Saturday, May 12, 2012

On Libya, UN "Seeks Clarification" Of Immunity Law As SC Members Fail to File

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 10 -- As Libya is said to move toward election, at least two highly problematic laws were brought into question at the UN this week. Law 38 would grant immunity for any "acts made necessary by the 17 February revolution" and for the revolution's "success or protection."

Inner City Press asked Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesman on May 8:

Inner City Press: there is a report of a proposed law in Libya, called law 38, which would grant amnesty for, quote, 'acts made necessary by the 17 February revolution, and for the revolution’s success of protection.' Some people are saying this is basically an amnesty law that whatever harm may have been created in the course of the rebellion are being forgiven. Does Ian Martin, or does the UN’s accountability people, have any view of this law?

Spokesperson Nesirky: I’d have to check with our colleagues in the Mission in Tripoli. I haven't seen anything on that. That doesn’t mean they haven't been working on this topic, but I haven't seen anything myself. So, I will check, Matthew. Anything else? Yeah?

Later this teaser was received:

Subject: Your question on Libya
From: UN Spokesperson - Do Not Reply [at] un.org
Date: Tue, May 8, 2012
To: Matthew.Lee [at] innercitypress.com

Ian Martin will speak to the Security Council this Thursday, and he expects to talk to reporters at the stakeout afterward. He will take questions about recent developments in Libya at that time.

  And so when Martin emerged late Thursday to take questions, Inner City Press asked him this one, as well as two others.

  Martin said that some amnesties for fighters are encouraged by humanitarian law, but this cannot extend to war crimes and crimes against humanity. Law 38, however, does not appear to make that distinction. Martin said the UN is "seeking clarification."

  To some, this echoed the UN's position in Yemen when Ali Saleh got immunity.

  Inner City Press asked Libya's representative Ibrahim Dabbashi about Law 38, and also Law 37 which would impose life sentences to praising Gaddafi. Dabbashi expressed some discomfort with these laws, and implied they could and would be changed after the upcoming elections.

Beyond Inner City Press' reporting during the Security Council session that five Council members didn't even file the short reports required by the Council's own Libya sanctions regime -- Martin declined comment on this -- Inner City Press asked about the threat to resign by finance minister Hassan Ziglam, due to corruption in payments to former and claimed former fighters.

Martin said he'd seen this, and that the program to pay former fights had not been well administered, leading for example to the recent incidents at the Prime Minister office. Does corruption run deeper? Is Libya, as alleged, exporting weapons to fighters in Syria? Martin said this is beyond UNSMIL's mandate. Apparently it is beyond the mandate of UNIFIL as well. Watch this site.

On Libya Sanctions, 5 UN SC Members Fail to File Reports, P5 Threatens S5

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 10 -- When Libya sanctions were adopted by the UN Security Council, all 193 member states were given until June 26, 2011 to file reports on their implementation.

  Now more than ten months after the deadline, it seems that only 57 countries have filed reports. At least five current Security Council members are not listed among those who have filed reports: Azerbaijan, Guatemala, India, Morocco and Pakistan.
Resolution 1970 provided:

"25. Calls upon all Member States to report to the Committee within 120 days of the adoption of this resolution on the steps they have taken with a view to implementing effectively paragraphs 9, 10, 15 and 17 above [of resolution 1970 (2011)]." 
 

"Accordingly, States that have not yet reported to the Committee on the steps they have taken with a view to implementing effectively the paragraphs cited above, which set out the arms embargo, the travel ban and the assets freeze, are reminded to do so no later than 26 June 2011." 
 
 And still -- five Council members are not listed as filing. The Permanent Representative of one of the N or Non-compliant Five sheepishly told Inner City Press that reporting is not that important. Another said he would go and find out.

  Some wonder how the Security Council members can ask other states to follow its mandates if they themselves do not practice what they preach. Another said "as long as the Permanent Five members file, that's what's important."

   Outside the Council's session on Libya on Thursday afternoon, Inner City Press asked a number of non-filers who are not on the Security Council to explain themselves. 

  The Permanent Representatives of a sample European nation, asking that he and it not be identified, said his country is waiting for greater Council transparency on sanctions before filing reports. The reform proposals of the so-called Small Five, which Inner City Press has covered, were cited among the reasons.

  Sanctions and due process are listed in Paragraph 9 of the Small Five's resolution's annex.

  Inner City Press' previous report, that the resolution will be put to a vote this month, appears to remain true. Sources say that the Permanent Five members of the Council have told the Small Five that if they go forward with the resolution, the P5 will still negotiating with them.

  A G4, meanwhile, loves this, and says it is "ready for the kill shot" once this happens. United for Consensus members shake their heads, bemoaning the Small Five's failure to take the time to get two-thirds support of member states, or to wait for a wider reform proposal. Watch this site.

At UN on Syria, May 10 Bombs Condemned, May 9 Left Out, UNIFIL Chided

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 10 -- When two suicide vehicle bombs killed more than 50 people in Damascus this morning, the day after a bomb went off near a convoy of UN observers injuring at least a half dozen Syrian soldiers, a fast UN Security Council press statement was expected.

