Saturday, May 8, 2021

In DC Insurrection Cases Copeland Swears at Judge While Antonio Lawyer Says Cooperating, Knows Biden

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Podcast Song
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

FEDERAL COURT, May 6 – Minutes into a break in the impeachment trial in the U.S. Senate, accused insurrectionist Domenic Pezzola was ordered detained until trial by Magistrate Judge Robin M. Meriweather. Inner City Press live tweeted it, below. There was an appeal.

  On May 6, well over a month after the DC Circuit's decision in US v. Munchel, Judge Meriweather held a series of proceedings including with Utah's Landon Kenneth Copeland. Inner City Press live tweeted it here:

before DDC Magistrate Judge Meriweather, courtroom deputy tells Zoomer with "expletive as name" to "change your name or removed." Uh, Cohen v California?

 Lawyer for accused insurrectionist Anthony Antonio tells someone (the prosecutor), You look like Chris Hayes of MSNBC. An advocacy tactic? [Seems so - see below, he bragged about knowing Biden]

 Now a "Mister Copeland" on the multi-defendant call is shouting, I'm in my car, I have nothing to hide! He is told, repeatedly, not to talk on the public line. I have nothing to hide, Copeland says.

Voice: "Can't the clerk mute Mr Copeland?" Deputy: You're not his lawyer. So, no. Voice: I'm just a person who wants to get some work done. Copeland: You are evil!

From DOJ website: "Copeland was arrested on April 29 and had his initial appearance the same afternoon. He was released on condition." Courtroom deputy says Copeland will be processed last today. Thread will continue

Confirmed: Copeland of "you are evil" is  Landon Kenneth COPELAND, calling in by phone for initial appearance in DDC,As Judge Meriweather runs through general condition of release for other defendants, Copeland cuts in - "I have questions about my conditions" .. I am free Deputy: This is not the time for you to speak.

Deputy: We are not going to get anywhere like this. We can't have these interruptions, or we're not going to get through this calendar today. Copeland: I'll keep my mouth shut, I promise. Deputy: Or I'll mute you. Copeland: Yes, ma'am.

Copeland: I just want to ask, if any of this negotiable? Deputy: You are going to be muted if you don't stop right now. We'll call on your lawyer later.

Now processed, with less fanfare, is William Tryon previously released by a Magistrate Judge in the Northern District of New York. His Magistrates' Court case number is lower than Copeland, but he is not listed on DOJ's web page of cases.

 Another straight forward appearance: Anthony Antonio. He was living in Delaware but now working on South Carolina for the past two months. His lawyer wants a loosening of conditions of release, says, "I'll keep it to four minutes or less... My client has no record"

 Anthony Antonio's lawyer says his client work for a "solar company, Excel." They moved him to Illinois where, during the lockdown, "he became hooked on Fox-mania." Copeland: I would like to object! That's not pertinent!

 [These multi-defendant presentments may not be a good idea - Copeland is objecting to Antonio's lawyer pleading "Fox-itis"] Antonio's lawyer: He stood on the steps exhorting peaceful protest. He smiled at police. Copeland: I object! Judge: Please mute Mr. Copeland

Antonio's lawyer: I will remember this hearing forever. My client came to me on Jan 20. I was not going to represent anyone from that mess, I was going to say, "I don't represent you people." #YouPeople

Antonio's lawyer: I contacted my Congress-person, to make him available at impeachment hearing. But they called no witnesses. [Imagine Copeland on mute]

 Antonio's lawyer: Now my client works for a roofing company in South Carolina. He has to travel to a seminar, May 15-19 in Utah. [He could visit Copeland] Antonio's lawyer calls his client "a cooperating witness with the FBI." Really?

Says, needs to go to Texas in June and another one in September. [Particularly bad idea to have a joint proceeding of a self-declared cooperating witness with a defendant like Copeland

 Antonio's lawyer is laying it on thick - says he knows Biden and would ask him to sponsor him into the DC Bar. Except Biden is not admitted. Also agrees to waiving Speedy Trial Act time, so that "the bad guys" can be prosecuted before his client.

 Now as routine insurrection cases from Kansas are processed, a friend of Copeland calls in and speaks up. Deputy is referring her to AT&T listen-only line. But I like to listen, she says. Copeland is soon: countdown

Copeland starts with a bang: You people f*cked this up, he says. "You're going to give me a psych eval. I don't like 70% of my income going to the government. F*ck all of you!

Copeland has been muted. Judge: Profanity is not allowed to be used in court proceedings. Whatever grievances you have with Federal law enforcement or the court, this is not the time to raise it. It does you a dis-service. We expect order in the court.

