Monday, April 8, 2013

On Syria, Qatar's and Others' UNGA Draft Resolution Inches Forward, Amid Vuk Jeremic's Tribunal Session and Smoke: Scoop



By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive
UNITED NATIONS, April 8 -- As UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon and his German negotiator Angela Kane play chicken with the Syrian government on the scope of the requested chemical weapons probe, another move is afoot at the UN in New York.
  Inner City Press has learned of another Qatar sponsored draft resolution making its way to the UN General Assembly. A draft was completed last Thursday, April 4. Issues include, of course, chemical weapons: and representation, Syria's UN seat, a "first step on that issue," as an Inner City Press source put it.
Also involved in drafting, the sources say, have been Saudi Arabia and the P-3 (France, UK and US, an acronym some use). Last year when Qatar's Nassir Abdulaziz Al-Nasser was President of the General Assembly, the moves were more out in the open.
  When Syrian Ambassador Bashar Ja'afari objected, asking under what rule the sponsors were proceeding, Nassir Abdulaziz Al-Nasser dismissed the question, saying merely, we have the votes.
Now Vuk Jeremic, Serbia's former foreign minister, is General Assembly President. Ja'afari praised him, here.
  From inside the PGA's Office in the increasingly empty North Lawn Building, where Nassir Abdulaziz Al-Nasser's chief of staff the slayer of Javier Ruperez once held court, Inner City Press is exclusively told of cigar smoking and dark talk.
  Jeremic's focus is on the UN's ad hoc tribunals, the session scheduled for April 10, now with Ban Ki-moon attending between Pope Francis and a Washington visit to Barack Obama. So will Qatar's Syria resolution have to wait? Watch this site.

At UN, Rule of Law Measurement Session Goes Into Overtime Despite Impunity on Cholera in Haiti, Whistleblowers Blindspots, Raid



By Matthew Russell Lee
UNITED NATIONS, April 8 -- At the UN Monday they debated how to measure the rule of law. What they couldn't measure was time.
  The session left less than ten minutes for questions before a closed meeting of the North Korea sanctions committee was to start in the same airless room.
  This allowed for only three questions or “interventions,” and even that caused protocol kerfuffles. A man with a statement from the Inter-Parliamentary Union was called on before an ambassador from Togo.
  The UK's Deputy Permanent Representative Philip Parham whispered that the Togolese Ambassador should be given the floor. He was, and asked three detailed question which the moderator said had to be answered in three minutes.Photo here.
  By then, Irene Khan had left, after Deputy Secretary General Jan Eliasson, as had an African Permanent Representative. No questions were allowed from the media. Inner City Press wonders, how can the UN measure anyone's rule of law when it so tersely dismissed legal claims for bringing cholera for Haiti?
  When it raids, without notice or consent, the office of critical media, takes pictures which are then leaked to BuzzFeed.com as soon as they ask the UN about the raid? This is the rule of law?
  An outside speaker, a professor, told a story about a scientist trying to measure the weight of the soul, bodies before and just after death. There was laughter. Remember: who brought cholera to Haiti? Rule of law indeed. Watch this site.

As Whistleblower Wasserstrom Calls for Cut in US Funds to UN, Ban Ki-moon's UN Is Silent, Raids Press Offices, Leaks Photos to BuzzFeed




