Wednesday, June 13, 2018

In DC at CFPB Mulvaney Disbands Consumer Advisory Board As OCC Cuts CRA, FOIA


By Matthew R. Lee, Patreon

NEW YORK, June 6 – The US Consumer Financial Protection Bureau under Mick Mulvany has moved to disband the statutory Consumer Advisory Board, Mulvaney told the 23 board members at 11 am on June 6. Mulvaney had cancelled an in-person meeting with the Board, mandated by the Dodd Frank act, proposing instead another telephone conference call - on which he fired the board members. 

On June 4 Inner City Press covered a media call by Consumer Advisory Board members, after asking Citigroup somequestions at the UN - just as it covered the shift before the 2016 election of some regulatory functions of the Federal Reserve, which continued to rubber stamp bank mergers, to the CFPB. Now the CFPB is stepping further back from regulation, to put it mildly. And the Fed and the other two federal bank regulators are not picking up any of the slack. US Comptroller of the Currency Joseph Otting, who generated fake comments supporting his OneWest Bank's merger with CIT Group, is now seeking to remove the "community" from the US Community Reinvestment Act, eliminating any focus on the areas from which banks draw their insured deposits. Otting told the ABA he wants to make it  “easy and simple for banks to understand” the CRA. His OCC spokesperson spuns that "the comptroller has mentioned in numerous public settings that we need to revisit how assessment areas are defined." The WSJ, for now, did not mention Otting's previous history of undermining the CRA. Otting has also been shown to have continued buy and owning bank and insurance company stocks even after he was nominated, confirmed and began at the OCC. The stocks included Wells Fargo, Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, Citigroup, KeyCorp and Prudential Financial. Now Otting has his eye on further weakening Community Reinvestment Act reviews of mergers. The OCC is still withholding documents requested by Inner City Press and CRC under FOIA including about how Otting's bank's lawyers responded to the fake comment issue. We'll have more on this. Even as Consumer Financial Protection Bureau chief Mick Mulvaney promises to scrap payday lending and other protections, on April 20 his CFPB with a new logo along with Joseph Otting's OCC announced a $1 billion fine against Wells Fargo. As one Inner City Press agency source put it, imagine what the fine would be under anyone else. Others noted how unspecific the press release of the CFPB - apparently being renamed the Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection - is, compared to those which came before. On April 9 the payday lenders' lobbying group Community Financial Services Association of Americasued to overturn the rule, in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas, Austin Division. This comes as the US Office of the Comptroller of the Currency's Joseph Otting has ended the ban on payday lender ACE Cash Express working with national banks, and with Mulvaney set to testify to the House Financial Services Committee on April 11, amid #JustEconomy outreach on Capitol Hill. Watch this site. Speaking of paydays, that of Janet Yellen in NYC's Tribeca last week, a big bucks speech to 40 Jeffries clients as a sort of appetizer to the NCAA March Madness basketball final, shows how corrupt US bank regulation is. While lower level bank regulators at the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency face a cooling off period before they can go through the revolving door, the very Chair of the Federal Reserve can sell out in two months, or as little as a week as Alan Greenspan did it. This should have been prohibited in Dodd Frank but wasn't. But Yellen? For shame - including to refusing to each disclose how much money she charged. We'll have more on this. After much focus on who at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York should replace outgoing William Dudley, on April 3 the Fed did the expected, picking insider John Williams from the San Fransisco Fed who oversaw Wells Fargo's many frauds. We'll have more on this. This comes days after Dudley himself on March 30 misrepresented the bill S.2155 as offering relief to "small banks" -- actually, it's banks up to $250 billion in assets, and foreign mega-banks larger than that. Dudley's misleading comment came on the New York public radio show of Brian Lehrer, who erroneously said that the bill has been enacted "by Congress" when it has only passed the Senate. Meanwhile everyone from Mayor Bill de Blasio to Senator Kirsten Gillibrand has been saying the Fed's process for naming the President of its Reserve Bank is not transparent enough. Now that the expected Williams has been picked, what next? We'll have more on this. Collusion between payday lenders and national banks has been invited by US Comptroller of the Currency Joseph Otting, under whose watch OneWest Bank generated fake public comments urging approval of its merger with CIT. Otting has lifted the 2002 consent order prohibiting ACE Cash Express from "partnering" with national banks. Speaking earlier in, where else, Las Vegas Otting said, "We think there’s a big market there that’s underserved, that really has the ability to be served by capital going forward." When he was selling off OneWest, those whose e-mail addresses and identities were stolen in order to promote the merger were thanked by David Finnegan of the OCC Otting now runs. Finnegan then asked OneWest's and Otting's lawyer Stephen M. Salley at Sullivan & Cromwell to explain. We'll have more on this - there's a lot of explaining to do. On March 14 as what was presented as a community bank regulatory relief bill was passed in the U.S. Senate 67-31 as S.2155, along with undercutting fair lending enforcement the bill would provide particular benefit to the US subsidiaries of some of the largest global banks. These include at least one which helped evade North Korea sanctions: Bank of Tokyo - Mitsubishi. But on the evening of March 14, this from the White House: "President Donald J. Trump commends the Senate, led by Chairman Mike Crapo (R-ID) for passing S.2155, the Economic Growth, Regulatory Relief, and Consumer Protection Act. The President supports this bill, and as recently noted in a Statement  of Administration Policy (SAP), he would sign it into law. The bill provides much-needed relief from the Dodd-Frank Act for thousands of community banks and credit unions and will spur lending and economic growth without creating risks to the financial system. By tailoring regulation, the bill seeks to prevent excessive regulation from undermining the viability of local and regional banks and their ability to serve their communities. The President looks forward to discussing any further revisions the House is interested in making, with the goal of bipartisan, pro-growth Dodd-Frank relief reaching his desk as soon as possible." Relief for foreign banks violating North Korea sanctions? These are banks with over $250 billion in assets which, by using "intermediary holding companies," would be evading regulation: Barclays, BBVA, Credit Suisse, RBC, Deutsche Bank, UBS, Santander, BNP Paribas and, notably, MUFG a/k/a Bank of Tokyo Mitsubishi. This last, as Inner City Press has reported on, already switched regulator to escape an including into non-enforcement of North Korea sanctions, in a process that included no public comment period at all. The OCC gave its approval in a week even while belatedly listing Bank of Tokyo - Mitsubishi's filings under "THESE APPLICATIONS APPEARED INCORRECTLY IN A PRIOR WEEKLY BULLETIN." Photo here; link to Bulletin here. The public, as is the trend under the OCC, was cut out.  