Saturday, May 12, 2012

At UN on Guinea Bissau, of Regional Dysfunction, Angola Lost, the Purloined Letter?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 7 -- In the wake of the coup in Guinea Bissau, Monday's UN Security Council meeting got more interactive -- or more indicative of dysfunction. 
 
    The Economic Community Of West African States and the Portuguese Speaking Community configuration CPLP had different proposals in the Council's open meeting.
   Then the Security Council changed buildings and rooms to hold an interactive session with, among others, the Foreign Minister of Angola.

   There was an initial problem: Angola's delegation didn't show up in the North Lawn building. Frantic cell phone calls were made, but as Inner City Press exclusively reported, the meeting started without them. Only at 11:50 am did they arrive.

   Outside, a story of deeper dysfunction emerged: that the now deposed prime minister of Guinea Bissau had written a letter, to be delivered by Angola to Secretary General Ban Ki-moon and then to Council members, asking for a broader mandate for the Angolan MISSANG mission in Bissau.

   The story goes that when word of the letter reached Guinea Bissau, the coup immediately happened. The prime minister was overthrown, and detained. Several Council members heard and shook their heads.
 
   This taken place in the context where Ban's envoy to Guinea Bissau, Joseph Mutaboba, sheltered an accused drug kingpin in the UN compound for weeks, so far without repercussions. 

  Monday in the Council's open session he spoke among other things about the impact on the price of cashews.

   As the Council's closed door session in the North Lawn's Conference Room 7 continued past 1:15 pm, in the hallway outside indigenous people gathered. They had booked the room, but were not allowed in. There was some talk of colonialism, and about the P-5 members. Ultimately the indigenous were moved, over to Conference Room 6, video here and below.

   Inner City Press learned that Portugal had been asking for a Council Press Statement, today, but that other members felt any statement would be "taking sides" at this point. (For the record, on the Security Council Togo "has the pen.")

   Another Council member said the Security Council should not be the judge, the regional organizations must work it out. Yet another, from the Continent, alluded to an African Union meeting on Wednesday. 
 
  Past 1:30 pm the Council's meeting broken, with talk of yet another meeting, to involve the CPLP, African Union, ECOWAS and the UN, representative by the aforesaid Joseph Mutaboba and perhaps even Lynn Pascoe. And what about the coup in Mali? One coup at a time. Watch this site.

As Sarkozy & Juppe Voted Out, Araud & Allies to Hold Over at UN?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 7 -- The morning after Nicolas Sarkozy and by implication his foreign minister Alain Juppe were voted out by French voters, despite or because of a plea for support from National Front militants, at the UN many asked: when will French Permanent Representative Araud and his allies be leaving?

  But the answer, surprising to some in contrast to the "Arab Spring" and French statements about it, appeared to be that Araud will "not necessarily" leave. 

  The argument seems to be that Araud was not actually aligned with Sarkozy and Juppe, and / or that he has been doing a good job.

   As previously noted, Araud has been the least transparent of all Permanent Five members of the Security Council's Permanent Representatives. During his Presidency of the Council in May 2011, Araud hit a new low with only three media stakeouts. 
 
   At one of the stakeouts, Araud refused to take any questions, by reading his statement in French then leaving while an aide read it out in English.

  Hostility to the press under Araud has gone beyond non-communication. Earlier in 2011 when Inner City Press obtained a trove of documents concerning the Sarkozy administration's dealings with and about Cote d'Ivoire, the French Mission rather than providing a comment threatened Inner City Press that any publication would be considered a "hostile act." (They then proceeded to try to use proxies to retaliate.)


  The same disparity occurred on other matters, including Iran, click here for that.

  Nor would Araud explain the disparity, at least publicly. His "off the record" statements, which his aides jealously guard, put a lie to the claim that he is non partisan and should stay on. 
 
  A new French foreign minister is expected to be named by May 15; scrutinizing these things should be straightforward, and fast. Watch this site.

Saturday, May 5, 2012

As ECOWAS Backslides on Mali, At UN A Murky View of Guinea Bissau Plans

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 5 -- After the coup d'etats in Mali and Guinea Bissau, there was talk of fast troop deployments by the neighboring countries in ECOWAS and restoration of democracy or at least scheduled elections. Now things do no look so certain.

  Following ECOWAS' communique of May 3, several sources at the UN in New York told Inner City Press that ECOWAS was "confused" or even "blowing it." Inner City Press is putting the English version of the Communique online, here.

  "What happened to democracy?" an African diplomat asked Inner City Press rhetorically, adding with reference to the Ivorian President favored over resistant Laurent Gbagbo, "wasn't that what Outattara was supposed to be about?" Alassane Ouattara leads ECOWAS and chaired the meeting for the Communique. 

  Another said of Mali, "This is what [deposed president] ATT did in 1991, take power and push elections back to use the time to show he was an OK leader. But why is ECOWAS going along?"

  With a UN Security Council session on Guinea Bissau scheduled for Monday, May 7, it had been said that ECOWAS might come at that time and ask for Council support for its moves in Mali as well. 

   Now that is not so sure, even though the May 3 Communique says it will be transmitted to the "UN Security Council" seeking "support." (As to Guinea Bissau ECOWAS refers only to the "assistance" of the "UN Organization," perhaps in light of the departing Angolan mission MISSANG -- gone mission, said one wag.)
 
  One non-Western Council member told Inner City Press that ECOWAS "should have come and said, we are considering sending troops, please give us a Chapter 7 resolution. Now with their announcements it would be stupid to come at this time."