Judge: Counsel, if I put you in a break-out room I could provide it. I would have asked the Marshals to remove him. We have other defendants. Lawyer: He might benefit from a break-out with the attorney he met with in Utah, Mr. Stout. We don't have a relationship

Mr. Stout: I'm available. Deputy: OK, we'll do another case first.

Copeland: I wanna talk in open court you mother f*ckers! Deputy: I thought I had muted that line.

 Update: Judge Meriweather put Copeland in a breakout room, said proceeding would resume. Then the AT&T line cut off. Now both of her lines are on AT&T hold music. No announcement as to whether Copeland came back on, or the resolution. Like the withheld videos...

We will have more on this.

Inner City Press live tweeted Riley June Williams on January 25, here. 


  From January 22, song here: Thread here.

 Inner City Press' John Earle Sullivan song on SoundCloud here. 


***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Avenatti Wanted To Ban Press From Sidebars So Inner City Press Opposed & Judge Furman Affirms Openness

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Song Radio
BBC - Decrypt - LightRead - Honduras - Source

SDNY COURTHOUSE, May 6 – When after three days of jury selection the trial of Michael Avenatti for allegedly extorting Nike began on January 29, Assistant US Attorney Robert Sobelman told the selected jurors that Avenatti was supposed to look out for the interests of his client, but he did not - he had a weapon, social media.  More on 1st day on Patreon here.

 On August 7, 2020 in the Stormy Daniels case, Avenatti had motions heard by U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Jesse M. Furman. Inner City Press live tweeted it, here.

 On April 14, 2021, Avenatti's Federal Defenders wrote to Judge Furman seeking to ban the press from sidebars, during jury selection in his Stormy Daniels trial.

Inner City Press immediately filed opposition, below. And podcast here.

And now on May 6, Judge Furman has ruled: "Two media outlets — the Daily News and Inner City Press — filed letters opposing the Defendant’s request to revisit the issue, see ECF Nos. 108 and 110; the Government filed a letter expressing its views, see ECF No. 111; and the Defendant filed a reply, see ECF No. 114 (“Reply”). Upon review of all these submissions, the Court overrules the Defendant’s objection and adopts the proposal set forth in the parties’ letter of March 13, 2020, which is consistent with the Case 1:19-cr-00374-JMF Document 120 Filed 05/06/21 Page 1 of 3 2 procedures followed by Judge Matsumoto in United States v. Shkreli, 260 F. Supp. 3d 257 (E.D.N.Y. 2017).

In the Court’s view, these procedures strike the right balance between the Defendant’s right to a fair trial and the First Amendment right of public access to judicial proceedings, substantially for the reasons explained by Judge Matsumoto. See id. at 260-64; see also ABC, Inc. v. Stewart, 360 F.3d 90, 99-106 & n.5 (2d Cir. 2004). United States v. King, 140 F.3d 76 (2d Cir. 1998), and United States v. Loera, No. 09-CR-466 (BMC), 2018 WL 5624143 (E.D.N.Y. Oct. 30, 2018) — upon which the Defendants relies — do not call for greater restrictions on public access as the questioning of prospective jurors in this case is not likely to involve the same number or kind of “sensitive and controversial issues” and “politically charged topics” that the questioning of prospective jurors in those cases involved. Loera, 2018 WL 5624143, at *2; see id. at *3 (emphasizing the “unique facts” of the case); King, 140 F.3d at 83 (emphasizing the “unusual” nature of the case). Accordingly, in the Court’s view, it will suffice for the Court to “ensure that prospective jurors are comfortable requesting that the reporter be excused from sidebar”; to “excuse the reporter if the [C]ourt determines that a juror does not appear comfortable answering questions fully and honestly in the presence of the reporter”; and to “excuse the pool reporter[] if a prospective juror so requests in order to provide a more fulsome, candid answer, when questioning may elicit issues of a personal or private nature.” Shkreli, 260 F. Supp. 3d at 263 & n.3." Full order here. Inner City Press is ready.

On Saturday, May 1 Avenatti's publicly funded Federal Defenders - his filing to get publicly paid lawyers will remains sealed, unlike for nearly all other defendants - filed another request for secrecy, this time for entire exhibits of his omnibus motion: "RE: United States v. Michael Avenatti,  19 Cr. 374 (JMF) Dear Judge Furman:  I write pursuant to the Court’s individual rules (Rule 10(C)) regarding the filing of redacted documents on CM/ECF. Tonight, the defense in the above-captioned case filed its omnibus pre-trial motion and seeks leave to keep Exhibits B, C, and F under seal." Inner City Press reported, This too should be opposed, once we can see what was actually filed.