Something to keep in mind as S.2155 is portrayed as all about community banks. While Inner City Press has been most focused on the proposed changes to the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act rules (NCRC op-ed here), the august New York Times appears to have lifted from the detailedearlier reporting of The Intercept. This happens at the United Nations all the time, with the added twist of the corporate thieves them working with the UN to evict and restrict the Press with the scoops. But it's particularly ironic hear, when predatory lending is the underlying topic. So we'll run these quotes to explicitly credit The Intercept: "The bill raises that threshold to $100 billion immediately, and to $250 billion within 18 months. That would relieve 25 of the 38 largest U.S. banks from enhanced regulations, including Citizens Bank (Philadelphia Phillies), Comerica (Detroit Tigers), M&T Bank (Baltimore Ravens), SunTrust (Atlanta Braves), KeyBank (Buffalo Sabres), BB&T (Wake Forest University), Regions Bank (AA baseball’s Birmingham Barons), and Zions Bank (Salt Lake City’s Real Monarchs of Major League Soccer).... The bill raises that threshold to $100 billion immediately, and to $250 billion within 18 months. That would relieve 25 of the 38 largest U.S. banks from enhanced regulations, including Citizens Bank (Philadelphia Phillies), Comerica (Detroit Tigers), M&T Bank (Baltimore Ravens), SunTrust (Atlanta Braves), KeyBank (Buffalo Sabres), BB&T (Wake Forest University), Regions Bank (AA baseball’s Birmingham Barons), and Zions Bank (Salt Lake City’s Real Monarchs of Major League Soccer)... Raising the threshold for stadium banks will likely also affect the U.S. operations of globally systemic foreign banks, companies like Barclays (Brooklyn Nets), Bank of Montreal (Toronto FC of Major League Soccer), BBVA Compass (Houston Dynamo, MLS), Santander (minor-league baseball’s York Revolution), and Deutsche Bank (an equestrian stadium in Aachen, Germany)." The bill is S.2155, the "Economic Growth, Regulatory Relief, and Consumer Protection Act." Meanwhile, the bank with the worst record in the United States for gouging consumers with overdraft fees, Ameris, has applied to the Federal Reserve to buy Atlantic Coast Bank in Florida, and thereafter Hamilton State Bancshares. On January 29, Fair Finance Watch filed formal opposition to both with the Federal Reserve, citing the gouging, Ameris' disparate mortgage lending record in Atlanta, Georgia and Florida, and the Community Reinvestment Act. See below. It turns out, from Ameris' response, that its application was false when it said it would continue the CRA policies of Atlantic - see full response on Patreon, here, question 3. Inner City Press has requested records under the Freedom of Information Act. Now the Federal Reserve has asked Ameris a series of question, full copyhere on Patreon: "In connection with the application under section 3 of the Bank Holding Company Act on behalf of Ameris Bancorp (“Ameris”), Moultrie, Georgia, to merge with Atlantic Coast
Financial Corporation (“ACFC”), and thereby indirectly acquire Atlantic Coast Bank, both of
Jacksonville, Florida, the following additional information is requested. Supporting
documentation should be provided as appropriate. 1. Describe any due diligence performed by Ameris or related to the Community Reinvestment Act (“CRA”), including any efforts to ascertain the needs of the communities served by Atlantic Coast Bank. To the extent the needs of the communities
to be served were identified, summarize how Ameris contemplates assisting in addressing
those needs. 2. Indicate any of products or services of Atlantic Coast Bank that Ameris contemplates discontinuing in connection with the proposal. To the extent that any products or
services would be offered in replacement of any products or services to be discontinued,
indicate what these are and how they would assist in meeting the convenience and needs
of the communities affected by the transaction. 3. In the application (page 10), Ameris indicates that Ameris Bank plans to continue to
implement the current CRA policies of Atlantic Coast Bank following consummation.
Elaborate on that statement, including to what extent, if at all, the CRA policies of
Ameris Bank would be implemented at the combined institution. 4. Indicate to what extent Ameris Bank’s consumer compliance program, including its fair lending program, would be implemented at the combined institution. 5. Relative to the branches of Atlantic Coast Bank that Ameris currently intends to close
upon consummation of the bank merger, which are listed on page 6 of the Bank Merger
application, as well as the “Julington Creek Branch” and “Jacksonville Branch” of
Ameris Bank that Ameris currently intends to close upon consummation, please specify
which are consolidations/relocations and closures in accordance with the guidance
provided in the revised joint policy statement by the banking agencies regarding branch
closings. 1 In addition, specify the branches which are located in LMI or minority census
tracts, and, for the contemplated closures in LMI or minority tracts, indicate efforts
contemplated to mitigate the potential impact of these closures. 6. Describe any litigation or investigations by local, state, or federal authorities involving Ameris or any of its subsidiaries or ACFC or any of its subsidiaries that is currently pending or was resolved within the last two years. 7. Based on staff’s review of the Agreement and Plan of Merger dated
November 16, 2017, between Ameris and ACFC (the “Agreement”), section 4.9 of the
Agreement (regarding the making of any loans in excess of $1,000,000) raises concerns
that Ameris may be able to exercise control over the day-to- day operations of ACFC and
Atlantic Coast Bank prior to the Federal Reserve’s approval of the application. Discuss
in detail the reasons ACFC and Atlantic Coast Bank are required to give prior notice to
Ameris for the actions described in section 4.9. Explain whether this provision would
give Ameris the ability to control the activities that ACFC and Atlantic Coast Bank
conduct in the ordinary course of business. Discuss the reason for choosing the specific
dollar amounts requiring prior notice to Ameris and provide the number and percentage
of transactions within the last year that would have required prior approval under the
stated conditions. 8. Provide the Disclosure Schedule referenced in the Agreement.
9. Clarify whether section 5.3 of the Agreement would require ACFC or Atlantic Coast
Bank to disclose confidential supervisory information or other information the disclosure
of which is prohibited by applicable statute or regulation. If section 5.3 of the Agreement
would require the disclosure of such information, provide a commitment signed by
Ameris stating that Ameris will not seek to enforce section 5.3 of the Agreement with
respect to any confidential supervisory information, and provide a copy of such
commitment to ACFC. 10. Provide updated financials for the period ending December 31, 2017. In your response, please include pro forma capital and asset quality ratios, as well as pro forma estimates for exposure to commercial real estate lending for the combined firm.
Please provide your response within eight business days." We'll have more on this. From Fair Finance Watch's (and Inner City Press') filing with the Fed: "This is a timely first comment opposing and requesting an extension of the FRB's public comment period on the Application by Ameris Bancorp to merge with Atlantic Coast Financial Corporation, and thereby directly acquire shares of Atlantic Coast Bank in Jacksonville, Florida. Fair Finance Watch has reviewed Ameris' lending in 2016, the most recent year for which Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA) data is available, in both the Atlanta and the Jacksonville Metropolitan Statistical Areas (MSAs) and finds both to be disparate. In the Atlanta MSA in 2016 for refinance loans, Ameris denied the applications of African Americans 3.75 times more frequently than those of whites. Ameris made 152 such loans to whites, only 16 to African Americans and only eight to Latinos. In the Atlanta MSA in 2016 for home purchase loans, Ameris denied the applications of African Americans 2.11 times more frequently than those of whites. Ameris made 582 such loans to whites, only 206 to African Americans and only 48to Latinos. In the Jacksonville MSA in 2016 for home purchase loans, Ameris denied the applications of African Americans 2.69 times more frequently than those of whites. Ameris made 203 such loans to whites and only SEVEN to African Americans. In the Jacksonville MSA in 2016 for home improvements loans, Ameris made five such loans to whites and none to African Americans or Latinos. In the Jacksonville MSA in 2016 for refinance loans, Ameris denied the applications of African Americans 2.2 times more frequently than those of whites. Ameris made 100 such loans to whites and only FOUR to African Americans. This is disparate. Fair Finance Watch also reviewed Ameris' home purchase lending in the Tallahassee MSA in 2016: Ameris denied the applications of African Americans 3.78 times more frequently than those of whites. Ameris made 147 such loans to whites and only FIVE to African Americans. Ameris is systemically disparate. Also for the record, and to be addressed at the requested evidentiary hearings: “Georgia bank socking customers with overdraft fees,” Atlanta Journal Constitution, January 3, 2017: “Ameris Bank collected the most overdraft/insufficient fund fees per account of any U.S. bank, says the analysis, which is based on federal government data from the first three quarters of 2016. Ameris collected an average of about $176 per account.. The No. 2 bank on the list of the top 10 collected an average of about $131 per account. The national average was $17.76.”  This is predatory. Ameris gobbled up Jacksonville Bank and now seeks Atlantic Coast. Would branched be consolidated or closed? This must be addressed, including at the requested evidentiary hearings. We note that Ameris is already trying to look beyond this challenged proposal, to try to acquire Hamilton State Bancshares, Inc. and Hamilton State Bank. We also hereby oppose that; the two proposal should be consolidated and hearings held on both. On the current record, Ameris' application should be denied." 

