Saturday, May 8, 2021

In Panama Papers Case Alex von der Goltz OK'd for Guatemala Travel Working for Bulltick LLC


By Matthew Russell Lee, Scope, Podcast

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Feb 17 – As the U.S. Panama Papers prosecution of accountant Richard Gaffey and tax expatriate Harald Joachim von der Goltz moved toward trial, back on May 29 disputes about suppressing files seized from the accountant's office and documents obtained from Panama, Germany and elsewhere overseas came to the fore. See here.

  On February 28, 2020 Gaffey showed up and pled guilty, thread here.

 Now on May 3, Joachim Alexander von der Goltz has requested and obtained permission to travel to Guatemala for the summer, and also on a week's notice for other international business travel, writing that "he is currently employed as a private equity investment adviser at Bulltick LCC, a financial services firm based in Miami, Florida, responsible for identifying companies in the US and Latin America for investment by Bulltick's Private Equity Investment Portfolio." Can you say, Panama Papers?

  Back on February 17, 2021, Harald Joachim von der Goltz asked Judge Richard M. Berman to delay his self surrender to prison, due for March 4, to April 4 so he can get his second dose of COVID vaccine. 

Back on September 24, this: RICHARD GAFFEY, a/k/a “Dick Gaffey,” was sentenced in Manhattan federal court to 39 months in prison for wire fraud, tax fraud, money laundering, aggravated identity theft, and other charges.  GAFFEY, a resident of Massachusetts, was charged along with Harald Joachim von der Goltz, Ramses Owens, and Dirk Brauer in connection with a decades-long criminal scheme perpetrated by Mossack Fonseca & Co. (“Mossack Fonseca”), a Panama-based global law firm, and its related entities.  GAFFEY previously pled guilty to the charges, and was sentenced today by U.S. District Judge Richard M. Berman.

 In July, Harald Joachim von der Goltz  filed a more than 100 page sentencing submission, and the US Attorney's Office has asked for an additional week to respond. The memo has sections on "early business ventures in Germany and Guatemala" (including the brewery Cerveceria del Sur which was stopped when a competitor bribed an employee to over-pasteurize the brew) to "Rain Forest Adventures" and how home confinement would be enough.

  On September 21, this: Harald Joachim von der Goltz was sentenced to 48 months in prison for wire fraud, tax fraud, money laundering, false statements, and other charges.  VON DER GOLTZ, a former U.S. resident and taxpayer, was charged along with Ramses Owens, Dirk Brauer, and Richard Gaffey, a/k/a “Dick Gaffey,” in connection with a decades-long criminal scheme perpetrated by Mossack Fonseca & Co. (“Mossack Fonseca”), a Panamanian-based global law firm, and its related entities.  VON DER GOLTZ previously pleaded guilty to the charges, and was sentenced today by U.S. District Judge Richard M. Berman." He faced 94 to 111 months.

 And now this order of removal: "Upon the application of the United States of America, by Eun Young Choi, Assistant United States Attorney, Southern District of New York and Thane Rehn, Assistant United States Attorney, Southern District of New York; upon the Factual Allegations in Support of Judicial Removal; upon the consent of HARALD JOACHIM VON DER GOLTZ, a/k/a “Harald von der Goltz Nottebohm,” a/k/a “H.J. von der Goltz,” a/k/a “Johan von der Goltz,” a/k/a “Jochen von der Goltz,” a/k/a “Tica,” a/k/a “Tika,” and upon all prior proceedings and submissions in this matter; and full consideration having been given to the matter set forth herein, the Court finds: 1. The defendant is not a citizen or national of the United States. 2. The defendant is a native of Germany and a dual citizen of Germany and Guatemala. 3. The defendant was paroled into the United States at John F. Kennedy International Airport, New York, New York on or about March 22, 2019.