  And now we have. Avenatti is seeking to preclude the introduction of his's "alleged WhatsApp communications with Stephanie Clifford" - while withholding, even from its motions, all information about them. Watch this site.
On April 16  Inner City Press' opposition to banning Press from sidebars was docketed and response from the US Attorney's Office called for on April 22, and Avenatti by April 26.

 Now, after 10 pm on April 26, Avenatti's is in: "e write in further support of our letter motion dated  April 14, 2021 (Dkt. No. 107), to preclude the media’s presence  at sidebar conferences during oral voir dire. In its April 22,  2021 response, the Government stated that it “would not object  to the exclusion of the press from sidebar conferences during  voir dire” provided “a substantial probability exists that  prospective jurors would not be candid regarding unfair or  improper biases were a member of the press to be present.” Gov’t  Resp. (Dkt. No. 111) at 1.1 Because there is a sufficient basis  to conclude that a reporter’s presence at sidebar conferences  during oral voir dire would likely stifle jurors’ candor and violate Michael Avenatti’s Sixth Amendment right to trial before  an impartial jury, the Court should grant the defense’s motion.2   1 Notwithstanding footnote three to the Government’s response  (Dkt. No. 111 at 3 n.3), the defense is still unclear as to the  basis for the Government’s assertion to Mr. Warren and in its  March 13, 2020 letter to the Court that Judge Gardephe  “permitted” a reporter to be present at sidebar voir dire in the  Nike case.  2 The defense also offers this letter in reply to the letters  submitted by Inner City Press and Daily News, L.P., opposing our  motion to preclude the press from sidebar voir dire. Dkt. Nos.  109, 110."  Full Avenatti press-ban reply on Patreon here.
 
Previously: "MEMO ENDORSEMENT as to Michael Avenatti on Letter addressed to Judge Jesse M. Furman from Matthew Russell Lee, Inner City Press dated 4/14/2021 re Formal request for press presence at voir dire sidebars and for full access including to both sides' exhibits in real time: The Clerk of Court is directed to docket this letter. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Jesse M. Furman on 1/29/2021)." And, "MEMO ENDORSEMENT as to Michael Avenatti on [107] LETTER MOTION re Reporter's Presence At Sidebar Voir Dire: The Government shall file a response to this letter (and the letter filed by Inner City Press, which will be docketed separately) no later than April 22, 2021. SO ORDERED."

  Now on April 22, the US Attorney's Office says it's fine with it to exclude the Press: "The Government respectfully submits this letter pursuant to the Court’s Order dated April  16, 2021 (Dkt. No. 109), directing the Government to respond to the defendant’s letter, filed April  14, 2021, regarding the presence of a reporter at sidebar during voir dire of prospective jurors (Dkt.  No. 107), and the letter of Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press, filed on the docket on April  16, 2021, requesting to be present at sidebar during voir dire of prospective jurors (Dkt. No. 108). 1 For the reasons set forth below, the Government would not object to the exclusion of the press  from sidebar conferences during voir dire of prospective jurors should the Court find a sufficient  basis to conclude that a substantial probability exists that prospective jurors would not be candid  regarding unfair or improper biases were a member of the press to be present." We'll have more on this - Avenatti's lawyers have to April 26 to reply - there will be more. Watch this site.

Here is Inner City Press' April 14 submission: "Dear Judge Furman:    This application responds to the defendant's letter motion earlier this evening seeking to bar the press from voir dire sidebars during jury selection in the above-captioned trial (Dkt. No. 107), and follows up on Inner City Press' August 28, 2020 submission in the same case (Dkt. No. 85).  

Federal Defenders writes to oppose any press presence at sidebars in voir dire, even though this has been allowed in this District in such recent high profile cases such as that involving the testimony of cooperator / hip-hop artist Daniel Hernandez a/k/a Tekashi 6ix9ine, US v. Jones, 18-cr-834 (PAE).

See also, US v. Shkreli, 260 F. Supp. 3d 257 (EDNY 2017).    The instant request to ban the press states that "no application from any press organization... is reflected on the docket."

This then is such an application, to be docketed. Note ABC v. Stewart, 360 F.3d 90 (2d Cir. 2004) - the district court erred in closing the voir dire proceedings. 'We therefore vacate the portion of the district court's order denying the media contemporaneous access to the voir dire.'

 Already in this case, unlike others in this District, the defendant and his Federal Defenders have sought the total withholding of his submission seeking taxpayer funded counsel. Now they seek further exclusion of the press and public from the upcoming criminal proceeding.

Inner City Press opposes this, and asks for media access to sidebars throughout the proceeding.   Since our August 2020 submission - we still have not seen the sought information - SDNY Judge Rakoff, for example, has granted Inner City Press' application that in US v. Weigand, 20-cr-188 (JSR), all exhibits be made available the evening of their submission. See, here.  We ask, prospectively, for the same in this proceeding - not only on USafx but to the public at large."

