Wednesday, January 8, 2014

As France Openly Picks & "Holds Back" Leaders in Central African Republic, Colonialism Not Mentioned be Reuters, Accepted by UN Secretariat?


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, January 8 -- On Central African Republic on January 6 some noted that UN Department of Political Affairs chief Jeffrey Feltman avoided directly answering on France's lack of impartiality in its intervention in its former colony.  

   Feltman seemed to focus on the UN's role on humanitarian issues -- even on that, the UN has been subject to scathing criticism from Doctors Without Borders -- while leaving the finding of a political solution to others.

   Today, Reuters quotes three French officials, two named and one unnamed, opining about who should lead CAR, including, "Djotodia and us, it's not a love story. The quicker he goes, the better things will be. We are making do with him and holding him back."

   And yet Reuters, now the colonial news wire, did not mention FrancAfrique or this colonial relationship, whether such picking of leaders from outside like France did with Ahmad al Jarba in Syria, is appropriate. This is, to some, "the international community."
  Back on January 6 as the Central African Republic consultations of the UN Security Council stretched past 6 pm, Permanent Representatives then even Deputy Permanent Representatives left, even as new Council member Lithuania spoke.
One departing diplomat told Inner City Press that US Ambassador Samantha Power "gave a moving speech" but "it's not longer a time for speeches but action."
Inner City Press asked the diplomat if the sentiment is to move to a UN peacekeeping mission, or stay with MISCA (in which component contingents have fought each other) and the French SANGARIS force, accused of disarming the Seleka but not anti-balaka militia.
  The answer was UNclear. The briefer was the head of the UN's Department of Political Affairs, Jeffrey Feltman, whose statement during the open meeting said "this is the first case for the Secretary General's new Rights Upfront agenda." That was the UN's belated reaction to its own systemic failure during the killing of tens of thousands of civilians in Sri Lanka in 2009.
  But last month Doctors Without Borders pilloried the UN for not protecting civilians, even inside its own compounds, and for not deploying despite requests to Yaloke and Bouca. UN humanitarian chief Valerie Amos told Inner City Pressshe was "disappointed" by MSF's letter. What would Feltman say?
  When finally Feltman emerged, Inner City Press asked him about reports of France disarming the Seleka, not the predominantly Christian anti-balaka. Feltman replied that a "non-discriminatory way" is required, all most be disarmed. He said more coordination is needed between the UN, France's Sangaris, and MISCA. 
 Moments later, Inner City Press asked Jordan's Permanent Representative Prince Zeid, the president of the Security Council for January, about perceived (im)partiality. He responded that the situation is complex, as African members pointed out, and that he and other new Council members had material to work through. We'll see.

 
  

Bolivia Heads G77 Today, Day After UN Layoff Letters & Denials, Showdown Now & in March on Mobility & "Partnerships"?


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, January 8 -- Two months ago, that Bolivia would come to head the Group of 77 was first reported on November 6 by Inner City Press. Today, Evo Morales is in New York to accept the hand-over from Fiji's foreign minister.
   In the interim, between Christmas and New Years, a UN budget deal was concluded which resulted in UN staff getting"notices of termination" -- layoff letters -- handed to them on January 6. 
  (The UN spokesperson on January 7 refused to confirm the layoff letters, referring instead to a Town Hall meetingSecretary General Ban Ki-moon will have on January 9 at 9:30 am, 24 hours after meeting Evo Morales. But Inner City Press has now published one of the layoff letters, here.)
   While the Group of 77 works on a number of issues within the UN system, it is a major player in UN budget negotiations, as evidenced by Fiji's omni-presence in the UN's North Lawn building throughout December, and Algeria's the year before.
   Closing speeches in December made much of Ban Ki-moon in March 2014 "getting his way" on a mobility plan not fully accepted by staff, and on a corporate partnership scheme headed by long-time American UN official Robert Orr (a sample partner, here, at UN January 7 with no read-out yet.)
  What positions will Bolivia-led G77 take on these? On the current layoffs, and those to come? We will be covering this. 
  "Game on," one G77 Permanent Representative told Inner City Press back in November. The G-77 sources said the timing is propitious, including given Bolivia's standing up on issues like the searching of Evo Morales' plane. 
  (On the night of January 7, amid frigid temperature, Morales' plane landed without incident, as tweeted by Bolivia's Permanent Representative Sacha Llorenti.)
  They said, again speaking exclusively to Inner City Press, that while in the past the UN Secretariat's budget proposals were closer to the side of the developing world, and then richer countries tried to scale them back, now "Ban Ki-moon has sided in advance with the rich."
  Similar cuts are proposed in the UN Development Program and also UNICEF, with talk of "nodes," under Anthony Lake, outsourcing and off-shoring jobs from New York. These were denounced by many speakers at an October 31 meeting of the Staff Union. Click here for that.
   Y ahora de verdad, Bolivia. Watch this site.