 4. At the time of sentencing in the instant criminal proceeding, the defendant will be convicted in the United States District Court, Southern District of New York, under the following counts: Count One conspiracy to commit tax evasion, in violation of 18 U.S.C. Section 371; Count Two wire fraud, in violation of 18 U.S.C. Sections 1343 and 2; Count Three money laundering conspiracy, in violation of 18 U.S.C. Section 1956(h); Counts Four through Seven willful failure to file Reports of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts, FinCEN Reports 114, in violation of 31 U.S.C. Sections 5314 and 5322(a), 31 C.F.R. Sections 1010.350, 1010.306 (c, d), and 1010.840 (b); and 18 U.S.C. Section 2; Counts Eight and Nine false statements, in violation of 18 U.S.C. Sections 1001(a)(2) and 2. 5. The maximum sentence of 75 years imprisonment may be imposed for violations of these offenses. 6. The defendant is, and at sentencing will be, subject to removal from the United States pursuant to Section 212(a)(7)(A)(i)(I) of the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1952 (“INA”), as amended, 8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)(7)(A)(i)(I), as an alien who, at the time of application for admission, was not in possession of a valid immigrant visa reentry permit, border crossing identification card, or other valid entry document required by the INA; Section 212(a)(2)(A)(i)(I) of the INA, 8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)(2)(A)(i)(I), as an alien who has been convicted of a crime involving moral turpitude (other than a purely political offense) or an attempt or conspiracy to commit such a crime. 7. The defendant has waived his right to notice and a hearing under Section 238(c) of the INA, 8 U.S.C. § 1228(c). 8. The defendant has waived the opportunity to pursue any and all forms of relief and protection from removal.  WHEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, pursuant to Section 238(c) of the INA, 8 U.S.C. § 1228(c), that the defendant shall be removed from the United States promptly upon his release from confinement, or, if the defendant is not sentenced to a term of imprisonment, promptly upon his sentencing, and that the defendant be ordered removed to Germany, with an alternate country designated as Guatemala."

 Watch this site.

   From February 28 on Gaffey: including with a forfeiture amount and order for notice despite the Assistant US Attorney saying that the only victim is the IRS: "CONSENT PRELIMINARY ORDER OF FORFEITURE AS TO SPECIFIC PROPERTY/MONEY JUDGMENT FOR Richard Gaffey. IT IS HEREBY STIPULATED AND AGREED, by and between theUnited States of America, by its attorney Geoffrey S. Berman,United States Attorney, Assistant United States Attorneys, THANE REHN and EUN YOUNG CHOI of counsel, and the defendant, and his counsel, WILLIAM LOVETT, Esq. and ROBERT BUEHLER, Esq., that As a result of the offenses charged in Counts Two and Three of the Indictment, to which the defendant pled guilty, a money judgment in the amount of $5,373, 609 in United States currency (the "Money Judgment "), representing the amount of proceeds traceable to the offense charged in Count Two of the Indictment that the defendant personally obtained and the amount of property involved in the offense charged in Count Three of the Indictment, shall be entered against the defendant. Pursuant to 32.2(b)(6) (A) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, the Government shall send notice to any person who reasonably appears to be a potential claimant with standing to contest the forfeiture in the ancillary proceeding."

  Periscope here, Podcast here. The plea agreement is for 94 to 111 months - how much less than that will Gaffey get? The sentencing is set for June 29 at 11 a.m.


Judge Richard M. Berman of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York asked whether the lawyer for initially lead defendant Ramses Owens, sitting on the side of his courtroom, even had the right to make arguments. Owens has not been arraigned or appeared in the case.

  From Panama, using J. Iandolo Law of 13th Avenue, Brooklyn, Owens is disputing the use of his mobile phone records obtained under the US - Panama Mutual Assistance in Criminal Matters Treaty.

   Assistant US Attorney Eun Young Choi argued that some of the US' request for information from other governments are covered by diplomatic privilege. She said, however, that information from and about Germany will be made available to the defendants on June 7.

  Judge Berman set a motion schedule running into August. The lawyer for von der Goltz said he may file a motion to dismiss the wire fraud and money laundering counts claiming that no money ever move through wires. The case is USA v. Owens, et al., 18-cr-00693 (Berman).

500
                        Pearl, not 40 Foley, photo by Inner City Press

Inner City Press readers may remember that Patrick Ho was found not guilty on only one of the eight UN bribery charges against him in December 2018, Chad money laundering - because the money moved in a gift box, in cash, and not through wires. Watch this site.