  On their way into the Council for a previously scheduled open debate on terrorism, Portugal's Ambassador Cabral said nothing had yet been circulated. Germany's Ambassador Peter Wittig while condemning the Damascus bombs said that Assad's "failure to comply" had "fueled" this. 
 
  Inner City Press asked Russia's Ambassador Vitaly Churkin about this moments later; Churkin stopped and pulled out a piece of paper and read the Council's boilerplate language about all acts of terrorism being criminal and unjustifiable. He told Inner City Press he would circulate a draft press statement with this language.

  While the open debate lurched on, with speeches by Israel and Syria, Armenia and the Council's President for May Azerbaijan, a silence procedure was opened on Russia's draft statement.

  While at least one delegation -- Pakistan -- proposed changes, apparently Germany did not. Because as soon as the open debate was over, right after he replied to Armenia's charges about Nagorno Karabakh, the Azerbaijani Ambassador came and read out the press statement, with the "all acts of terrorism are criminal and unjustifiable" language in place.

(Another on again, off again phrase about complying with human rights law while combating terrorism was also in.)

  Inner City Press understands that Pakistan proposed that the statement be expanded to include the May 9 bombing near the UNSMIS observers, but that others opposed the inclusion, saying it is not clear if the UN observers were targeted. Pakistan countered, what does it matter? But they did not break silence, in order to allow this fast Council reaction.

  Meanwhile Syrian Ambassador Bashar Ja'afari told the Council that he has a list of 12 terrorists killed in Syria, including one each from France, Belgium and the UK. He chided the UN's Lebanon mission, UNIFIL, for doing nothing to stop a ship of weapons coming from Libya to fighters in Syria.

  Afterward Inner City Press asked Ja'afari what he meant about UNIFIL's inaction. "UNIFIL is only to protect Israel," Ja'afari said. He said the other dead foreign fighters were from Tunisia, Libya and Algeria.
Of the 26 previously mentioned (by Ja'afari) terrorists captured alive, Ja'afari told Inner City Press they are from Libya, Tunisia, Jordan and Palestine. 

  Inner City Press asked the Azerbaijani president of the Council if this list, and the brandished CD, has been turned in to the Council.

   "I didn't see it yet," he replied. Earlier, on his own issue, he told the Council he'd submitted a letter yesterday to Ban Ki-moon about Armenia's "bloody terrorism" and "propaganda." Armenia's Ambassador stopped and told Inner City Press that Azerbaijan is "not ready for an open debate." 

  Israel's Ambassador Ron Prosor spoke of "draining the swamps of hate," and of plots in Bangkok and Baku. And so it goes at the UN.

With Pillay 2d Term In Doubt, Simonovic Lurks, Activists Wonder on Jilani

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 10 -- As UN High Commissioner on Human Rights Navi Pillay's first and maybe only term comes to an end, now names of possible replacements have begun to circulate.


  Now a name is circulating, someone that Secretary General Ban Ki-moon and apparently the Americans are comfortable with, unlike many human rights activists: Ivan Simonovic. 
 
  When he was named as Pillay's New York based deputy, Simonovic's previous service to Franjo Tudman was raised, click here for Inner City Press' story. Since he's had the post, he's been less than accessible, soft on Sudan and the victors in Cote d'Ivoire and somewhat "joyless" as one reporter called him, adding that Simonovic is "not in any way associated with criticism of Israel."

  And could that be the point?

  Actual human rights activist suggest other names, like while not necessarily realistic, Hina Jilani, who has been a UN representative on Human Rights Defenders.

They note a series of "old names" in the mixed, ranging from Sergio Pinheiro the lead speaker on the panel on Syria, Juan Mendez and even Francis Deng, who wrote his own books while on UN time as the expert in the prevention of genocide. Watch this site.

At UN SC on Terror, Assad Blamed for Fueling, Russia Targets Sweden on Web

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 10 -- With terrorism the subject of a UN Security Council session on Thursday morning, Russian Permanent Representative Vitaly Churkin told Inner City Press on his way into the chamber that he would be circulating to the Council a draft press statement on the "terrorist attacks" in Damascus, including the death of children. 

  Churkin stopped and read out word for word the Council's boilerplate language about terrorism never being justifiable.

  By contrast German Ambassador Peter Wittig on his way in while comdemning the Damascus bombs said that Assad's "failure to comply" had "fueled" this. Is that a justification?

  At 1 pm a Permanent Representative told Inner City Press that Russia's draft "has been circulated." There are previously scheduled afternoon consultations.

  Once inside the Chamber in the open meeting, Churkin took on another subject and target, saying that Sweden has not complied with Paragraph 6 of Resolution 1989 in not shutting down the website "Caucasus Emirates."

Paragraph 6 is read as including Internet hosting as the type of service that cannot be provided to a group on the terrorism list. 

 Some wonder if non UN members, or de facto territories like Azawad, are bound by this: can one imagine server farms in Timbuktu?

  There was a long scheduled visit by CTED to three Scandinavian countries set for next month, confirmed to Inner City Press by Ambassador Churkin on his way out of the Council.

   Inner City Press further understands that Russia has asked for a Resolution 1989 expert to go along, specifically on the issue of this website in Sweden. Meanwhile Swedish Jan Eliasson is coming to take over as Ban Ki-moon's Deputy Secretary General. Watch this site.