Amid the ongoing scandal of the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency covering upSterling Bank's unreliable Community Reinvestment Act data by withholding most of 400 pages released to Inner City Press under the Freedom of Information the OCC is now trying to strong-arm Inner City Press into scaling back its request to exclude "internal OCC communications." On November 30 the OCC wrote to Inner City Press, "Since the Federal Reserve Board has already submitted its final response to you regarding your FOIA request to them, would you consider modifying your OCC request to receiving: 1) All communications between the OCC and the Bank minus the Federal Reserve Board application transmittal documents; 2) Bank CRA Data; 3) Public Comments received by OCC on the merger application. Please respond to this email if you concur as soon as practicable." Inner City Press replied, "The problem Inner City Press has with this proposed limitation of FOIA request is we don't know what we are waiving - what beyond this that is responsive to our request are you asking us to waive our request to?" Now on December 5, this response: "OCC internal communications." But this is a purpose of FOIA, to see how government actually works, and for who. On December 27, the OCC provided Inner City Press a "final" response with virtually all information about the CRA data redacted. Inner City Press has submitted a FOIA appeal "of the OCC's December 27, 2017 (and any other) Denials of ICP's FOIA Request regarding the application Sterling to acquire Astoria and in particular Sterling's unreliable CRA data and the [OCC's] awareness of this unreliability." This is UNacceptable. The FDIC is primed to take as its leader the lawyer of Fifth Third Bank, Jelena McWilliams. When Fair Finance Watch asked Fifth Third for its Home Mortgage Disclosure Act data, Fifth Third insisted on only giving the data in paper form, unlike nearly all other banks which gave it electronically. The effect was to make it impossible to analyze patterns in the data, the purpose of the HMDA law. Meanwhile the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has become a battlefield. In order to run in Ohio, Richard Cordray stepped down at the head of the CFPB, naming as his successor Leandra English. Hours later, Trump issued a statement that "he is designating Director of the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) Mick Mulvaney as Acting Director of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB)." On November 25 the White House held a background press call, on which opposition to the naming of Mulvaney was characterized coming from "blog-posts." Still, the Senior Administration Officials were asked if they plan to have Leandra English removed from the premises. No, was the answer: she should show up at the Deputy. But have they spoken with Ms English? No, was the answer.  On Sunday English filed suit against Mulvany "in his capacity as the person claiming to be the acting director of the CFPB." But a preliminary injunction has been denied. Watch this site. After non-response by the OCC even has it promises merger approvals to banks with Needs to Improve CRA ratings and allows Bank of Tokyo - Mitsubishi to skirt North Korea sanctions review by fast approving applications for which effective public notice was never provided (ICP scoop on notice here),Already, the low percentage of banks being given less than satisfactory Community Reinvestment Act rating has become infinitesimal. Now the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency has signaled that even those few low scores will have no impact. In a "Policy and Procedures Manual" quietly issued on November 8, with no notice or comment, the OCC says "An overall less than satisfactory CRA rating is not a bar to approval of an application. Rather, the facts and
circumstances of the application must be evaluated as discussed in this PPM." (PPM 6300-2). All of this under an "Acting" Comptroller who has overstayed his term. We'll have more on this- and this: Sseven months after Wells Fargo Bank's CRA rating was dropped two levels to "Needs to Improve," barring it from acquisitions, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency has quietly said, in a footnote to a Bulletin issued on October 12, that "The OCC’s policy is not to lower a bank’s CRA composite or component rating by more than one rating level." See here, footnote 8. So when did this become the OCC's policy, after it dropped Wells by two levels? Call it a stealth sop to Wells Fargo - and seemingly a violation of the Administrative Procedures Act. We'll have more on this. In July it emerged that over 800,000 people who took car loans from Wells were charged for needless auto insurance, pushing 274,000 Wells Fargo customers into delinquency and triggering nearly 25,000 wrongful vehicle repossessions. So much for the industry having cleaned itself up after the predatory lending meltdown. New York City announced it will not enter any new relationships with the bank, also suspending Wells Fargo's role as a senior book-running manager for NYC General Obligation and Transactional Finance Authority bond sales. A statement by Mayor Bill de Blasio and Controller Scott Stringer noted that "Currently, Wells Fargo holds contracts with the City to provide banking services, including to operate 'Lock Box' services that hold taxes and fees collected by the City. There is approximately $227 million of City dollars held in Wells Fargo accounts." But will they get involved in opposing Sterling National Bank, which Inner City Press and Fair Finance Watch have exposed as having "unreliable" CRA data, notwithstanding the OCC's scam "Satisfactory" rating on May 30? Click here. 

In UN Library Inner City Press Is Ordered to Leave Jane's Defence Oil Event It Registered For


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 6 –  The UN Library advertised and hosted a presentative by Jane's Defence Industry Solutions IHS Markit on June 6 at 11 am. Inner City Press registered, clicking the box "Media Representative," and got an email confirming it was registered. It went to the UN Library's Room L-133 at 11:02 am only to hear, from the podium, that is was "Chatham House Rules," that what was said could be reported but not attributed. Strangely, someone was being allowed to film the event, with assurances not to show the audience. The presentation ranged from oil blocks being offered in Southern Lebanon to losses of Turkey and Saudi Arabia. Inner City Press was typing a tweet with a quote, without attibribution, when it was tapped on the shoulder. "You can't do that," an officious man who will remain unnamed said. Inner City Press countered that it had registered and was obeying Chatham House Rules, and that the man should not be reading Inner City Press' laptop over its shoulder. "You'll have to leave," an equally officious woman came to say. Inner City Press voluntarily left, despite having registered as media and following the stated rules. What is wrong with today's UN? We'll have more on this.  The UN which earlier this year hosted advertisements for rocket launchers and tanks on June 5 was asked about a display in its lobby for Jane’s Defence Industry Solutions complete with fighter jet, American flag and photo of the Chinese Army. The spokesman for Antonio Guterres the UN Secretary General, Stephane Dujarric, said he hadn't seen the display just one story below his office. Inner City Press asked, UN transcript here: Dujarric: Let me look close to the screens as I go downstairs, and I'll try to answer and find… to your question.  Mr. Lee?
Inner City Press:  I can't resist.  I have some other things, but --
Spokesman:  When have you ever resisted?
[Note: As Dujarric has been informed, Inner City Press *has* resisted for more than a month the entirely legal live-streaming from the New York City sidewalk of UN Sec-Gen Antonio Guterres' $60 million mansion, first streamed by Inner City Press with its lights ablaze as Guterres told others to turn their lights off. A self styled intermediary said these streams caused security issues, so Inner City Press has “resisted” live streaming for more than a month. But not change, still restricted. It was just a pretext?]
 The June 5 transcript continued: Inner City Press: In light of the tank and other military equipment that was advertised in the 1B area of the UN, this was late… said to be about… only about a Member State, I guess I… I just wonder, in this case, these days there are the signs up saying that the UN is not in any way endorsing any Member State thing.  This is… would you acknowledge… even before you look into this, are the ads that are next to the… next to the café that talk about these library meetings with publications, these are endorsements.  I mean, these are…
Spokesman:  I'm not going to acknowledge anything until I see it.
Inner City Press: All right, but when you do see it… can we watch you see it?