On January 8, Avenatti's trial in the Stormy Daniels case was pushed back to... 2022: "MEMO ENDORSEMENT as to Michael Avenatti on [102] Letter re Trial Date: Much as the Court would like to keep the trial date as is, it concludes that, given the continuing public health crisis, going to trial on that date - particularly in a case of this nature - is not likely to be realistic or prudent. Accordingly, and in view of the Defendant's California trial dates, trial is hereby ADJOURNED to January 10, 2022. Within three weeks, defense counsel shall file a letter confirming that Defendant (1) is aware of the trial date and (2) understands that it is a firm date and that any application (e.g., relating to discovery, counsel, etc.) that could affect the ability to begin trial as scheduled may be denied on that basis alone and therefore must be filed as early as possible. The Clerk of Court is directed to terminate ECF No. 102. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Jesse M. Furman on 1/8/2021)."

On January 7 in the Nike case, Avenatti asked to again push back his sentencing to May 2021, full letter on Patreon here.

 On August 27, Inner City Press filed a formal request that documents in the case not be sealed, full filing on Patreon here.

 On November 12, Inner City Press made a third filing with Judge Furman, on a decision to unseal issued earlier in the day by SDNY Judge J. Paul Oetken after Inner City Press filed to similarly unseal Lev Parnas' co-defendant David Correia's financial info, below. It has been docketed in the case before Judge Furman, at Dkt. No. 99.

On November 13 in the Nike case Avenatti sought a delay: "United States v. Avenatti, No. S1 19 Cr. 373 (PGG) Motion for an Additional 60-day Adjournment of Sentencing Date and Filing of Sentencing Submissions Dear Judge Gardephe: Mr. Avenatti’s sentencing hearing is currently scheduled for December 9, 2020. We write to respectfully request an additional adjournment of the sentencing date for approximately sixty (60) days, until early February 2021, if the Court’s schedule permits."

Now on November 16 Judge Gardephe has issued this: "ORDER as to Michael Avenatti: It is hereby ORDERED that the sentencing of Defendant Michael Avenatti, currently scheduled for December 9, 2020, will now take place on February 17, 2021 at 12:00 p.m. Any submissions on behalf of Defendant are due on January 27, 2021, and any submission by the Government is due on February 3, 2021. SO ORDERED. (Sentencing set for 2/17/2021 at 12:00 PM before Judge Paul G. Gardephe) (Signed by Judge Paul G. Gardephe on 11/16/2020)."

From Inner City Press' November 12 letter: "Dear Judge Furman:     Pursuant to this Court's August 28, 2020 Order granting leave to be heard, this is a further argument and District precedent for the unsealing of the CJA Form 23, affidavit and all associated documents in US v. Avenatti, 19-cr-374 (JMF).     Today in US v. Parnas, Correia et al., 19-cr-725, Judge J. Paul Oetken in a nearly identical case in which Inner City Press also timely sought unsealing has ordered that David Correia's financial declarations should be unsealed in full and docketed in five business days. See 19-cr-725, Dkt No 145 citing Dkt No 123 ("letter filed by Matthew Russell Lee advocating for public access to these declaration.")   

 Judge Oetken cites United States v. Smith, 985 F. Supp. 2d 506, 517 (S.D.N.Y. 2013) (collecting cases) and states  "The Court sees no reason why the declarations at issue depart from judicial documents associated with criminal pretrial proceedings as to which the Second Circuit has previously recognized the First Amendment right of access.... Accordingly, defense counsel’s request to seal or redact the attorney declarations is DENIED. Counsel are directed to file the unredacted declarations on the public docket within five business days."   

The same logic obtains and should be applied here, to the too-long filings of Defendant Avenatti.     

Again, Inner City Press which closely covers SDNY criminal proceedings noted in September that before SDNY Magistrate Judge Barbara Moses the financial situation of defendant Jonathan Smith was fully disclosed on the record.  

  Similar disclosures have been made, even this week, in the SDNY Magistrates Court under Judge Freeman.  

  We again ask, why should lower income and less high profile defendants in the SDNY -- and now David Correia -- have their financial information so disclosed while Avenatti's information is sealed in its entirety?     The documents at issue should not be sealed and should be made available." Watch this site.

  On August 28 Judge Furman entered an order: "The Court received the attached communication from Matthew Lee of Inner City Press “seeking leave to be heard and for the unsealing of the CJA Form 23, affidavit, and all associated documents” relating to this litigation. To the extent that Mr. Lee (who is admitted to the bar of the Southern District of New York) seeks leave to be heard, his application is GRANTED. The Court reserves judgment on the question of whether Defendant’s CJA Form 23 and related documents should be unsealed. SO ORDERED. Dated: August 28, 2020 New York, New York JESSE M. FURMAN." Docket No. 85, on Inner City Press' DocumentCloud, here.