  UK Permanent Representative Mark Lyall Grant told Inner City Press that it would still be "better" for ECOWAS to come to the Security Council, even as he acknowledged it is a confusing situation.

Under the new Communique, ECOWAS would only send troops if requested by the Malian authorities. Meanwhile in the north of Mali, those who've taken over blasted open bank vaults in Gao, while Niger may now also be under threat.

  Regarding Guinea Bissau, several Council members expressed displeasure at how little Ban Ki-moon's envoy to the country, Joseph Mutaboba, seemed to know about what was going on. 

  This follows an incident in which Mutaboba allowed a US-alleged drug kingpin to take shelter for an extended period in the UN compound. Is it time for a new envoy? Watch this site.

At UN, Right to Info Stripped from Rio + 20, Extra Week Set, Indigenous Silenced?


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 4 -- In the run up to the Rio + 20 conference, on Friday evening at the UN yet another week of negotiations was arranged, for May 29 to June 2. 

  Four hundred paragraphs remain without agreement; Inner City Press asked about those dealing with the "right to information," switched by the US to "legitimate access" to information, limited by trade secrets, patents and copyright. 
 
  After Friday night's deferral, the nine "Major Groups" were given two minutes each to speak. The Indigenous group, which started speaking in Spanish about la Madre Tierra or Pachamama, was cut off by the chair and told to speak in English. Ultimately this was translated by the Local Authorities group.

  Still the Groups hit hard, with Farmers criticizing the mention of the World Trade Organization in the agriculture section, and the Youth group denouncing greenwashing (if not Blue-washing, in a week where Secretary General Ban Ki-moon in Myanmar congratulated a company involved in spying technology, as exposed by Inner City Press.)

  At the front of the room was outgoing DESA chief Sha Zukang, urging that at least 90% of the text be agreed before Rio begins. China has put in two names to replace Sha, but Brazil is pushing hard now for the DESA post, as Inner City Press exclusively reported yesterday.

Now, this update: China might accept the top post at the Department of General Assembly and Conference Affairs as long as it also got the Number Two post in DESA, at the Assistant Secretary General level. 

  But then what would sub Saharan Africa get? The Department of Public Information has, as Inner City Press reported, been promised to a European. And so it goes at the UN.

At a press conference Friday afternoon, Inner City Press asked about the right to information that was in Rio Principle 10. The response, from Neth Dano of the ETC Group of the Philippines, was that "one delegation" pushed to limited the right to only "legitimate" information. 
 
Inner City Press asked her to name that delegation, but she declined. Afterward she said it was the US, "from the State Department." Meanwhile, the US was expected to make a statement on Friday night about no more funding - will that now come on June 2? Will Obama go to Rio? Watch this site.

In Myanmar, Ban Ki-Moon Praised & Partnered with Spying Company

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 4 -- While in Myanmar, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon held an event with businesses, praising them for their Burmese engagements.

   Inner City Press asked Ban's Spokesperson, twice, which businesses were in attendance to receive Ban's thanks. After the second request a list was provided, and the delay perhaps became more understandable.

  Invited and thanked was a company which has sold surveillance and spying equipment, including to Gaddafi's Libya: ZTE Corporation. See this link and Wall Street Journal of August 30, 2011.

  With this company in attendance, Ban Ki-moon concluded on the 1st of May, "I wish you strength and success in your important efforts, and I very much welcome your partnership with the United Nations."

  Success for this company, it seems, is selling surveillance equipment, as for example France's Amesys / Bull SA. But a spy company partnering with the UN?

Already Ban's had of Peacekeeping Herve Ladsous, the fourth Frenchman in a row to hold the job, has proposed the UN using surveillance drones. But wiretapping?
  Also in attendance and praised by Ban were, among others, SK Telecom, PTT International, Mitsubishi, Total and Alcatel - Lucent.

In Tripoli as reported by the WSJ, 
 
"on the ground floor of a six-story building here, agents working for Moammar Gadhafi sat in an open room, spying on emails and chat messages with the help of technology Libya acquired from the West. The recently abandoned room is lined with posters and English-language training manuals stamped with the name Amesys, a unit of French technology firm Bull SA, which installed the monitoring center. A warning by the door bears the Amesys logo. The sign reads: 'Help keep our classified business secret. Don't discuss classified information out of the HQ.'"

   This is more than a little ironic, given that outgoing French president Nicolas Sarkozy is now threatening to sue Mediapart for publishing Moussa Koussa's letter to Bachir Saleh. A documentary on the subject, including Sarkozy adviser Jean-David Levitte, is scheduled for broadcast on May 8, two days after Sarkozy's expected electoral loss despite his plea to National Front supporters. 

  This has led to questions of whether not only Alain Juppe but at least some in the French Mission to the UN would also be replaced. Watch this site.


Inner City Press: On Myanmar, Ban Ki-moon gave a speech with the, promoting the Global Compact. But, is there a way to get a list of the businesses he cited? He said, I am here with these businesses, many people think that most of the businesses in the country are affiliated with the, you called it a dictatorship. But, the former military Government. You may not have it, but is it possible to get a list of the businesses in attendance or certainly the ones that he was citing as, you know, the future of a non-military Myanmar?

Deputy Spokesperson Eduardo Del Buey: We’ll have to check on that, Matthew.

From the UN's noon briefing transcript of May 2:

Inner City Press: were you able to get the businesses that he was referring to when he introduced the Global Compact in Myanmar. Ban's speech definitely says "the businesses here," referring to particular businesses.

Deputy Spokesperson: Yeah, we’ll get that for you.