Tuesday, April 1, 2014

After Sri Lanka Samarasinghe Rebuffs Pillay, UN Tells Inner City Press That Ban Ki-moon Wants Cooperation


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 1 -- While UN Secretary General had no comment last week on restrictions on human rights defenders in Sri Lanka (and previously accepted controversial military figure Shavendra Silva as an adviser, telling Inner City Press it was entirely up to the member states), on April 1 Ban through his deputy spokesperson Farhan Haq gave a pre-prepared answer to Inner City Press' question.

   After Sri Lanka's Mahinda Samarasinghe, whom Ban met on October 16, 2012, said that the government will not cooperate with the UN Office of the High Commission on Human Rights probe included in the Human Rights Council resolution adopted last week 23-12-12, Inner City Press on April 1 asked Haq if Ban had any comment.

  He did. Haq replied that "the Secretary General has underlined importance of accountability [and] welcomes determination of the High Commission on Human Rights [and] calls on gov to constructive engage and cooperate in implementation of the resolution," citing President Mahinda Rajapaksa and his own joint statement in May 2009. Video here.

  From the UN's April 1, 2014 transcript:

Inner City Press: you mention the Rights Up Front plan that the Secretary-General has spoken about. Since there was a resolution passed last week in Geneva at the Human Rights Council calling for an independent, international investigation of war crimes in Sri Lanka. Since then, Mahinda Samarasinghe, who the Secretary-General has met with in the past, has said that Sri Lanka will not participate in any way, will not corporate, and essentially won’t allow these investigators into the country. And I wanted to know if the Secretary-General or the Secretariat has any response to that.

Deputy Spokesman Farhan Haq: Yes, the Secretary-General has consistently underlined the importance of an accountability process for addressing violations of international humanitarian and human rights law in Sri Lanka. He welcomes the determination by the High Commissioner for Human Rights to advance accountability and promote lasting peace and reconciliation in the country. The Secretary-General calls on the Government of Sri Lanka to constructively engage and cooperate with the Office of the High Commissioner on the implementation of the resolution adopted last week by the Human Rights Council. He recalls the commitments made to him on accountability by the President of Sri Lanka in their Joint Statement of 2009. The United Nations will remain engaged with Sri Lanka to support Sri Lanka’s efforts to make progress in accountability, reconciliation and a lasting political solution. Have a good afternoon, everyone.
  Back on March 28 when there was testimony that two human rights defenders were prohibited from traveling or speaking with the media:
Inner City Press asked UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's deputy spokesperson Farhan Haq about the restrictions:
Inner City Press: On Sri Lanka, there were these two human right defenders, Ruki Fernando and Father Praveen Mahesan, who were taken into custody during the pendency of the resolution in Geneva. And although they’ve been released, it was said at the Geneva hearing yesterday that both are subject to travel, can’t travel and can’t speak to the media. And I wanted to know — is that something that the UN Secretariat would be concerned about?
Deputy Spokesman Haq: Well, I think first and foremost, that would be an issue for the Human Rights mechanisms in Geneva, specifically the office dealing with human rights defenders. So, I think you should ask them how they’re following up on this, because they’re the ones who’ve been expressing their concerns about this case.
  This passing the buck now seems at odds with Haq's April 1 answer as well as to his March 28 answer about Ukraine: when asked about journalists there, Haq said that's why we, Ban's UN, wants to and is deploying a human rights monitoring team to Ukraine. Video here.

