Wednesday, April 7, 2021

Hamid Akhavan For Pot & Wirecard Trial Wants Armed Guards Now Patterson To Be Added

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon

BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - The Source

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Feb 11 – Hamid Akhavan and Ruben Weigand are charged with a "scheme to deceive US banks into processing in excess of $100 million for marijuana products."

 On January 7, Akhavan and Weigand had a proceeding before U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Jed S. Rakoff, covered by Inner City Press, below.

It emerged that Akhavan had been presented in Magistrates Court earlier in the day on an alleged violation of supervised release, and detained on consent. It involved a gun.

   After being arrested and detained in California, Akhavan was writted to SDNY in connection with the case before Judge Rakoff. He was returned on the warrant related to the violation of pretrial release on January 7, after a December 30 arrest.  His counsel Christopher Tayback of Quinn Emanuel consented to his detention without prejudice to make a future bail application.

 On February 9 Judge Rakoff heard arguments on releasing Akhavan for the week or two weeks of trial, starting March 1. He will rule by Feb 12.  Inner City Press live tweeted below.

 Now on February 11, this: "MEMORANDUM TO THE DOCKET CLERK as to Ruben Weigand, Hamid Akhavan. On February 19 at 5pm, Judge Rakoff will have a waiver of indictment, arraignment, and plea proceeding for a defendant, James Patterson, that the Government plans to add to this case."

From February 9: Judge Rakoff: What about his use of a gun?

Akhavan's lawyer: It was gun possession. He needs to be out to prepare for this serious fraud case.

Judge Rakoff: You're telling me, Screw you judge, we're one of the best law firms in the country but we can't prepare

Defense lawyer: I'm definitely not saying Screw you judge. But we just got a lot of discovery, in a corrupted file. I'll be in NY soon. You know the risks of COVID - what is one of his lawyers gets sick? It impacts the trial. We're asking for another chance.

 Akhavan's lawyer: We would pay for armed guards. [That's what UN briber Ng Lap Seng got, in 47th Street condo, before he was found guilty of bribing  @UN_PGA  and others.] AUSA: Detain him Judge Rakoff: Let me cut to the chase. 3142(i) is for preparation of defense.

Judge Rakoff: I'm wonder if for week of trial he could be released to this private facility.  AUSA: His defendant is in a fundamentally different position that the co-defendant. He has a long history -- Judge Rakoff: I agree with all that. But there's new docs

AUSA: MCC is allowing in person visits, and video conference. So he can prepare. Being in a rented apartment, he can try to obtain drugs through guards, or while visiting counsel. Plus, we couldn't oversee his communications. He's trying to interfere in state case Inner City Press @innercitypress · 13m Judge Rakoff: OK, last opportunity for the defense.

Defense: We'd have to get the state custodial hold released too. Judge Rakoff: What about interfering with witness in state case?

Defense: We could arrange that he doesn't have a phone.

Judge Rakoff: I'm going to think about this. The only argument on the defense side that has any weight is about preparing for trial. I granted bail for Mr. Weigand. I went out on a limb for Mr. Akhavan, but his behavior was the equivalent of "Screw you judge."

 Judge Rakoff: I'll get you a decision by Friday. OK - the trial will start on March 1 rather than March 2.

Inner City Press has been digging into the possible Wirecard link.

 On July 27, Judge Rakoff held an oral argument on motions to dismiss, and motions to suppress, with a trial scheduled for January 2021. Inner City Press live tweeted it:

Judge Rakoff expressing frustration at counsel going over old ground, says "I have another matter at noon." Lawyer: If transaction occurred by debit card, there's no damage to the bank, a sine quo non of bank fraud.

 Defense lawyer: The banks received a lot of money for these transactions. There was no harm to them. Judge Rakoff: What you're saying is that when they deceived the banks, all they cheated the banks out of was some policy the banks wanted to adhere to

AUSA: It is not clear that the bank fraud statue is a prosecutor's Stradivarius. In the recent case of Attila, harm is a not a factor. The cheating in this case is obtaining the bank's own money through pretense. The analysis can end right there

Judge Rakoff: Let me hear from co-defendant's counsel.

William Burck of Quinn Emmanuel for Akhavan: There has to be a risk of loss to the bank for bank fraud.

