Saturday, June 9, 2012

At UN, Ban Ki-moon Dons Helmet But Does Not Bike, Dark Talk on Law of the Sea


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 9 -- From bikes up Beekman to the Law of the Sea, the summer party season was kicked off Friday at the UN. It started at 4:30 pm when Secretary General Ban Ki-moon appeared in a bicycle helmet to introduce Janette Sadik-Khan. 
 
Ban called her the "High Commissioner" of Transportation -- an appropriate malapropism given Brooklynites' perception of her as imperious. He then "launched," without participating in, a six block bicycle ride up First Avenue to 50th Street and Beekman Place. Ban has a broken hand so his not riding is understandable (though several other more physically challenged Ambassador did ride). 
 
But why did Ban Ki-moon don a bicycle helmet if he wasn't going to ride? This is the UN.
Up on Beekman there was a reception, champagne at 5 pm in a back garden overlooking the East River. There was talk of how Ban killed off reform of the Security Council's working methods, and his bad treatment of Africans as he's been doling out top posts.
A legally-minded Permanent Representative told Inner City Press that it is hypocritical for the UN to talk about media freedom but not practice it, and suggested a litigation strategy to hold Ban to account.

Back south in the UN's North Lawn building, a "media availability" by Ban, announced with only fifteen minutes notice, had come and gone, just the way Ban likes it. In the so-called Riverview tent there was drinking and bitter talk that even the UN Singers group is "corrupt" and full of "ringers," discriminating against Africans and those of African descent. Inner City Press had to move on.

In the General Assembly lobby a fancier group was assembled, with live chamber music and lamb chops and Singha beer from Thailand. 
 
It was for the Law of the Sea, which Inner City Press exclusively covered earlier in the day, including Palestine gaining Observer State status. After that, more swag was passed out in Conference Room 1, where Continental Shelf candidates vied for voted with free pens and Danish chocolate; now there were coffee mugs and posters.

In the GA Lobby a crowd gathered around a surprisingly large fish: Serge Brammertz, formerly of the Lebanon or Hariri Tribunal and now the ICTY. The French Mission's legal specialist, genially forthcoming of late about the ICC, conversed with Brammertz and others. One wondered what he thought of the election earlier in the day of Serbia's Vuk Jeremic.

Before the vote, based on informal polling, Inner City Press tweeted a prediction: Jeremic winning with 97 votes. Many laughed. Then he won with 99 votes. Well, no one is perfect. This prediction must have been from the worst journalist at the UN in the last 20 years. Watch this site.

UN Uses UNCA to Ban Free Press, Hypocrisy Like Haiti, Astroturf like Darfur


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 9 -- The UN too often preaches one thing but does another. It preaches accountability, then covers up its proven role in introducing cholera into Haiti. 
 
  At a different level, it criticizes governments for dictating with which groups they will negotiate -- for example these days in Syria -- while the UN in New York undermines free press by only negotiating such things as physical access and conditions for reporting with the one entity it has chosen, the UN Correspondents Association.

  The UN has "Media Guidelines," and claims these are legitimate because they were negotiated with "the media." But by "the media" the UN actually only means "UNCA."
  This is similar to the way the Sudanese government created then negotiated with the Liberty & Justice Movement in Darfur, thereby marginalize the actual opposition. 

  LJM was founded and is headed, as Inner City Press exposed, by a former UN staff member who for a time was a UN-paid Darfur "rebel." LJM has been dubbed "Astroturf," a synthetic grassless sports surface: fake grassroots.

   The UN's Media Guidelines, formally the "Guidelines on Media Access at United Nations Headquarters," say they are an agreement involving the "Office of the Spokesperson of the Secretary-General" (Ban Ki-moon) and "the United Nations Correspondents Association."

  How can the UN's media access guidelines be dictated by an agreement with UNCA, which does not represent (or defend) all journalists at the UN?

  This is particularly problematic because anyone deemed, without due process, to have violated these UNCA-agreed guidelines will face "withdrawal of their accreditation."

  As previously exposed, a stealth allegation of violation was filed with MALU by UNCA Louis Charbonneau First Vice President. Charbonneau is the bureau chief of Reuters which on May 21 made unauthorized uncredited use of Inner City Press' March 28 exclusive story that US official Jeffrey Feltman will come work at the UN.

  So big media can use the UN-legitimated UNCA to seek to expel smaller media which beats them on stories. Then the UN's MALU does not even inform the small media (in this case Inner City Press) that the complaint has been filed. Due process? Not at the UN.

