Saturday, May 5, 2012

UN Terror Post May Be For Orr, as Germany, UK & Pakistan Vie for WMD Slots

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, May 4, updated -- As the UN Security Council met Friday on terrorism, under the surface there was a fight between three Council members for two experts posts on Weapons of Mass Destruction or 1540 committee: Germany, the UK and Pakistan. 
 
  During the session, Secretary General Ban Ki-moon announced, what else, a new high UN post, Counter Terrorism Coordinator. Immediately sources began to tell Inner City Press who is in the running to get this new job: Mike Smith, who already essentially does it, and long time American UN official Robert Orr.

  In surface compliance with Ban's Five Year Mobility Rule, Orr was recent shunted to a new job in Public Private Partnerships. There's only one problem, Budget Committee sources tell Inner City Press: this is not a funded post, and Ban can't just make up jobs and hand them out. Ah, Change Management.

  And so, cynics say, Bob Orr could get the new Counter Terrorism Coordinator post.

  A non-Western Security Council member asked Inner City Press, rhetorically it seems, "What, they can't find anyone new in the world?"

   When Ban Ki-moon and his entourage came out of the Council, Inner City Press posed the name of Mike Smith and Bob Orr, a close ally of Ban. There was an expression, but we don't interpret facial expressions here.

  Meanwhile, between Germany, the UK and Pakistan one prospective WMD expert will be left without a seat. Many say, let one of the two Europeans stand down, probably Germany.
  But a German diplomat, speaking as such, told Inner City Press that expertise should be the first and primary criterion.

  Pakistan counters that its candidate is an expert, that "not only Europeans have expertise," in this case in export controls.

  Germany questions why this is not viewed as nine candidates for the eight seats. But the six who have already informally "won" a position don't want to re-open the race, or the criteria. We hope to have more on this - watch this site.

At UN, EU Wants DPI, Will Rio+20 = DESA & Man Get Sexual Violence Post?


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 4 -- With four or really three Under Secretary General posts still in play at the UN, the Special Representative on Sexual Violence in Conflict post now also needs to be filled, Inner City Press has learned.

  When Margot Wallstrom of Sweden took the post and was slow in responding to the ongoing scandal of the mass rapes in Waliwale in the Eastern Congo, Inner City Press questioned whether she would ever move to New York and fully engage in her new Office. 
 
  Now Inner City Press is told that after she did some good she is leaving and that there are two main contenders to replace her: the deputy in the MONUSCO peacekeeping mission in the Congo and Patrick Cammaert, who to his credit once criticized the UN for doing nothing about indicted war criminal Bosco Ntaganda having fancy public dinners in Goma.

  Whether a man can get the Sexual Violence in Conflict post is dubious. The Sri Lanka mission, to which Secretary General Ban Ki-moon closely listens, also has pitched its own tales of Cammaert. But, it is suggested, why doesn't he go for the job of Radhika Coomaraswamy, who once sent him to her native Sri Lanka in her stead?

 Coomaraswamy spoke, movingly, at  German Mission event on Thursday night, and provided news that will be reported shortly.

  Also Thursday night at a press freedom event at CNN topping France's sleaze fest the talk turned to Navi Pillay's post as High Commissioner for Human Rights -- if no second term and no Western replacement then who? This we will cover soon.

  Meanwhile while Inner City Press has it most reliably that China has put in two names, Brazil is said to also be pushing for the top post in the Department of Economic and Social Affairs. If Brazil uses Rio + 20 to get it, then China would have to get the Department of General Assembly and Conference Management or the Department of Public Affairs (DPI).

(A disgusted UN staff member told Inner City Press that Ban's chief Information Technology officer, CITO Choi, might be considered to head DGACM; others say he's bound for Timor L'este to replace Amira Haq, who reportedly ended with friction with the Timorese.)

   An Ambassador who asked Ban's then chief of staff Vijay Nambiar to be considered for the DPI job was told "the Europeans want it." 

  There's said to be a candidate from Italy and one from Greece, reportedly the Ambassador who while on the Security Council helped shepherd through Ban Ki-moon's first term. This is how it works in Ban's UN - watch this site.

At UN, Doubts on Journalist Protection from Darfur to Prageeth, As Sarkozy Sues?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 3 -- There was much talk at the UN Thursday about protecting journalists, but a seeming lack of action, from UN Peacekeeping mission like that in Darfur actively undermining media Khartoum doesn't like to Secretary General Ban Ki-moon not following up on petitions about disappeared journalists like Prageeth Eknelygoda in Sri Lanka.

  At a French and Greek sponsored event on the fifth anniversary of Security Council Resolution 1738 regarding the protection of journalists in armed conflict, Inner City Press asked without answer about Prageeth, and about the UNAMID mission and its stance on Radio Dabanga.

  The Sri Lanka and Prageeth question, even now in the news, was not answered by anyone on the first panel. 

  Inner City Press directed the Darfur question to French Deputy Martin Briens, replacing Permanent Representative Gerard Araud on the panel. 


  Araud's deputy Briens did not answer, on the World Press Freedom Day panel. Finally the moderator re-asked Briens directly. He said that the Security Council could cite 1738 more often, and set up a committee.