By Matthew Russell Lee
UNITED NATIONS, April 8 -- After the UN staffer James Wasserstrom blew the whistle in 2007 on corruption in the UN Peacekeeping mission in Kosovo, he was retaliated against. For example, his home was illegally searched, and the UN arranged to attack him in the media.
  Inner City Press wrote in 2007 about the corruption, by Joachim Ruecker, Stephen Schook, and Alexander Borg-Olivier and others. Click here for one example. On Monday Inner City Press asked Wasserstrom where these individuals are now.
  Wasserstrom said Rucker is an official in the German foreign service, while Schook is an adviser to a senior political official in Kosovo and Borg-Olivier is a lawyer in private practice in Kosovo.
  There has been no accountability for those who retaliated against Wasserstrom for blowing the whistle; he has been awarded a mere $65,000, far less than his costs.
  As Shelley Walden of the Government Accountability Project put it, at the UN even when whistleblowers win, they lose.
  Inner City Press asked Walden if she or GAP have been able to raise this issue and the need to reform to Secretary General Ban Ki-moon or his team. No, she said, despite requests there was been total silence.
  So much for the supposedly reforming Secretary General.
  Wassterstrom is calling for activation of the whistleblower protection criteria adopted in the 2012 US Consolidated Appropriations Act (H.R. 2055).
   HR 2055 requires a 15% withholding of the US contribution to any UN agency if it "is not taking steps to … implement best practices for the protection of whistleblowers from retaliation, including best practices for legal burdens of proof, access to independent adjudicative bodies, [and] results that eliminate the effects of retaliation..."
  Inner City Press asked if the US Mission to the UN, particularly Ambassador for reform Joe Torsella has been helpful. 
  Walden said they've met with Torsella before, he's done what he can -- that, we'd like to hear more about -- and they they hoped to meet with later on Monday, if his schedule permits.
  Inner City Press has been covering Torsella's involvement in the negotiations around the UN Senior Advisory Group on Peacekeeping Operations, click here for that.
  Inner City Press asked Walden how whistleblower protections could be extended to actual UN peacekeepers and police, and to victims. Walden said none of these are currently covered by UN policies, only UN staff. And even then...
The UN also retaliated against the investigative press. On March 18, 2013, UN official raised Inner City Press' office without notice or consent.
On March 21, after Ban Ki-moon's spokesperson's office was contacted by outside media about the raid, photos taken during the raid were sent to BuzzFeed.com through an anonymous “Concerned UN Reporter” e-mail account. This seems to be a pattern, and will be confronted and combated, including by the new Free UN Coalition for Access. Watch this site.
Footnote: Inner City Press asked Walden about a previous UN system whistleblower case about North Korea. She said that the case of Artjon Tony Shkurtaj, on which Inner City Press extensively reported, showed the need for a UNDP ethics office. But how is it performing? We'll have more on UNDP.

In 2012 Subprime Lending Disparities Continued at Key Bank, Suntrust and US Bank, Denials at TD, Regions and Others as Fed Lax




By Matthew R. Lee

SOUTH BRONX NY, April 7, 2013 -- In its second study of the just-released 2012 mortgage lending data, Inner City Press and Bronx-based Fair Finance Watch have found that a range of regional banks including KeyCorp, US Bank NA and SunTrust Mortgage continued with high cost loans and disparities by race and ethnicity in denials and higher-cost lending.

  2012 is the ninth year in which the data distinguishes which loans are higher cost, over a federally-defined rate spread of 1.5 percent over Treasury bill yields.
The just released data show that KeyCorp confined African Americans to higher-cost loans above this rate spread 2.51 times more frequently than whites in 2012, Fair Finance Watch has found. 

  KeyCorp denied the applications of African Americans 1.76 times more frequently than those of whites.

  KeyCorp confined Latinos to higher-cost loans above the rate spread 1.53 times more frequently than whites in 2012, the data show. It denied the applications of Latinos 1.44 times more frequently than those of whites.

  SunTrust Mortgage confined African Americans to higher-cost loans above this rate spread 2.50 times more frequently than whites in 2012; for Latinos its disparity was 1.50.

  US Bank NA confined African Americans to higher-cost loans above this rate spread 1.74 times more frequently than whites in 2012; for Latinos its disparity was 1.97. There are some irregularities in US Bank NA's data that Inner City Press will be further raising.

“Even after the bailouts, lending disparities grew worse and not better," said Fair Finance Watch. "Regulatory laxity, at least on fair lending, has continued despite the financial meltdown caused by predatory lending."

  In 2012, Toronto Dominion or TD Bank denied the applications of African Americans 1.75 times more frequently than those of whites. For both PNC and Regions the disparity for African Americans was 1.57.

  "The Federal Reserve is becoming more and more bank-friendly, including with recent Freedom of Information Act appeal denials by Governor Jay Power, formerly a hedge funder and Deutsche Bank official Jay Powell. It remains unclear if the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau will get to this problem," Fair Finance Watch continued. "The disparities in the 2012 mortgage data of these banks further militate for aggressively watchdogging and breaking up these banks."