  As simply another example, the UN / UNCA rules agreed with UNCA state that "No cameras or photographers will be allowed in the cordoned off area by the stairs." But some are allowed, and others not.

  Likewise, those on the UNCA Executive Committee have been allowed by the UN to make decisions, fraught with conflicts of interest and payback, on which media get offices, big offices, studios. UNCA Executive Committee members have spend much time ensuring themselves big spaces, mostly furthering their own interests and not even those of the other "general" UNCA members, much less non-UNCA members.

  Then there is the question of accreditation of bloggers, which Inner City Press has fought for since arriving to cover the UN. The President of UNCA Giampioli Pioli first proposed agreeing with the UN on a rule that would not include bloggers, then would confine them to a footnote, and impose on them a different standard than is applicable to other media.

  In light of the special status the UN accords to UNCA, legally, UNCA's acts can be attributable to the UN. 
 
(An aside on law: on June 8 UNCA's Pioli announced he was "suspending" Inner City Press, an act for which there is no provision in the UNCA Constitution. But he did it, and this is the organization the UN exclusively negotiates the rights of all journalists with.)

So, for example, when the UNCA Executive Committee proceeds with a witch hunt and kangaroo court against Inner City Press, and the process is amplified and turned into threats by Sri Lankan government media and Sinhalese extremists around the world, including in New York -- all of this is attributable to Ban Ki-moon's UN.

  This is particularly true because the UN Secretariat, its Media Accreditation and Liaison Unit, senior advisers to Ban and others have all seen this witch hunt developing, have formally been given copies of the Sri Lanka newspaper articles, and have done nothing. 
 
Apparently, they like it.

  When UNCA President Giampaolo Pioli on June 8 for the upteenth time threatened to sue and bankrupt small media Inner City Press if it did not take down its reporting that Pioli accepted rent money from Palitha Kohona, the UN official who is now, through another revolving door, Sri Lanka's Permanent Representative to the UN -- this too might be attributed to Ban Ki-moon's UN, if not to the Sri Lankan government.

There are other connections. When Inner City Press tried to cover the meetings of Ban Ki-moon's Senior Advisory Group on Peacekeeping Operations to see if alleged war criminal Sri Lankan government Shavendra Silva was still attending, Ban's MALU told Inner City Press No, citing a meeting with UNCA.

It's all very convenient. But in fact, the acts of UNCA are attributable in these ways and many others to the UN. Watch this site.

At UN, Serbia Jeremic Wins GA Race over Lithuania 99 to 85, Inner City Press Prediction of 97 Was Close


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 8 -- Serbia's Vuk Jeremic was elected the next President of the UN General Assembly on Friday morning, by a secret ballot vote of over the Lithuanian Permanent Representative.

Inner City Press had interviewed Jeremic about his race, which some called "playing the NAM card" referring to the Non-Aligned Movement. Still, Jeremic is if nothing else energetic and articulate, something often lacking in those who hold this post.

On the eve of the vote, an International Criminal Court-minded European complained to Inner City Press that "Serbia's government still denies that Srbrenica was a genocide." Inner City Press asked, and asks: Does Vuk? 
 
Among those turning out to vote was Russia's Permanent Representative Vitaly Churkin, Brazil's PR Viotti, Japan's PR Nishida, the PRs of, among others, Jamaica, Grenada and Venezuela, India's PR and Deputy PR, and seemingly at the Deputy PR level, the UK, among others.

Lamberto Zannier, former head of the UN Mission in Kosovo and now chief of the OSCE, sauntered in. One wondered, to congratulate Jeremic? Or its opposite?

Before the vote, based on informal polling, Inner City Press tweeted a prediction: Jeremic winning with 97 votes. Many laughed. Then he won with 99 votes. Well, no one is perfect. This prediction must have been from the worst journalist at the UN in the last 20 years. Watch this site.

On Syria, Ban Ki-moon Takes Center Stage Then Defers to Annan, UN/Acceptable Violations?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNdisclosed Location, June 7 -- Outside the UN Security Council on Thursday afternoon, three separate rostrums were set up. When they emerged, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon took the center. But why?

Kofi Annan is the JOINT Special Envoy of the UN and Arab League: Ban and the Arab League's Araby should have been on his two sides. Especially when Ban answered a question by saying, I have much to add to what [Annan] said. One wag muttered, You're right, you don't have much to add.

