Monday, June 11, 2012

As Sri Lanka Press Appraises Casa Pioli, Campaign Contributions Raise New Questions


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 10 -- The Sri Lankan government media is having a field day with the proceeding against Inner City Press by the UN Correspondents Association and its president Giampaolo Piolo. The pro government Daily Mirror reports that

"Mr. Lee is on trial not for his attacks on Sri Lanka but for accusing the UNCA President Giampaolo Pioli of 'accepting rent money' [from] Dr. Palitha Kohona, who is Sri Lanka’s Permanent Representative at the UN when Dr. Kohona was Chief of the UN Treaty Section some eight years ago. He has also accused Mr. Pioli of arranging Dr. Kohona and his team to screen the government's 'Lies Agreed Upon' film at the UN under UNCA auspices without asking other UNCA executive board members about the screening."

  There are two facts that Inner City Press reported, and that Pioli and now his big media Greek chorus demanded be retracted and taken off the internet, or else Inner City Press would be expelled.

   But these were and are legitimate facts to report. The Daily Mirror continues

"Mr. Pioli admitted accepting rent from Dr. Kohona but denied the accusation he was biased in favour of Sri Lanka and while Mr. Pioli demanded the article be removed from Lee’s blog, he had refused calling it censorship. If Mr. Lee is impeached, he would be the first UNCA journalist to be expelled from the association. He has also being critical of Major General Shavendra Silva-the Deputy Permanent Representative of Sri Lanka at the UN. Mr. Lee has criticized the UN for appointing Major General Silva to the UN Advisory Panel on Peacekeeping."

  Silva is depicted even in Ban Ki-moon's Panel of Experts report as engaged in war crimes. Sri Lanka's Mission to the UN sent a letter to Pioli denouncing Inner City Press' reporting on Silva. 

  Other Missions don't do this, but it appears that the past financial relationship between Permanent Representative Kohona and Pioli leads the Sri Lankans to believe they have an "in" with Pioli's UNCA.

   Ironically, Pioli brags that he doesn't need extra funds. When Inner City Press first challenged him in 2008, he said, "I have a lot of money." Who knew then that some of it came from Sri Lanka's Palitha Kohona.

   These matters are entirely legitimate to be reported on. So is this: public records show Pioli campaign contributions in the US. This too is problematic, or emblematic of Pioli: the editor of the Boston Globe Martin Baron, among many others, opines that "It is simply not appropriate for any journalist to make a campaign contribution."

   How can you cover US politics while making campaign contributions? 
 
 What are the policies of the Poligrafici Editoriale Group and its Quotidiano Nazionale, La Nazione, Il Resto de Carlino, Il Giorno and Quotidiano.net? The companies' Stefania Dal Rio has been asked, in writing and by phone, still without response. And head of these family businesses, Maria Luisa Monti Riffeser? Watch this site.

Sunday, June 10, 2012

At UN, Complaint of Eliasson Nepotism Filed by Whistleblower, NOW Ban Ki-moon Response

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, June 10, updated June 11 -- Even before Jan Eliasson starts as Ban Ki-moon's second Deputy Secretary General on July 1, complaints of nepotism and corrupt hiring have been made.

  Whistleblowing sources tell Inner City Press that Eliasson's "former Special Assistant Ms. Shirin Pakfar has been brought from Libya on a Temporary Duty Assignment for 90 days to help start his office," at an estimated cost of $70,000.

  Inner City Press has also learned that outgoing DSG Asha Rose Migiro's chief of staff, before taking up the Burundi post he has won, is slated to stay on in New York for the entire month of July to help Eliasson settle in. So what is the total cost of this Deputy's transition?

  Worse, the complaint continues, "Ms. Pakfar has also made it known to many of her colleagues that she will ultimately be employed at a key P5 position within the Deputy Secretary-General's office after she completes a year in Libya and satisfies the mobility requirement for a promotion."

  This apparent "gaming" of Ban Ki-moon's supposed mobility policy, which for favored officials like Robert Orr and Kim Won-soo means only moving laterally without leaving New York, shouldn't accompany Eliasson's tenure even before he begins.