Judge Rakoff: I was surprised that no one referred to the civil RICO cases that have address this issue

 Judge Rakoff: There was a case in the 5th Circuit, [or the 11th], after an airline takeover, to avoid unionization, the public was told that Continental Airlines was not as safe as Eastern had been. The allegation was that the pilot deceived the public

AUSA (sounds like Dimase) - these are more like Rule 29 motions, arguments about Visa and Master Card, let the jury decide. The indictment is sufficient.

Judge Rakoff: I have read your briefs. And I have other matters today.

AUSA: Conflating loss and harm is a mistake


Judge Rakoff: Let's turn to the motions to suppress. 

Weigand's lawyer: The warrants didn't allege that the devices seized were being used for the scheme.

Judge Rakoff: I'd like to hear from the government.

AUSA Nicholas Folly: We only had to show probability... The evidence in the affidavit came from the cell phone of the cooperating witness.  

Judge Rakoff: I'll issue an omnibus ruling by the end of August; trial now set for January.

 Weigand since he has money, unlike many SDNY defendants, on April 28 already had high powered lawyers from Wilson Sonsini. On April 28 they demanded a bill of particulars. 

  Judge Rakoff pushed back, setting a tight schedule for that: May 12, May 18 and he'll rule by May 20.

  But these high powered lawyers have a grueling trial schedule for other clients, from the Central District of California and elsewhere.

So Judge Rakoff agreed to a trial in December 2020, to be finished before Christmas. Inner City Press will cover it. The case is US v. Weigand, 20-cr-188 (Rakoff). 

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Meredith Who Threatened Pelosi Is Detained For Trial Now Hires DC Lawyer Kiyonaga

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Song

BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

FEDERAL COURT, Feb 11 –  Eight days after in the US Capitol among other things Mark Leffingwell stuck a Capitol Police officer repeatedly with a closed fist (and was freed), Cleveland Grover Meredith who arrived a day late in DC with guns in his trailer was detained.

  U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia Magistrate Judge G. Michael Harvey held the January 14 proceeding. Inner City Press live tweeted it, here and below.

  On February 4, with Meredith still detained, Judge Harvey held another proceeding (time changed from 2 to 2:30 pm ) at which he determined Meredith is NOT entitled to publicly funded counsel. He told Meredith to find and hire and pay lawyer and now he has. On February 11, filing a notice of appearance for Meredith is Paul Yoshio Kiyonaga, who has previously sued among others the US Broadcast Board of Governors. Inner City Press will stay on the case.

   From January 14: AUSA: Interstate threats can constitute a crime of violence.

Meredith's defense lawyer: The three cases they cite are inapposite. The 2013 case is no longer applicable after Supreme Court decisions in 2019.

Judge Harvey: Let me address the threshold issue. I'll skip to the conclusion. I'm going to rule for the government. But I'd like to make a record.

Judge: What the defendant is charged will must fall into one of the 3142(f) factors. So the government has to assert a crime of violence under the Bail Reform Act. It's defined as an offense using the threat of physical force... Section 875(c) criminalizes interstate communication of a threat of violence or to kidnap.  [Citing cases on Westlaw, privatization of legal precedents]

Judge: Does the threat to kidnap qualify as a crime of violence? Some cases say no, puzzling laymen and lawyers alike...

Judge: A person could be kidnapped through trickery. The DC Circuit has not addressed that. The 5th has, & 8th Circuit in Roth (2020). But this is not a kidnapping case - it's a threat case. Every threat case involves violence. [Without this, Meredith walks out on bond]

 Judge: Kidnapping by trickery scenario wouldn't happen in the real world. I conclude that the communicated threat is a crime of violence, & hence detention eligible. Now, let's hear the government on the four factors.

Defense: I still don't have financial affidavit

 Judge: File it by close of business tomorrow. Defense: I also have another status conference at 3:45 pm. Judge says tell other judge to wait. Now, the issue of confidential health issues arises. They want a break-out room. [This could have been done in writing] I

 Now they are arranging to take this public proceeding private, or sealed, apparently about Meredith's medical issues that militate for release. "You are now in a break-out session."  "You are now in the main session." Then, "You are now in a break-out session."

[While awaiting return of judge and lawyers (and Meredith?) note that the memo for release, 10 pages, didn't have anything redacted. This allegedly confidential medical info arguing for release could have been put in it writing, rather than this "break out" ...