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Kevin Spacey Gets to Unmask Anonymous C.D. Alleging Rape at 14 Now C.D. Must Name Self

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

SDNY COURTHOUSE, May 3 – Anthony Rapp's lawsuit against Kevin Spacey was removed to Federal court in November 2020, and an anonymous co-plaintiff C.D. was added.

Spacey wants to make C.D.'s name public, to order to conduct discovery, he says.  C.D.'s lawyers oppose it, letter on Patreon here.

On February 2 U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Lewis A. Kaplan held a proceeding. Inner City Press live tweeted it, here and below.

Now on May 3, Judge Kaplan has denied C.D.'s motion: "MEMORANDUM OPINION re: [30] FIRST MOTION for Leave to File Motion for Leave to Proceed Anonymously (Redacted) filed by C. D., Anthony Rapp. Plaintiff C.D.'s motion to proceed by pseudonym (Dkt. 30] is denied in all respects. Plaintiff shall file an amended complaint containing his name no later than ten days after the date of this opinion. Defendant's motions to strike (Dkts. 46, 54] are denied and his objection to Dr. Block's expert report [Dkt. 55] is overruled without prejudice. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Lewis A. Kaplan on 5/3/2021)."

Judge Kaplan's order noted that C.D. told an unknown number of people about his "relationship" with Spacey, and told Vulture. Full order here.

 On February 23 in the Spacey case Inner City Press is tracking, another proceeding, an oral argument. Inner City Press live tweeted it here:
and below; now, Anthony Rapp Feb 3, 2021 deposition transcript on Patreon here

 On February 24 Rapp's lawyer filed a collection of messages he received after accusing Spacey, many full of profanity, and "what u did is a sick way to gain attention."

  On February 25, Spacey's lawyers filed to try to get the social media posts and declaration stricken as "not authorized by the Court." They say that 98% of the messages Rapp got were positive.

  On March 2 plaintiffs' counsel wrote in that Spacey's "papers make other uninformed and speculative statements. It is simply not the true that C.D. has widely broadcast or disclosed his allegations to others. C.D. did speak to New York Magazine in 2017... He did so to refute Spacey's assertion that the sexual assault of Anthony Rapp was an isolated drunken incident."

On March 3, Spacey through counsel wrote to oppose "offers for plaintiff D.C. to speak to Your Honor in camera... C.D. claims he may dismiss his claims if the Motion is not granted... that is no one's decision but his."

On March 22, a proposed extension of expert discovery time by two weeks: WHEREAS, the current deadline to disclose rebuttal expert witnesses in this action is April 12, 2021;  WHEREAS, the parties agree that additional time is needed to complete the depositions of Plaintiffs’ recently-disclosed expert witnesses and the medical examinations of Plaintiffs so as to allow for the disclosure of any rebuttal expert witness(es) and for such expert(s) to complete a report by the disclosure deadline; and  WHEREAS, the parties recognize a potential need to extend the rebuttal expert disclosure date further, especially as to any delays in the deposition or medical examination of plaintiff C.D. or his expert witness; WHEREAS, this is the first such request for an extension of time in which to disclose rebuttal expert witnesses.  IT IS NOW HEREBY STIPULATED AND AGREED, by and between the undersigned counsel, and subject to the Court, as follows:
The deadline to disclose any rebuttal expert witness(es) under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(a)(2) is continued by two weeks and is now April 26, 2021." This has been proposed.

From February 23: Lawyers for Kevin Spacey are arguing to strike testimony of Doctor Seymour H. Block. Spacey is being sued civilly for sex abuse.

 Judge Kaplan: You are asking me to make an important decision, in a country that values public trials as much as we do, in the unique circumstance of a person who sued and also went to the press with it. In advance.

 Plaintiffs lawyer: When my client gave the interview before this case. So there was no attempt to influence the jury. In fact, when my client spoke to the press this case would have been barred by the statute of limitations.