   Is this human rights, or politics? How long and how will Ban's UN's strange relationship with Sri Lanka continue?
  Later on March 28 Ban Ki-moon mentioned his "Rights Up Front" plan, without mentioning its roots in his UN's failure in Sri Lanka, and without taking any questions on this. Ban (or Haq) chose four questions from AP, CBS / UNCA, Bloomberg and Voice of America (which asked Ban's spokesperson to "review" the UN accreditation of Inner City Press, here).
   On March 27 in Geneva when the Sri Lanka draft resolution came up for the vote, or votes, at the UN Human Rights Council in Geneva on March 27, the US spoke in favor, as did Karen Pierce of the UK.
   Then came a series of speakers in opposition, including Pakistan proposing a vote to strip Operative Paragraph 10, and before that for a no-action motion since, it argued, the $1.4 million needed was not (yet) in the regular budget.
  India gave a long speech, concluded that it would abstain.
  The no-action motion failed 16 for, 25 against. On Pakistan's request for a separate vote on OP10, the paragraph stayed in, 23 in favor, 14 against and 10 abstaining.
  Then the resolution as a whole passed: 23 for, 12 against, 12 abstentions.
  Back on March 26, High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay introduced her report to the Council, followed by three-minute speeches. The UK's Karen Pierce stressed the need for an investigation; the US cited undue military influence. But why then was demilitarization dropped from the draft? 
  Back on March 24, UK Minister of State Hugo Swire was asked, Will you call for demilitarization from Tamils land which can prevent many Sri Lanka issues?
  To this Swire replied, "Resolution is a result of negotiations. Current resolution text has impact and calls for international inquiry."
  Inner City Press directed a question at Swire: "What does UK think of UN Peacekeeping continued use of Sri Lanka troops, & Shavendra Silva as advisor?"
   This, Swire did not answer. It is noteworthy that alongside its work on the Sri Lanka issue in Geneva, at the UN in New York where the UK has a Permanent Five seat on the Security Council that it uses on such issues as Syria and now Ukraine, the UK has by comparison done little.
  While David Cameron did use the CHOGM in Sri Lanka to use raises, recently the UK co-sponsored a Commonwealth event in New York with Sri Lanka, without a word.  What explains this?
  Sri Lanka currently holds the chair of the UN General Assembly's Sixth (Legal) Committee.  Its controversial military figure Shavendra Silva was put on the Senior Advisory Group on Peacekeeping Operations with little said by the UK.
  It was, in the first instance, other South Asian countries which tried to avoid what one of them called a "travesty." UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon played no role, telling Inner City Press it is entirely up to member states. Rights Up Front?
  On March 26, France cited crack down on the media. But at the UN in New York its Permanent Representative Gerard Araud has moved past French official Herve Ladsous to issue threats to sue, in order to silence, on Western Sahara and a New York Police Department document about France's now consul to San Francisco Romain Serman - a document on which the French mission refused to provide comment, only threats.
The only response to attempts to censor is continued digging and publication.
  Likewise, the old UN Correspondents Association at the UN in New York screened the Sri Lankan government's denial of war crimes, then tried to get the investigative Press thrown out of the UN after it reported on conflicts of interest in this regard. The UNCA president at the time has resurfaced in charge of the group's award. So who will they or he give a prize to: Mahinda Rajapaksa?
  On Sunday March 23, the US television network CBS, employer of UNCA's new president, broadcast an hour-long mockumentary called "The Amazing Race" filmed in Sri Lanka, at a Buddhist temple and an apparel factory with nary a word about war crimes or GPS Plus. A CBS correspondent leads the UN Correspondents Association, followinganother who rented one of his apartments to Sri Lanka's Ambassador to the UN, then tried to get the investigative Press thrown out of the UN for reporting it. The UNCA role and trolling have revived.)
   After the government arrested two human rights defenders, Ruki Fernando and Praveen Mahesahn, Inner City Press asked Ban Ki-moon's new spokesperson Stephane Dujarric about these arrests.
  On March 17, Dujarric said the UN had seen the reports but had no comment. He noted Ban's statement in [May] 2009 with President Mahinda Rajapaksa. But when Inner City Press asked how that relates or is applied to these arrests, Dujarric said that was the entirety of the response. Video here.
  Inner City Press asked who in the UN Secretariat is now monitoring Sri Lanka. Before, it was Vijay Nambiar and others. Now what?
  Dujarric replied that "like any country," Sri Lanka is monitored by the UN. Not too closely, it seems... 