 Maybe it goes without saying, but is this shielded "break out" session being transcribed by a court reporter, so that the sealing could be meaningfully challenged? Or one is supposed to reply on the Magistrate Judge to decide to unseal. But is that reviewable? ]

Anyway, "you are back in the main session."

Judge: OK government, go right ahead.

AUSA: There are no condition that will assure the community's safety, and return. He remained in DC and made multiple threats, including to Nancy Pelosi and the DC mayor...

AUSA: This misogynistic rhetoric... He sent a text message he was headed to DC for target practice. He said he took steps how to accomplish his goal, the best way to assault the city. He relished carnage. He said the mayor was stupid for calling it terrorism

 AUSA: There are text he wanted to stay a day later to, quote, F*ck with the Commies. He took steps to see these threats through. They are not protected by the First Amendment. He told officers he knew he had crossed the line. He booked a hotel room.

AUSA: He had an automatic rifle used by the Israeli military. He went so far as to apply duct tape to the magazine to more quickly fire bullets. He arrived day late -- Judge: That's the irony, isn't it? Why wasn't he hear on the 6th? AUSA: His car broke down. Inner City Press @innercitypress · 44m AUSA: Even late, he tried to accomplish his nihilistic goals. This violent rhetoric, it was fortunately discovered before it went further. The texts speak for themselves. He attended Governor Kemp's rally - ok, it is an open carry state, but...

 AUSA: He's acknowledged drug use, on the night of the offense. That day, prior to this offense, along the same time, at 3 pm he assaults a resident of the city, in a road rage issue. [That is not to be found, at least not yet, on the DC Court's website]
AUSA: That just goes to show the mental state that he was in. The fourth factor, danger to the community, our final point is this is someone who is under the spell of the Q-Anon...

He won't follow any conditions of release.

AUSA: He follows that ideological conspiracy theory movement.

Judge: Defense? Defense: He's a father of two. The text messages were in jest, to friends, and not posted online. An individual said, Im' worried about you. He replied, LOL I'm just having fun

Defense: He'd came to DC in November for a rally. It was a lot of fun. People were friendly. This time, when they came to his hotel room, he was friendly, he answered questions without an attorney present.  He is remorseful.

Defense: The government's own evidence say that as he got close to DC he released he couldn't have guns in his car, only in the trailer. We should be able to see what they are relying on. We don't know anything about the head-butting.

 Defense: He participates heavily in his church, traveled to other countries to build homes. He had an amicable divorce. His character reference [not in the docket?] says he's no troublemaker, just a patriot. She states she would help with a curfew & removing guns

 Defense: He was in his room, resting, when the authorities found him. We look at the community, in terms of danger, where he resides. He has no criminal history. He has ties in the North Carolina community.  Judge: Who is the custodian? Defense: Ms Jeffords [ph]

 Defense: He would refrain from the use of alcohol. He could turn over his passport.  [Note that this judge while releasing Leffingwell has detained Lonnie Coffman...]

Pre-Trial: There are not conditions to release him and keep community safe.

AUSA: He said he'd like to use the armor-piercing bullets to shoot the mayor of DC. He was texting about his weapons. That is was in jest is undercut by statements to FBI. He was asked if social media posts were for reaction or he believe. He said, a bit of both

AUSA: That he'd have access to social media could make worse the things happening in his head.. especially for the next couple of weeks.

Judge: I am going to grant request to detain Mr. Meredith.

 Judge: We get our fair share of these threat cases in DC. But I conclude this was a true threat. I don't remember any more concerning threats case. Threats to the mayor and Speaker of the House, of running them over. You said, "3 1/2 hours from target practice"

 Judge: Often people make threats from their basement. You took steps to come here. He drove from Colorado and brought with you the means to make good on your threats. The fire power in the vehicle: 9mm, a telescopic scope, 320 armor piercing rounds...

Judge: The threats were found on your cell phone. Exchanged with others the government could call as witnesses. The guns were in a truck behind your vehicle. You admitted that. It's a strong case, though that'd be up to a jury. But the factor weighs for detention

Judge: I do not see the point of sending you back to Colorado or North Carolina, even with GPS, since you traveled to get here. GPS is imperfect. We don't have room for error when it comes to you. I have no role in the Superior Court case. Here, Jan 28 at 3 pm

  Inner City Press will cover that too, watch this site.

