Saturday, May 8, 2021

Columbia Doctor Hadden Pushed Trial to 2022 Now Questions DOJ Sharing With DiPietro

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Video Photo
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

SDNY COURTHOUSE, May 5 –  Columbia University doctor Robert A. Hadden was hit on September 9 with a Federal indictment charging that "sexually abused dozens of female patients, including multiple minors, under the guise of conducting purported gynecological and obstetric examinations."

The case was assigned to U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Richard M. Berman, who handled the case of Jeffrey Epstein until he died in the Metropolitan Correctional Center.   Epstein came up during the bail argument, which Hadden won. Inner City Press live tweeted it, below.

  On December 23 Judge Berman denied Hadden's request for a taxpayer funded lawyer, and said that Clayman & Rosenberg LLP which represented Hadden at his arraignment and since should remain on the case.

 On December 24 as Inner City Press within minutes reported that firm, through Wayne E. Gosnell, Hr. and Isabell Kirshner, wrote to Judge Berman arguing they only represented Hadden on bail, criticizing the process and result of them being kept in the case. They say that "as officers of the court" they will file a redacted financial statement, but that they want out. See below.

On April 15, 2021, Hadden's Federal Defenders wrote to Judge Berman seeking to push the trial back into 2022. The letter has a number of redactions. But hours later, this:

ORDER as to Robert Hadden: Based upon the record herein, the submission of Defense counsel, dated April 14, 2021, the submission of Government counsel, dated April 15, 2021, and the continuing COVID pandemic, the pretrial motion schedule; the trial submission schedule; and trial date are modified as follows: 1- Defense pretrial motion is due August 2, 2021; 2- Government response is due September 2, 2021; 3- Defense reply (if any) is due September 15, 2021; 4- Trial will commence on Wednesday, January 5, 2022; 5- Motions in limine, joint proposed jury charges, joint proposed voir dire, joint proposed verdict sheet, joint list of names and places, are due on November 15, 2021; 6- Responses to motions in limine are due on November 22, 2021; 7- A final pretrial conference will be held on Wednesday, December 15, 2021. (Signed by Judge Richard M. Berman on 4/15/2021)."

  But even now on May 5, Hadden's Federal Defender has written to the US Attorney's Office including to "please set forth whether Anthony DiPietro, the civil lawyer suing Mr. Hadden, and the US Attorney's Office / FBI are sharing information... some appears to be subject to a protective order entered by Judge Billings in NY Supreme Court Index # 152438/20017, Order dated July 26, 2019 (NYSECF # 236)." Watch this site.

 On December 26, Judge Berman denied and criticized their letter: "Defense counsel Gosnell and Kirshner’s 10-page letter to the Court in this case, dated December 24, 2020, is respectfully rejected. And, the Court’s Decision & Order, dated December 23, 2020, remains fully in effect. If defense counsel intended or intend to seek or obtain specific action or relief from the Court (or any of the Court’s staff), they must do so in a written motion, and in accordance with the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure and the Court’s individual rules. See e.g. Fed. R. Cr. P. 47. If counsels’ intention in sending their December 24 letter to the Court was to share their stream of consciousness musings and opinions following the Court’s Decision & Order, even if their letter had been factually and/or legally correct, their letter was improper (and quite rude)."

 On December 28, the lawyers followed up by filing a motion: "Dear Judge Berman:  We are temporary counsel to Robert Hadden. We write following (1) this Court’s Decision & Order dated December 23, 2020; (2) Clayman & Rosenberg LLP’s Letter Motion dated December 24, 2020; and (3) this Court’s December 26, 2020 Order rejecting Clayman & Rosenberg LLP’s Letter Motion.  Pursuant to the December 26 Order, Clayman & Rosenberg LLP will be filing a motion that addresses its status as counsel to Mr. Hadden in this matter and Mr. Hadden’s application for court-appointed counsel."

