Tuesday, February 4, 2014

At UN, After Urging Page Limits to Cut Costs, US Opposes Them, As Torsella Succession, Whither Leslie Berger Kiernan?


By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, February 4 -- The need for the UN to limit the number of pages or words in filings has been emphasized by countries of the European Union, Japan and the United States, particularly under previous US Ambassador for Reform Joe Torsella.

  In in a closed-door meeting at the UN on February 3, on which Inner City Press now exclusively reports, the US and others pushed back against proposals to put limits on the length of submissions to the UN human rights treaty bodies. Canada, for example, said that its political system requires longer submissions.

  The US recognized the contradiction between its or Torsella's cost-saving proposal and the position it took on February 3. It counter-proposed a limit by the number of words -- noting that India, too, would sometimes resort to a small font. 

  If the length limit mentions national human rights institutions and NGOs, it was argued, them they should be listed as "stakeholders" in the resolution.  Discussions are to continue on the afternoon of February 4.
   For the US Mission, it remains unclear who will replace Torsella. Back in November, we reported that the US Mission to the UN's ambassador for reform Joe Torsella will leave by the end of the year, then on November 21 that the Obama administration nominated to replace Torsella the lawyer Leslie Berger Kiernan.  
  On January 30, still without explanation despite stil pending requests in New York (including on other topics) and DC, her nomination was withdrawn, notified to the press by email after 6:25 pm:
WITHDRAWALS SENT TO THE SENATE:
Leslie Berger Kiernan, of Maryland, to be Representative of the United States of America to the United Nations for U.N. Management and Reform, with the rank of Ambassador, which was sent to the Senate on January 6, 2014.
  The administration's summary was that she has been with the Office of the White House Counsel since 2011 -- and from 1988 to 2011 with the firm Zuckerman Spaeder.
  There, her highest profile client at least from public records was Congressman Charles Rangel. This seemed noteworthy, given the nomination for the US Mission position trying to root out UN corruption. But a lawyer is not his or her client; Inner City Press  sought comment from the US Mission, as it has now, then from the White House, natch.
Background: On November 15 the US Mission's Ambassador Samantha Power announced that Torsella would be leaving by the end of 2013.
  Inner City Press immediately tweeted it, along with the suggestion of 21 audit salute, since Torsella focused on the issue of releasing UN audits, pushing forward from where things were under his predecessor at the US Mission, Mark Wallace.
(Wallace went, notably, to United Against a Nuclear Iran which appears dis-united on the issue of new sanctions, with president saying no but spokesperson saying members say yes.)
  Torsella pushed for Fifth (Budget) Committee proceedings to be on UN Television. The Group of 77 responded that other committees like the Second on development and Fourth which included decolonization and work on the rights of Palestinians should also be filmed. 
  Both have happened -- improvements in technology are also involved -- and it's all to the good.
   Two weeks ago the G77 meeting at which Bolivia became as Inner City Press first reported the successor to Fiji was not initially televised; when Inner City Press and the Free UN Coalition for Access complained, the UN official in charge said it was belatedly on, check before asking.
   But it was UN staff which also complained, and this automatic defending of the UN is one of the things wrong, in the bigger picture for example on the UN bringing cholera to Haiti. Where does Torsella stand on that, before he leaves?
  Where does or would Leslie Berger Kiernan stand on it? And a newly arising issues, which Inner City Press reported on yesterday: should the US State Department support a UN bid for immunity for allegedly bringing cholera to Haiti? 
  We'll have more on that. For now, this on less reported parts of Torsella's legacy:
Torsella to his credit wasn't just about the money. The issue of lack of accountability in Sri Lanka got delegated to him, in part because military figure Shavendra Silva was cynically put on Ban's Senior Advisory Group on Peacekeeping Operations.
  In classic UN form, Ban stayed away telling Inner City Press it was a decision of the member states. Without saying more, Inner City Press can report Torsella worked on this. One reason more can't be said is that the US Mission so often puts things off the record, sometimes after the fact. 
  Even the farewell for Ambassador Susan Rice was said to be off the record. Inner City Press complied, but scribes more obsequious to the US uploaded selfies of themselves with Rice, and left them up, while attacking investigative journalism and free press at the UN. 
 This too is an issue in the purview of Torsella and whoever his successor will be. The US should do more on this -- with spying undermining privacy, claims of freedom of the press are one of the definitely US values. Let that be pushed at thelawless UN, not only in 2014 but by Torsella before he leaves. 
  Torsella said the US is opposed to "clean slates," without competition, in UN system elections. But in the recent elections for the Human Rights Council, there was no competition to France and the UK in the Western Europe and Other Group, of which the US is a member. There's more work to be done at and on the UN -- much more. 
  Here's one, in the spirit of reform and transparency: cost cutting proposals in the UN system, largely supported by the US Mission, would involve Americans losing their jobs to off-shoring. Is this the US being selfless? Or just hoping no one puts the contradiction together? 
  American Tony Lake at UNICEF is also doing it - but he can say he is an international civil servant. The US State Department and Mission - isn't their job to advance American (and Americans') interests at and in the UN? Watch this site.