Spokesman:  When I see it, I'll tell you.” Seven hours later, nothing - and the ad still up. Watch this site.

On UN Bribery Indictee Ho of CEFC, Czech Reply to ICP, Same From UN Spox, As Zeman Keep Ye Jianming


By Matthew Russell Lee, Video, Q&A, HK here

UNITED NATIONS, June 5 – Four months after the arrest for UN bribery of Patrick Ho, the head of China Energy Fund Committee full funded by CEFC China Energy, his ultimate boss at CEFC Ye Jianming was brought in for questioning in China.  On May 17, Ho was denied bail in a proceeding in which the UN was described as corrupted, and Ho's emails offering bribes to the foundation of UN President of the General Assembly Sam Kutesa were made part of the judge's order. Post-hearing Periscope video here. Inner City Press' reporting that day, as before, included the non-response since November 2017 of the UN Mission the the Czech Republic, which holds the presidency of the UN ECOSOC to which CEFC continues to hold consultative status, while CEFC's Ye Jianming was and remains an adviser to Czech President Zeman. Even as the Mission in New York refused to answer, on for example 28 November 2017 and 6 February 2018, Inner City Press' reporting has been picked up in the Czech Republic, on 12 January 2018 here, then on 28 May 2018 here. On June 4, a belated response from the Czech Mission to the UN, published by Inner City Press in full below along with the Press' follow up questions on June 4, still not answered as of 4 pm on June 5. Inner City Press is also informed that Marie Chatardova has reached out with the same answer to the Czech Press Agency; some say she is under consideration by Zeman to become the country's foreign minister and that this Press question unresponded to by the Czech Mission since November could be a problem. Suddenly on June 5, Antonio Guterres' spokesman Stephane Dujarric read out an answer (he rushed off the podium so follow up question have not yet been possible). Video here. He emailed the answer to Inner City Press, which he usually does not do, seemingly in this case an invitation to be sure to publish in full what he read. Here it is: "The procedure for withdrawal of consultative status, as per para 56 of ECOSOC resolution 1996/31, is the following:

A member State has to make a complaint against an organization at the NGO Committee (it does not need to be a member of the Committee nor a member of ECOSOC) through a letter addressed to the Chair of the NGO Committee;

The NGO Committee reviews the complaint and the NGO concerned is informed of the complaint in writing and is asked to present its response for consideration by the NGO Committee.

In plain English, this means that these initiatives and decisions are within the sole purview of the Member States.  They are the ones deciding on whether or not to make a complaint to the NGO Committee, and they are the ones making the ultimate decision in the NGO Committee and then ECOSOC on any change in the consultative status of an organization.

The President of ECOSOC is not personally involved in any step of this procedure." Inner City Press asks, overall, doesn't a president of ECOSOC have an interested and duty in ensuring that indicted bribers don't remain in status?  Has anything precluded 
Marie Chatardova for the Czech Republic asking for the needed action? To Dujarric and his deputy, Inner City Press has put these follow up questions and will report response (or non response) - "Did this note come from (Secretariat's) Paul Simon, to whom I've previously sent questions [or] from the the Czech Mission to the Mission, which belatedly responded to Inner City Press' Nov 2017 and Feb 2018 questions last night?  And, what would be the Secretary General's (Office's) response to a statement that the failure in the China Energy Fund Committee / Patrick Ho case to commission and release an OIOS audit as was done in the South South News / Ng Lap Seng case makes it much less likely that the steps set out in the note will take place, and make it more likely that such an NGO, allegedly involved in bribery including of a UN PGA, remains in consultative status to UN ECOSOC?" Here is what the Czech mission belatedly sent, followed by Inner City Press' June 4 follow up questions not answered or even acknowledged as of 4 pm on June 5. "Dear Mr. Matthew Russel Lee,
       Allow me to contact you in my capacity as a  diplomat responsible at the Permanent Mission of the Czech Republic to the United Nations for contacts with media. I take this opportunity  to refer to your latest articles in Inner City Press issued  on 2 May 2018 and 28 May 2018 respectively, namely to the part concerning H.E. Ms. Marie Chatardova and her role as President of the ECOSOC repeatedly mentioned by you.
(See:  http://www.innercitypress.com/unbribery1hobeltroad050218.html

http://www.innercitypress.com/unbribery5hojeremic052818.html
Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC) is composed of 54 Member States, elected for a period of three years. ECOSOC plays a coordinating role to as many as 29 subsidiary bodies covering very fast field of activities. One of these subsidiary bodies is Committee on Non-Governmental organizations. This Committee is composed of 19 Member States elected on the principal of geographical distribution for a period of 4 years. (The Czech Republic is not currently member of this Committee.)
At present day, 5.083 non-governmental organizations obtained this statute.The question of the Suspension and withdrawal of the consultative statute is covered by Part VII (Articles 55 -59) of the ECOSOC Resolution 1996/31 as follows:
"55. Organizations granted consultative status by the Council and those on the Roster shall conform at all times to the principles governing the establishment and nature of their consultative relations with the Council. In periodically reviewing the activities of non-governmental organizations on the basis of the reports submitted under paragraph 61 (c) below and other relevant information, the Council Committee on Non-Governmental Organizations shall determine the extent to which the organizations have complied with the principles governing consultative status and have contributed to the work of the Council, and may recommend to the Council suspension of or exclusion from consultative status of organizations that have not met the requirements for consultative status as set forth in the present resolution."
"56. In cases where the Committee on Non-Governmental Organizations has decided to recommend that the general or special consultative status of a non-governmental organization or its listing on the Roster be suspended or withdrawn, the non-governmental organization concerned shall be given written reasons for that decision and shall have an opportunity to present its response for appropriate consideration by the Committee as expeditiously as possible."
"58. The consultative status of organizations in general consultative status and special consultative status and the listing of those on the Roster shall be suspended or withdrawn by the decision of the Economic and Social Council on the recommendation of its Committee on Non-Governmental Organizations."
(Note:  By the decision of the ECOSOC´s Member States, not by the decision of ECOSOC´s President.)
        It is thus obvious that the President of the ECOSOC, according to the valid rules, has no competence to start the procedure of the suspension and removal of the already granted consultative statute of the given NGO.
        I hope you will find this explanation useful and we will really appreciate if you stop to disseminate incorrect information and speculations on this topic.
        Best regards,
Karel Komárek, Minister-Counsellor
Permanent Mission of the Czech Republic
to the United Nations
1109 -1111 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10028." So "Organizations granted consultative status by the Council and those on the Roster shall conform at all times to the principles governing the establishment and nature of their consultative relations with the Council." Doesn't being indicted for using the access to the UN to bribe the President of the GA - Sam Kutesa and, it seems, Vuk Jeremic - violate the principles? And doesn't the president of ECOSOC, even if her president has the head of the bribing group as an adviser, have standing to raise this issue? Soon after receiving the above, Inner City Press on June 4 send these follow up questions: "
 Given that China Energy Fund Committee's Patrick Ho has been indicted for, and remains incarcerated for, allegedly bribing PGA Kutesa, does not “comform... to the principles governing the establishment and nature of their consultative relations with the Council”? If not, are you arguing that the President of ECOSOC has not power to raise and pursue this issue which to some makes a mockery of ECOSOC under her presidency? Given Czech President Zeman's relationship with Ye Jianming, isn't it imperative that Zeman's Ambassador, while heading UN ECOSOC, respond to this indictment of Jianming's ECOSOC adviser for bribery? Has she sought any legal or ethical advice in this regard? From whom? Does a President of ECOSOC not have responsibility for what happens with / in ECOSOC under her or his presidency?" No answer yet. Watch this site. Back on May 18, Inner City Press asked UN spokesman Farhan Haq about it, video here, UN transcript here: and below. Now on May 28, with UN Secretary General still not having even started an audit, the scope of the China Energy Fund Committee / Ye Jianming / Patrick Ho scandal expands again as to the UN. Yet another President of the UN General Assembly, Vuk Jeremic, is reported have received his funding from Ho, Ye Jinming and CEFC, click here for example, citing Inner City Press and its questions to "Farhan Haku," and reporting that "Ho was one of Jermic's main financiers and that he had transferred 4.3 million euros to Jeremic's organization and his private company." We'll have more on this. From the May 18 UN transcript: Inner City Press:  Yesterday, there was a court hearing down in the Southern District of New York where Patrick Ho was applying once again…  of the China Energy Fund Committee (CEFC) was applying again for bail. He was denied, but I'm asking you this, because in the court hearing, it was said, these were two direct quotes.  One quote was that he's charged with "corrupting the UN", and second quote is "many people at the UN were involved".  So it made me wonder, and I looked around the courtroom, whether the UN is already following this case?  I'm aware that there has yet…  at least my understanding is there's no audit yet.  Is OLA (Office of Legal Affairs)…  do they have somebody there?  Are they ringing up fees, would be one way to put it, but what's your response to these statements in court?

