Saturday, April 14, 2012

Amid Border War, UN in South Sudan Sees Nothing, Unclear Where Ban Calls

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 11 -- As tensions mount between Khartoum and Juba, the UN Mission in South Sudan despite the public money it spends shows itself unwilling or unable to verify any facts, much less save lives. Earlier this year it reacted slowly to mass killing in Jonglei State and has yet to release its report on casualties. Now it will not confirm aerial bombing, or more recent incursions.

After a Security Council meeting Wednesday morning, US Ambassador Susan Rice as April's Council President told the press that "the Secretary-General is also seeking to engage senior authorities in Khartoum."

Inner City Press' questions to Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesman proved fruitless (see below). Nor would Sudan's Permanent Representative, in a surreal stakeout interview with two journalists late on Wednesday, say to whom if anyone Ban Ki-moon had called.

There were two experts' meetings in the Concil Wednesday afternoon: on a draft Sudan statement, and on a US thematic topic called "illicit flows." Inner City Press was covering both when Sudan's Ambassador Daffa-Alla Elhag Ali Osman arrived.

He told Inner City Press that what Rice said at the stakeout and what the US presented in the statement it drafted were inconsistent; he called for UN Television to set its cameras up.

This took some 20 minutes, during which time much was learned about Sudanese diplomacy ranging from Bangledesh to the Central African Republic. A US diplomat, not Rice, took Sudan's Permanent Representative into the Council's quiet room to talk. Slowly the UNTV camera was assembled.

When the stakeout began, only one other journalist had come, to ask how far into Sudan the South Sudanese had driven. Eighty kilometers was the answer. Inner City Press asked about rebels targeting Sudan's other oil wells, and to whom Ban Ki-moon had called.

The responses all jibes strangely with arguments about Syria: who is the victim, who should be condemned, who sets the deadline. Sudan has threatened to retaliate, "deep inside South Sudan." This does not sound good.

From the UN's April 11 noon briefing transcript:

Inner City Press: the Secretary-General has made these contacts, but the Mission in South Sudan what insights does it have? Does it play any role? Does it have any sense of who is doing what and who breached the border or does it not look at that?

Spokesperson Martin Nesirky: I am trying to unpack the many layers of your question.

Question: Sure. But he has a peacekeeping mission there, and there is a war, and there is now a war, so I am wondering, the peacekeeping mission, does it have anything to say on, did South Sudan go across the border into [inaudible]?

Spokesperson: Well, first of all, as I mentioned, Matthew, Mr. Mulet briefed the Council to provide an update on what we understand the position to be at the moment. The Mission, as you point out, is in South Sudan and its remit is South Sudan, therefore, it does not have a presence on the other side of the border. The other point is that, what is really important here is that there should be a de-escalation by both parties, and that is what the Secretary-General has been emphasizing in his phone calls and in his discussions, as I mentioned, in Washington, and that’s, I think, understandable. And those contacts will continue when the Secretary-General returns to New York. He is on his way back right now.

Inner City Press: the reason I asked this is because I asked over at the Security Council if Mr. Mulet would do a stakeout and sort of provide some factual stuff from DPKO, and I was told no, that the… the place for that was here, so that’s why I am asking you.

Spokesperson: Well, Matthew, I have given you an update based on the information we have at this point. You should also understand that it goes well beyond the remit of the UN Mission in South Sudan, clearly because it involves two countries and the Mission does not have a presence or a mandate in Sudan proper. So therefore, the Secretary-General has been reaching out to both parties; others, of course, are involved in this, including regional leaders, including Prime Minister Meles, as I have just said, the Secretary-General just spoke to him. This is, obviously, a very serious matter, and it is something that the Secretary-General is actively involved in trying to de-escalate. That’s the focus.

Some focus. Watch this site.

As IMF Tells Bangladesh How to Regulate Banks, Insiders Rush for Licenses

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 11 -- While the International Monetary Fund often insists it does not impose conditions on loans, for the $1 billion program it announced Wednesday for Bangladesh, it required among other things lower fuel subsidies, and centralizing bank regulation.

Inner City Press asked David Cowen, IMF Mission Chief for Bangladesh, about this bank regulation condition, and about the rush by Bank Bangladesh to give licenses to nine new banks chartered by political insiders, on the eve of the IMF decision.

Cowen described the required amendments to the Bank Companies Act, for "fit criteria for bank directors," and said that the IMF was aware of the recent license grants, and hadn't had the chance to discuss them with Bangladesh authorities.

He said regular procedures for licensing new banks had been followed -- indeed -- and that the banks should be subject to the regulations applicable to all banks in Bangladesh.

Here's a description of the six most recent banks and their sponsors:

"former president and Jatiya Party chief H.M. Ershad (Union Bank), ruling party lawmakers Fazle Noor Taposh (Modhumati Bank) and Mohiuddin Khan Al Amgir (Farmers Bank), S.M. Amjad Hussain (South Bangla Agriculture and Commerce Bank) and Ashequr Rahman (Meghna Bank) and Moniruzzaman Khan Khandaker (Midland Bank), the income tax lawyer to Shaikh Hasina."

What was that again, about "fit criteria for bank directors"?

Meanwhile HSBC is trying either to sell its 13 Bangladesh branches, reportedly to Standard Chartered, or simply to close them by some accounts.