  Meanwhile in the Human Rights Council on March 17, Sri Lanka cynically praised a country for inviting UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay -- even as the Sri Lankan government trashes her for proposing an international accountability mechanism.
  Only days ago near Kilinochchi an outspoken mother of the disappeared, Belendran Jeyakumari, was arrested by the government.
  She protested when UK prime minister David Cameron traveled to the North last November. Now what?
   Sri Lankan state television has run the photographs of leaders of non-governmental organizations which dared speak up about conditions in the country. Video here, from Minute 11:15. (The state TV mistakenly says the concurrent debate about Ukraine is about "Slovenia," too.)
  But when Inner City Press asked UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's new spokesperson Stephane Dujarric about it back on March 10, he replied, "I haven't seen the video." He said that his predecessor had spoken clearly on Sri Lanka in the last few days. See Inner City PressYouTube of the exchange, here.
   Five days later, Ban Ki-moon's spokesperson Dujarric has still not provided any UN comment on the video, nor on the crackdown in Sri Lanka. On a parallel track, Ban's senior advisor Vijay Nambiar has invited Myanmar to contribute "peacekeepers" to the UN. Under Dujarric's previously boss, a country was blocked from getting paid for any new peacekeepers after a coup d'etat. But this is what the UN has become.
  Most recently Ban's office was UNclear about whether the Rajapaksa government has invited him to Colombo in May for a youth conference. When asked about accountability, the answer was it is up to member states, just as Ban said about accepting military figure Shavendra Silva as an advisor on peacekeeping.
  On the revised draft resolution, a negotiating session is slated in Geneva for March 18 in Room XXII; the vote seems set for March 26...
  

  When the UN Human Rights Council speeches resumed on the morning of March 5, Sri Lanka's foreign minister G.L. Peiris denounced the report of outgoing High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay, the pending draft and any international inquiry.
   Peiris cited two reports that he said are to be released within weeks; he cited a railroad plan announced only yesterday. This comes after nearly five years of stonewalling and intimidation.
  At the UN, where blame for inaction in 2009 and even participation in events leading to the execution of surrenderees go to the highest levels, Sri Lanka sent military figure Shavendra Silva as its Deputy Permanent Representative.
   Under Ban Ki-moon as Secretary General, Shavendra Silva became a senior adviser to UN Peacekeeping under Herve Ladsous, the fourth Frenchman in a row to hold that post. When Inner City Press asked, Ban said this was entirely up to member states.
   After Inner City Press wrote about the United Nations Correspondents Association screening the government's "Lies Agreed To" inside the UN, when "Killing Fields" which it purported to rebut was not shown in the UN, and noted that Sri Lanka's Permanent Representative Palitha Kohona had a prior financial relationship with the president of UNCA, a demand was made to remove the article from the Internet.
  When Inner City Press refused this censorship bid, attempts began to get Inner City Press thrown out of the UN, directed to the UN official set to become Ban's new spokesperson on March 10. 
  One such complaint, upon the dubious request by Reuters UN bureau chief Louis Charbonneau under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, has been banned from Google's search. (The new Free UN Coalition for Access is now combating censorship at the UN and beyond.)
   Ban Ki-moon ended up giving Pillay only half of a second term; the "Rights Up Front" plan he belatedly announced, specifically as a response to what was found to be the UN's "systemic failure" on Sri Lanka, he now presents without any reference to Sri Lanka.  
  Despite denials, Sri Lankan official tell Inner City Press when they met recently with Ban, they invited him to Colombo in May. 
   Before then, it appears, a vote will be held at the 25th session of the Human Rights Council.  When HRC25 began its speeches on Monday morning the 3rd of March, Hugo Swire of the UK, Canada and others cited Sri Lanka and the need for accountability.
  US Ambassador Samantha Power, according to the UN's list of speakers, was to appear late Tuesday.
   But at 4 pm on Monday when the marked up Sri Lanka resolution was tabled, its eight operative paragraph appeared to some to simply kick the can down the road again, asking for another update from the High Commissioner for Human Rights -- who soon won't be Navi Pillay anymore. Click here for draft as provided to Inner City Press.
   Later on Monday, the US State Department announced that the US' speech would be given by another official, Under Secretary of State for Civilian Security, Democracy, and Human Rights Sarah Sewall: not Power.
  During the speeches on Monday, Syria and North Korea remained in nearly every speech but Ukraine and the Central African Republic worked their way in, along with a smattering of references to Sri Lanka, where the killing of tens of thousands of civilians remains unaddressed.
  It was noted that the term of High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay is almost up. But it was Secretary General Ban Ki-moon who said she'd only have one half of a second term. 
  Pillay on January 20 said the France put Muslim communities at risk in CAR. How will that be acted on? She's called for a international accountability mechanism for Sri Lanka; Ban says its entirely up to member states, as he told Inner City Press regarding having controversial military figure Shavendra Silva as an adviser to UN Peacekeeping under Herve Ladsous.
  Qatar, which sent only a "Minister's Assistant," predictable denounced Syria and also spoke for freedom of the press if not of speech. #FreeAJstaff, we and the Free UN Coalition for Access absolutely agree with. But what about Qatar having locked up the poet Ajami?
  Greece spoke on Ukraine, taking the EU line, which implies that the International Monetary Fund will save Ukraine. Has they happened in Greece? What about the protesters in Greece's squares?
  Ban Ki-moon gave a press conference, pitching for relevance and a role in Ukraine, where instead of Robert Serry he has now sent his deputy Jan Eliasson. But once it was leaked that former US now UN official Jeff Feltman "got" Ban to send Serry to Ukraine, Ban's UN being viewed as impartial is more difficult.
  It was World Wildlife Day, so Ban gave a speech on that as well. But unaddressed since Inner City Press reported and asked about it on February 28 are what UN whistleblowers say are more than 50 rapes in Eastern Congo by poacher Mai Mai Morgan. Ban will meet his Special Representatives including Martin Kobler from the Congo. What will the UN's answer be?
  UK Hugo Swire took on the Sri Lanka issue; here's his response to Pillay's report. He said it's time for international action.
 US Samantha Power won't speak until March 4, in the afternoon in Geneva so work hours in the US. Sri Lanka's G.L. Peiris on the other hand appears March 5 but 3:40 am Eastern Times. Watch this site.