 
  

In Mali, UN's Final Cuts Heavy on French PR & US Power, Nothing on Kidal or Gang Rapes Charges Against UN Peacekeepers


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, February 4 -- The French-led half-tour of Mali by the UN Security Council has ended, carefully scripted and edited, declared a success. In the Mopti meeting of the Council, Kidal in the north was not represented, and questions about killings there were not addressed.


   Likewise, despite claims by many Council members and the Council as a whole to have a zero tolerance policy for sexual abuse or exploitation by UN peacekeepers, the charges of gang rape against UN peacekeepers from Chad serving in Mali were not addressed.

   At trip's end, the UN mission MINUSMA uploaded a 7 1/2 minute YouTube video. The Council members speaking in it, as edited in the final cut, were France's Gerard Araud and Samantha Power of the US, along with UN envoy Bert Koenders. Inner City Press asked MINUSMA, and the UN in New York, that the concluding press conference be live streamed, or made available on a phone line, or at least shown afterwards. From the February 3 UNHQ transcript:

Inner City Press: I’m wondering if the press conference of the Security Council in Bamako at the headquarters of MINUSMA, is there some way… they seem to say it couldn’t be live-streamed due to slow Internet. Either via telephone or in some other way, is there a way? It seems like you communicate with MINUSMA, there must be some connection possible.
Spokesperson Martin Nesirky: I hope my colleagues in [the Department of Peacekeeping Operations] are listening to this and can dial the line right now. It is certainly true that the Internet speed leaves something to be desired as I recall from my own recent visit there — through nobody’s fault, of course. Even if it’s not possible for you to listen through by telephone, I’m sure that there will be an audio recording that we could make available. Okay?
  But DPKO under Herve Ladsous never provided anything. The MINUSMA mission put up the 7/12 minute video, the last minute and a half of which appear to be the press conference. But only Araud and Koenders speak in this final cut of the press conference. 
  Clearly, MINUSMA filmed the whole press conference, to then choose these clips. Why not make the whole video available, as the UN does at headquarters, and as MONUSCO does in the Congo? Is MINUSMA's Mali the UN's new Hollywood - or Cannes?
   Again: before the press conference, Inner City Press for the Free UN Coalition for Access asked at the UN's noon briefing about access to the event, where questions about Kidal and alleged gang rapes by peacekeepers could and should be asked. Video here, from Minute 19:05.
 UN spokesperson Martin Nesirky said Internet speeds are slow but he hoped his colleagues in UN Peacekeeping were listening and could dial. This did not happen; the MINUSMA mission made Inner City Press aware of bullet points to open the press conference and a photo with Araud in the middle, other Ambassadors sitting behind. Inner City Press has asked for the Q&A.
  Meanwhile it emerges that King Mohammed VI of French ally Morocco is meeting with the MNLA, giving more credence to pre-existing doubts. It's all a French connection: are the Council and most of the UN, other than French-run UN Peacekeeping, just along with the ride?
  During the Council's Mali trip, MINUSMA produced and uploaded a series of YouTube videos, heavy on the positions of French Ambassador Gerard Araud.
  Inner City Press noted that the "interview" uploaded from Mopti, where the Council did not meet representatives from Kidal in the North, omitted all of the questions asked. Inner City Press asked why, and on behalf of the Free UN Coalition for Access asked that the Council's 7 pm press conference be live-streamed or otherwise made accessible in real time.
  MINUSMA responded that "Internet speed is not sufficiently fast, sorry for that." FUNCA has asked that questions can be posed and answered by Twitter, as done for example the UN in Somalia and the Democratic Republic of the Congo (from which envoy Martin Kobler complained on February 3 of protesters stoning UN vehicles; Kobler did a live-streamed Twitter Q&A.)
  We note that from Mail the UN's MINUSMA, despite the statement about Internet speed, has continued to put online Araud (and envoy Bert Koenders) videos on YouTube, for example here and here. Koenders claimed that with president IBK, "all the aspects" were discussed -- but still nothing has been said pubicly about the failure to meet with those from Kidal, and about the alleged gang rapes by UN peacekeepers.
  Araud went further in his MINUSMA video, quoting US Ambassador Samantha Power that strong-man IBK is "impressive," video here at Minute 0;40, and calling his dialogue "completely inclusive" despite the absence of those from Kidal.
  So will these questions be asked, allowed and answered at "the Security Council's" 7 pm press conference? The Free UN Coalition for Access has asked.
 That the Malian Presidency proudly links to a Radio France Internationale story praising the French ambassador as "at once very nuance and very clear" is one thing.
  Now the UN Peacekeeping mission in Mali MINUSMA has edited and posted a video of Ambassador Araud, with all questions edited out. Click here. Thus Araud is able to speak about "inspecting" the UN force, without anything about oversight of the French Serval force the UN belated authorized.
