelstein's son live there. But in what district? And why was the underlying US Attorney for the SDNY press release not sent to or received by the Press?

     In a November 25 letter to Magistrate Judge Katharine H. Parker, AUSA Bhashakan corrected the complaint's summary by Mason Posilkin of the ADA based on information she "provided to the former U.S. Attorney's Office Special Agent Posilkin (Mr. Posilkin is leaving [the] Office to join the FDIC)."

  Apparently, now the law no longer requires that to allege past injury a plaintiff must make some effort to visit the public establishment that is being sued. Inner City Press, the only media in the Mag Court when Finkelstein was presented, said it would stay on this - and has.

Jump cut to September 2, 2021. Assigned District Judge Paul G. Gardephe said Finkelstein's lawyer Brian John Griffin has a conflict, and gave Finkelstein until September 17 at 11:30 am to find another lawyer. Finkelstein said he has his antennas out.

 The case is now US v. Finkelstein, 21-cr-217 (Gardephe). 

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Carpenters Union Bribee Tagliaferro Wants Probation While US Asks 60+ Month Sept 8

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - The Source

SDNY COURTHOUSE, September 2–  Charged with demanding bribes to join the United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners of America, Salvatore Tagliaferro has begun trial before U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Paul A. Crotty.

  On April 21 Inner City Press up in the courtroom published: "day ended as witness described planning with Tagliaferro, in Brooklyn, to charge $600 fees "into our pockets... Our motive? To make some money." 2 big guys laugh."

   On April 28: "TAGLIAFERRO, the president of Local 926 chapter of the United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners of America (the “Union”), was found guilty today in Manhattan federal court of honest services wire fraud, conversion of union assets, and conspiracy, in connection with his involvement in a scheme to solicit cash bribes from hundreds of prospective members in exchange for union membership.  The jury convicted TAGLIAFERRO today following a one-week trial before U.S. District Judge Paul A. Crotty.  TAGLIAFERRO is scheduled to appear for sentencing before Judge Crotty."

 It was pushed to September 8, and now on September 2 Tagiaferro in a heavily redacted letter has asked for... probation, no jail time. The US Attorney's Office wants at least 60 months. Watch this site.

Back on July 7, Tagliaferro's lawyer asked for a delay of two months, for the "development of mitigating factors." The US Attorney's Office immediately opposed the request, mocking this very phrase.

On July 8 Judge Crotty granted a one month delay, but said it would be the last one: "The Court will allow one thirty day adjournment to September 8, 2021 at 12 noon. There will be no further adjournments. SO ORDERED. (Sentencing set for 9/8/2021 at 12:00 PM before Judge Paul A. Crotty) (Signed by Judge Paul A. Crotty on 7/8/2021)." Watch this site.

Back on April 26, after the government's closing, Tagliaferro's lawyer Susan Kellman noted that the jury consists of "11 women and a black man," and that women's weren't allowed on juries until 1957. Then she tore into cooperating witness John DeFalco, quoting him about his home as big as a school - with a dock, no less.

   She portrayed Tagliaferro as increasingly powerless, 200 of his members taken, and DeFalco as the one selling union books. He was in Puerto Rico, she said, "not dropping paper towels from helicopters" but volunteering. Tagliaferro nodded to five family members / supporters in the front row.

  There was talk of a leak in SDNY - we'll have more on this.

Back on March 30, Judge Crotty ruled on various motions in limine: "OPINION & ORDER as to Salvatore Tagliaferro. The Court DENIES the Government's motion in limine to introduce the Defendant's 1997 conviction as impeachment evidence against the Defendant or any character witnesses, should they elect to testify at trial. The 1997 conviction is inadmissible for all purposes. The Court GRANTS the Government's motion in limine to introduce the two kickback schemes as subjects of cross-examination against character witnesses. The Court DENIES Tagliaferro's cross-motion to exclude evidence about the Contracting Kickback in the Government's case-in-chief. The Court DEFERS judgment on the Government's motion in limine to preclude or otherwise limit testimony regarding the Defendant's prior activities as a confidential informant."

Now on March 31, this: "SEALING ORDER as to Salvatore Tagliaferro. This order GRANTS the parties' request to file the following material under seal: the Government's supplemental motion in limine ("SML"), Tagliaferro's response (Def.'s Resp. dated Mar. 25, 2021), and the Government's reply (Gov't's Reply dated Mar. 28, 2021) (collectively, "the Briefing"), along with Tagliaferro's ex parte letter dated March 25, 2021 (the "Ex Parte Letter"). The Court has weighed the presumption of public access to these judicial documents against the risk that public disclosure would present a significant risk to (1) Tagliaferro's safety, (2) the safety of a potential defense witness, and (3) law enforcement efforts."

  Inner City Press will be pushing that this in-person trial also be open to the press and public by phone, given COVID. It is not either / or. Watch this site.

This case is USA v. Tagliaferro, et al., 19-cr-472 (Crotty)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.