Saturday, April 14, 2012

In Sudan, UN's Tchalian "Met Daily" With Harun, Now UNAMID Chief of Staff: War Criminals Not Banned

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, April 11 -- The UN's intimacy with war criminals is exemplified in Sudan by UN official Karen Tchalian, now the chief of staff of the Mission in Darfur, UNAMID.

While Tchalian worked for UNMIS in Southern Kordofan, complaints were made to the Department of Peacekeeping Operations that he was meeting frequently -- "daily" -- with Ahmed Harun, indicted by the International Criminal Court for war crimes in Darfur, Inner City Press has learned. Tchalian's dubious positions, beyond Haroun, also appear in cables obtained and published by Wikileaks:

"The UNMIS head of the Section IV office in Kadugli, Mr. Karen Tchalian, said he was 'cautiously optimistic' that demobilization of SPLM units and reintegration of SPLM-controlled areas in the Nuba Mountains was making reasonably good progress after a long delay. He expressed concern at the availability of inflammatory misinformation on various internet sites about tens of thousands of armed men massed in the area, and criticized a recent Small Arms Survey report on the situation there."

Rather than be admonished, Tchalian was promoted to a higher UN position, in the region for which Harun was indicted: Darfur.

The UN claims to only deal with ICC indictees "as necessary." But Tchalian's new boss in Darfur, Ibrahim Gambari, took photos with ICC indictee Omar al Bashir at a wedding reception for the daughter of Chad's Idriss Deby and Musa Hilal, founder of the janjaweed militia.

After Inner City Press asked about it for more than a week, the UN announced that Gambari had been told to avoid this in the future. But Gambari has said that he will do it again, and Ban Ki-moon has not responded.

Meanwhile Ban Ki-moon has another alleged war criminal as a Senior Adviser on Peacekeeping Operations: Sri Lankan General Shavendra Silva, whose 58th Division is depicted in Ban's own Panel of Experts report as engaged in war crimes. As with Tchalian, will Ban's UN offer Silva an ever higher advisory post next time?

Harun is in the news, as much as the UN tries to play it down. Inner City Press on April 2 asked Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesman:

Inner City Press: footage has come out over the weekend of Ahmed Haroun, the Governor of Southern Kordofan, shown in very clear video fashion telling troops in Southern Kordofan to take no prisoners and to clean them out, and a general stands next to him and says, “let’s eat them raw”. And many are saying that this is proof of a war crime and obviously into some [inaudible] back to the UN actually flying Ahmed Haroun to Abyei and back. Does the UN, given its continuing interest in this area, Southern Kordofan, and its role in the past with Ahmed Haroun, have any view of this tape and what should happen now?

Spokesperson Martin Nesirky: Well, listen, as you know, we don’t have direct full access to Southern Kordofan in the fashion that we would obviously like. So, it is very difficult for us to have a full picture of what is happening on the ground. We are obviously extremely concerned about the reports that are coming out of there. I think it is a bit of a stretch to be linking what may or may not be happening now with previous engagements of the kind that you mentioned — transporting this gentleman by helicopter. But, I understand what you are saying. I don’t have anything further on that particular point, except simply to stress that we are concerned about the reports that are emerging from there. But, we don’t have the direct access that we would need to be able to really understand fully what is going on.

So, the UN sought not to respond to what Harun was filmed saying, and even to avoid commenting on what is going on in South Kordofan by citing its lack of access.

Beyond the UN's Tchalian's meeting with Harun, the UN has offered free helicopter flights to Harun after he was indicted by the International Criminal Court.

On April 4, Inner City Press asked Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Nesirky about it again. This time, Nesirky said "there's a couple of points here. There appears to be some controversy around the video itself.... as a general principle any incitement that could potentially lead to war crimes we would not welcome... There are already outstanding accusation against Mr. Harun, that's within the bailiwick of the prosecutor of the ICC, it's for them to deal with that."

Of Silva and Ban's Senior Advisory Group on Peacekeeping, coverage of which Ban's minders are now trying to hinder, Ban told Inner City Press, it was a decision of member states, and nothing since. From photos with Bashir to no comment on Silva and now Harun: this is Ban's UN.

UN Says Silva "Not Participating" in SAG, But Coverage "Not Permitted"

By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive

UNITED NATIONS, April 10 -- After UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon repeatedly declined to opine on or oppose the appointment to his Senior Advisory Group on Peacekeeping (SAG) of Sri Lankan General Shavendra Silva, whose 58th Division is depicted in Ban's own Panel of Experts report as engaged in war crimes, the SAG chair Louise Frechette herself ruled Silva inappropriate.

On April 9, Sri Lanka Permanent Representative Palitha Kohona told Inner City Press that the only reason Silva did not attend is that "he's not here, Mr. Silva is out of the country... Two points, one is, it's illegal, this is inconsistent with the resolution. The chair has no right to say I don't like your face. Second, the chair can't tell the Asia Group who to send. This is insulting and humiliating to the Asians."

It seems obvious in this context that to journalistically cover this issue requires going to observe if Silva attends or does not attend the UN SAG meetings.

But earlier this month the SAG's "organizers," Inner City Press was told, "did not give their permission for press coverage." Ban's UN Secretariat, citing a meeting with the UN Correspondents' Association, said that the Press cannot go try to see if Silva attends the meetings, at least not without a minder.

This followed Inner City Press going on April 2 to see if Silva would attend the SAG meeting, which was held in the UN rented building at 380 Madison Avenue. Several members of the SAG spoke with Inner City Press, but again, Ban's Secretariat claims that "the organizers" don't want this -- without identifying who the organizers are.