 On November 10, with the Avenatti submissions still sealed, he appeared with "with attorneys Robert Baum, Tamara Lila Giwa, and Andrew John Dalack. AUSAs Matthew Podolsky and Robert Sobelman present. Court reporter present. -- Pursuant to Fed R. Crim. P. 5(f), the Court reminded the Government of its obligations under Brady v. Maryland and its progeny. -- Trial is scheduled for April 21, 2021 and is expected to last 2 weeks. Time is excluded in the interests of justice from November 11, 2020 until April 21, 2021. (ab)." The above is the Order; others reported the trial as April 26.

  On September 2 Federal Defenders, rather than attempt to explain why they routinely divulge and put in the public record the financial information of less high profile and lower income clients, stating in Magistrates Court exactly how much their clients make and where they and even their spouses work, has written in this: "The defense acknowledges that the Court granted Matthew Lee, a representative of “Inner City Press,” leave to be heard on this matter. The defense requests leave to respond to Mr. Lee one week from the timely filing of any substantive brief or letter. For now, it bears emphasizing that the Court’s measures requiring the Federal Defenders to keep an accurate record of the hours spent on Mr. Avenatti’s defense, and also requiring Mr. Avenatti to regularly update the Court on his finances, are sufficient to protect the public fisc and to ensure that funds for court-appointed counsel are being properly spent. Further, “neither the First Amendment nor the common law provides a right of access to financial documents submitted with an initial application to demonstrate a defendant’s eligibility for CJA assistance.” In re Boston Herald, Inc., 321 F.3d 174, 191 (1st Cir. 2003). And “even if there were a common law presumption of access, then it would be outweighed here … by [Avenatti’s] countervailing privacy interests” and rights under the Fifth and Sixth Amendments. Id."  Full letter on Patreon here. It is UNacceptable -- the public's and press' right of access is not limited to the public fisc, it is based on the FIRST Amendment. 

  Hearing nothing more, but continuing to closely cover all things SDNY, on September 8 Inner City Press filed again: "Re: US v. Avenatti, 19-cr-374 (JMF) - Further on the need to unseal CJA Form 23 and associated documents including affidavit 

Dear Judge Furman:     Pursuant to this Court's August 28, 2020 Order granting leave to be heard, and in response to Federal Defenders' September 2 (footnote) response), this is a further argument for the unsealing of the CJA Form 23, affidavit and all associated documents in US v. Avenatti, 19-cr-374 (JMF).   

  Before citing case law, Inner City Press which closely covers SDNY criminal proceedings notes that just today, before SDNY Magistrate Judge Barbara Moses, the financial situation of defendant Jonathan Smith was fully disclosed on the record.

To obtain CJA counsel it was disclosed that Mr. Smith of The Bronx received $471 a week in unemployment, and pays $150 to $200 a month in child support of each of his three children, and $65 a month for cell phone service. See, US v. Smith, 20-cr-317 (Swain / Moses).    

We again ask, why should lower income and less high profile defendants in the SDNY have their financial information so disclosed while Avenatti's information is sealed in its entirety? 

  Avenatti in his other SDNY case, in which he was convicted by a jury, has requested another adjournment of sentencing, to December.   

 On September 10, Federal Defenders responded, saying that the disclosure of the Bronxite and Massachusetts drug defendants' information is somehow different than for Avenatti, who is apparently in their view due great privacy and protection. Then they threaten to appeal if Judge Furman rules for transparency: "RE: United States v. Michael Avenatti 19 Cr. 374 (JMF) Dear Judge Furman: We write to briefly respond to the letter submitted on behalf of Inner City Press by Matthew R. Lee requesting the unsealing of Michael Avenatti’s CJA 23 Form and accompanying affidavit. See Dkt. No. 90. Neither the public nor the media have a presumptive right to access the financial documents of a defendant who seeks court-appointed counsel under the Sixth Amendment. In re Boston Herald, Inc., 321 F.3d 174, 191 (1st Cir. 2003) (“[N]either the First Amendment nor the common law provides a right of access to financial documents submitted with an initial application to demonstrate a defendant’s eligibility for CJA assistance.”). And as discussed more thoroughly in Mr. Avenatti’s previous letters, any such common law or First Amendment interest is trumped by the real and appreciable risk of self-incrimination Mr. Avenatti faces should his sworn statements about his financial condition be made available to the government or publicly.1  1 As set forth in Mr. Avenatti’s reply to the government’s response in opposition to keeping his sworn financial statements sealed, the court in the Central District of California presiding over a different case against him has sealed Mr. Avenatti’s application for court-appointed counsel under Ninth Circuit precedent and local rules. Accordingly, Mr. Avenatti respectfully requests that the Court stay any order to unseal those same documents in this case so that he may pursue appropriate appellate relief."