 Judge Kaplan: But if disclosure would harm him, why did he go to the press? Plaintiff's lawyer: They did not reveal his name. Judge Kaplan: But he couldn't know it would work. The publication checked his account with others. There was a chance he would be ID-ed

Judge Kaplan: What's that case you're citing? Defense: Doe, 241 FRD 154, 159 (SDNY, 2006). And another one by Justice Brennan, about how public trials bring in more witnesses. CD made his decision. We have our due process rights. [He calls Spacey "Mr. Fowler"]

Judge Kaplan: On a proper showing, the pleadings need not contain the name of a party, no? Defense: They have to meet the Doe factors. And CD has not met his burden. Plaintiff: Doe v. Colgate, the plaintiff went to the press and was still anonymous.

 Judge Kaplan: I'm going to wait until you make your expert disclosure.  Plaintiff's lawyer: There is a person beyond Mr Rapp who is aware of this. And Mr Rapp is not seeking to withhold his name.

Judge Kaplan: You need to file the relevant piece of the deposition.


The proceeding ends, just like that.

From February 2: Spacey's lawyer says it is unfair for C.D. to proceeding anonymously. "While it is true we have C.D.'s name, only if we make it public can others come forward with evidence about him... this is the right to due process."

C.D.'s lawyer: The sealed plaintiff versus sealed defendant factors weigh in our favor. We are talking about the rape of a minor. The declaration by his therapist shows he would suffer harm if his name is made public.

 Judge: If it happened it's abhorrent. But I don't have to be reminded of what Mr Spacey is accused of in every sentence. CD's lawyer: Spacey said, as to Rapp, that if it happened he was sorry. But here he is denying it entirely.

Judge: You're not getting anywhere.

Judge Kaplan: Get me your papers, and you'll get a decision promptly. Until then, don't disclose the name to third parties - except to Mr. Rapp, subject to sealing.

Spacey's lawyer: Every day is lost time.

  So Rapp's deposition will go forward, with C.D.'s real name said at it but reported in the transcript as C.D..  Inner City Press will continue to report on this case. More on Patreon here.


***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

To UN Opposing Guterres Inner City Press Filed to PGA As SG Flew to Kentucky Derby on UN Allotment

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Song
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

SDNY COURTHOUSE, May 3 – How corrupt and undemocratic is today's United Nations?

Well, now that Antonio Guterres is pushing for a second five-year term, while banning the Press for the 1036th day for daring to ask about his finances and failures, he has collaborators. 

  On May 1 Guterres, flying back from Europe, flew to Louisville for the Kentucky Derby horse race. While his spokesman Stephane Dujarric refuses all of Inner City Press' questions, on May 3 he said that Guterres' travels was somehow attributable to a "system of allotment," not that Guterres who receives a large tax free salary paid for it. What waste. What arrogance. Dump Guterres.

  The current President of the General Assembly Volkan Bozkir, a strongman from Turkey who due to his bigoted comments even pro-UN New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio wouldn't meet with, has the duty of circulating letters from candidates. 

  But throughout February, March and now April 2021, Bozkir refused to circulate any letters or CVs. Now on April 27 his spokesman Brenden Varma, who blocks Inner City Press on Twitter, described with a straight face a one-man "debate" on May 7, Guterres as Dear Leader, and said there are not criteria or rules under which Inner City Press and others are not having letters and CVs blocked. It's just corruption.


Guterres will do anything for a 2d term.

Bozkir's spokesman Brendan Varma, who blocks Inner City Press on Twitter, continues to dance around what the rules are and won't answer. 

 So, as a test - and to raise the issue of the UN's lack of content neutral media access rules, lack of a Freedom of Information Act (fought for the Free UN Coalition for Access) and lack of scruples - Inner City Press on the morning of February 26 submitted a signed letter and C.V. to the PGA's Office and to Varma.  Since then, four weeks of dodging and blockage, now of four. And this:

Pakistan supports Guterres, here. Apparently, Paul Biya's Cameroon and other states like that of narco Juan Orlando Hernandez are asked to be more quiet with their support for their favorite dictator supporter, Antonio Guterres, for now. Watch this site.


