Monday, July 27, 2020

In Sarah Palin Case NYT Lawyer Says Bennet Negligence Is Not Defamation in SDNY


By Matthew Russell Lee, PatreonBBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - The Source
SDNY COURTHOUSE, July 27 –   In the ongoing case of Sarah Palin versus New York Times and James Bennet, on July 24 U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Jed S. Rakoff held oral arguments. Inner City Press live tweeted them:
NYT lawyer, Jay Brown of Ballard, says Bennet - since ousted or resigned - is able to bring this motion. Judge Rakoff: I was not persuaded by plaintiff's argument on that. NYT lawyer: This is Palin's contention that a jury might disbelieve Mr Bennet's testimony
 NYT: There's no need for the court to make credibility determinations. There's no dispute of material fact. Let me turn to the merits. Did Bennet act with actual malice when he wrote the sentences? Did he accuse her of inciting shooting? We say no, not with malice
 NYT: Bennet was unaware that his words would be interpreted that way. Judge Rakoff: Isn't it partly a function of what a reasonable jury could infer where the language is essentially unambiguous, like if the Defendant  said, "Mr Jones is a cold blooded murderer"
 Judge Rakoff: .. the jury could draw an inference. NYT: The defamatory statement can't be considered in isolation. "Under NYT v. Sullivan, the statement must be judged entire based on what the publisher intended it to mean."
 Judge Rakoff: But I'm to follow case law, and not treatises, no? Let me go back to my rather over-simple hypo. Supposing the defendant at his deposition, When I said Jones was a cold blooded murderer, I didn't mean that literally, I just meant he's nasty
 Judge Rakoff: Cannot a jury say, That's preposterous. The words were so without qualification we don't believe you didn't mean it literally? Can't that be part of the mix?
NYT: The language of the publication is part of the mix -- [then NYT lawyer is cut off]
 Judge Rakoff [after NYT lawyer is cut off]: I interpret that to mean he thought his rhetoric was so electric...
 NYT is back: Elizabeth Williamson prepared a draft of the editorial... In her draft, she said, "Just as in 2011, the rage in Virginia was nurtured," etc. Mr. Bennet removed the Virginia reference, there, but kept in "link to political incitement was clear."
NYT lawyer: Let's consider the 5:08 am email by Bennet: "I don't know what the truth is here... We may have relied too much on our own earlier editorials."
Judge Rakoff: Plaintiff says Bennet committed at his deposition that he had read a report in The Atlantic   Judge Rakoff: Why couldn't a jury infer that he had read it, and knew what he wrote was false, but after criticism was trying to cover his read end? NYT: Let's compare what Mrs. Palin said and what the Second Circuit ruled.
 lawyer: Mr. Bennet did not click on hyperlinks in [his] editorial... He relied on fact checkers to ensure his editorials were accurate
 Palin's lawyer: There's nothing binding from the Supreme Court imposing the defendant's standard here. Judge Rakoff: Even under your approach you have to show reckless disregard, no? Palin's lawyer: Correct.
 Palin's lawyer: The decision was already made to write about gun control, and "hate speech" of people on the Right.  Judge Rakoff: You're saying he started with a bias? Palin's lawyer: Yes, your Honor.
 Palin's lawyer: The NYT was already under fire, sponsoring Shakespeare in the Park portraying Trump as Caesar, some advertisers were pulling out. So Bennet was back pedaling. Palin's lawyer: They resorted to framing, to pre-conceived notions.
This is a case of willful avoidance of the truth. He published the editorial without re-acquainting himself with what the Atlantic [he is or was affiliated with] published
 Palin's lawyer: Bennet has a narrative he wanted to tell and he didn't care what the fact checkers said. It's purposeful avoidance of truth. Bennet insisted on persisting with narrative even after corruption came out, he told CNN it didn't undercut the editorial
Palin's lawyer: Bennet was still insisting that the piece was justifiable. The international edition cut out the defamatory terms, but Ms. Cohen claimed it still conveyed the same message. So Bennet was engaged in political score-keeping
Palin lawyer: There were 3 to 4 other editorials ready that could have run that day. All of this could have been avoided. But this falls in line with Bennet's pre-determined narrative. There was recklessness. So the summary judgment motion should be denied.
Judge Rakoff: I'll give the defendant nine minutes, then I have to head up to my courtroom for a proceeding.
NYT's lawyer: This may have been negligence, but it is not defamation of a public figure.
Judge Rakoff tells the lawyer the history of "malapropism," promises an end of August ruling before Feb 2021 trial.
 The case is Palin v. The New York Times Company, 17-cv-4853-JSR (Rakoff)
***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Ogunbambo Applied For US Passports in 2016 and 2018 Then Pled Guilty to Fraud in SDNY


