Saturday, May 19, 2012

ICC's Ocampo Slow on Majer NATO Deaths, Duekoue in Cote d'Ivoire, 2 Stage Justice?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 16 -- The International Criminal Court under Luis Moreno Ocampo has seemed engaged in two-stage justice, if that. 
 
  In Libya it issued indictments of the Gaddafi side, but on Wednesday Ocampo told Inner City Press that even in the case of NATO's bombing of Majer, which reportedly killed rescue workers, he is merely seeking more information. He declined to say much about immunity offered by the new Libyan government to its own fighters.

  Inner City Press asked about Law 37, which threatens life in prison for praising Gaddafi. Couldn't that hinder defense lawyers? Ocampo shrugged.

  Turning to Cote d'Ivoire, where Ocampo indicted Laurent Gbagbo but has yet to finish investigating the Ouattara side massacres at Duekoue, Inner City Press asked for an update. Ocampo said his office is working, and it will continue under Fatou Bensouda. But why does this side take so long?

  And now, Cote d'Ivoire is talking about sending soldiers to Mali. Could it be the same units that were in Duekoue?

  Inner City Press asked if Ocampo and Bensouda, on what's billed as his farewell to Africa tour, will visit Kenya, where some officials are trying to move the trial of the so-called Ocampo Four back to the East African Court of Justice in Arusha. Why can't they?

Ocampo said there is a lot of work these days -- reportedly they'll go to Kampala and not Kenya, to avoid controversy -- and did not explain why cases can't be transferred to regional courts. Or, he said, creating new courts is not enough. But it is enough in Libya?

Ocampo was asked about the proposal, since withdrawn, by the so call Small Five states to recommend that the Security Council's Permanent Member not use the veto in cases of ICC specified crimes. Ocampo declined to comment. 
 
Ocampo was asked if this was his "last press conference." He in turn asked, tellingly, "my last as prosecutor?" So what will be his next move? Watch this site.

Rice Says Can't Delink Kordofan from North-South Sudan, UN in Denial?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 16 -- On the deadline for compliance with the UN Security Council's most recent resolution on Sudan and South Sudan, the Council met behind closed doors. On the way in, US Ambassador Susan Rice told the press not to expect any "product" or further statement or enforcement action, at least that day.

When the session was over, Inner City Press asked about one or two paragraphs of the resolution:

Inner City Press: What about talks with SPLM-North? I'm sorry if you've addressed this, but Sudan has said that they don't they think the resolution can force them-they've said that no one can make them talk to SPLM-North about Southern Kordofan?

Ambassador Rice: Well, the resolution makes clear that this is part of the African Union Roadmap, and it is a requirement. The reality is that, as we all agree in there, it is impossible to separate what is happening from Southern Kordofan and Blue Nile from the larger conflict between North and South. And the North would be wise to return to the table with the SPLM-North, to allow humanitarian access, which was discussed in there as a matter of enormous urgency given the onslaught of the rainy season. And the North needs to know-and the SPLM-North needs to know-that they have obligations in this regard under the resolution.

Moments later, Inner City Press asked Sudanese diplomats about this statement, and the situation in Abyei. On the latter, they reiterated the position of minister Ali Karti that an administrative structure should be agreed to and be in place, and said that while South Sudan pulled back, they had "not gone back behind the 1/1/1956 border."

Inner City Press asked South Sudan's representative Francis Nazario about Abyei and he said that there could be no pre-conditions to leaving Abyei. Another representative said Sudan should be asked where they think the 1956 border is.

Meanwhile on Sudan the UN Secretariat is in denial -- or at least, is directly denying a press account that the government has told non-Sudanese NGOs to leave El Geneina. Inner City Press asked, then the UN e-mailed this answer:

Subject: Your question El Geneina (Sudan)
From: UN Spokesperson - Do Not Reply [at] un.org
Date: Tue, May 15, 2012 at 1:05 PM
To: Matthew.Lee@innercitypress.com

On yesterday's question, the Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) in El Geneina confirmed that no international NGO in El Geneina has received information asking them to leave the refugee camp there. There is one international NGO that is in the process of a planned scale-down.

We'll see. On May 16 Inner City Press asked about 30 reported arrests of civilians in South Darfur. Typically, the UN Secretariat had nothing. Watch this site.