  (Will the 7 p.m. press conference at MINUSMA headquarters in Bamako be live-streamed? One would think with the money spent that the UN could do it. But will they?)
  Likewise, Araud speaks of meeting with the armed groups of the north without saying anything about Kidal.
   It's one thing that the Security Council members did not visit the north due to safety concerns. But given the centrality of Kidal to the split in the country, how could their meeting in Mopti with "civil society" from the north not include Kidal? 
  It is confirmed, by French-selected scribes: the Council met with it "civil society from Timbuktu, Gao and Mopti" - and NOT from Kidal. But the scribes, typically, did not question the omission, much less disparities in description of killings in Kidal or the lack of transparency by the UN about gang rapes by its peacekeepers, despite claims of "zero tolerance."
  On February 3, France's Operation Serval is set to make a presentation. While the Security Council has so far remained silent about France's Operation Sangaris' killings in Central African Republic, and taking sides and leaving some at risk as even Navi Pillay noted, more should be expected in person in Mali.
MaliActu, a publication on which the government in Bamako has previously cracked down and threatened, reported that Kidal was notrepresented in the meeting: "Les émissaires de l’ONU ont rencontré les représentants de la société civile -chefs religieux ou traditionnels, fonctionnaires- de Mopti, Gao, et Tombouctou, mais pas de Kidal."  
  It and the below are important issues, but are not addressed in the tweetsand facebook-ed statements of the Council members on the trip, much less in MINUSMA's upbeat photos of Bert Koenders and France's Gerard Araud inspecting the troops. 
   Did the Security Council, led by France and Chad, meet with leaders from Kidal or not? Especially given the dipute, below, about killings in Kidal?
  So far, the way France arranges this trips like the one to the Democratic Republic of the Congo last year, there is too little media coverage, at least online, about the trip. 
   Alongside a growing with of tweets (beginning with UK, Lithuania, US,now joined by Luxembourg, Bert Koenders and Araud inspecting the troops),, the Council members have returned to Bamako. Not yet mentioned: the UNresolved charges of gang rape by the UN peacekeepers from Chad.
  If the UN's and Security Council's stated policies on sexual violence and conflict and "Zero Tolerance" mean anything, the issue will have to be addressed, and publicly, during the two day trip.
  Back on January 16 the UN Spokesperson's Office sent Inner City Press this response, which does not answer the question of accountability. But here it is, in full:
Subject: Your question on Mali
From: UN Spokesperson - Do Not Reply [at] un.org
Date: Thu, Jan 16, 2014 at 3:23 PM
To: Matthew.Lee [at] innercitypress.com
In response to your question about the follow-up to the allegations of sexual assault by United Nations peacekeepers in MINUSMA in September 2013, we have received the following information:
The Department of Peacekeeping Operations officially notified the Government of Chad of these allegations in late September. The Government of Chad officially responded, saying that it would take responsibility for the investigations. The Government of Chad has further advised the Department of Peacekeeping Operations that it has completed the national investigation, and the United Nations awaits advice on the outcome of the investigations and follow-up accountability measures as appropriate.
  The UN is waiting for "advice" -- but will it ever make it public? How else can the UN's stated Human Rights Due Diligence Policy be assessed?
  On January 17, Inner City Press asked UN acting deputy spokesperson Farhan Haq about it. From the UN's transcript, video here and embedded below:
Inner City Press: On Mali, I wanted to thank you for this written answer you gave yesterday afternoon that Mali has said that its completed its investigation of the alleged rape in Mali by the Chadian troops. And it said that the UN awaits advice on the outcome of the investigation. And what I wanted to know is whether… what part of that is going to be made public, given both the human rights due diligence policy, etcetera? I appreciate you saying that the investigation is finished, but, has… did they clear the soldiers? Were the soldiers found guilty? Where does it stand?
Acting Deputy Spokesperson Haq: As we emailed to you, the Mission does await advice on the outcome of the proceedings. We know that there have been proceedings regarding the case. You know this is a case regarding sexual assault and so, we await further information from that. We’ll try to make public what we can of the information that we receive.
Inner City Press: So, they literally just told you that it’s complete, but…no indication on what was done? I guess I wonder when --
Acting Deputy Spokesperson: The information I have in the email that was sent to you is the information we have. If we have any further updates, we’ll share it with you at that point.
  Two weeks later, nothing. So what will members of the Security Council ask, find and make public?