We'll have more on this, once the situation becomes clearer - it is not clear if Inner City Press is permitted to surreply to this. It should not be necessary. The courts should be transparent, and defendants should be treated equally.

And later the US Attorney's Office said, " in light of the presumption of openness in criminal proceedings and the approach favored by the Second Circuit, the defendant has failed to provide a legally sufficient basis for wholesale and indefinite sealing of the CJA 23 Form and supporting affidavit." Full letter on Patreon here. Now we await Avenatti's / his Federal Defenders' reply. Watch this site.

This case is US v. Avenatti, 19-cr-374 (Furman).

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

HSBC Accused For Breaching China Mexico Iron Ore Deal In SDNY Lawsuit

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

SDNY COURTHOUSE, May 5 – Lamda Solutions Corp. counted  on HSBC Bank in connection with brokering a iron ore deal between China and Mexico. HSBC reneged, and Lamda sued.  

 On May 5, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Gregory H. Woods held a proceeding. Inner City Press covered it. 

 Judge Woods asked where in the complaint the breach of contract was to be found.

The plaintiff's lawyer pointed to Paragraph 10, that HSBC "confirmed its interest in proceeding with the transaction." HSBC's Yonkers branch is cited.

The case is Lamda Solutions Corp. v. HSBC Bank USA, N.A., 21-cv-2259 (Woods)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Columbia Doctor Hadden Pushed Trial to 2022 Now Questions DOJ Sharing With DiPietro

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Video Photo
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

SDNY COURTHOUSE, May 5 –  Columbia University doctor Robert A. Hadden was hit on September 9 with a Federal indictment charging that "sexually abused dozens of female patients, including multiple minors, under the guise of conducting purported gynecological and obstetric examinations."

The case was assigned to U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Richard M. Berman, who handled the case of Jeffrey Epstein until he died in the Metropolitan Correctional Center.   Epstein came up during the bail argument, which Hadden won. Inner City Press live tweeted it, below.

  On December 23 Judge Berman denied Hadden's request for a taxpayer funded lawyer, and said that Clayman & Rosenberg LLP which represented Hadden at his arraignment and since should remain on the case.

 On December 24 as Inner City Press within minutes reported that firm, through Wayne E. Gosnell, Hr. and Isabell Kirshner, wrote to Judge Berman arguing they only represented Hadden on bail, criticizing the process and result of them being kept in the case. They say that "as officers of the court" they will file a redacted financial statement, but that they want out. See below.

On April 15, 2021, Hadden's Federal Defenders wrote to Judge Berman seeking to push the trial back into 2022. The letter has a number of redactions. But hours later, this:

ORDER as to Robert Hadden: Based upon the record herein, the submission of Defense counsel, dated April 14, 2021, the submission of Government counsel, dated April 15, 2021, and the continuing COVID pandemic, the pretrial motion schedule; the trial submission schedule; and trial date are modified as follows: 1- Defense pretrial motion is due August 2, 2021; 2- Government response is due September 2, 2021; 3- Defense reply (if any) is due September 15, 2021; 4- Trial will commence on Wednesday, January 5, 2022; 5- Motions in limine, joint proposed jury charges, joint proposed voir dire, joint proposed verdict sheet, joint list of names and places, are due on November 15, 2021; 6- Responses to motions in limine are due on November 22, 2021; 7- A final pretrial conference will be held on Wednesday, December 15, 2021. (Signed by Judge Richard M. Berman on 4/15/2021)."

  But even now on May 5, Hadden's Federal Defender has written to the US Attorney's Office including to "please set forth whether Anthony DiPietro, the civil lawyer suing Mr. Hadden, and the US Attorney's Office / FBI are sharing information... some appears to be subject to a protective order entered by Judge Billings in NY Supreme Court Index # 152438/20017, Order dated July 26, 2019 (NYSECF # 236)." Watch this site.

 On December 26, Judge Berman denied and criticized their letter: "Defense counsel Gosnell and Kirshner’s 10-page letter to the Court in this case, dated December 24, 2020, is respectfully rejected. And, the Court’s Decision & Order, dated December 23, 2020, remains fully in effect. If defense counsel intended or intend to seek or obtain specific action or relief from the Court (or any of the Court’s staff), they must do so in a written motion, and in accordance with the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure and the Court’s individual rules. See e.g. Fed. R. Cr. P. 47. If counsels’ intention in sending their December 24 letter to the Court was to share their stream of consciousness musings and opinions following the Court’s Decision & Order, even if their letter had been factually and/or legally correct, their letter was improper (and quite rude)."

