Saturday, December 19, 2020

SDNY Strauss Responds To Discovery Abuse In Letter to Judges Castel and Nathan Here

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon Letter

BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Dec 18 – The mounting criticism of the discovery practices of the US Attorney Office for the Southern District of New York has today given given to a letter from Acting US Attorney Audrey Strauss. 

 The letter, first reported by Inner City Press here, is directed to SDNY Judge P. Kevin Castel in the case of US v. Niket Jain. But it is explicitly cc-ed to Judge Alison J. Nathan, who is digging into misconducted in US v. Nejad that resulted in the dropping of a jury guilty verdict. 

 It might just as well has been cc-ed to Judges like Katherine Polk Failla, overseeing US v. Ahuja and Shor, or Judge Engelmayer in Teman, or Judge Hellerstein in Coro, etc....  Letter here

Strauss writes: " The Court directed the leadership of this Office and FBI New York’s Criminal Investigative Division to confer regarding steps to prevent a recurrence of these mistakes and report to the Court on corrective action. (Id. at 25). The October Order specifically cited breakdowns in communication between case agents and AUSAs, insufficient policies to ensure compliance with disclosure obligations, and inadequate unit-chief supervision of disclosure as contributors to the devices’ delayed production. (See Dkt. 143 at 25 n.6 (citing United States v. Nejad, 18 Cr. 224 (AJN), 2020 WL 5549931 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 16, 2020), at * 6)). As discussed below, we have implemented policy changes to mitigate the risk of poor communication and facilitate appropriate AUSA and supervisory attention to disclosure considerations from the earliest stages of our prosecutions. We have also conducted disclosure training for agents and prosecutors and instituted additional AUSA training on an ongoing basis, emphasizing the need for “prudent and timely” attention to these responsibilities. (Cf. id. at 2). Recognizing that addressing this Court’s concerns, as well as related issues that surfaced in other prosecutions, requires sustained engagement, we established a standing Disclosure Committee, led by a unit chief and deputy chief of the Criminal Division, and staffed by senior AUSAs, which is helping oversee our policy changes’ implementation, assess their effectiveness, and develop further improvements. A Technology Working Group is complementing the Disclosure Committee’s efforts by exploring ways to enhance our technological and administrative infrastructure for data management and disclosure.

 Our corrective actions began with a concerted effort to understand the underlying failures. Informed by the problems that arose in this case, as well as concerns highlighted by the Court in other prosecutions (see generally Nejad, 2020 WL 5549931), I and other executive staff members oversaw an analysis of disclosure-related failures. This assessment formed the framework for meetings between the executive staff and the leadership of each unit in the Office’s Criminal Division, aimed at identifying flaws in current procedures, as well as best practices for data management and disclosure. Unit chiefs continued these conversations within their units, to ensure engagement on these issues at all levels of the Office and that our review benefitted from line AUSAs’ perspectives." 

 And what will defense counsel, and civil libertarians, have to say? Full letter here
We'll have more on this.

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
SDNY Press Room 480, front cubicle
500 Pearl Street, NY NY 10007 USA

Mail: Box 20047, Dag Hammarskjold Station NY NY 10017

McHenry Sued Fox and Tyrus After Frozen Out Of Watters World Now Some Dismissed

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon

BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Dec 18 – In late 2019 Brittany McHenry filed a sexual harassment and retaliation lawsuit against Fox New, Fox Corporation, George Murdoch a/k/a Tyrus and the others.   On September 25 U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Paul A. Engelmayer held an oral argument on a partial motion to dismiss. Inner City Press live tweeted it, below.