***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Avenatti Now Withholds Exhibits to Motion As Seeks Ban From Sidebars Inner City Press Opposed

 

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Song Radio
BBC - Decrypt - LightRead - Honduras - Source

SDNY COURTHOUSE, May 2 – When after three days of jury selection the trial of Michael Avenatti for allegedly extorting Nike began on January 29, Assistant US Attorney Robert Sobelman told the selected jurors that Avenatti was supposed to look out for the interests of his client, but he did not - he had a weapon, social media.  More on 1st day on Patreon here.

 On August 7, 2020 in the Stormy Daniels case, Avenatti had motions heard by U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Jesse M. Furman. Inner City Press live tweeted it, here.

 On April 14, 2021, Avenatti's Federal Defenders wrote to Judge Furman seeking to ban the press from sidebars, during jury selection in his Stormy Daniels trial.

Inner City Press immediately filed opposition, below.

Now on May 1-2, Avenatti's publicly funded Federal Defenders - his filing to get publicly paid lawyers will remains sealed, unlike for nearly all other defendants - filed another request for secrecy, this time for entire exhibits of his omnibus motion: "RE: United States v. Michael Avenatti,  19 Cr. 374 (JMF) Dear Judge Furman:  I write pursuant to the Court’s individual rules (Rule 10(C)) regarding the filing of redacted documents on CM/ECF. Tonight, the defense in the above-captioned case filed its omnibus pre-trial motion and seeks leave to keep Exhibits B, C, and F under seal. These exhibits contain sensitive information that is subject to the standing protective order governing the disclosure of confidential materials. Should the Court deny this application to keep the exhibits sealed in their entirety, the defense respectfully requests an opportunity to propose specific redactions for the Court’s consideration." This too should be opposed, once we can see what was actually filed. Watch this site.
On April 16  Inner City Press' opposition to banning Press from sidebars was docketed and response from the US Attorney's Office called for on April 22, and Avenatti by April 26.

 Now, after 10 pm on April 26, Avenatti's is in: "e write in further support of our letter motion dated  April 14, 2021 (Dkt. No. 107), to preclude the media’s presence  at sidebar conferences during oral voir dire. In its April 22,  2021 response, the Government stated that it “would not object  to the exclusion of the press from sidebar conferences during  voir dire” provided “a substantial probability exists that  prospective jurors would not be candid regarding unfair or  improper biases were a member of the press to be present.” Gov’t  Resp. (Dkt. No. 111) at 1.1 Because there is a sufficient basis  to conclude that a reporter’s presence at sidebar conferences  during oral voir dire would likely stifle jurors’ candor and violate Michael Avenatti’s Sixth Amendment right to trial before  an impartial jury, the Court should grant the defense’s motion.2   1 Notwithstanding footnote three to the Government’s response  (Dkt. No. 111 at 3 n.3), the defense is still unclear as to the  basis for the Government’s assertion to Mr. Warren and in its  March 13, 2020 letter to the Court that Judge Gardephe  “permitted” a reporter to be present at sidebar voir dire in the  Nike case.  2 The defense also offers this letter in reply to the letters  submitted by Inner City Press and Daily News, L.P., opposing our  motion to preclude the press from sidebar voir dire. Dkt. Nos.  109, 110."  Full Avenatti press-ban reply on Patreon here.
 
Previously: "MEMO ENDORSEMENT as to Michael Avenatti on Letter addressed to Judge Jesse M. Furman from Matthew Russell Lee, Inner City Press dated 4/14/2021 re Formal request for press presence at voir dire sidebars and for full access including to both sides' exhibits in real time: The Clerk of Court is directed to docket this letter. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Jesse M. Furman on 1/29/2021)." And, "MEMO ENDORSEMENT as to Michael Avenatti on [107] LETTER MOTION re Reporter's Presence At Sidebar Voir Dire: The Government shall file a response to this letter (and the letter filed by Inner City Press, which will be docketed separately) no later than April 22, 2021. SO ORDERED."