 On December 28, the lawyers followed up by filing a motion: "Dear Judge Berman:  We are temporary counsel to Robert Hadden. We write following (1) this Court’s Decision & Order dated December 23, 2020; (2) Clayman & Rosenberg LLP’s Letter Motion dated December 24, 2020; and (3) this Court’s December 26, 2020 Order rejecting Clayman & Rosenberg LLP’s Letter Motion.  Pursuant to the December 26 Order, Clayman & Rosenberg LLP will be filing a motion that addresses its status as counsel to Mr. Hadden in this matter and Mr. Hadden’s application for court-appointed counsel."

 Judge Berman after-hours on December 28 granted some, but said the unsealing must proceed: "MEMO ENDORSEMENT re: [38] LETTER MOTION re: Briefing Schedule and Partial Stay of Decision & Order as to Robert Hadden (1). ENDORSEMENT: Defendant's proposed motion is acceptable with with two modifications: (1) no stay of redactions; and (2) Government response to Defendant's motion is not optional. (Signed by Judge Richard M. Berman on 12/28/2020)."

  As Inner City Press predicted on December 24, it seems they might appeal.

Then on January 12, a referral from Judge Berman, to Magistrate Judge Ona T. Wang.

  Inner City Press live tweeted the proceeding on January 15, here

On January 20, Federal Defender Deirdre D. von Dornum asked Magistrate Judge Ona T. Wang to reconsider her order that Hadden must transfer $100,000 of his $130,000 to the SDNY Clerk of Court. She points out that $11,800 is supposed to be the maximum and proposed $2000 a month.

 Judge Wang held a proceeding on February 4 and Inner City Press live tweeted it here:

Judge Wang: I found Mr. Hadden was partially eligible for appointed (publicly-paid) counsel. I will reconsider, now with financial statements provided in redacted form

Here's from Hadden's financial statements, put into the docket in this case (of the type still being withheld as to Michael Avenatti despite Inner City Press' pending application to unseal, here)

Hadden says he's had to fix his water heater.

Judge Wang: I am going to vacate my previous order that Mr Hadden pay $100,000. Instead, this is my directive: Federal Defenders should keep track of their time monthly, & Mr Hadden is to pay it to the Clerk of Court

Federal Defenders: Will it be at the CJA rate? With the applicable cap?

Judge Wang: Yes. If the cap comes into play, we will consider it then. [$12,000?] Adjourned.

Watch this site.

On December 23 Judge Berman, in a 9 am proceeding that Inner City Press covered, recounted how Hadden disclaimed his share of a $2 million inheritance from his father (in favor of his children), and transferred funds. His affidavit will be made public - while Inner City Press has filed to unseal that of Michael Avenatti, here.

  Talk turned to putting a foot on the gas pedal for discovery. Thread here.

  It emerges that Judge Berman granted modifications to Hadden's bond - and the sealing of the names of non-family suretors. No notice to the press and public was provided.

On October 21 Judge Berman held a proceeding, and Inner City Press live tweeted it here:

Judge Berman is starting - says Hadden wants a tax payer funded lawyer now (like Michael Avenatti has gotten, while sealing his affidavit for now, here, like Parnas co-defendant David Correia).

 Judge Berman says he wants more information from Hadden. Judge Berman: We need a more professional and up to date financial affidavit. I want one that is notarized, accompanied by a certified financial report prepared by an accountant. [Could most low income defendants do this? What are the rules/ And will it be public?

 Now Pre-Trial Services from NJ is on the line.  Judge Berman: I need more than back of the envelope type information, before I can determine if he is entitled to appointed counsel. We're going to have to do a do-over.

Q: Like in a pre-sentence report? Judge Berman: I want three years of financials, certified. Then I'll take a look. For the moment, I prefer that current counsel remains in the picture. Any questions? So, the 2d issue, I want to hear from pre-trial services

Pre-trial: No issues. He calls in when need. Judge Berman: He has other obligations. A mental health evaluation & therapeutic counseling.  Pre-Trial: I have spoken with his psychiatrist.  Judge Berman: Did you mention a name?

Pre-Trial: They are meeting on Zoom

Hadden's lawyer: That should be ex parte, not public - like the suretors are not public. Some might target them, members of the public who have an agenda.

Judge Berman: I don't agree as to professionals. Over your objection, I am going to ask for the names.

