Saturday, April 14, 2012

On W. Sahara, UN Airbrushes Spying & Drops Moroccan Flags From April 6 Report

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 12 -- The day after Inner City Press first reported substantial changes between the April 6 and April 11 versions of the UN's report on its mission in Western Sahara, Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesman refused to explain the revision process or who had input. Video here, from Minute 12:25.

Inner City Press asked in particular about deletions from Paragraph 46, which its in April 6 version stated that

"MINURSO civilian personnel movements there are closely monitored with the consequent chilling effect on interaction with the full spectrum of local interlocutors. In parallel, the Moroccan police surveillance outside the compound discourages visitors from approaching MINURSO in an independent capacity; Mission staff who have received such visitors have been taken to task by Moroccan authorities."

In the April 11 version this is air-brushed to

"access to external contacts is controlled [monitored (the word is crossed out)] which has an effect on interaction with the full spectrum of local interlocutors. In parallel, Moroccan police presence outside the compound discourages visitors from approaching MINURSO in an independent capacity. There were also indications that the confidentiality of communications between MINURSO headquarters and New York was, at least on occasion, compromised."

Compare April 6 version, here, especially Paragraph 46, with April 11 changed version, here.

The Frente Polisario had written to the Security Council to complain of the deletion of reporting of 21 Moroccan flags around the MINURSO headquarters in Aaiun, "undermining the independence and impartiality of the UN." Inner City Press is putting the letter online, here.

It was about this that Inner City Press sought to ask spokesman Nesirky. But he merely said, and repeated, that it is not unprecedented for there to be such changes. As Inner City Press reported and pointed out, it happened last year, too, under Alain Le Roy who was the third Frenchman in a row to head UN Peacekeeping.

Now under the fourth Frenchman, Herve Ladsous, the process is even more blatant, with changes dictated even after a draft is circulated to Security Council members and otherwise. Also noted is the hypocrisy of certain of these Security Council members who make much when it suits them of the importance of independent reports not subject to political interference on issues like Iran, DPRK and Sudan sanctions -- but think ordering changes on reports like this MINURSO one is perfectly fine.

Again, most tellingly, the April 6 versions said that MINURSO was

"intended to operate for three critical purposes: 1) as an instrument of stability in the event that the political stalemate continues; 2) as a mechanism to implement a referendum on self-determination in the event that the talks led by my Personal Envoy are successful; and 3) to provide independent information on conditions in the Territory to the Secretariat, the Security Council, and the international community."

The revised April 11 version changes 2) to

"as a mechanism to support implementation of successive Security Council resolutions related to the mandate of MINURSO (the United Nations Mission for the Referendum in Western Sahara)."

Compare April 6 version, here, especially from Paragraph 114, with April 11 changed version, here.

How will envoy Christopher Ross respond? His briefing is scheduled for April 17. Watch this site.

As IMF Praises and Turns from Iceland, Cites Basel, Calls Hungary Anti-Bank

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 12 -- Has Iceland turned the corner away from financial meltdown? The International Monetary Fund seems to think so. On Thursday the IMF released three reviews of the country and held an embargoed conference call for the press hosted by Julie Kozack, tellingly her last as IMF Mission Chief to Iceland. She will be moving on to Lithuania and Poland.

The IMF has praised Iceland's write-down of debts, while criticizing Hungary's restructuring, complaining that "all losses from the implied debt reduction would be borne by the banks alone."

As previously noted by Inner City Press, the IMF likes bank mergers. Last April, IMF European Department Director Antonio Borges told reporters on Friday that Belgium was smart to have pushed Fortis to being acquired by BNP Paribas. He urged more such mergers.

Inner City Press asked Borges if the IMF proposed any safeguards at all, given that concerns exist that when a local bank is acquired by one based far away, there will be less reinvestment and accountability.

Borges, while calling this an “interesting question,” bragged that the IMF organized a coordinated effort to get large banks to treat communities, particularly in Emerging Europe, fairly, and that this had worked

And so it seems, the IMF likes bank mergers. In Iceland this is footnoted, that "data for Landsbankinn and Islandsbanki reflect the impact of their respective mergers with Sp Kef. and Byr in the second half of 2011."

Only yesterday, the IMF minimized the rushed licensing of nine new banks by political insiders in Bangladesh on the eve of its program with that country, saying that at least they'll be subject to new rules.

Regarding bank regulation in Iceland, the IMF says

"A strong, intrusive, and independent supervisory agency is essential to help avoid the build-up of risks that can lead to crisis... additional examiners with credit risk expertise may be needed in the onsite inspection area and the credit risk bureau may need more resources to become a powerful supervisory tool. Staff underscored that preserving the FME’s independence, and its capacity and willingness to act, is essential to ensure that the needed strengthening of supervision continues, toward full compliance with Basel Core Principles."

But what of bank regulation in countries like the United States, UK, France and Germany? Watch this site.