 
  

Syrian Coalition Wants Brahimi to Convince "Wendy Chairman" of US to Pressure Russia: Then Geneva III?


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 1 -- Ten days after protests inside Syria to oust Ahmad al Jarba as head of the Syrian National Coalition, this Syria Coalition has sent out conditions for re-starting the Geneva talks:

"Louay Safi, spokesman for the Syrian Coalition, said that if Lakhdar Brahimi managed to convince U.S. Assistant Secretary of State Wendy Chairman to put pressure on Russia's Deputy Foreign Minister Bogdanov to change the Russian position towards the Syrian crisis, then we can consider the resumption of negotiations with the Assad regime."

 Who is this "Wendy Chairman," you ask? What does she chair? It appears to be the US State Department's Wendy Sherman.

  At the State Department's March 31 briefing, deputy spokesperson Marie Harf said "right now what we’re really focused on is to see if Special Joint Representative Brahimi can get these talks re-started again. As we’ve said, they’re on a pause."
  But not if Brahimi can convince Wendy Chairman!
  After the protest, Jarba gave a speech in Kuwait asking that Syrian embassies in Arab capitals be given to him. 
  Apparently credibility inside Syria is not important. If for example France and its scribes deem Jarba the representative of the Syrian people, the logic goes, why not give him the far-flung embassies?
  From Jarba's March 25 speech to the Arab League Summit in Kuwait:
"Let me say quite frankly that keeping Syria’s seat empty in your midst sends a clear message to Assad that he can kill and that the seat will wait for him to resolve his war. This is how the regime understands the message, and our people ask themselves: if the West failed to provide us with the needed weapons, what prevents our brothers from resolving the matter of our seat amongst you? I would like to add that reality dictates that the Syrian embassies in Arab capitals should be given to the National Coalition."
   While Qatar sponsored an event at the UN in New York on March 21 featuring Jarba's Syrian Coalition headed, a group calling its the Syrian Grassroots Movement held protests seeking to oust Jarba.
   By March 22, the group stated that some 40,000 people in 58 cities inside Syria had participated in demonstrations to get Jarba out of his post, saying "it is time to put an end to political corruption."
  Back in September 2013, France sponsored an event in the UN and called Jarba the sole legitimate representative of the Syrian people. French Ambassador Gerard Araud was the first questioner, with a intentionally easy question, at Qatar's March 21 Syrian Coalition event. What is France's position now? Who chooses the leaders?
  Likewise, back in July 2013 and earlier this month, the Jarba-led Syrian Coalition held faux "UN" events in the clubhouse Ban Ki-moon's Secretariat gives to the largely Gulf and Western UN Correspondents Association. How does that now appear, in light of the anti-Jarba protests?
   Qatar's March 21 event was not listed in the UN Journal nor in the UN Media Alert. It was not on the UN's publicly available webcast.
  Select media outlets were there, when Inner City Press came in at the end to ask a question: Al Jazeera on the podium in Qatar's event, Al Arabiya like a Saudi diplomat -- not the Permanent Representative -- in the audience along with Al Hayat, even Al Hurra, on whose Broadcasting Board of Governors US Secretary of State John Kerry serves.
   The new Free UN Coalition for Access is against faux UN events, in the clubhouse the Secretariat gives to what's become its UN Censorship Alliance or elsewhere.