 Pre-Trial: Susan Powders (sp), psychiatrist and Dr Mirantz, psychologist, tele-health. Judge Berman:  I had requested documents from the NYS court proceeding, the plea and sentencing transcript [Inner City Press note: echoes of Epstein, Florida state proceeding]

Judge Berman: You've said you want to avoid additional adverse pre-trial publicity - that is, to not file the NYS transcripts. But they are publicly filed documents, including the risk assessment repeated in the NYS sentencing proceeding Inner City Press

Judge Berman: You've argued that the non public nature of the documents is based on the practices of the NY County DA

Judge Berman: Frankly I didn't see much that was private in those documents... There was a written waiver of a right to appeal... the SORA risk assessment (Judge Berman reading from a transcript)

Judge Berman: The NYS documents were relied upon, so I am going to file on the public docket: the NYS indictment, the NYS plea transcript, the NYS sentencing transcript, the risk assessment, the NYS plea agreement and the email between the ADA and Hadden's counsel

 AUSA: If Hadden gets a taxpayer funded CJA lawyer, the government is only aware of conflicts of interest with regard to Debevoise and Paul Weiss, but not with Federal Defenders.

 Hadden's lawyer asks how to get anything notarized due to COVID. Judge Berman says he's looking forward to it. Sets next conference for after election day. Nov 12, 9:30 pm.

 On September 25 Judge Berman held a proceeding, and Inner City Press live tweeted:

Hadden's lawyer emphasizes he stopped practicing medicine in 2012. AUSA wants names redacted; says her Office forwards all court date info to the victims.

Judge Berman: If you send me a joint letter, maybe the next status conference won't be needed. First is the conditional discharge that was subject to the plea agreement. Was it for three years? Or one year?

 Judge Berman: And what's the level of Mr. Hadden's reporting in New Jersey, where he lives?

Q: Is the Court asking the District Attorney's office to say why it accept, for Mr. Haddan, Level 1?

[NOTE: While NY DA is playing hero in 2d Cir, looking baaad here.]

 Hadden proceeding wrapping up. Next is Oct 2, though that would be canceled if bail issues are resolved. There's a letter due about what NY District Attorney did on Hadden

 Inner City Press will continue on this.

  Back on September 9 close to 10 pm, Hadden emerged from Pre-Trial then the courthouse. Inner City Press and three others sought to ask him questions, about the victims' statements and double jeopardy. He did not answer. A man in an FBI t-shirt led him first up Mulberry Street, then past the NYC criminal court at 100 Centre Street and finally out to Broadway and Reade Street where a taxi was waiting for Hadden. Periscope video here.

 SDNY Acting US Attorney Audrey Strauss held a press conference about the case on September 9.

  Inner City Press asked her if the indictment had been returned by a fully in-person grand jury, or if it had included a virtual component of the type being questioned in the CIA / Joshua Schulte, Melzer, Balde and other cases.

   US Attorney Strauss said the indictment was returned in the normal course, by a sitting grand jury. Periscope video here. Alamy photo here. She declined to say whether her office would be seeking detention pending trial, or agreeing to a bail package as they did in the recent case of indicted UN rapist Karim Elkorany.

There was no mention at the press conference for the charges against Hadden made publicly by Evelyn Yang, the wife of Andrew Yang, and not much mention of Manhattan DA Cyrus Vance.

Hours later, a bail proceeding before SDNY Magistrate Judge Robert Lehrburger (and not the Magistrate on duty on September 8, Barbara Moses). Inner City Press live tweeted it:

Speaking for the US is AUSA Maurene Comey...

 Judge Lehrburger: We are proceeding under the CARES Act. This is open to the press and public. Any recording is  prohibited. Hadden's lawyer: We are only representing him for this proceeding

 Judge Lehrburger: You have the right to remain silent... You have a right to be released unless I find danger to the community or risk of non-appearance for future court proceedings.  [Note: Ghislaine Maxwell was found a risk of flight]

Judge Lehrburger: You are charged with six counts of Enticement and Inducement to Travel To Engage In Illegal Sex Acts. Hadden's lawyer enters not guilty plea. AUSA Maurene Comey: The government seeks detention as risk of flight.

AUSA Comey: Today, the government has communicated with 20 victims. They all say he should be detained. He has the financial means to flee. Because of the minor victim, there is a statutory presumption of detention that cannot be overcome.

 AUSA Comey: He abused dozens of victims, including multiple minors, as prominent institution's [Columbia U] OB-GYN. He would sent nurses out of the room. [Did they ever report it?]

AUSA Comey: He conducted unneeded breast exams. He touched genitals without any medical purpose. He attempted to stimulate them, to gratify himself. For two decades. One victim, he had delivered as a baby

AUSA Comey: The women traveled to see him because he worked at a prominent institution. [What about Columbia?]

 The case is US v. Hadden, 20-cr-468 (Berman / Wang).

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.