Saturday, May 19, 2012

UN In Denial on Haiti Cholera Despite NYT, Defends $800 Afghan Shredder

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 13 -- While the UN continues to deny that it introduced cholera to Haiti, or claims that "it doesn't matter" who introduced it, today's New York Times in an unsigned editorial states flatly that "the UN bears heavy responsibility for the outbreak: its own peacekeepers introduced the disease through sewage leaks at one of their encampments."

  We'll see if the UN continues to reflexively send denial letters to the editor (below, there's the UN system's response to a finding of its corruption in Afghanistan, defending its 10-seater sofa set and $800 shredder).

   But the Times editorial on Haiti goes on to recite that the "CDC estimates that adequate water and sanitation systems will cost $800 million."

  The editorial doesn't directly say, but Inner City Press has reported, that this is the annual budget the UN spends on soldiers in Haiti, which has not seen a war for years. 
 
  Back on April 10, Inner City Press asked Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesman about this:
 
Inner City Press: yesterday, there was a press conference across the street by Haitian activists, including human rights activists and those who filed the claim for compensation with MINUSTAH and the Secretary-General. And, among other things, they said that they have heard nothing back from this UN, at any level, since December.... Since it has been four months and there have been new developments, is there a time line? What’s the UN’s thinking about this issue, because they are saying that it is hurting the credibility of the UN with Haitians and others?

Spokesperson Martin Nesirky: Two things, Matthew. One is that, as we have repeatedly said, a claim has been received and it is being studied. There is nothing unusual in the time frame for studying a claim of this nature. The second point is that the focus is on what we can do to help the Haitian people now, and, of course, in the run-up to the rainy season, which is to come. So, I think that the focus is rightly on the need to help people now and to ensure that sanitation measures are put in place before the rainy season and during the rainy season. On the first part of the question, the answer remains the same.

Inner City Press: Mario Joseph, a very widely respected Haitian human rights lawyer, makes this comparison of the $800 million a year they say is spent on MINUSTAH peacekeeping, they say if this money was actually devoted to water purification, it would change Haitians’ lives. Is that the real number? Is there some way to get a comparison of what the UN spends in Haiti on just what you are saying, sanitation, water and forward-looking preventative measures as opposed to this peacekeeping force?

Spokesperson Nesirky: I think that we’ll be in a position to provide you and others with an overview of precisely the kind of measures that are being taken, and have been taken since the outbreak began. And obviously that is our focus. Progress has been made in reducing the number of cases, but there is a long way to go and that is precisely why the focus needs to be there. Let’s see if we can come up with something that gives you a good snapshot of where we are. Other questions, please? 
 
  And more than a month later, still no response to the formal claim on cholera.

Question: On Afghanistan? There is a report that the Monitoring and Evaluation Committee, the Afghan Government, and the international donors have said that the UN system's role in funding the Afghan national police may involve false receipts, what is the UN system’s response? Does it believe that there are problems with the program or that everything is running well?

Spokesperson: Seen the story; speak to UNDP [United Nations Development Programme]. Thanks very much.

And here's from the response UNDP put out, and the UN sent to Inner City Press:

UNDP has a zero tolerance policy towards any form of mismanagement or corruption for its entire country program in Afghanistan. Your article refers to the Law and Order Trust Fund for Afghanistan (LOTFA), which is part of our program and helps increase security by training the Afghan National Police—including through payment of salaries. It is audited every year by a globally respected and independent third party auditing firm.

A financial audit recently conducted by KPMG of the 2011 project’s expenditure concluded that there were no financial irregularities. In addition, a comprehensive evaluation of the previous LOTFA phase, also conducted by an external evaluation firm, found no cause for concern.

UNDP notes with concern a statement in your report, which describes a "pattern of bad behavior" at LOTFA – comments you have attributed to an anti-corruption body set up by the Afghan government, the Monitoring and Evaluation Committee. However, their report was released the day before your article was published and makes no reference to “bad behavior”. It does recommend improved oversight and monitoring and UNDP is committed to diligently following up on this.
Moreover, we would like to set the record straight on the following additional allegations in your piece:

1/ For example, a 10-seater sofa set and four tables costing $6,000 -- which the article refers to as “luxury furniture” that might not even have been purchased – were procured with full procedural checks and are still being used by the head of the Afghan Border Police.

2/ The purchase order of a paper shredder, mentioned in your report, matched its $800 price. The purchase was in line with our procurement policy and was only approved after the project justified its need for a more robust product...
Yours truly, Satinder Bindra, Director of Communications - UNDP

So why the long -- if factually challenged -- response to the WSJ about Afghanistan, including 10-seater sofa set and "robust" $800 shredder? Especially when compared with the still total silence from the UN on the Haiti cholera claim and belated NYT story and editorial? 
 
A range of possibilities, call them multiple choice:

a) The UN cares more about, or is more afraid of exposure of its misdeeds in, Afghanistan than Haiti because the US and other powers cares about Afghanistan. (The NYT on Haiti references a Congressional move to direct Susan Rice to act, but the UN's responsibility for cholera introduction has yet to be acted on.)

b) The UN is more worried about the WSJ than the NYT, which it views as a liberal paper tiger.

c) UNDP is more media savvy than Ban Ki-moon's Secretariat.

