Wednesday, April 7, 2021

In Citibank Wire Transfer Case Money Does Not Have To Be Returned Judge Furman Rules

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Song Podcast

BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Feb 16 – As Citibank tries to recoup the money it wired out on August 11, 2020, the virtual / Zoom trial began on December 9 before U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Jesse M. Furman. Inner City Press reported daily on the trial, below.

Now on February 16, Judge Furman has ruled that the Defendants can keep the money: "Defendants in this case — ten investment advisory firms managing entities that, collectively, received more than $500 million of the mistaken August 11th wire transfers from Citibank — contend that this exception to the general rule, known as the “discharge-for-value defense,” applies here and that Citibank is therefore not entitled to the return of its money. In December 2020, the Court held a bench trial to decide whether Defendants are correct. For the reasons that follow, the Court concludes that Defendants are indeed correct. As the Court will explain, application of the discharge-for-value defense ultimately turns on whether Defendants (or, more precisely, their clients) were on constructive notice of Citibank’s mistake at the moment they received the August 11th wire transfers. Based on the credible testimony of Defendants’ employees and the documentary record, the Court concludes that they were not. Taken together, the evidence shows that the entities believed — in good faith and with ample justification — that the payments they received were prepayments in full of the Revlon loan. The real explanation for the payments — a banking error of perhaps unprecedented nature and  magnitude — understandably did not occur to them until, nearly a day later, Citibank itself realized the error and sent notices demanding the money back. Because the discharge-for-value defense applies, the Court holds that Citibank is not entitled to its money back. Instead, Defendants’ clients are entitled to keep the money. Accordingly, and for the reasons that follow, judgment will be entered in favor of Defendants." Full order on Inner City Press' DocumentCloud, here. Podcast here

 Here for now some of the Day 1 blow by blow.

And Day 2 documents / Defendants exhibits zipped on Patreon here, one on DocumentCloud here, saying "Please retain the funds received 8/11 into Battalion CLO VIII Ltd. on account of the Revlon Term Loan 2016 pending further instruction. Please do not book, and carry the funds as a cash break for the time being."

 Hear, for now, this song.

On Day 6 and last, there were closing arguments and questions, and this: Judge Furman begin with questions about the Banque Worms decision. There's some talk about getting a phone charger. Counsel classily presses on. It's not easy being a court reporter. Judge Furman: Page 47 of Plaintiff's brief argues the District Court erred...

 Closing arguments still going. Lot of talk of imputed knowledge; Judge Furman asks if there's any excited utterance showing the defendants knew something was wrong, even before Citibank notified them. Judge Furman also asks why Citibank didn't get a grace period

 OK - it's over. Judge Furman: It was a well-tried case, but I hope the industry finds a better way of dealing with this, even if it was a black swan event. I will get you a decision as quickly as I can.

Note: the defendants, after Saturday December 12, stopped sending any of their exhibits. Watch this site.

  Day 5, the evidence wrapped up - but again exhibits were withheld despite request(s). Some of it:

Q: the official books of those investors would be in one place, and what Symphony had was the shadow books, correct? A: You could say that, yeah. Q: Is there any specific segregation you could identify?

A: State Street, P zero. Bromton, P zero. CLO, T plus one.

 Judge Furman: Could you explain? A: T plus zero, same day. T plus one, we can do it from the day prior. Now, questions about exhibits still withheld from Press.

 After long re-direct of Vaughan, now on the stand is Eric Lee of Symphony. Citibank's lawyer: You're on West Coast time, so thanks for getting up early. Are you familiar with pre-payment notices? A: Yes.

Judge Furman tells the lawyers he has gotten a letter on subject matter jurisdiction issues but not reviewed it yet; he'll tell them if he gets any thoughts from it. Also, he's gone back to look at transcript of final pre-trial conference & will allow Citi experts

And that's it - the evidence is over Citibank closed with an hour and two minutes left; defendants with an hour and 15 minutes left. Closing arguments tomorrow morning.

Now Judge Furman is telling counsel what he'd like to hearing about tomorrow, on "the timing question" -- he cites a Judge Patterson decision, Banque Worms' commentary on finality - when each defendant found out about the payments.

  Inner City Press will have more on this.

  Here's a document from Day 3, stating "It looks like they erroneously released paydown payment and are asking for it back. Do you agree?" Here on DocumentCloud, full Zip on Patreon here.

From Day 4: Continued cross, delayed by tech issues: Q: Did he make any comment about the Revlon payments after 9 am Aug 12?