Small 5 Have Support Ranging from S. Africa to Norway But May Withdraw

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 16, updated 10:50 am -- As Permanent Representatives poured into the General Assembly on Wednesday morning for the expected fight on the Small Five's draft resolution recommending changes to the Security Council's working methods, Inner City Press began taking an informal poll.

South Africa's Permanent Representative Baso Sangqu expressed support for the S5, as did for example Norway and G-4 member Japan.

Others in the UfC said it is "too important an issue" to divide the membership, and urged withdrawal of the proposal, citing the legal opinion letter of Ban Ki-moon's reclusive top lawyer Patricia O'Brien, which Inner City Press obtained and put online yesterday.

After that story, some in UfC pointed out to Inner City Press that even though the Permanent Five wanted that opinion from O'Brien, so did they, and that there are "some Davids" in the UfC, not only the P5 Goliaths.

In fact, the P5 was advised to take a backseat or less visible role, but chose not to. Likewise the P5 were offered an informal process of conferring on working methods, a large Latin country says, but the P5 rejected it.

Still, by 10:15 am Permanent Representatives from Africa and Latin America emerged and told Inenr City Press the buzz is that the Small Five would give a speech and withdraw their proposal.

If not, a UfC Perm Rep told Inner City Press, there would be a no-action motion, and if that failed, a push by the Small Five to lower the requirement to 50% from the O'Brien dictated two-thirds. 

Update of 10:50 am -- a Small Five Permanent Representative who had been fiery on Tuesday now tells Inner City Press, we are going to meet with the PGA. O'Brien's letter sure to figure. Meanwhile there's talk of the African Group asking for a deferral. Watch this site.

Update of 11:12 am -- a Small Five dip has said they will withdraw, not just defer. Still no formal confirmation.

Update of 11:50 am - after a long speech, live Tweeted here, the Swiss Perm Rep said "S5 withdraw" the resolution. Fin.

At UN, Ban's Lawyer O'Brien Sides with P5 Against S5, Says 2/3 Required

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, May 15 -- What is the place of law in the UN? This is a question raised not only by the so-called Small Five's draft resolution about the Security Council, but also the May 14 advisory letter of reclusive chief UN lawyer Patricia O'Brien, which Inner City Press has obtained and puts online here, and how it will be dealt with on May 16.

  Costa Rica, Jordan, Liechtenstein, Singapore and Switzerland, as the Small Five, have put forward recommendations for reforms of the Security Council's working methods. Inner City Press first wrote about the proposal on May 2, then earlier today after being the only media staking out meetings with the President of the General Assembly by the Permanent Five members of the Council, then the Small Five, exclusive article here.
  A member of the Permanent Five told Inner City Press, "This requires a two-thirds vote. We hope they [the Small Five] will just withdraw it."

  Inner City Press asked the PGA's office about the Legal Adviser's letter, but they would not confirm it. The PGA himself told Inner City Press, "we are still going through it," he said, "in the morning." 
 
  When the Small Five, and entourage, came out later from the PGA's office, one of their representatives told Inner City Press with a smile, "We say simple majority and that it will be adopted by consensus!"

  Patricia O'Brien, not surprisingly, sided with the powerful Permanent Five. (O'Brien has repeatedly refused to take questions from the Press, including on the long pending complaint that the UN introduced cholera to Haiti.) One her grounds, the last paragraph in the Annex, has now been taken away by its deletion. But what will happen on May 16? Watch this site.

On Small Five Reforms, As P5 Confab with PGA, Two-Thirds Vote Required?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 15, updated 6:58 pm -- At the UN, the Small Five got the attention of the Permanent Five members of the Security Council. It was after 5 pm when the P5, each representated at the level of Permanent Representative, came out from the President of the General Assembly's office. 
 
They huddled, and afterward one of the Permanent Representatives confirmed to Inner City Press that the topic was "big, the reform of the Security Council. This requires a two-thirds vote. We hope they [the Small Five] will just withdraw it."

  Inner City Press first wrote about the Small Five proposal on May 2. Costa Rica, Jordan, Liechtenstein, Singapore and Switzerland make up the Small Five. Unlike the G4, UFC and L69 the Small Five is pushing to reform the Council's "working methods," with a resolution making 21 reform points. 
 
  These include no vetoes of actions aimed at preventing or ending genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity, given the General Assembly a greater role in selecting the Secretary General, and improving due process in sanctions lists.