  One of the UN's other too-few criticisms of military action in north Mail, the shooting into a crowd of protesters in Kidal on November 28, was disputed in the Security Council on January 16.
  In a statement prepared like a defense attorney, trying raise reasonable doubt, Mali's Permanent Representative Sekou Kasse said that the UN Mission MINUSMA elements closest to the shooting were 400 meters away, precluding them from "objective" testimony. 
  The argument made was one must wait for the ballistic analysis ordered by the Malian government itself. Will that be credible? Shouldn't the Council, or less "invested" Council members, inquire into this during the two day visit?
 Again, similarly, can statements by the French Mission to the UN, about military action in its former colony Mali and related topics, be believed? If so, does that require disbelieving the UN itself, whose reports are different?
  In the run-up to the UN Security Council's January 16 meeting on Mali, both France and the UN Mission MINUSMA filed reports. It's worth comparing their accounts of the same incidents, for example on October 23, 2013 in Tessalit.
France gave a Polyanna report emphasizing its good works and downplaying death:
"On 23 October 2013, in response to an attack on a Chadian post in Tessalit by a commando made up of three armed terrorist groups using a vehicle-borne improvised explosive device, the Operation Serval Liaison and Support Detachment assigned to the Chadian battalion assisted MINUSMA by conducting a patrol with a Mirage 2000D jet and sending a CASA 'Nurse' medical evacuation aircraft. The end result was that six wounded Chadians were evacuated and the remaining explosives were neutralized."
  The UN by contrast recounts seven deaths including five civilians (one child) and two peacekeepers:
"On 23 October, four individuals drove and detonated a vehicle-borne improvised explosive device into a MINUSMA checkpoint in Tessalit. Seven people were killed, including four adult civilians, a six-year-old boy and two MINUSMA peacekeepers."
  This type of disparities in reporting - misleading - would and should be delved into into during the two day Council trip. How and where will these disparities be explained?
  One might say, ask at the Security Council stakeout. But in mid JanuaryFrench Permanent Representative Gerard Araud used the stakeout to rail against publication of a New York Police Department document concerning a French diplomat -- contrasting with the case of Indian diplomat Khobragade -- an NYPD document on which Araud's French Mission to the UN had declined to comment, responding only with threats that publication would a "hostile act."
 While continuing to pursue that, particularly given developments in the Khobragade case, delving into the French report, and the roles of UN Peacekeeping, MINUSMA and their respective leadership(s), should be done - including by the Council during their two days "on the ground." Watch this site.

 
  

Monday, February 3, 2014

After UN Gives "Climate & Cities" Post to Bloomberg, He Speaks on His Africa TV Station, Covers Mining and Air France: Conflicts of Interest?


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, February 3 -- Three days after the UN announced a "climate change and cities" post for Michael Bloomberg, and Inner City Press asked about conflicts of interest, Bloomberg is in the news on his own Bloomberg Africa TV, which covers such issues as Air France and mining on The Continent.