"Objection- leading." Judge Furman: I'll allow it. But watch out, with your questions. "Let's turn to Defendants' exhibits"

Judge Furman: What is the relationship between Mr. Davis saying to book it, then telling US Bancorp to apply it? And where are the books and records on the outstanding principal on the loan? Citibank follows up: You were unaware on Aug 12 that Mr. Davis did that?

 This witness who only appeared by phone due to technology problems is excused. Defendants call Mr. Scott Crocombe. "Flip to page 6 of your declaration - is that your signature?" Yes.

Judge Furman: The objection with respect to para 12 is sustained, para 17 too.

 "May I publish this exhibit, a Bloomberg chat message?" Judge Furman: There's no jury, so you can put it on the screen. "This chat is dated Aug 12 --"

Objection. Not a business record kept in the ordinary course. Judge Furman: Sustained, for the moment.

 Q: Do you see the message, "I feel bad for the person who fat-fingered a $900 million payment... Not a good career move." Do you see, "How was work today honey? Fine, except I sent $900 million to people who weren't supposed to get it."

OK - now up for cross examination is Catherine McCoy of Allstate. She's not sure what the parent is. She has been sent the exhibits she'll be asked about in a zip file. Citibank lawyer is on mute. "You'd think by Day 4, I'd know how it works," he says. Disarming

 Michael Josephson has been testifying from an empty room. Judge Furman asks him about CLO 4.  Now Jeremy Phipps. Judge Furman: "Can you turn your camera on?" Defense counsel's name is lagging, amid transition. #TrialByZoom

Now up, Eric Warren, purple suit, purple tie, trees in side yard behind him. Topic is, once again, springing maturity of Revlon loan. 

Judge Furman: Can you give me the gave of the August re-purchases? Inner City Press @innercitypress · 1h Still on the stand: Eric Warren of Revlon, being asked about cross-defaults and bankruptcy. Q: Was Revlon prepared to defend the lawsuit on the merits if necessary? Warren: Yes.

 Now at 4:57 pm, witness John Vaughan takes the stand. Lawyer asks, How much longer will we be going? Judge Furman: 3 minutes. Vaughan signed his declaration on Nov 12 in SF.

 Judge Furman asks about exhibits.  Inner City Press is awaiting the exhibits since Friday. Judge Furman: Mr. Vaughan, I'm going to ask you to be in the Zoom room tomorrow morning. Lawyer: Is he under cross examination? Judge Furman: Any objection I tell him not to speak with you? Lawyer: no objection - as much as he might want to.

Judge Furman: Are you going to use all of your time? Citi: I think so. Defendants: Much of the time will be used. Judge Furman: Defendants have only 4 more witnesses. Maybe a rebuttal case? Now it arises: Mister Vinella must be rebutted

Judge Furman: The letters due at 7 pm, you can have until tomorrow morning if both sides want. Lawyer: At the collective groan of our associates, we'll take you up on that. So closing arguments / summations will be Wednesday.

The case is In re Citibank August 11, 2020 Wire Transfers, 20-cv-6539 (Furman)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

On CRA Reg Inner City Press Tells FRB Bronx Branches Lack & Lackluster No Credit for Jails

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon

BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

FEDERAL COURT / S Bronx, Feb 15 – Whether or not the U.S. Community Reinvestment Act will be again enforced under the new Administration and its regulators is an open question.

  On the 25th day of the new Administration, Fair Finance Watch with Inner City Press on the FOIA filed comments with the Federal Reserve Board on its proposal on the CRA: "Re Docket Number R-1723 and RIN Number 7100-AF94   Dear Chair Powell, Secretary Misback and others in the FRS:   On behalf of Inner City Press / Fair Finance Watch (ICP), this is a timely comment on the Community Reinvestment Act.   

ICP has been increasingly concerned by the Federal Reserve System's rubber-stamping of merger applications, which are the enforcement mechanism of the CRA, as well as with the Fed's lack of transparency is withholding large portions of applications and of its communication with and about applicants.

  On the policy issues raised in the Fed's ANPR, Fair Finance Watch joins in the comments of the NCRC of which it is a proud member. A few additional, question-specific responses:

"Question 1. Does the Board capture the most important CRA modernization objectives? Are there additional objectives that should be considered?"  

 No. The Federal Reserve has overseen the mass closing of bank branches serving low and moderate income communities; meanwhile fintechs and even crypto-currency entities are moving into banking without any accountability to LMI communities. These must be addressed - with public hearings, FOIA responses, and the too-needy but never-occurring denial of explansion applications.