 
  

Tuesday, January 7, 2014

Exclusive: After UN Issues Lay-Off Letters, Won't Confirm Them, But Here Is One, Now Put Online by Inner City Press


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, January 7 -- The UN handed out lay-off letters to staff on the morning of Monday, January 6, as exclusively reported by Inner City Press. 

  But on January 7, UN spokesperson Farhan Haq refused to confirm that the UN had given out the "notices of termination," either at the noon briefing when Inner City Press asked about them -- video here and embedded below -- or in at least the seven hours that followed.

Instead, Haq said that the initial move would be "Town Hall" meetings with staff, including one involving Secretary General Ban Ki-moon. Here's from the UN's January 7 transcript:

Inner City Press: there were people who work in the Publishing Section here at the UN, received letters yesterday that seemed to talk about separation from service, notices of termination. I wanted to know, is that accurate? Since the budget was adopted in late December, have there been, essentially, lay-off letters issued, and, if so, how many?
Acting Deputy Spokesperson Haq: I don’t… the budget was only just agreed to. I believe that there’s a series of Town Hall meetings being conducted with staff to reflect on what the results of the budget mean. So I’ll wait for those town hall meetings to proceed and then let’s see whether we can say anything further after that.
Inner City Press: I’m specifically asking about a DGACM [Department for General Assembly and Conference Management] meeting that was held yesterday at 11:15, at which letters were handed out, called formal termination, notice of termination and separation of service letters. I just want your confirmation that, prior to the town hall and anything else, that these letters did go out.
Acting Deputy Spokesperson Haq: I’m not aware of anything like that. I can check with them, but ultimately the initial result of the last few weeks’ developments on a budget is that we’ll be able to discuss with staff through town hall meetings. I believe one of them was happening today with the Deputy Secretary-General and the Chef de Cabinet. I believe the Secretary-General will also have town hall meetings with staff.
  Well, prior to this "Town Hall meeting," which Inner City Press will also cover, the letter DID go out. Inner City Press had on January 6 published the e-mail inviting those to be laid-off to the meeting to get the letter, and now publishes, with consent, one of the lay-off letters, here.

 The letters were dated December 31, 2013 and were handed out on January 6, 2013. But see January 7 noon briefing



 Why would the UN not confirm what it did? In seven hours after they were asked, and the Department and even (sub) Section at issue was specified? 
  The UN wants to be perceived in one way, and to operate in another. 
  This is true with regard to freedom of the press and of association, too, as combated by the new Free UN Coalition for Access - for example, the UN on January 7 met with Google's "Head of Free Expression" after Google banned from its Search a leaked anti-Press email to the UN from the bureau chief of Reuters based on a bad faith complaint under the US Digital Millennium Copyright Act. Now, legal questions exist about these notices of termination. We'll have more on this. Watch this site.