  Now on April 22, the US Attorney's Office says it's fine with it to exclude the Press: "The Government respectfully submits this letter pursuant to the Court’s Order dated April  16, 2021 (Dkt. No. 109), directing the Government to respond to the defendant’s letter, filed April  14, 2021, regarding the presence of a reporter at sidebar during voir dire of prospective jurors (Dkt.  No. 107), and the letter of Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press, filed on the docket on April  16, 2021, requesting to be present at sidebar during voir dire of prospective jurors (Dkt. No. 108). 1 For the reasons set forth below, the Government would not object to the exclusion of the press  from sidebar conferences during voir dire of prospective jurors should the Court find a sufficient  basis to conclude that a substantial probability exists that prospective jurors would not be candid  regarding unfair or improper biases were a member of the press to be present." We'll have more on this - Avenatti's lawyers have to April 26 to reply - there will be more. Watch this site.

Here is Inner City Press' April 14 submission: "Dear Judge Furman:    This application responds to the defendant's letter motion earlier this evening seeking to bar the press from voir dire sidebars during jury selection in the above-captioned trial (Dkt. No. 107), and follows up on Inner City Press' August 28, 2020 submission in the same case (Dkt. No. 85).  

Federal Defenders writes to oppose any press presence at sidebars in voir dire, even though this has been allowed in this District in such recent high profile cases such as that involving the testimony of cooperator / hip-hop artist Daniel Hernandez a/k/a Tekashi 6ix9ine, US v. Jones, 18-cr-834 (PAE).

See also, US v. Shkreli, 260 F. Supp. 3d 257 (EDNY 2017).    The instant request to ban the press states that "no application from any press organization... is reflected on the docket."

This then is such an application, to be docketed. Note ABC v. Stewart, 360 F.3d 90 (2d Cir. 2004) - the district court erred in closing the voir dire proceedings. 'We therefore vacate the portion of the district court's order denying the media contemporaneous access to the voir dire.'

 Already in this case, unlike others in this District, the defendant and his Federal Defenders have sought the total withholding of his submission seeking taxpayer funded counsel. Now they seek further exclusion of the press and public from the upcoming criminal proceeding.

Inner City Press opposes this, and asks for media access to sidebars throughout the proceeding.   Since our August 2020 submission - we still have not seen the sought information - SDNY Judge Rakoff, for example, has granted Inner City Press' application that in US v. Weigand, 20-cr-188 (JSR), all exhibits be made available the evening of their submission. See, here.  We ask, prospectively, for the same in this proceeding - not only on USafx but to the public at large."

On January 8, Avenatti's trial in the Stormy Daniels case was pushed back to... 2022: "MEMO ENDORSEMENT as to Michael Avenatti on [102] Letter re Trial Date: Much as the Court would like to keep the trial date as is, it concludes that, given the continuing public health crisis, going to trial on that date - particularly in a case of this nature - is not likely to be realistic or prudent. Accordingly, and in view of the Defendant's California trial dates, trial is hereby ADJOURNED to January 10, 2022. Within three weeks, defense counsel shall file a letter confirming that Defendant (1) is aware of the trial date and (2) understands that it is a firm date and that any application (e.g., relating to discovery, counsel, etc.) that could affect the ability to begin trial as scheduled may be denied on that basis alone and therefore must be filed as early as possible. The Clerk of Court is directed to terminate ECF No. 102. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Jesse M. Furman on 1/8/2021)."

On January 7 in the Nike case, Avenatti asked to again push back his sentencing to May 2021, full letter on Patreon here.

 On August 27, Inner City Press filed a formal request that documents in the case not be sealed, full filing on Patreon here.

 On November 12, Inner City Press made a third filing with Judge Furman, on a decision to unseal issued earlier in the day by SDNY Judge J. Paul Oetken after Inner City Press filed to similarly unseal Lev Parnas' co-defendant David Correia's financial info, below. It has been docketed in the case before Judge Furman, at Dkt. No. 99.

On November 13 in the Nike case Avenatti sought a delay: "United States v. Avenatti, No. S1 19 Cr. 373 (PGG) Motion for an Additional 60-day Adjournment of Sentencing Date and Filing of Sentencing Submissions Dear Judge Gardephe: Mr. Avenatti’s sentencing hearing is currently scheduled for December 9, 2020. We write to respectfully request an additional adjournment of the sentencing date for approximately sixty (60) days, until early February 2021, if the Court’s schedule permits."