Instead, the Fed allowed the creation of a fifth mega-bank in Capital One when it acquired ING DIRECT and the subprime assets of HSBC. In 2012, Fair Finance Watch has found, HSBC denied the applications of African Americans 1.34 times more frequently than those of whites.

Also in 2012, fully 9.93 percent of Capital One's morgage loans to African American were higher cost loans, versus 7.61 percent of Capital One's loans to whites. To Latinos, the percentage was even higher: 10.31 percent.
And so Fair Finance Watch and Inner City Press have re-doubled watchdogging. Last week it studied the 2012 lending of the “Big Four” -- Citigroup, JPMorgan Chase,Bank of America and Wells Fargo.
The data show that Citigroup confined African Americans to higher-cost loans above this rate spread 2.09 times more frequently than whites in 2012, Fair Finance Watch found.
Citigroup confined Latinos to higher-cost loans above the rate spread 1.83 times more frequently than whites in 2012, the data show.
For JPMorgan Chase, the disparity for African Americans in 2012 was 1.7; for Bank of America it was 1.61; for the largest of Wells Fargo's many HMDA data reporters, the disparity for African Americans in 2011 was up to 2.32.
Challenged by the groups in 2012 and still pending are applications by Customers Bancorp and by M&T, to acquire Hudson City Savings Bank.
Regulators had allowed Hudson City in 2011, for conventional home purchase loans in the New York City Metropolitan Statistical Area, to make 765 such loans to whites and only FIVE to African Americans (and only 44 to Latinos). Meanwhile, Hudson City denied the applications of African Americans 3.21 times more frequently then those of whites.

In March 2013 Inner City Press and Fair Finance Watch began a challenge to Investors Bancorp's application to acquire Roma. In the NYC MSA in 2011 for conventional home purchase loans, Investors Bank made 220 such loans to whites, and only TWO such loans to African Americans. Its denial rate for Latinos was FIVE TIMES higher than for whites.

 On April 5, Investors Bancorp announced it will try to also acquire $300 million Gateway Community Financial Corp - this also will be opposed, on the current record.

The Home Mortgage Disclosure Act required that the 2012 data be provided by March 31, following March 1 joint requests by Fair Finance Watch and Inner City Press. Several banks still did not provide their data by the deadline, despite confirming receipt of the request. Further studies will follow: watch this site.

UN on Rwanda Genocide Rings False, Between Callixte Mbarushimana and Ladsous



By Matthew Russell Lee
UNITED NATIONS, April 7 -- Remembrances of the 1994 Rwanda genocide at the UN have an air of falsity to them, like some other things at the UN.
  Take for example the case of UN employee Callixte Mbarushimana. In 1994 he is strongly alleged to have used his UN vehicle and radio and access to assist in the killing of at least three dozen Tutsi, including Florence Ngirumpatse, the director of personnel at UNDP's office in Kigali.
  What did the UN do about this? They gave Mbarushimana other UN jobs including in Angola (for which he was not language-qualified) and in Kosovo, as if on an ethnic cleansing road trip. Only when outed did they act; then they ended up paying Mbarushimana an additional $35,000. 
  The International Criminal Court, charging him in connection with other killings in Eastern Congo in 2009, also failed.
What does this say about the UN? At the UN's French-free genocide memorial on April 7, 2008, Inner City Press asked asked Rwanda's then-Ambassador Nsengimana about Mbarushimana's case. "The UN's awareness came very late," he said, diplomatically.
  But it's gotten worse. As we asked yesterday and before, what does it say about the UN that Herve Ladsous, who in 1994 as French deputy permanent representative argued for the evacuation of the genocidaires to refuge in Eastern Congo through Operation Turquoise, is now chief of UN Peacekeeping?
When Ladsous held his first press conference as head of DPKO on October 13, 2011, Inner City Press asked him about his past on Rwanda. Video here, from Minute 22:50.
  All Ladsous would say that day was that was history, that was the past. But is it only the past?
  Ladsous has refused to answer Inner City Press questions about his previous work; most recently last month Tim Witcher of Agence France Presse, on an management board of which Ladsous used to serve, complained to the UN that Inner City Press asked Ladsous a question, or how it asked the question.
Click here for questions, refused by Ladsous in 2012 on November 27, December 7 and December 18, all about rapes in Minova by the Congolese Army.
  Plus ca change, as they say. Never again? Hardly. Watch this site.