   There was this, from the US response filing on the night of January 13:

the Government counsel filed a Memorandum in Support of Detention (ECF 4) on January 13, 2021, at 3:09 a.m., and was in receipt of the defendant’s Memorandum in Support of Relief (ECF 5) that day at 12:09 p.m.

Argument The defendant argues that the interstate communication of a threat to kidnap or injure another person does not qualify as a crime of violence. This ignores the analysis in United States v. Santoro, 359 F.Supp. 3d 122 (D. Me. 2019), which determined that such an offense, as enumerated under 18 U.S.C. § 875(c), is a crime of violence. The very threat to injure another, it reasoned, is a threatened use of violent force. As is the case here, the court noted that “[t]he defendant has not explained how one can threaten to injure the person of another without such a threat implying the use of violent force to do so.” Santoro, 359 F.Supp. 3d at 128; citing United  States v. Chapman, 866 F.3d 129, 134-35 (3rd Cir. 2017) (where a mailed threat to injure someone under section 876(c) amounted to a crime of violence). Similarly, in citing Sontoro, the same decision was reached in United States v. Christy, No. 3:18-CR-223, 2020 WL 2794617, at *4 (M.D. Pa. May 29, 2020), where the communication of threats, including to the President, “are clearly crimes of violence under the Bail Reform Act.” See 18 U.S.C. 3156(a)(4); United States v. Choudhry, 941 F.Supp. 2d 347, 351 (E.D.N.Y. 2013) (communication of threat to injure another is a crime of violence for detention purposes).

As in the case where a threat issued to the President of the United States qualifies as a crime of violence for purposes of detention, the same conclusion should follow here in the communication of a threat against a Congresswoman. Nevertheless, the defendant does pose a serious risk of flight as well. He has no ties to this community and has a means of transportation. Moreover, he has exhibited an extreme degree of hostility against governmental functions, ostensibly traveling to the District with violent intentions at a time that coincided with a hearing to confirm the next President of the United States." Watch this site.


On January 8, by contrast, Mark Leffingwell was released to fly back to him home in Seattle, no GPS monitor, no bond. 

Inner City Press covered the case.   U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia Magistrate Judge G. Michael Harvey held the detention, or really non-detention, proceeding. Inner City Press live tweeted it here:  (then, song here)

Now in Federal Court in DC, hearing of detained  Mark Jefferson LEFFINGWELL who "attempted to push past me and other officers. When he was deterred from advancing further into the building, LEFFINGWELL punched me repeatedly with a closed fist."

Assistant US Attorney is *not* asking for detention . He'll be allowed to travel back home to Seattle.

 AUSA: We'll be requesting strict conditions... A stay-away from DC... A curfew.  Judge: You say he works. What is it? Lawyer: A packaging plant called Panacea in Everett, Washington. 30 to 40 hours a week.

 From the complaint: "I was struck in the helmet that I was wearing and in the chest. Working with other officers, I was able to gain control over LEFFINGWELL, who attempted to struggle while being detained. I transported LEFFINGWELL to US Capitol Police HQ."

Judge Harvey: Believe it or not, I have a lot of these case. Pre-Trial should find out about GPS in the Districts where these folks come from. I released someone else yesterday. Defense: GPS is not necessary. He has 2 children.

Defense: He wants to go to church on the weekend. No need to be on a GPS. We'll take a stay away. He's never been to DC before.

Mrs. Leffingwell: I'm an insurance agent. We have a son, Noah, and Nicholas. Judge: I am going to release Mr. Leffingwell.

Judge: You can turn in your guns to a police station. You must call pre-trial once a week and keep working [at the packaging plant.] Stay away from DC except for court. Our proceedings will be remote, you probably won't have to come.

 Judge Harvey: I don't see the point of putting him on a curfew if we're not going to do GPS. Defense: He needs his ID to fly back to Seattle.

AUSA: We have nothing.

 Defense: He passed his phone to one of his friends. I think they have his license.

AUSA: A third party? I can look for it. Which agency.

Defense: He was brought to 1-D-1, next to the baseball field, then the cell block.