UN Mission in Congo Uses Private Military Contractor, ICP Proves, As Ban Stonewalls, Deal with Museveni

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 11, updated April 12 -- The UN uses private military contractors or mercenaries, in the Congo for example, Inner City Press has learned.

The UN is not supposed to use mercenaries, but on April 9 Inner City Press asked the Department of Peacekeeping Operations in writing:

"please confirm or deny that MONUSCO uses the private security firm Saracen, and if not deny, state what they do, and how use of this firm does not constitute UN using private military contractor or 'mercenaries,' including in light of interaction between Saracen and UN Somalia / Eritrea sanctions committee. Where (else) does DPKO or DFS use private security?"

But DPKO, despite having a database to contractors to which Inner City Press also has access, said it needed time to response. So the next day on April 10 Inner City Press asked the UN spokesman:

Inner City Press: I have asked DPKO and I haven't received an answer, does MONUSCO use Saracen Uganda or any other Saracen variant which is a private military contractor, for security in the Congo and how does it comply with UN rules on using mercenaries?

Spokesperson Martin Nesirky: if you have asked DPKO and they haven't answered yet, don’t take that necessarily as a no, it means they may still be trying to get the answer you are looking for, okay.

Inner City Press: Since you’ve got a procurement data base, they can just plug the name in.

Spokesperson Nesirky: Thanks, Matthew, for that, and let’s see what we can come up with. Good afternoon everybody.

But even the next day April 11, the spokesman did not send Inner City Press any answer, and DPKO said it needed yet more time.

Saracen, as Inner City Press previously reported in connection with its attempts to get paid by Somalia's Transitional Federal Government despite the UN's Somalia / Eritrea sanctions, is partially owned by the brother of Uganda's president Yoweri Museveni -- who Secretary General Ban Ki-moon called on April 11, according to Sudan's Permanent Representative with whom Ban also spoke.

So here from Inner City Press is information from the UN's procurement database, answering the question in the affirmative (but in turn raising more questions to be pursued) --

August 2010 SARACEN UGANDA LTD UGA CON/MON/10-085
Provision of Unarmed Security Services at Entebbe and Kampala
1-Aug-10 to 31-Jul-11 $170,685 MONUSCO

September 2010 SARACEN UGANDA LTD UGA
Security services $132,935 11KIN-200211 MONUSCO

July 2011 SARACEN UGANDA LTD UGA
Security services $144,648 12KIN-200059 MONUSCO

So why wouldn't DPKO and Ban Ki-moon's spokesman just answer the question? Watch this site.

Update of April 12, 10 am -- DPKO has written, in response to the April 9 questions:

"I have a response on the parts of your questions related to MONUSCO. On private security more generally, I am still following up. Question: Is MONUSCO using the services of SARACEN, a Ugandan private security company?

"MONUSCO contracts private unarmed security companies to assist in access control procedures in all of its compounds. Saracen is contracted by MONUSCO for these purposes at its base in Entebbe, Uganda."

While DPKO did not provide that actual contract information which Inner City Press published, this information says Saracen is under UN contract in Kampala as well. We seek explanation and await response "private security more generally" - and how it complies with UN system rules and principles. Watch this site.

Carr Says Ban Acknowledged Australia's SC Case, BanWould "Praise Any State"

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 11 -- When new Australia Foreign Minister Bob Carr came to meet UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon on April 10, Inner City Press went to the photo-op, along with two Australian photographers. See here and here.

Afterward Carr bragged that Ban had acknowledged the strength of his country's case for a Security Council seat, a campaign started by his predecessor Kevin Rudd.

Funny thing, though -- when Ban issued his own read out of the meeting, there was no mention of the Security Council, much less Australia's race against Finland and Luxembourg, where Ban is traveling to now.

So at the UN's April 11 noon briefing Inner City Press asked:

Inner City Press: This meeting with the Australian Foreign Minister, Bob Carr, I saw the readout and then I also saw what Mr. Carr said that Australia’s bid for a Security Council seat was discussed and he said that the Secretary-General has acknowledged that Australia has a good case, so I just wonder, was it discussed in that meeting? This is obviously a key issue to Australia. Is Mr. Carr wrong or is there some diplomatic reason not to include the full agenda of the discussion?

Spokesperson Martin Nesirky: Matthew, readouts are not transcripts of meetings, they are readouts of meetings and we do not put in readouts the interlocutors comments. We are referring to what the Secretary-General has raised or topics that have been raised that are of a general interest. For example, the DPRK. Everybody knows that a number of countries are bidding for Security Council seats, non-permanent seats. And everybody knows that that’s a decision that is in the hands of Member States and not the Secretary-General. And, therefore, it is not proper for him to take a position on any Member State’s bid. It is also obvious that the Secretary-General would recognize the work of any Member State at the United Nations. So, I think that is pretty clear, Matthew.

Any member state? How about Syria? Watch this site.