 
  

In South Sudan, As UN Self-Reports from Bentiu, Khartoum Contradictions UNsaid


By Matthew Russell Lee
UNITED NATIONS, January 7 -- After reports of South Sudan president Salva Kiir and Sudan's Omar al Bashir discussing a joint oil protection force, the plight of Sudanese nationals holed up in the UN compound in Bentiu is all the more troubling.
  On January 5 the UN Mission in South Sudan, reporting on itself, said that "foreign governments have worked with UNMISS to relocate their citizens. Some, including Kenya, Ethiopia, Eritrea and Uganda have chartered planes to Bentiu or Heglig to bring their people back home."
  Heglig is the oil town the SLPA damage to which became a big issue in the UN Security Council back in April 2012.Click here for Inner City Press reporting from that time.
  So other countries fly their nationals from Bentui to Heglig -- but Sudan cannot? Or does not? The UNMISS self-reportdoes not ask the question. Nor does the UN say who controls Mayom, or answer questions about Rubkona, across the river from Bentiu.
  Back on December 20, Inner City Press asked then Security Council president Gerard Araud of France about Rubkona. Video here, from Minute 12:54. Araud said the issue did not come up; the French mission's transcript spelled it "Rupkona." Now what?
 Again, despite the UN's stated focus on South Sudan, it will not squarely answer the most basic questions about it. 
  At the UN noon briefing on January 6, Inner City Press asked spokesperson Farhan Haq to confirm that UNMISS had been asked to provide protection to MP Kong Dak Jishlive, whose house near UNDP in Juba was reported repeatedly raided by authorities.
  Three hours later there was neither confirmation nor denial. At the January 7 noon briefing, without having sent any e-mail answer to Inner City Press, Haq read out a (non) answer, that UNMISS does protect some people but will not answer on this MP.
   Inner City Press also asked Haq on January 6 what the UN thought of the lack of women in the negotiations in Addis Ababa, other than Rebecca Garang and perhaps a few others. The UN talks endlessly about this, under Security Council resolution 1325 and many since.
 (In fact, UN Department of Political Affairs chief Jeffrey Feltman cited Resolution 1325 later on January 6 -- but that was about the Central African Republic. And the Security Council will hold an Arria formula meeting on January 17 about the participation of women in talks -- on Syria. What of South Sudan?)
  Haq said they are IGAD's negotiations, adding that of course the UN like representative delegations to talks. But what does the UN do about it? As long as South Sudan has been a country, and before, the UN has been there.
  Half an hour later at incoming Security Council president Zeid's press conference, Inner City Press asked about the talks between presidents Kiir and Bashir about a joint oil security force. He said to wait for the Security Council's January 9th meeting on Sudan and South Sudan. We'll be there.
Even in South Sudan, the lack of transparency by UN Peacekeeping does not serve it. On December 30, Department of Peacekeeping Operations chief Herve Ladsous admonished South Sudan to not put in "caveat" on accepting troops from any country.
Though Ladsous didn't name the country -- for reasons that soon became obvious -- and later in the week UN spokesperson Farhan Haq declined to specify any country being considered for South Sudan, later on December 30 at the UN Mission of an African (and troop contributing) country Inner City Press was told Ladsous was trying to push into South Sudan peacekeeping from Morocco. Click here for more on that.
  After telling Inner City Press "I don't answer you Mister," Ladsous dodged about the impact of shifting peacekeepers out of Darfur, where two had just been killed, and the Democratic Republic of the Congo. Then he mentioned, for South Sudan, "half a regiment" from the MINUSTAH mission in Haiti. UN Video here, from Minute 3:09.