Watch this site.

Saturday, May 12, 2012

After Complaint, Sweden Says It Can't Make Prosecutors Shut "Terrorist" Site

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 11 -- When Russia's Ambassador to the UN Vitaly Churkin in a May 10 Security Council session called out Sweden for failing to close down the web site of Caucuses Emirate, saying this violated UNSC Resolution 1989, Inner City Press wrote about it and asked the Swedish government for its response. A day later, it has arrived, and it published in full below.

  At issue is Operative Paragraph 6 of Resolution 1989, which 
 
"Confirms that the requirements in paragraph 1 (a) above apply to financial and economic resources of every kind, including but not limited to those used for the provision of Internet hosting or related services, used for the support of Al-Qaida and other individuals, groups, undertakings or entities associated with it."

  While Inner City Press believes, with others, that freedom of expression issues may be raised by making illegal the "provision of Internet hosting services," for the UN and its member states, that train has left the station. Under Resolution 1989, adopted in 2011, and its cited Paragraph 1(a), UN member states must

"ensure that neither these nor any other funds, financial assets or economic resources are made available, directly or indirectly for such persons’ benefit, by their nationals or by persons within their territory."

 
"The Kavkazcenter has been proclaimed the official information organ of the Emarat Kavkaz by Doku Umarov. Publications on the website are in Russian, English, Arabic, Turkish and Ukrainian... The principal internet provider of the website is located in Stockholm, Sweden.. The website has regularly published videos in which Doku Umarov and the heads of the Emarat Kavkaz have taken personal responsibility for terrorist acts carried out on the territory of Russia including the one at the Domodedovo airport (Moscow) on 24 January 2011."

  So what how does Sweden respond? With a day's delay, and after Inner City Press also tweeted the question at Swedish foreign minister Carl Bildt, the First Secretary (Legal) of the Swedish Mission to the UN sent this to Inner City Press:

As to the first issue regarding the website, the Swedish Government's comments are the following.
Once the Security Council decides on sanctions, Member States are obliged, under international law, to implement these measures and incorporate the provisions in their own legal systems. For Sweden, this is done jointly with the other EU countries. Accordingly, Sweden has fully implemented UN Security Council Resolution 1989, including the listing of the organization ”Emarat Kavkaz”, through the EU Council Regulation (EC) No 881/2002, which is directly applicable in Swedish national law.
Violations of an EU regulation on sanctions are punishable by Swedish law, i.e. the Act on Certain International Sanctions (1996:95). Swedish police, prosecutors and courts conduct investigations, press charges and issue verdicts independently from the Government. The Government cannot influence an authority or a court concerning a decision on how to apply Swedish law. It is up to the competent Swedish authorities to look into the issues of possible sanctions crime related to the listing of 'Emarat Kavkaz.'

As to the second question, it is, as you mention a CTED visit under resolution 1373. There are no visits foreseen by the 1267/1989 Committee or the Monitoring Group. 
 
  The "second question" referred to was

"I have learned that along with a CTED visit to Sweden in June, an expert of the 1989 Committee may go as well. What will Sweden say to them?"

  Along with arguing that the Swedish "Government cannot influence an authority or a court concerning a decision on how to apply Swedish law," the response says "there are no visits foreseen by the 1267/1989 Committee or the Monitoring Group."

  But Inner City Press understands that, at the request of Russia, an Al Qaeda / Resolution 1989 expert is slated to now accompany the previously scheduled CTED visit to Sweden in June. And what will come of it? 
 
  Inner City Press view is that if Sweden thinks the ban on providing web hosting violates free speech, it should say so, as should have members of the Council. 

  But silent non-compliance with resolutions -- just as Inner City Press discovered on May 10 that five Security Council members never even filed reports under Libya sanctions -- is the opposite of the rule of law. Watch this site.

Syria UN List of Foreign Fighters Has Libyan Busboy & "Terrorists" From Tunisia

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 12 -- Amid suicide car bombings in Damascus, German Ambassador to the UN Peter Wittig while condemning the bombs on May 10 told the press that Bashar al Assad's "failure to comply" had "fueled" this. 
 
  An hour later Syrian Ambassador Bashar Ja'afari told Inner City Press that 26 foreign fighters arrested in his country came from Tunisia, Lebanon, Palestine, Libya, Egypt and Jordan. Now Inner City Press has obtained Syria's list, translated into English, and puts it online here.

  Most of the 26 "detained Arab nationals" on the list are Tunisians described as entering Syria through Turkey and "using arms against Syrian Arab Army forces in response to fatwas issued by takfiri religious figures in Tunisia."

  Several are described as having previously been imprisoned for terrorism and even "pardoned and freed after the Tunisian revolution."

  One was arrested after being solicited to go to Iraq for similar fighting. The car bombs in Damascus, while blamed by some on the government, are reminiscent of the carnage that became a daily occurrence in Iraq.