Now on November 16 Judge Gardephe has issued this: "ORDER as to Michael Avenatti: It is hereby ORDERED that the sentencing of Defendant Michael Avenatti, currently scheduled for December 9, 2020, will now take place on February 17, 2021 at 12:00 p.m. Any submissions on behalf of Defendant are due on January 27, 2021, and any submission by the Government is due on February 3, 2021. SO ORDERED. (Sentencing set for 2/17/2021 at 12:00 PM before Judge Paul G. Gardephe) (Signed by Judge Paul G. Gardephe on 11/16/2020)."

From Inner City Press' November 12 letter: "Dear Judge Furman:     Pursuant to this Court's August 28, 2020 Order granting leave to be heard, this is a further argument and District precedent for the unsealing of the CJA Form 23, affidavit and all associated documents in US v. Avenatti, 19-cr-374 (JMF).     Today in US v. Parnas, Correia et al., 19-cr-725, Judge J. Paul Oetken in a nearly identical case in which Inner City Press also timely sought unsealing has ordered that David Correia's financial declarations should be unsealed in full and docketed in five business days. See 19-cr-725, Dkt No 145 citing Dkt No 123 ("letter filed by Matthew Russell Lee advocating for public access to these declaration.")   

 Judge Oetken cites United States v. Smith, 985 F. Supp. 2d 506, 517 (S.D.N.Y. 2013) (collecting cases) and states  "The Court sees no reason why the declarations at issue depart from judicial documents associated with criminal pretrial proceedings as to which the Second Circuit has previously recognized the First Amendment right of access.... Accordingly, defense counsel’s request to seal or redact the attorney declarations is DENIED. Counsel are directed to file the unredacted declarations on the public docket within five business days."   

The same logic obtains and should be applied here, to the too-long filings of Defendant Avenatti.     

Again, Inner City Press which closely covers SDNY criminal proceedings noted in September that before SDNY Magistrate Judge Barbara Moses the financial situation of defendant Jonathan Smith was fully disclosed on the record.  

  Similar disclosures have been made, even this week, in the SDNY Magistrates Court under Judge Freeman.  

  We again ask, why should lower income and less high profile defendants in the SDNY -- and now David Correia -- have their financial information so disclosed while Avenatti's information is sealed in its entirety?     The documents at issue should not be sealed and should be made available." Watch this site.

  On August 28 Judge Furman entered an order: "The Court received the attached communication from Matthew Lee of Inner City Press “seeking leave to be heard and for the unsealing of the CJA Form 23, affidavit, and all associated documents” relating to this litigation. To the extent that Mr. Lee (who is admitted to the bar of the Southern District of New York) seeks leave to be heard, his application is GRANTED. The Court reserves judgment on the question of whether Defendant’s CJA Form 23 and related documents should be unsealed. SO ORDERED. Dated: August 28, 2020 New York, New York JESSE M. FURMAN." Docket No. 85, on Inner City Press' DocumentCloud, here.

 On November 10, with the Avenatti submissions still sealed, he appeared with "with attorneys Robert Baum, Tamara Lila Giwa, and Andrew John Dalack. AUSAs Matthew Podolsky and Robert Sobelman present. Court reporter present. -- Pursuant to Fed R. Crim. P. 5(f), the Court reminded the Government of its obligations under Brady v. Maryland and its progeny. -- Trial is scheduled for April 21, 2021 and is expected to last 2 weeks. Time is excluded in the interests of justice from November 11, 2020 until April 21, 2021. (ab)." The above is the Order; others reported the trial as April 26.

  On September 2 Federal Defenders, rather than attempt to explain why they routinely divulge and put in the public record the financial information of less high profile and lower income clients, stating in Magistrates Court exactly how much their clients make and where they and even their spouses work, has written in this: "The defense acknowledges that the Court granted Matthew Lee, a representative of “Inner City Press,” leave to be heard on this matter. The defense requests leave to respond to Mr. Lee one week from the timely filing of any substantive brief or letter. For now, it bears emphasizing that the Court’s measures requiring the Federal Defenders to keep an accurate record of the hours spent on Mr. Avenatti’s defense, and also requiring Mr. Avenatti to regularly update the Court on his finances, are sufficient to protect the public fisc and to ensure that funds for court-appointed counsel are being properly spent. Further, “neither the First Amendment nor the common law provides a right of access to financial documents submitted with an initial application to demonstrate a defendant’s eligibility for CJA assistance.” In re Boston Herald, Inc., 321 F.3d 174, 191 (1st Cir. 2003). And “even if there were a common law presumption of access, then it would be outweighed here … by [Avenatti’s] countervailing privacy interests” and rights under the Fifth and Sixth Amendments. Id."  Full letter on Patreon here. It is UNacceptable -- the public's and press' right of access is not limited to the public fisc, it is based on the FIRST Amendment. 