Judge Harvey: I am going to release Mr Leffingwell. He must stay away from Washington DC. [That seems to be the main focus]

Judge Harvey: You'll have to Zoom in to the preliminary hearing... We've got the phone number, no worries, Mr. Leffingwell.

Song on SoundCloud here.

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

In Griffith NoKo Crypto Case Dispute About Who Knew What When But Kiddle Use OKed

By Matthew Russell Lee, Pod Exclusive Patreon

BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - The Source

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Feb 11 – Virgil Griffith, charged with violating North Korea sanctions in connection with a crypto-currency conference there, now faces trial in September 2021 in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.

This emerged at a telephone conference in the case on December 22. Griffith's defense lawyer Brian E. Klein spoke among other things about filings not yet placed in the public docket, only emailed to SDNY Judge P. Kevin Castel. 

 On February 11, Judge Castel held a proceeding about who knew what before and at the conference Griffith spoke at. A stipulation or agreement has been proposed, essentially that some people know, but the DPRK / Kim government as such did not. Inner City Press live tweeted the proceeding, here:

The US and Virgil Griffith's lawyers disagree on how to describe the crypto knowledge of North Korea at the time of the conference Griffith spoke at. They seem to agree that some officials knew - but did "the DPRK government"?

Meanwhile, Griffith has requested loosening of pre-trial release conditions, including use of a Kindle, emailing with people other than his lawyers, and termination of drug testing. Full letter on Patreon here.

Assistant US Attorney: There were statements by Mr. Griffith to the FBI about what the conference attendees understood about crypto currencies. That evidence must be allowed, and would not fall under the Court's proposed stipulation.

 Judge Castel: I did not think the language in the stipulation would preclude that - otherwise there's no case here and we all go home. Some at the conference did not have this knowledge - that's the premise of the US' services argument.

Judge Castel: I assume if the US agreed that everyone at the conference knew in advance about what Mr. Griffith presented, the US would be consenting to dismiss the indictment.  Griffith's lawyer: We would like that. But we need time to consider the stipulation.

AUSA also wants to confer- with DC? Judge Castel signs off on agreed bail modifications: Kiddle, e-mail, no more drug testing. There may be more.

Inner City Press will continue to report on this case. More on Patreon here.


Here was a proposed stipulation: "The Government proposes the following stipulation: The Government is not arguing in this case that the information that the defendant allegedly provided and intended to provide at the Cryptocurrency Conference held in Pyongyang in April 2019 was above and beyond the then-existing capabilities and knowledge of at least certain individuals within the government of the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea. The defense proposes the following stipulation: Any information that Mr. Griffith disclosed or provided during his time in North Korea in April 2019, including at the Cryptocurrency Conference held in Pyongyang, was previously known to, and accessible from, the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea. The parties shared their proposals with each other, conferred regarding their respective positions, and determined that an agreement could not be reached." Full letter on Patreon here.

  On January 12 Klein filed multiple exhibits, with many redactions. Inner City Press is reviewing them but for now can first report there's an email from Brandon M. Cavanaugh of the FBI to three redacted recipients, that "Hey sir. Its [REDACTED.] However, DOJ asked us to hang on on reaching out to OFAC. Apparently, one or more people have already reached out to [REDACTED] and he's becoming frustrated. Just wanted you to be aware of the sensitivity." Watch this site.

   Inner City Press, which has covered the case from Griffith's first appearance in the SDNY Magistrates Court to his Christmas 2019 holiday legal moves to get released to home confinement in Alabama, has previously successfully sought sealed documents in this criminal case, see below. Dec 22 podcast here. It live tweeted the December 22 arguments, here and below.

 On December 30, the parties agreed the Griffith case can be tried in September 2021, specifically September 7: "Re: United States v. Virgil Griffith, 20 Cr. 15 (PKC) Dear Judge Castel: The parties submit this letter in response to the Court’s December 22, 2020 order to advise on whether there is any reason why the “the Court ought not seek a date for commencement of trial on or after September 7, 2021 and before September 30, 2021.” ECF No. 82. The parties have conferred and identified no reason why the case cannot be tried on or about September 7, 2021 and within the window identified by the Court. Defense counsel, however, request the date of September 7, 2020 because Mr. Buckley has a federal criminal trial in Chicago, United States v. Gregg Smith, 19 Cr. 669 (EEC) (N.D. Ill.), currently scheduled to commence on October 18, 2021." Watch this site.

