Saturday, April 7, 2012

As UN Silent on Malawi & Congo, Ban-Lib Syria Statement Laundered by Wires

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 6 -- On a day when the UN in New York was closed and essentially did nothing, including not answering questions about the death of the president of Malawi and a mutiny in Eastern Congo where it has a peacekeeping mission, 7 pm Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Martin Nesirky sent an e-mail.

It conveyed a canned quote from Ban Ki-moon, a seeming cut and paste statement that might have been issued yesterday, or last week, or from Washington, or Paris. It seemed perfunctory -- but soon it appeared, in full and with no added analysis or context, on the Reuters newswire.

AFP issued a longer story, but the additional length was only Ban Ki-moon's quotes from the day before, combined with more quotes from Nesirky. This is what these professional journalists call having two source -- i.e., "confirmation."

The problem with this is that it gives the impression that something is being done when it is not. Even the most passionately anti-Assad activist is ill-served by this type of cut and paste stenography, or quote laundering. But this is what happened on Good Friday, as on so many other days.

And here are two questions which Ban Ki-moon's spokesman Nesirky has neither answered nor even confirmed receipt of, on actual new topics on which the UN is supposed to have something to say, not least because it spends hundreds of millions of dollars a year in the Congo with a peacekeeping mission more robust than it wants to send to Syria:

What is the UN / MONUSCO doing about the reported fighting in the Eastern DRC involving fighters aligned with Bosco Ntaganda? What is the UN doing about Ntaganda?

Can the UN confirm, and does the S-G have any comment on, the reported death of the president of Malawi?

After 15 hours, no answer. As the fairytale says, the Emperor has no clothes. Watch this site.

UN Won't Confirm or Comment on Malawi's President's Death, 8 Hours of Silence

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 6 -- While the UN is increasingly slow to respond to or even comment on things ranging from the killing of civilians in South Sudan through claims for compensation for giving Haitians cholera to the placement on its Senior Advisory Group on Peacekeeping of an alleged war criminal, one expects the UN to respond and comment on the death of a member state's president.

When North Korea's Kim Jong-Il passed away, a moment of silence was held (though a request for such a moment by Syria's Ambassador was rejected on April 5). When a French professor died this week in a New York hotel, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon immediately commented.

But while media all over the world report that Malawi's president Bingu wa Mutharika died on April 5, for eight hours on April 6 the UN's top two spokespeople neither confirmed it nor even acknowledged receipt of that question, plus one on a mutiny by a International Criminal Court indictee in Eastern Congo, where the UN spends hundreds of millions of dollars a year on "peacekeeping."

Early on April 6 Inner City Press asked Ban Ki-moon's two top spokesmen, "can the UN confirm, and does the Secretary General have any comment on, the reported death of the president of Malawi?"

No response, eight hours and counting as of this publication. Previously at the UN, Inner City Press asked Ban's adviser Jeffrey Sachs about Bingu wa Mutharika, the first time getting an answer and more recently not, while Sachs was still running for the World Bank's top job. (Since then he's confirmed to Inner City Press he fully supports US-nominated Korean-born Jim Yong Kim, strange given the stated rationale of Sachs' run.)

Earlier still at the UN, Inner City Press exposed the mis-use of UN grounds by Madonna for a fundraiser ostensibly for "Raising Malawi." Inner City Press has directed questions about Malawi to the IMF, which answers on Egypt and Sri Lanka, but declined on Malawi. Now with the Bingu wa Mutharika era over - though his brother's in the wings -- will that change? Watch this site.

UN Hinders Coverage of Advisory Group & War Criminal Silva's Role, Minders?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 6 -- When it emerged in January that UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's Senior Advisory Group on Peacekeeping would have on it Sri Lanka General Shavendra Silva, whose 58th Division is depicted in Ban's own Panel of Experts report as engaged in war crimes, Inner City Press asked Ban about it and went to stand outside the first SAG meeting on February 22.

Ban said it was a decision of member states, and on February 22 Inner City Press was ejected from the UN-rented building at 380 Madison Avenue, after spotting Silva in attendance (and then filming him driving away in a $100,000 BMW).

The chair of the SAG, Louise Frechette, issued a press release that Silva's participation would be inappropriate. Sri Lanka sought the support of the Asia Group, and vowed that Silva would attend the next SAG meeting, set for April 2. Ban still said nothing.

On April 2, Inner City Press again went to 380 Madison Avenue to observe who went in to the 16th floor meeting room. As Inner City Press stood by the elevators, various SAG members came to speak, noting that Silva had yet to show up.

A UN Security officer came, and Inner City Press explained what it was doing. The officer went into the suite of offices and emerged to say that they weren't asking for the Press to be removed. He added that he'd told them that if they later did, they should call and he would ask the Press to leave. Fine.

After this, the UN's Media and Accreditation Unit has twice written to Inner City Press. The first:

"I wanted to double check with you if you went to cover recently a meeting of the senior advisory group on peacekeeping, which took place in UN offices located on Madison Avenue."