  While the complainant had attempted to send all this information directly to Ban Ki-moon, they suspected that it would be cut off and not reach Ban. Therefore Inner City Press is putting it online, here. Inner City Press also sent it and sought comment from Ban's top and Associate spokesmen, and from Pakfar at the UN. 

Update: more than 24 hours later, the following was received as is, as "expected," being published here in full:

From: UN Spokesperson - Do Not Reply [at] UN
Date: Mon, Jun 11, 2012 at 3:24 PM
Subject: Response to your question on Sunday about anonymous accusations
To: Matthew.Lee [at] innercitypress.com
Cc: Martin Nesirky [at] un.org

In answer to your question from Sunday 10 June, the Spokesperson has this to say and expects the full text to be printed:

First, let me make it clear that we do not in the normal course of events respond to anonymous accusations.  The more so where they impugn specific staff members without attribution.

However, in response to your query, the Secretary-General’s office does, from time to time, call on the service of staff members from various offices of the Organization, for limited periods of time, to help support his immediate office.  This has allowed the Office to benefit from the rich experience of staff thorough out the Organization while ensuring that the maximum number of staff have the experience of working with the Secretary-General’s immediate office.

With regard to the transition between the serving DSG and the incoming DSG, it is recognized that the current level of activities of the Office must continue and staff of the office are fully engaged in supporting DSG Migiro.  Therefore, as is the norm, short term assistance is brought to bear to help coordinate the transition of incoming DSG Eliasson. This is a time bound and focused activity.

Finally, the Executive Office of the Secretary-General has been consistent in its approach to staffing the office.  Following the Secretary-General's open letter of 19 January 2007 on positions in his office, in which he invited staff members who meet the qualifications to express interest in being considered for placement in his office, posts have been and continue to be circulated to staff at headquarters and the field.  For your information, there are currently three positions posted in iSeek, 2 D-2 level and 1 P-5 level.  Others will continue to be circulated as well.
This is the open letter from 2007:

19 January 2007
Dear Colleagues,

My first three weeks in office have been busy ones, as I have staked out a number of priorities in the work of the United Nations. In addition to the many challenges in peace, development and human rights, I believe there is also a need to change the working culture of the Organization itself.  

I am convinced that for the United Nations to meet the global challenges of the 21st century, we need to build a staff that is truly mobile and multi-functional -- a staff better equipped to serve our Member States, and uphold the purposes of our Organization.

To give life to those principles in an open and transparent manner, I intend as far as possible to lead by example. That is why I am taking steps to promote mobility in the Executive Office of the Secretary-General. As a first step, I have decided to initiate a new practice of circulating a number of EOSG positions on iSeek for a period of 10 working days, with a view to opening these positions to expressions of interest from UN staff members, both at headquarters and in the field. I hope you will study closely the job descriptions below, and I invite you to express interest if you consider that you are fully qualified and meet all the competencies required for one of the positions. We look forward to receiving a broad range of expressions of interest from throughout the UN.

As I undertake these efforts to lead by example, I look to all senior managers to follow suit and promote mobility among their staff in the same manner, beyond the requirements of managed mobility.
 
I thank all of you for your diligent service and dedication to the work and ideals of the United Nations.
Yours sincerely,
Ban Ki-moon

Saturday, June 9, 2012

Ban Ki-moon Advisers Defend Sri Lanka Crimes By Linking Press with LTTE, HRW Silent, CPJ Busy, France Smells Blood?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 9 -- Amid threatening anonymous telephone calls triggered by a proceeding at the UN against Inner City Press, on June 7 a Sri Lankan journalist asked Inner City Press, "there is wide spread allegation that you have been funded by pro Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam LTTE lobby groups during the last few years. How do you react to that allegation?"

  As Inner City Press was, in part for self-protection, seeking to end the public witch hunt against it by offering a balanced mutual apology, it could not on June 7 answer as directly as now. Instead the Sri Lankan journalist was told, and reported 
 
"I reject these funding allegations which are made by Sinhalese extremists, including in the Sri Lankan government, against anyone who raises the issue of the killing of civilians in May 2009. I am troubled that some in UN SG Ban Ki-moon's administration, who feel Inner City Press' coverage has made Ban look bad, including for accepting General Shavendra Silva as an adviser, are known to have echoed or amplified these Sinhalese extremist claims."