 Judge Berman after-hours on December 28 granted some, but said the unsealing must proceed: "MEMO ENDORSEMENT re: [38] LETTER MOTION re: Briefing Schedule and Partial Stay of Decision & Order as to Robert Hadden (1). ENDORSEMENT: Defendant's proposed motion is acceptable with with two modifications: (1) no stay of redactions; and (2) Government response to Defendant's motion is not optional. (Signed by Judge Richard M. Berman on 12/28/2020)."

  As Inner City Press predicted on December 24, it seems they might appeal.

Then on January 12, a referral from Judge Berman, to Magistrate Judge Ona T. Wang.

  Inner City Press live tweeted the proceeding on January 15, here

On January 20, Federal Defender Deirdre D. von Dornum asked Magistrate Judge Ona T. Wang to reconsider her order that Hadden must transfer $100,000 of his $130,000 to the SDNY Clerk of Court. She points out that $11,800 is supposed to be the maximum and proposed $2000 a month.

 Judge Wang held a proceeding on February 4 and Inner City Press live tweeted it here:

Judge Wang: I found Mr. Hadden was partially eligible for appointed (publicly-paid) counsel. I will reconsider, now with financial statements provided in redacted form

Here's from Hadden's financial statements, put into the docket in this case (of the type still being withheld as to Michael Avenatti despite Inner City Press' pending application to unseal, here)

Hadden says he's had to fix his water heater.

Judge Wang: I am going to vacate my previous order that Mr Hadden pay $100,000. Instead, this is my directive: Federal Defenders should keep track of their time monthly, & Mr Hadden is to pay it to the Clerk of Court

Federal Defenders: Will it be at the CJA rate? With the applicable cap?

Judge Wang: Yes. If the cap comes into play, we will consider it then. [$12,000?] Adjourned.

Watch this site.

On December 23 Judge Berman, in a 9 am proceeding that Inner City Press covered, recounted how Hadden disclaimed his share of a $2 million inheritance from his father (in favor of his children), and transferred funds. His affidavit will be made public - while Inner City Press has filed to unseal that of Michael Avenatti, here.

  Talk turned to putting a foot on the gas pedal for discovery. Thread here.

  It emerges that Judge Berman granted modifications to Hadden's bond - and the sealing of the names of non-family suretors. No notice to the press and public was provided.

On October 21 Judge Berman held a proceeding, and Inner City Press live tweeted it here:

Judge Berman is starting - says Hadden wants a tax payer funded lawyer now (like Michael Avenatti has gotten, while sealing his affidavit for now, here, like Parnas co-defendant David Correia).

 Judge Berman says he wants more information from Hadden. Judge Berman: We need a more professional and up to date financial affidavit. I want one that is notarized, accompanied by a certified financial report prepared by an accountant. [Could most low income defendants do this? What are the rules/ And will it be public?

 Now Pre-Trial Services from NJ is on the line.  Judge Berman: I need more than back of the envelope type information, before I can determine if he is entitled to appointed counsel. We're going to have to do a do-over.

Q: Like in a pre-sentence report? Judge Berman: I want three years of financials, certified. Then I'll take a look. For the moment, I prefer that current counsel remains in the picture. Any questions? So, the 2d issue, I want to hear from pre-trial services

Pre-trial: No issues. He calls in when need. Judge Berman: He has other obligations. A mental health evaluation & therapeutic counseling.  Pre-Trial: I have spoken with his psychiatrist.  Judge Berman: Did you mention a name?

Pre-Trial: They are meeting on Zoom

Hadden's lawyer: That should be ex parte, not public - like the suretors are not public. Some might target them, members of the public who have an agenda.

Judge Berman: I don't agree as to professionals. Over your objection, I am going to ask for the names.