  Hearing nothing more, but continuing to closely cover all things SDNY, on September 8 Inner City Press filed again: "Re: US v. Avenatti, 19-cr-374 (JMF) - Further on the need to unseal CJA Form 23 and associated documents including affidavit 

Dear Judge Furman:     Pursuant to this Court's August 28, 2020 Order granting leave to be heard, and in response to Federal Defenders' September 2 (footnote) response), this is a further argument for the unsealing of the CJA Form 23, affidavit and all associated documents in US v. Avenatti, 19-cr-374 (JMF).   

  Before citing case law, Inner City Press which closely covers SDNY criminal proceedings notes that just today, before SDNY Magistrate Judge Barbara Moses, the financial situation of defendant Jonathan Smith was fully disclosed on the record.

To obtain CJA counsel it was disclosed that Mr. Smith of The Bronx received $471 a week in unemployment, and pays $150 to $200 a month in child support of each of his three children, and $65 a month for cell phone service. See, US v. Smith, 20-cr-317 (Swain / Moses).    

We again ask, why should lower income and less high profile defendants in the SDNY have their financial information so disclosed while Avenatti's information is sealed in its entirety? 

  Avenatti in his other SDNY case, in which he was convicted by a jury, has requested another adjournment of sentencing, to December.   

 On September 10, Federal Defenders responded, saying that the disclosure of the Bronxite and Massachusetts drug defendants' information is somehow different than for Avenatti, who is apparently in their view due great privacy and protection. Then they threaten to appeal if Judge Furman rules for transparency: "RE: United States v. Michael Avenatti 19 Cr. 374 (JMF) Dear Judge Furman: We write to briefly respond to the letter submitted on behalf of Inner City Press by Matthew R. Lee requesting the unsealing of Michael Avenatti’s CJA 23 Form and accompanying affidavit. See Dkt. No. 90. Neither the public nor the media have a presumptive right to access the financial documents of a defendant who seeks court-appointed counsel under the Sixth Amendment. In re Boston Herald, Inc., 321 F.3d 174, 191 (1st Cir. 2003) (“[N]either the First Amendment nor the common law provides a right of access to financial documents submitted with an initial application to demonstrate a defendant’s eligibility for CJA assistance.”). And as discussed more thoroughly in Mr. Avenatti’s previous letters, any such common law or First Amendment interest is trumped by the real and appreciable risk of self-incrimination Mr. Avenatti faces should his sworn statements about his financial condition be made available to the government or publicly.1  1 As set forth in Mr. Avenatti’s reply to the government’s response in opposition to keeping his sworn financial statements sealed, the court in the Central District of California presiding over a different case against him has sealed Mr. Avenatti’s application for court-appointed counsel under Ninth Circuit precedent and local rules. Accordingly, Mr. Avenatti respectfully requests that the Court stay any order to unseal those same documents in this case so that he may pursue appropriate appellate relief."

We'll have more on this, once the situation becomes clearer - it is not clear if Inner City Press is permitted to surreply to this. It should not be necessary. The courts should be transparent, and defendants should be treated equally.

And later the US Attorney's Office said, " in light of the presumption of openness in criminal proceedings and the approach favored by the Second Circuit, the defendant has failed to provide a legally sufficient basis for wholesale and indefinite sealing of the CJA 23 Form and supporting affidavit." Full letter on Patreon here. Now we await Avenatti's / his Federal Defenders' reply. Watch this site.

This case is US v. Avenatti, 19-cr-374 (Furman).

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.