Saturday, May 5, 2012

As Finns Vie for SC, Small 5 Talk Reform & Vote, Colonial Echo in African Trip


By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 2, updated -- The UN Security Council need to be reformed - but there is little agreement as to how or when. In the interim countries continue to vie for their two years on the Council. 
 
  All this was on display on May 2 at the UN, when the so-called Small Five held a session in the General Assembly, while Council candidate for 2013-14 Finland showed off its peacekeeping and even chocolates in the Kuwaiti Boat area between the Council and GA.

  Costa Rica, Jordan, Liechtenstein, Singapore and Switzerland make up the Small Five. Unlike the G4, UFC and L69 the Small Five is pushing to reform the Council's "working methods," with a resolution making 21 reform points. 
 
  These include no vetoes of actions aimed at preventing or ending genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity, given the General Assembly a greater role in selecting the Secretary General, and improving due process in sanctions lists.

  A proponent Permanent Representative told Inner City Press on Wednesday that it is 90% sure that this resolution will be put to a vote on May 16, saying it requires only 50%. Others say two-third should be required.

Update of 4:07 pm - the meeting is closed, but sources tell Inner City Press Canada is proposing a vote on whether 2/3 should be required. A vote about a vote. Meanwhile a reader replies about Finland's chocolate "Martti Bar," see below, that one shouldn't eat a Nobel Peace Prize winner...

  While some say to call a vote is good -- "enough talk, let's vote" -- others say it is jumping the gun. There are five points to reform, several Ambassadors told Inner City Press, and Working Methods is the last. They should hold off.

Update of 6:20 pm -- After speaking with three of the Small Five Permanent Representatives, Inner City Press gleens that a legal opinon will be sought from the President of the GA. If he says only 50% is needed, a member of UfC may call a vote to overrule the PGA -- a vote that would be simple majority. 

  The Small Five -- perhaps they should re-brand themselves the "Strategic"Five -- seem to acknowledge that obtaining 2/3 would be a stretch. So they hope for the ruling of 50%, and that it not be overturned. Opponents have different motives; some but not all take positions in support of one or more of the Permanent Five.  We will continue on this.

  Downstairs Finland's peacekeeping and chocolate display, with a loop of upbeat music and video clips of Martti Ahtisaari, is openly directly to getting elected to the Council in October. It's a rare contested race, with Australia and Luxembourg for two seats.
Australia's pitch is that yes it is WEOG -- Western European and Other Group, to you -- but it is also in Asia, bridging the gap.

  Finland, which gave Inner City Press a tour and, in full disclosure, a chocolate bar we'll call the Martti Bar, in the tradition of the Reggie (Jackson) bar given out at one point in Yankee Stadium, is that for a small non-aligned country they do a lot in mediation, even have a war crimes expert who worked in Libya in April 2012, Helena Ranta. We aim to cover Luxembourg's pitch when we can.

  Meanwhile as Azerbaijan takes over the Security Council presidency in May there is a trip to West Africa. Tellingly, each stop is co-sponsored by the former colonialist or sponsor, paired with an African country. 

 The Cote d'Ivoire leg will be led by colonialist France, along with Togo. The Sierra Leone stop will be co-led by the UK and South Africa. And the Liberia leg's by Morocco and the United States.

   Finland went to pains to point out that it never had colonies. Australia, while both funding and some say controlling a number of small island states, was itself a colony in a sense, and now claims to be the country with the highest rate of inter-racial marriage in the world. Again, we aim to cover Luxembourg's pitch, sure to involved peacebuilding, when we can. Watch this site.

From UN Sudan Sanctions Threat, S. Kordofan & Blue Nile Are Distinguished, Qs On Jonglei & Kosti

By Matthew Russell Lee
 
UNITED NATIONS, May 2, updated -- Does the threat of sanctions in the new UN Security Council resolution on the Sudans apply to Southern Kordofan and Blue Nile and if so, how and how much?