Saturday, April 6, 2013

On Rwanda at UN, Herve Ladsous in 1994 Protected Genocidaires, Now Seeks Drones & Lapdogs, AFP & Reuters



By Matthew Russell Lee
UNITED NATIONS, April 6 -- Nineteen years ago today above Kigali, a plane carrying Rwandan president Juvenal Habyarimana was shot down, setting off a 100 day genocide.
Several events by the UN this month will echo the “never again” tagline. 
  But it is significant that the current head of UN Peacekeeping is Herve Ladsous, who as France's Deputy Permanent Representative in 1994 argued to the UN Security Council in favor of helping the genocidaires escape into Eastern Congo.
  Now, after Secretary General Ban Ki-moon in 2001 accepted Ladsous as a last minute substitute for Jerome Bonnafont as the fourth Frenchman in a row to head DPKO, Ladsous has lobbied for drones to oversee Eastern Congo; he has stonewalled on at least 126 rapes committed by the Congolese Army, his partners.
  When Ladsous held his first press conference as head of DPKO on October 13, 2011, Inner City Press asked him about his past on Rwanda. Video here, from Minute 22:50.
  All Ladsous would say that day was that was history, that was the past. But is it only the past?
  Alongside Ladsous' public dodging, Agence France Presse on one of the management boards of which Ladsous once served and which is 41% funded by the French government,began to seek the expulsion of Inner City Press, first from the so-called UN Correspondents Association (more appropriately, the UN's Censorship Alliance) then from the UN as a whole.
  In fact, AFP's Tim Witcher has complained to the UN not only about Inner City Press calling him, in response to his hissing “lies and distortion,” a lapdog for Ladsous, but even about Inner City Press' question to Ladsous about Eastern Congo.
  Is that consistent with AFP's or any non-corrupt media's policies, to seek to get other journalists thrown out for the substantive questions they ask? We aim to find out.
As to Ladsous, once UNCA was conducting a kangaroo court proceeding against Inner City Press in May 2012, Ladsous on May 29 simple refused to answer any Inner City Press question. See YouTube video, here.
He has continued that, for example at the Security Council stakeout on November 27, December 7 and December 18, which he directed his spokesman to seize the UNTV microphone to try to avoid Inner City Press' question on the 126 rapes in Minova by the Congolese Army.
  In March 2013 after Inner City Press asked the question, without meaningful answer, to Ban Ki-moon, Ladsous's DPKO spoon-fed half an answer to AFP's Witcher andReuters' Michelle Nichols (who absurdly but typically characterizes such spoon-feeding as a Reuters “scoop”). Is this, and the repeated filing of false complaints, consistent with Reuters' policy? Stephen J. Adler never answered.
  It was the next day, March 8, that Witcher cut into a conversation Inner City Press was having with another journalist and hissed, “lies and distortion.” Inner City Press replied, Lapdog, and sarcastically complimented Nichols on her scoop.
Cynically and in bad faith, the two went that afternoon and filed coordinated complaints, even claiming to be afraid from a verbal disagreement with Witcher instigated. Reuters more generally including its UN bureau chief Louis Charbonneau jumped in. That the UN has no rules on false complaints, or due process, has only made it worse.
But Ladsous loves it -- since then he's again tried to hand “scoops” to AFP, finally falling back on the UN's own UN Radio. And the UN and its Department of Public Information (and Ban Ki-moon's spokesperson's office) have put up with this.
So what to make of their statements this month about “never again” and the Rwandan genocide? Not much. Watch this site.