By Matthew Russell Lee, PatreonBBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - The Source
SDNY COURTHOUSE, July 27 – Oluwaseun Ogunbambo applied for US Passports in 2016, 2017 and 2018.
On July 24 he pled guilty to "False Statement in Application for Passport," in exchange for the US dropped the Aggravated Identity Theft court. Inner City Press covered it.  
U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Alvin K. Hellerstein asked, Why did the US give this man three passports? 
It turned out that the 2016 application was granted; 2017 was to change the name on the passport. And 2018 was denied.
Sentencing was set for October 8.
The case is US v. Ogunbambo, 19-cr-895 (Hellerstein)
***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Charged With Bronx Kidnapping Arce Is Bailed To Bethlehem PA By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon


SDNY COURTHOUSE, July 27 – Paul "Pablo" Arce is indicted for kidnapping on Simpson Street in The Bronx - the indictment puts it that he "did knowingly inveigle, abduct and carry away" Victim-1.
   On July 27 Arce had a proceeding before U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge P. Kevin Castel. Inner City Press covered it. 
  Arce pled not guilty.
 The question was, would he be released on bond?
Judge Castel recounted his prior arrests, citing two at age 14, another while in school. He decided that Arce could be released to his mother's house in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania. 
  Pre-Trial Services said that home confinement would be the best way to go, to allow for treatment.
 Judge Castel genially agreed, and set September 22 as the next conference in the case, excluding time under the Speedy Trial Act.
This case is US v. Arce, 20-cr-292 (Castel)
***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

After Slip and Fall Fraud Trial US Asked For Extra Month on Duncan But $644056 Imposed


By Matthew Russell Lee, PatreonBBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - The Source
SDNY COURTHOUSE, July 27 – Bryan Duncan was convicted in a slip and fall insurance fraud conspiracy and has been awaiting sentencing, with restitution to be determined.
On May 29 he called the Chambers voicemail of U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Sidney H. Stein.    Judge Stein ordered Duncan "to have no further direct contact with chambers," and scheduled a July 10 proceeding. Inner City Press, which covered the trial, covered this as well. 
 Duncan's new lawyer Patrick Megaro, based in Florida and having now having tested positive for Coronavirus, on July 17 continued to argue for a reduction in restitution and to file exhibits under seal, which he has.
  He said he would appear by phone at Duncan's sentencing on July 27.
 But on July 26, the day before already delayed sentencing, the US Attorney's Office asked for another month: "Re: United States v. Bryan Duncan, S2 18 Cr. 289 (SHS) Dear Judge Stein: With the consent of counsel for the above-referenced defendant, the Government respectfully requests a one-month adjournment of the sentencing proceeding scheduled for tomorrow, July 27, 2020, at 11:00 am... Since July 17, the Government has been investigating the defendant’s arguments and, earlier this afternoon, learned information from a cooperating witness that may alter the Government’s position on forfeiture. Accordingly, and regrettably at this late hour, the Government respectfully requests a one-month adjournment of tomorrow morning’s sentencing proceeding. The adjournment will allow the Government to further investigate newly-obtained information about the percentage of fraudulent proceeds that are attributable to trip-and-fall cases verses non-trip-and-fall cases. Based on the defendant’s July 17 submission, the Government also intends to revise its request for restitution, but no further investigation is required on that score. The proposed adjournment will also allow defense counsel, who recently tested positive for COVID-19, to appear at the sentencing proceeding in person."
Inner City Press asked, Will Judge Stein grant this? The answer was, No.
   Judge Stein went forward, imposing the 72 months he had previewed, and adopting the dubious $644,056 figure. Is it supported by the trial record?  Inner City Press will continue to report on this case.
The case is US v. Duncan, 18-cr-289 (Stein)
***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

For Stealing $3 Million in Bar Works Ponzi Scheme Gata Aura Gets 48 Months in SDNY