  Now, which country's half-regiment could that be? Questions have been asked, particularly in light of UN Peacekeeping's dubious record in Haiti: the introduction of cholera, multiple cases of sexual abuse or exploitation, nearly always followed by mere repatriation and no update on any discipline meted out, for example in the case of repatriated Sri Lanka peacekeepers.
Inner City Press: Yes, Farhan. I wanted to ask you two questions about peacekeeping in South Sudan. One is that, it’s reported that India is unhappy with not being consulted in some of the ways their peacekeepers were used and intends to send its own military team to meet with its peacekeepers there. I wanted to know, separately, [Permanent Representative Asoke Kumar] Mukerji has, over the holidays, said that the Force Intervention Brigade may put peacekeepers in danger. What’s your response to that? And also, if you could confirm, I’ve heard that the UN wants to send Moroccan peacekeepers to South Sudan and they’re pushing back. And one of their reasons for pushing back is that Morocco is not a member of the African Union due to the Western Sahara. And I wanted if it’s DPKO’s (Department of Peacekeeping Operations) position that countries don’t have a right to have a sort of principled, political stand on why they wouldn’t take peacekeepers? Or should they take anyone that DPKO sends?
Acting Deputy Spokesperson Haq: Well, first of all, we wouldn’t comment on the specifics of how we’re trying to bring more peacekeepers in. We, as you know, are in touch with a number of Member States trying to build up the forces, as was approved by the Security Council. And when we have details of which countries are coming in, we’ll provide those details at that point. But, I don’t have any specific names to give up until more arrivals come in.
Inner City Press: I ask that only because Mr. [Hervé] Ladsous at the stakeout made a big point of saying, it’s not… when the house is on fire, anyone must be taken. So, I just wanted to know, can you say… is that the UN’s position? That even if there’s a political, principled stated reason not to take them… that wouldn’t… that should be overridden?
Acting Deputy Spokesperson: For us, the priority is to get as many peacekeepers in as we can. They’ve been authorized by the Security Council. We’re trying to get the right numbers in order to stop the bloodshed as soon as we possibly can. So, that’s our priority. But, if we have any specific announcements to make about different countries joining in, we’ll make it at that point. But, that’s not ready at this stage.
Inner City Press: And on India?
Acting Deputy Spokesperson: I wouldn’t have any comment on that. Is that it? Okay? Pam?
Correspondent: Hi, Farhan. I’d like to just correct the record that was established at this briefing a few weeks ago that the UN Correspondents’ Association has not… does not have any new Samsung TV sets in the room, never has had and has never accepted any donation or loan from the UN for Samsung TVs. Thank you.
Acting Deputy Spokesperson: Yeah, thanks. I’m in receipt of aletter from the United Nations Correspondent’s Association, which says, which does read: “Please be advised that there are no new Samsung TV sets in the UNCA room and have never been. And the UN Correspondents’ Association has not accepted a donation or loan of new Samsung TVs”. Thanks for that update. We’ll try to get any updated guidance about the language that we had earlier received. Yes?
Inner City Press: Because I’m thinking maybe you’ll correct the transcript on the answer that was given to me in writing about the television. If so, do you have any response about the note verbale that was filed by Syria that we previously discussed here?
Acting Deputy Spokesperson: No, there’s no response to that at present. But, yes, if there’s any fresh language on the language that was given to you, we’ll try to correct the record here. Yes, Lou?
Watch this site.