After-hours on December 28 the SDNY prosecutors admitted another errors, like in the Iran/Nejad and other cases - and belated promised to give the defense - but not the public - the information they withheld and mis-represented, see more on Patreon here: "Re: United States v. Virgil Griffith, 20 Cr. 15 (PKC) Dear Judge Castel: The Government respectfully submits this letter to correct a factual error at the December 22, 2020 argument. The Government apologizes to the Court and counsel for the mistake. The Court inquired at the argument about the initiation of communications with the Office of Foreign Assets Control (“OFAC”) regarding “Virgil Griffith’s activities in North Korea.” (Tr. 42 (enclosed as Exhibit A)). The Government responded that the first contact between prosecutors and OFAC occurred on November 19, 2019, and that there were additional communications “between the FBI and another employee of OFAC” in “October of 2019.” (Id.). The Government later specified that “October 24[, 2019,] is the initiation of conversation between OFAC and the FBI.” (Tr. 48; see also Def. Reply Ex. G). Based in part on those representations, the Court ruled at the argument that the Government must “do a Brady review with OFAC that begins as of October 24, 2019, with the initiatory conversation between an FBI agent and someone at OFAC . . . for any Brady materials in OFAC’s possession on or after that date.” (Tr. 50-51). Following the argument, the Government re-reviewed communications it has collected to date and realized that the FBI began to communicate with OFAC regarding topics that are relevant to this case on August 5, 2019. To address this error and related difficulties in identifying the onset of communications with OFAC prior to undertaking the review, the Government will request from OFAC—without date limitation— any materials relating to Griffith and the 2019 Cryptocurrency Conference in Pyongyang, including participants such as the coconspirators described in the Complaint, and any materials relating to witnesses for the Government at trial. Based on that review, the Government will make any necessary disclosures or proceed, with notice to defense counsel, under the Classified Information Procedures Act." More on Patreon here.

Judge Castel: This is a case with a single count, of conspiracy to violate the law, the IEEPA, not the substantive charge. That may have consequences. The president at the time, President Obama, barred export of goods and services to the DPRK [North Korea]

Judge Castel: I'm looking at an email from Matthew McKenzie, it says "the basis for Griffith's presentation was publicly available info does not undermine the conclusion" that it violated the law. He packaged the info for the DPRK audience

Judge Castel: They traveled to a country where sale was blocked. They agree they are going to endeavor to sell the blocked weapons discussed at the Paris Air Show [this is a hypothetical]. Perhaps you could speak to that? Griffith's lawyer: Hypotheticals are hard

Griffith's lawyer: We're talking about publicly available technology, not weapons.  Judge Castel: What if the conference was just a prelude, but there'd be follow through, to transfer info tailored for the DPRK? Griffith's lawyer: That does not fit this case

 Griffith's lawyer: The government here is restricting speech. We're encouraging the court to apply strict scrutiny... We had a whole string cite about intangible goods and services. We think the indictment should be dismissed. AUSA Ravener: We specify the services

 AUSA Ravener: We cite Griffith pitching his company to the conference attendees. He was offering crypto-currency services.

Judge Castel: Did this conspiracy end, having achieved its purposes by the time Mr. Griffith departed North Korea airspace? Or was it longer?

AUSA Ravener: He followed up, that he'd like to find an emissary to make the crypto-currency exchange. At the conference he identified himself as working for the Ethereum Foundation. He said, we can give you contracts that don't go through the US

Judge Castel: He was a senior research for the Ethereum Foundation. That was essentially a marketing position. Did Ethereum Foundation provide services to others? Or just promote the Ethereum blockchain? AUSA Ravener: We would have to conduct further investigation

AUSA Ravener: Ethereum deals in Ether, that's potentially a service. We have evidence that Mr Griffith spoke with individuals at Ethereum about this ideas of providing services to North Korea. He was admonished not to go. But he went anyway.