Deputy Spokesman:  We're monitoring this case and, as you know, we've been cooperating with the US legal authorities concerning this overall case.

Inner City Press:  In this case…  in this case…  I know that in the previous case documents were provided and $302,000 were paid as legal fees back to the UN.  In the case of Patrick Ho and CEFC, have documents been provided to the prosecution?

Deputy Spokesman:  We're cooperating as needed with the authorities." And charging?  China Energy Fund Committee, the bribery vehicle, is still in special consultative status with UN ECOSOC. Oft-traveling Secretary General Antonio Guterres has not even ordered an audit (though he keeps restrictions on Inner City Press which covered the Ng Lap Seng and now Patrick Ho UN bribery scandals. The UN is a corrupted institution. In court on May 17, Ho's lawyer 
Andrew Levander argued that now China is cutting "the energy company" CEFC China Energy no slack. Prosecutor Douglas Zolkind on the other hand emphasized that the energy company has now essentially been taken over the Chinese government, which he also said controls Hong Kong's decisions to extradite or not. Judge Katherine Forrest noted that the energy company is paying Ho's legal fees and said its motives could not be known. She read into the record not only the Kutesa emails in Paragraph 40 of the complaint but also those about Chad's president Deby in Paragraphs 24 and 26. It was said the case "involves many people at the UN." We'll have more on this. On May 15 the prosecution detailed how the bribes were paid, as part of responding to Ho's motion to dismissed. The funds to Kutesa when from HSBC in Hong Kong to Deutsche Bank in New York to Stanbic in Uganda. The funding to Gadio, in two tranches, when from HSBC in Hong Kong to HSBC in New York to Mashreq Bank in New York to Mashreq Bank in Dubai. On May 17 Ho should hear a ruling on his re-request for bail. At the UN, which has yet to even order an audit while Ho's China Energy Fund Committee is still in special consultative status with UN ECOSOC, Inner City Press asked if the UN hopes to get awarded attorneys fees like it did, to the tune of $302,000, in the case of Ng Lap Seng, with the same prosecutors. The UN declined to comment - it remains UNreformed. Watch this site. On May 2, Patrick Ho and five lawyers argued for more than an hour to try to get bail granted - it was not. Judge Katherine Forrest noted that even if Ho's motions to dismiss some counts, and to suppress evidence collected with his iPad password, are in fact granted, the case will still proceed. She asked his lawyers to research whether the equity in his mother's home in Hong Kong could be transferred to a bank in the United States. Ho's lawyerAndrew Levander quoted him that this is a case not only against Ho, but also against CEFC and China it its "One Belt, One Road." The prosecution's Douglas Zolkind recounted how Ho inside the UN worked with former Senegal foreign minister Gadio to bribe Chadian president Deby, who "laughingly" referred to Brazilian bribes for another oil concession. Ho's lawyers analogized him to Jeff Bezos of Amazon and to Donald J. Trump. He will be back in court in a forthnight on May 17 at 3 pm - and so will we. Post hearing Periscope video here. 


Management and day to day operations of CEFC have reportedly been taken over by the Shanghai city government's investment arm, Shanghai Guosheng Group Company. At the UN, Inner City Press asked if this meant that its fundee could not longer be in special consultative status to UN ECOSOC; this has not been answered. Inner City Press made this connection: the president of ECOSOC is Marie Chatardová, Permanent Representative of the Czech Republic to the UN. Her president, in Prague Castle, is Miloš Zeman -- who, like Uganda's Foreign Minister Sam Kutesa when he was UN President of the General Assembly, made 
Ye Jianming an official adviser. (Inner City Press' CEFC investigative covered has been picked up in the Czech media, for example here.) Amazingly, UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres has yet to even order an audit, which his predecessor Ban Ki-moon did in the case resulting in a 48 month sentence for Ng Lap Seng (while also evicted Inner City Press for pursuing the story; Guterres and his Global Communicator Alison Smale continue the restrictions). Watch this site.

New UN PGA Ecuador FM Tells Inner City Press of Anti Tax Haven Law, ICP Asks of FOIA