 Now on December 18 Judge Engelmayer has dismissed some but not all of the claims, including this focus on the new amendment: "In August 2019, the NYSHRL was amended to direct courts to construe the NYSHRL, like the NYCHRL, “liberally for the accomplishment of the remedial purposes thereof, regardless of whether federal civil rights laws including those laws with provisions worded comparably to the provisions of [the NYSHRL] have been so construed.” N.Y. Exec. Law § 300. The amendment took effect on the signing date, August 12, 2019, although other parts of  the omnibus bill containing it took effect on October 11, 2019. See S. 6577, 242d Leg. § 16 (N.Y. 2019). McHenry depicts the amendment as broadly applicable to her claims under the NYSHRL. But the amendment has only a limited impact on her case, for two reasons. First, the amendment does not have retroactive effect. The omnibus bill does not contain language indicating that the 2019 amendments were intended to apply retroactively, see Arg. Tr. at 77–78, and “[i]t is a fundamental canon of statutory construction that retroactive operation is not favored by courts and statutes will not be given such construction unless the language expressly or by necessary implication requires it,” Majewski v. Broadalbin-Perth Cent. Sch. Dist., 91 N.Y.2d 577, 584 (1998). Accordingly, courts to date have held that the 2019 NYSHRL amendments are not retroactive. See, e.g., Wellner v. Montefiore Med. Ctr., No. 17 Civ. 3479 (KPF), 2019 WL 4081898, at *5 n.4 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 29, 2019) (holding that omnibus bill’s effective date is October 11, 2019). Second, McHenry’s Amended Complaint alleges only discrete actions after the effective date of the amendment. These are by Rauchet and Murdoch only. See Am. Compl. ¶ 99 (in November 2019, Rauchet told a Fox News guest to stay away from McHenry because she was “drama” for suing the network); id. ¶ 106 (in October 2019, McHenry discovered that Murdoch had, at an unspecified time, circulated doctored messages containing photos purporting to be of her). There is no occasion at this stage to consider the legal consequence, if any, of the fact that Rauchet’s and Murdoch’s conduct, as alleged, straddled the effective date of the amendment. That is because, for the reasons that follow, the Court finds McHenry’s claims against those two defendants sounding in retaliation to state a claim under the pre-amendment standard. These are the retaliation claims against Murdoch and the aiding-and-abetting-retaliation claims against Murdoch and Rauchet. The remaining claims presently at issue are all based exclusively on conduct predating the amendment, and none state a claim. These are the claims against Fox Corp., Finley, and Mekeel, and the harassment claims against Rauchet."

From the oral argument, Inner City Press' live tweets: Fox's lawyer points back to a time it was called "21st Century Fox." Judge Engelmayer: When I grew up, it was 20th Century Fox... Which I guess is better than 19th Century Fox.  Fox Corp is moving to get out of the case, leaving Fox News in (while disputing facts)

Fox's lawyer: She doesn't allege details of how she was hired, does not bring in 21CF.. Judge Engelmayer: Got it. Let me ask you about Monica Mekeel, listed as SVP for both Fox News *and* Fox Corp. Fox's lawyer: That's not enough to plead single employer.

Judge Engelmayer: Was she wearing both hats? Fox's lawyer: It's not pled clearly enough. And Ms. Mekeel wasn't made aware of the alleged harassment early enough. Judge Engelmayer: If the behavior of Mister [George] Murdoch is not attributable to either Fox...

Fox's lawyer: She hasn't alleged anything specific about John Finley... And saying that Mekeel asked her what she'd done to trigger this from Mr. Murdoch is not enough under the applicable law. Inner City Press

Judge Engelmayer asks about the Amended Complaint's statement that "Ms. McHenry used to regularly appear on Fox News Channel's 'Watters' World,' but has not been booked since her complaint (despite communications from bookers that they wanted her to appear)."

Fox's lawyer: There are a lot of people who work on these shows. Judge Engelmayer: But Jen Rauchet is the executive producer... Let's walk about Ms. Mekeel. Doesn't she own this problem, such as it is? Didn't she have an affirmative duty? And Ms McHenry got iced

Fox's lawyer: the investigation was taken away from Mekeel, to an outside investigator, as Ms. McHenry's request.  [Argument by Kristina Yost of Jones Day for Fox is over. Now Thomas Clare for George Murdoch / Tyrus - he says, Tyrus was NOT her employer

Tyrus' lawyer: They were co-hosts, co-workers. Judge Engelmayer, quoting from the complaint: But he said, Your picture looks so good, I could knock it up. And he grabbed her hand in Times Square. Tyrus' lawyer: That doesn't show it was unwanted.

As the argument proceeds, this from the Amended Complaint at Para 74: "On November 5, 2018, Mr. Murdoch texted Ms. McHenry, 'I'll show you what it means to be bad Brittany Mc Henry // D*ck pic coming in 5 sec!!!'"

Judge Engelmayer: Doesn't this cross the line?   DP alert: Judge Engelmayer just said, without the asterisk, "Di*k pic," asks about "You'll need those legs to escape from me to Montana" - doesn't that imply no consent? Tyrus' lawyer: There's not a lot I can say. Judge Engelmayer: We'll see where the case goes.

Now Ms McHenry's lawyer is up. Judge Engelmayer asks him how it is possibly retaliatory to ask to see all the text messages. "What have you done to provoke Mr. Murdoch"- are you saying that is retaliation? McHenry's lawyer: It's victim-blaming. It's discriminatory

Judge Engelmayer: But how can you claim Ms. Mekeel aided and abetted harassment, and not just retaliation? McHenry's lawyer: She did nothing to stop it.  Judge Engelmayer: What about Finley? It's just a cameo appearance. McHenry's lawyer: He was the VP...

Judge Engelmayer, to McHenry's lawyer: Why did you include Fox Corp and not just Fox News? A: You never know. Judge Engelmayer: That's not the pleading standard. And why do you argument that the new amendment applies retroactively? A: I don't have cases on that.