 Pre-Trial: Susan Powders (sp), psychiatrist and Dr Mirantz, psychologist, tele-health. Judge Berman:  I had requested documents from the NYS court proceeding, the plea and sentencing transcript [Inner City Press note: echoes of Epstein, Florida state proceeding]

Judge Berman: You've said you want to avoid additional adverse pre-trial publicity - that is, to not file the NYS transcripts. But they are publicly filed documents, including the risk assessment repeated in the NYS sentencing proceeding Inner City Press

Judge Berman: You've argued that the non public nature of the documents is based on the practices of the NY County DA

Judge Berman: Frankly I didn't see much that was private in those documents... There was a written waiver of a right to appeal... the SORA risk assessment (Judge Berman reading from a transcript)

Judge Berman: The NYS documents were relied upon, so I am going to file on the public docket: the NYS indictment, the NYS plea transcript, the NYS sentencing transcript, the risk assessment, the NYS plea agreement and the email between the ADA and Hadden's counsel

 AUSA: If Hadden gets a taxpayer funded CJA lawyer, the government is only aware of conflicts of interest with regard to Debevoise and Paul Weiss, but not with Federal Defenders.

 Hadden's lawyer asks how to get anything notarized due to COVID. Judge Berman says he's looking forward to it. Sets next conference for after election day. Nov 12, 9:30 pm.

 On September 25 Judge Berman held a proceeding, and Inner City Press live tweeted:

Hadden's lawyer emphasizes he stopped practicing medicine in 2012. AUSA wants names redacted; says her Office forwards all court date info to the victims.

Judge Berman: If you send me a joint letter, maybe the next status conference won't be needed. First is the conditional discharge that was subject to the plea agreement. Was it for three years? Or one year?

 Judge Berman: And what's the level of Mr. Hadden's reporting in New Jersey, where he lives?

Q: Is the Court asking the District Attorney's office to say why it accept, for Mr. Haddan, Level 1?

[NOTE: While NY DA is playing hero in 2d Cir, looking baaad here.]

 Hadden proceeding wrapping up. Next is Oct 2, though that would be canceled if bail issues are resolved. There's a letter due about what NY District Attorney did on Hadden

 Inner City Press will continue on this.

  Back on September 9 close to 10 pm, Hadden emerged from Pre-Trial then the courthouse. Inner City Press and three others sought to ask him questions, about the victims' statements and double jeopardy. He did not answer. A man in an FBI t-shirt led him first up Mulberry Street, then past the NYC criminal court at 100 Centre Street and finally out to Broadway and Reade Street where a taxi was waiting for Hadden. Periscope video here.

 SDNY Acting US Attorney Audrey Strauss held a press conference about the case on September 9.

  Inner City Press asked her if the indictment had been returned by a fully in-person grand jury, or if it had included a virtual component of the type being questioned in the CIA / Joshua Schulte, Melzer, Balde and other cases.

   US Attorney Strauss said the indictment was returned in the normal course, by a sitting grand jury. Periscope video here. Alamy photo here. She declined to say whether her office would be seeking detention pending trial, or agreeing to a bail package as they did in the recent case of indicted UN rapist Karim Elkorany.

There was no mention at the press conference for the charges against Hadden made publicly by Evelyn Yang, the wife of Andrew Yang, and not much mention of Manhattan DA Cyrus Vance.

Hours later, a bail proceeding before SDNY Magistrate Judge Robert Lehrburger (and not the Magistrate on duty on September 8, Barbara Moses). Inner City Press live tweeted it:

Speaking for the US is AUSA Maurene Comey...

 Judge Lehrburger: We are proceeding under the CARES Act. This is open to the press and public. Any recording is  prohibited. Hadden's lawyer: We are only representing him for this proceeding

 Judge Lehrburger: You have the right to remain silent... You have a right to be released unless I find danger to the community or risk of non-appearance for future court proceedings.  [Note: Ghislaine Maxwell was found a risk of flight]

Judge Lehrburger: You are charged with six counts of Enticement and Inducement to Travel To Engage In Illegal Sex Acts. Hadden's lawyer enters not guilty plea. AUSA Maurene Comey: The government seeks detention as risk of flight.

AUSA Comey: Today, the government has communicated with 20 victims. They all say he should be detained. He has the financial means to flee. Because of the minor victim, there is a statutory presumption of detention that cannot be overcome.

 AUSA Comey: He abused dozens of victims, including multiple minors, as prominent institution's [Columbia U] OB-GYN. He would sent nurses out of the room. [Did they ever report it?]