By Matthew Russell Lee, Photo

UNITED NATIONS, June 5 – In a contested election to be the next UN General Assembly President, Ecuador's Foreign Minister Maria Fernanda Espinosa Garces beat out Honduras' Permanent Representative Mary Elizabeth Flores Flake, 128 to 62. Afterward at a media encounter, Inner City Press asked the winner, in light of the involvement of two and now apparently three recent PGAs in UN bribery cases, if she will support a UN Freedom of Information Act so that the public and press can assess influences by businesses and even purported NGOs like China Energy Fund Committee. She replied that in Ecuador, she made financial disclosures including under a government prohibition against using tax havens, and she will commit to transparency as PGA. Some of these things, particularly a FOIA, should be made madatory through resolutions. But we will see. Watch this site. Even before the results were announced, UN Protocol carried out of the GA Hall the un-needed flag of Honduras. Inner City Press Periscope here. Some said that Honduras' move of embassy to Jerusalem was not helpful to its candidate; others pointed at the debate or interactive dialogue. We'll have more on this - back on April 19 Inner City Press asked Colombia's foreign minister María Ángela Holguín Cuéllar who her countries would vote for in the UN President of the General Assembly race, Honduras or Ecuador (Honduras was the answer). Video here.  Back in April 2017 Inner City Press has asked Colombia's Ambassador and High Commissioner for Peace about it, and on 19 April 2017 asked the country's foreign minister María Ángela Holguín Cuéllar about the upcoming Council visit which Inner City Press timely requested to accompany and cover. Video of María Ángela Holguín Cuéllar Q&Ahere, in Spanish. Meanwhile after Colombia's former President Uribe met Donald Trump at Mar-a-Lago, Florida Senator Marco Rubio denied having anything to do with it, while noting that Uribe is a sitting Senator. On April 24, even ghoulishly accompanied and watched by a UN Department of Public Information minder, Inner City Press was told that the meeting happened because Uribe was invited by a Mar-a-Lago member. Access is everything, as the UN tries to use and abuse with regard to the investigative Press. Back on April 19, Holguin said she had met with the Permanent Five members and the others at a lunch; another Ambassador told Inner City Press of the need to check if paramilitaries are "filling in" the spaced vacated by the FARC. Then on April 20 from the office of the UN's holdover spokesman Stephane Dujarric came this form letter, "We regret to inform you that due to logistical constraints, we are not able to accommodate your request to travel with the Security Council during their visit to Colombia." This stands in contrast to Inner City Press covering Council trips to Darfur and South Sudan, Kenya, Djibouti and Cote d'Ivoire, and a Ban Ki-moon (ghoulish) trip to Sri Lanka. Since then, though, Dujarric and the UN Department of Public Information have evicted Inner City Press from its office for covering UN corruption, and still have it confined to minders and without an office, fourteen months later. This must be reversed. We'll have more on all this. 
Colombia's High Commissioner for Peace Sergio Jaramillo spoke with the Press in New York on August 19, 2016, in the run-up to the August 26 UN Security Council meeting about Colombia. In the sit-down portion, Inner City Press asked him about criticism of the accountability provisions in the government's deal with the FARC, and of the status of talks with the ELN.

   Jaramillo said the criticism is unrealistic; they had to negotiated with the FARC, and got them to agree to trials for grave crimes like rape and other war crimes. But others get softer treatment. Jaramillo said implementation will be the key.

   Jaramillo said FARC has agreed, no illicit activity to fund their organization. The UN mission would be storing weapons in containers, as it did for example in Nepal. But would it have any drug or illicit activity role?

  On the ELN, Jaramillo said as long as they hold hostages, talks cannot proceed.

 On January 6, 2017, Inner City Press asked the UN's holdover spokesman Staphan Dujarric, vidoe here, UN Transcript here:

Inner City Press: Wanted to ask about the mission in Colombia.  Obviously, it's been reported that the four people have been taken.  Were they members of national contingents, or were they UN staff members?  Often in these cases we were told, like, there's due process or whatever.  Is the video evidence so compelling that…

Spokesman:  They were repatriated by their home countries.

Inner City Press:  What countries do they come from?

Spokesman:  I don't have those.

Inner City Press:  And was a decision made by the UN or by the troop-contributing country?

Spokesman:  There was a discussion between the UN Mission and the countries… and the countries concerned.  We can try to see if we can get you the list of the countries impacted.

  Eight hours later, nothing. And if it's wrong for observers to dance with rebels, why is it OK for "UN Correspondents" to take selfies with the new SG? We'll have more on this.

 On August 26, 2016, just before the Colombia meeting of the UN Security Council, UK Deputy Ambassador Peter Wilson took questions about the Council's role:

UK DPR Wilson: "This is a piece of extremely good news. It is a historic peace agreement. We are no looking forward to hearing from the SRSG about how the two parties want the UN to help take this peace agreement forward and help take implementation forward. We will then consider very carefully as a Council our next steps.

Q: Have you read the report by the Secretary-General? There’s a part that’s particularly interesting for us in Colombia, which is that we don’t know exactly who’s going to pay for the whole mission – between the mission, the guerrillas, and the government.

UK DPR Wilson: Well, I think that’s one of the issues that we are very much encouraging the UN to take forward with the Colombian government. I think overall the atmosphere in the Council on this is extremely happy to see this very good piece of news, and I think these are the kinds of details that we will want to be settling in a very cooperative matter.

Q: There’s also a possibility of it being signed here at the UN, because of the timings actually. It’s going to be towards the end of September. What do you think?

UK DPR Wilson: I think all of those things; those are things that we really want to take forward with the Government of Colombia in a way that satisfies the parties. So, it is they that we will be listening to most closely.

   Colombia's President Santos will speak at the UN General Assembly on September 21; there may be an event for bankers or investment bankers. Watch this site.

On Colombia back on March 11, even with the deadline for an agreement between the government and the FARC being pushed back, Germany's Special Envoy on Colombia Tom Koenigs spoke with the Press.

He had, he said, met with UN Under Secretaries General Feltman, Mulet, Ladsous and Khare, about the upcoming UN mission to be headed by Frenchman Jean Arnault. He noted the history of cultural exchange between Germany and Colombia," saying that "Germans read a lot of Garcia Marquez."

And now another German, Horst Kohler, stands poised to take the envoy position in one of the Council's failures, Western Sahara...

For Cyprus Envoy As Lute Awaits Turkish OK Guterres Tried Guehenno But Rejected, ICP Asks


By Matthew Russell Lee, Patreon


UNITED NATIONS, June 4 – After the Cyprus talks collapsed at Crans Montana in Switzerland back in early July 2017, on August 3 Inner City Press asked the UN when its Special Adviser Espen Barth Eide was quitting. It happened on August 15; he has still not been replaced as of May 25. Now Inner City Press can report that as UN interim special envoy Jane Holl Lute has still not been approved by Turkey - and that previously Antonio Guterres tried to give the job to French former head of UN Peacekeeping Jean-Marie Guehenno, recently out of a job with the Crisis Group. Guehenno was rejected, on EU grounds that will also limit any ongoing envoy. On June 1 Inner City Press asked UN Security Council president Nebenzia, here, which got picked up without direct attribution by the Cyprus Mail, here. On June 4, Inner City Press asked Guterres' spokesman Stephane Dujarric, UN transcript here: Inner City Press: On Cyprus, the… the President of the Security Council, Ambassador [Vassily] Nebenzia, said on Friday, when I asked him about Cyprus, that he didn't think that this even interim envoy would move forward until some political events took place, which I took to mean elections in Turkey.  And I wanted to ask you point-blank, I guess, because there was… basically, Jane Holl Lute was welcomed by one side, and then you said, we have nothing to announce.  Can you just give us sort of a sense of what's led to the…

Spokesman:  It's… you know, its a case of people speculating without any official announcement from our part.  We… you know, we will announce what we need to announce when we feel the situation is ready.  And I'm not… you know, Cyprus, as most of the issues we deal with, are delicate and complex.  And I'm not going to try to look into the future, say when… if and when we're going to announce it.
Inner City Press: What about a quick look into the past, not on speculation, but just to understand how things work?  It's my understanding that… that the Secretary-General tried to send Mr.  [Jean-Marie] Guéhenno to Cyprus as an envoy, and he was rejected on the grounds that he's an EU [European Union] member.  And I wanted to know, is it true… does the UN accept that one of the parties of interest in the Cyprus matter now determines that… that EU members can't be envoys?