Friday, April 5, 2013

At UN, Before Staff Walkout, Audio Shows Ban's War on Labor, No Confidence



By Matthew Russell Lee
UNITED NATIONS, April 5 -- How dysfunctional the UN's relations with its staff have become under Secretary General Ban Ki-moon was shown Friday by staff's walkout of a meeting with Ban's departing chief of the Department of General Assembly and Conference Management, Jean-Jacques Graisse.
  Inner City Press staked out the meeting, held in Conference Room 7 in the UN's North Lawn building, and published a story about it as the meeting broke up.
In the three hours since, Inner City Press has been provided with an audio recording of the meeting, and runs the 16 minutes question and answer session, here.
  As if in a dark comedy about layoffs and austerity, an official of the Office of Human Resources Management tells a 21 year UN veteran, I understand you are upset, but you need to market yourself.
Another participant reminds Graisse and his Assistant Secretary General Franz Baumann off the UN Staff Union wide vote of “no confidence” in Ban Ki-moon, and says it extends to those officials present.
They are mocked for earning $200,000 but still claiming they need housing subsidy, while 59 or 100 jobs are slated to be cut.
  Graisse is accused of mis-stating a UN dispute tribunal ruling on 19 posts. Graisse said only nine were in the Inspira computer system, 10 were “in the pipeline.”
The name of Ban's chief of staff Susana Malcorra, who many say got her former colleague Graisse the job as she has moved in so many others, is cited.
Who is running the show at the UN, while for example it conducted a raid on Inner City Press' office on March 18, as the president of its UN Censorship Alliance, Pamela Falk of CBS, took photographs? 
  Immediately after Ban's spokesperson was contacted by an outside journalist about the raid, photographs of Inner City Press' desk and bookshelf were leaked to BuzzFeed.com by an anonymous e-mail account “Concerned UN Reporter.”Who is behind this?
  Ban Ki-moon, typically, can been away all week, in San Marino, Andorra and Monaco. Now with a flourish he's confirmed he will stay away to meet President Barack Obama on April 11. 
  Could an elected politician act this way, leaving chaos at home, no confidence? No. But this is the UN. Watch this site.

At UN, Voice of America Circus Has Iran Question Shouted Off Mic at Rwanda



By Matthew Russell Lee
UNITED NATIONS, April 5 -- Voice of America, controlled by the US State Department, claims to be a serious media outlet. Not original -- they have been called scoopless due to their lack of exclusives -- but doggedly derivative.
  Essentially they take other media's content, match two to get confirmation, then file their own story.
  But they can be not only arrogant, trying to get media which actually investigates original stories thrown out of the UN for example, but also clown-like.
  The full time UN correspondent saw fit to lobby Steve Redisch of VOA to try to throw Inner City Press out of the UN. Even now off the UN Correspondents Association (a/k/a UN's Censorship Alliance) Executive Committee, she remains involved in such campaigns.
  On April 4 another VOA reporter showed up, and how, at the UN Security Council stakeout. Doing a loud and repetitive stand-up in the hallway, she drowned out and even shushed a long time UN Permanent Representative.
  Just before this she had conferred with VOA's full time UN correspondent. Call it the VOA training program.
Then when Rwanda's Permanent Representative Eugene Richard Gasana, April's Security Council president, came out to the stakeout, she stood in the back shouting out her question. Video here, from Minute 1:25.
She was not on the UN microphone; as part of the Alliance, the UN's Media Accreditation and Liaison Unit helped move the boom microphone to the back. But what was VOA's question? Was it about the morning's Council topic, and subject of Gasana's stakeout, Yemen?
No. The question was about Iran talks, not at the UN but in Almaty, Khazakstan. Gasana at first couldn't hear her question, then shook his head: off topic.
Didn't he know, this was a question from the US State Department? Sometimes the State Department's three, count 'em three, outlets at the UN, each with its own office, tag team and pretend to be unaffiliated. The subject of the questions says, darn, this is a trend.
The VOA circus on April 4 led some to wonder: is Voice of America showing up now, even if off topic, in order to defend getting three separate offices, including a big spread for Voice of America's main correspondent? But is this the way? Watch this site.

UN's Ban to Meet Obama on April 11, Will Mali and De Mistura Be Discussed?