   So Inner City Press went to the February 3 UN noon briefing and asked for whom Bloomberg is speaking, the UN or himself?  Video here from Minute 14:52. UN spokesperson Martin Nesirky replied that his deputy Farhan Haq had answered on this on January 31. 

  But Haq on January 31 after citing "terms of reference" said they are not public, instead to look at a press release which, it turns out, contains no safeguards. Nesirky said this is an early stage, and that is true. But it already seems clear that safeguards will be necessary. For now: UNIFEED video of Ban Ki-moon and team dining with Bloomberg, here.
  On January 31 Inner City Press asked Haq if any thought had been given to possible conflicts of interest, or restrictions on how information or access from the post could be used, given Bloomberg's businesses.
  The UN's Haq replied, "I believe appropriate terms of reference have been worked out with former Mayor Bloombeg, that should be an acceptable arrangement devised between them." Video here and embedded below.
  Inner City Press asked if these "terms of reference" were public and could be seen. Haq said "No... What's public is a lengthy press release available in our office."
  But the press release does not address any safeguards on conflict of interest at all. 

  As Inner City Press noted before the UN's announcement, when Michael Bloomberg was Mayor of New York, in light of obvious conflicts of interest he stepped back from Bloomberg News. He was criticized on issues ranging from stop-and-frisk to defending banks against minimal City community reinvestment standards.
  Now, according to one gushing report, he is poised to move to the United Nations, as envoy on cities and climate change. What about new conflicts of interest, and the above critiques?
  To give what credit is due, on the evening of January 30 Reuters' UN bureau issued a breathless "exclusive" with nothing but praise of Bloomberg -- not a word of any criticism, nothing on the conflict of interest with Bloomberg News purporting to cover the UN and Secretary General Ban Ki-moon. Given the percentage of the piece praising Bloomberg, that would seem to be the (anonymous) sourcing.
  Meanwhile at the UN on January 30, Inner City Press on climate changeasked Ban's acting deputy spokesperson Farhan Haq of documents leaked by Edward Snowden showing that the NSA spied on the Copenhagen talks in 2009:
Inner City Press: there’s one of the [Edward] Snowden-released documents, but there’s a reason I’m asking you is it’s published in a Danish website “Information”and it talks about the Copenhagen climate change talks of 2009. And this seems to be the document and it says that the NSA [United States National Security Agency] was involved in monitoring communications at the discussions in order to advise the United States on the position of other Governments and presumably at the UN. So, I’m wondering, this seems to get more closely into things that are of much import to the UN, to the Secretary-General. Is there any response as to this memo coming out and the propriety of such surveillance?
Acting Deputy Spokesperson: Well, we wouldn’t have any specific response to this because ultimately, again, this is a case where we’d need to know what the basic facts are and whether there was any such surveillance that’s happened. However, our basic point that we’ve articulated many times in recent months still holds: that the inviolability of diplomatic premises needs to be respected by all States.
  If Bloomberg is named on Friday, or is named at all, what will the coverage of criticism and conflicts of interest be? Watch this site.
Footnote: While giving what credit is due to Reuters' UN bureau, despite their history, it must be noted that the bureau chief has not only spied for the UN -- he has also misused the US Digital Millennium Copyright Act to get Google to block from its search a leaked document showing him trying to get the investigative Press thrown out of the UN. All of this.. is how this UN works, or doesn't.

 
  

In Mali, French PR Bullet Points Have Nothing on Kidal or UN Peacekeepers' Alleged Rapes, Of Morocco & MNLA, FrancAfrique


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, February 3 -- Before the Mali press conference led by French Ambassador Gerard Araud at the MINUSMA headquarters in Bamako on February 3, Inner City Press asked at the UN's noon briefing about access to the event, where questions about Kidal and alleged gang rapes by peacekeepers could and should be asked. Video here, from Minute 19:05.

 UN spokesperson Martin Nesirky said Internet speeds are slow but he hoped his colleagues in UN Peacekeeping were listening and could dial. This did not happen; the MINUSMA mission made Inner City Press aware of bullet points to open the press conference and a photo with Araud in the middle, other Ambassadors sitting behind. Inner City Press has asked for the Q&A.

  Meanwhile it emerges that King Mohammed VI of French ally Morocco is meeting with the MNLA, giving more credence to pre-existing doubts. It's all a French connection: are the Council and most of the UN, other than French-run UN Peacekeeping, just along with the ride?