 Judge Castel: Usually the US has no problem showing the guilty hand, they have problems with showing the guilty mind, mens rea. Here maybe the government can show guilty mind - but you still have to show the guilty hand, the actus reus. AUSA: We'll show at trial

AUSA Ravener: He created a bespoke presentation for the DPRK. It's clear he had done so in coordination with the DPRK. He was the keynote speaker. It's out of the information materials exemption in the OFAC regs

Judge Castel: My understanding of the exemption is that it is not precluded just because the audience didn't know the information. AUSA: He create a pitch how the info could be used to evade sanctions. And he pitched his own financial services processing services.

AUSA Ravener: We believe he tried to acquire domain names like http://blockchain.kp or http://crypto.kp, to enter this market... Judge Castel: So you say the conspiracy continued to December 2019.

Griffith's lawyer: If he gave this speech at Columbia University and it's allowed under the First Amendment, then it's allowed here. Part of a pitch? That is not in their briefs. With respect to Ethereum Foundation, they want to have it both way. He was on leave

 Griffith's lawyer: Ethereum is not a company. It's a blockchain. Judge Castel: I got it. The Foundation supports the blockchain. But Mr. Griffith received a paycheck or something from the Ethereum Foundation to promote the blockchain

Judge Castel: How does doubt by OFAC about whether it's a violation of law do anything for the defense? Griffith's lawyer Brian Klein: They asked OFAC for a determination to allow the arrest, and for a witness for the trial. So the OFAC doubts come into play. AUSA Wirshba: We'll be turning over 3500 material.

Griffith's lawyer Klein: I'm glad to here that. We want to know what OFAC said. They are also relying on Chevron deference. We need access to these records. They need to review it for Brady material. [See Rule 5f]

 Griffith's lawyer Klein: We'd like to know OFAC's view of DPRK's crypto currency capability. Judge Castel: My library could have that info, but they can't get it in North Korea, and in DPRK they don't have Google searches. Klein: We think some in DPRK have Google

 Griffith's lawyer Klein: We believe North Korea already knew a lot before Mr. Griffith's alleged speech. Judge Castel: You may want to ask to know the identity of all witnesses, like in any drug conspiracy case in this courthouse. The ID of cooperators.

 Griffith's lawyer Klein: We need the identity of the witness. Judge Castel: That's usually not given, at least in drug cases.  Now he cites the Middendorf factors - Inner City Press covered that case, here

 Judge Castel is back to the McKenzie email. AUSA: That was the first contact before our Office and OFAC's counsel office. There were discussions between the FBI and OFAC, in October 2019. Another call in November.

Judge Castel: What about Witness Number 2? AUSA: The government is withholding only limited information.  Griffith's lawyer Klein: Before Judge Broderick, another prosecutor said everyone in the DPRK works for the government.

Griffith's lawyer Klein: A jury should know that people in North Korea have info about crypto currency. We should get the info now, we are entitled to it or to a broad stipulation.

Judge Castel: There's more merit to that. I'm going to address that in my ruling

 Griffith's lawyer Klein: This is the first we're hearing about a call between FBI and OFAC -- Judge Castel: But you got notice of that in writing, Tab G, in your possession. Griffith lawyer Klein: The AUSA spoke about another call, too [He did]

 Judge Castel (with a ruling tone of voice) - The communications between the FBI and OFAC began in October 2019. When the prosecution conducts a joint investigation, courts in this circuit have held they must review the other agency's material for Brady material

 Judge Castel: My colleague Judge Oetken set forth a very useful test in Middendorf. But it does not completely fit here. OFAC interprets its own regulations. So now a Brady review is required, from October 2019 onward

 Judge Castel: With regard to Witness Number 2, the case law is that nothing obligates the government to disclose the identity of its witnesses before trial. I understand that a redacted version of Witness 2's statement has been provided.

Judge Castel: The government says that Mr. Griffith's supporters will try to help him. So I am withholding the identity to protect the witness [!] I'm going to reserve decision on materials about DPRK's crypto capabilities. The parties may wish to stipulate on this

 Judge Castel proposes a trial date: after Labor Day 2021. Klein: I want to discuss that with my client. We intend to ask for loosening of restrictions - he has been without Internet. Judge Castel: Each side should write to me why Sept 7, 2021 trial doesn't work

Griffith's lawyer Klein: We will put in a letter on loosening restrictions.  Judge Castel: It's one thing to have a case with tough issues. But it's a joy to a judge to have lawyers that can answer questions. It has been helpful. Peaceful holidays to Mr. Griffith