"Question 3. Given the CRA's purpose and its nexus with fair lending laws, what changes to Regulation BB would reaffirm the practice of ensuring that assessment areas do not reflect illegal discrimination and do not arbitrarily exclude LMI census tracts?"  

Given how the Board's merger approval orders explain away fair lending disparities including in HMDA data and the demographics of assessment areas, this appears to be a disingenuous question. Or, this recommendation: if the Board as stated recognizes CRA's "nexus with fair lending laws," it should directly address these on merger applications. For example, in the NYC MSA, banks which exclude the South Bronx and Upper Manhattan should not have their applications approved.

"Question 7. Should banks have the option of delineating assessment areas around deposit-taking ATMs or should this remain a requirement?"  

Obviously this should remain a requirement. "Should delineation of new deposit- or lending-based assessment areas apply only to internet banks that do not have physical locations or should it also apply more broadly to other large banks with substantial activity beyond their branch-based assessment areas? Is there a certain threshold of such activity that should trigger additional assessment areas?"   Of course banks should be assess everywhere they take deposits and / or make loans: five of either.   

"Is $750 million or $1 billion an appropriate asset threshold to distinguish between small and large retail banks? Or should this threshold be lower so that it is closer to the current small bank threshold of $326 million? Should the regulation contain an automatic mechanism for allowing that threshold to adjust with aggregate national inflation over time?"

  Lower - down to $326 million or lower still. Automatic adjustment would be fine.

"Question 22. Does the performance ranges approach complement the use of a presumption of “satisfactory”? How should the Board determine the performance range for a “satisfactory” in conjunction with the threshold for a presumption of “satisfactory”? How should the Board also determine the performance ranges for “outstanding,” “needs to improve,” and “substantial noncompliance”?"  

Again, big picture: it is absurd how low the percentage of banks getting even "needs to improve" is. So the performance ranges have to be changed, made less grade inflationary.  

"Question 24. In addition to the number of branches and the community and market quantitative benchmarks discussed above, how should examiners evaluate a bank's branch distribution?"    There are far too few branches in LMI communities - and those there provide too little service. Without (yet) naming it, a bank on 149th Street in the South Bronx for months during the pandemic made itself entirely inaccessible to residents of the community, already underbanked. Nothing was done.  

"Question 50. Should volunteer activities unrelated to the provision of financial services, or those without a primary purpose of community development, receive CRA consideration for banks in rural assessment areas? If so, should consideration be expanded to include all banks?" No, and no.

Question 51. Should financial literacy and housing counseling activities without regard to income levels be eligible for CRA credit?

No - otherwise, lower income people will be even further underserved.

Question 61. What standards should the Board consider to define “essential community needs” and “essential community infrastructure,” and should these standards be the same across all targeted geographies?   

Given disparities and other human rights issues, the idea of banks getting CRA credit for criminal justice systems must be rejected."

 Meanwhile in Federal court, PNC Bank and its Midland Loan Services have been sued for usury, predatory lending and civil conspiracy, under New York and Federal law.  

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

In CRA Test 3d Rakuten Application Challenged to FDIC by Inner City Press on Compliance

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon

BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

FEDERAL COURT / S Bronx, Feb 15 – Whether or not the U.S. Community Reinvestment Act will be again enforced under the new Administration and its regulators is an open questions.

  On the 25th day of the new Administration, Fair Finance Watch with Inner City Press on the FOIA filed comments with the FDIC on the third application by Rakuten for Federal deposit insurance:

"Re: Timely first opposition to (third) application by Rakuten for FDIC insurance  Dear Chairman McWilliams:      Inner City Press / Fair Finance Watch is hereby timely opposing the second re-submission by Rakuten Card Co., Ltd., a subsidiary of Rakuten, Inc., of an application for federal deposit insurance (Rakuten Application) with the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) to insure the deposits of Rakuten Bank America (Rakuten Bank).     

Not only do we believe that the revised application has not meaningfully changed and does little to address the fundamental question of mixing banking and non-financial activity as raised by the initial application, including concerns involving the use, privacy, and security of customer information - we also have these Rakuten-specific concerns which must be addressed, including at the public hearings we are hereby timely requesting.