 
  

As Syria Says Geneva II Outcome Would Need Referendum, No UN Comment, UN Media Rules, Censors' Meeting


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, January 7 -- With the Syria "Geneva Two" talks still set for January 22, albeit in Montreux, on January 7 Inner City Press asked UN spokesperson Farhan Haq what the UN thought of Syrian information minister saying whatever is agreed there would be subject to a referendum in Syria. Video here and embedded below.

The UN's Haq declined, twice, to comment on the idea of a referendum, saying that such review would itself be subject to the negotiations in Switzerland, to which thirty countries (not including Iran) and three organizations beyond the UN have been invited.



At the US State Department on January 6, deputy spokesperson Marie Harf was asked if Iran might have some "associate" role at the talks -- it sounded like a side table for children.

  On January 7, the UN sent reporters its rules for accreditation to cover the talks, including that media must be "formally registered as a media organization in a country recognized by the United Nations General Assembly" and that the UN "reserves the right to deny or withdraw accreditation of journalists from media organizations whose activities run counter to the principles of the Charter of the United Nations." 
The Free UN Coalition for Access has been critiquing and opposing these type of vague UN rules, which invite double standards and hypocrisy, such as is demonstrated by the January 7 visit to the UN of Google's "Head of Free Expression" Ross LaJeunesse after Google censored from its Search a leaked e-mail to the UN from Reuters' bureau chief, who sought to get the investigative Press thrown out of the UN.
Do the principles of the UN include freedom of expression? Democracy? Watch this site.

 
  

Google "Head of Free Expression" Comes to UN, After Censoring Leaked Reuters E-mail to UN from Its Search under Digital Millennium Copyright Act: Abuse


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, January 7 -- Google's "Global Head of Free Expression" Ross LaJeunesse meets at the UN later today with Deputy Secretary General Jan Eliasson. See UN notice, saved here.

  It is ironic: most recently regarding the UN, Google allowed a censorship-related leaked document to be blocked from its Search, based on a bad faith complaint by Reuters bureau chief under the US Digital Millennium Copyright Act.

  So what is LaJeunesse at the UN to discuss: more censorship? 

  There are further ironies. Prior to lobbying for Google, LaJeunesse worked for California's then-Governor Arnold Schwartzenegger, who 13 months ago was given an award by the United Nations Correspondents Association. This is the group which tried to get the investigative Press thrown out of the UN for its reporting on Sri Lanka -- a topic on which Eliasson now leads up the UN's post-failure "Rights Upfront" initiative. 

   While free press protections are in some ways advanced in the United States, as the Free UN Coalition for Access has begun highlighting, the US Digital Millennium Copyright Act can be and has been used as an end-run attack on freedom of the press.

(Another irony: from UN transcripts of Eliasson's press conference, the "Free UN Coalition for Access" introduction was omitted, while the UN's Censorship Alliance was left in, click here for that.)

    Bigger picture, as exemplified by an August 14, 2013 bad faith complaint to Google by Reuters' UN bureau chief Louis Charbonneau, DMCA's provisions for "take-down" or blocking of information with no prior judicial review allow for abuse.

   Leaked documents used in an investigative story can be blocked, as the Reuters' complaint to Google blocked from Google's search its bureau chief's e-mail to the UN seeking to get Inner City Press thrown out. This is a perversion of the concept of copyright (as well as a contradictory argument for Reuters or anyone in journalism to be making, that such documents should be taken down or blocked.)

   In Chile, for example, any such take-down requires the requester to get a court order. But DMCA provides, and Google allowed, blocking based on a non-reviewed, bad faith complaint.

  As the Electronic Frontier Foundation's Intellectual Property Director Corynne McSherry told Inner City Press about the case:

"Unfortunately, it is all too easy for a copyright holder (assuming that the person that sent this notice actually held copyright in the email) to abuse the DMCA to take down content and stifle legitimate speech. As countries outside the US consider adopting DMCA-like procedures, they must make sure they include strong protections for free speech, such as significant penalties for takedown abuse."
  Along with other pro-corporate provisions, TPP would internationalize this abuse of copyright to undermine freedom of the press.  
 If this remains precedent, what else could come down?
  Why not an email from Iran, for example, to the UN's International Atomic Energy Agency? Why not a sanctions filing by a country? Here is Reuters logic, accepted if only automatically by Google:
The copyrighted material is a private email I wrote in April 2012 and for which I never gave permission to be published. It has been published on a blog and appears in on the first page of search results for my name and the firm I work for, Reuters. It can be seen here: http://www.innercitypress.com/reutersLC3unmalu.pdf
  But this is true of ANY leaked document: it can be said that the entity or person exposed "never gave permission [for it] to be published." Does that mean Google can or should block search access to it?
  Can a complaint to a Media Accreditation official against a competitor legitimately be considered "private"? In any event, the DMCA is not about protecting privacy.
  Iran or North Korea could say a filing or status report they make with the IAEA is "private" and was not intended to be published. Would Google, receiving a DMCA filing, block access to the information on, say, Reuters.com?
  Charbonneau's bad-faith argument says his complaint to the UN was "published on a blog." Is THAT what Reuters claims makes it different that publication in some other media?
  The logic of Reuters' and Charbonneau's August 14, 2013 filing with Google, put online via the ChillingEffects.org project, is profoundly anti free press.
  The fact that Google accepts or didn't check, to remain in the DMCA Safe Harbor, the filing makes it even worse. The request to take-down wasn't made to InnerCityPress.com or its server -- it would have been rejected. But banning a page from Search has the same censoring effect.
  The US has a regime to protect freedom of the press, and against prior restraint. But this is a loophole, exploited cynically by Reuters. What if a media conducted a long investigation of a mayor, fueled by a leaked email. When the story was published, could the Mayor make a Reuters-like filing with Google and get it blocked?
  Here is the text of Charbonneau's communication to the UN's top Media Accreditation and Liaison Unit official Stephane Dujarric and MALU's manager, to which he claimed "copyright" and for now has banned from Google's Search:
Hi Isabelle and Stephane,
I just wanted to pass on for the record that I was just confronted by Matt Lee in the DHL auditorium in very hostile fashion a short while ago (there were several witnesses, including Giampaolo). He's obviously gotten wind that there's a movement afoot to expel him from the UNCA executive committee, though he doesn't know the details yet. But he was going out of his way to be as intimidating and aggressive as possible towards me, told me I "disgust" him, etc.
In all my 20+ years of reporting I've never been approached like that by a follow journalist in any press corps, no matter how stressful things got. He's become someone who's making it very hard for me and others in the UN press to do our jobs. His harassment of fellow reporters is reaching a new fever pitch.
I just thought you should know this.
Cheers,
Lou
Louis Charbonneau
Bureau Chief. United Nations
Reuters News Thomson Reuters reuters. com
This email was sent to you by Thomson Reuters, the global news and information company.
"UNCA" in the for-now banned e-mail is the United Nations Correspondents Association. The story developed here, as to Sri Lanka; here is a sample pick-up in Italian. Watch this site.

Monday, January 6, 2014

Outside Central African Republic Crisis UNSC Meeting, "Time for Speeches Is Over," Now What? Feltman & Zeid on (Im) Partiality


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, January 6 -- As the Central African Republic consultations of the UN Security Council stretched past 6 pm on January 6, Permanent Representatives then even Deputy Permanent Representatives left, even as new Council member Lithuania spoke.

One departing diplomat told Inner City Press that US Ambassador Samantha Power "gave a moving speech" but "it's not longer a time for speeches but action."
Inner City Press asked the diplomat if the sentiment is to move to a UN peacekeeping mission, or stay with MISCA (in which component contingents have fought each other) and the French SANGARIS force, accused of disarming the Seleka but not anti-balaka militia.
  The answer was UNclear. The briefer was the head of the UN's Department of Political Affairs, Jeffrey Feltman, whose statement during the open meeting said "this is the first case for the Secretary General's new Rights Upfront agenda." That was the UN's belated reaction to its own systemic failure during the killing of tens of thousands of civilians in Sri Lanka in 2009.
  But last month Doctors Without Borders pilloried the UN for not protecting civilians, even inside its own compounds, and for not deploying despite requests to Yaloke and Bouca. UN humanitarian chief Valerie Amos told Inner City Pressshe was "disappointed" by MSF's letter. What would Feltman say?
  When finally Feltman emerged, Inner City Press asked him about reports of France disarming the Seleka, not the predominantly Christian anti-balaka. Feltman replied that a "non-discriminatory way" is required, all most be disarmed. He said more coordination is needed between the UN, France's Sangaris, and MISCA. 
 Moments later, Inner City Press asked Jordan's Permanent Representative Prince Zeid, the president of the Security Council for January, about perceived (im)partiality. He responded that the situation is complex, as African members pointed out, and that he and other new Council members had material to work through. We'll see.