While this inquiry was cc-ed elsewhere in the UN, Inner City Press went directly to the sender, usually genial, and explained exactly what happened, including that UN Security had inquired and then allowed Inner City Press to stay. But then this formal follow-up:

"Thank you for your explanation regarding your presence a few days ago on Madison when the Senior Advisory Group for DPKO met. It's not clear exactly to whom the security guard in question spoke to but the organizers say they did not give their permission for press coverage nor did they speak to a security guard.

"As we discussed with you and the UNCA Executive Committee recently in Stephane's office, press need to contact MALU if they want to cover anything in the UN offices on Madison, the Innovation Building, DC1 & 2, and any other off-campus building. I recall Stephane being extremely clear on this point. So if you wish to stake-out a meeting in one of those places, just call us and we will be happy to help."

It is unclear who the referenced "organizers" are, since the SAG is a meeting of many countries' Permanent Representatives, some of whom invited and spoke with Inner City Press. If the undisclosed organizers "did not give their permission for press coverage" -- some concept, that -- why would they in the future? And if not, what help would be provided?

In the referenced meeting, the Correspondents' Association did little to fight for more access -- but later told Inner City Press that it had been resolved, and that such meetings could be covered.

At the same time, the Correspondents' Association complained that another of Inner City Press' Sri Lanka related articles was inappropriate, and asked that it be changed.

Previously, the Correspondents' Association screened inside the UN the Sri Lankan government's response to Killing Fields, which itself was never screened in the UN. As Inner City Press noted, the President of the Correspondents' Association used to accept money from Sri Lankan Ambassador Palitha Kohona as rent -- far in the past, he now argues.

So what it is, about the UN and Sri Lanka? Why are the SAG meetings, primarily of member states' Permanent Representatives, held not in the North Lawn building but in 380 Madison? Why the attempt to apply different rules there, as if it were a staff meeting?

In context, the UN's Media Accreditation and Liaison Unit rather than helping to cover UN news is acting like a "minder," as many criticize for example in North Korea. Why should Ban Ki-moon's minder unit be permitted to shadow the Press, either observing who speaks or discouraging such contact by its presence? Why have these issues never been brought up? Watch this site.

At UN, Ban Said to Commend Syria, "Secret Suck Up" Like Sri Lanka?

By Matthew Russell Lee

UNITED NATIONS, April 5 -- The ambiguous, some say shameful, role of Secretary General Ban Ki-moon in today's UN came into relief Thursday when Syria's Permanent Representative Bashar Ja'afari told Inner City Press that, privately, Ban had "commended the Syrian government."

This is at odds with public statements by Ban Ki-moon, such as that President Bashar al Assad had lost his sense of humanity. But placating -- or as some call it, sucking up to -- strongmen has become a Ban Ki-moon trait. As exclusively reported by Inner City Press, Ban berated his own staff for alleged unfairness in front of President Mahinda Rajapaksa of Sri Lanka, accused of killing 40,000 civilians.

Inner City Press asked Ja'afari what he thinks of Ban Ki-moon's role, since Ban has acknowledged taking flights on jets owned by the Qatari government. "On other matters he says it's up to member states, but do you think he is operating differently on this, and if so why?"

Tellingly, Ja'afari defended Ban, recounting what one wag characterized as Ban's secret Syria suck-up. More seriously, some take this to mean, Ban is so weak that all sides can claim him. Mubarak's ambassador Maged Abdelaziz publicly trashed Ban, and said much worse in private, Inner City Press is told -- and has been rewarded with the post of Special Adviser on Africa.

Maged was still sitting in Egypt's seat in the General Assembly meeting on Syria on Thursday morning, of which UN TV televised the first part, but cut off just as Ja'afari began to speak for Syria. Many saw this as unfair or a form of censorship, another example of Banning of free press.

At Thursday's noon briefing, Inner City Press asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky why UN TV had shown only some speeches, and not what Syria itself said. Nesirky said, as the PGA's spokeswoman had at some length, that it was an informal meeting, therefore not televised.

Inner City Press asked, but why then was a portion of the informal meeting televised? Nesirky said, because there was public interest in it.

But there was some interest in hearing from Syria, too, Inner City Press asked, trying to understand.

"You're not trying very hard," Nesirky said, "I've spelled it out twice."

Inner City Press then asked if Ban had granted Ja'afari's request for a minute of silence for "all" the victims in Syria. Ban's spokesman would not answer, referring the question to the Qatari President of the General Assembly's spokeswoman. But it's a question for Ban: did he observe this moment of silent requested by Syria's government or not?

The reference above to Ban saying, on other matters, it's up to member states was Ban's response to what he thinks of having as a Special Adviser on Peacekeeping the Sri Lankan General Shavendra Silva, whose 58th Division is depicted in Ban's own Panel of Experts report as engaged in war crimes.

Ban wouldn't comment, saying it is up to member states. Most recently his Secretariat has tried to make it difficult or impossible to ascertain if Silva is, in fact, still attending the Special Advisory Group meetings. We may have more on this. Watch this site.