On April 10 HSBC announced it is in talks to sell off its operations in Pakistan and is moving in on a sale of its South Korean businesses to the Korea Development Bank.

Beyond Bangladesh, other Asian markets where HSBC has fewer than 20 branches are Brunei Darussalam, Macao, New Zealand, the Philippines and Sri Lanka. Watch this site.

On W. Sahara, UN Drops "Referendum for Self-Determination" From April 6 Report

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 11 -- In what is becoming an annual ritual of craven ineptitude, the UN Secretariat of Ban Ki-moon and Frenchman Herve Ladsous have again crudely watered down their report on Western Sahara.

Inner City Press is today putting online the versions of April 6, 2012, which had a discussion of the referendum on self-determination for which the UN mission MINURSO was set up, and the changed version of April 11, which drops the reference, and more.

The April 6 version said that MINURSO was

"intended to operate for three critical purposes: 1) as an instrument of stability in the event that the political stalemate continues; 2) as a mechanism to implement a referendum on self-determination in the event that the talks led by my Personal Envoy are successful; and 3) to provide independent information on conditions in the Territory to the Secretariat, the Security Council, and the international community."

The revised April 11 version changes 2) to

"as a mechanism to support implementation of successive Security Council resolutions related to the mandate of MINURSO (the United Nations Mission for the Referendum in Western Sahara)."

Compare April 6 version, here, especially from Paragraph 114, with April 11 changed version, here.

This happened last year, though it took an actual leak to Inner City Press to expose it. This year, the UN did it openly, after having circulated the April 6 version.

While most attribute the changes to pressure from Morocco, which this year unlike last is a member of the Security Council, active not only on Western Sahara and often positively, Inner City Press would put more of the blame, or shame, on the Secretariat of Ban Ki-moon and Ladsous, the fourth Frenchman in a row to head the UN Department of Peacekeeping Operations.

Already Ladsous has been written to with this complaint:

"Dear Mr. Ladsous. I am concerned by the fact that the UNSG report whose copy has been already sent to the UNSC members and the parties (Morocco news agency MAP has already published several parts of the report) still not available on the UN web site. I learned that once again Morocco is trying to force changes on some specific paragraphs contained in the 'recommendations and observations.' This attempt is showing nothing more nothing less than is not only MINRSDO on the ground which is submitted to 'unacceptable established practices' imposed by Morocco but also the UN headquarters."

But Ladsous and Ban Ki-moon who appointed him appear to be more and more shameless. How will they explain these changes? How will envoy Christopher Ross respond? His briefing is scheduled for April 17. And what's called the Group of Friends on Western Sahara are, without AU input, negotiating a draft resolution, on which we'll have more. Watch this site.

Myanmar and Kachin Now UN Afterthoughts, Ban on Voting Scarcely Mentioned

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 11 -- Have things in Myanmar changed so much that its fallen off the UN Security Council's radar screen, even on the rare day there's a Burmese item on the agenda?

The Council was to have heard from UN envoy Vijay Nambiar on Tuesday, but it was unceremoniously postponed because Syria, a briefing by former head of peacekeeping Jean-Marie Guehenno, was added to the agenda.

So Nambiar came to the Council Wednesday morning,but quickly left -- Sudan came first, the cross border fighting between Juba and Khartoum.

Outside, Inner City Press asked Nambiar again about Kachin State, where in three constituencies voting was not allowed.

As Inner City Press reported last month, one of the constituencies, Mogaung, has had no known fighting so its unclear why voting has been canceled there -- except for the fact that the the candidate running there Dr. Tu Ja was a former vice chairman of the KIO and would almost certainly have won.

Another constituency Hpakant has had some fighting but very little over the past few months so again its unclear if security is the real reason voting can't take place. The popular candidate is Bauk Ja (also Bawk Ja or Bauk Gyar) is from the NLD splinter group the NDF and almost certainly would win in a fair fight.

At least outside the Security Council, Nambiar acknowledged that this is a concern, adding that recent meetings between the government and Karen rebels might portend well for the Kachin.

When US Ambassador Susan Rice emerged at the end of the session, she read out summaries on Sudan and, on Myanmar, a relatively glowing one. The first of what were going to be only two questions was on neither of the morning's topics, but rather on Syria.

The day previous a question on North Korea, which has not been on the agenda pending the country's impending missile launch, was allowed but taken last, after Syria. But on Wednesday, Syria came before either of the day's Council agenda items. Ambassador Rice answered in her national capacity.

Then came a question on Sudan, something about the unity of the Council. (As Inner City Press reported prior to the stakeout, and after asking about Sudan at the day's UN noon briefing, a draft Presidential Statement has already been circulated, and experts will meet on it in the afternoon.)

Then that was supposed to be it: no question on Myanmar, and no mention of Kachin or any other problem.

Inner City Press asked about Kachin, and to her credit Ambassador Rice stopped and answered, that yes it had come up in consultations and members had expressed concerns. But what will they do about it? Myanmar is a country with a now full-time Under Secretary General assigned to it. What will be accomplished, for example for the Kachin?

Secretary General Ban Ki-moon is slated to go to Myanmar later this month for what many thing will be a sort of victory tour highlighting a country that has gotten better while he has been Secretary General.

When even those countries which used to watchdog backsliding on Myanmar now trend to forgetting it, what will be accomplished, for example for the Kachin? Watch this site.