   Inner City Press put this question to US Ambassador Susan Rice, Russia's Vitaly Churkin, South Africa's Baso Sangqu and finally Sudan's Ambassador Daffa-Alla Elhag Ali Osman and got different answers.

  In the Council chamber after the 15-0 vote, Churkin distinguished the two areas and especially the SPLM-North. As he left, Inner City Press asked him, so the sanctions language doesn't apply to Kordofan and Blue Nile? Correct, he said, calling these internal conflicts.

  Moments later Inner City Press put the same question to South Africa's Sangqu, who distinguished between the paragraph that begin with the word "decides" from Paragraph 4, which by contrasts "strongly urges" with regard to the humanitarian situation in the two areas. The African Union, he said, only wanted Article 41 for the political roadmap.
When Inner City Press asked Ambassador Susan Rice, she emphasized the Paragraph 3 is also about the SPLM-N, and they are listed in the paragraph citing Article 41 sanctions. Transcript below. 

  She also told Inner City Press that the "as necessary" concession, that China got, didn't change anything. 

  Another Western diplomat told Inner City Press that "of course it's only as necessary, that goes without saying."

  Sudan's Permanent Representative Daffa-Alla Elhag Ali Osman, when asked by Inner City Press, said his government might not adhere to the portions of the resolution about the two areas.

  He said Sudan is talking to the Arab League and African Union about this but you can't impose sanctions on this issue.

  Inner City Press asked him about another humanitarian issue, which it asked the UN about on April 30: the 12,000 South Sudanese trapped in the port of Kosti. He blamed their plight on Juba, saying that Sudan had provided seven or 10 vessel which had all be confiscated and put to military use by the South.

   South Sudanese minister Deng Alor was present and came to the stakeout. (Susan Rice twice joked that the microphone would have to be raised for him.) Inner City Press asked him, if he thought the Thabo Mbeki panel process didn't have enough teeth, did this resolution? 

  He said that the President Mbeki process had to be enhanced, and this was a move in that direction.

Inner City Press also asked Deng Alor a humanitarian question: is his government's disarmament program in Jonglei voluntary or by force? Recently it's been said that Jonglei "raiders" who don't disarm will be killed. Alor insisted that the disarmament program is voluntary, and that it is going well. We'll see. Watch this site.

From the US Mission transcript:

Inner City Press: In the chamber, Ambassador Churkin said that his understanding is that Chapter VII, Article 41 doesn't apply in Southern Kordofan and Blue Nile. And outside, he said that's because it's an internal matter. Another ambassador that it makes this distinction between the paragraphs that are "decides" and the one that "strongly urges." Do you see this distinction? Do you agree that somehow this resolution treats SPLM-North and those two areas differently than the North-South?

Ambassador Rice: Well, first of all the entire operative part is under Chapter VII, and there are, if I'm not mistaken off the top of my head, four "decides" paragraphs, including one-paragraph three-which relates to resolving the political issues that are at the root of the conflict in Southern Kordofan and Blue Nile. And we view both Sudan-the government of Sudan-and the SPLM-North as bound by OP 3 of the resolution. You'll also notice in OP 6-where we talk about the potential for sanctions under Article 41-we list not only the government of Sudan and the government of South Sudan but the SPLM-North as potentially subject to measures should they not comply. So I think that answers the question. The Council took its time and was quite deliberate in negotiating and discussing and debating this resolution, and it has come forth with a clear and unanimous set of requirements on the parties and a clear statement of its intentions should the parties fail to comply.

As Deutsche Bank Evades Fed, Tarullo Airbrushes "Some Private Actors," Blurs FOIA and Volcker Rulemaking

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, May 2 -- When the Federal Reserve's Daniel Tarullo spoke Wednesday at the Council on Foreign Relations about regulatory reform, he did not mention a single bank or financial institution.

  Inner City Press asked him about Deutsche Bank, which earlier this year split off its investment banking business so as to avoid Fed regulation. Tarullo on March 22 told the Senate the Fed would have to "respond" to this, that it had some impact on this thinking on regulation.