AUSA Comey: He conducted unneeded breast exams. He touched genitals without any medical purpose. He attempted to stimulate them, to gratify himself. For two decades. One victim, he had delivered as a baby

AUSA Comey: The women traveled to see him because he worked at a prominent institution. [What about Columbia?]

 The case is US v. Hadden, 20-cr-468 (Berman / Wang).

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Corrupt UNPGA Volkan Bozkir Spox Blocks Press & Refuses Transparency Worse Than Ashe

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Periscope
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - CJR - PFT

UN GATE, May 4 – In the United Nations pn September 14, 2020, the day before Volkan Bozkir took over as President of the General Assembly, Inner City Press wrote to his spokesperson Brenden Varma "to request the password(s) to access and ask a question at the September 15 press conference."

  Varma replied, "This will be my first hybrid press conference, and I’m not sure how virtual access works. Please follow up with MALU."

   MALU, run by Melissa Fleming, has not answered. So Inner City Press emailed Varma this question: Why is there NO CONTENT on the PGA's "Ethics and Transparency" page, given that this was the lone reform after it was shown that PGA Ashe took bribes from Ng Lap Seng, and PGA Kutesa arranged bribes from CEFC China Energy? How much did Mr. Bozkir spend on his campaign for PGA? Who paid for all travel? Who are the staff members and who is paying each one?

  The response? Brenden Varma, "spokesman" of PGA, blocked Inner City Press on Twitter. Photo here. This is the UN, and Bozkir.

Now on May 4, after months of failure including being rebuffed even by NYC Mayor De Blasio and running interference for Antonio Guterres lust for a second term of bribe taking, on May 3 Bozkir held a staged press conference and afterwards bragged about some of the coverage. Not so fast.

Bozkir on May 4 said, "I wasn't thinking of saying this, but you must not ask these questions continuously to [my spokesperson] Brenden Varma." We call B.S. - his "spokes" person Varma BLOCKS THE PRESS. And Bozkir knows it. It is a charade, a corrupt charade. And he still hadn't answered who pays his staff members, the lone reform to come out of the John Ashe PGA scandal. So, Bozkir is worse than Ashe. Ashe to ashes.

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Omar Amanat Hiring Patterson Belknap Under Question Before SDNY Judge Gardephe

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

SDNY COURTHOUSE, May 4 – Omar Amanat, described as a high flying tech entrepreneur and producer of some of the "Twilight" films until his indictment for fraud, now faces sentencing.

But the law firm seeking to represent him may not be able to.

On May 4, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Paul G. Gardephe held a proceeding. Inner City Press covered it. 

At issue was whether Judge Gardephe's long ties with the law firm of Patterson, Belknap, Webb & Tyler LLP means either he would be recused - unlikely, given the word he has put into the wider case - or Patterson Belknap be barred from putting in a notice of appearance.  

Judge Gardephe to his credit ran though his connections to Patterson Belknap. He was an associate there from 1983 to 1987, then a partner from 2003 to 2008 when he took the bench. Many of his law clerks have been hired there, and two of him mentors from there have photos on the wall of his chambers.   

The Patterson Belknap representative acknowledged the unlikelihood of recusal but said they though appearing for the sentencing would be different.

Judge Gardephe requested submission on the issue, including from Assistant US Attorney Daniel Tracer.  

Sentencing was tentatively set for August 19, two days after the sentencing of Omar's brother Irfan Amanat.

A request was made to lift the separation order the brothers have been subject to in the MDC; Judge Gardephe directed Tracer to tell the MDC it is lifted.

The case is USA v. Tuzman et al., 15-cr-536 (Gardephe)

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Brooklyn Rapper Jeezy Mula Pled Guilty to Bank Fraud Conspiracy Now Gets 24 Months

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive Patreon
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - The Source

SDNY COURTHOUSE, May 4 – Brooklyn rapper Dajahn McBean, also known as Jeezy Mula, entered a guilty plea on January 22 to conspiracy to commit bank fraud. He got a plea deal for a stipulated guideline of 63 to 78 months in prison. More on Patreon here.