   On March 21 Inner City Press put these questions, also on behalf of the Free UN Coalition for Access, to the UN's top two spokespeople:
"there is an event in Conference Room 4 right now, sponsored by Qatar, which is no listed in today's UN Journal, nor is it on UN Webcast http://webtv.un.org/ but it appears to be being filmed. Please explain the legal status of this meeting, if there are any sponsored beyond Qatar, how it was publicized and if any request to have it webcast was made. Thanks, on deadline."
  But no answer was provided. Inner City Press ran to the event and from the back of a three quarters empty Conference Room 4 asked why the event was so stealth: not in the UN Journal, not webcast.
  The Permanent Representative of Qatar answered, saying it was a "special event" to which Qatar had invited (some) member states and groups, and (some) media. There is a UN Media Alert, but this event was not put in it.
  Perhaps it was publicized by the Gulf & Western United Nations Correspondents Association, which has twice hosted faux "UN" events by the Syrian National Coalition or Syrian Coalition. (In both cases, the Free UN Coalition for Access suggested that the SNC hold its events in the UN briefing room, accessible to all journalists.)
  Since French Ambassador Gerard Araud, the first questioner flanked by representatives of Saudi Arabia and of Turkey which earlier in the day banned Twitter, has spoken about "fakes" and others about accountability, Inner City Press asked if the groups Al Nusra and ISIS, and those who fund them such as private individuals in Qatar alluded to at the US State Department briefing earlier in the day, could or would be held accountable.
  The SNC representative emphasized what he called links between the Assad regime and ISIS, saying it was too easy to blame the Gulf countries.
Question: you have concerns about the withdrawal of the ambassadors. Do you also have concerns about the reasons that these countries said that they withdrew their ambassadors from Qatar? In other words, do you – if you have concerns about the withdrawal of the ambassadors, do you also have concerns about Qatar’s behavior, which – alleged behavior, let’s say – which led to these countries withdrawing their ambassadors?
MS. PSAKI: Well, I know one of the issues that has been mentioned is the issue of private donations to extremists – and that’s something that some have mentioned – operating in Syria and elsewhere. It remains an important priority in our high-level discussions, and one that we also certainly raise with all states in the region, including Qatar, including the Government of Kuwait, wherever we have concerns.
After Inner City Press asked about the sponsorship of the event, a one-page "Joint Statement by the Co-Organizers" was passed out, listing among the co-organizers France, the UK, US, Belgium, the Netherlands, Saudi Arabia and Turkey. Inner City Press tweeted it. 
   Even 24 hours later, the UN's top two spokespeople had not answered the simple questions put to them, above. Watch this site.

 
  

At UN, Coverage of Dispute Banned So As To Not Impact Dispute, Censors Circle


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 1 -- While the UN continues to preach transparency, democracy and even lack of censorship around the world, in two elections held in December inside the UN, disputes and decay were the rule, and have continued to grow worse ever since.

  On March 28, Inner City Press asked UN deputy spokesperson Farhan Haq why the UN would censor a staff member's balanced article about the Staff Union standoff from the "Staff Voices" of the UN's in-house web site, i-Seek, video here, transcript below.