Inner City Press wrote to the spokesman of UN Peacekeeping asking

"on the Senior Advisory Group on Peacekeeping Operations, you circulated Ms. Frechette's statement but said she doesn't have a spokesperson, does she now or please ask and get answer to: what is Shavendra Silva's current status with the SAG? Was the Asia Group represented at April 2-3 SAG meetings? I've been told SAG 'organizers' do not give their permission for press coverage -- is Frechette that organizer? Who are the organizers, and why do they seek in inhibit press coverage? On deadline."

The next day, not having any response to or support on this, Inner City Press put the questions to Ban's spokesman: (video here)

Inner City Press: This has to do with the Senior Advisory Group on peacekeeping operations, they met April 2 and 3, and I went to try and cover it, it appears that Shavendra Silva who appears in Ban Ki-moon’s report about this Panel of Experts, his division is depicted engaged in war crimes, did not attend. If I can just get a confirmation from the UN system that he didn’t attend. I am told by the Sri Lankans that the only reason he didn’t attend is that he was out of town. What bothered me the most I heard from Media Accreditation here that the organizers did not give permission for press coverage of the meeting, and it was unclear to me, number one, if that in the UN system people have to give permission for press coverage, but more substantially, I don’t know who the organizers are. Is it a panel? Ban Ki-moon appointed some people, regional groups appointed others, who makes that decision? Who are the organizers, because a number of the Member States on it did not only permit, but invited press coverage, and so I want to know, it may seem like a little bit kind of a logistical question, but since it is something that I was trying to cover, it’s a committee that advises Ban Ki-moon and I am told I can’t cover it without their permission, I would like to know what the position is.

Spokesperson Martin Nesirky : Well, I think there is a difference between covering it and seeking access to a building without being accompanied by an official from the Media and Accreditation Liaison Unit, which is standard procedure. And as I understand it, MALU, the Unit in question, has made it very clear what the rules are, but also their readiness to help you to be able to have access to parts of the UN premises that are off campus, if you wish, to be able to cover an event. So, that’s the technical part of it. On the other bits, let me find out.

Inner City Press: The problem that I have here is that, if they are saying that the organizers, and I don’t know who they are, don’t permit press coverage, it seems strange. I’m going to cover it the next time they meet, I intend to cover it. The question becomes they said yes, we’ll escort you into the building, but does this require [the permission of] the undisclosed and unnamed organizers who I don’t know who they are, and I would like to know if the Secretariat is some part of it--

Spokesperson: Well if…

Inner City Press: the other part of the question, if I can just say this…

Spokesperson: Yeah.

Question: I hate to say this, but [garbled by UN - the word "minders" was used]

Spokesperson: Well, if you hate to say it, why are you saying it?

Question: Okay, does MALU report any information to the rest of the Secretariat? I am a reporter trying to get information --

Spokesperson: Matthew, can I just interrupt you?

Correspondent: Please.

Spokesperson: For one second?

Correspondent: Yes.

Spokesperson: Which I don’t do terribly often, but…

Correspondent: Okay, I understa… no, I [inaudible].

Spokesperson: But, let me just say, I think that this is a conversation that is best carried on off-line rather than taking up the time of the briefing on what is very much an individual request, which I respect, which I respect, but I think that we can deal with it off-line. So let me just — I know you have a question on Congo — but I want to see if other people have other questions first. No, they don’t.

This is typical. The spokesman cuts off a question about the Secretariat's own performance by claiming that there are other questions -- only, there aren't any other questions. The UN transcript intentionally garbles the questions, and cuts out words like "minder." Compare to video, here.

Nevertheless, after the above exchange, UN Peacekeeping's spokesman replied with this:

Subject: Reply ... on / for Senior Advisory Group on Peacekeeping
From: Kieran Dwyer [at] un.org
Date: Tue, Apr 10, 2012 at 6:03 PM
To: matthew.lee[at] innercitypress.com, cc: Andre-Michel Essoungou [at] un.org

Dear Matthew, In response to your question about the Senior Advisory Group, I have the following information - I am following this up to facilitate your query but I am not the spokesperson for this advisory group which is not part of DPKO. The Senior Advisory Group (SAG) does not have a spokesperson or media officer. I am advised that the SAG is continuing its assessment of troop cost reimbursement issues. Once the Group has finished this assessment, I understand that it will deliver its report to the General Assembly through the Secretary-General, as mandated in its founding resolution. I am advised that General Silva is not participating in the Group, and that the Chair's previous statement on this matter stands. There are nineteen other SAG members, including several from the Asia-Pacific region. I am continuing to follow up on your other questions.

It's appreciated. The other questions concern, among other things, the UN's seeming use of mercenaries...

Footnote: there has been no help from the Correspondents' Association. To the contrary, an officer of the Association on April 9 emailed other members of the Executive Committee -- of which Inner City Press is an elected member -- seeking to exclude Inner City Press from future meetings, all without sending a copy to Inner City Press, amid without apparent irony references to journalistic ethics.

When confronted, the officer said "there was no meeting, do your homework." Indeed. The issue is not as claimed describing any purportedly confidential Correspondents' Association meeting -- with MALU, one that the officer in question didn't even take the time to attend -- but rather that the current Ban-era Association, supposed to be supporting journalists to be able to physically cover the UN, in fact seeks to engage in censorship, then to censor any reports of its own actions, and to exhort in its own meetings "more positive coverage of the UN."

While a diversion, we can have more on this. Watch this site.