  Earlier on Tuesday May 15 another P5 source told Inner City Press that the Legal Adviser -- presumably Secretary General Ban Ki-moon top lawyer Patricia O'Brien -- had dutifully issued a ruling that a two thirds vote, rather than simple majority, should be required on the draft resolution of the Small Five to recommend Council reforms.

  Back on May 2, a proponent Permanent Representative told Inner City Press that it was 90% sure that this resolution will be put to a vote on May 16. And now? Watch this site.
Update of 6:50 pm -- Inner City Press asked the President of the General Assembly, when he emerged at 6:45 pm on the way to the Jamaica-sponsored concerned in the GA Hall, if two thirds or 50 percent will be required.

  "We are still going through it," he said, "in the morning." But what of the Legal Adviser's ruling? On the way into the North Lawn building, one of the Small Five Permanent Representatives told Inner City Press, "onward to victory!" 

Update of 6:58 pm -- When the Small Five, and entourage, came out later from the PGA's office, one of their representatives told Inner City Press with a smile, "We say simple majority and that it will be adopted by consensus!" We'll see.

As Hollande Names Ayrault, at UN Araud Angles for a Year, Bonne to Leave?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 15 -- Hours after Francois Hollande took over from the deposed Nicolas Sarkozy in Paris, in New York French Ambassador to the UN Gerard Araud stopped on his way into the Security Council and told the press, "I have a new prime minister, for two minutes."

  That would be Jean-Marc Ayrault, the former mayor of Nantes. While speculation continues on Araud's fate, now under Ayrault, Inner City Press was told by another Security Council member that the French Mission's political coordinator Emmanuel Bonne will be leaving. (Mr. Bonne did not reply for five hours to a request for confirmation or denial.)

  It's said that Araud is angling to be given an extra and final year; it's not clear if he'd get it. There are questions of whether the new French government should replace Herve Ladsous, who was a last minute Sarkozy appointment substituting for Jerome Bonnafont who bragged too much about getting the top UN DPKO post, and neglects his duties to publicly explain what UN peacekeepers do and are facing.

  A well placed source snarked that Ladsous went for the DPKO post because he thought Sarkozy would lose and wanted to assure himself job and pay. But should it be that easy, especially if not places like Eastern Congo are being ill-served by his silence, but UN Peacekeepers too? Watch this site.

As EU Hits In Somalia, Question of Consent, Mahiga's Tardiness Echoed by TFG?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 15 -- While US Ambassador Susan Rice on Tuesday stressed that the Somali Transitional Federal Government must finally transition to a new elected government by August 20, the UN's envoy Augustine Mahiga arrived more than 20 minutes late for the Security Council meeting. 
 
  Whether or not Mahiga's tardiness portends another delay for the TFG, Inner City Press inquired into why he had come late and was told "he was to meet with Karl Wycoff," a US official on Africa.

  Mahiga was to have addressed the Council first, but once he did not arrive TFG president Sharif Sheikh Ahmed took his place, and asked for the arms embargo to be removed. This came right after the first of what may be many European Union helicopter raids inland in Somalia. 
 
  Inner City Press asked the EU about this plan, and was told not to over-focus on inland attacks. Specifically, on April 27 Inner City Press asked Operation ATALANTA commander Admiral Duncan Potts about this proposal, he said the reporting was "incorrect." 

 Potts told Inner City Press, "I wouldn't focus too much on the two kilometers. We want to create the perception in the mind of the pirates that they can no longer act with impunity from beaches of Somalia. It's about the perception of impunity rather than a kinetic effect."

  At the at time Inner City Press wrote that it still seems that the way the EU wants to "create this perception" is to shoot guns, from helicopters, up to two kilometers inside Somali territory.

   And now it has happened. 
 
  Sharif Sheikh Ahmed to his credit did a UN TV stakeout, at which Inner City Press asked him about the EU inland helicopter action and how and why it was approved, and about other non-Somali military actors in the country. 
 
  He said that the way to solve piracy is ongoing development, that one or two action like this won't solve it. I have no details on approvals, he said somewhat strangely. Another Security Council diplomat said Germany described not only approval but close cooperation.

  Sharif Sheikh Ahmed had with him a big entourage, from Permanent Representative to First Secretary, amid much talk of the Millennium Hotel. But when will they take the T out of the TFG and actually hold elections? Watch this site.