  Having no answer, Inner City Press put the question again on March 31 to Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's Spokesperson Stephane Dujarric at the day's noon briefing. Later on April 1 the follow rationale for censorship arrived:
Subject: Your question on iSeek
From: UN Spokesperson - Do Not Reply [at] un.org
Date: Mon, Mar 31, 2014 at 5:28 PM
To: Matthew Russell Lee [at] innercitypress.com
The Administration will refrain from taking any action that may prejudice the outcome of the efforts by the Arbitration Committee to resolve these disputes.
  So the UN says it refused to publish a balanced staff article about a dispute, in order not to impact the dispute. This is the rationale for censorship in regimes around the world. And now in Ban's UN.
  Back on March 28, Inner City Press asked Haq:
Inner City Press: I wanted to ask you about something that some in the UN called censorship. I know you said you have no comment even if a letter has been received by Yukio Takasu about the Staff Union dispute, but I wanted to ask you this – an editor in the Office of Legal Affairs Treaty Division submitted an article for the Staff Voices section of the iSeek and was told in response that although they welcome it as a venue for staff information, on the issues you’re writing about, we have to take the advice of management into consideration and it would not be published. What I wanted to know is — what are the standards for this Staff Voices section of iSeek? Is it really what the staff think and if an article, which I’ve seen the article, it actually quotes both sides… what is management’s role in deciding or censoring what goes into the Staff Voices section?
Deputy Spokesman Farhan Haq: I’m not aware of that dispute, so I’d have to check with the people responsible for Staff Voices. It is meant to be a place where all staff can contribute their views... I’m not aware of this at all, so I would need to check up what the details are.
  But on the question on the UN's censorship, by noon on March 31, there was still no explanation or even answer. So Inner City Press asked again, and got the answer published in full above.
  Back on March 20, even as Secretary General Ban Ki-moon refuses to recognize any UN Staff Union, the ticket which received the most votes in December held a protest outside the Budget Committee. Inner City Press tweeted photos here& here.
  The topic was Ban's "mobility" proposal, which is in front of the Committee "without any counter-proposals from staff," as the flier handed out at the protest put it.
  While this proposal would send staff to far flung duty posts, the protesters said without regard to family situations, Ban has advisers who dodge his "five year" mobility rule by simply changing job titles but remaining in New York. Protesters mentioned Bob Orr, who has his own proposal in front of the Budget Committee, and senior adviser Kim Won-soo.
   In any event, even as the Secretariat tries in essence to break the Union, the actions continue. Inside the budget committee, Management chief Yukio Takasu presented an update on the Capital Master Plan renovation, which the protesters said would spend yet more money on security while some of them are being laid off, pending an arbitration decision.
  Back on March 11, new UN spokesperson Stephane Dujarric tried to put his own headline on the protests.
  He said it was only about the Publishing Section -- which Inner City Press has covered since the UN used Hurricane Sandy as an excuse to eliminate jobs -- but the problems under Ban run much deeper.
  Dujarric on March 10 called the continued pay at the Under Secretary General level for Augustine Mahiga a short stint, closely aligned with a board of correspondents who clapped for him, and for Ban Ki-moon. It's a new development, and one in which the Free UN Coalition for Access will not participate. Last video here.
  On March 11, Dujarric dodged on a new Haiti cholera case filed in Federal Court in Brooklyn; he talked about "protection of minorities" being upfront. But on March 10 he said he hadn't watched the brutal footage of Tamils being killed by the Sri Lankan Army; there has still been no comment by the Secretariat.
  Back on February 11, despite a Staff Union election have been conducted including in the UN Lobby in December, since Ban's Secretariat has not recognized the winners a call for new Polling Officers went out. This despite a meeting earlier that day at which the caller did not disclose this course of action. The next day, UN Security had to be called to try to put down the dispute.
  Also on February 11, having moved to break the UN staff union by citing alleged irregularities in voting, the UN Secretariat held a closed door meeting with Permanent Representative on Ban Ki-moon's "mobility" proposal, which the union opposed. The meeting was not in the day's UN Journal, and was not on UNTV. 