  What does this last line mean? Well, advisers close to Ban Ki-moon now and before he became Secretary General have said, as a defense, that Inner City Press is funded by the LTTE.

  Other UN officials have told Inner City Press that that the allegation of LTTE funding has been bandied around in decision making meetings.

  This is the UN itself, at the highest level, fanning anti press freedom flames.

  On June 3 the largest English langauge newspaper in Sri Lanka reported, "if the allegations against Lee are proven, the UN headquarters will be made out of bounds for him. If the harassment charges are proven he could face a jail term of up to six years." See, http://www.sundayobserver.lk/2012/06/03/new11.asp
 
  After Ban's Media Accreditation and Liaison Unit three times said it would renew Inner City Press accreditation to cover the UN, including in this context, on June 4 it reverse course and said no. What has the response to this been?


  A week ago, Inner City Press wrote to Ken Roth of Human Rights Watch, the Committee to Protect Journalists, the chief editors of Reuters (Stephen Adler) and Bloomberg (Matthew Winkler) and then UNESCO.

   Inner City Press raised to these and others the fact that Inner City Press is being targeted by pro government Sri Lanka media, with stories now using information from the Sri Lankan Mission led by Permanent Representative Palitha Kohona and citing his deputy General Shavendra Silva. The stories also quote a letter and e-mails from the UN Correspondents Association, whose president Giampaolo Pioli accepted money as rent from Kohona and then refused to recuse himself. 
 
   So far, despite an inquiry with HRW's Richard Dicker outside a press conference by outgoing International Criminal Court prosecutor Luis Moreno Ocampo, there has been no response at all from Roth and HRW, nor from Adler or Reuters, nor Winkler or Bloomberg.

   Inner City Press wrote to the editor of another UNCA officer, and the only response was to be hauled again in front of UNCA and berated for having dared write to the officer's editor.

  When shown virulent Sri Lanka government media attacks on Inner City Press, the UNCA officer said "I don't care about that." The Reuters bureau chief turned over one such article handed to him, before Inner City Press was told it was summarily "suspended" from UNCA.


   Others have said they will look into it, and still others will be asked. Luis Moreno Ocampo, when he spotted one of the Sri Lanka articles, took an interest and opined why "they want you out." What he will do is not yet known.

  A journalist who daily covers not only Sri Lanka but also Sudan, Syria, Western Sahara, the Congo and UN corruption shouldn't need to go to such lengths to be allowed to continue to cover the UN. But this is Ban Ki-moon's UN, seen through the fun house mirror of the UNCA "Pioli's Playhouse." Watch this site.

UN Peacekeeping Budget Session Has Haiti, Kosovo & S. Sudan Open, Punts on Silva SAG


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 9 -- As the UN Budget Committee closes weeks of work on Peacekeeping, spending for at least three Missions, in South Sudan, Kosovo and Haiti, still has to be decided on Monday, sources tell Inner City Press.

   The sources list among major issues this session the transfer of functions from New York to Brindisi, Italy, which was approved, while transfers to Valencia, Spain were rejected, and a new director level (D2) position in the Department of Field Support.

   The top issue, they say, was Troop Costs, for which the supplemental payment of seven percent begrudgingly agreed last year was extended until March 2013, "when the Special Advisory Group on Peacekeeping Operations" results will be discussed.

As Inner City Press on May 23 quoted a South Asian representative in attendance at this SAG, "France is the worst, in trying to cut the pay. We told them, fine, then don't keep creating new missions. Two of my country's peacekeepers died in Ivory Coast, carrying out French foreign policy." 

  It subsequently emerged and the Press reported that France's representative on the SAG switched from Jean-Marie Guehenno, now one of Kofi Annan's two deputies on Syria, to Nicolas de la Riviere, who like current Ban DPKO Peacekeeping chief Herve Ladsous was a former Deputy Permanent Representative of France to the UN, serving under Permanent Representative Gerard Araud (who, incidentally, has not been seen in UN Headquarters for some time, replaced by Deputy now charge d'affaires Martin Briens.)