1) " Rakuten USA, Inc’s Americas President, Yasuhisa “Yaz” Iida, allegedly grooming, sexually harassing, and finally, demoting Director of Corporate Hospitality, Jessica Wyman, who spurned his advances across two and a half years." See here 

2) "A former SoftBank Corp. employee has been arrested on suspicion of illegally disclosing 5G trade secrets to his new employer, Rakuten Mobile Inc., as it was preparing to launch its own mobile network.  [Police] arrested Kuniaki Aiba, 45, on suspicion of leaking secret information in breach of a law preventing unfair competition. See, here 

3) Also on anticompetitive behavior by Rakuten: "antitrust watchdog will launch an investigation into e-commerce giant Rakuten Inc. after receiving a petition from a group of merchants over the planned free-shipping policy of the company's online shopping mall.  According to the petition organized by around 450 Rakuten marketplace merchants that was signed by 4,000 people, the company is abusing its dominant position by forcing them to shoulder the costs of free shipping for all orders." See, here

 4) Rakuten, Inc. has confirmed a judgement has been issued in a class action lawsuit against its consolidated subsidiary Buy.com Inc. (currently, RAKUTEN COMMERCE LLC) (U.S.). 1.Court and date of judgement (i) Court:  United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, here

  Procedurally, we requested a copy of Rakuten's application and received an acknowledgement of the request - but not yet the application. "Thank you for your request to receive the public, non-confidential portion of the selected deposit insurance application.  The FDIC appreciates your interest and will forward the requested application to the email address indicated." The application should have been put online; the comment period should be extended.    FFW and Inner City Press have been deeply concerned about the rush by the FDIC to rubber-stamp mergers by redliners. This has been killing the Community Reinvestment Act and we timely request public hearings, including on these concerns: (i) significant risks to the Deposit Insurance Fund (DIF) raised by the affiliation, integration, and assimilation of banking and non-financial businesses, and (ii) consumer protection concerns raised by the collection, use, privacy, security, and safeguarding of customer information."

 Meanwhile in Federal court, PNC Bank and its Midland Loan Services have been sued for usury, predatory lending and civil conspiracy, under New York and Federal law.  

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Music / Video: UN Democracy, Throw Censoring SG Antonio Guterres Out, by...

Cerveceria Modelo Sues in SDNY For Bootleg Corona Hard Seltzer Sales With Sake Cited

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon

BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Feb 15 –    Cerveceria Modelo, makers of Corona, Modelo, Pacifico and Victoria beers, on February 15 filed a lawsuit against CE Brand Strategies for misappropriating the Modelo name for "Modelo Hard Selzer."  

In a 26-page complaint dug up by Inner City Press in the just-filed docket of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, Modelo recounts that the defendant "failed its its attempt to introduce a commercially viable "hard seltzer" into the marketplace and, in February 2020, launched Corona Hard Seltzer to rectify that failure. But Constellation cannot se the CORONA trademark for Corona Hard Seltzer because it is outside the Sub-license's express limitation to 'Beer.'"  

 The attached sublicence agreement has the definition: beer means "beer, ale, porter, stout, malt beverages, and any other version of combination of the foregoing, including non alcoholic versison of any of the foregoing."  

 The Complaint, filed by Sullivan & Cromwell, says that the parties specifically agreed to drop from the definition sake and "other similar fermented beverage."  

  Perhaps significantly, Modelo's complaint noted that while Constellation has never called the seltzer "beer" in its ads, on the can it calls it beer "in order to achieve a lower tax rate for the product."

 Modelo wants, along with an injunction, all of its "damages and/or lost profits, and/or Constellation's profits, in any amount to be proven at trial."

The case is Cerveceria Modelo de Mexico, S. de R.L. de C.V. v. CB Brand Strategies, LLC et al., 21-cr-1317 (Unassigned).

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Banca IMI Trader Meyers Pleds Guilty to Antitrust Violation Now Seeks End of Probation

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive, Patreon

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Feb 15 – The US  quietly filed a criminal antitrust case against Banca IMI trader Larry D. Meyers - who quietly pled guilty and agreed to cooperate on June 27, 2019 before Judge Paul A. Engelmayer of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, Inner City Press first reported.

  The case involves violations with the Sherman Act with respect to American Depository Receipts. It is a quiet part of a larger case. On June 27 the representative of DOJ's Antitrust Division said Meyers would get a 5K1.1 letter if he fully cooperates.

  Judge Engelmayer asked Meyers to explain what he did. Meyers, going beyond the script prepared for him by his new lawyer Mr. Alvarez, said that only a few had access to the pre-release ADRs and had become a "cozy community." He said, "We became too friendly." Not anymore...