  Then as noted Ban Ki-moon held a lunch and "secret" question and answer session, with no question about Ukraineand the UN's derivative role, with what's become the UN's Censorship Alliance, despite its leadership openly violating the group's own constitution, which they recently put back online, by not having the required financial meeting in the first half of January, as promised in an email disclosing a donated Samsung television subsequently denied by UNCA 2013-14 president Pam Falk of CBS.
   Nor has the Ukraine-less Q&A at this lunch been disclosed to the wider press corps or public, despite a formal request from the Free UN Coalition for Access:
a tape or transcript of what the Secretary General said today this lunch: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BgOCAllCUAAwTxU.jpgSince the photo shows tape recorders, this is a request to be informed if any embargo was placed on what the Secretary General said. If not, this is a request including on behalf of the Free UN Coalition for Access for an explanation, why this was not provided to all correspondents, and for the tape (or transcript) forthwith.
  What Nesirky's office did after that was to email out Ban's prepared remarks, with no question and answer, much less what is understood as his comments on crimes against humanity. (Since Ban was silent at the time on those in Sri Lanka, some ask, is it any wonder? Click here for UNCA's "leadership" on Sri Lanka.)
   How can the UN cite rules against one group, the union, while ignoring them on another? The answer is that the union fights or pushes to hold Ban accountable, while the UNCA leadership does not. So one is broken, the other lunched with.
  Most telling are direct censorship efforts by Louis Charbonneau the UN bureau chief of Reuters, with its Permanent seat on UNCA's board. He got Google to ban from its Search a complaint he filed with the UN trying to get the investigative Press thrown out of the UN, (mis) using the US Digital Millennium Copyright Act as diagnosed by the Electronic Frontier Foundation. That's straight up censorship, and it's enough, well, to lose your lunch. But not today, apparently.
  More contrast: in the UN Staff Union election, in which an incumbent sought to stay on despite term limits, there werecharges of illegal polling, and an attempt to stop paying the Elections Services Company.
   Now, the ticket that came out on top in the election has written to UN Department of Management chief Yukio Takasu for a statement if he and the UN recognize this union leadership.
   Takasu presided over a Department of Management town hall meeting at which impacts on staff members were discussed -- but without a recognized union?
   Inner City Press is informed that in the UN facility in Valencia, for example, contract workers will re obtained through the UN Office for Project Services. Union-busting and outsourcing, at the UN.
  On December 17 Inner City Press published the results,putting the document online here:
Winner with 430 votes: Ticket 1 [They have thanked voters]
President Stephen Kisambira (DESA/PD)
First Vice-President Emad Hassanin (DGACM/MPD/PS)
Second Vice-President Leonid Dolgopolov (DSS/DSSS/SSS)
2d place with 231 votes: Ticket 2
President Nadir A. Dirar Bashir (DGACM/MPD/PS/DTPU)...
  We will continue to cover that showdown, which is at least competitive. Even more decayed is the United Nations Correspondents Association or UN's Censorship Alliance. 
  To compare: while the UN uses a dispute about the legality of the December election to refuse to recognize those who came out on top in the union election, the fact the UNCA has again violated its own Constitution, only today put back online, by not holding a meeting about its finance in the first half of January is ignored by the UN. Because UNCA serves this UN.
   It's simple: the UNCA Constitution Article 7, 1, states "The Association shall convene an annual Membership Meeting during the first half of the month of January."
  This didn't happen; instead, 2013-14 president Pamela Falk of CBS distributed November 25 minutes, which also directly referred to a donated Samsung television which UNCA later denied, stating as to the Constitution that
"It was noted that the meeting was a General Meeting, not the Annual General Meeting. The UNCA constitution requires an Annual General meeting that should be held in the first half of January; the date was set for January 14th. There was discussion and a vote for a meeting on December 5, but because the budget will not be completed until year's end, the meeting will be held, as the Constitution requires in January."
   Despite this acknowledgment of the requirements of the UNCA Constitution, the meeting was not held in the first half of January, or even in January at all.
  A Constitutionally-invalid meeting was finally held -- largely about, what else, another party, like the one held March 7 even as the Security Council meeting on children and armed conflict continued.