On April 30 he had this sentencing, and Inner City Press covered it, here. Now docketed on May 4, the full order: "JUDGMENT IN A CRIMINAL CASE as to Dajahn McBean (1). THE DEFENDANT: pleaded guilty to Count One. ALL OPEN COUNTS are dismissed on the motion of the United States. IMPRISONMENT: Twenty-four (24) months, which the Court orders to run concurrently with any undischarged portion of Mr. McBean's sentence in the case in Westchester County Court assigned docket number 00157S-2019. In imposing this sentence, the Court has credited Mr. McBean pursuant to U.S.S.G. § 5G1.3(b) for 27 months of time previously served that will not be credited to the sentence in this case by the Bureau of Prisons. The court makes the following recommendations to the Bureau of Prisons: The Court recommends that Defendant be designated to a facility of an appropriate security level close to the New York City metropolitan area. The defendant is remanded to the custody of the United States Marshal. SUPERVISED RELEASE: Three (3) years. See SPECIAL CONDITIONS OF SUPERVISION. ASSESSMENT: $100.00 due immediately. RESTITUTION: $55,705.34. Name of Payee: Restitution order to follow. Special instructions regarding the payment of criminal monetary penalties: In accordance with a restitution order to be issued at a later date. The defendant shall forfeit the defendant's interest in the following property to the United States: $55,705.34 (Signed by Judge Katherine Polk Failla on 5/3/2021)."

  Inner City Press live tweeted January 22  here:

Jeezy Mula a/k/a Dajahn McBean pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit bank fraud. Inner City Press first reported the change of plea on Dec 28 here

Judge Failla: Are you being treated by a doctor? McBean: Did I ever go to a doctor? Judge: No, is your mind clear today, for this proceeding? McBean: Yes.

 Judge: Do you waive your presence? McBean: Yes, I'll make this video. Inner City Press

Judge Failla: If you plead guilty, and I accept your plea, there will be no appeal of whether you committed the offense. Do you understand? McBean / Jeezy Mula: Yes, Your Honor.  Judge Failla: The maximum term of imprisonment is thirty years in prison.

Judge Failla: Do you have other open cases? McBean / Jeezy Mula: The one in Westchester, and another in the Eastern District. Judge Failla: What is the status? McBean: Could my lawyer answer that? Lawyer: Open indictment in EDNY, I'm not the attorney of record. Defense lawyer: There is also a violation of supervised release proceeding before Judge Sullivan. Judge Failla: I remember that one.  [Inner City Press too, here]

McBean / Jeezy Mula: Could I speak with my attorney one last time before the plea?

[Break]

They're back; Judge Failla discloses to McBean's counsel that she had a short discussion with AUSA Chan, about the signing of papers, going into the Office / Chambers, etc. All fine. Judge Failla: Do you admit to the forfeiture, $55,000? McBean: Yes, your Honor.

 Judge Failla: You and the government have agreed to a stipulated guidelines range starting at 63 months, correct?

McBean / Jeezy Mula: Yes, Your Honor. Judge Failla: And you should receive credit for the time you are serving on this Westchester County case.

 Judge Failla: You are agreeing not to appeal any sentence between 63 and 78 months, correct?

McBean / Jeezy Mula: Yes, Your Honor.   McBean describes counterfeit check scheme, involving Manhattan 

AUSA Andrew Ken-Wei Chan: We would show that the defendant and William Valdez were arrested after a car chase with debit cards in others' names. We have surveillance video of AMTs in the SDNY, text messages from Valdez' cell phone

 Judge Failla: Mr McBean, how do you plead? McBean / Jeezy Mula: Guilty, your Honor.

McBean's lawyer: Can we put off sentencing in light of the EDNY matter?

Judge Failla: Might your client want to Rule 20 that case to over here?

Proceeding was over; guilty plea accepted.

Now on January 25, a sentencing date was set: "Set/Reset Deadlines/Hearings as to Dajahn McBean: Sentencing set for 4/30/2021 at 09:00 AM before Judge Katherine Polk Failla."

Document on Patreon here.