During the closed door Security Council consultations, Western diplomats were bragging that inside Ban had said that Annan's six point plan is not likely to be implemented. Inner City Press asked a non-Western diplomat who was inside the room, did Annan say that? No, was the answer. And it IS the "Annan plan."

Annan, of course, if far from perfect. When Fox News was given a question, the specter of the Oil for Food scandal was in the air. To ITN, Annan denounced "unacceptable human rights violations." It begs the question: are there "acceptable" rights violations? There do seem to be, at least for Ban Ki-moon in Sri Lanka. Anyone who raises this gets targeted, including for expulsion.

Another discrepancy arose and seemed to go un- or under-reported. Earlier in the week, Inner City Press learned and exclusively reported that after indicating he wanted to have an "informal interactive dialogue" with the Security Council, as for example Thabo Mbeki recently did about Sudan, Araby switched course and said he DIDN'T want to meet with the Council.

Thursday morning a non-Western diplomat exclusively told Inner City Press that Arabi had "changed his mind or was persuaded by someone else" and now wanted an informal dialogue, which was then scheduled for 2:30. Perhaps this was reported in Western big media and it's just not yet in Google News. But as of 6:15 pm on Thursday, it's not there: until now.

UN Denies Re-Accreditation Bid of Inner City Press In Face of Sri Lanka Propaganda, Fueled by UNCA


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, June 4 -- After three times last week telling Inner City Press its request for re-accreditation to cover the UN would be granted on Monday, Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's Media Accreditation and Liaison Unit on June 4 reversed course and declined to process the renewal request.

  This comes after a June 3 article in the Sri Lanka government aligned newspaper Sunday Observer that "the United Nations Correspondents’ Association (UNCA) has initiated an inquiry against Inner City Press correspondent Matthew Russell Lee... The sources said if the allegations against Lee are proven, the UN headquarters will be made out of bounds for him."

  The article also discusses imprisonment, and has led to fall-out.

  In the run-up, which included UNCA President Giampiolo Pioli demanding that Inner City Press remove from the internet coverage of his prior financial relationship as landlord with Sri Lanka Permanent Representative Palitha Kohona, Inner City Press at least four times last week asked MALU to grant a renewal of accreditation, ideally for more than one year to take the issue of retaliation for the content of reports off the table.

 
   Inner City Press had become aware that Reuters' Louis Charbonneau, UNCA's First Vice President, had filed a complaint with MALU against Inner City Press, sending copies to Pioli, Voice of America's Margaret Besheer and AFP's Tim Witcher, but not to Inner City Press.

   Ironically, while MALU told Inner City Press on May 31 and June 1 that it was too busy with Rio Plus 20 preparations to even look at Inner City Press' request for reaccreditation, it is understood that Charbonneau on June 1 asked for re-accreditation and even new accreditation for four Reuters technicians -- and had the request approved that same day by MALU after a single phone call. 

  They say the UN has double standards, but this too some is too much.

Inner City Press based and bases its request for re-accreditation on this:

I am writing now to renew my accreditation to cover the United Nations. While I have written exclusive articles such as on March 28, 2012 reporting that US official Jeffrey Feltman will come to work for the UN, used with credit by Foreign Policy's "The Cable" but without any credit by Reuters on May 21, I have become concerned that the current UN allows expulsion threats to media in order to censor critical coverage. So I am formally requesting that, today, my accreditation be extended -- for at least one year, but I am in context requesting a longer extension.

To explain this longer-than-one-year request, consider for example that after the Mission of Sri Lanka sent a letter to the President of UNCA, to whom he previously paid money, complaining about my coverage of the reported 40,000 civilians killed by his government in May 2009, the President of UNCA not only screen the Sri Lankan government's genocide denial film inside the UN, but threatened to have me "thrown out of the UN."

Similarly, after I reported that the French Mission to the UN was so out of touch with Paris that it did not know that Herve Ladsous and not Jerome Bonnafont was France's person to head UN Peacekeeping, Agence France Presse moved to get UNCA to denounce the reporting. Only yesterday, Ladsous himself on camera said he would refuse to answer my questions about the UN role in cholera in Haiti, and Sri Lankan alleged war criminal Shavendra Silva now advising Ban Ki-moon, because of my reporting.

In this context, it is imperative that you and the UN immediately provide a renewed accreditation for much more than one year.

That remains the request. Watch this site.