 Reporting on the Security Council is undermine by UNCA's laxity: there are fewer and fewer UNTV stakeouts, as potential speakers are diverted to private chats in the so-called Turkish Lounge. This happened on February 10, while the "new" UNCA fed quotes from French president Hollande's state dinner in Washington.
    Ban's UN hands the first question and more to UNCA, which does not challenge Ban. In 2012 its leaders tried to get the investigative Press thrown out of the UN, pointing at a factual article Inner City Press published about Sri Lanka, the UN and conflicts of interest.
  Ban's Secretariat now admits on Sri Lanka a "systemic failure" - his Deputy Jan Eliasson repeatedly says that -- but UNCA, which still has no rules against trying to throw journalists out of the UN, nor apparently any conflict of interest rules, makes no admission, no reforms.
  It demands the first question at press conferences even if it has nothing to ask, or the answers will never be published.
  Not surprisingly it is in decay. ng a 2009 trip to Sri Lanka with Ban Ki-moon and UK humanitarian chief Sir John Holmes not only didn't report Holmes on the record comment that he deleted all complaining emails from Tamils -- she said the Press reporting this "ruined" relations with Holmes for her and, for example, Reuters. Though over 2000 journalists are accredited at the UN, in December 2013 only 111 even tried to vote in the three days of polling -- and door to door demands to vote for -- the United Nations Correspondents Association. Seven of these ballots failed. The incumbent Pamela Falk of CBS, running unopposed, still managed to not get 26 of the 104 votes cast.
  Falk's vote total of 78 was lower than the 85 obtained in December 2011 by her predecessor, who was the one who first demanded that Inner City Press remove an article about Sri Lanka from the Internet, click here for that.
 The article UNCA "leaders" tries to censor reported on the previous financial relationship of Sri Lanka's Permanent Representative with UNCA's then president, in the context of this president screening in the UN the Sri Lankan government's war crimes denial film, without asking or the consent of Inner City Press then on the Executive Committee of UNCA.
  No reforms in UNCA were ever instituted after this.
 Inner City Press after withstanding a kangaroo court UNCA proceeding quit the organization and co-founded the newFree UN Coalition for Access, @FUNCA_info, to actually defend the right of free press and free inquiry in and about the UN system.
    In 2012 UNCA "leaders" tried to get the investigative Press thrown out of the UN, as documented by documents obtained under the Freedom of Information Act. Voice of America asked the UN to "review" Inner City Press' accreditation; VOA said it had the support of Agence France Presse and Reuters, click here for that.
The Reuters first vice president of UNCA spied for the UN, giving them an internal anti Press UNCA document three minutes after promising not to (story here, document here,audio here). 
 While he has stepped off, the Reuters reporter he supervised (and who also tried to get the investigative Press thrown out of the UN) campaigned to get on UNCA's board, demanded on camera in a UN noon briefing to all present, "Have you voted?" It's as if Reuters has a Permanent seat on UNCA's 15-member Executive Committee, like the P5 in the Security Council.
Here are the December 2013 results, compared to votes in December 2011 for the "candidate" or their predecessor
Dec '13 Dec '11
Prez: * 78 [85] Pamela Falk, CBS News TV and Radio
1st VP * 74 [79] Kahraman Haliscelik, TRT Turkish Radio & TV
2d VP * 48 71 Masood Haider, Dawn, Pakistan
* 48 [71] Sylviane Zehil, L’Orient Le Jour
3d VP * 55 [62] Erol Avdovic, Webpublicapress
38 Ali Barada, An-Nahar/France 24
Trez * 81 [71] Bouchra Benyoussef, Maghreb Arab Press
Sect * 79 [81] Seana Magee, Kyodo News
Members at Large:
* 57 1. Nabil Abi Saab , Alhurra TV
* 57 2. Talal Al-Haj ,Al-Arabiya News channel
22 3. George Baumgarten , Jewish Newspapers, Nation Media
* 50 4. Sherwin Bryce-Pease, South African Broadcasting (SABC)
* 51 5. Zhenqiu Gu, Xinhua News Agency
* 69 6. Melissa Kent, CBC/Radio Canada
* 56 7. Evelyn Leopold, Huffington Post Contributor
49 8. J. Tuyet Nguyen, German Press Agency DPA
* 67 9. Michelle Nichols, Reuters
41 10. Edwin Nwanchukwu, News Agency of Nigeria
27 11. Cia Pak, Scannews
*54 12. Valeria Robecco, ANSA
* 54 13. Sangwon Yoon , Bloomberg
  Some of the elected are new and their positions on UNCA Executive Committee members trying to get other (investigative) media thrown out of the UN, and the need to preclude this and UNCA leaders' anonymous social media trolling, are not yet known. (Some not elected were among the better / more diverse candidates.)
When the UN Correspondents Association leaders tried stealthy to get the investigative Press thrown out of the UN, and have failed to institute any reform since, it became the UN's Censorship Alliance. Party on. Watch this site.