  The plea almost got delayed again because Meyers old lawyer had not yet formally withdrawn; Judge Engelmayer said a Curcio hearing might be needed then decided not. He asked Ms. Brown of DOJ if anything was needed with regard to the transcript, presumably to seal it.

  We don't think that's necessary, Ms. Brown told Judge Engelmayer. So the cooperation is entirely public now, in this cozy community. Inner City Press wrote that it would continue to follow the case. And it has.

Now on February 15, 2021 - President's Day - Meyers' lawyer Casey Aerin Lucier of McGuireWoods has written to Judge Engelmayer seeking an end to probation and cancellation of the next nine months of supervision, saying DOJ does not object. Two systems of justice?

   Back on 9 May 2019 DOJ Antitrust Division criminal chief James J. Fredricks signed a "Notice of Intent to File An Information" against Meyers. Through so-called "Wheel B" it was assigned to SDNY Judge Engelmayer, by Magistrate Judge Ona T. Wang.

 On June 5 - it is not clear where -  Meyers and his attorney Dan Portnov "waive[d] in open court prosecution by indictment and consent[ed] that the proceeding may be by information instead of by indictment."

   That way, instead of through the more public Magistrates Court, Meyers' presentment was before Judge Engelmayer, with a Docket Number listed as "19-CR- [blank]," quickly released on $100,000 bond, travel restricted to the US and Ireland unlike most defendants confined to two or three US Districts.

  This is the VIP aisle of indictments, with the DOJ helping to avoid any possible perp walk.

  And so it was that while the week's SDNY "Civil and Criminal Proceedings Calendar" for the week of 06/17/19 listed on June 19 at 5 pm a plea before Judge Engelmayer in USA v. Meyers, 19-cr-[blank], the courtroom of Judge Engelmayer where Inner City Press had been earlier in the day on a Hobbs Act robbery trial was empty.

  There was no sign on the door explaining why, as was done for example on the door of Judge Deborah Batts about Michael Avenatti. There are VIP lines, and vip lines. Watch this site - and for more, see its Patreon, here.

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

UN Guterres Serviced Indicted Iran Lobbyist Afrasiabi Court Finds By Inner City Press Show

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Podcast

BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

EDNY COURT / UN GATE, Feb 15 –    UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres responded positively to entreaties by indicted Iran lobbyist Kaveh Afrisaibi, documents now sought to be withdrawn from the Federal court file but obtained by Inner City Press show. 

   Afrisiabi was illegal paid as a lobbyist by Iran Mission the UN for years, through the UN Federal Credit Union.

  Inner City Press, banned from the UN by Guterres, has repeated put in written questions about this to UN Spokespeople Stephane Dujarric and Melissa Fleming and to Guterres, including through SGcentral [at] un.org.

  But despite an on-camera promise to at least answer Inner City Press' written questions, there have been no answers. 

 By contrast, when Iran illegal lobbyist Afrisiabi wrote to Guterres through SGCentral [at] un.org, he got an immediately response and solicitation to clarify and request a meeting, from Guterres staffer Susanne Rose.   

A subsequent message from Rose to Afrasiabi makes clear that Afrasiabi was granted a meeting with UN official Darko Mocibob, and that Afriasiabi's illegal Iran lobbying was passed on to SG Guterres.  Sample document on Inner City Press' DocumentCloud here, more on Patreon here including "Afrasiabi was operating under UN norms" and "Exhibit I: Afrasiabi’s email to UN Secretary General, responses from the Secretary General."

  Likewise there have been not answers to this question, emailed and WhatsApp-ed on the morning of February 15 by Inner City Press to Guterres, Fleming, Dujarric and his deputy Farhan Haq, before publication of this article.

 So where are the answers on this? And given Guterres' undisclosed links also with convicted UN bribery firm CEFC China Energy, and banning of the Press which asked, how can he be allowed the second five-year term is now seeking? Watch this site.

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Wells Fargo Account Scam Triggers SDNY Suit So Demand By Wells For Arbitration

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon

BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Feb 11 – Billy Dixon opened a Wells Fargo account with $750 in 2013. Then with Wells Fargo caught up in account opening fraud, it was closed the money not paid back for three weeks.

Dixon sued.

   On February 11, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge John P. Cronan held a proceeding. Inner City Press covered it.  

 Wells Fargo predictably wants to compel arbitration, or to dismiss the case.

 It has no fewer than three lawyers in the docket.

The case is Dixon v. Wells Fargo Bank, NA, 21-cv-10 (Cronan)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.