  During the Council's Mali trip, MINUSMA produced and uploaded a series of YouTube videos, heavy on the positions of French Ambassador Gerard Araud.
  Inner City Press noted that the "interview" uploaded from Mopti, where the Council did not meet representatives from Kidal in the North, omitted all of the questions asked. Inner City Press asked why, and on behalf of the Free UN Coalition for Access asked that the Council's 7 pm press conference be live-streamed or otherwise made accessible in real time.
  MINUSMA responded that "Internet speed is not sufficiently fast, sorry for that." FUNCA has asked that questions can be posed and answered by Twitter, as done for example the UN in Somalia and the Democratic Republic of the Congo (from which envoy Martin Kobler complained on February 3 of protesters stoning UN vehicles; Kobler did a live-streamed Twitter Q&A.)
  We note that from Mail the UN's MINUSMA, despite the statement about Internet speed, has continued to put online Araud (and envoy Bert Koenders) videos on YouTube, for example here and here. Koenders claimed that with president IBK, "all the aspects" were discussed -- but still nothing has been said pubicly about the failure to meet with those from Kidal, and about the alleged gang rapes by UN peacekeepers.
  Araud went further in his MINUSMA video, quoting US Ambassador Samantha Power that strong-man IBK is "impressive," video here at Minute 0;40, and calling his dialogue "completely inclusive" despite the absence of those from Kidal.
  So will these questions be asked, allowed and answered at "the Security Council's" 7 pm press conference? The Free UN Coalition for Access has asked.
 That the Malian Presidency proudly links to a Radio France Internationale story praising the French ambassador as "at once very nuance and very clear" is one thing.
  Now the UN Peacekeeping mission in Mali MINUSMA has edited and posted a video of Ambassador Araud, with all questions edited out. Click here. Thus Araud is able to speak about "inspecting" the UN force, without anything about oversight of the French Serval force the UN belated authorized.
  (Will the 7 p.m. press conference at MINUSMA headquarters in Bamako be live-streamed? One would think with the money spent that the UN could do it. But will they?)
  Likewise, Araud speaks of meeting with the armed groups of the north without saying anything about Kidal.
   It's one thing that the Security Council members did not visit the north due to safety concerns. But given the centrality of Kidal to the split in the country, how could their meeting in Mopti with "civil society" from the north not include Kidal? 
  It is confirmed, by French-selected scribes: the Council met with it "civil society from Timbuktu, Gao and Mopti" - and NOT from Kidal. But the scribes, typically, did not question the omission, much less disparities in description of killings in Kidal or the lack of transparency by the UN about gang rapes by its peacekeepers, despite claims of "zero tolerance."
  On February 3, France's Operation Serval is set to make a presentation. While the Security Council has so far remained silent about France's Operation Sangaris' killings in Central African Republic, and taking sides and leaving some at risk as even Navi Pillay noted, more should be expected in person in Mali.
MaliActu, a publication on which the government in Bamako has previously cracked down and threatened, reported that Kidal was notrepresented in the meeting: "Les émissaires de l’ONU ont rencontré les représentants de la société civile -chefs religieux ou traditionnels, fonctionnaires- de Mopti, Gao, et Tombouctou, mais pas de Kidal."  
  It and the below are important issues, but are not addressed in the tweetsand facebook-ed statements of the Council members on the trip, much less in MINUSMA's upbeat photos of Bert Koenders and France's Gerard Araud inspecting the troops. 
   Did the Security Council, led by France and Chad, meet with leaders from Kidal or not? Especially given the dipute, below, about killings in Kidal?
  So far, the way France arranges this trips like the one to the Democratic Republic of the Congo last year, there is too little media coverage, at least online, about the trip. 
   Alongside a growing with of tweets (beginning with UK, Lithuania, US,now joined by Luxembourg, Bert Koenders and Araud inspecting the troops),, the Council members have returned to Bamako. Not yet mentioned: the UNresolved charges of gang rape by the UN peacekeepers from Chad.
  If the UN's and Security Council's stated policies on sexual violence and conflict and "Zero Tolerance" mean anything, the issue will have to be addressed, and publicly, during the two day trip.
  Back on January 16 the UN Spokesperson's Office sent Inner City Press this response, which does not answer the question of accountability. But here it is, in full:
Subject: Your question on Mali
From: UN Spokesperson - Do Not Reply [at] un.org
Date: Thu, Jan 16, 2014 at 3:23 PM
To: Matthew.Lee [at] innercitypress.com
In response to your question about the follow-up to the allegations of sexual assault by United Nations peacekeepers in MINUSMA in September 2013, we have received the following information:
The Department of Peacekeeping Operations officially notified the Government of Chad of these allegations in late September. The Government of Chad officially responded, saying that it would take responsibility for the investigations. The Government of Chad has further advised the Department of Peacekeeping Operations that it has completed the national investigation, and the United Nations awaits advice on the outcome of the investigations and follow-up accountability measures as appropriate.
  The UN is waiting for "advice" -- but will it ever make it public? How else can the UN's stated Human Rights Due Diligence Policy be assessed?
  On January 17, Inner City Press asked UN acting deputy spokesperson Farhan Haq about it. From the UN's transcript, video here and embedded below:
Inner City Press: On Mali, I wanted to thank you for this written answer you gave yesterday afternoon that Mali has said that its completed its investigation of the alleged rape in Mali by the Chadian troops. And it said that the UN awaits advice on the outcome of the investigation. And what I wanted to know is whether… what part of that is going to be made public, given both the human rights due diligence policy, etcetera? I appreciate you saying that the investigation is finished, but, has… did they clear the soldiers? Were the soldiers found guilty? Where does it stand?
Acting Deputy Spokesperson Haq: As we emailed to you, the Mission does await advice on the outcome of the proceedings. We know that there have been proceedings regarding the case. You know this is a case regarding sexual assault and so, we await further information from that. We’ll try to make public what we can of the information that we receive.
Inner City Press: So, they literally just told you that it’s complete, but…no indication on what was done? I guess I wonder when --
Acting Deputy Spokesperson: The information I have in the email that was sent to you is the information we have. If we have any further updates, we’ll share it with you at that point.
  Two weeks later, nothing. So what will members of the Security Council ask, find and make public?