Spokesman:  Listen, I'm not going to get into whatever discussions may be had, but it's an obvious answer that the UN will not propose an envoy or a mediator or a negotiator between parties if both parties don't agree to that person.  But on Mr. Guéhenno, I have no specific comment.

Inner City Press: I mean, is there a situation in which a party could announce a… a… a systematic banning of all… of a certain category from a continent or…

Spokesman:  Every case is looked at." Really? Guterres is to meet with Guehenno on June 4, still in accurately listed as CEO of the International Crisis Group... The interim Cyprus job would only be to talk to the Cypriot, Greek Cypriot and the guarantors; for the more permanent post, if necessary, it seems no national of a P5 country, or even of the EU, could be selected. So... a diplomat from Latin America, Africa or Asia? Guterres recently sent Bathily to Madascagar, another failed mediation. The UN is getting lower each day. Here is the May 8 video: Inner City Press asked Guterres' spokesman Dujarric to confirm that Jane Holl Lute is Guterres' interim envoy on Cyprus. Dujarric refused. [Later, the transcript became available, here: Inner City Press: I wanted to ask you, on Cyprus, I'd asked you before — or maybe it was Farhan [Haq] — to confirm that Jane Holl Lute was named as interim envoy; it seems to be the case.

Spokesman:  No.  That's not the case.
Inner City Press:  There is no interim… there's no one reaching out…?

Spokesman:  I have no announcement to share with you.
Inner City Press: The… the… the Foreign Minister of Cyprus has… has thanked the Secretary-General for naming an interim official.  So who is that interim official?

Spokesman:  I don't have any announcement for you at this point.  Yes, sir?

Inner City Press:  That's kind of un-transparent.

Spokesman:  It's not un-transparent.  When we're ready to announce something, we're ready to announce.  People from… in 193 Member States often announce things for us.  When we are ready to announce it, we will announce it.] On May 4, Inner City Press asked UN spokesman Farhan Haq, UN transcript here: Inner City Press:  A spokesperson for the Turkish foreign ministry, Hami Aksoy, has said:  "It is not possible to reach a federal solution with the Greek Cypriots' mindset.  We believe it is time to try a new way."  So, this is setting off waves, saying that essentially that Turkey is saying that the former framework for dealing with this may be thrown out the window.  Is there a response from the UN? And people there continue to say that Jane Holl Lute is this temporary envoy.  Is that something that you continue to deny?

Deputy Spokesman:  There's nothing to announce about any visits and, like I said a few days ago, there's certainly no appointment of a special envoy to announce.  Regarding these quotes, we're not going to respond to all of the rhetoric from different officials, but what we have made clear is the need for the parties to come back to the table, and we're trying to see what can be done to bring them back." On May 2, Inner City Press asked the UN to confirm or deny reports that Jane Holl Lute is becoming interim envoy - the UN refused to confirm. From the UN's May 2 transcript: Inner City Press:  there have been a number of reports saying the Secretary-General has made Jane Holl Lute a sort of a temporary or interim envoy on Cyprus.  Can you address that?  I know, also, in her other role that she has for the UN… you know, she has a number of other… of outside… some business and board… corporate board service.  Has this been vetted?

Deputy Spokesman:  At this point, all I can really say on that is that there are currently no plans to appoint a Special Adviser of the Secretary-General on Cyprus.  Upon the closing of the Conference on Cyprus last year, the Secretary-General encouraged all parties to reflect in order to determine whether the conditions would mature again for a meaningful process in the near future.  The UN is in contact with the parties to determine a way to seek the outcomes of their reflections and their views on the way forward.  Yes?

Inner City Press:  But on Jane Holl Lute, nothing?

Deputy Spokesman:  That's what I have for now.  I’ve got no further thing to announce." And he closed his Office five hours later with nothing. From the UN's April 17 transcript: Inner City Press: I want to be sure to ask you something on Cyprus, just to understand better.  There's a story in the Cyprus Mail that says, "Rosemary DiCarlo has the most likely chance of becoming the next personal envoy of UN Secretary-General António Guterres in Cyprus"… or “on Cyprus”, I guess that would be.  And I just wanted to know, is it even possible that one could be Under-Secretary-General of Political Affairs and also a… an envoy on a specific topic?  And when does she begin?

Spokesman:  As you know, we announce new appointments when we're ready to announce them so that there's… wherever we are in the world, there's a wonderful game of speculating what the Secretary-General will do until there's an announcement.  As… in theory, anything is possible.  But, obviously, we're not in a position to talk about an announcement.
Inner City Press:  But isn't it a job that takes…?

Spokesman:  There was a discussion yesterday with the two… in Cyprus where the two leaders had a frank and open exchange of views during their two-hour tête-à-tête discussion, which was facilitated by the UN.  This was the first time the two leaders met since the conclusion of the Conference on Cyprus in Crans-Montana in July of last year.  Both sides have made it clear that the meeting did not mark the resumption of the negotiations.  But, obviously, as we've always said, the Secretary-General's good offices remain at the disposal of both parties.

Inner City Press:  And when does Rosemary DiCarlo start?

Spokesman:  1 May, I believe." We'll see. The UN wouldn't even give a read out of UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres' meeting with Cyprus' foreign minister Christodoulides in Rome, despite Cyprus statements about it being constructive and productive. The UN calls it short and not worthy of a read-out. Video here. 

As Citigroup Brags At UN About Renewables Inner City Press Asks of Dakota Access Pipeline


By Matthew Russell Lee, Video

UNITED NATIONS, June 4 – When Citigroup managing director Michael Eckhart appeared at the UN on June 4, it was to talk about renewable energy with the UN Environment Program. Inner City Press asked Eckhart about Citigroup's role in the Dakota Access Pipeline. 

He paused and admitted it was a lender, than said that the outcry against the pipeline, on indigenous human rights and other issues, was entirely unexpected. He said they had not protested early enough. Video here. But what about free prior informed CONSENT? Is silence consent? Or, as is too often the case, is the UN a place of hypocrisy? 

As Inner City Press has shown, UNEP paid money to Volvo Ocean Races, and appears to have engaged in pay-for-prize with MoBikes. Inner City Press also asked about the UN bribery scandal in which China Energy Fund Committee - oil money - bribed UN President of the General Assembly Sam Kutesa, but CEFC remains in special consultative status with UN ECOSOC. Video here. We'll have more on this - and on Citigroup. Watch this site.

Censorship in Vietnam As Mai Khoi Is Cut Off TV Is Echoed In UN's Eviction of Critics In Favor of State Media