This McHenry v. Fox argument is over. Judge Engelmayer: I'm taking it under submission. I wish you all well, and I know I will be seeing you down the road. We are adjourned.

The case is McHenry v. Fox News Networks, LLC et al., 19-cv-11294 (Engelmayer)

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
SDNY Press Room 480, front cubicle
500 Pearl Street, NY NY 10007 USA

Mail: Box 20047, Dag Hammarskjold Station NY NY 10017

Enzo Vettese Extradited From Canada to SDNY For Money Laundering Now Gets Time Served

By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon

BBC - Decrypt - LightRead - Honduras - Source

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Dec 18 -- On February 28, 2020 an indictment from 2013 was unsealed in US v. Enzo Vettese, and the defendant was remanded with bail conditions including a return to Montreal stayed until March 3.

    U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Magistrate Judge Sarah L. Cave added to the districts the defendant could travel to the Northern District of New York. The defendant's lawyer said there were unspecified medical issues to be addressed, and Judge Cave summoned her up to the sidebar. Inner City Press was the only media in the Magistrates Court.

The background, recounted from documents the SDNY US Attorney's Office filed in Vettese’s Quebec court proceedings: law enforcement set up surveillance in 2013 near Park Avenue and East 20th Street. They zeroed in on red Pontiac Montana with a Quebec licence plate. A middle-age man carrying a travel suitcase approached the van, loaded the case into it and drove off.  Enzo Vettese, a 67-year-old Montrealer, was pulled over shortly after.  When the agents searched the car and opened the suitcase, they found wrapped in individual bundles, held together with rubber bands, $242,880.  Now Vettese he lost a challenge before the Quebec Court of Appeal after failing to convince the federal justice department the extradition order violates his Charter rights. Next up: co-defendant Edgar Belapatino.   

The case was assigned to Judge Denise L. Cote, who after a plea held a sentencing proceeding on December 18. Inner City Press covered it.

  Judge Cote said it was a serious crime, and what was found in 2013 was probably only the "tip of the iceberg." Still, due to the conditions of confinement during COVID, and the additional time in ICE custody he'll spend on the way back to Canada, Judge Cote sentenced him to time served.
The case is US v. Vettese, 13-cr-987 (Cote / Cave).

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
SDNY Press Room 480, front cubicle
500 Pearl Street, NY NY 10007 USA

Mail: Box 20047, Dag Hammarskjold Station NY NY 10017

On OneCoin Greenwood and US Get Stay of Discovery 90 Days Next SDNY Date March 26

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive Patreon

BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - The Source 

SDNY COURTHOUSE, Dec 18 – As Inner City Press covered the OneCoin trial in October 2019, a number of names of indicted co-conspirators emerged on which we followed up.

  One of them was Gilbert Armenta, who  recorded Ruja Ignatova. Inner City Press has repeatedly asked the US Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York for more information; it continues even now to withhold the exhibits it flashed on the screen at trial. Inner City Press had to file a FOIA request; the Department of Justice denied expedited processing.

  Then on August 6, Konstantin Ignatov got himself released from the civil suit, full filing here.

   On Sebastian Greenwood, on December 15, three days before a scheduled proceeding, this: "Re: United States v. Karl Sebastian Greenwood, S5 17 Cr. 630 (ER) Dear Judge Ramos: We write with the consent of the defendant to request a 90-day stay of discovery in the above-captioned matter. To date, the Government has produced to the defendant a voluminous amount of discovery, including, but not limited to, two hard drives containing several terabytes of data. In light of the voluminous discovery produced to date, which defense counsel is still in the process of reviewing, the Government would request that the production of discovery be stayed for a period of 90 days."

  Inner City Press live tweeted the December 18 Greenwood proceeding, such as it was, here:

AUSA: We have requested a stay, to try to work out a disposition.

Greenwood's lawyer Barket:  Correct. Plus, we're going through a lot of discovery material. Meeting my client is difficult, given the circumstances. I don't know how the jail permits who gets visits.

Greenwood's lawyer Barket: I had a few visit, then they stopped. I have three or four other clients in the facility and I can't meet any of them. We speak on the phone - once - and setting up the video conferencing has been difficult. It was easier in the summer

 Judge Ramos: You don't object to a stay of discovery? Barket: I don't.

Judge Ramos: So we'll come back in three months to see where we are? AUSA: Yes. Barket: Yes.

Judge Ramos: So, March 26 at 10:30 am. Speedy Trial Act time excluded. We are adjourned.

We'll continue to cover this.