By Matthew Russell Lee, PatreonBBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - The Source
SDNY COURTHOUSE, July 27 – Savraj Gata-Aura was involved in the Bar Works Ponzi scheme of selling shared-work spaces to retail investors, stealing some $3 million in the process.
He pled guity with a sentencing range of 97 to 121 months, but counted on defense lawyer Randy Zelin to get him less.
   On July 27 in a rare in-person sentencing in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York which Inner City Press attended, he got 48 months. Here was some of the blow by blow: 
Gata-Aura's lawyer Zelin says he's asking for time served because he will be removed to UK, alone.
He cites SDNY Judge Rakoff's decision on inside trader Millul. 
AUSA Vladislav Vainberg cites the big loss figure: $40 million. 
Judge Rakoff says the learned Zelin has not convinced him to grant time served because of removal to UK. He says this was pure greed, and that just punishment requires 48 months in prison. 
 There was more: in the gallery were six people, supporters of the defendant. This was the same courtroom where Millul had argued, about deportation. But insider trading is different than ripping of retail investors of their life savings.
Some commented to Inner City Press that at least some time was given; others than people get more time for knocking over a liquor store.
This case is US v. Gata-Aura, 18-cr-759 (Rakoff)
***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Weigard and Akhavan Charged With $100M Pot Scam Before January Trial Argue To Dismiss


By Matthew Russell Lee, PatreonBBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - The Source
SDNY COURTHOUSE, July 27 – Ruben Weigand and Hamid Akhavan are charged with a "scheme to deceive US banks into processing in excess of $100 million for marijuana products."
 On April 28, Weigand had a proceeding before U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Jed S. Rakoff, covered by Inner City Press, below. Since then Inner City Press has been digging into the possible Wirecard link.
 On July 27, Judge Rakoff held an oral argument on motions to dismiss, and motions to suppress, with a trial scheduled for January 2021. Inner City Press live tweeted it:
Judge Rakoff expressing frustration at counsel going over old ground, says "I have another matter at noon." Lawyer: If transaction occurred by debit card, there's no damage to the bank, a sine quo non of bank fraud.
 Defense lawyer: The banks received a lot of money for these transactions. There was no harm to them. Judge Rakoff: What you're saying is that when they deceived the banks, all they cheated the banks out of was some policy the banks wanted to adhere to
AUSA: It is not clear that the bank fraud statue is a prosecutor's Stradivarius. In the recent case of Attila, harm is a not a factor. The cheating in this case is obtaining the bank's own money through pretense. The analysis can end right there
Judge Rakoff: Let me hear from co-defendant's counsel.
William Burck of Quinn Emmanuel for Akhavan: There has to be a risk of loss to the bank for bank fraud.
Judge Rakoff: I was surprised that no one referred to the civil RICO cases that have address this issue
 Judge Rakoff: There was a case in the 5th Circuit, [or the 11th], after an airline takeover, to avoid unionization, the public was told that Continental Airlines was not as safe as Eastern had been. The allegation was that the pilot deceived the public
AUSA (sounds like Dimase) - these are more like Rule 29 motions, arguments about Visa and Master Card, let the jury decide. The indictment is sufficient.
Judge Rakoff: I have read your briefs. And I have other matters today.
AUSA: Conflating loss and harm is a mistake

Judge Rakoff: Let's turn to the motions to suppress. 
Weigand's lawyer: The warrants didn't allege that the devices seized were being used for the scheme.
Judge Rakoff: I'd like to hear from the government.
AUSA Nicholas Folly: We only had to show probability... The evidence in the affidavit came from the cell phone of the cooperating witness.  
Judge Rakoff: I'll issue an omnibus ruling by the end of August; trial now set for January.
 Weigand since he has money, unlike many SDNY defendants, on April 28 already had high powered lawyers from Wilson Sonsini. On April 28 they demanded a bill of particulars. 
  Judge Rakoff pushed back, setting a tight schedule for that: May 12, May 18 and he'll rule by May 20.
  But these high powered lawyers have a grueling trial schedule for other clients, from the Central District of California and elsewhere.
So Judge Rakoff agreed to a trial in December 2020, to be finished before Christmas. Inner City Press will cover it. The case is US v. Weigand, 20-cr-188 (Rakoff). 
***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.