  Tarullo replied, "Matthew, what I said was it effected my thinking, not change, that implies a dramatic shift." Then he answered, six minutes in all, without once mentioning Deutsche Bank. He said that "the kind of changes some private actors are engaged in will have to effect the scope of our regulations."

  These regulations, he said, will be "under 165... to make sure we can implement Congressional concern."

  Inner City Press also asked Tarullo if he claimed the Fed has gotten more transparent since the financial meltdown, noting the Fed's recent denial in full of access to over 2000 pages responses to an Inner City Press FOIA request.


  Tarullo, which has previously heard of FOIA problems at the Fed, said he didn't know which FOIA request was referred to, then answered about administrative rule making. He said "for rule making, we get comments" and now distinguish "unique comments -- that is, not form letters."

He said there have been "17,000 Volcker Rule submissions... Absorbing all the comments is a substantial undertaking. If it takes longer to give due respect to comments," so be it.

  The FOIA request referred to was about Capital One's compliance, since the Fed's approval order on Capital One - ING DIRECT, including with Capital One's commitments to open branches and lend $180 billion" and about Capital One firing 490 assistant branch managers despite having made representations about increasing service.

  Amazingly, the Fed found 2200 pages responsive but provided not a single document, instead saying that "your request is denied in full," including as to each and every record "regarding with the Approval Order" of Capital One - ING DIRECT. ICP commented extensively on that application, as did NCRC, and the Fed's order cites the comments and Capital One's responses and representations. Now the Fed denies access to every record about compliance with the representations. 
 
Inner City Press' request included a specific reference to branch closings, for example, which are not confidential. Additionally, information submitted and reviewed about compliance with Capital One's representations would contain HMDA data, which is public and not withholdable.

Even since the April 10 request, ICP on April 22 submitted to the Fed information about an admission by Capital One of fraud on consumers:

"Earnings power of HSBC card deal to drown out near-term noise, says Capital One CEO," April 19, 2012

Fairbank also reported a $75 million accrual for customer refunds stemming from what he described as 'instances in which phone sales people didn't adhere to our scripts and sales policy when cross-selling products to our credit card customers.' He said it is very important that Capital One ensures customers bought the unspecified products in the manner the company intended."

Just because it SOUNDS like the responsive records might include some withholdable information, it is outrageous to withheld each and every responsive record, citing the catch-all Exemption 8. The Fed is increasingly abusing and evading FOIA. Watch this site.

On Sudans, China Got Change to Sanctions Only "If Necessary," Russia to Vote Yes

By Matthew Russell Lee


  On May 2 in front of the Security Council, Chinese Permanent Representative Li Baodong told the Press that a change had been made -- Article 41 sanctions only "if necessary." With that, he said, China would vote yes.

  Inner City Press asked US Ambassador Susan Rice if the draft resolution in blue had been modified. She nodded and answered, "Very little, it's a good text." 
 
  Unanimous adoption has been brought about. Russia's Ambassador Vitaly Churkin told the press that he would be voting yes, "because of the African Union" and its request. He said Russia would make a statement expressing reservations.

  South Sudan representative Agnes Oswaha told Inner City Press that Article 41 is still in "but not explicitly." She entered the Security Council with her ministerial delegation including Deng Alor, who has said that the negotiations with Khartoum have to go beyond the Thabo Mbeki process and have more teeth.

Sudan's Permanent Representative walked into the Council in a bright white suit. One expects another round of dueling stakeouts after the vote. What about the damage at Heglig?

  Separately -- or not -- the buzz in front of the Security Council Wednesday morning was that the proposed lists of 40 new entities to be put on the North Korea sanctions list, whittled by China down to two, was now up to three, with a silence procedure running until noon on Wednesday. Questions were posed to entering Ambassadors but those asked, did not answer.

Footnote: Azerbaijan, May's President of the Security Council, had a press conference on May's program of work scheduled for 12:30, the normal time. But then it was listed as "canceled." One wonders if that means postponed until the Sudan resolution dust settles. Every other recent president has done such a presser. Watch this site.