On exclusion of time under Speedy Trial Act, Klein said he'd like to speak with Griffith; his other lawyer Mr. Buckley said March makes sure. Judge Castel: I exclude time to Sept 7, this is not a run of the mill case. Adjourned

Update: after publication of the above, this order: "ORDER as to Virgil Griffith. Defendants motion to compel discovery of material in the possession of OFAC is GRANTED to the extent that the government is directed to conduct a review of material in the possession of OFAC for the period from October 24, 2019 to the present that is related to Mr. Griffith's prosecution; the government shall disclose any materials that must be disclosed to the defendant consistent with the governments obligations. Defendant's motion to compel discovery of the identity of the individual identified as Witness 2 is DENIED. The Court defers ruling on defendants motion to compel a search of files of certain government agencies regarding the cryptocurrency and blockchain capabilities of the DPRK. The parties shall meet and confer on a stipulation. The proposed stipulation shall be submitted to the Court no later than January 25, 2021. The parties are directed to submit a letter to the Court by December 30, 2020 setting forth any reason why the Court ought not seek a date for commencement of trial on or after September 7, 2021 and before September 30, 2021. A conference is set for September 7, 2021 at 9:30 am in Courtroom 11D 500 Pearl Street, New York, NY. For reasons stated on the record, time is excluded in the interest of justice under the Speedy Trial Act through September 7, 2021 to allow both sides to discuss a resolution of this matter and review discovery Time excluded from 12/22/20 until 9/7/21. (Signed by Judge P. Kevin Castel on 12/22/20)(jw)  "

 Back on November 10, Inner City Press went in person to the proceeding in Judge Castel's Courtroom 11D. It was alone in the gallery; in the front were the three ASUAs, Mr. Buckley for Griffith, and on the side CISO Hartenstein, who performs the same role in the CIA leaks case US v. Joshua Schulte.

  The government said it won't make its CIPA motion under March 19. Buckley point out that is more than a year after Griffith was arrested, and that Griffith is seeking FBI and other information.

 Judge Castel replied that he will bring the parties in on December 22. He said the public portion of the CIPA Section 2 conference was over; he told Mr Buckley he did not have to wait around (and Inner City Press, by implication, either). But what are the rights of the press and public with respect to these CIPA sealings?

  Earlier in the case: Judge Castel to his credit the same day asked each side's counsel to respond: "The Court has received an application from Inner City Press for the unsealing of certain applications by the defendant for the issuance of subpoenas. The parties shall respond to the application by May 22, 2020. If there is no objection, the Court will order the applications and any resulting order unsealed."

 On May 29, Judge Castel ruled: "Defendant is directed to file forthwith on ECF his ex parte and in camera applications for subpoenas pursuant to Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 17. (Signed by Judge P. Kevin Castel on 5/29/2020) (ap)."

  And now they have been filed: a March 17 letter and affirmation, and the subpoena itself, for "A list of any and all IP addresses associated with the email address dprk.un@verizon.net, and any logs or similar records of access to the email address dprk.un@verizon.net, for the period from November 1, 2018 to October 30, 2019."

  Inner City Press has uploaded the application, affirmation and subpoena on Patreon here.

   An aside: the application of diplomatic immunity and/or the Vienna convention to this subpoena, and Verizon's response to it, remain UNclear.

 On June 1, Griffith's lawyer filed a motion to dismiss for lack of venue, stating that Griffith's email to the North Korea Mission in New York, responded to, might not have been "received" in New York. Inner City Press is tweeting the photo here. Watch this site.

    On May 28, from Judge Castel again to his credit, this: "ORDER as to Virgil Griffith. The government advises that the defendant consents to public disclosure of his ex parte and in camera application for a subpoena pursuant to Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 17 (the Application) but does not consent to advance disclosure of the Application to the government. To enable the government to intelligently state its position on public disclosure, defendant shall transmit the Application to the government by 1 p.m. today, May 28, 2020. The government shall state whether it has any objection to public disclosure by 1 p.m. on May 29, 2020. The Court will thereafter rule on whether the Application should be publicly filed (Signed by Judge P. Kevin Castel on 5/28/20)(jw)." Watch this site.

The case is US v. Griffith, 20-cr-15 (Castel). 

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.