They are listed as students, engineers, farmers and drivers; one counterfeiter and a smuggler of "narcotic pills" from Lebanon; even a restaurant worker from Libya.

  Ja'afari on May 10 described a ship of weapons from Libya meant for fighters in Syria; he told Inner City Press that the UN mission UNIFIL didn't stop it because "UNIFIL is only to protect Israel."

  What will happen with these names, and these people? Several are alleged to be members of Al-Qaida. Yesterday, Inner City Press wrote about the Al Qaida sanctions committee and its various listings. Will these individuals be listed? And what of the referenced killed fighter from Belgium, the UK and France? Watch this site.

At UN on Indigenous, Congo Claims and Sakha Music, Chiapas & a Cash Bar

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 11 -- When the Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues comes to the UN has it has this week, it's often a study in contrasts. In the UN's North Lawn building, tribes people and Native Americans multi-colored hats and walking sticks pass in a parallel universe the here-indigenous diplomats in their native dress, dark suits. 
 
  The two worlds intersected Friday afternoon when a custom-suited minister from Republic of Congo held a three course lunch in the re-opened Delegates Dining Room facing the East River, with a room only half filled, mostly by other African diplomats. Many places were empty: Somalia, Zimbabwe, even neighboring Democratic Republic of the Congo.

  The Permanent Representatives of Cameroon, Chad and Angola were there, the last as this month's African Group chairman. (He did not mention the coup in Guinea Bissau, on which his country seems to disagree with some other African countries like Nigeria and Togo.)

  The Minister in from Brazzaville, Bienvenu Okiemy, promoted his country's Law No. 5-2011 of February 25, 2011 on the Promotion and Protection of Indigenous Populations' Rights. Given that some African countries argued at the UN not long ago that either all Africans are indigenous, or none are, the law is noteworthy. 
 
  The Law starts that "the term Indigenous Populations mean populations who differ from the national population by virtual of their cultural identity, way of life and extreme vulnerability." It also provides that "the use of the term pygmy is prohibited."

  It did not seem that the delegation from Brazzaville brought any indigenous person with them, those the two African members of the Permanent Forum's 16 members, and some other members including from Finland, Estonia, Canada and New Zealand were in attendance.

  When Q&A time came, the Permanent Forum member from Kenya congratulated Congo for taking the lead, noted that Nairobi "might lose the UNEP headquarters," and asked that the PFII preparatory session to be held in Congo in 2013 include a pan-African meeting of indigenous people. 
 
  These include, according to UNFPA's David Lawson's speech, the Masai of Kenya, the Baaka of Congo, the Mbororos of Cameroon, the Batwa of Uganda and the Twa of the DRC and Rwanda, to say nothing of the Bushmen and others.

  Inner City Press asked the Minister what progress has been made on the recommendation of Rapporteur James Anaya that the Congo - Brazzaville "Government will need to develop and fully implement a new procedure for demarcating and registering lands in accordance with indigenous peoples’ customary rights and tenure." The Minister said this IS being done, then closed the session.

  Earlier in the week music filled the General Assembly visitors' lobby: two songs by Sak Tzevul of Chiapas, Mexico; much from Kahurangi theater of New Zealand, Andes Manta of Ecuador and the Chakma people of Bangladesh's Chittagong Hill Tracts; Nepalese dance and a group from the Republic of Sakha in Russia.

  In a session listed as closed, the "first Finno-Ugric Event at the UN" ever was held, and hockey player Alexander Ovechkin was claimed as Finno-Ugric. Across First Avenue the "Doctrine of Discovery" was rebutted by a display, complete with cash bar, of the Six Nations of the Grand River in Canada. They presented a litany of broken treaties. And so it goes at the UN.

With Guinea Bissau Coup Now Accepted by ECOWAS & UN, Cote d'Ivoire Contrast

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 11 -- After much talk at the United Nations of not accepting the coup in Guinea Bissau and restoring the overthrown government, on Friday ECOWAS' representative Nurudeen Mohammad said there "is no question of the return" of former prime minister Carlos Gomes and former interim president Raimundo Pereira.

  So much for restoring the government. As the UN Security Council met Friday morning behind closed doors to hear from West Africa envoy Said Djinnit, Inner City Press asked a number of Council members if they are, in fact, accepting the coup in Guinea Bissau.

  One interested delegation argued that the statement by Nurudeen Mohammad, Nigeria's state minister for foreign affairs, may not be the final word, "let's see." 
 

  There is an obvious contrast with the Security Council's approach to Cote d'Ivoire, where after Laurent Gbagbo got at least 45% of the vote but refused to leave power, contesting the results in some districts, the Council authorized force including the involvement of France's Force Licorne until Alassane Ouattara was installed in power, and Gbagbo sent to the ICC in the Hague.

  All of that was done, it was said, to enforce democracy. But here, Carlos Gomes was ousted in a coup, and the coup leaders are given at least 12 months. ECOWAS says Gomes cannot come back, and the Council so far says nothing.

  So was were France's real motives in Cote d'Ivoire? And why is the response to the outright military coup in Guinea Bissau so different?

   We haven't even touched, in this article, the situation in Mali. But we will, soon. Watch this site.