By Matthew Russell Lee, Photos, Periscope

UNITED NATIONS, June 3 – In Vietnam,  activist Do Nguyen Mai Khoi was being shown on television receiving a Creative Dissent award when the government abruptly cut it off. Video here. “This confirms that it is official government policy to ban me from appearing in media. The aim of this policy is to erase me from public consciousness and isolate me,” Mai Khoi told HRF. This ham-handed censorship is echoed at the UN, where for example the UN Department of Public Information had critical Inner City Press evicted for pursuing the story of the UN bribery by Chinese businessman Ng Lap Seng and has ever since confined it to minders. Meanwhile Viet Nam News Agency which rarely if ever asks the UN any questions continues in its office, with full access to the building it doesn't use, like the Egyptian state media Akbhar al Yom to which the UN has purported to assign Inner City Press' work space. Following the "election" of Abdel Fattah El-Sisi as Egypt's president with 97% of the vote amid fining of media like Al-Masry Al-Youm and the expulsion of journalists, the spokesman for UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres on April 2 said, "We were not involved in the holding of the election, whether in observing or offering technical assistance as far as I know.  So, I will leave it at that." This is the same UN - and spokesman - which evicted independent Inner City Press and put in its work place Sissi's state media Akhbar al-Youm, in the form of Sanaa Youssef a former (1984) president of the UN Correspondents Association who hasn't asked a single question of the UN in more than ten years. Now the government behind that media has grabbed up Hazem Abdel-Azim, a critic since the government since he left Sissi’s campaign in the 2014 elections. Hazem Abdel-Azim was taken from his home in a Cairo suburb late Saturday on charges of disseminating fake news (!) and belonging to an outlawed group. This follows the detention of noted blogger Wael Abbas. Abbas was seized on accusations including disseminating false news and joining an outlawed group. He was taken blindfoldedfrom his home to an unknown location and not allowed to contact his lawyer. His YouTube channel was shut in 2007, resulting in the removal of hundreds of videos depicting abuses by security forces. In December, he posted on Facebook that Twitter had suspended his account without providing any justification.
Last week they arrested labor rights lawyer 
Haytham Mohamedeen for "belonging to an outlawed group." (In the UN, the Department of Public Information before evicting Inner City Press told it it would be ousted if it did not remove the sign of the Free UN Coalition for Access from the door of its past (and future?) office S-303, even as the neighboring door carried and carries Turkish government paraphernalia. That threat, from DPI's holdover Hua Jiang, cc-ed to holdover spokesman Stephane Dujarric, is here). In 2016, Mohamedeen was arrested and later released over calling for protests against Egypt's transfer of two strategic Red Sea islands to Saudi Arabia. (When Inner City Press asked Guterres' spokesman on May 23 about Saudi detaining women's right activist, he spoke vaguely about space for civil society.) Apparently Sisi's Egypt is as much for sale as the UN, to Ng Lap Seng and more recently Patrick Ho and their mutual controller. An independent jury for a UNESCO prize awarded it to jailed Egyptian photo journalist Mahmoud Abu Zeid a/k/a Shawkan, about whom Inner City Press asked Amnesty International at the UN this month. The Egyptian government, needless to say, has criticized the award. This is the Sisi government to which Guterres sends his warm regards, and to whose state media Akhbar al Yom's Sanaa Youssef Guterres and his Global Communicator Alison Smale have purported to assign Inner City Press' long time work space in the UN. UNCA, the only claim to UN fame of Sanaa Youssef, has said nothing, bungling forward this April 23 with a 5 pm wine event for a novel seemingly entirely unrelated to the UN by
Elizabeth Strout, "at the event marking 'UN English Language Day', Ms. Strout will be joined by fiction writer Katherine Vaz and poet, Major Jackson... with a with a [sic] wine and cheese reception beginning at 5:00 pm." Then on April 24, ghoulishly an event in their clubhouse for a movement the UN's exclusionof which from the public UNSC stakeout UNCA, heavy with Moroccan state media, said nothing. We'll have more on this. On April 4, again with Akhbar al Youm's Saana Youssef nowhere in sight much less asking a question after a decade, Inner City Press asked UN spokesman Dujarric, UN transcript here: Inner City Press: when you were asked about the 97 per cent election of President Sisi, you said, 'We were not involved in the holding of the election, whether in observing or technical assistance.  So, I'll leave it at that.' I wanted to ask you, since then, one, a newspaper, Al-Masry Al-Youm, has been fined for its independent coverage of the election.  And now a website, Masr al-Arabia, has been raided by the Government.  So, beyond your… what you said on Monday, do you believe that… that… that… that the way in which the press was disallowed from covering this cake-walk election complies with the principles of António Guterres and his open-press ways?

Spokesman:  I think the Secretary-General, in the run-up to the election, had expressed his concern at the limited political space in the country, and that is a concern we continue to have." Really. On April 5 it emerged that Egyptian prosecutors ordered the editor-in-chief of 
Masr al-Arabia, Adel Sabry, be detained for 15 days pending investigations. A prosecutor in Cairo’s Dokki district accused Sabry of belonging to a terrorist group, publishing false news, using text and visuals that contradict the constitution, and inciting demonstrations, according to Eman Hamed, the defendant’s lawyer. This is what today's UN is siding with, in the form of former UNCA President Sanaa Youssef of Egyptian state media. Back on February 28 when Guterres met Egypt's new Ambassador Mohamed Fathi Ahmed Edrees on February 28, Inner City Press went through the UN's tourist entrance and then UN Security on the 37th floor to cover it. Still, before Guterres expressed his warm regards for Sisi, who is arresting all opponents, the UN Security officer who has already checked Inner City Press' microphone told it it could not record audio, see below. Now on March 8, Inner City Press asked Guterres' spokesman Stephane Dujarric about Sisi's government seeking the death penalty against photo journalist Shawkan, as relates to Guterres warm regards. From the UN transcript: Inner City Press:  it was pretty… pretty recently that the Secretary-General sent his very, very warm regards to President [Abdelfattah al] Sisi of Egypt, and so, in that re… in that connection, I wanted to ask you, the noted photographer, Mahmoud Abou Zeid, also known as Shawkan, has now been informed that he faces the death penalty.  He's been in jail for four and a half years.  It's kind of a cause célèbre.  And I wondered if the Secretary-General, who has these warm feelings, is this something he might have a comment on, a photojournalist being… facing the death by hanging? Spokesman:  I will check on that particular case.  The Secretary-General stands firmly against the death penalty.  And as for questions of the ongoing climate in Egypt, I think I answered that to Masood two days ago, and my answer stands." Masood-ji, Dujarric's straight man for justification of eviction of the Press, videohere. This is censorship, and it remains ongoing - they have not answered a petition with thousands of signatures. Meanwhile Guterres and his Global Communicator Alison Smale have purported to assign Inner City Press' long time UN work space to Sisi's no show state media, Sanaa Youssef of Akhbar al Yom. We'll have more on this. Six days before when Guterres met Ecuador's Vice President María Alejandra Vicuña on February 22 it was supposed to be at 11:50 am. But another Inner City Press arrived half an hour before, by the time it was allowed in at 11:44 am the meeting was already underway. There was no handshake, and  the Press was quickly ushered out. With Guterres was a single UN staffer: Katrin Hett. On the elevator down from the 38th floor, UN Department of Political Affairs deputy Miroslav Jenca was just arriving, and UN Photo missed the shot again. This is a pattern. The evening before on February 21 when Guterres met Cote d'Ivoire foreign minister Marcel Amon-Tanoh on February 21, Guterres changed the time twice. First from 5 pm to 6:40 pm - for this, notice was provided - and then without notice moving it up to 6:34 pm such that both the Ivorian photographer and even UN Photo missed it. It seems Guterres is only interested in accommodating those who can help him - he has been happy, for example, to have the investigative Press restricted for his entire tenure, with no explanation of what the rules are. No show state media in, investigative press, through the tourist entrance, minders required. This is "Big Tony's" United Nations, do as I say, not as I do. Big shots are getting over with sexual harassment, while directives go to underlings. The Global Communicator Alison Smale, censor in chief, is involved. At the February 21, restricted Inner City Press was the only media which asked any questions, on Justin Forsyth multiple abuser, now at UNICEF, about mis-statements about immunity in India, another no-answer on Tanzania. The only media asking, and the only media restricted by Guterres and Smale. We'll have more on this.