  But if an envoy like Ibrahim Gambari doesn't like or protect a media like Radio Dabanga, what will the Security Council or Secretary General do?

  Ban Ki-moon, so beholden to Sri Lanka's President Mahinda Rajapaksa that he yelled at his own staff in front of the Sri Lankan delegation, seems to have done nothing to follow up on Pragath's disappearance, among others. 
 
  In the audience there was talk not only of Occupy Wall Street but also of a former UN press officer, Kanak Dixit, who is being harassed in Nepal. Ban Ki-moon was asked to raise the issue but has not; his focus in Nepal seems to be on a development called Lumbini.

  Tellingly in his recent trip to Myanmar -- which beyond domestic repression killed a Japanese photo journalist in 2007 -- Ban Ki-moon boosted a business which sells surveillance technology, including to Gaddafi's Libya. Protecting journalists, indeed. Watch this site.

Update of 6:05 pm -- CPJ raised NATO's bombing of Libyan state television; Inner City Press asked about Ban Ki-moon saying NATO fully complying with international law and the resolutions of the Security Council, which has refused to probe the TV bombing. By then, France's Briens had left the podium but not the room. And so it goes at the UN.

Mali & ECOWAS' Plan Not on SC Agenda for May, No Horizon, Ban Office Fail?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 3 -- Days after ECOWAS announced a plan to send 3000 soldiers to Mali, the Azeri President of the UN Security Council for May told Inner City Press that "Mali is not on the Council's agenda," and that there are no current plans for ECOWAS to brief the Council and ask for support for the planned deployment.

  For days, Inner City Press has been asking Council Ambassadors about ECOWAS' two announcements, the second about Guinea-Bissau. 
 
  Most told Inner City Press either that ECOWAS "must" come to the Council, or even if they argue that Mali's membership, or the "invitation" of the recently installed interim leader provides a legal fig leaf for intervention, it is "better" if ECOWAS comes to the Council.

  But apparently ECOWAS is not coming. The Program of Work for May, which Inner City Press obtained on May 2, has only a briefing about Guinea Bissau on May 7. 

  At Azerbaijan's May 3 press conference on the program of work, Inner City Press asked Azeri Permanent Representative Agshin Mehdiyev if ECOWAS would be coming that day, and if it would raise Mali. No and no, he answered.


Footnote: in the midst of Mehdiyev's press conference it emerged that neither the Azeris nor Ban Ki-moon's Spokesperson's Office had distributed the Program of Work, which is usually done as soon as it was adopted. 

This may be a further reflection of the loss to the press when Ban's Spokesperson was "thrown out" of the Security Council, and his then-Chief of Staff Vijay Nambiar acquiesced in the expulsion. Of note, these exchanges took place on World Press Freedom Day.
 
Another possible loss: Inner City Press asked Mehdiyev why there is in the month's agenda no "DPA Horizon Scanning Briefing," a format which all Security Council members in the past year except the US have used. Mehdiyev replied that the future of such briefing is "under negotiation," but that for now, any member can invite the Secretariat to briefing on any issue of concern. We'll see.

IMF Notes Heglig Impact, Dodges on Sudans Oil Transfer Fee, Answers ICP on Romania

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 3 -- During the International Monetary Fund's Spring Meeting last month, Inner City Press asked the the spokesperson for the IMF's Masood Ahmed about the conflict between Sudan and South Sudan:

after the press conference, in which my question was about Egypt, I asked Masood Ahmed about Sudan, South Sudan and the IMF, on which he's written, and specifically his / the IMF's view of the oil transfer fee (and impact of stopping oil pumping and destroying the Heglig field). I was told to email the question so here it is: I cover the UN, and Sudan diplomats say they want $34 a barrel transfer fee, South Sudan offers some 40 cents, citing example of Chad to Cameroon, and Azerbaijan to Turkey. What is the IMF's view of this oil transfer fee issue?

   But even as, or because, the conflict military and diplomatic around Heglig continued to heat up, the IMF never answered.

    And so to the IMF's bi-weekly embargoed briefing on May 3 Inner City Press, from in front of the UN Security Council where the day prior Sudan's Ambassador spoke of an investigation and possible reparations for Heglig, resubmitted the above question as well as a question about Romania. 
 
    Lead IMF spokesman Gerry Rice on camera answered the Romania question, saying that even after the fall of the government the IMF mission remains in dialogue and will report back. 
 
   On the reformulated Sudans question, the IMF replied:

In response to your question on South Sudan during today’s press briefing, you can attribute this to an IMF spokesperson:

"Conflict in border areas and a prolonged shutdown of oil production will have serious implications on both countries' economies and people's livelihoods. We look forward to a mutually beneficial resolution of oil and other bilateral issues as soon as possible."

While appreciated, this was the question posed by Inner City Press:

"What is the IMF doing in Sudan and South Sudan given the economic and oil transfer fee roots of the conflict between them? South Sudan cites the IMF for the less than a dollar a barrel transfer fee it proposes. I asked Ahmed Masood during the Spring meeting but have not heard back. What IS the IMF's position?"

So Inner City Press has asked again, and is now told "Sure. Will get back to you on this." Watch this site.