  One of the UN's other too-few criticisms of military action in north Mail, the shooting into a crowd of protesters in Kidal on November 28, was disputed in the Security Council on January 16.
  In a statement prepared like a defense attorney, trying raise reasonable doubt, Mali's Permanent Representative Sekou Kasse said that the UN Mission MINUSMA elements closest to the shooting were 400 meters away, precluding them from "objective" testimony. 
  The argument made was one must wait for the ballistic analysis ordered by the Malian government itself. Will that be credible? Shouldn't the Council, or less "invested" Council members, inquire into this during the two day visit?
 Again, similarly, can statements by the French Mission to the UN, about military action in its former colony Mali and related topics, be believed? If so, does that require disbelieving the UN itself, whose reports are different?
  In the run-up to the UN Security Council's January 16 meeting on Mali, both France and the UN Mission MINUSMA filed reports. It's worth comparing their accounts of the same incidents, for example on October 23, 2013 in Tessalit.
France gave a Polyanna report emphasizing its good works and downplaying death:
"On 23 October 2013, in response to an attack on a Chadian post in Tessalit by a commando made up of three armed terrorist groups using a vehicle-borne improvised explosive device, the Operation Serval Liaison and Support Detachment assigned to the Chadian battalion assisted MINUSMA by conducting a patrol with a Mirage 2000D jet and sending a CASA 'Nurse' medical evacuation aircraft. The end result was that six wounded Chadians were evacuated and the remaining explosives were neutralized."
  The UN by contrast recounts seven deaths including five civilians (one child) and two peacekeepers:
"On 23 October, four individuals drove and detonated a vehicle-borne improvised explosive device into a MINUSMA checkpoint in Tessalit. Seven people were killed, including four adult civilians, a six-year-old boy and two MINUSMA peacekeepers."
  This type of disparities in reporting - misleading - would and should be delved into into during the two day Council trip. How and where will these disparities be explained?
  One might say, ask at the Security Council stakeout. But in mid JanuaryFrench Permanent Representative Gerard Araud used the stakeout to rail against publication of a New York Police Department document concerning a French diplomat -- contrasting with the case of Indian diplomat Khobragade -- an NYPD document on which Araud's French Mission to the UN had declined to comment, responding only with threats that publication would a "hostile act."
 While continuing to pursue that, particularly given developments in the Khobragade case, delving into the French report, and the roles of UN Peacekeeping, MINUSMA and their respective leadership(s), should be done - including by the Council during their two days "on the ground." Watch this site.