By Matthew Russell Lee
UNITED NATIONS, April 5 -- UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's current trip started small on March 30... literally. Ban went to San Marino, then Andorra, then Monaco.
But the trip is now set to finish big, with Pope Francis in Rome on April 9, and President Barack Obama in Washington on April 11.
At the UN's noon briefing on April 5, Inner City Press asked for confirmation that Ban would meet the Pope on April 9 -- and to confirm its April 3 exclusive that Italian deputy foreign minister and American favorite Staffan De Mistura is in line to be UN envoy to Mali. Video here, from Minute 5:40.
Ban's spokesperson's office belatedly confirmed the first, but only to journalists other than Inner City Press, by squawking it to the scribes in their cubicle, not even an e-mail.
At 5:37 pm on April 5, a Friday, the White House announced Ban's visit, mention only Syria by name:
“On Thursday, April 11, President Obama will host United Nations Secretary General Ban Ki-moon for an Oval Office visit. The President looks forward to welcoming the Secretary General back to the White House and consulting with him on key issues, including the crisis in Syria, and expressing his gratitude for the many sacrifices United Nations personnel have made to protect vulnerable populations and to deliver aid to those most in need. This meeting is a demonstration of the robust partnership between this United States and the United Nations in facing a wide array of global challenges.”
  What about Mali? Obama's ambassador Susan Rice questioned France's and the UN's plans for Mali when Inner City Press asked her about them this week. She said that for UN envoy, there should be someone with experience with complex missions.
  De Mistura headed the UN mission in Iraq (where he hired Ban's son in law as his chief of staff), then got the top job in Afghanistan. For that, the US came out in favor, through the late Richard Holbrooke. And now Mali? Watch this site.

After ICP Asks If Ban to Meet Pope, UN Squawks Answer to Scribes, No E-mail



By Matthew Russell Lee
UNITED NATIONS, April 5 -- Here's a small example of how the UN works, or doesn't. 
 At Friday's noon briefing, Inner City Press asked Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's lead spokesman Martin Nesirky, piped into the briefing from Madrid, to confirm that Ban will meet Pope Francis in Rome on April 9. Video here, from Minute 5:40.
  Nesirky refused to answer, saying when they have an announcement they'll make it, that's how it's done.
It seemed strange, since the Vatican had already announced that Ban would go. 
  Inner City Press immediately wrote the story, after Nesirky's deputy Eduardo Del Buey refused questions on Haiti and the Democratic Republic of Congo, then headed to the UN's North Lawn building to cover more fall out from the Staff Union's vote of “no confidence” in Ban.
  Ban's spokesperson's office sent no e-mail answer, nothing. But then a flurry of tweets from UN correspondents who weren't at the noon briefing, “reporting” that the UN says Ban will go to Rome.
  How can the UN answer the question it declined at noon, while not providing the information to the journalist who asked the question?
  Well, Ban's spokesperson's office has a “squawk” system where they pipe in audio to correspondents sitting in their cubicles. They get answers, in this case, to others' questions, while the questioner, not in the cubicle that the UN raided on March 18, does not get the answer.
  This is an institutionalized version of what Ban's UN Peacekeeping chief Herve Ladsous does -- refuse questions from Inner City Press for weeks about the rapes in Minova, for example, then hand half-answers to the scribes. Rather than standing up to Ladsous, the UN has sunk to his level.
  While the UN conducted its March 18 raid, Pamela Falk of CBS, the president of the UN Correspondents Association -- now known as the UN's Censorship Alliance -- ghoulishly took photographs. Later she sent a legal threat from her CBSNews.com e-mail address to Inner City Press, to not ask or write about it.
  She was not among the tweeters of the spoon- (or squawk) fed news. But “first” was Voice of America, which tried in 2012 to get the UN to “review the accreditation” of Inner City Press.
  Then there was Louis Charbonneau of Reuters; documents obtained under the US Freedom of Information Act from VOA say Reuters supported the request.
  Then there was Denis Fitzgerald of Saudi Press Agency, who volunteered to “judge” Inner City Press in 2012, and is now on the Executive Committee of the UN Censorship Alliance. And so it goes at the UN. Watch this site.