  Inner City Press began closely covering the SAG after alleged war criminal Sri Lankan general Shavendra Silva was made one of the Senior Advisers to Secretary General Ban Ki-moon and his Peacekeeping chief Herve Ladsous. Attacks on Inner City Press now cite not only UNCA but also Shavendra Silva, here.

  Ban Ki-moon told Inner City Press that this is entirely up to member states; meanwhile his advisers whisper that Inner City Press must be funded by remnants of the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam, giving rise to threatening anonymous telephone calls.

  Ladsous, when Inner City Press asked him about accepting Silva on the SAG, as well as about the Mission in Haiti introducing cholera to that country, refused to answer, saying "Well, Mister, I will start answering your questions when you stop insulting me and making malicious and insulting insinuations." The video, at Minute 28:10, is online here.

  As Ladsous said this, he was flanked by Ban's spokesman and former Reuters reporter Martin Nesirky and by the acting head of the Department of Field Support Anthony Banbury, who did not answer the question Inner City Press put to him. Will he, on the DFS budget? Watch this site.

As Sri Lanka PR Kohona Like UNCA Demands Apology, "Casa Pioli" On Market Against Press


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 9 -- While Sri Lankan government media uses a proceeding at the UN against Inner City Press as putting war crimes in the past, on June 8 in the UN's North Lawn building Inner City Press asked Sri Lankan Permanent Representative Palitha Kohona about two articles and one forthcoming.

  Kohona's answer was that the dogs would be called off "if you issue a public apology to me." 
 
  But Inner City Press' reporting that Kohona was involved in luring Tamil surrenderees to their deaths by summary execution is based on facts, including the recollection of the since deceased Marie Colvin.
 
  That Kohona paid money as rent to Giampaolo Pioli, the President of the UN Correspondents Association which has now "suspended" Inner City Press and began a "Board of Examination" with an eye toward total expulsion, has subsequently been admitted by Pioli himself.

   So it is striking that the demands of Kohona and Pioli are identical: a public apology, or else attacks that lead to threatening phone calls from Sinhalese extremists will continue. 

  Kohona may view this as just part of his job for the Rajapaksa government, like getting Pioli to let Sri Lanka screen inside the UN its video responding to UK Channel 4's documentary "Killing Fields of Sri Lanka" -- which was NOT shown in "Pioli's Playhouse" or elsewhere in the UN, due to a celebration for Ban Ki-moon.

 But for the president of a journalists' association to fan anti press freedom flames in order to extract a blanket apology for legitimate reporting on a conflict of interest is more surprising, and troubling.

   And increasingly the usually low (low) profile Pioli is being noticed. Ambassadors who had assumed that the "UNCA versus Inner City Press fight" was, as one of them put it early last week, "Reuters, AFP and Bloomberg as big media fighting a harder working blogger," now marvel at Pioli's deeds, and role.

  This being the UN, some see opportunity in all this, and are starting to inquire into how to pay for a place in what they call Casa Pioli. 

  Apparently, said one at a reception Friday night, if you pay rent to Pioli, he will use his position in UNCA to attack journalists who question your country.

   France, for example, has had some success in Pioli's UNCA, most directly through Timothy Witcher of Agence France Presse, which derives over 40% of its income from "subscriptions" to AFP by government offices. 
 
When the French Mission to the UN was shamed by Inner City Press' report that the Mission was unaware that the Sarkozy Administration had switched its candidate to head UN Peacekeeping from Jerome Bonnafont to Herve Ladsous, they got Witcher of AFP, through Pioli's UNCA, to spend weeks concocting a statement denouncing press use of what other journalists say. 
 
  (AFP was not the source, but this didn't matter. For the record, Witcher says he didn't "draft" the statement, but rather wanted greater punishment such as the lawless "suspension" Pioli meted out on June 8.)

So who wants to pay for space in Casa Pioli? Watch this site.