 On September 16 in a filing with Judge Caproni more details: Ignatov's cooperation with the civil case plaintiff included calls on September 11 and 16: "Re: Grablis v. OneCoin Ltd. et. al., Case No. 1:19-cv-4074 Dear Judge Caproni: We write on behalf of Lead Plaintiff Donald Berdeaux and Plaintiff Christine Grablis (together, “Plaintiffs”) in the above-captioned matter (the “Action”). Plaintiffs request clarification from the Court regarding: (1) whether Plaintiffs have already received leave to file a Second Amended Complaint based on this Court’s July 24, 2019 Order (the “July 2019 Order,” ECF No. 39), and if not, whether Plaintiffs must seek leave to file a Second Amended Complaint; and (2) based upon the July 2019 Order, whether Plaintiffs must choose to file either a Second Amended Complaint or file an opposition to the Defendants’ Motions to Dismiss... Then-Defendant Ignatov was voluntarily dismissed from this Action without prejudice on August 20, 2020 on the basis of cooperation with Plaintiffs. [ECF No. 118]. Since granting the extension, and due to the issues involved with navigating call schedules with an inmate, Plaintiffs were able to obtain their first interview with Ignatov on September 11, 2020, and their second interview on September 16, 2020. These interviews have produced substantial useful information with which to bolster Plaintiffs’ claims in a Second Amended Complaint."

  The willingness to hide Armenta and the case against him, as he continued dubious business presumably for others, has Inner City Press wondering about these individuals it is researching through links to Ruja Ignatova's RavenR:

Thomas Christodoulou
Maria Serbina
Joanna Hilary Alinson
Simon John Longworth
Anna Marie Longworth
Robert Henry Rothenberg
Gary Michael Gilford
Nikolaou Nikolaos
Louca Theocharis
Mary Skoullou
Giannakis Tsiannaros
Svitlana Kolesnyk
Cyprus Development Bank
Vladislav Velkov

We'll have more on this.   Here are the Armenta business moves Inner City Press exclusively reported on December 1, 2019, here:

  ESOL B.V. LLC was incorporated on July 8, 2019; the manager is Gilbert Armenta and the agent is Giselle Valentin, both of 500 E. Broward Boulevard, PH 2, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33394. See here. And here.

   Armenta's Tblisi, Georgia-based money laundering bank JSC Capital Bank had as its parent a company of exactly this name. See KPMG review of Georgia banking sector here. More on Armenta's ongoing companies on Patreon here.

  Inner City Press asked, on December 1, 2019: Is the US Attorney's Office allowing its cooperator to keep on money laundering? Or looking the other way while whatever cooperation agreement exists is openly violated?
Perhaps these and other quesitons will be answered in connection with Armenta's sentencing in the too long seal case against him. Watch this site.

More on Patreon here.

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
SDNY Press Room 480, front cubicle
500 Pearl Street, NY NY 10007 USA

Mail: Box 20047, Dag Hammarskjold Station NY NY 10017

Friday, December 18, 2020

Rice Versus AOC For Energy In DC As Politics of Place But Not Bank Reregulation Are Zoomed


By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN

NEW YORK, SDNY & EDNY, Dec 17 – The difference between retail and wholesale politics was on display Thursday night, on calls on Zoom and video, DC, The Bronx and Queens. 

   Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez held a Zoom town hall from 7:30 to 8:30 pm, at which she took constituent and three media questions, focused on the stimulus negotiations but the Paycheck Protection Program or bank re-regulation aspects of it.  

   But as DC based sources report, there was a video call to vote on contested seats on the House Energy and Commerce Committee, where Democratic leadership set up a vote between Ocasio-Cortez and Long Island former prosecutor Kathleen Rice, which as set up the latter won, 46-13.

     Surprisingly, this showdown did not come up in the questions selected in the questions picked on Thursday night, except perhaps indirectly.

A constituent in the Bronx' Parkchester housing development asked about how the Green New Deal deals with such issues as pollution from trucks on the nearby Cross Bronx Expressway.  

Ocasio-Cortez replied among other things that corporations are given tax breaks to come into the Bronx and then pollute it; she spoke about health problems caused by older housing stock like Parkchester.

  She also said that earmarks are in the past, and that Federal Congresspeople have to work on nationwide issues. 

   As an example, a constituent from Astoria, Queens was given an update on negotiations on PPP and other stimulus (but again, not the bank regulatory aspect of PPP).

    In full disclosure, Inner City Press which is headquartered in Ocasio-Cortez' district had asked in writing, and in advance, about PPP and the Community Reinvestment Act, specifically anti-CRA Comptroller of the Currency Brian Brooks. We hope to have more on this. Watch this site.

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
SDNY Press Room 480, front cubicle
500 Pearl Street, NY NY 10007 USA

Mail: Box 20047, Dag Hammarskjold Station NY NY 10017