   Inner City Press will aim to cover and live tweet the plea and subsequent proceeding.

Earlier, McBean seemed to have supporters in Garden City.

 A document was Fed-Exed from there with a forged or satire court order that he should be released, it emerged on July 29 in a proceeding that Inner City Press covered, apparently exclusively.
  
  McBean has two cases in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, before SDNY Judge Katherine Polk Failla and Second Circuit Judge Richard J. Sullivan, as well as an EDNY case on which he has yet to be presented.

 On July 29 Judge Failla held a proceeding; Inner City Press covered it. After a routine interchange setting a briefing schedule of September 11 and 25 and October 2, Judge Failla announced that a false filing had been made.

  She said a Federal Express package had arrived with a false signature of Judge Sullivan, saying that McBean was now a "supervisee." She said Judge Sullivan is "not amused," and asked McBean's lawyer Steven Gary Brill if he knew anything about it.

  No, Brill said. AUSA Andrew Chan said he had been made aware of it by Judge Sullivan's chambers.

   Judge Failla noted that McBean was laughing - Inner City Press could not see, since the CourtCall platform only has video for participants.

 On October 13, the next proceeding was scheduled. But on that very day, the US Attorney's Office wrote in to postpone it to October 30, "because of the defendant's move to another facility." Judge Failla granted it. Inner City Press said it would continue to cover the case - and it has.

 On October 30 at 9 am, Judge Failla held a CourtCall proceeding with McBean. She took an interest in how he will be able to review discovery in the MCC. McBean said he's seen a computer that takes CDs, but no USB. Judge Failla asked that the discovery by taken to his unit and not to the closed library.

She said it has become a pet project for her, prisoners' access to discovery in the MCC and MDC. (She is also handling issues in the civil case of Casiano in Auburn, which Inner City Press is also covering). The trial's set for April.

  Later on October 30 Judge Failla held a proceeding for co-defendant William Valdez to change lawyers, if not go pro so. The change of counsel was approved. And so it goes.

 

  Back in a June 26 video court appearance McBean resisted the mention of William Valdez and did not want the charges against him to be read out loud.

  The proceeding was held by Judge Richard J. Sullivan, now on the Second Circuit Court of Appeals but still handling a number of other cases still on his docket covered by Inner City Press, which covers this one too, live tweeted:

Judge Sullivan: Mr. McBean appeared before me and denied the violations, and asked for a stay pending resolution of the state charges. I heard he pled guilty to assault and is awaiting sentencing.

McBean: Excuse me your honor, if I already talked about the charges with my lawyer, do you have to read them?

Judge Sullivan: I want to make a record. You interacted with William Valdez. Do you admit or deny that allegation?

McBean: I deny.

 Judge Sullivan: There's also conspiracy to commit bank fraud. This is also before Judge Failla. McBean: I deny. Judge Sullivan: Also aggravated identity theft. McBean: Also denied.

Judge Sullivan: I'll ask for periodic updates, every 30 days or so. Any questions Mr. McBean?

McBean: No your Honor.

 Judge Sullivan: Hopefully this COVID thing will work itself out and we'll be back in court in person soon.

This case is US v. McBean, 17-cr-216 (Sullivan).

On May 8 McBean was late for a video proceeding before U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Katharine Polk Failla.

 And McBean wasn't late by choice. He is in Westchester County Jail in Valhalla, and the video connection was late.

  When he got on, he pleaded not guilty to bank fraud charged in a case filed in 2020, but which dates back to allegations in 2018 and early 2019.

  Assistant US Attorney Andrew Chan told Judge Failla that of four smartphone seized in January 2019, law enforcement has only been able to crack one of them.

Still, both McBean and his co-defendant William Valdez are purchasing 1-terabyte hard drive have the discovery material burned onto them.

   Judge Failla said she will inform Judge Richard J. Sullivan, now on the Second Circuit Court of Appeals but who is still handling a McBean case and a number of other cases still on his docket covered by Inner City Press, of the day's proceedings. That case is 20-cr-226, US v. McBean (Failla). 

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.